Ion irradiation is a powerful tool to tune properties of semiconductors and, in particular, of gallium oxide (Ga2O3) which is a promising ultra-wide bandgap semiconductor exhibiting phase instability for high enough strain/disorder levels. In the present paper we observed an interesting interplay between the disorder and strain in monoclinic β-Ga2O3 single crystals by comparing atomic and cluster ion irradiations as well as atomic ions co-implants. The results obtained by a combination of the channeling technique, X-ray diffraction and theoretical calculations show that the disorder accumulation in β-Ga2O3 exhibits superlinear behavior as a function of the collision cascade density. Moreover, the level of strain in the implanted region can be engineered by changing the disorder conditions in the near surface layer. The results can be used for better understanding of the radiation effects in β-Ga2O3 and imply that disorder/strain interplay provides an additional degree of freedom to maintain desirable strain in Ga2O3, potentially applicable to modify the rate of the polymorphic transitions in this material.
Ion implantation is a well-known technology to modify properties of materials. For example, it changed the paradigm in transistor manufacturing, providing accurate control of both spatial localization of dopants and their concentration1. Concurrently, the associated radiation disorder was considered as an artifact, rising a high demand for studies of the radiation disorder accumulation, with a practical focus to minimize the harm. More recently, a new concept of the defects functionalization became popular, e.g. along with the vision of the isolated intrinsic defects and defect complexes as building blocks for quantum devices2,3,4. Another defect functionalization option is to exploit the collective impact of the irradiation-induced disorder on the phase transitions occurring without changing chemical composition, i.e., polymorph transitions. In particular, such self-organized transitions have been recently observed in gallium oxide (Ga2O3)5. The phenomenon was interpreted in terms of the monoclinic (β-Ga2O3) to orthorhombic (κ-Ga2O3) or cubic (γ-Ga2O3) phase transition starting at a certain threshold of accumulated strain, in its turn controlled by the disorder level5,6. Notably, Ga2O3 is a very promising ultra-wide bandgap semiconductor for a range of applications and ion implantation is considered among the prime device fabrication tools6,7,8. Thus, on one hand the polymorphic transitions occurring under irradiation may be highly undesirable, since it may challenge the integrity of the device. On the other hand, the appearance of different polymorphs may turn to an advantage, if one gains control over the single-phase polymorph fabrication. In either case, the ultimate requirement is to understand and gain the control over the interplay between the disorder and strain in Ga2O3.
Notably, it is well established that the irradiation-induced disorder affects the strain level in the materials9. In semiconductors, the strain relaxation occurs most commonly via amorphization10, while the polymorphic transitions are rare5,11. To the best of our knowledge, Ga2O3 is the only material where the irradiation induced polymorph transitions were demonstrated in a tractable way5, in contrast to the observations in other materials demonstrating much less controllable polymorphism11,12. So far, the phenomenon in Ga2O3 has been studied as a function of the ion mass, dose, dose rate, and temperature5,13,14; altogether demonstrating a consistent trend for the strain accumulation induced by radiation defects.
However, there is yet no clear picture on how the disorder, and the corresponding strain accumulation, depend on the density of the collision cascades which is, in general, a rather complex function of the ion mass and energy15. Importantly, a direct comparison and unambiguous interpretation of the results obtained for irradiation regimes with ions having different atomic masses may be challenging. Previously, it was demonstrated that the cascade density effects can be efficiently studied by comparing the disorder induced by atomic and cluster ions, with the implantation parameters adjusted in such a way that the only difference between these irradiation regimes is the discrepancy between the atomic and cluster ions locations16; as schematically illustrated in Fig. 1. In the present paper, based on the formalism from Ref.16, we compare all three types of implants, as illustrated in Fig. 1, to study the interplay between the disorder and strain in β-Ga2O3. As a result, we obtained a superlinear dependence of the disorder as a function of the collision cascades density and unveil the crucial role of the near-surface disorder for the strain accumulation. Such interplay between the disorder and strain provides an additional degree of freedom to maintain desirable strain in gallium oxide, potentially applicable to modify the rate of the polymorphic transitions in this material.
