Triphenyl phosphate (TPHP) is one of the most highly utilized organophosphorus flame retardants, and has been frequently detected in various environmental matrices, including soil. So far, limited information is known regarding the potential toxicity of TPHP to the earthworm-soil ecosystem. We investigated the metabolism of TPHP and the perturbation of the endogenous metabolome in the earthworm, Perionyx excavatus, using gas chromatography mass spectrometry (GC-MS) and liquid chromatography quadrupole time-of-flight (LC-QTOF)-based untargeted metabolomics approach after acute exposure to TPHP for one and two days through a filter paper contact test, as well as after chronic exposure for 28 days in a soil microcosm experiment. TPHP showed low bioaccumulation potential in the earthworm-soil ecosystem at concentrations of 10 mg/kg and 50 mg/kg. Identified phase I metabolites include diphenyl phosphate, mono-hydroxylated and di-hydroxylated TPHP. Two groups of phase II metabolites, thiol conjugates (including mercaptolactic acid, cysteine, cysteinylglycine, and mercaptoethanol conjugates) and glucoside conjugates (including glucoside, glucoside-phosphate, and C14H19O10P conjugates), were putatively identified. Only acute TPHP exposure caused significant perturbations of the endogenous metabolome in earthworms, featuring fluctuations in amino acids, glucose, inosine and phospholipids. These results reveal novel phase II metabolism and toxicity of TPHP in P. excavatus.
Flame retardants are commonly added to manufactured materials, such as textiles and plastics, to inhibit the spread of fire. Since the phase-out of persistent, bioaccumulative and toxic polybrominated diphenyl ethers in 2004, the production of alternative flame retardants, such as organophosphate esters, has been increased to meet fire safety standards1. Triphenyl phosphate (TPHP) is one of the most highly utilized organophosphorus flame retardants, with usage volume reaching 4500–22700 tons in the United States as of 20062. It is incorporated in polyvinyl chloride and unsaturated polyester resins, as well as in commercial mixtures, such as Firemaster 550 (FM550)3. Since many flame retardants are present as additives rather than chemically bonded to the consumer products, they can be readily released into the environment via volatilization, leaching and abrasion1. TPHP has been detected in various environmental matrices. The concentrations of TPHP in private house dust samples reached 7360 ng/g (geometric mean) in 2002–20074, and 3000 ng/g (median value) in 2006–20115 in USA. A high level of TPHP (12,000 pg/m3) originating from traffic emissions was reported in the remote air from northern Finland6. The maximum reported level of TPHP reached 14 μg/L in the influent of wastewater treatment plant in Norway in 20077. Since TPHP is widely distributed in the environment, there is growing interest in its metabolic fate and toxicological effect on ecological systems.
Metabolism of TPHP has previously been studied in vitro in chicken embryonic hepatocytes8,9, human liver microsomes and the S9 fraction10 and human serum11, as well as in vivo in zebrafish12. Major phase I metabolites are diphenyl phosphate (DPHP), mono-hydroxylated (para- and meta-OH-TPHP) TPHP, and di-hydroxylated TPHP (di-OH-TPHP). Reported phase II metabolites include the glucuronide and sulfate conjugates of OH-TPHP as well as the glucuronide conjugate of di-OH-TPHP. Due to the structural similarity of TPHP with organophosphorus pesticides, TPHP has been linked with neurotoxicity, but so far reported studies have been conflicting1. Recent studies revealed that TPHP possesses endocrine disrupting properties13,14,15,16,17, and can also induce developmental toxicity in fish, including neurotoxicity18 and cardiotoxicity3. In rats, it can cause serum hypertriglyceridemia by inhibiting specific liver carboxylesterases19.
Knowledge of TPHP metabolism has so far been gained only from studies of human, chicken and aquatic organism exposure, whereas toxicological information available refers only to in vitro assays or in vivo studies involving rats and aquatic organisms. So far, no work regarding the metabolism and toxicity of TPHP on terrestrial organisms, such as earthworms, has been reported. Soil is vulnerable to contamination originated from aqueous TPHP, as well as atmospheric TPHP that can be globally transported and then deposited/precipitated1. Moreover, considerable release of TPHP to soil from e-waste recycling activities20 and plastic waste treatment21 has been confirmed. Once TPHP enters into the soil, its reverse release from soil to the air is considered to be negligible, due to its high estimated soil sorption coefficient (log Koc = 3.72) and low vapor pressure (1.2 × 10−6 mm Hg at 25 °C)1. These facts raise the concerns on whether TPHP elicits adverse effects on soil-dwelling organisms. Earthworms play important roles in organic matter turnover in terrestrial ecosystems, and are frequently used in ecotoxicology to investigate toxicity of anthropogenic chemicals present in soil22. Thus, investigating the metabolic fate and toxicity of TPHP on earthworms is warranted.
Metabolomics is an “omics” technology that characterizes measurement of the perturbations of a variety of metabolites in cells, tissues and biofluids under aberrant conditions. By analyzing significantly differentiated metabolites and their related pathways, metabolomics provides the opportunity to potentially gain insights on novel toxicity targets for xenobiotics. This saves time and resources compared with using multiple targeted assays in traditional toxicology studies, and allows discovery of novel biomarkers23. A few typical works24,25,26 using metabolomics to study sub-lethal toxicity of environmental contaminants on earthworm have exemplified its utility. A recent work using metabolomics to study zebrafish exposure to TPHP provided insights on the perturbation of carbohydrate and lipid metabolism27.
