A large volcanic sulfate increase observed in ice core records around 1450 C.E. has been attributed in previous studies to a volcanic eruption from the submarine Kuwae caldera in Vanuatu. Both EPMA–WDS (electron microprobe analysis using a wavelength dispersive spectrometer) and SEM–EDS (scanning electron microscopy analysis using an energy dispersive spectrometer) analyses of five microscopic volcanic ash (cryptotephra) particles extracted from the ice interval associated with a rise in sulfate ca. 1458 C.E. in the South Pole ice core (SPICEcore) indicate that the tephra deposits are chemically distinct from those erupted from the Kuwae caldera. Recognizing that the sulfate peak is not associated with the Kuwae volcano, and likely not a large stratospheric tropical eruption, requires revision of the stratospheric sulfate injection mass that is used for parameterization of paleoclimate models. Future work is needed to confirm that a volcanic eruption from Mt. Reclus is one of the possible sources of the 1458 C.E. sulfate anomaly in Antarctic ice cores.
The second largest sulfate loading event in the last 2500 years has long been thought to originate from the Kuwae caldera in Vanuatu. This event would be second only to the 1259 C.E. Samalas eruption in Indonesia1 in sulfate emission, and would have had a similar to or possibly larger impact on the climate system than the 1815 C.E. Tambora eruption2,3,4. Ice core studies first suggested the occurrence of a large volcanic event around 1450 C.E. based on glaciochemical evidence in a South Pole ice core5, a large electrical conductivity spike at 1460 C.E. in East Antarctica6, and a sulfate increase between 1380–1460 C.E. in a South Pole ice core7. The Greenland ice sheet acidity record also shows a modest increase at 1450 C.E.8, which was not thought to be a tropical volcanic event at the time. Later, Pang9 tied the southern hemisphere ice core anomaly to a large volcanic event from Kuwae volcano in Vanuatu primarily utilizing historical reports and tree ring data. The Kuwae caldera collapse was first suggested to have occurred in 1425 C.E., based on historical reconstructions and radiocarbon dating10. The timing was shortly revised by Robin et al.11 to 1452–1453 C.E. by combining 14C and ice core chronologies. Published tree ring frost damage12 and density data13 were interpreted as being the result of a strong cooling in the northern hemisphere in 1453 C.E., seemingly confirming 1452 C.E. as the start of the major volcanic eruption.
A number of Greenland and Antarctic ice core studies2,3,14,15,16 accepted the 1452 C.E. age and Kuwae as the source caldera. At odds with this are proximal volcanological data collected at Tongoa and Tongariki islands17, reported as a sequence of subaqueous deposits with no evidence of widespread fall deposits that would be expected for a large caldera-forming eruption. The same report also disputed early historical evidences, and pointed to early radiocarbon dates17,18. This information did not influence the attribution of the largest sulfate signal observed in the developed 2000-yr Law Dome ice core record around 1458 C.E. to the large caldera forming event from Kuwae19.
Recently, the eVolv2k compilation of stratospheric volcanic injections listed the 1458 C.E. event as the third largest since 500 B.C.E., but Kuwae was not identified as a potential source20. Updated tree-ring based paleoclimate reconstructions strongly support a major cooling event in 1453 C.E. in the Northern Hemisphere21, implying that a large tropical volcanic event occurred in 1452 C.E. There are no similar reconstructions yet available for the Southern Hemisphere.
Recent developments in methodology and instrumentation in the last decade have made it possible to detect and measure physicochemical properties of ultra fine tephra particles (cryptotephra) in various depositional media22. The new methodology has made it possible to correlate tephra deposits located thousands of kilometers from source volcanoes23,24. Here we test the proposed source of this large 1450s enigmatic sulfate signal by investigating the geochemical composition of cryptotephra (micron sized volcanic glass particles) extracted from ice sampled between 72.53–72.63 meters depth of the South Pole Ice Core (SPICEcore) from Antarctica (89.99°S, 98.16°W; Fig. 1). According to the SP19 timescale25, developed using annual layer counting and volcanic signal synchronization with the WDC-06A ice core, this depth interval corresponds to 1458 C.E (Supplementary Fig. S1). To date, no ice-core-based studies have analyzed cryptotephra extracted from the mid-1450s interval. Cryptotephra geochemistry23 is instrumental for independent verification of developed time scales and source confirmation of identified volcanic events, which is what this work was originally designed to do.
