Herein, the effect of dietary inclusion of insect (Tenebrio molitor) meal on hepatic pathways of apoptosis and autophagy in three farmed fish species, gilthead seabream (Sparus aurata), European seabass (Dicentrarchus labrax) and rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss), fed diets at 25%, 50% and 60% insect meal inclusion levels respectively, was investigated. Hepatic proteome was examined by liver protein profiles from the three fish species, obtained by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. Although cellular stress was evident in the three teleost species following insect meal, inclusion by T. molitor, D. labrax and O. mykiss suppressed apoptosis through induction of hepatic autophagy, while in S. aurata both cellular procedures were activated. Protein abundance showed that a total of 30, 81 and 74 spots were altered significantly in seabream, European seabass and rainbow trout, respectively. Insect meal inclusion resulted in individual protein abundance changes, with less number of proteins altered in gilthead seabream compared to European seabass and rainbow trout. This is the first study demonstrating that insect meal in fish diets is causing changes in liver protein abundances. However, a species-specific response both in the above mentioned bioindicators, indicates the need to strategically manage fish meal replacement in fish diets per species.
Sustainable aquaculture production has never been more crucial due to the expanding export and the increased consumption of seafood products. To this end, development and improvement of aquaculture sustainable practices are in great need of research and knowledge concerning fish nutrition. Finding alternative feed ingredients and protein sources for the aqua feed industry due to insufficient global supplies of fishmeal (FM)1,2 is an active area in fish nutrition research.
Insect larvae meals are considered a very promising alternative to provide valuable proteins for aqua feeds and have been in the spotlight of many researches3,4,5,6. The European Commission approved the use of processed animal protein from insects in feeds for aquaculture (Reg. EU 2017/893) and their use is expected to dramatically increase7,8. Different insect species are considered for the production of larvae meal and among them yellow mealworm (Tenebrio molitor—TM) is one of the most promising. Recent studies reported positive results in different fish species9,10,11,12,13 as well as crustaceans14 even though, high levels of inclusion could lead to a slight decrease of performances, especially in fish juveniles9,15.
Diet-induced oxidation stress leading to immune dysfunction has been previously reported in many studies16,17,18. Oxidative stress can activate two different closely linked cell mechanisms, autophagy and apoptosis19. Autophagy, a lysosome-mediated mechanism pivotal in the regulation of cellular damage, targets dysfunctional proteins and cytoplasmic organelles for degradation and recycling19,20, in order to avoid apoptosis. However, autophagy and apoptosis can coexist since both can be triggered by similar stressors which activate the upstream signaling pathway21. If apoptosis, which is a mitochondria-related pathway of programmed cell death in multicellular organisms, is triggered, the activation of caspases cleaves for the damaged cells22. Therefore, key components of the aforementioned cell pathways, that are widely characterized according to the existing literature as indicators of physiological and dietary stress, may elucidate if nutrient changes in aquafeeds maintain a welfare regime. Such stress indicators include Bax and Bcl-2 proteins, which promotes and prevents apoptosis respectively, caspases which finally induce apoptosis and are in turn activated when the relative amount of Bax is higher than Bcl-2, and LC3 II/I ratio and SQSTM1/p62 which are basic constituents of the autophagosomes and indicators of the autophagic process.
Moreover, to determine mechanisms of diet-host response, methods and techniques (genomics, transcriptomics, proteomics, metabolomics and bioinformatics) are applied to evaluate the new feed ingredients in order to ensure fish health and performance23. In proteomics analysis, the abundance of many proteins is measured simultaneously and can provide indications of the affected metabolic pathways. Proteomic studies have improved the understanding of the relationships between diet composition, protein metabolism and nutrient utilisation in aquatic animals24,25,26. Proteomics approaches have been used extensively to examine protein responses to dietary stimulations in both liver and muscle in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss)26,27,28,29, zebrafish30,31, Atlantic salmon32, gilthead seabream and white sea bream25,26,33. This paper investigated whether the dietary inclusion of T. molitor meal affected hepatic pathways of apoptosis and autophagy in three farmed fish species, gilthead seabream (Sparus aurata), European seabass (Dicentrarchus labrax) and rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Due to the fact that changes in mRNA and protein levels can strongly correlate or not (e.g., transcriptional and translational control regulation) (e.g.,34,35,36), and although the examination of differences between transcriptional and translational events is of great interest, this study mainly focused on the biochemical responses as a result of translational processes, in order to be consistent to the proteome analysis presented herein. Thus, this study investigated the effect of insect meal inclusion on the liver proteome of the aforementioned species to assess the magnitude of changes occurring in hepatic proteins expression and to give indications of how the different species may adapt to the diet modification.
Material and methods
Dietary experiments and sampling
Three independent dietary trials were conducted using three farmed fish species; gilthead seabream, European seabass and rainbow trout. The experiments are described in detail for European seabass in Gasco et al.9 and for gilthead seabream in Piccolo et al.11. As partial fish meal substitution, the same full-fat TM larvae meal, purchased from the Gaobeidian Shannong Biology CO. LTD (Shannong, China) (Italy) (DGSFA 0019960-P) (02/11/2012), was used in the fish diets. Ingredients and proximate composition of experimental diets are reported in Table 19,11. Formulated diets were designed to meet the different nutritional requirements of each fish species.
The experimental protocols were designed according to the guidelines of the current European Directive (2010/63/EU) on the protection of animals used for scientific purposes. The gilthead seabream trial was performed at the Department of Veterinary Medicine and Animal Production (University of Naples Federico II, Italy), as described in Piccolo et al.11, and was approved by the Ethic Committee of Federico II University. The European seabass trial was performed at the Institute of Marine Biology, Biotechnology and Aquaculture (IMBBC) of the Hellenic Center for Marine Research (Crete, Greece) (EL91- BIOexp-04), as described in Gasco et al.9 and approved by the Aquaexcel Ethic Committee (Ref 0013/03/05/15B and Ref. 0125/08/05/15/TNA). The rainbow trout experiment was approved by the Ethic Committee and was conducted at the registered experimental facility of the DISAFA (Torino, Italy) (DM n. 182/2010) by accredited scientists. All methods are reported in accordance with ARRIVE guidelines.