In this study, earthworms were exposed to TPHP in both acute and chronic exposure scenarios to investigate TPHP metabolism and toxicity. TPHP metabolites and endogenous metabolites of earthworm were comprehensively profiled by using multi-platform techniques combing liquid chromatography - quadrupole time-of-flight (LC-QTOF) tandem mass spectrometry and gas chromatography - mass spectrometry (GC-MS) analyses. Significantly altered metabolites were identified through multivariate statistical analysis. Various biotransformation products of TPHP were identified and perturbations of certain metabolic pathways caused by TPHP exposure were proposed.
TPHP degradation in soil and accumulation in earthworm
Figure 1(A) shows TPHP concentrations in soil through 28 days of chronic exposure. For both exposure groups of 50 mg/kg and 10 mg/kg, TPHP concentrations decreased gradually through time, both with earthworms and without earthworms in the soil. Final concentrations reached around 1/4 of the initial concentration of 50 mg/kg and 1/2 of the initial concentration of 10 mg/kg. Su et al.28 revealed that TPHP maintained its concentration in aqueous solution at pH 7–11 in the dark for 35 days, thus it is likely that TPHP did not degrade in the soil pore water. As the soil was placed in dark conditions during experiments, the concentration decrease may be mostly attributed to activity of soil microorganisms. An earlier study also revealed that TPHP degradation in soil was mostly mediated by microorganisms29.
TPHP concentrations in earthworms after acute and chronic exposure are shown in Fig. 1(B). For acute exposure, average TPHP concentrations in earthworms exposed to 1/10 LC50 for one day was higher than for two days, indicating fast biotransformation rate. The body-burden of TPHP depends on exposure concentrations. The bioaccumulation factor (BAF) can be calculated by dividing TPHP concentration in worms Cworm (ng/gdry weight) with that in the soil Csoil (ng/gdry weight). Here, BAF was calculated as 0.022–0.069 for 10 mg/kg group, and 0.075–0.319 for 50 mg/kg group. The BAF values are all less than 1, indicating low risk of bioaccumulation in earthworm-related food webs.
Identification of TPHP metabolites
In soil without earthworms, we identified two TPHP transformation products, DPHP and OH-TPHP. We putatively identified a list of phase I and phase II metabolites, as shown in Table 1, from the earthworm body after 28 days of exposure. Phase I metabolites include DPHP, OH-TPHP and di-OH-TPHP, which are consistent with previous reports of TPHP metabolites8,9,10,11,12. We did not find OH-DPHP, or monophenyl phosphate, indicating that no further hydroxylation or hydrolysis occurred. Interestingly, we found two groups of possible phase II conjugates, i.e. thiol conjugates and glucoside conjugates. Most of them are OH-TPHP conjugates, and there was only one di-OH-TPHP conjugate. The thiol conjugates included mercaptolactic acid, cysteine, cysteinylglycine, and mercaptoethanol conjugates, while glucoside conjugates included glucoside, glucoside-phosphate and C14H19O10P conjugates. The fragment with m/z 383.0503 appeared in mercaptolactic acid, cysteine, and cysteinylglycine conjugates, and we assigned it as TPHP-S1CH2C1. This assignment can be supported by the ESI+ Q-TOF fragments of L-cysteine, which can be found in the METLIN database. L-cysteine has a fragment with m/z 58.9956, which is assigned as H1S1CH2C1 in METLIN. This structure is the same as the conjugated part of TPHP-S1CH2C1, given that one hydrogen has been used for dehydration condensation in the conjugation process. We assigned the fragments with m/z 152.0608 and 215.0245 based on calculated formulae. Using a criterion of mass error <15 ppm and elemental compositions range of C0–100 H0–100 O0–10 P0–1, the predicted formulae for 152.0608 were C5H13O3P and C12H8, and the predicted formula for 215.0245 is C12H8O2P. C5H13O3P has an unsaturation of zero, which is not reasonable as a TPHP fragment. Therefore, C12H8 and C12H8O2P were annotated for m/z 152.0608 and 215.0245, respectively. In fact, the two fragments are from both triphenyl phosphate and diphenyl phosphate, and hence their assignment does not affect the identification of TPHP conjugates. The fragment with m/z 241.0118 in the MS/MS spectra of m/z 583.0797 in ESI- was assigned as C14H19O10P, i.e. a structure with missing hydrogen in the carbon that is bonded to TPHP-O. This structure might be explained by the loss of TPHP-OH from the precursor ion in the collision process. The structure of C14H19O10P could not be unambiguously identified by MS/MS spectra, and was tentatively assigned in Supplementary Fig. S2. The ion of the glutathione conjugate (a typical thiol conjugate) of OH-TPHP was found at much lower abundance than other thiol conjugates. Its MS/MS was not even triggered by information dependent acquisition. This indicates that glutathione conjugation comprises only a small portion of the thiol conjugations in the phase II metabolism of TPHP by earthworms. OH-TPHP and its thiol conjugates all have two or three isomers eluting at different retention times. This indicates that the hydroxyl substitution of TPHP could occur at the ortho-, meta-, and para- positions. Our results add to previously reported TPHP hydroxylations by Nele Van den et al.10, who found para- and meta- hydroxylated metabolites of TPHP in human liver fractions. Different glucoside isomers could also derive from alpha and beta glycosidic conjugation, which was reported previously in earthworms30. The MS/MS spectra of cysteine-TPHP (m/z 446.0811 in ESI+) and glucoside-TPHP (m/z 549.1181 in ESI-) are shown in Fig. 2 for structure confirmation. The MS/MS spectra of other conjugates can be found in Supplementary Fig. S2.