The particles found in the SPICEcore are rhyolitic with ~75 wt.% SiO2, ~3 wt.% Na2O and K2O, and ~2 wt.% FeO. Figure 2 and Table S2 show the major element concentrations (expressed as oxide weight percent) for two particles measured by EMPA-WDS and for five particles measured by SEM-EDS. All individual point measurements were averaged after normalization of data from both analyses. In previous ice core cryptotephra work studies26, a 2% uncertainty for SEM-EDS analyses was established and observed standard deviation of a secondary standard rhyolite glass fit within this parameterization (see Supplemental section for details).
We observed (Fig. 2) slight variations between the two measurement techniques and within populations measured using the same instrument. The SEM-EDS population variability, notably in K2O and CaO, can be explained by the particles being unpolished. Rough surface geometry is known to cause some geochemical variations27. Iverson and others26 established that for some major element oxides, unpolished SEM-EDS measurements are robust enough to be useful for geochemical comparison despite a high standard deviation. In addition, the microprobe results show generally higher Na2O wt% compared to the SEM-EDS measurements. This is expected because microprobes are configured to measure Na2O in the first counting period during EPMA tephra analyses, whereas all elements are measured simultaneously during SEM-EDS analyses (longer counting time could result in Na loss on the SEM/EDS), and the SEM-EDS measurements are on unpolished particles, which increases variability of the results.
The geochemical composition of volcanic glass particles extracted from 72.53–72.63 meters depth in the South Pole ice core is very distinct from Kuwae eruptive products. The Kuwae glass analyses published by Robin et al.11 define a basic to intermediate geochemical composition (Fig. 2). The high SiO2 observed in ice core tephra particles is inconsistent with any known Kuwae eruptive products. An argument could be made that these particles represent a more evolved composition of the Kuwae glass; however, low K2O values do not support this (Fig. 2). The expected trend for the measured ice core cryptotephra SiO2/K2O ratio is in disagreement with values expected for Kuwae eruptive products, which suggests that the ice core cryptotephra originated from a different volcanic source. The composition of ice core cryptotephra is chemically distinct from Kuwae with a similarity coefficient (SC)22,28,29 around 0.5 (see Table S3). In ideal cases, an SC exceeding 0.92 is considered to be a reasonable match29. Therefore, other volcanic sources for these particles must be considered.
Relatively large particle size (Fig. 3), implies rapid (within weeks after injection into the atmosphere) particle transport, so a range of regional volcanic sources are possible. Typical regional sources for tephra in Antarctic ice cores are Antarctic, sub-Antarctic, South American, and New Zealand volcanoes30,31,32.
The last 1000 years of the New Zealand volcanism record is fairly comprehensive33, therefore missing a large eruption from a New Zealand source would be unlikely. One large New Zealand rhyolitic event (Fig. 2) was the Kaharoa eruption which occurred in 1314 C.E. from Taupo Volcanic Zone34. Because the tephra was extracted from a relatively modern part of the ice core record, the uncertainty in the layer counting-based SP19 timescale25 is relatively low (±3 years). Therefore, the age alone makes Kaharoa tephra an unlikely candidate for the SPICEcore tephra deposits match. In a very comprehensive volcanism record from New Zealand there are no other identified eruptions from New Zealand around the 1450’s, which makes New Zealand volcanism an unlikely source for the tephra extracted from the SPICEcore, despite a very similar geochemical signature (SC range 0.7–0.9, see Table S3) of Kaharoa tephra from the eruption of Mt. Tarawera. The affiliation of tephra with the large sulfate increase also rules out potential transport of wind blown material from New Zealand.