In the present study (010) β-Ga2O3 single crystals were implanted with atomic (P and F) and cluster (PF2 and PF4) ions. The ion dose in displacements per atom (DPA), the defect generation rate in DPA/s, and the ion energy per atomic mass unit (amu) were kept the same for these implants. In addition, the low energy (36 keV) Ni ion implants were performed into the virgin sample as well as into the samples pre-implanted with F and P ions. Table 1 summarizes the energy, dose, beam flux as well as the depth corresponding to the nuclear energy loss maximum (Rpd) for all ions used. All implants were performed at room temperature, maintaining 7° off-angle orientation from normal direction to minimize channeling. The samples were analyzed by a combination of Rutherford backscattering spectrometry in channeling mode (RBS/C) and X-ray diffraction (XRD). RBS/C measurements was performed using 1.6 MeV He+ ions incident along  direction and backscattered into a detector placed at 100° relative the incident beam direction. All RBS/C spectra were analyzed using one of the conventional algorithms17 for extracting the effective number of scattering centres (referred to below as a ‘relative disorder’). Thus, the relative disorder varies from 0 to 1 corresponding to the unimplanted and fully disordered states, respectively. XRD measurements were performed using the Bruker AXS D8 Discover diffractometer with high-resolution Cu Kα1 radiation selected by a triple-bounce Ge (022) asymmetric monochromator exhibiting the instrumental broadness of 0.008°, as calibrated by Si (111) single crystal. The 2θ measurements were performed in the locked-coupled mode with position sensitive detector (PSD-LYNXEYE™) operating in the 1D mode.
Results and discussion
The role of the collision cascade density on the disorder formation in β-Ga2O3 is illustrated by Fig. 2 showing the RBS/C spectra of the samples implanted with atomic (F and P) and cluster (PF2 and PF4) ions. It should be noted, the sensitivity of the RBS technique is much better to heavy elements as compared to light atoms. Thus, in the rest of the paper we analyze the disorder in the Ga sublattice only; despite that the O signal is resolvable around 260 channel number in Fig. 2, corresponding to the surface position of O atoms. Thus, considering the Ga sublattice disorder, all implants in Fig. 2 result in two prominent features: one distinct peak at the surface and another broad peak centered at around Rpd; in direct comparison with the SRIM simulations data as indicated by the solid line in Fig. 2. Importantly, for the same DPA, P ions produce more defects in the bulk as compared to that of F which is a direct consequence of the collision cascade density effect ruled by the mass difference between these ions. In its turn, the cluster ion irradiation leads to a dramatic increase of the defects at the surface and in the region between the bulk and the surface defect peaks. It should be noted that even for PF4 ions the height of the surface peak is well below the amorphous level, which is equivalent to the height of the random (fully disordered) spectrum. This surface disorder enhancement is attributed to the defect interaction from the overlapping collision cascades produced by the atoms comprising cluster ions as also schematically illustrated in Fig. 1. The cascade overlapping is obviously maximal near the surface, affecting the RBS/C data.
In order to better understand the mechanisms of the surface peak buildup, we use the SRIM code18 simulations in combination with the previously developed methodology which takes into account the sub-cascades formation19,20. The results of the data processing are plotted in Fig. 3 (see “Supplementary Materials” for detailed description of the procedure). Notably, the inset in Fig. 3 shows the depth profiles of the effective cascade density as a function of the depth for all ions studied. It is seen that cluster ions produce much denser collision cascades for the depth ≤ 15 nm consistently with the data in Fig. 2. Thus, our results indicate a crucial role of the collision cascade density for the defect formation in β-Ga2O3. Indeed, Fig. 3 shows that the relative disorder in the surface peak exhibits superlinear behavior with increasing effective collision cascade density, with a very rapid disorder increase for the effective cascade density in excess of ~ 0.8 atomic %. Previously, it was demonstrated that surface amorphization in ion implanted GaN exhibits threshold-like behavior that was explained in the framework of the energy spike models20. However, in contrast to GaN, no amorphization was observed in ion implanted β-Ga2O35,7 and the disorder enhancement in β-Ga2O3 for cluster ions can be attributed to a nonlinear defect interaction as supported by a strong dose-rate effect in this material13.