Multivariate analyses of GC-MS and LC-QTOF data
After acute exposure experiments, one worm died at 1/5 LC50 concentration after both days. The dead worms exhibited tapering tail and bleeding tissues. In contrast, there were no dead or deformed worm after chronic exposure. GC-MS and LC-QTOF in positive and negative mode were used to profile global metabolites in earthworm after acute and chronic TPHP exposure. Principal component analysis (PCA) was first performed for an overview of possible clustering of different treatment groups. Scores plot of features extracted from LC-QTOF positive mode spectra after acute exposure (Supplementary Fig. S3A) reveals a slight shift from control groups to exposure groups at both days. In addition, there were large overlaps of score points for both control groups and exposure groups at the same day. Hence, in further partial least squares discriminant analysis (PLS-DA) of these features, we grouped samples from two days together as “Control” and “Exposure”, respectively. In scores plots of features extracted from LC-QTOF negative mode spectra (Supplementary Fig. S3B) and GC-MS spectra (Supplementary Fig. S3C), we did not observe clear trends in separations between control and exposure groups. However, the samples from the 1/5 LC50-day 2 group were found to be clustering slightly separated from the other groups in the GC-MS dataset scores plot. This group was further compared with control-day2 group in PLS-DA. The PCA scores plots after chronic exposure using features from the three datasets (Supplementary Fig. S4) reveals large overlap for all three groups.
Observations from PCA were further examined by cross validation of PLS-DA model. A good model should have high values of model prediction accuracy as well as high values of R2 and Q2, representing the explained variance and the quality assessment of the model, respectively31. In consistency with PCA observations, the PLS-DA models using “Control versus Exposure” in LC-QTOF positive mode and “control day2 versus 1/5LC50 day2” in GC-MS generate high accuracy, R2 and Q2 values, whereas models using datasets after chronic exposure result in lower values (Table 2). Scores plots exhibit good separations between these groups after acute exposure (Fig. 3). Permutation tests were further conducted for the PLS-DA models. The significance level was 0.02 for LC-QTOF spectra (control versus exposure) and 0.01 for GC-MS spectra (control-day 2 versus 1/5 LC50-day2) at permutation numbers of 100. Both values were smaller than 0.05, thus meeting the criteria of significance level (P < 0.05). In addition, for GC-MS data between control-day 2 and 1/5 LC50-day 2, the scatter plot showed even clearer separation between control group and exposure group after probabilistic quotient normalization than that obtained without probabilistic quotient normalization (Fig. S5). This clearly indicates that there are differences between the two groups. This result is consistent with earthworm mortality data after exposure, suggesting considerable and negligible perturbation to endogenous metabolites after acute and chronic exposure of TPHP, respectively.
Changes of endogenous metabolites after acute exposure
In order to learn more about significantly changed metabolites after acute exposure, features with variable importance on projection (VIP) values larger than 1.5 and P values smaller than 0.05 in t-test were identified and shown in Table 3. These metabolites include eight amino acids (asparagine, leucine, lysine, phenylalanine, proline, serine, threonine and valine), glucose, inosine and seven phospholipids. Fold changes of these metabolites were shown in Fig. 4. For amino acids, glucose and inosine, levels at 1/5LC50-day2 are all nearly half of the levels at control-day2. In addition, the levels of these metabolites were elevated to varying extents at 1/10LC50-day1, 1/5LC50-day1 and 1/10LC50-day2 than the related control. Phospholipids with only one long fatty acid chain (lysophosphatidylcholine and lysophosphatidylethanolamine, LPC and LPE) exhibited significantly higher levels after exposure, while phospholipids with two long fatty acid chains (phosphatidylcholine, PC) showed significantly lower levels after exposure.
The acute exposure bioassay was designed as a filter paper test because it is time-saving, easily controllable, and allows direct contact of TPHP with earthworms. The chronic exposure experiment was conducted in soil to mimic practical scenarios in the environment. Although the concentrations used in the soil experiments exceeded those commonly reported environmentally relevant concentrations in the literature20,21, they allowed accumulation of TPHP metabolites that makes further identification easier using LC-QTOF and information dependent acquisition.
TPHP in soil enters the earthworm body likely through both dermal and ingestion routes. Bioaccumulation is the direct biological measure of bioavailability of chemicals in soil. The calculated BCFs of TPHP in soil-earthworm ecosystem are much smaller than the theoretical BCF of 113.3. This can be ascribed to TPHP degradation in soil, high hydrophobicity of TPHP which results in low concentration in pore water32, and metabolism of TPHP by the earthworms, which might be accelerated by gut microflora and ingested soil microflora. Quantitative data on the fate of TPHP in different matrices in the soil-earthworm ecosystem might be obtained in the future using isotope-labeled TPHP. Environmentally relevant bioaccumulation study of TPHP in the soil-earthworm ecosystem is also warranted.
Common enzymes in earthworms responsible for xenobiotic metabolism include cytochrome P450, carboxylesterases and glutathione-S-transferases (GST)32. For TPHP, oxidative hydroxylation is likely catalyzed by cytochrome P450, while hydrolysis may be catalyzed by phosphotriesterase. Previous work has indicated the presence of phosphotriesterase in Eisenia andrei33 and phosphodiesterase in Lumbricus terrestris34 being able to hydrolyze phosphor-triester and -diester pesticides, respectively. We did not observe degradation of diphenyl phosphate, possibly due to lack of phosphodiesterase in P. excavatus. Previously reported phase II conjugations of organic xenobiotics in earthworms include spermine35, glutamyl36,37,38 and glucoside37,38 conjugations. Our separate study (under peer review) revealed that phosphate was substantially used to conjugate hydroxylated tributyl phosphate (TBP) in both acute and chronic exposure scenarios39. This study reported glucoside and thiol conjugations of TPHP in P. excavatus. Glucoside conjugation is reasonable as it typically appears to be a more common route than glucuronic acid conjugation in invertebrates compared to vertebrates40. The phosphate-glucoside and C14H19O10P conjugates might be further metabolites of the glucoside conjugation. An alternative explanation might be that earthworm glucoside transferases are readily saturated, thus other similar enzymes may be used to metabolize excessive TPHP. The thiol conjugates include, but are not limited to, glutathione conjugates. Glutathione conjugation, catalyzed by GST, accounts for only a small portion of the thiol conjugates, while its hydrolysis products, cysteinylglycine conjugates and cysteine conjugates, account for larger portions. The activity of GST varies among different earthworm species41. Recent studies have shown that when Aporrectodea caliginosa and E. andrei were exposed to organophosphate pesticides, the activity of GST increased42,43,44. Our study revealed that P. excavatus may also possess GST activity to some extent. The presence of other thiol conjugates has not been reported previously in earthworms. These thiols may serve as complementary chemical pool to conjugate excessive xenobiotics when GST activity is limited. These findings indicate unique enzyme systems in P. excavatus for detoxicification of xenobiotics.