The present characterization of South American and Antarctic volcanism in the 1450’s is less comprehensive than other localities (i.e. New Zealand), and a volcanic eruption from these regions could be a source for SPICEcore tephra deposits. Antarctic volcanism during the last 1000 years typically has a basic composition35 and no known rhyolitic eruptions occurred in the 15th century in Antarctica. However, the Malta Plateau volcanic area is known for compositionally evolved lavas35. A comparison of a general geochemical suite of eruptive products from this area is shown in Fig. 2. It is not a perfect match because FeO values from Malta Plateau volcanic products are within a range of 3–10 wt.%, which is higher than the 1–2.5 wt.% observed in SPICEcore tephra. According to Thouret et al.36, an eruption was observed in the 1450s C.E. at El Misti volcano in Peru. Geochemical data from this volcanic center are included in Fig. 2 for comparison. The SPICEcore tephra SiO2 and K2O geochemical fingerprint is inconsistent with the El Misti signature. A geochemical match (SC ranging from 0.7 to 0.8, Table S3) with Reclus tephra and evidence of recent activity of that volcano point to the possibility that a relatively large, unknown volcanic eruption from this volcanic center is responsible for this largest increase in sulfate in Antarctic ice cores in the last two millennia37.
The highly variable magnitude and duration of the sulfate peak observed in many Antarctic ice core records (Figs 1, S1) favors a South American source volcanic eruption around 1458 C.E. The 1453 C.E. temperature anomalies in the Northern Hemisphere and the sulfate increase in Greenland ice cores around 1454 and 1460 C.E.38 can possibly be attributed to different volcanic eruptions occurring in the northern hemisphere. Several moderate eruptions occurring in both hemispheres over a short time frame could have complex global effects on atmospheric circulation patterns and temperatures39. Location sources and potentially different timing for signals attributed to a large volcanic eruption from the Kuwae caldera call for revision of parameterization values for ice core based volcanic forcing time series used in climate models since the pioneering work of40.
In addition, the 1458 C.E. Antarctic sulfate signal timing should not be used to adjust the Greenland sulfate signal originally observed at 1452 C.E.3,12,13,14,21. Therefore, the proposed use of a 1458 C.E. event for bipolar synchronization1 should be reevaluated.
This study presents the first quantitative EPMA-WDS and EDS-based geochemical data set on volcanic glass particles extracted from the 72.53–72.63 m depth of the SPICEcore. These new data challenge the majority of previous studies that have suggested that the large sulfate peak present during the ~1450’s C.E. time interval is associated with a large tropical eruption from the Kuwae volcano in Vanuatu, while providing further evidence toward the emerging volcanological and historical data that question such attribution. An accurate determination of the volcanic eruption source and magnitude is important and data presented here suggest that Kuwae has been incorrectly used in past climate model simulations as a source of the ca. 1450s C.E. large sulfate signal in polar ice cores. Although no volcanic source is unambiguously identified in this research, particle size and sulfate appearance in many Antarctic ice core records suggest the eruption is likely affiliated with a tropospherically transported aerosol cloud. A reasonably good geochemical match of SPICEcore tephra with the Reclus volcano and relatively recent, compositionally similar reworked tephra in Laguna Potrok Aike, provide a basis for a preliminary conclusion that possibly an unknown Reclus eruption is responsible for the volcanic signal in Antarctic ice cores. These data contribute to the Antarctic tephra framework needed for future tephrochronological studies, and suggest that paleoclimate models using Kuwae as a climate-forcing event for the ca. 1450 C.E. climate anomaly need to be revised.