Notably, instead of amorphization, high dose irradiations result into a polymorphic transition in β-Ga2O35,14. In this context, as it interpreted in5, the strain accumulation in the implanted region is of paramount importance to control the polymorphic transitions. Thus, accounting for the data in Figs. 2 and 3, we investigated the interplay between the disorder and strain in our systematic set of samples as introduced by Fig. 1. The XRD data for the samples studied in Fig. 2 are plotted in Fig. 4 showing 2θ scans around the main (020) reflection (centered at 60.9°) of β-Ga2O3 (the full range XRD 2θ spectra are shown in Fig. S3 of “Supplementary Materials”). It is seen from Fig. 4 that for F implants, a high-angle shoulder appears on the side of the (020) reflection and this shoulder becomes more pronounced for P implants, resulting in a peak at ~ 61.04°. In context of the literature interpretations of the XRD data in irradiated materials, such shoulders/peaks may be attributed to the accumulation of compressive strain21. Previously, we demonstrated that this strain accumulation is scaling with the disorder level in the bulk damage peak13. However, surprisingly enough, the strain value does not scale up with the enhanced disorder in samples implanted with the cluster ions. Indeed, as clearly seen from Fig. 4 the intensity of the 61.04° peak is damped upon the PF2 and PF4 implants as compared to that for P implants. On the other hand the cluster implants lead to the formation of a broad tail at the right-hand-side of the (020) peak, see Fig. 4. This tail is most pronounced for PF4 implants. Taking into account its strong asymmetry, it can be attributed to an enhanced concentration of extended defects22. Thus, lowering of the 61.04° peak for the cluster implants in contrast the P implants can be interpreted as shrinkage of the stressed layer due to strain relaxation stimulated by the extended defects in the near surface region.
The obtained results give an opportunity to manipulate the strain accumulation in the crystal bulk by the defect engineering in the near the surface region. In order to verify this hypothesis we performed additional low energy co-implantation with Ni ions into the samples having pre-existing disorder produced by F and P ions. The energy and the dose of Ni ions were chosen to produce similar disorder in the near surface region as in samples implanted with cluster ions (see the schematics in Fig. 1 and the implant parameters in Table 1). The impact of such co-implants on the interplay between the disorder and strain is illustrated by Fig. 5 including the disorder depth profiles, as deduced from the RBS/C spectra in panel (a) and the corresponding XRD data presented in panels (b) and (c). As expected, the low energy Ni implants generate disorder near the surface region, see Fig. 5a. Importantly, the disorder in the co-implanted samples is not a simple superposition of the individual disorder profiles. In particular, the amplitude of the surface disorder in the co-implanted samples is significantly higher as compared to the sum of the components, see Fig. 5a, consistently with nonlinear disorder accumulation for relatively high disorder levels7,23. Most importantly for the interplay with strain, we observe the decrease in the bulk disorder level in the co-implanted samples, systematically both for P + Ni and F + Ni co-implants. There are of course rational explanations for that, e.g. in terms the radiation-stimulated defect annealing due to migration of the defects from the near surface region and their interaction with the pre-existing disorder deeper in the bulk. It should be noted, that migration of the defects can be affected by the accumulated strain24.
The disorder changes in the co-implanted samples can be readily correlated with the strain evolution and, to some extent, with the corresponding features for the cluster ion implants. Indeed, one common feature is the extension of the tail on the high-angle side of the (020) reflection peak upon the co-implants, compare Figs. 4 and 5b,c. On the other hand, the co-implants do not release strain; e.g. for the P + Ni sample the 61.04° peak shifts to the higher angles indicating some increase of the compressive strain, as compared to the P implants alone. However, its intensity decreases that can be potentially attributed to a partial strain relaxation. Thus, even though the exact mechanisms affecting the difference in the disorder accumulation and strain evolution in β-Ga2O3 for implants with atomic ions having different mass, cluster ions, and co-implants may vary, there a consistent trend as shown in Figs. 2, 3, 4 and 5.
In conclusion, we demonstrate that the collision cascade density has a strong impact on the ion-beam-induced defect/strain accumulation in gallium oxide. Specifically, we show that the disorder accumulation exhibits superlinear behavior with the collision cascade density. Moreover, the level of strain correlated with the amplitude of the bulk disorder peak can be engineered by changing the disorder conditions in the near surface layer. Such interplay between the disorder and strain was observed by comparing both atomic/cluster ion irradiations as well as atomic ion co-implants. Thus, the manipulation with the disorder depth profiles is an additional degree of freedom to maintain the desirable strain in gallium oxide, making it potentially applicable to modify the rate of the polymorphic transitions in this material.
All data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article and its Supplementary Information file.
Fair, R. B. History of some early developments in ion-implantation technology leading to silicon transistor manufacturing. Proc. IEEE 86, 111 (1998).
Maurer, P. C. et al. Room-temperature quantum bit memory exceeding one second. Science 336, 1283 (2012).
Redjem, W. et al. Single artificial atoms in silicon emitting at telecom wavelengths. Nat. Electron. 3, 738 (2020).
Vasquez, G. C. et al. Strain modulation of Si vacancy emission from SiC micro-and nanoparticles. Nano Lett. 20, 8689 (2020).