It should be noted that the identified phase II metabolites are putative structures and require further validation using nuclear magnetic resonance technique and commercial or synthesized metabolite standards. This is especially true for glucoside conjugates, because the conjugated molecules are large and complicated, and the fragments in MS/MS spectra are few and not informative. For example, the ion with m/z 583.0797 in negative mode has only one fragment with m/z 241.0118 in its MS/MS spectrum besides phosphate fragments. Another factor that makes unambiguous identification difficult is that the binding positions between different moieties could not be recognized via LC-QTOF. For example, the binding location of phosphate to the glucose structure is unknown. Nevertheless, these putative metabolites provide evidences of novel phase II metabolism of xenobiotics in P. excavatus.
Only acute exposure of TPHP for two days at 1/10 and 1/5 LC50 in filter-paper contact test resulted in significant perturbations of the endogenous metabolome in earthworms. The amino acids increased after one day exposure and decreased after two days exposure at 1/5 LC50. This concentration-dependent trend is similar to the perturbations of amino acids (glycine, valine, serine, phenylalanine, glutamine, lysine and tyrosine) in McKelvie et al.’s study45 after acute exposure of E. fetida to endosulfan, as well as the reported changes of amino acid levels (leucine, arginine, lysine and phenylalanine) after exposure of E. fetida to phenanthrene46. In stress conditions, such as exposure to high concentration of TPHP, increased utilization of glucose might occur due to high energy consumption47. Moreover, we have shown that glucose and its derivatives may be utilized to conjugate OH-TPHP. Thus, significant decrease of glucose after two days exposure at high concentration of TPHP is reasonable. Inosine, an intermediate in nucleotide synthesis, showed a similar trend as the amino acids and glucose, suggesting possible connection of their metabolic pathways. An earlier study showed that inosine can be generated by breakdown of 5′-adenosine monophosphate (5′-AMP) in the earthworm L. terrestris48. AMP can be used to synthesize adenosine diphosphate, a primary substrate for synthesis of adenosine triphosphate, the main product of glycolysis. Observed decrease of inosine in this study might be the result of higher glycolytic activity for enzyme production in response to excessive TPHP body-burden. Similar associations of amino acids, glucose and inosine have also been observed in earthworms after exposure to C60 nanoparticles49. Phospholipids are major components of cell membrane, and the lipophilic nature of TPHP makes it easily retained in the cell membrane, causing membranes to swell and increasing lipid membrane fluidity50,51. The perturbations of phospholipid metabolism might result from maintenance of cell membrane integrity. Moreover, significant decrease of PC is accompanied by significant increase of lysophosphatidylcholine bearing the same fatty acid chain, possibly suggesting increased hydrolysis of phosphatidylcholine arising from enhanced phospholipase A2 activity52,53.
The metabolomics results in soil experiments indicated no significant differences of endogenous metabolome between the control and exposure groups. It can be inferred that TPHP may not be toxic to earthworms under environmentally relevant concentrations, at least at the metabolic level.
In summary, the bioaccumulation, biotransformation and perturbation of endogenous metabolites of earthworms after exposure to TPHP using a filter-paper contact test and soil microcosm experiment revealed that the bioaccumulation potential of TPHP in earthworm-soil ecosystem is low at 10 mg/kg and 50 mg/kg of TPHP. Various phase I and phase II biotransformation products were putatively identified in the earthworms. Phase I metabolites include DPHP, OH-TPHP and di-OH-TPHP, while phase II metabolites can be categorized to thiol conjugates and glucoside conjugates. These metabolites reveal novel phase II metabolism of xenobiotics in P. excavatus. Only acute TPHP exposure caused significant perturbations of the endogenous metabolome in earthworms, featuring fluctuations in amino acids, glucose, inosine and phospholipids. Alterations of metabolites might be useful for understanding toxic mode of action of TPHP following acute exposure.
Materials and Methods
The tropical composting earthworm22 species Perionyx excavatus was employed in this study. The worms were purchased from a local worm farm in Singapore. Upon collection, worms were placed in soil and fed with sheep manure for one month at 20 ± 1 °C in laboratory for adaptation. Mature worms with clear clitellum were used in all experiments. These worms had weights ranging from 0.65 g to 1.12 g, and lengths ranging from 13 cm to 17 cm.
The LC50 test was first conducted based on the OECD guideline on acute toxicity test using earthworms54. Briefly, 1 ml solutions of TPHP (Sigma-Aldrich, CAS 115-86-6) in acetone were pipetted onto a filter paper disk of 12.5 cm2 placed in amber glass jars. A geometric series of concentrations of 0.000128, 0.00128, 0.0128, 0.128, 1.28 mg/cm2 TPHP were prepared with 10 replicates. The filter papers were placed in a fume hood for 4 h to allow acetone evaporation before earthworm dermal exposure under dark conditions. Based on the recorded mortalities after 48 h exposure under these concentrations, another two medium concentrations of 0.0043 and 0.0085 mg/cm2 were further tested using the same protocol.