Briefly, as described in Piccolo et al.11, gilthead seabream juveniles of 105.2 ± 0.17 g average initial body weight were fed two isoenergetic and isoproteic diets, for 163 days. These were a control diet (TM0) in which fish meal (FM) was the main protein source and TM25 diet in which 25% of TM larvae meal was added to the diet as partial substitution of FM. European seabass juveniles (initial body weight 5.2 ± 0.82 g) were fed two isonitrogenous, isolipidic and isoenergetic diets where TM was included at a level of 0% or 50% (well above the recommended level of 10%) as partial substitution of FM (further details in Gasco et al.9) and the feeding trial lasted 70 days. Finally, a 90-day trial was conducted on rainbow trout (initial body weight:115.2 ± 14.2 g), which was fed two experimental diets having 0% or 60% (well above the recommended level of 10%) of TM inclusion, as described in Antonopoulou et al.37. In all trials, fish were fed to apparent satiation, gilthead seabream and European seabass were fed 7 days per week whereas the rainbow trout was fed 6 days per week.
At the end of each growth trial, 10 healthy fish from each dietary group were removed and sacrificed by aneasthesia overdose (tricaine methanesulfonate-MS222, Sigma Aldrich, St. Louis, MO, USA), 24 h following their final meal. The fish body weight was measured and the liver was sampled and kept in -80 °C for proteomic analysis.
Protein extraction and gel analysis
Proteins from liver of gilthead seabream, European seabass and rainbow trout were identified by 2DE gels. Protein extraction and analysis were performed in line with Cash et al.38 and Martin et al.28. As described in Mente et al.26 liver samples were kept cool and using a pestle were homogenized in 2-D lysis buffer [0.5 ml 0.5 M Tris–HCl pH 6.8, 0.125 ml 0.2 M EDTA, 12 g urea (8 M), 2.5 ml 0.5 M DTT, 2.5 ml glycerol (10%), 1.25 ml NP-40 (5%), 3.7 ml pH 3–10 ampholytes (40%) 6%, 5 ml MilliQ water]. Lysis buffer was added in a 10:1 ratio and the homogenates were centrifuged at 11,000× g for 10 min. The supernatants were collected and stored at − 80 °C. Proteins (in the supernatants) were precipitated by using a ReadyPrep 2-D Clean up kit (Bio-Rad Laboratories, Hercules USA) following the manufacturer’s instructions. The precipitate was solubilized in 200 µL IPG buffer [(2.01 g UREA (7 M), 0.76 g Thiourea (2 M), 0.2 g CHAPS (4%), 0.015 g DTT (0.3%), 3 ml MilliQ water, 50 μl pH 4–7 IPG buffer (GE Healthcare)] and in sufficient bromophenol blue to provide to the solution a blue color. The protein solution was sonicated with 3 bursts each of 5 s and then was incubated with one part of DNase solution (0.05 ml 1 M MgCl2, 0.5 ml 1 M Tris–HCl pH 8.0 and 0.1 ml 20,000 U ml/1) to two parts protein solution for 10 min on ice. The protein samples were analyzed by 1-dimensional SDS PAGE to check protein quality and concentration prior to 2 DE. Following isoelectric focusing, IPG strips were applied to the second dimension SDS-PAGE (Criterion AnykD Gel, Bio-Rad), electrophoresed and the resolved proteins detected using Colloidal Coomassie Blue G250 staining. The gels were dried and scanned in an Image ScannerTMIII (GE Healthcare, UK) with LabScan software (GE Healthcare, UK). 16 bit images were obtained in a resolution of 600 dpi. The digitilised images were transferred to the Progenesis SameSpots, version 4.5 (Non-linear Dynamics, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK). A reference gel from the control samples was selected.
Comparison of the 2D protein profiles between fish fed the 0% TM inclusion dietary treatment and the 25%, 50% and 60% TM inclusion, was carried out using 4 biological replicates. The 2D protein profiles for each fish and treatment were matched to the 2D reference gel within Progenesis SameSpots software. Protein spots showing statistically significant differences in abundance between the three species groups per treatment were selected using ANOVA (p < 0.05). Each species was analyzed independently as it is not possible to compare across species as 2 DE (2-dimension gel electrophoresis) proteome patterns are highly different between species. A reference gel was chosen for each species to represent the “proteome map”.
SDS/PAGE, ubiquitin and cleaved caspases conjugates, and immunoblot analysis
The preparation of tissue samples for SDS-PAGE, quantification of caspases and ubiquitinated proteins and the immunoblot analysis are based on well-established protocols. Specifically, for the SDS-PAGE in the present study, equivalent amounts of proteins (50 μg), from livers from 5 individual animals from each species and diet regime, were separated either on 10% and 0.275% or 15% and 0.33% (w/v) acrylamide and bisacrylamide respectively. Thereafter, they were electrophoretically transferred onto nitrocellulose membranes. Antibodies used were as follows: monoclonal rabbit anti-LC3B (3868, Cell Signaling), polyclonal rabbit anti-p62/SQSTM1 (5114, Cell Signaling), anti-Bcl2 (7973, Abcam) and anti-Bax (B-9) (2772, Cell Signaling). Quantification of caspases and ubiquitinated proteins was assessed in a solid- phase immunochemical assay. The antibodies used were a polyclonal anti-ubiquitin rabbit antibody (Cat. No. 3936, Cell Signalling, Beverly, MA, USA) and anti-cleaved caspase antibody (Cat. No.8698 Cell Signalling, Beverly, MA, USA).
