As fossilized feces, coprolites represent direct evidence of animal behavior captured in the fossil record. They encapsulate past ecological interactions between a consumer and its prey and, when they contain plant material, can also guide paleoenvironmental reconstructions. Here we describe the first coprolites from the lagerstätte Rancho La Brea (RLB) in Los Angeles, California, which also represent the first confirmed coprolites from an asphaltic (“tar pit”) context globally. Combining multiple lines of evidence, including radiocarbon dating, body size reconstructions, stable isotope analysis, scanning electron microscopy, and sediment analyses, we document hundreds of rodent coprolites found in association with plant material, and tentatively assign them to the woodrat genus Neotoma. Neotoma nests (i.e., middens) and their associated coprolites inform paleoclimatic reconstructions for the arid southwestern US but are not typically preserved in coastal areas due to environmental and physiological characteristics. The serendipitous activity of an asphalt seep preserved coprolites and their original cellulosic material for 50,000 years at RLB, yielding a snapshot of coastal California during Marine Isotope Stage 3. This discovery augments the proxies available at an already critical fossil locality and highlights the potential for more comprehensive paleoenvironmental analyses at other asphaltic localities globally.
Coprolites are some of the most important ichnofossils that can be recovered from a diversity of taphonomic, ecological, and geologic contexts1. As trace fossils, coprolites represent windows into the evolution of ecological interactions such as predation, herbivory, and parasitism, and can contain paleoecological proxies spanning thousands to millions of years in the past2,3,4. In deep time, they are permineralized or lithified, constituting a cast or mold of the original fecal matter5. Conversely, coprolites containing their original biological material have been recovered from a taxonomically diverse range of Quaternary vertebrates including, for example, ground sloths6, mammoths7, crocodiles8, and moas9. The intact digested matter present in Quaternary coprolites can provide crucial evidence for testing ecological questions that may be otherwise difficult to address in the fossil record and that can be examined with techniques suitable for bridging fossil and modern samples (e.g., identification of plant macrofossils and pollen, ancient DNA, and biomarkers10). Despite these advantages, the preservation of Quaternary coprolites is biased to cold or arid climates, permanently wet sites, caves, rock shelters, and/or high elevation areas, thereby excluding many ecosystems, deposits, and taxonomic groups from this form of study.
Rancho La Brea (RLB) is a famous Quaternary lagerstätte that has yielded >5 million specimens and is located in Los Angeles, California (34°03′48″N, 118°21′20″W). Studies leveraging RLB’s abundant and well-preserved vertebrate remains have defined our understanding of late Pleistocene carnivores, through studies of morphological change11, pathologies12, and trophic interactions13,14. Far less attention, however, has historically been focused on primary producers and the lower trophic levels of food webs, thus hindering the current use of the site for paleoenvironmental proxies despite its potential (though see recent entomological progress15). While known colloquially as the “La Brea Tar Pits”, the site actually comprises a series of asphaltic deposits containing fossil material in a matrix of gravels, sands, silts, and clays—the “pit” shapes are the result of human excavations that subsequently refilled with liquid asphalt16. RLB sits above the Salt Lake Oilfield, and throughout the Late Quaternary, Miocene-aged hydrocarbons migrated upwards from the Puente Formation reservoir (Monterey Formation equivalent in the Los Angeles Basin17), resulting in periodically surficial liquid asphalt that infiltrated sediments, entrapped organisms, and preserved biological tissues including bone collagen, insect chitin, plant cellulose, and mollusk shells18. While RLB’s climatic and elevational qualities do not align with optimal coprolite recovery conditions given its low elevation, non-arid coastal setting that favors decomposition rather than desiccation, the biological material of coprolites could theoretically be preserved by rapid impregnation with liquid asphalt.
The vast majority of catalogued RLB specimens originated from >90 deposits (“pits”) that were excavated with a near-exclusive focus on the bones of large mammals and birds in the early 1900s18. Reconstructions based on megafaunal remains consider the site to have operated as a “trap” in which carnivores were attracted to struggling herbivores stuck in pooling surficial asphalt, subsequently died, and were rapidly covered19,20. Extensive disarticulation of faunal elements and lack of stratigraphic integrity in RLB deposits have been cited to invoke churning of viscous, asphalt-saturated sediments and/or trampling by panicked animals as primary processes in the formation of RLB fossil deposits19,20, both of which could preclude the preservation of intact coprolites. Other models that incorporate geologic lines of evidence instead emphasize the roles of fluviatile agents and burial by alluvium from the Santa Monica Mountains; such a high-energy depositional environment could also be unfavorable for coprolite preservation16.
A new opportunity to systematically excavate RLB deposits arose when, in 2006, the construction of an adjacent underground parking garage for the Los Angeles County Museum of Art (LACMA; Fig. 1A) unearthed 16 new fossiliferous asphaltic deposits. Entire blocks were exposed and pedestalled, and custom boxes were then built around deposits, allowing them to be removed and transplanted intact from their in situ position in 23 custom-built wooden boxes (“Project 23”). Project 23’s Box 1, weighing ~123,000 lbs and measuring 4 m wide x 5 m long x 2 m deep, was the first to be excavated, and has yielded >25,000 specimens21,22. Excavation efforts in Box 1 were focused primarily on the main vertebrate deposit of coarse sediment (referred to as the “main vent” for consistency with prior work22; grids A1–2/B1–2; Fig. 1B) that most closely mirrored a “typical” fossiliferous RLB deposit containing the remains of ungulates such as Bison, Camelops, Odocoileus and Equus; the carnivores Canis, Lynx, Panthera, Puma, and Smilodon; and the ground sloths Nothrotheriops and Paramylodon22.