The acute exposure assay was conducted on filter paper disks similar to the LC50 test. LC50 was first calculated as 4.25 μg/cm2 (Supplementary Fig. S1). TPHP concentrations in the acute exposure experiment were set as 1/10 and 1/5 of the LC50, i.e. 0.425 and 0.85 μg/cm2, respectively. The control consisted of solvent applied to filter paper disks. Worms were collected after exposure of 24 h and 48 h. Eight replicates were prepared and in each replicate one worm was used.
Chronic exposure was conducted in soil microcosm using a silty clay loam soil collected from the campus of National University of Singapore. The soil pH was 7.8 and organic matter content was 7.7%. After stones and plant residues were removed from the soil, the soil was air dried, ground and sieved through a 1-mm sieve before being used in assays.
Acetone (0.2 ml) containing TPHP was dispensed onto 20 g of soil, which was then placed in fume hood for 30 min to allow solvent evaporation. Concentrations of 0, 10 and 50 mg TPHP per kg were prepared by thorough mixing of the spiked soil with 80 g clean soil. Water was added to the prepared soils to reach 25% (weight percentage) before adding worms. All glass beakers were placed in the dark at 18 °C. There were 8 replicates in each concentration, and one worm was used in each replicate. Worms were fed with 5 g sheep manure containing 0, 10 or 50 mg/kg TPHP every 7 days. Soil spiked with TPHP without earthworms and with addition of sheep manure was prepared with three replicates in the same protocol. Worms were collected after 28 days exposure, rinsed and placed onto a wet filter paper in a beaker for 24 h in the dark to empty the gut contents. Three replicates of soil with and without earthworms were sampled at day 0, 1, 2, 3, 5, 8, 13, 21 and 28 after TPHP spiking and kept at −80 °C until extraction.
Simultaneous extraction of TPHP metabolites and endogenous metabolites of earthworm
Collected worms were all flash-frozen and ground in liquid nitrogen using mortar and pestle, then kept at −80 °C until extraction. To simultaneously extract TPHP metabolites and endogenous metabolites of earthworm, 600 μl ice cold methanol (LC-MS grade)/ultrapure water (volume ratio 4:1) containing internal standard N-9-Fmoc-L-glycine (20 mg/l, Sigma Aldrich, CAS 29022-11-5, >98%) was added to 50 mg worm tissue. The mixture was homogenized with three zirconium oxide beads (2.8 mm diameter) at medium speed for 60 s and two times using a Minilys homogenizer (Bertin Technologies, France). Then, the mixture was vortexed for 5 min, placed on dry ice for 15 min, and centrifuged at 14000 rpm for 10 min at 4 °C. The supernatant was transferred to a sample vial and analysed by LC-QTOF. An aliquot of 50 μl was dried in a vacuum concentrator (Labconco, MO, USA) at 4 °C for further derivatization and analysis via GC-MS.
GC-MS derivatization and analysis
The dried extract was mixed with 50 μl methoxyamine hydrochloride (15 mg/ml in pyridine, Sigma Aldrich) and incubated at 30 °C for 90 min. After adding 100 μl N,O-Bis(trimethylsilyl)trifluoroacetamide containing 1% trimethylsilyl chloride (Sigma Aldrich), the mixture was further incubated at 60 °C for 1 h. The derivatized sample was analysed using a GC (Agilent 7890A), coupled with a triple quadrupole mass analyser (Agilent 7000B). The ion source temperature, transfer line temperature and injector temperature were set at 230 °C, 290 °C and 250 °C, respectively. The oven temperature ramp was set as follows: initially at 60 °C for 2 min, increased to 300 °C at a rate of 7.5 °C/min and held for 6 min. The carrier gas was helium at a flow rate of 1.0 ml/min. Derivatized samples of 1 μl were injected via splitless mode, and analyzed under full scan mode. Metabolites were separated on a DB-5MS capillary column (30 m X 0.25 mm i.d., 0.25 μm film thickness) consisting of a stationary phase of 5% phenyl 95% methylpolysiloxane, and detected in electron impact ionization mode at 70 eV. Acquired mass range was 50 – 650 Da. Samples were randomized and analysed within 24 h after derivatization.
The extracted supernatants were analysed using a Dionex Ultimate 3000 HPLC system (Thermo Fisher Scientific, USA) coupled to a TripleTOF 5600 system (AB Sciex, USA) with electrospray ionization (ESI) source under both positive and negative mode. In positive mode, mobile phase A and B were 0.1% formic acid in water and acetonitrile, respectively, while in negative mode, mobile phase A was changed to 10 mM ammonium formate in water. The injection volume was 3 μl. Chromatographic separation was achieved with a Zorbax Eclipse Plus C18 column (2.1 × 100 mm, 3.5 μm) at flow rate of 0.3 ml/min using the following gradient: 5% B for 2 min, ramped to 95% B at 22 min, held for 2 min, then dropped to 5% B over 0.1 min and held for 6 min. TOF scan was performed simultaneously with product ion scan using information dependent acquisition (IDA). In each acquisition cycle, ten of the most abundant ions were chosen for MS/MS experiments at collision energy of 35 eV and spread of 15 eV. The accumulation time for TOF scan and product ion scan was set as 250 ms and 100 ms, respectively. The ESI source parameters were as follows: nebulizer gas = 50 psi, heater gas = 50 psi, curtain gas = 25 psi, and heater temperature = 550 °C. The ion spray voltage and declustering potential were 5400 and 80, respectively, in positive mode and −4500 and −100 in negative mode. Acquired mass range was set as 50–1000 Da for both TOF and product ion scan. The samples were randomized and analysed at 4 °C. Each batch was run within 12 h to ensure sample stability based on a preliminary test.