Changes in apoptosis and autophagy indicators were tested for significance at the 5% level by using one way ANOVA [GraphPad Instat 3.10 (GraphPad Instat Software)]. Post-hoc comparisons were performed using the Bonferroni test. Values are presented as means ± S.D.
The experimental protocols were designed according to the guidelines of the current European Directive (2010/63/EU) on the protection of animals used for scientific purposes. The gilthead sea bream trial was performed at the Department of Veterinary Medicine and Animal Production (University of Naples Federico II, Italy), as described in Piccolo et al. (2017) and was approved by the Ethic Committee of Federico II University. The European seabass trial was performed at the Institute of Marine Biology, Biotechnology and Aquaculture (IMBBC) of the Hellenic Center for Marine Research (Crete, Greece) (EL91- BIOexp-04), as described in Gasco et al. (2016) and approved by the Aquaexcel Ethic Committee (Ref 0013/03/05/15B and Ref. 0125/08/05/15/TNA). The trout experiment was approved by the Ethic Committee and conducted at the registered experimental facility of the DISAFA (DM n. 182/2010) by accredited scientists.
The protein profile from a fish at the 0% insect (TM) meal inclusion shows a representative sample of the liver proteins separated by 2DE and it represents the reference gel for gilthead seabream, European seabass and rainbow trout (Fig. 1). The gels show high resolution of the cellular proteins with pI of 4–7 and molecular weights of 10–150 kDa.
The number of protein spots identified across all gels varied from 500 to 900. Following quality control and editing, 550 spots for each species were obtained for statistical analysis in all gels, among which 30, 81 and 72 spots were found to differ significantly (ANOVA, p < 0.05) in abundance in gilthead seabream, European seabass and rainbow trout, respectively (Table 2). We found fourteen, twenty-three and thirty-three spots that increased in abundance, at the 25%, 50% and 60% insect (TM) meal inclusion in gilthead seabream, European seabass and rainbow trout, respectively. The magnitude of the protein abundances for significant spots in the three dietary groups ranged between 1.24 and 2.25 for gilthead seabream, 1.17 to 3.2 for European seabass and 1.8–3.3 for rainbow trout. Sixteen, fifty-eight and forty proteins were found decreased in abundance in gilthead seabream, European seabass and rainbow trout, respectively. The mean normalized protein spot volume for the 60% insect (TM) meal inclusion was expressed significantly different in abundance than the 0% insect (TM) meal inclusion group in rainbow trout (p < 0.05). There were no significant differences in abundance of the mean normalized protein spot volume at the dietary treatments of the 25 and 50% insect (TM) meal inclusion (p > 0.05). To further assess the dietary impact on the proteome, PCA analysis characterized the spots according to their abundance levels amongst the three species in relation to their TM inclusion dietary treatment (Fig. 2). According to the PCA, 58% spots were significantly more abundant in proteins in gilthead sea bream in the 25% fishmeal replacement by TM meal cluster, compared to the abundance of 79% spots in the European seabass at the 50% insect (TM) meal inclusion and the 79% spots at the 60% insect (TM) meal inclusion in rainbow trout.
In the sea bream, feeding with insect meal at 25% insect (TM) meal inclusion resulted in a significant increase (p < 0.05) of Bax in the liver compared to the control (0%). In the European seabass, a significant reduction (p < 0.05) of Bax was observed in the liver with the 50% fishmeal replacement by TM meal. In the rainbow trout, Bax significantly decreased (p < 0.05) in the liver of 60% insect (TM) meal inclusion (Fig. 3a).
In the sea bream, significantly increased (p < 0.05) expression of Bcl-2 was observed in the liver at 25% insect (TM) meal inclusion. In the European seabass, no significant differences were observed in the liver between 0 and 50% diet treatment (p > 0.05). Similarly, in the rainbow trout, no differences were observed in the liver of 0% and 60% insect (TM) meal inclusion treated fish (p > 0.05) (Fig. 3b).
Pro-apoptotic and pro-survival proteins (Bax/Bcl-2) ratio finally results in pro-caspases and subsequently caspase activation. After their activation, caspases are substantially involved in the pro-apoptotic pathway which finally induces apoptosis39,40. Concerning Bax/Bcl-2 ratio, while in the sea bream, the 25% insect (TM) meal inclusion significantly increased levels of this ratio, in the European seabass and rainbow trout, the 50% and 60% diet treatments respectively, significantly reduced Bax/Bcl-2 ratio (p < 0.05) (Fig. 3c).
In the gilthead sea bream and European seabass, no significant differences were observed regarding caspase-conjugated proteins in the liver of 0–25% and 0–50% insect (TM) meal inclusion treated fish, respectively. In the rainbow trout the levels of caspase-conjugated proteins were significantly reduced (p < 0.05) in the 60% insect (TM) meal inclusion fish group (Fig. 3d).
Regarding interspecies differences (accompanying tables in Fig. 3), the TM inclusion showed statistically significant differences (expressed as x fold differences compared to control—0%) in Bax, Bcl-2, caspases levels, and Bax/Bcl-2 ratio between all three examined species.
Ubiquitination and autophagy
Similar to the caspase-conjugated proteins, in the gilthead sea bream and European seabass, no significant differences were observed regarding ubiquitin levels in the liver of 0–25% and 0–50% insect (TM) meal inclusion treated fish, respectively (Fig. 4a). In the rainbow trout, the levels of ubiquitin-conjugated proteins were significantly increased (p < 0.05) in the liver of fish fed the 60% insect (TM) meal inclusion group, compared to the fish meal rich diet (Fig. 4a).