Here we report the first confirmed coprolites in the 100-year history of RLB’s extensive exploration and the first confirmed asphalt-preserved coprolites, providing new taphonomic scenarios for both RLB and the known preservation conditions of coprolites. We combine multiple lines of evidence to identify and describe the coprolites and their paleoecological significance, including radiocarbon dating, stable isotope analysis, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and comparative measurements. Both body size reconstructions and a plant macrofossil context suggest that the coprolite producer was of the genus Neotoma, a group of rodents whose middens form the backbone of paleoclimatic inferences across arid and high elevation ecosystems of North America. These specimens provide a direct window into the behavior of a still-extant small mammal and the base of a southern California food web ~50,000 years ago, during Marine Isotope Stage 3 prior to the last glacial maximum. As there are three other fossiliferous asphaltic localities in California alone (Carpinteria, McKittrick, and Maricopa18) and more than a dozen globally across the Americas and Eurasia23, we suggest that closer inspection using quantitative analyses for identifying taphonomic diversity would help improve palaeoecological reconstructions based on these deposits.
Fecal pellet discovery in Box 1
Rodent fecal pellets were first noted in matrix washing records by excavators in 2016 while following standard Project 23 salvage processing protocols, which include asphalt removal with n-propyl bromide and bulk sieving24. The fecal pellets were first thought to be modern contamination produced by the invasive rats prevalent in urban Los Angeles (black rat, Rattus rattus, or brown rat, Rattus norvegicus). The pellet-containing grids in Box 1 were found outside of the megafauna-containing “main vent” and included articulated millipedes, birds, turtles, and plant mats in the context of finer sands, silts, and clays. The fecal pellets in this study were found in the grid square C3 and excavation depth level 7 (thus the unit C3/L7, Fig. 1B), that differed from typical coarse-grained RLB asphaltic disarticulated vertebrate deposits25. Subsequent analyses of bulk sediment in 2018 demonstrated that material from the unit C3/L7 contained higher than average percent asphalt content as compared with “typical” RLB sediments (~35–45% asphalt for C3/L7 as compared with ~5–10% asphalt for Box 13, B3/L525).
Determination of fecal pellet age
Hydrocarbon contaminants such as asphaltenes were removed from the pellets to produce radiocarbon dates on bleached holocellulose22. Direct radiocarbon dates on two individual pellets yielded 14C ages of >47,000 years before present (ybp), confirming that these fecal pellets are indeed coprolites and are not the result of modern contamination by invasive Rattus in a highly urbanized area (Table 1). While the probability distributions of all of the dates extend well beyond the range of the IntCal13 calibration26, the overall trend of that curve suggests median calibrated ages close to 50,000 ybp or older, with likely calibrated uncertainties of 1000–2,500 ybp. The two coprolite dates (UCIAMS-199130, UCIAMS-203246) overlap with their large errors. Therefore, it is reasonable to suggest that the coprolites were either deposited contemporaneously by one or multiple individuals or by a series of individuals occupying a transgenerational midden, as is the typical scenario for paleomiddens across North America27. We also produced two dates on oak leaves accompanying the coprolites (UCIAMS-220767, UCIAMS-220768), confirming the stratigraphic association of the material within the unit C3/L7. This temporal range is ~10,000 years older on average than the more than 30 radiocarbon dates previously produced on fossils excavated from Box 1’s “main vent”21,22.
Identity of the coprolites
The coprolites are cylindrical pellets that represent terrestrial mammal feces (“group III” characterization28) found in a context of plant macrofossils, fine sediments, and a high percent asphalt content (Fig. 2). SEM imaging revealed the presence of plant material within the coprolites, consistent with an herbivorous rodent as the producer (Fig. 3). This was corroborated by average carbon stable isotope (δ13C) values of −24.5 ± 0.59 indicative of a diet comprising C3 plants, and a mean %C of 43.2% ± 1.50 on cellulosic material (n = 10) (Supplemental Material). A number of small mammal skeletal elements have been recovered from other grid/level units within Box 1, spanning four orders including Lagomorphs, Eulipotyphlans, Chiropterans, and Rodents. Rabbits (Lagomorpha: Leporidae: Lepus californicus, Sylvilagus audubonii, Sylvilagus bachmani) can be eliminated based on pellet size and the cylindrical (as opposed to rounded) morphology. An exclusively herbivorous diet is also inconsistent with the resource use of eulipotyphlans such as shrews (e.g, Sorex ornatus) as well as insectivorous rodents (e.g., Onychomys sp.). Potential rodent candidates that can be discerned by coprolite shape, size, and consistency include geomyids (Thomomys bottae), heteromyids (Perognathus, Dipodomys), sciuirids (Otospermophilus, Eutamias), and cricetids (Microtus, Peromyscus, Reithrodontomys, and Neotoma).
The sheer quantity of pellets (hundreds, potentially thousands) and location in an exceptionally large mass of plant macrofossils is consistent with a rodent nest, such as the middens produced by woodrats (Neotoma sp.). The surface of each pellet is generally smooth with small fissures that expose what appear to be plant fibers (Fig. 3). A measured sample of 431 randomly selected cylindrical pellets from the unit C3/L7 had an average length of 9.59 ± 1.34 mm, ranging from 6.25–13.37 mm, and a width of 3.86 ± 0.47 mm, ranging from 2.43–5.43 mm. Such measurements are consistent with the widths of fecal pellets reported in the literature for the genus Neotoma (Table 2). Pellet width is more consistently diagnostic of rodent species as diet items can generate variable pellet lengths29.