Determination of TPHP in earthworm and soil
TPHP in soil and earthworm was extracted using acetonitrile with recovery of 87–95%. Soils and earthworms were dried in a freeze dryer (Labconco, MO, USA). Dry soil or earthworm tissue (0.2 g) was mixed with 1 ml acetonitrile, sonicated for 30 min and centrifuged. This process was repeated and resulting supernatants were pooled. The extracts were diluted to a pre-determined calibration range and analysed using a Dionex Ultimate 3000 HPLC coupled with a QTrap 5500 system (AB Sciex, USA) with ESI source under positive mode. Mobile phases used were 0.1% formic acid in water (A) and 0.1% formic acid in acetonitrile (B). Gradient was set at 70% B at 0–2 min, increased to 100% B in 3 min, then dropped to 70% B in 0.1 min and kept for 6 min. Two m/z transitions were used for quantitation and confirmation: 327 → 152 (CE 52 eV, CXP 18 eV) and 327 → 215 (CE 33 eV and CXP 12 eV) at DP 150 eV and EP 8 eV.
Data processing and statistical analysis
The GC-MS and LC-QTOF data files were converted to mzXML format and uploaded to XCMS online (https://xcmsonline.scripps.edu) to extract features. Intensities of internal standard were used to normalize feature intensities in LC-QTOF data. Features from blanks with average intensity larger than half of the average intensity from samples were removed. Multivariate and univariate analysis were performed in the online MetaboAnalyst platform55. Pareto scaling was performed before PCA and PLS-DA. Features with VIP values in PLS-DA larger than 1.5 were selected and further subjected to student t-test in the same platform. Only significantly different features (P < 0.05) in the t-test were identified as corresponding metabolites together with associated isotopes, adducts and fragments.
We used several approaches to screen potential TPHP metabolites in LC-QTOF spectra. First, literature reported phase I TPHP metabolites were screened. From their MS/MS spectra, we found that 215.0245 is a typical and abundant fragment in positive mode. Second, we screened 215.0245 in product ion spectra obtained by IDA. Ions with similar MS/MS spectra with TPHP were identified, including thiol conjugates. We further screened 357.0335 using the same strategy in search of more thiol conjugates. Glucoside conjugates were identified in the same manner in negative mode. Third, t-tests between features extracted from exposure and control spectra were performed. Features with low P values (<0.001) were selected. Last, we also employed selected ion extraction based on suspected structures to find low intensity metabolites for which the data-dependent MS/MS were not triggered. In these approaches, compounds present in control without TPHP spiking were removed. Suspected ions were putatively identified using the following four criteria: (1) the accuracy of m/z values of precursor ions does not exceed 5 ppm; (2) the isotope ratios are similar as theoretical values; (3) fragments in MS/MS spectra can be explained; (4) retention time is reasonable based on polarity of a proposed structure.
The earthworm endogenous metabolites in the GC-MS spectra were identified using National Institute of Standards and Technology library. Only metabolites with matching scores of >70% were considered as reliable. Endogenous metabolites in LC-QTOF dataset were identified using accurate m/z of the precursor ion combined with comparison of the corresponding MS/MS spectrum in the METLIN MS/MS spectral database.
The datasets generated during and analysed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Wei, G. L. et al. Organophosphorus flame retardants and plasticizers: Sources, occurrence, toxicity and human exposure. Environ. Pollut. 196, 29–46 (2015).
Van der Veen, I. & de Boer, J. Phosphorus flame retardants: Properties, production, environmental occurrence, toxicity and analysis. Chemosphere 88, 1119–1153 2012.03.067 (2012).
McGee, S. P., Konstantinov, A., Stapleton, H. M. & Volz, D. C. Aryl phosphate esters within a major pentaBDE replacement product induce cardiotoxicity in developing zebrafish embryos: Potential role of the aryl hydrocarbon receptor. Toxicol. Sci. 133, 144–156 (2013).
Stapleton, H. M. et al. Detection of Organophosphate Flame Retardants in Furniture Foam and US House Dust. Environm. Sci. Technol. 43, 7490–7495 (2009).
Dodson, R. E. et al. After the PBDE Phase-Out: A Broad Suite of Flame Retardants in Repeat House Dust Samples from California. Environ. Sci. Technol. 46, 13056–13066 (2012).
Marklund, A., Andersson, B. & Haglund, P. Traffic as a source of organophosphorus flame retardants and plasticizers in snow. Environ. Sci. Technol. 39, 3555–3562 (2005).
Green, N. et al. Screening of Selected Metals and New Organic Contaminants 2007. NIVA Report 5569–2008 (2008).
Su, G. Y., Crump, D., Letcher, R. J. & Kennedy, S. W. Rapid in Vitro Metabolism of the Flame Retardant Triphenyl Phosphate and Effects on Cytotoxicity and mRNA Expression in Chicken Embryonic Hepatocytes. Environ. Sci. Technol. 48, 13511–13519 (2014).
Su, G. Y., Letcher, R. J., Crump, D., Gooden, D. M. & Stapleton, H. M. In Vitro Metabolism of the Flame Retardant Triphenyl Phosphate in Chicken Embryonic Hepatocytes and the Importance of the Hydroxylation Pathway. Environ. Sci. Technol. Let. 2, 100–104 (2015).
Van den Eede, N., Maho, W., Erratico, C., Neels, H. & Covaci, A. First insights in the metabolism of phosphate flame retardants and plasticizers using human liver fractions. Toxicol. Let. 223, 9–15 (2013).