Concerning LC3BII/LC3BI ratio, in the liver of all three examined species, the insect meal replacement provoked significant increase (p < 0.05) in the levels of the above mentioned ratio (Fig. 4b).
In the gilthead sea bream, feeding with insect meal at 25% insect (TM) meal inclusion resulted in a significant reduction (p < 0.05) of SQSTM1/p62 in the liver relative to 0%, indicating autophagic activity. In the European seabass, the expression of SQSTM1/p62 was significantly increased (p < 0.05) in the 50% insect (TM) meal inclusion in the liver, while the opposite was observed in the rainbow trout liver at the 60% insect (TM) meal inclusion fish group (Fig. 4c).
Regarding interspecies differences (accompanying tables in Fig. 4), while the TM inclusion showed no differences in ubiquitination levels, statistically significant differences (expressed as x fold differences compared to control—0%) were found for SQSTM1/p62 levels and LC3II/I ratio between sea bream, the European seabass and rainbow trout.
Previous studies have demonstrated that insects can be used as an alternative protein source for fish feeds [e.g.10,41,42,43] and results on fish growth performances highly depend on insect meal type, inclusion rate, feed formulation, and, on the fish species and age5. The inclusion of TM larvae meal in gilthead sea bream diets was feasible up to 25%, while there were no negative effects on weight gain, crude protein and digestibility and marketable indexes in comparison to the control group (0% TM)11. Gasco et al.9 showed that in the European seabass of 5.23 g initial body weight a 50% insect (TM) meal inclusion resulted in a significant reduction in growth performance. Results for rainbow trout trial showed that a 60% TM inclusion resulted in a significant reduction in individual weight gain and feeding rate while other performance parameters were not affected by the TM substitution (unpublished data).
Information on the effect of dietary supplementation of fish meal on biochemical pathways is relatively scarce. However, differentiation in protein expression of apoptotic and cytoprotective pathways in response to dietary changes has been reported in few studies [e.g.,17,44] indicating nutritionally-induced stress. Partial fish meal supplementation with soybean meal in common dentex (Dentex dentex) exerted influence on several heat shock proteins (HSPs) and mitogen-activated protein kinases (MAPKs) expression in a tissue- and inclusion percentage- specific manner17. Furthermore, complementary mixture of plant protein as fish meal substitution led to modulation of hepatocyte apoptosis in hybrid grouper (Epinephelus lanceolatus♂ × E. fuscoguttatus♀) through down-regulation of apoptosis-related genes44. Modification in the European seabass cellular defense mechanisms concerning HSR (Heat Shock Response) has also been shown in response to fasting45. Nutrient intake has been previously characterized as a stressor that tends to directly affect HSPs expression and MAPK phosphorylation46. It is evident in this study that insect (TM) meal inclusion has an immediate effect on several pathways that influence apoptosis and autophagy. The observed stress effect may be attributed to the presence of chitin in the TM -based meal. Chitin is a naturally abundant long-chain polysaccharide found in the exoskeleton of a plethora of organisms such as the shell of crustaceans, the cuticle of insects and fungi and microorganisms cell wall47. Similar to our results, treatment of 3T3-L1 adipocytes with carboxymethyl chitin activated AMPK, which indicates the link between autophagy and the regulation of energy metabolism48. The intrinsic/Bcl-2-regulated/mitochondrial pathway is the main apoptosis signalling pathway49. Increase of pro-apoptotic to pro-survival proteins (Bax/Bcl-2) ratio determines the cellular resistance to several stressful stimuli, resulting in caspases activation which induces apoptosis39,40. Apoptosis can be activated by the inflammatory response initiated by the cellular damage due to oxidative stress50. Increased activity of antioxidant enzymes, indicating oxidative stress, was observed among others in the serum of Jian carp (Cyprinus carpio var. Jian) fed defatted Hermetia illucens meal51 and in the liver of pearl gentian grouper (Epinephelus fuscoguttatus × E. lanceolatus) fed TM meal52. In addition, taurine supplementation to primary liver cells of Atlantic salmon had been found to ameliorate the effects of CdCl2 on apoptosis by reducing caspace-3 activity while Bax and Bcl-2 levels were unaffected53.