As is consistent with the Neotoma literature, we assume that these fecal pellets represent multiple generations of individuals and therefore are a population-level estimate of fecal pellets, rather than representing fecal pellets produced from a single individual rodent; intergenerational use of one midden is the standard assumption of paleontological studies and has been documented in the modern day27. We estimated body size using an equation that relates body mass to width of the fecal pellets29. Various body size estimates that account for ontogeny and exclusion of juveniles/subadults, including the widest 50%, widest 50, and widest 20 pellets, are consistent with the genus Neotoma, in particular the two species that are known to occupy Los Angeles county in the present day: Neotoma macrotis (the big-eared woodrat) and Neotoma lepida (the desert woodrat) (Fig. 4A). While we use the species names macrotis and lepida to remain consistent with local museum collections, we recognize there have been recent systematic revisions for the Neotoma lepida group30 that are not reflected in museum labels (e.g, skeletal remains at RLB are listed as Neotoma fuscipes but Neotoma fuscipes macrotis has been elevated to Neotoma macrotis31); we are primarily interested in an identification at the genus level. Coprolite-based estimates of body size range from ~100–200 grams, which is also consistent with measurements of museum specimens of Neotoma collected in Los Angeles county (Fig. 4B). Such estimates may represent a conservative underestimate of body mass given the effects of pellet desiccation and asphalt removal.
Coprolites provide one of the most direct windows into past behaviors and ecological interactions available in the paleontological record. Neotoma middens and the coprolites and plant macrofossils contained within them have come to define our understanding of Quaternary vegetation in the arid southwestern US32. While the USGS-NOAA midden database contains ~3,200 individual middens (USGS/NOAA North American Packrat Midden Database v.4; https://geochange.er.usgs.gov/midden/search.html), nearly all of these are restricted to the arid southwest due to favorable environmental preservation factors and physiological variations including the viscous urine of desert dwelling species adapted to dry conditions that hardens into a resinous substance called amberat33. Recent studies have highlighted the limitations of this ecological and spatial restriction to such preservation conditions, and the exclusion coastal regions in forming a broader narrative of North American vegetation change34. The RLB material described here represents the first occurrence of Neotoma coprolites and associated plant material from the Pacific coast (Los Angeles) and are therefore a new geographic contribution to the paleoecological proxy literature.
Their size, physical appearance, isotopic composition, and depositional context within significant quantities of plant macrofossils suggest that the fecal pellets from RLB represent coprolites produced by rodents of the woodrat genus Neotoma. Neotoma droppings typically accumulate within the nest chamber of a midden and each individual rodent can produce enormous quantities of fecal pellets; for example, a single captive female has been documented to produce 144 pellets over the course of just 24 hours35. This occurrence represents the westernmost locality for Neotoma coprolites, distinctive in both its present-day low elevation (~50 masl) and proximity to the Pacific coastline. The RLB coprolites are also exceptional in their age of ~50,000 ybp, within Marine Isotope Stage 3 (MIS3)36 (Table 1); of the 345 midden occurrences in California, less than 1% pre-date 40,000 ybp, and <2% recorded occurrences are older than 30,000 ybp. Moreover, all of the pre-30,000 ybp middens in California represent localities characterized by high elevations and/or arid climates (e.g, Kings Canyon, Joshua Tree, Death Valley, Mojave Desert37,38,39,40,41); Fig. 4).
Two woodrat species co-occur in the Los Angeles region today: the big-eared woodrat, Neotoma macrotis, and the desert woodrat, Neotoma lepida (Fig. 4). Today, Neotoma lepida is typically associated with arid environments and is common in pinyon-juniper, sagebrush, and desert habitats including Joshua Tree and the Mojave Desert42. Neotoma macrotis prefers chaparral with moderate tree canopy and understory brush and is a specialist on oak (Quercus agrifolia) in the western coastal Santa Ana mountains of California43. It is possible that Neotoma fuscipes was present during the cooler temperatures of the Late Pleistocene and its range has shifted northwards in the Holocene and present day. However, Neotoma fuscipes and macrotis form hybrid zones today in central California44 and as distinguishing the evolutionary history of these two species is difficult in the present-day, we do not attempt to do so from coprolites alone. Ancient DNA analyses have so far been unsuccessful for RLB vertebrate material45, precluding the use of genetic identification techniques for Neotoma species in RLB deposits for now.
The range of RLB coprolite-based body size estimates, and thus species identifications, depends on the number of coprolites considered as the representative population. Using the largest fecal pellets for a population estimate29, the widest 20–50 coprolites would be consistent with Neotoma macrotis, yet the larger sample (top 50% of all pellets) encompasses variation that extends to Neotoma lepida. Members of the genus Neotoma have been shown to follow Bergman’s rule, where populations experiencing colder temperatures exhibit larger average body sizes46. Therefore, this size variation could represent either within-species responses to past temperature fluctuations captured in the intergenerational record or could be due to species turnover at the site in response to changing microclimates or vegetation at the local scale. Including the full error range and calibration uncertainty, the temporal span of the RLB coprolite radiocarbon dates stretches across two Greenland interstadials (numbers 12, 13) and an intervening stadial during MIS347. Regional climate records from lake cores suggest a more mesic and cooler MIS348,49. However, these records are from higher elevation areas; for example, today Lake Elsinore is 400 meters above sea level, while RLB is just 50 meters above sea level and therefore Lake Elsinore may not reflect the local conditions of the Los Angeles basin. The only available quantitative paleoclimate record for the Los Angeles basin is derived from insect-based temperature analogues from RLB, which suggest local conditions were more aligned with modern values, and less mesic and cool than suggested by lake cores (mean summer temperatures within ±5 °C of modern conditions and summer precipitation from 0–40mm15). Unfortunately, paleoclimate inferences from RLB’s existing botanical descriptions are currently considered unreliable due to the lack of stratigraphic and taphonomic context (including allochthonous vs. autochthonous origins) for curated isolated specimens50,51. There is thus a clear need to develop additional quantitative microclimate and vegetation proxies at RLB, such as the plant macrofossils associated with our stratified C3L7 unit, which are of direct relevance to furthering paleoecological interpretations of vertebrates13,22.