Van den Eede, N., Ballesteros-Gomez, A., Neels, H. & Covaci, A. Does Biotransformation of Aryl Phosphate Flame Retardants in Blood Cast a New Perspective on Their Debated Biomarkers? Environ. Sci. Technol. 50, 12439–12445 (2016).
Wang, G. W. et al. Tissue-Specific Accumulation, Depuration, and Transformation of Triphenyl Phosphate (TPHP) in Adult Zebrafish (Danio rerio). Environ. Sci. Technol. 50, 13555–13564 (2016).
Zhang, Q. et al. Potential Estrogenic Effects of Phosphorus-Containing Flame Retardants. Environ. Sci. Technol. 48, 6995–7001 (2014).
Liu, X., Ji, K., Jo, A., Moon, H. B. & Choi, K. Effects of TDCPP or TPP on gene transcriptions and hormones of HPG axis, and their consequences on reproduction in adult zebrafish (Danio rerio). Aquat. Toxicol. 134, 104–111 (2013).
Liu, X., Ji, K. & Choi, K. Endocrine disruption potentials of organophosphate flame retardants and related mechanisms in H295R and MVLN cell lines and in zebrafish. Aquat. Toxicol. 114, 173–181 (2012).
Liu, X. S. et al. Long-term exposure to triphenyl phosphate alters hormone balance and HPG, HPI, and HPT gene experission in zebrafish (Danio rerio). Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 35, 2288–2296 (2016).
Kim, S. et al. Thyroid disruption by triphenyl phosphate, an organophosphate flame retardant, in zebrafish (Danio rerio) embryos/larvae, and in GH3 and FRTL-5 cell lines. Aquat. Toxicol. 160, 188–196 (2015).
Sun, L. W. et al. Developmental neurotoxicity of organophosphaate flame retardants in early life stages of Japanese medaka (Oryzias latipes). Environ.Toxicol. Chem. 35, 2931–2940 (2016).
Morris, P. J. et al. Organophosphorus Flame Retardants Inhibit Specific Liver Carboxylesterases and Cause Serum Hypertriglyceridemia. ACS Chem. Biol. 9, 1097–1103 (2014).
Matsukami, H. et al. Flame retardant emission from e-waste recycling operation in northern Vietnam: Environmental occurrence of emerging organophosphorus esters used as alternatives for PBDEs. Sci. Total Environ. 514, 492–499 (2015).
Wan, W. N., Zhang, S. Z., Huang, H. L. & Wu, T. Occurrence and distribution of organophosphorus esters in soils and wheat plants in a plastic waste treatment area in China. Environ. Pollut. 214, 349–353 (2016).
Edwards, C. A. Earthworm ecology. Vol. 2nd (CRC Press, 2004).
Bundy, J. G., Davey, M. P. & Viant, M. R. Environmental metabolomics: a critical review and future perspectives. Metabolomics 5, 3–21 (2009).
Aslund, M. W., Simpson, M. J., Simpson, A. J., Zeeb, B. A. & Rutter, A. Earthworm metabolomic responses after exposure to aged PCB contaminated soils. Ecotoxicology 21, 1947–1956 (2012).
Yuk, J., Simpson, M. J. & Simpson, A. J. Coelomic fluid: a complimentary biological medium to assess sub-lethal endosulfan exposure using 1H NMR-based earthworm metabolomics. Ecotoxicology 21, 1301–1313 (2012).
Aslund, M. L. W. et al. Earthworm Sublethal Responses to Titanium Dioxide Nanomaterial in Soil Detected by H-1 NMR Metabolomics. Environ. Sci. Technol. 46, 1111–1118 (2012).
Du, Z. K. et al. TPhP exposure disturbs carbohydrate metabolism, lipid metabolism, and the DNA damage repair system in zebrafish liver. Sci. Reports 6 (2016).
Su, G. Y., Letcher, R. J. & Yu, H. X. Organophosphate Flame Retardants and Plasticizers in Aqueous Solution: pH-Dependent Hydrolysis, Kinetics, and Pathways. Environ. Sci. Technol. 50, 8103–8111 (2016).
Anderson, C., Wischer, D., Schmieder, A. & Spiteller, M. Fate of triphenyl phosphate in soil. Chemosphere 27, 869–879 (1993).
Lenz, E. M., Lindon, J. C., Nicholson, J. K., Weeks, J. M. & Osborn, D. F-19-NMR and directly coupled F-19/H-1-HPLC-NMR spectroscopic investigations of the metabolism of the model ecotoxin 3-trifluoromethylaniline in the earthworm species Eisenia veneta. Xenobiotica 32, 535–546 (2002).
Gromski, P. S. et al. A tutorial review: Metabolomics and partial least squares-discriminant analysis - a marriage of convenience or a shotgun wedding. Analytica Chimica Acta 879, 10–23 (2015).
Katagi, T. & Ose, K. Toxicity, bioaccumulation and metabolism of pesticides in the earthworm. J. Pestic. Sci. 40, 69–81 (2015).
Sik Lee, M. et al. Partial characterization of phosphotriesterase activity from the earthworm, Eisenia andrei. Int. Biodeter. Biodegr. 47, 1–5 (2001).
Park, S. C., Smith, T. J. & Bisesi, M. S. Bioactivation of BIS[p-nitrophenyl]phosphate by phosphoesterases of the earthworm: Lumbricus terrestris. Drug Chem. Toxicol. 16, 111–116 (1993).
Curl, E. A., Edwards, P. J., Elliott, C. & LeAhey, J. P. The conjugation and accumulation of metabolites of cypermethrin by earthworms. Pestic. Sci. 20, 207–222 (1987).
Sloley, B. D. γ-Glutamyl conjugation of 5-hydroxytryptamine (serotonin) in the earthworm (Lumbricus terrestris). Neurochem. Res. 19, 217–222 (1994).