By allowing the orderly cellular degradation and recycling of unnecessary or dysfunctional components, autophagy is a regulated cellular mechanism which can in general prevent apoptosis54,55. During autophagy, LC3-I is converted to LC3-II by an ubiquitin-like system that allows for LC3 to become associated with autophagosomes56,57. Moreover, SQSTM1/p62 interaction with ubiquitin, provides a scaffold for several signaling proteins and triggers degradation of proteins through the proteasome or lysosome58. Protein aggregates formed by SQSTM1/p62 can be degraded by the autophagosome59,60. The above seem to be consistent with our results concerning rainbow trout and European seabass, where insect (TM) meal inclusion provoked stress seems to induce hepatic autophagy which in turns inhibits apoptosis. On the other hand, gilthead seabream exhibits a different pattern of stress with increased levels of both autophagy and apoptosis. The latter is observed probably due to the fact that although autophagy serves as an anti-apoptotic process, when prolonged or in certain conditions (e.g., cells deprivation of oxygen and nutrients) cells will subsequently go through apoptosis61,62. It must be noted that insect meals appear to be limiting in several indispensable amino acids like methionine, lysine, histidine and tyrosine3. TM, specifically, has 39.2% less lysine, 34.4% less histidine and 48.4% less methionine than fish meal (Table 1, Feedtables63). In the present study, there was no supplementation of essential amino acids, namely methionine and lysine, in any of the substitution diets suggesting that these diets were deficient in those amino acids, and potentially others. Feed consumption of gilthead sea bream and European seabass was not increased to compensate for the amino acid limiting diets9,11, therefore an amino acid deprivation regime occurred. In cases of nutrient deprivation, when the availability of amino acids or glucose is not enough to sustain protein synthesis or other metabolic reactions, the rapid deactivation of the function of the target of rapamycin (TOR) induces autophagy to degrade and recycle cell components64,65,66. In the muscle of rainbow trout, a 14-day starvation led to an upregulation of autophagy related genes67 and in the muscle of Chinese perch, Siniperca chuatsi, a five day starvation led to upregulation of core autophagy related genes, increased formation of autophagosomes and autolysosomes and higher levels of LC3 protein68. In mammals, starvation leads to major activation of the ubiquitin–proteasome pathway for protein degradation, while the autophagic-lysosomal pathway plays a much smaller role, if activated at all69. In fish systems, the exact opposite applies. The lysosomal system is responsible for the 30–34% of protein degradation and the ubiquitin–proteasome system for the 4%69,70, which is in line with our data about the activation of the lysosomal pathway in all three species and the increase in ubiquitin-conjugated proteins only in rainbow trout, probably because of the high level of substitution. In the muscle of rainbow trout, methionine deficiency has been found to induce autophagy through both pathways71. After 6 weeks of feeding with a methionine deficient diet, in which the methionine content was 32% lower than the nutrient requirements, Belghit et al.71 observed an induction of the autophagic-lysosomal pathway and also upregulation of several proteasome related genes involved in the attachment of ubiquitin to substrates and the recognition of the ubiquitin conjugated proteins to the proteasome. Methionine is a sulphur amino acid which is essential for the growth of most animals not only because it is a constituent of body protein, but also because of its very important metabolic roles. Methionine is a major methyl-group donor and is involved in the production of cysteine, taurine and glutathione, among others72. Taurine, which is abundant in fish meal but not present in insect meals73, acts beneficially as an antioxidant agent by reducing lipid peroxidation levels, scavenging various radicals and modulating the production of reactive oxygen species74. Since autophagy is induced in cases of oxidative stress, it can be hypothesized that taurine protects proteins from oxidative damage leading to lower autophagic activity for protein degradation75. In meagre, Argyrosomus regius, 2% of taurine supplementation in plant-based diets decreased cathepsin activity in the liver, thus lowering the autophagy-lysosomal degradation of proteins75 and in pufferfish, Takifugu obscurus, exposed to low temperature stress, taurine supplementation led to a decrease in reactive oxygen species, an enhancement of the activity of antioxidant enzymes and a decrease of apoptosis through caspace-3 activity reduction76.
Proteomics is a well-established post-genomic tool which allows investigation in fish biology. Research in aquaculture uses this methodology to investigate issues for fish pathology, nutrition and physiology. Furthermore, there have been few attempts to determine the relationship between diet quality and nutrient utilization in fish liver proteome26,27,28,32,77. However, to the knowledge of the authors this is the first study that examines proteome analysis of liver tissue in two marine fish species and one freshwater, fed an insect meal diet. Differences regarding the liver proteome were found in each of the three- different fish species. Liver proteome comparisons in each species per two different treatments were made. Insect (TM) meal inclusion in fish diets has a more observable effect on the liver proteome of European seabass and gilthead sea bream. Nevertheless, in gilthead sea bream fewer proteins spots were altered in comparison to European seabass and rainbow trout after insect (TM) meal inclusion suggesting a possible relationship to the animal’s natural chitin-enriched diet78,79. Moreover, insect (TM) meal inclusion in European seabass and 60% in rainbow trout stimulates higher protein abundance changes and lower fish growth in comparison to the 0% insect (TM) meal inclusion. Composition and quality of dietary protein intake influence the changes in fish protein abundance. A lower non-structural protein expression level was observed by Martin et al.28 in rainbow trout (O. mykiss) fed a fishmeal and plant protein diet than a higher proportion of soy protein diet. Furthermore, previous studies in rainbow trout28,29 demonstrated changes in hepatic metabolism as a response to the dietary consumption of various plant proteins. Thus, the present protein profile analysis reflects a specific proteomic phenotype, which reinforces the knowledge regarding the biology of the fish.
Alternative feed ingredients and protein sources for the aqua feed industry due to insufficient global supplies of FM1,2 is of great necessity in the aquaculture sector. Although insect larvae meals are considered as very promising alternative to provide valuable proteins for aqua feeds and have been in the spotlight of many researches, extensive study is needed for adequate management of fish resources. The present study has highlighted that although cellular stress was evident in the three teleost species following dietary TM inclusion, European seabass and rainbow trout were able to suppress apoptosis through induction of hepatic autophagy, while in gilthead seabream, both cellular procedures were activated. Along with the changes observed in apoptotic and autophagic pathway, which play a vital role to cell and organism homeostasis, changes in protein abundance are also affected by the dietary composition and quality of consumed proteins. This study also shows that insect meal, at least in terms of protein changes, is more suitable for species whose natural diet includes such ingredients. The results of this study indicate that the most desirable fish diet substitution differentially affects fish protein profile, implying that a species-specific tailor-made approach in diet manipulations should be considered in the future (Fig. 5). To our knowledge, this is the first study that showed that insect (TM) meal inclusion stimulates higher protein abundance changes and lower fish growth in European seabass and rainbow trout compared to gilthead sea bream. However, a species-specific response both in apoptosis and autophagy, as well as the abundance of liver proteins, indicates a need to strategically manage fish meal replacement in fish diets per species. The proteomics and cellular stress response approach described here could be used to further investigate biochemical pathways that are likely to be affected due to fish diet composition in aquaculture and to identify protein change most associated with fish species-specific physiology. This lays the basis for future research to explore in detail the identity of the altered proteins and allow for more in-depth interpretation of the metabolic and cellular responses, delivering further insights into fish nutrition etiology and providing sustainable feeding management practices.