As a lagerstätte, RLB is well-known for both its preservation of an exceptional abundance of specimens as well as a diversity of taxonomic groups and tissues including collagen, chitin, and cellulose18. The only published reports of ichnofossils at RLB are from insects: post-mortem bone damage resulting from carrion-consuming beetles52 and intact wasp galls53. Insects also represent the only record of fossilized nest building behavior documented at RLB: a specimen of fossilized leafcutter bee (Megachile gentilis, LACMRLP 388E from Pit 91) preserves pupal morphology and nest cell construction in three dimensions54. For such preservation to occur, the leafcutter bee likely created its nest first in a non-asphaltic area, and this nest was subsequently infiltrated by a newly active asphalt seep— a probable scenario for the coprolite-associated plant material reported here.
Vertebrate behavior has been inferred at RLB indirectly via the study of pathologies12, morphological proxies (e.g, dental microwear55), and stable isotopes of bone collagen13,22 and tooth enamel14. The coprolites, as the first fossilized diet product at RLB, are thus unique in directly capturing a record of vertebrate behavior: in this case, Neotoma’s consumption of leaves and other plant fibers, as evidenced in SEM images of coprolite cross-sections. Plant tissues vary distinctively in the ranges of their percent carbon (%C) values: leaves are 42–50% C, stems are 46–48% C, and wood/twigs are 40–44% C56. With an average %C of 43.2 ± 1.50%, the RLB coprolites are consistent with a Neotoma diet of leaves and/or twigs.
Stable isotopes of carbon (δ13C) are a widely used tool in evaluating the diets and food web linkages of past organisms as it relates to primary producer pathways (e.g., C3 vs. C4 plants). Previous research at RLB has pointed to largely C3 vegetation conditions in the immediate area based on the δ13C values of megafauna bone collagen13,22. The Neotoma coprolites have a mean δ13C of −24.5‰ ± 0.59, suggesting the meals consisted of C3 plants and that the rodents foraged in a closed wooded environment. Although plant stable isotopes have seldom been studied at RLB, δ13C values of a contemporaneous C3 plant, juniper (Juniperus) from 40,140–68,000 years before present have been reported as −19 to −22‰57 and a single unidentified piece of “wood” has yielded a δ13C value of −20.2‰ from Project 23’s Box 122. Correcting for the enrichment between diet item and consumer (a rodent specific feces-diet fractionation of δ13Cfeces-diet = Δ = −3.77‰58), the RLB Neotoma δ13C values could be more consistent with consumption of juniper, Juniperus sp., rather than oak (estimated diet value δ13C = −20.73‰; RLB juniper values −19–22‰; P23–39539 oak = −24.4‰). Modern Neotoma are known to consume juniper when it is available59, and juniper is abundant in preserved woodrat middens across California’s Mojave Desert and Death Valley60. The δ13C values of RLB coprolites are also broadly consistent with those recovered from tissues of modern Neotoma fuscipes populations inhabiting juniper woodlands61. Given the exceptional preservation of these coprolites, investigation of additional diet proxies, such as plant cuticles62, may be possible.
The coprolites differ from the coarser “main vent” of Box 1 in their sedimentary context, the higher asphalt content of their surrounding matrix, and their significantly older age. For example, radiocarbon dates on saber-tooth cat (Smilodon fatalis), dire wolf (Canis dirus), and American lion (Panthera atrox) span ~33–37,000 14C years before present (uncalibrated), as compared with our dates of 46–49,000 14C years before present (uncalibrated)21,22 (Fig. 5). This difference is most consistent with a scenario in which there were either two activity periods of the same seep or two different, temporally segregated seeps. While it is possible that the coprolites and associated plant material were buried and then secondarily preserved in-situ by the same asphalt seep that generated the “main vent” deposit 10,000 years later, this is unlikely because the very climatic and elevational qualities that have heretofore prevented midden recovery from coastlines would very likely have precluded the exceptional preservation of material seen here for 10,000 years prior to impregnation with asphalt. Combined with a previous insect radiocarbon study at Rancho La Brea15, these coprolites suggest that the processes dictating preservation of small organisms such as rodents and plants may differ from those producing non-stratified megafaunal assemblages15.
There are three other known fossiliferous asphaltic deposits within California linked to hydrocarbons of the Monterey Formation and their equivalents, all of which were historically excavated in the early-mid 1900s: Carpinteria on the Pacific Coast, and McKittrick and Maricopa inland within the central valley18. All three have yielded plant, insect, and vertebrate remains, though they vary in their preservational quality63. Neotoma skeletal remains have been reported from Carpinteria64 and McKittrick’s Sternberg pit (UCMP locality −7139; listed as N. lepida and N. fuscipes). With renewed study, it is possible that coprolites may be encountered at these localities as well.
Globally, while the genus Neotoma is not present in South America, several families of rodents including chinchilla rats (Abrocomidae), viscachas (Chinchillidae), leaf-eared mice (Cricetidae), and degus (Octodontidae) have been used in paleoenvironmental reconstructions because their similarly urine-hardened deposits contain plant macrofossils and pollen65. Perhaps future studies of South American asphaltic deposits23, with renewed attention to sediment and microfossil excavation protocols, could also yield rodent coprolites and nests of paleoecological relevance. Indeed, a recent study from Tanque Loma in Ecuador hypothesized that plant material associated with a mass death assemblage of ground sloths (Eremotherium) could represent disaggregated fecal material66. Similarly, the presence of putative “cigar-shaped” coprolites “the size and shape of rodentia” has been reported from the asphaltic site Las Breas de San Felipe of Cuba67. In both cases, these promising observations have yet to be tested with quantitative, stratigraphic, and chemical analyses and, in light of our study, warrant further investigation.