Azarov, A. et al. Disorder-induced ordering in gallium oxide polymorphs. Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 015704 (2022).
Yoo, T., Xia, X., Ren, F., Jacobs, A., Tadjer, M. J., Pearton, S. and Kim, H. Atomic-scale characterization of structural damage and recovery in Sn ion-implanted β-Ga2O3. Appl. Phys. Lett. 121, 072111 (2022).
Wendler, E., Treiber, E., Baldauf, J., Wolf, S. & Ronning, C. High-level damage saturation below amorphisation in ion implanted β-Ga2O3. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. B 379, 85 (2016).
Peres, M. et al. Doping β-Ga2O3 with europium: influence of the implantation and annealing temperature. J. Phys. D Appl. Phys. 50, 325101 (2017).
Debelle, A. et al. Lattice strain in irradiated materials unveils a prevalent defect evolution mechanism. Phys. Rev. Mater. 2, 013604 (2018).
Boulle, A., Debelle, A., Wallace, J. B., BayuAji, L. B. & Kucheyev, S. O. The amorphization of 3C-SiC irradiated at moderately elevated temperatures as revealed by X-ray diffraction. Acta Mater. 140, 250 (2017).
Nikolskaya, A. et al. Photoluminescence of ion-synthesized 9R-Si inclusions in SiO2/Si structure: Effect of irradiation dose and oxide film thickness. Appl. Phys. Lett. 118, 212101 (2021).
Valdez, J. A., Chi, Z. & Sickafus, K. E. Light ion irradiation-induced phase transformation in the monoclinic polymorph of zirconia. J. Nucl. Mat. 381, 259 (2008).
Azarov, A., Venkatachalapathy, V., Monakhov, E. V. & Kuznetsov, A. Yu. Dominating migration barrier for intrinsic defects in gallium oxide: Dose-rate effect measurements. Appl. Phys. Lett. 118, 232101 (2021).
Anber, E. A. et al. Structural transition and recovery of Ge implanted β-Ga2O3. Appl. Phys. Lett. 117, 152101 (2020).
Wallace, J. B., Bayu Aji, L. B., Shao, L. & Kucheyev, S. O. Deterministic role of collision cascade density in radiation defect dynamics in Si. Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 216101 (2018).
Titov, A. I., Azarov, A. Yu., Nikulina, L. M. & Kucheyev, S. O. Damage buildup and the molecular effect in Si bombarded with PFn cluster ions. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. B 256, 207 (2007).
Schmid, K. Some new aspects for the evaluation of disorder profiles in silicon by backscattering. Radiat. Eff. 17, 201 (1973).
Ziegler, J. F., Ziegler, M. D. & Biersack, J. P. SRIM—The stopping and range of ions in matter (2010). Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. B 268, 1818 (2010).
Karaseov, P. A., Azarov, A. Yu., Titov, A. I. & Kucheyev, S. O. Density of displacement cascades for cluster ions: An algorithm of calculation and the influence on damage formation in ZnO and GaN. Semiconductors 43, 691 (2009).
Kucheyev, S. O., Azarov, A. Yu., Titov, A. I., Karaseov, P. A. & Kuchumova, T. M. Energy spike effects in ion-bombarded GaN. J. Phys. D Appl. Phys. 42, 085309 (2009).
Debelle, A. & Declémy, A. XRD investigation of the strain/stress state of ion-irradiated crystals. Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. B 268, 1460 (2010).
Moram, M. A. & Vickers, M. E. X-ray diffraction of III-nitrides. Rep. Prog. Phys. 72, 036502 (2009).
Titov, A. I. et al. Comparative study of radiation tolerance of GaN and Ga2O3 polymorphs. Vacuum 200, 111005 (2022).
Britton, D. T. & Härting, M. The influence of strain on point defect dynamics. Adv. Eng. Mater. 4, 629 (2002).
The Research Council of Norway is acknowledged for the support to the Norwegian Micro- and Nano-Fabrication Facility, NorFab, project number 295864. M-ERA.NET GOFIB project (RCN project number 337627) is acknowledged for financial support. Work in St Petersburg was supported by the Russian Science Foundation (Project No. 22-19-00166). The INTPART Program at the Research Council of Norway, Projects Nos. 261574 and 322382, enabled the international collaboration.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Azarov, A., Venkatachalapathy, V., Karaseov, P. et al. Interplay of the disorder and strain in gallium oxide. Sci Rep 12, 15366 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-19191-8