Olsen, R. L. & Hasan, M. R. A limited supply of fishmeal: Impact on future increases in global aquaculture production. Trends Food Sci. Technol. 27(2), 120–128 (2012).
Froehlich, H. E., Jacobsen, N. S., Essington, T. E., Clavelle, T. & Halpern, B. S. Avoiding the ecological limits of forage fish for fed aquaculture. Nat. Sustain. 1(6), 298–303 (2018).
Barroso, F. G. et al. The potential of various insect species for use as food for fish. Aquaculture 422, 193–201 (2014).
Lock, E.-J., Biancarosa, I. & Gasco, L. Insects as raw materials in compound feed for aquaculture. In Edible Insects in Sustainable Food Systems (eds Halloran, A. et al.) 263–276 (Springer, 2018).
Gasco, L., Biasato, I., Dabbou, S., Schiavone, A. & Gai, F. Animals fed insect-based diets: State-of-the-art on digestibility, performance and product quality. Animals 9(4), 170 (2019).
Gasco, L. et al. Insect and fish by-products as sustainable alternatives to conventional animal proteins in animal nutrition. Ital. J. Anim. Sci. 19(1), 360–372 (2020).
Mancuso, T., Poppinato, L. & Gasco, L. The European insects sector and its role in the provision of green proteins in feed supply. Calitatea. 20(S2), 374–381 (2019).
Sogari, G., Amato, M., Biasato, I., Chiesa, S. & Gasco, L. The potential role of insects as feed: A multi-perspective review. Animals 9(4), 119 (2019).
Gasco, L. et al. Tenebrio molitor meal in diets for European seabass (Dicentrarchus labrax L.) juveniles: Growth performance, whole body composition and in vivo apparent digestibility. Anim. Feed Sci. Technol. 220, 34–45 (2016).
Iaconisi, V. et al. Dietary replacement of Tenebrio molitor larvae meal: Effects on growth performance and final quality treats of blackspot sea bream (Pagellus bogaraveo). Aquaculture 476, 49–58 (2017).
Piccolo, G. et al. Effect of Tenebrio molitor larvae meal on growth performance, in vivo nutrients digestibility, somatic and marketable indexes of gilthead sea bream (Sparus aurata). Anim. Feed Sci. Technol. 226, 12–20 (2017).
Rema, P., Saravanan, S., Armenjon, B., Motte, C. & Dias, J. Graded incorporation of defatted yellow mealworm (Tenebrio molitor) in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) diet improves growth performance and nutrient retention. Animals 9(4), 187 (2019).
Chemello, G. et al. Partially defatted Tenebrio molitor larva meal in diets for grow-out rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss (Walbaum): Effects on growth performance, diet digestibility and metabolic responses. Animals 10(2), 229 (2020).
Mastoraki, M. et al. The effect of insect meal as a feed ingredient on survival, growth, and metabolic and antioxidant response of juvenile prawn Palaemon adspersus (Rathke, 1837). Aquac. Res. 51(9), 3551–3562 (2020).
Khosravi, S., Kim, E., Lee, Y. S. & Lee, S. M. Dietary replacement of mealworm (Tenebrio molitor) meal as an alternative protein source in practical diets for juvenile rockfish (Sebastes schlegeli). Entomol. Res. 48(3), 214–221 (2018).
Lin, Y. H. & Shiau, S. Y. The effects of dietary selenium on the oxidative stress of grouper, Epinephelus malabaricus, fed high copper. Aquaculture 267(1–4), 38–43 (2007).
Antonopoulou, E., Chouri, E., Feidantsis, K., Lazou, A. & Chatzifotis, S. Effects of partial dietary supplementation of fish meal with soymeal on the stress and apoptosis response in the digestive system of common dentex (Dentex dentex). J. Biol. Res. Thessalon. 24(1), 14 (2017).
Wei, H. C. et al. Plant protein diet suppressed immune function by inhibiting spiral valve intestinal mucosal barrier integrity, anti-oxidation, apoptosis, autophagy and proliferation responses in amur sturgeon (Acipenser schrenckii). Fish Shellfish Immunol. 94, 711–722 (2019).
Chen, J. W. et al. The responses of autophagy and apoptosis to oxidative stress in nucleus pulposus cells: Implications for disc degeneration. Cell. Physiol. Biochem. 34(4), 1175–1189 (2014).
Galati, S., Boni, C., Gerra, M. C., Lazzaretti, M. & Buschini, A. Autophagy: A player in response to oxidative stress and DNA damage. oxidative medicine and cellular longevity (2019).
Mariño, G., Niso-Santano, M., Baehrecke, E. H. & Kroemer, G. Self-consumption: The interplay of autophagy and apoptosis. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 15(2), 81–94 (2014).
Green, D. R. Means to an End: Apoptosis and Other Cell Death Mechanisms (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, 2011).
Martin, S. A. & Król, E. Nutrigenomics and immune function in fish: New insights from omics technologies. Dev. Comp. Immunol. 75, 86–98 (2017).
Rodrigues, P. M., Silva, T. S., Dias, J. & Jessen, F. Proteomics in aquaculture: Applications and trends. J. Proteom. 75(14), 4325–4345 (2012).
Rodrigues, P., Richard, N., De Vareilles, M., Silva, T. S. & Conceicao, L. E. Proteomics as a tool to develop molecular indicators of nutritional condition in farmed gilthead seabream. J. Proteom Bioinform. 5(6), 97 (2012).
Mente, E., Pierce, G. J., Antonopoulou, E., Stead, D. & Martin, S. A. Postprandial hepatic protein expression in trout Oncorhynchus mykiss a proteomics examination. Biochem. Biophys. Rep. 9, 79–85 (2017).
Martin, S. A. M., Cash, P., Blaney, S. & Houlihan, D. F. Proteome analysis of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) liver proteins during short term starvation. Fish Physiol. Biochem. 24(3), 259–270 (2001).