Our multidisciplinary study highlights the evolving proxies and techniques that can be employed to reconstruct paleoenvironments at asphaltic localities. We also emphasize the value of paleomitigation endeavors in urban areas, such as Project 23, which can yield unanticipated and high-quality datasets that benefit research questions. Traditional studies at RLB have focused on reconstructing the interactions between megafaunal mammal carnivores and herbivores, e.g., saber-tooth cats and bison13 and attempting to track how carnivores respond to climatic and biotic perturbations14. However, such studies have yet to incorporate values of primary producers in assessing isotopic change through time, and thus do not account for potential baseline shifts in stable isotopes of nitrogen that may obscure true inferences of trophic position shifts68. Prior studies of RLB plant material have been hampered by a lack of stratigraphic control for plant assemblages, and the plant macrofossils in the midden of C3/L7, and potentially others, represent stratigraphically intact material that could be assessed as a coherent assemblage. While Neotoma is no longer present in the immediate RLB vicinity of Hancock Park because of extreme habitat modification and isolation from natural areas, the genus is still found in nearby urban-suburban green spaces such as Griffith Park (~9 km away), where sightings of both the rodents and their middens are abundantly recorded on citizen science platforms such as iNaturalist (https://www.inaturalist.org). Thus, the coprolites featured here provide an unexpected baseline of the past, and one that could be connected to the present through new studies of “urban” Los Angeles middens, yielding a transect through time of changing climates, ecosystem baselines, and animal behaviors.
Excavation of Rancho La Brea’s Project 23 began in August 2008 as a salvage/mitigation project. Sixteen entire asphaltic deposits were removed from their in situ position in one or multiple intact sections. Custom-sized wooden boxes were built around blocks of sediment containing asphaltic deposits and filled in with polyurethane foam and fill dirt to preserve integrity during storage. Boxes range in weight from ~123,000 lbs (Box 1) to ~9,000 lbs (Box 10B). Excavation took place within the “boxes” (Fig. 1C), with walls removed as needed to allow excavation to proceed following standard protocols developed for RLB deposit Pit 9169. All grids are oriented with respect to the deposit’s original north orientation, with alphanumeric grid/level combinations excavated in 25 cm spits. Sediments and fossiliferous matrix were placed into 5-gallon metal buckets corresponding to specific grid/level excavation units. Asphalt was removed from the microfossil matrix using heated biodiesel and n-propyl bromide24. Cleaned matrix was screened through a #20 ASTM standard mesh (0.85 mm sieve size) initially; such a mesh size is the typical tool for processing Neotoma fossil middens70. The coprolites were encountered in unit C3/L7 of Box 1 during processing.
We processed additional 2 kg batches of previously unprocessed sediment archived at the La Brea Tar Pits & Museum long-term storage for Project 23 salvage, following a modified version of the museum’s standard protocol24 in which sieves of additional size were used (10 meshes ranging from 5/16” to #400 ASTM size) to account for smaller sediments and microfossils. Percent asphalt content was calculated by subtracting the dried, processed sediment weight from its original 2 kg weight. Though we employed fine mesh sizes to capture fine sands and silts, loss during sieving and drying is possible and thus we may slightly overestimate asphalt content due to sediment weight loss through processing. Unfortunately, initial salvage excavations did not retain bulk unprocessed sediment for the “main vent” A1–2/B1–2; we therefore used material from highly similar deposits from Project 23’s Box 13, B3/L5 grid for direct quantitative comparison25.
We produced radiocarbon dates for two individual coprolites (P23–33721 batch catalogued) and two sets of directly associated oak leaves (P23–39548, P23–39539), thus accounting for potential differences in age of deposition. While asphalt is an effective preservative agent of organic material, it is also a hydrocarbon contaminant that will skew dates to artificially older ages. Residual asphalt was removed using toluene/methanol rinses until liquid was clear, followed by methanol and water21. We performed an acid-base-acid wash (1 N HCL and 1 N NaOH at 75 °C) and bleached samples to holocellulose (1:1 mixture of 1 N HCl and 1 M NaClO2) prior to combustion. Graphitized specimens were run at UC Irvine W.M. Keck Carbon Cycle Accelerator Mass Spectrometer Facility. Using OxCal v.4.3.2, we found the probability distributions of the resulting dates to be outside the range of the calibration curve IntCal13 and could not confidently report a calibrated median or 95.4% age range26. Following the above pre-treatment procedures for radiocarbon dating, we produced stable isotope values of δ13C only; bleaching precludes analysis of δ15N. δ13C values were measured to a precision of <0.1‰ using a Fisons NA1500NC elemental analyzer/Finnigan Delta Plus isotope ratio mass spectrometer. We present %C as the carbon percentage in the treated cellulosic material measured.
We generated high-resolution SEM images of four individual coprolites that were cleaned following standard biodiesel/n-propyl bromide protocols, with two imaged whole (P23–33820, P23–33821) and two splits (P23–38822, P23–38819). We sputter-coated individual coprolites in a mixture of gold and palladium using an Emitech K550x sputter coater to provide conductive metal coating for SEM. Images were generated using a Hitachi S-3000N variable-pressure scanning electron microscope at the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County.