Duckett, C. J. et al. Metabolism of 2-fluoro-4-iodoaniline in earthworm Eisenia veneta using 19F-NMR spectroscopy, HPLC-MS, and HPLC-ICPMS (127I). Xenobiotica 37, 1378–1393 (2007).
Bundy, J. G. et al. Metabolism of 4-fluoroaniline and 4-fluorobiphenyl in the earthworm Eisenia veneta characterized by high-resolution NMR spectroscopy with directly coupled HPLC-NMR and HPLC-MS. Xenobiotica 32, 479–490 (2002).
Wang, L., Huang, X. L., Laserna, A. K. C. & Li, S. F. Y. Metabolism of tri-n-butyl phosphate in earthworm Perionyx excavatus. Environmental Pollution 234, 389–395 (2018).
Livingstone, D. R. The fate of organic xenobiotics in aquatic ecosystems: quantitative and qualitative differences in biotransformation by invertebrates and fish. Comp. Biochem. Phys. A 120, 43–49 (1998).
Stenersen, J., Guthenberg, C. & Mannervik, B. Glutathione S-transferases in earthworms (Lumbricidae). Biochem. J. 181, 47–50 (1979).
Stepic, S., Hackenberger, B. K., Velki, M., Loncaric, Z. & Hackenberger, D. K. Effects of individual and binary-combined commercial insecticides endosulfan, temephos, malathion and pirimiphos-methyl on biomarker responses in earthworm Eisenia andrei. Environ. Toxicol. Phar. 36, 715–723 (2013).
Velki, M. & Hackenberger, B. K. Inhibition and recovery of molecular biomarkers of earthworm Eisenia andrei after exposure to organophosphate dimethoate. Soil Biol. Biochem. 57, 100–108 (2013).
Sanchez-Hernandez, J. C., Narvaez, C., Sabat, P. & Mocillo, S. M. Integrated biomarker analysis of chlorpyrifos metabolism and toxicity in the earthworm Aporrectodea caliginosa. Sci. Total Environ. 490, 445–455 (2014).
McKelvie, J. R., Yuk, J., Xu, Y. P., Simpson, A. J. & Simpson, M. J. 1H NMR and GC/MS metabolomics of earthworm responses to sub-lethal DDT and endosulfan exposure. Metabolomics 5, 84–94 (2009).
Lankadurai, B. P., Wolfe, D. M., Aslund, M. L. W., Simpson, A. J. & Simpson, M. J. 1H NMR-based metabolomic analysis of polar and non-polar earthworm metabolites after sub-lethal exposure to phenanthrene. Metabolomics 9, 44–56 (2013).
Ch, R., Singh, A. K., Pandey, P., Saxena, P. N. & Mudiam, M. K. R. Identifying the metabolic perturbations in earthworm induced by cypermethrin using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry based metabolomics. Sci. Reports 5 (2015).
Macdonnell, P. C. & Tillinghast, E. K. Metabolic sources of ammonia in earthworm. Lumbricus-terrestrial. J. Exp. Zool. 185, 145–151 (1973).
Lankadurai, B. P., Nagato, E. G., Simpson, A. J. & Simpson, M. J. Analysis of Eisenia fetida earthworm responses to sub-lethal C-60 nanoparticle exposure using 1H-NWIR based metabolomics. Ecotoxicol. Environ. Safety 120, 48–58 (2015).
Mackay, D. et al. The physicochemical basis of QSARs for baseline toxicity. SAR QSAR Environ. Res. 20, 393–414 (2009).
Ankley, G. T. et al. Adverse outcome pathways: A conceptural framework to support ecotoxicology research and risk assessment. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 29, 730–741 (2010).
García-Sevillano, M. A. et al. Use of metallomics and metabolomics to assess metal pollution in Doñana National Park (SW Spain). Environ. Sci. Technol. 48, 7747–7755 (2014).
Schomburg, D. & Michal, G. Biochemical pathways: an atlas of biochemistry and molecular biology. Vol. 2nd (John Wiley & Sons, 2012).
OECD. Test No. 207: Earthworm, Acute Toxicity Tests. (OECD Publishing).
Xia, J. G., Sinelnikov, I. V., Han, B. & Wishart, D. S. MetaboAnalyst 3.0-making metabolomics more meaningful. Nucleic Acids Res. 43, W251–W257 (2015).
The authors gratefully acknowledge financial support from the Singapore National Research Foundation under its Environment and Water Technologies Strategic Research Programme and administered by the Environment and Water Industry Programme Office (EWI) of the PUB on project 1301-IRIS-21, and the Ministry of Education (R-143-000-582-112).
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Electronic supplementary material
About this article
Cite this article
Wang, L., Huang, X., Laserna, A.K.C. et al. Untargeted metabolomics reveals transformation pathways and metabolic response of the earthworm Perionyx excavatus after exposure to triphenyl phosphate. Sci Rep 8, 16440 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-34814-9
- Triphenyl Phosphate (TPHP)
- Thiol Conjugates
- Endogenous Metabolome
- Glucoside Conjugates
Ecological and toxicological assessments of anthropogenic contaminants based on environmental metabolomics
Environmental Science and Ecotechnology (2021)
Environmental Pollution (2020)
Triphenyl phosphate exposure induces kidney structural damage and gut microbiota disorders in mice under different diets
Environment International (2020)
mRNA-Sequencing Identifies Liver as a Potential Target Organ for Triphenyl Phosphate in Embryonic Zebrafish
Toxicological Sciences (2019)
Environmentally Relevant Concentrations of the Flame Retardant Tris(1,3-dichloro-2-propyl) Phosphate Inhibit the Growth and Reproduction of Earthworms in Soil
Environmental Science & Technology Letters (2019)