Martin, S. A. M. et al. Proteomic sensitivity to dietary manipulations in rainbow trout. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1651(1–2), 17–29 (2003).
Vilhelmsson, O. T., Martin, S. A., Médale, F., Kaushik, S. J. & Houlihan, D. F. Dietary plant-protein substitution affects hepatic metabolism in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Br. J. Nutr. 92(1), 71–80 (2004).
Jury, D. R. et al. Effects of calorie restriction on the zebrafish liver proteome. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. D. 3(4), 275–282 (2008).
de Vareilles, M. et al. Dietary Lysine Imbalance Affects muscle proteome in zebrafish (Danio rerio): A comparative 2D-DIGE study. Mar. Biotechnol. 14(5), 643–654 (2012).
Sissener, N. H. et al. Proteomic profiling of liver from Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) fed genetically modified soy compared to the near-isogenic non-GM line. Mar. Biotechnol. 12(3), 273–281 (2010).
Matos, E. et al. Influence of supplemental maslinic acid (olive-derived triterpene) on the post-mortem muscle properties and quality traits of gilthead seabream. Aquaculture 396–399, 146–155 (2013).
Kumar, D. et al. Integrating transcriptome and proteome profiling: Strategies and applications. Proteomics 16(19), 2533–2544 (2016).
Marguerat, S. et al. Quantitative analysis of fission yeast transcriptomes and proteomes in proliferating and quiescent cells. Cell 151(3), 671–683 (2012).
Vogel, C. & Marcotte, E. Insights into the regulation of protein abundance from proteomic and transcriptomic analyses. Nat. Rev. Genet. 13, 227–232 (2012).
Antonopoulou, E. et al. Reshaping gut bacterial communities after dietary Tenebrio molitor larvae meal supplementation in three fish species. Aquaculture 503, 628–635 (2019).
Cash, P., Argo, E. & Bruce, K. D. Characterisation of Haemophilus influenzae proteins by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. Electrophoresis 16(1), 135–148 (1995).
Kratz, E. et al. Functional characterization of the Bcl-2 gene family in the zebrafish. Cell Death Differ. 13(10), 1631–1640 (2006).
Yabu, T., Ishibashi, Y. & Yamashita, M. Stress-induced apoptosis in larval embryos of Japanese flounder. Fish. Sci. 69, 1218–1223 (2003).
Sánchez-Muros, M. J., Barroso, F. G. & Manzano-Agugliaro, F. Insect meal as renewable source of food for animal feeding: A review. J. Clean. Prod. 65, 16–27 (2014).
Renna, M. et al. Evaluation of the suitability of a partially defatted black soldier fly (Hermetia illucens L.) larvae meal as ingredient for rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss Walbaum) diets. J. Anim. Sci. Biotechnol. 8(1), 57 (2017).
Caimi, C. et al. First insights on Black Soldier Fly (Hermetia illucens L.) larvae meal dietary administration in Siberian sturgeon (Acipenser baerii Brandt) juveniles. Aquaculture 515, 734539 (2020).
Ye, H. et al. Effects of dietary plant protein sources influencing hepatic lipid metabolism and hepatocyte apoptosis in hybrid grouper (Epinephelus lanceolatus♂× Epinephelus fuscoguttatus♀). Aquaculture 506, 437–444 (2019).
Antonopoulou, E. et al. Starvation and re-feeding affect Hsp expression, MAPK activation and antioxidant enzymes activity of European Seabass (Dicentrarchus labrax). Comp. Biochem. Physiol. A. 165(1), 79–88 (2013).
Feidantsis, K. et al. Effect of taurine-enriched diets on the Hsp expression, MAPK activation and the antioxidant defence of the European seabass (Dicentrarchus labrax). Aquac. Nutr. 20(4), 431–442 (2014).
Je, J. Y. & Kim, S. K. Water-soluble chitosan derivatives as a BACE1 inhibitor. Bioorg. Med. Chem. 13, 6551–6555 (2005).
Kong, C. S., Kim, J. A., Bak, S. S., Byun, H. G. & Kim, S. K. Anti-obesity effect of carboxymethyl chitin by AMPK and aquaporin-7 pathways in 3T3-L1 adipocytes. J. Nutr. Biochem. 22(3), 276–281 (2011).
Kroemer, G., Galluzzi, L. & Brenner, C. Mitochondrial membrane permeabilization in cell death. Physiol. Rev. 87(1), 99–163 (2007).
Lugrin, J., Rosenblatt-Velin, N., Parapanov, R. & Liaudet, L. The role of oxidative stress during inflammatory processes. Biol. Chem. 395, 203–230 (2014).
Li, S., Ji, H., Zhang, B., Zhou, J. & Yu, H. Defatted black soldier fly (Hermetia illucens) larvae meal in diets for juvenile Jian carp (Cyprinus carpio var. Jian): Growth performance, antioxidant enzyme activities, digestive enzyme activities, intestine and hepatopancreas histological structure. Aquaculture 477, 62–70 (2017).
Song, S. G. et al. Effects of fishmeal replacement by Tenebrio molitor meal on growth performance, antioxidant enzyme activities and disease resistance of the juvenile pearl gentian grouper (Epinephelus lanceolatus♂× Epinephelus fuscoguttatus♀). Aquac. Res. 49, 2210–2217 (2018).
Espe, M. & Holen, E. Taurine attenuates apoptosis in primary liver cells isolated from Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar). Br. J. Nutr. 110, 20–28 (2013).
Mizushima, N. & Komatsu, M. Autophagy: Renovation of cells and tissues. Cell 147(4), 728–741 (2011).
Kobayashi, S. Choose delicately and reuse adequately: The newly revealed process of autophagy. Biol. Pharm. Bull. 38(8), 1098–1103 (2015).