We measured the length and width of 431 fecal pellets from Box 1’s unit C3/L7 using digital calipers to the nearest 0.1 mm. Following standard protocol29, we dropped the 50% narrowest pellets by width to avoid inclusion of subadults. We also present the mean of the widest top 50, top 20, and top 10 by width, as it has been shown to be less sensitive to sampling method27,29.We assume that these fecal pellets represent multiple generations of individuals and therefore are a population-level estimate, rather than the deposition of an individual rodent, as is known from modern woodrat midden studies27. We estimated body size using an equation29 (y = 0.005×+ 3.559, r2 = 0.69, p < 0.0001) that relates body mass to width of the fecal pellets. For a comparative reference, we collected values on modern fecal width from the literature for Neotoma fuscipes35 and Neotoma lepida71 – two species that co-occur in the Los Angeles county area based on specimen occurrences and their associated metadata at the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County. We generated a comparative reference set of body masses for these two species from weight recorded at capture for Neotoma macrotis (historically Neotoma fuscipes macrotis31) (N = 30) and Neotoma lepida (N = 59) caught in Los Angeles county. While we use the species names fuscipes and lepida to remain consistent with local museum collections, we recognize there have been recent systematic revisions for the Neotoma lepida group30, and Neotoma fuscipes macrotis has been elevated to Neotoma macrotis31; we are primarily interested in an identification at the genus level.
All fossil specimens are publicly available at the La Brea Tar Pits & Museum collections and comparative modern specimens are publicly available at the LACM Mammalogy collection. All relevant data are in the manuscript or are available as supplemental materials.
Qvarnström, M., Niedzwiedzki, G. & Zigaite, Z. Vertebrate coprolites (fossil faeces): an underexplored konservat-lagerstatte. Earth-Science Reviews. 162, 44–57 (2016).
Barrios-de Pedro, S., Poyato-Ariza, F. J., Moratalla, J. J. & Buscalioni, A. D. Exceptional coprolite association from the Early Cretaceous continental lagerstatte of Las Hoyas, Cuenca, Spain. PLoS One 13, e0196982, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0196982 (2018).
Dentzien-Dias, P. C. et al. Tapeworm eggs in a 270 million-year-old shark coprolite. PLoS One 8, e55007, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0055007 (2013).
Qvarnström, M., Niedzwiedzki, G., Tafforeau, P., Zigaite, Z. & Ahlberg, P. E. Synchrotron phase-contrast microtomography of coprolites generates novel paleobiological data. Scientific Reports. 7, 2723, https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-017-02893-9 (2017).
Bajdek, P. et al. Residues from the Upper Permian carnivore coprolites from Vyazniki in Russia - key questions in reconstruction of feeding habits. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. 482, 70–82 (2017).
Poinar, H., Kuch, M., McDonald, G., Martin, P. & Pääbo, S. Nuclear gene sequences from a Late Pleistocene sloth coprolite. Current Biology. 13, 1150–1152 (2003).
Kirillova, I. V. et al The diet and environment of mammoths in North-East Russia reconstructed from the contents of their feces. Quaternary International. 406 Part B, 147–161 (2016).
Morgan, G. S. & Albury, N. A. The Cuban crocodile (Crocodylus rhombifer) from late Quaternary fossil deposits in the Bahamas and Cayman Islands. Bulletin of the Florida Museum of Natural History. 52, 161–236 (2013).
Boast, A. P. et al. Coprolites reveal ecological interactions lost with the extinction of New Zealand birds. PNAS. 115, 1546–1551 (2018).
Wood, J. R. & Wilmshurst, J. M. A protocol for subsampling Late Quaternary coprolites for multi-proxy analysis. Quaternary Science Reviews. 138, 1–5 (2016).
Binder, W. J., Cervantes, K. S. & Meachen, J. A. Measures of relative dentary strength in Rancho La Brea Smilodon fatalis over time. PLoS One 11, e0162270, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0162270 (2016).
Scott, E., Rega, E., Scott, K., Bennett, B. & Sumida, S. A pathological timber wolf (Canis lupus) femur from Rancho La Brea indicates extended survival after traumatic amputation injury. Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County Science Series. 42, 33–36 (2015).
Coltrain, J. B. et al. Rancho La Brea stable isotope biogeochemistry and its implications for the palaeoecology of late Pleistocene, coastal southern California. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. 205, 199–219 (2004).
DeSantis, L. R. G. et al. Causes and consequences of Pleistocene megafaunal extinctions as revealed from Rancho La Brea mammals. Current Biology. 29, P2488–P2495 (2019).
Holden, A. R. et al. A 50,000 year insect record from Rancho La Brea, Southern California: insights into past climate and fossil deposition. Quaternary Science Reviews. 168, 123–136 (2017).
Woodard, G. D. & Marcus, L. F. Rancho La Brea fossil deposits: a re-evaluation from stratigraphic and geologic evidence. Journal of Paleontology. 47, 54–69 (1973).
Critelli, S., Rumelhart, P. E. & Ingersoll, R. V. Petrofacies and provenance of the Puente Formation (middle to upper Miocene), Los Angeles Basin, Southern California: implications for rapid uplift and accumulation. Journal of Sedimentary Research. 65, 656–667 (1995).
Stock, C., & Harris, J. M. Rancho la Brea: A record of Pleistocene life in California. Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County Science Series. 37, 7th ed.:i–xiv + 1–113 (1992).
Spencer, L. M., Van Valkenburgh, B. & Harris, J. M. Taphonomic analysis of large mammals recovered from the Pleistocene Rancho La Brea tar seeps. Paleobiology. 29, 561–575 (2003).
Friscia, A. R., Van Valkenburgh, B., Spencer, L. & Harris, J. Chronology and spatial distribution of large mammal bones in Pit 91, Rancho La Brea. Palaios. 23, 35–42 (2008).
Fuller, B. T. et al. Ultrafiltration for asphalt removal from bone collagen for radiocarbon dating and isotopic analysis of Pleistocene fauna at the tar pits of Rancho La Brea, Los Angeles, California. Quaternary Geochronology. 22, 85–98 (2014).
Fuller, B. T. et al. Pleistocene paleoecology and feeding behavior of terrestrial vertebrates recorded in a pre-LGM asphaltic deposit at Rancho La Brea, California. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. 537, 109383 (2020).