The sampled interval targeted to locate and extract tephra associated with the 1450s sulfate anomaly was initially selected based on the preliminary version of the SP19 timescale. We sampled two depth intervals: 72.43–72.525 m (sample AntT-335) and 72.525–72.63 m (AntT-336). The sampling was guided by the age of an electrical conductivity (ECM) anomaly in the SPICEcore41. In the final version of the SP19 time scale, developed using ECM, visual layer counting, sodium and magnesium ions measurements, interpolation between 251 stratigraphic volcanic tie points to the WD2014 chronology, and previously published South Pole ice core records, the increase in electrical conductivity starts around 1459 (±2) C.E. and lasts for two years25. The remarkable manifestation of the sulfate-based volcanic record at the South Pole is attributable to low contributions of sulfate from dust, biogenic, and anthropogenic sources as well as stratospheric air masses5. Supplementary Figs S1 and S2 highlight the studied SPICEcore interval and correlated volcanic signals in other Antarctic ice core records.
Using improved ice core tephra mounting methodologies (see online Supplementary section for more details), five tephra particles (ca. 5–50 μm in size) were captured and analyzed using a Tescan Vega-II XMU scanning electron microscope (SEM) equipped with an EDAX Apollo SSD40 energy dispersive spectrometer (EDS). The particles were analyzed on a single spot with a 140 pA beam for 100 seconds of live time at 15 kV of accelerating voltage. Major element oxides were calculated and adjusted using the semi-quantitative EDAX Genesis PhiRhoZ internal quantification procedure and the USNM 72854 VG-568 rhyolitic glass standard. The two largest particles were then polished and subsequently reanalyzed using a Cameca SX-100 electron microprobe equipped with five wavelength dispersive spectrometers (WDS). All measurements were made using instrumentation at the University of Maine. Analytical settings are discussed in Supplementary methods.
All analytical cryptotephra geochemical data shown in Figs 2 and S3 are available in the Supplement Table S2. The data that support findings of this study are available within the paper and its supplementary files. All tephra related microbeam measurements will be archived with the publication of this paper at the U.S. Antarctic Program Data Center (USAP-DC) http://www.usap-dc.org.
Sigl, M. et al. Timing and climate forcing of volcanic eruptions for the past 2,500 years. Nature 523, 543–549 (2015).
Cole-Dai, J., Mosley-Thompson, E., Wight, S. & Thompson, L. A 4100-year record of explosive volcanism from an East Antarctica ice core. Journal of Geophysical Research 105, 2431–24441 (2000).
Gao, C. et al. The 1452 or 1453 A.D. Kuwae eruption signal derived from multiple ice core records: Greatest volcanic sulfate event of the past 700 years. Journal of Geophysical Research-Atmospheres 111, 12107 (2006).
Witter, J. B. & Self, S. The Kuwae (Vanuatu) eruption of AD 1452: potential magnitude and volatile release. Bulletin of Volcanology 69, 301–318 (2006).
Legrand, M. R. & Kirchner, S. Origins and variations of nitrate in south polar precipitation. Journal of Geophysical Research 95, 3493–3507 (1990).
Moore, J. C., Narita, H. & Maeno, N. A continuous 770-year record of volcanic activity from east Antarctica. Journal of Geophysical Research-Atmospheres 96, 17353–17359 (1991).
Delmas, R. J., Kirchner, S., Palais, J. M. & Petit, J. R. 1000 years of explosive volcanism recorded at the South Pole. CNRS, Lab. de Glaciologie et Geophysique de l’Environnement, St.-Martin-d’Heres, France (1992).
Hammer, C. U., Clausen, H. B. & Dansgaard, W. Greenland ice sheet evidence of post-glacial volcanism and its climatic impact. Nature 288, 230–235 (1980).
Pang, K. D. Climatic impact of the mid-fifteenth century kuwae caldera formation, as reconstructed from historical and proxy data. Eos Trans. AGU 74, 10 (1993).
Monzier, M., Robin, C. & Eissen, J.-P. Kuwae (≈1425 A.D.): the forgotten caldera. Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research 59, 207–218 (1994).
Robin, C., Monzier, M. & Eissen, J.-P. Formation of the mid-fifteenth century Kuwae caldera (Vanuatu) by an initial hydroclastic and subsequent ignimbritic eruption. Bulletin of Volcanology 56, 170–183 (1994).