Ichimura, Y. et al. A ubiquitin-like system mediates protein lipidation. Nature 408(6811), 488–492 (2000).
Kabeya, Y. et al. LC3, a mammalian homologue of yeast Apg8p, is localized in autophagosome membranes after processing. EMBO J. 19(21), 5720–5728 (2000).
Vadlamudi, R. K., Joung, I., Strominger, J. L. & Shin, J. p62, a phosphotyrosine-independent ligand of the SH2 domain of p56lck, belongs to a new class of ubiquitin-binding proteins. J. Biol. Chem. 271(34), 20235–20237 (1996).
Bjørkøy, G., Lamark, T. & Johansen, T. p62/SQSTM1: A missing link between protein aggregates and the autophagy machinery. Autophagy 2(2), 138–139 (2006).
Komatsu, M. et al. Homeostatic levels of p62 control cytoplasmic inclusion body formation in autophagy-deficient mice. Cell 31(6), 1149–1163 (2007).
Portt, L. et al. Anti-apoptosis and cell survival: A review. Biochim Biophys. Acta. 1813, 238–259 (2011).
Dodson, M., Darley-Usmar, V. & Zhang, J. Cellular metabolic and autophagic pathways: Traffic control by redox signaling. Free Radic. Biol. Med. 63, 207–221 (2013).
Feedtables, Composition. and nutritive values of feeds for cattle, sheep, goats, pigs, poultry, rabbits, horses and salmonids, a programme by INRA, CIRAD and AFZ. www.feedtables.com.
Díaz-Troya, S., Pérez-Pérez, M. E., Florencio, F. J. & Crespo, J. L. The role of TOR in autophagy regulation from yeast to plants and mammals. Autophagy 4, 851–865 (2008).
Yabu, T., Imamura, S., Mizusawa, N., Touhata, K. & Yamashita, M. Induction of autophagy by amino acid starvation in fish cells. Mar. Biotechnol. 14, 491–501 (2012).
Filomeni, G., De Zio, D. & Cecconi, F. Oxidative stress and autophagy: The clash between damage and metabolic needs. Cell Death Differ. 22, 377–388 (2015).
Seiliez, I. et al. An in vivo and in vitro assessment of autophagy-related gene expression in muscle of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Comp. Biochem. Physiol. B. 157, 258–266 (2010).
Wu, P. et al. Effects of starvation on antioxidant-related signaling molecules, oxidative stress, and autophagy in juvenile Chinese perch skeletal muscle. Mar. Biotechnol. 22, 81–93 (2020).
Mommsen, T. P. Salmon spawning migration and muscle protein metabolism: The August Krogh principle at work. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. B. 139, 383–400 (2004).
Seiliez, I., Dias, K. & Cleveland, B. M. Contribution of the autophagy-lysosomal and ubiquitin-proteasomal proteolytic systems to total proteolysis in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) myotubes. Am. J. Physiol. 307, R1330–R1337 (2014).
Belghit, I. et al. Dietary methionine availability affects the main factors involved in muscle protein turnover in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Br. J. Nutr. 112, 493–503 (2014).
Andersen, S. M., Waagbø, R. & Espe, M. Functional amino acids in fish health and welfare. Front. Biosci. 8, 143–169 (2016).
Mastoraki, M. et al. A comparative study on the effect of fish meal substitution with three different insect meals on growth, body composition and metabolism of European seabass (Dicentrarchus labrax L.). Aquaculture 528, 735511 (2020).
Salze, G. P. & Davis, D. A. Taurine: A critical nutrient for future fish feeds. Aquaculture 437, 215–229 (2015).
Matias, A. C. et al. Taurine modulates protein turnover in several tissues of meagre juveniles. Aquaculture 528, 735478 (2020).
Cheng, C.-H., Guo, Z.-X. & Wang, A.-L. The protective effects of taurine on oxidative stress, cytoplasmic free-Ca2+ and apoptosis of pufferfish (Takifugu obscurus) under low temperature stress. Fish Shellfish Immunol. 77, 457–464 (2018).
Enyu, Y. L. & Shu-Chien, A. C. Proteomics analysis of mitochondrial extract from liver of female zebrafish undergoing starvation and refeeding. Aquac. Nutr. 17(2), e413–e423 (2011).
Power, M. E. Effects of fish in river food webs. Science 250(4982), 811–814 (1990).
Bell, J. G., Ghioni, C. & Sargent, J. R. Fatty acid compositions of 10 freshwater invertebrates which are natural food organisms of Atlantic salmon parr (Salmo salar): A comparison with commercial diets. Aquaculture 128(3–4), 301–313 (1994).
Financial support for the trial on European sea bass was provided by the AQUAEXEL Project PROINSECTLIFE (Ref. No. 0013/03/05/15B), the AQUAEXEL Project INDIFISH (Ref. No. 0125/08/05/15/TNA), and by the University of Turin (ex 60%) Grant (Es. fin. 2014). NP (Scholarship Code: 1752) has been financially supported by the General Secretariat for Research and Technology (GSRT) of Greece and the Hellenic Foundation for Research and Innovation (HFRI) and MM by the Operational Programme “Human Resources Development, Education and Lifelong Learning” in the context of the project “Strengthening Human Resources Research Potential via Doctorate Research” (MIS-5000432) as implemented by the State Scholarships Foundation (ΙΚΥ). Thanks to Evelyn Argo and Craig Pattinson (University of Aberdeen) for providing help with 2DE. EM was financially supported by Marine Alliance for Science and Technology Scotland (MASTS) visiting Fellowship.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Mente, E., Bousdras, T., Feidantsis, K. et al. Tenebrio molitor larvae meal inclusion affects hepatic proteome and apoptosis and/or autophagy of three farmed fish species. Sci Rep 12, 121 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-03306-8