Lindsey, E. L. & Seymour, K. L. “Tar Pits” of the Western Neotropics: paleoecology, taphonomy, and mammalian biogeography. Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County Science Series. 42, 111–123 (2015).
Rice, K. A., Sessions, A., Lai, K. & Takeuchi, G. T. New technique to remove asphalt from microfossil-rich matrix from Rancho La Brea. Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County Science Series. 42, 169–174 (2015).
Rice, K., et al Examining preservation bias and depositional setting with grain size at La Brea Tar Pits fossil bed, California. GSA Annual Meeting in Phoenix, Arizona, USA published abstracts. https://doi.org/10.1130/abs/2019AM-341137 (2019).
Bronk Ramsey, C. Bayesian analysis of radiocarbon dates. Radiocarbon. 51, 337–360 (2009).
Smith, F. A. & Betancourt, J. L. Predicting woodrat (Neotoma) responses to anthropogenic warming from studies of the palaeomidden record. Journal of Biogeography. 33, 2061–2076 (2006).
Chame, M. Terrestrial mammal feces: a morphometrics summary and description. Memorias do Instituto Oswaldo Cruz. 98(Suppl. I), 71–94 (2003).
Smith, F. A., Betancourt, J. L. & Brown, J. H. Evolution of body size in the woodrat over the past 25,000 years of climate change. Science. 270, 2012–2014 (1995).
Patton, J. L., Huckaby, D. G. & Álvarez-Castañeda, S. T. The evolutionary history and a systematic revision of woodrats of the Neotoma lepida group. University of California Publications in Zoology, Volume 135 (2014).
Matocq, M. D. Morphological and molecular analysis of a contact zone in the Neotoma fuscipes species complex. Journal of Mammalogy. 83, 866–863 (2002).
Harbert, R. S. & Nixon, K. C. Quantitative Late Quaternary climate reconstruction from plant macrofossil communities in western North America. Open Quaternary. 4, 8, https://doi.org/10.5334/oq.46 (2018).
Vaughan, T. A. Ecology of living packrats. In Betancourt, J.L., Van Devender, T.R., and Martin, P.S. (eds.) “Packrat Middens: The Last 40,000 Years of Biotic Change”. University of Arizona Press. pp. 14–27 (1990).
Inman, R., Franklin, J., Esque, T. & Nussear, K. Spatial sampling bias in the Neotoma paleoecological archives affects species paleodistribution models. Quaternary Science Reviews. 198, 115–125 (2018).
Vestal, E. H. Biotic relations of the wood rat (Neotoma fuscipes) in the Berkeley Hills. Journal of Mammalogy. 19, 1–36 (1938).
Brandefelt, J. et al. A coupled climate model simulation of Marine Isotope Stage 3 stadial climate. Clim. Past. 7, 649–670 (2011).
Cole, K. Late Pleistocene vegetation of Kings Canyon, Sierra Nevada, California. Quaternary Research. 19, 117–129 (1983).
Woodcock, D. The late Pleistocene of Death Valley: a climatic reconstruction based on macrofossil data. Paleogeography, Paleoclimatology, Paleoecology. 57, 273–283 (1986).
Cole, K. L. & Webb, R. H. Late Holocene vegetation changes in Greenwater Valley, Mojave Desert, California. Quaternary Research. 23, 227–235 (1985).
Holmgren, C. A., Betancourt, J. L. & Rylander, K. A. A long-term vegetation history of the Mojave-Colorado Desert ecotone at Joshua Tree National Park. Journal of Quaternary Science. 25, 222–236 (2010).
Koehler, P. A. & Anderson, R. S. Thirty thousand years of vegetation changes in the Alabama Hills, Owens Valley, California. Quaternary Research. 43, 238–248 (1995).
Verts, B. J. & Carraway, L. N. Neotoma lepida. Mammalian Species 699, 1–12 (2002).
Atsatt, P. R. & Ingram, T. Adaptation to oak and other fibrous, phenolic-rich foliage by a small mammal, Neotoma fuscipes. Oecologia. 60, 135–142 (1983).
Coyner, B. S., Murphy, P. J. & Matocq, M. Hybridization and asymmetric introgression across a narrow zone of contact between Neotoma fuscipes and N. macrotis (Rodentia: Cricetidae). Biological Journal of the Linnaean Society. 115, 162–172 (2015).
Gold, D. A. et al. Attempted DNA extraction from a Rancho La Brea Columbian mammoth (Mammuthus columbi): prospects for ancient DNA from asphalt deposits. Ecology and Evolution. 4, 329–336 (2014).
Smith, F. A. & Betancourt, J. L. Response of bushy-tailed woodrats (Neotoma cinerea) to late Quaternary climatic change in the Colorado Plateau. Quaternary Research. 50, 1–11 (1998).
Svensson, A. et al. A 60 000 year Greenland stratigraphic ice core chronology. Clim. Past. 4, 47–57 (2008).
Heusser, L. E., Kirby, M. E. & Nichols, J. E. Pollen-based evidence of extreme drought during the last Glacial (32.6-9.0 ka) in coastal southern California. Quaternary Science Reviews. 126, 242–253 (2015).
Kirby, M. E., Lund, S. P. & Bird, B. W. Mid-Wisconsin sediment record from Baldwin Lake reveals hemispheric climate dynamics (Southern CA, USA). Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. 241, 267–283 (2006).
Templeton, B. C. Fossil plants in the La Brea deposits. Los Angeles County Museum of Natural History Quarterly. 12, 8–11 (1955).
Heusser, L. E. Direct correlation of millennial-scale changes in western North America vegetation and climate with changes in the California Current system over the past ~60 kyr. Paleoceanography. 13, 252–262 (1998).