LaMarche, V. C. & Hirschboeck, K. K. Tree rings and volcanoes. Nature 307, 121–126 (1984).
Briffa, K. R., Jones, P. D., Schweingruber, F. H. & Osborn, T. J. Influence of volcanic eruptions on northern hemisphere summer temperature over the past 600 years. Nature 393, 450–455 (1998).
Zielinski, G. A. et al. Record of Volcanism Since 7000 B.C. from the GISP2 Greenland Ice Core and Implications for the Volcano-Climate System. Science 264, 948–952 (1994).
Langway, C. C., Osada, K., Clausen, H. B., Hammer, C. U. & Shoji, H. A 10-century comparison of prominent bipolar volcanic events in ice cores. Journal of Geophysical Research 100, 16241–16247 (1995).
Ferris, D. G., Cole-Dai, J., Reyes, A. R. & Budner, D. M. South Pole ice core record of explosive volcanic eruptions in the first and second millennia A.D. and evidence of a large eruption in the tropics around 535 A.D. Journal of Geophysical Research 116, D17308 (2011).
Németh, K., Cronin, S. J. & White, J. D. L. Kuwae Caldera and Climate Confusion. The Open Geology Journal 1, 7–11 (2007).
Oppenheimer, C. Ice core and palaeoclimatic evidence for the timing and nature of the great mid-13th century volcanic eruption. International Journal of Climatology 23, 417–426 (2003).
Plummer, C. et al. An independently dated 2000-yr volcanic record from Law Dome, East Antarctica, including a new perspective on the dating of the c. 1450s eruption of Kuwae, Vanuatu. Climate of the Past Discussions 8, 1567–1590 (2012).
Toohey, M. & Sigl, M. Volcanic stratospheric sulphur injections and aerosol optical depth from 500 BCE to 1900 CE. Earth System Science Data Discussions 1–40 (2017).
Esper, J., Buntgen, U., Hartl-Meier, C., Oppenheimer, C. & Schneider, L. Northern Hemisphere temperature anomalies during the 1450s period of ambiguous volcanic forcing. Bulletin of Volcanology 79, 41 (2017).
Lowe, D. J. et al. Correlating tephras and cryptotephras using glass compositional analyses and numerical and statistical methods: Review and evaluation. Quaternary Science Reviews (2017).
Pyne-O’Donnell, S. D. F. et al. Quaternary Science Reviews. Quaternary Science Reviews (2016).
Haflidason, H., Regnéll, C., Pyne-O’Donnell, S. D. F. & Svendsen, J. I. Extending the known distribution of the Vedde Ash into Siberia: occurrence in lake sediments from the Timan Ridge and the Ural Mountains, northern Russia. Boreas (2018).
Winski, D. A. et al. The SP19 Chronology for the South Pole Ice Core – Part 1: Volcanic matching and annual-layer counting. Climate of the Past Discussions (2019).
Iverson, N. A., Kalteyer, D., Dunbar, N. W., Kurbatov, A. V. & Yates, M. Advancements and best practices for analysis and correlation of tephra and cryptotephra in ice. Quaternary Geochronology 40, 45–55 (2017).
Goldstein, J. I. et al. Scanning Electron Microscopy and X-Ray Microanalysis, 3rd edition edn (Springer, New York, NY, 2003).
Borchardt, G., Aruscavage, P. & Millard, H. Correlation of the Bishop ash, a Pleistocene marker bed, using instrumental neutron activation analysis. Journal of Sedimentary Petrology 42, 301–306 (1972).
Froggatt, P. C. Standardization of the chemical analysis of tephra deposits. Report of the ICCT Working Group. Quaternary International 13/14, 93–96 (1992).
Basile, I., Petit, J. R., Touron, S., Grousset, F. E. & Barkov, N. Volcanic layers in Antarctic (Vostok) ice cores: Source identification and atmospheric implications. Journal of Geophysical Research 106, 31915–31931 (2001).