Holden, A. R., Harris, J. M. & Timm, R. M. Paleoecological and taphonomic implications of insect-damaged Pleistocene vertebrate remains from Rancho La Brea, Southern California. PLoS One. 8, e67119, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0067119 (2013).
Holden, A. R., Erwin, D. M., Schick, K. N. & Gross, J. Late Pleistocene galls from the La Brea Tar Pits and their implications for cynipine wasp and native plant distribution in southern California. Quaternary Research. 84, 358–367 (2015).
Holden, A. R., Koch, J. B., Griswold, T., Erwin, D. M. & Hall, J. Leafcutter bee nests and pupae from the Rancho La Brea tar pits of Southern California: implications for understanding the paleoenvironment of the Late Pleistocene. PLoS One. 9, e94724, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0094724 (2014).
Jones, D. B. & DeSantis, L. R. G. Dietary ecology of ungulates from the La Brea tar pits in southern California: a multi-proxy approach. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. 466, 110–127 (2017).
Ma, S. et al. Variations and determinants of carbon content in plants: a global synthesis. Biogeosciences. 15, 693–702 (2018).
Ward, J. K. et al. Carbon starvation in glacial trees recovered from the La Brea tar pits, southern California. PNAS. 102, 690–694 (2005).
Hwang, Y. T., Millar, J. S. & Longstaffe, F. J. Do δ15N and δ13C values of feces reflect the isotopic composition of diets in small mammals? Canadian Journal of Zoology. 85, 388–396 (2007).
Dial, K. P. Three sympatric species of Neotoma: dietary specialization and coexistence. Oecologia. 76, 531–537 (1988).
Wells, P. V. & Woodcock, D. Full-glacial vegetation of Death Valley, California: juniper woodland opening to Yucca semidesert. Madrono. 32, 11–23 (1985).
McEachern, M. B., Eagles-Smith, C. A., Efferson, C. M. & Van Vuren, D. H. Evidence for local specialization in a generalist mammalian herbivore, Neotoma fuscipes. Oikos. 113, 440–448 (2006).
Borrelli, M. P. & Holmgren, C. A. Dietary modifications of packrats in response to changing plant communities: Evidence from fossil plant cuticles spanning >55,000 years in Sonoran Desert packrat middens. Journal of Arid Environments. 138, 1–8 (2016).
Fox-Dobbs, F., Dundas, R. G., Trayler, R. B. & Holroyd, P. A. Paleoecological implications of new megafaunal 14C ages from the McKittrick tar seeps, California. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 34, 220–223 (2014).
Wilson, R. W. Pleistocene mammalian fauna from the Carpinteria asphalt. Carnegie Institute of Washington. 440, 59–76 (1933).
de Porras, M. E., Maldonado, A., Pol-Holz, R. D., Latorre, C. & Betancourt, J. L. Late Quaternary environmental dynamics in the Atacama Desert reconstructed from rodent midden pollen records. Journal of Quaternary Science. 32, 665–684 (2017).
Lindsey, E. L., Lopez Reyes, E. X., Matzke, G. E., Rice, K. A. & McDonald, G. A monodominant late-Pleistocene megafauna locality from Santa Elena, Ecuador: insight on the biology and behavior of giant ground sloths. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. 544, 109599 (2020).
Iturralde-Vinent, M. A. et al. Las Breas de San Felipe, a Quaternary fossiliferous asphalt seep near Marti (Matanzas Province, Cuba). Caribbean Journal of Science. 36, 300–313 (2000).
Tahmasebi, F., Longstaffe, F. J. & Zazula, G. Nitrogen isotopes suggest a change in nitrogen dynamics between the Late Pleistocene and modern time in Yukon, Canada. PLoS One. 13, e0192713, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0192713 (2018).
Shaw, C. A. Techniques used in excavation, preparation, and curation of fossils from Rancho La Brea. Curator The Museum Journal. 25, 63–77 (1982).
Spaulding, W. G., Betancourt, J. L., Cole, K. L. & Croft, L. K. Packrat middens: Observations on composition, methods of analysis, and nature of the data. In: Betancourt, J. L. Van Devender, T. R. Martin, P. S. Fossil Packrat Middens: The Last 40,000 Years of Biotic Change in the Desert Southwest Univ. of Arizona Press (1990).
Smith, F. A. et al. A tale of two species: extirpation and range expansion during the late Quaternary in an extreme environment. Global and Planetary Change. 65, 122–133 (2009).
We are thankful for the excavation and preparation efforts of La Brea Tar Pits & Museum staff including Beau Campbell, Sean Campbell, Connie Clark, and Stephany Potze, and the invaluable contributions of museum volunteers including Lynn Schneider and Brooke Hambley. For facilitating access to specimens, we thank Aisling Farrell and Gary Takeuchi of the La Brea Tar Pits & Museum and Jim Dines of the LACM Mammalogy department. Carrie Howard provided specimen photographs and Giar-Ann Kung guided use of SEM machinery at LACM (supported by NSF DBI-0216506). We are grateful for the guidance and expertise of UCIAMS lab staff members in preparing coprolites for radiocarbon dating. Comments from Libby Ellwood, Nate Fox, Mairin Balisi, Jessie George, and two anonymous reviewers greatly enhanced the quality of this manuscript. We thank the contributors to PhyloPic for allowing modification of their silhouette images. A.M.M was supported by a Japan Society for the Promotion of Science Short-Term Postdoctoral Fellowship (PE19723) at Hokkaido University while developing this manuscript.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Mychajliw, A.M., Rice, K.A., Tewksbury, L.R. et al. Exceptionally preserved asphaltic coprolites expand the spatiotemporal range of a North American paleoecological proxy. Sci Rep 10, 5069 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-020-61996-y