Dunbar, N. W. & Kurbatov, A. V. Tephrochronology of the Siple Dome ice core, West Antarctica: correlations and sources. Quaternary Science Reviews 30, 1602–1614 (2011).
Dunbar, N. W. et al. New Zealand supereruption provides time marker for the Last Glacial Maximum in Antarctica. Scientific Reports 7, 1181–1188 (2017).
Lowe, D. J., Blaauw, M., Hogg, A. G. & Newnham, R. M. Ages of 24 widespread tephras erupted since 30,000 years ago in New Zealand, with re-evaluation of the timing and palaeoclimatic implications of the Lateglacial cool episode recorded at Kaipo bog. Quaternary Science Reviews 74, 170–194 (2013).
Hogg, A. et al. A wiggle-match date for polynesian settlement of new zealand. Antiquity 77, 116–125 (2003).
LeMasurier, W. E. et al. (eds) Volcanoes of the Antarctic Plate and Southern Oceans, vol. 48 of Antarct. Res. Ser. (AGU, Washington, DC, 1990).
Thouret, J.-C. et al. Geology of El Misti volcano near the city of Arequipa, Peru. Bulletin of the Geological Society of America 113, 1593–1610 (2001).
Smith, R. E. et al. Refining the Late Quaternary tephrochronology for southern South America using the Laguna Potrok Aike sedimentary record. Quaternary Science Reviews 218, 136–156 (2019).
Cole-Dai, J. et al. Two likely stratospheric volcanic eruptions in the 1450s C.E. found in a bipolar, subannually dated 800 year ice core record. Journal of Geophysical Research-Atmospheres 118, 7459–7466 (2013).
Schmidt, A. M. Z. et al. Volcanic Radiative Forcing From 1979 to 2015. Journal of Geophysical Research-Atmospheres 123, 12,491–12,508 (2018).
Robock, A. & Free, M. Ice cores as an index of global volcanism from 1850 to the present. Journal of Geophysical Research 100, 11549–11568 (1995).
Lilien, D. A. et al. Holocene Ice-Flow Speedup in the Vicinity of the South Pole. Geophysical Research Letters 45, 6557–6565 (2018).
Wessel, P., Smith, W. H. F., Scharroo, R., Luis, J. & Wobbe, F. Generic Mapping Tools: Improved Version Released. Eos Trans. AGU 94, 409–410 (2013).
Bindschadler, R. et al. Getting around antarctica: new high-resolution mappings of the grounded and freely-floating boundaries of the antarctic ice sheet created for the international polar year. The Cryosphere 5, 569–588, https://www.the-cryosphere.net/5/569/2011/ (2011).
Osipov, E. Y. et al. High-resolution 900 year volcanic and climatic record from the Vostok area, East Antarctica. The Cryosphere 8, 843–851 (2014).
This work is directly supported by the National Science Foundation grants PLR1543454, 1142069 and 1542778. We would like to thank Mark Twickler, Joseph Souney and the SPICEcore Science Coordination Office; the U.S. Ice Drill Program Office for SPICEcore recovery; the 109th New York Air National Guard for transport in Antarctica; the members of South Pole station for field operations support. The U.S. NSF Ice Core Facility support for allocation and storage of SPICEcore samples and the many student researchers assisting on core packaging and processing are acknowledged.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Hartman, L.H., Kurbatov, A.V., Winski, D.A. et al. Volcanic glass properties from 1459 C.E. volcanic event in South Pole ice core dismiss Kuwae caldera as a potential source. Sci Rep 9, 14437 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-50939-x
A New Volcanic Stratospheric Sulfate Aerosol Forcing Emulator (EVA_H): Comparison With Interactive Stratospheric Aerosol Models
Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres (2020)
Volcanic Fluxes Over the Last Millennium as Recorded in the Gv7 Ice Core (Northern Victoria Land, Antarctica)