Article | Open | Published:

Positive Platinum anomalies at three late Holocene high magnitude volcanic events in Western Hemisphere sediments

Scientific Reportsvolume 8, Article number: 11298 (2018) | Download Citation

Abstract

Changes in the global atmospheric budget of platinum reportedly correspond to explosive volcanic eruptions. Using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) elemental analysis we examined eight widely separated stratified sites to evaluate the geographic extent of three late Holocene high magnitude volcanic events. We found characteristic Pt anomalies across the Western Hemisphere dating to the Laki, Iceland (CE 1783–1784), Kuwae, Vanuatu (CE 1452–1453), and Eldgjá, Iceland (CE 934) explosive volcanic eruptions. Pt anomalies in sediments over a broad geographic area indicate distinctive time-correlative atmospheric deposition rates of platinum-rich volcanic ash. These anomalies provide new chronostratigraphic markers for these late Holocene high magnitude volcanic eruptions, which are especially valuable in the Western Hemisphere in strata with limited chronometric control. Pt anomalies provide an important tracer for the age of these volcanic events and ultimately a new chronostratigraphic marker in archaeological, geological, palynological, and paleontological sediments.

Introduction

In 2011, Soyol-Erdene et al.1 documented atmospheric deposition rates of platinum for the past ~50 years in high summit snow samples collected from two sites in Queen Maud Land, East Antarctica. They sampled snow at 5 cm continuous sequence intervals to a depth of 4 m for Pt concentrations, which were analyzed using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS). Soyol-Erdene et al.1 discovered an anomalously highly elevated Pt concentration that corresponded to the non-sea salt sulfate (nss-SO4) concentration peak of the 1991–1992 Cerro Hudson volcanic eruption. Their finding demonstrates that Pt can be used as a tracer of the aerosol loading of the atmosphere from a high magnitude volcanic event.

Globally, volcanic Pt emission concentrations are significantly higher than in urban air2. The magmatic fractionation of Pt is governed by the volatility of Pt-containing complexes (oxides, hydrogen halides, sulfides) and the physicochemical properties of the magma (temperature, fugacities of relevant chemical species). Pt aerosol layers form in the stratosphere after major volcanic eruptions. The dominant Pt aerosol layer is formed by sulfur dioxide gas, which is converted to droplets of sulfuric acid in the stratosphere over the course of a week to several months after the eruption3,4. Winds in the stratosphere spread the Pt aerosols until they practically cover the globe and remain in the stratosphere for about two years. Volcanic ash clouds travel along the same pathways as SO2 and Pt aerosol particles with a diameter of 0.1 mm can be widely distributed by prevailing wind patterns5.

Positive Pt anomalies are concentrations greater than the crustal abundance of 0.5 ppb, and these have been used as reliable tracers for internal geological processes such as tectonic movements, faulting, and hydrothermal activity6,7. Pt anomalies are also useful as tracers for the accretion of cosmic dust from comets, meteors, and extraterrestrial impacts6,7,8,9,10. We investigate sediments from eight late Holocene geomorphic/geologic sites that exhibit no or only minimal signs of bioturbation or other natural or cultural disturbance across the Western Hemisphere where hot springs, faults, and chondrite-rich sediments containing magnetic microspherules and microtektites were absent. These sites allow us to test the occurrence of Pt anomalies at the timing of three high-magnitude late Holocene volcanic events (Supplementary Information). Unlike varved sediments in glacial lakes, undisturbed, well-stratified, and dated geomorphic/geologic sites have a wider geographic distribution and offer more opportunities to examine the occurrence of positive Pt anomalies.

While not all explosive eruptions with a volcanic explosivity index (VEI) ≥5 result in global distributions of tephra, there is causal link between high-magnitude volcanic events and late Holocene climatic change, the most profound of which in terms of human impact is known as the Little Ice Age11. Northern latitude tephras tend to remain in the northern hemisphere and tropical latitude eruptions such as Kuwae have global distributions. High-magnitude volcanic activity produces ash and SO2, which reaches the stratosphere creating a pan-global ash cloud obstructing solar radiation and results in global cooling. Theoretically, a long-term feedback loop is created when cooled ocean waters and an increase in sea ice result in unusually cold summers12. Volcanic ash and SO2 from the CE 1452–1453 eruption of the Kuwae volcano in the Republic of Vanuatu and the CE 1783–1784 eruption of the Laki volcano system have been posited as significant contributing factors in the global cooling of the Little Ice Age11,13. The ~CE 934 eruption of the Eldgjá volcano in Iceland occurred at the beginning of a warm climatic period in the North Atlantic known as the Medieval Climate Optimum14. A climatic warming period may result when significant amounts of volcanic carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas, are produced.

Kuwae is a submarine volcanic caldera located between the Epi and Tongoa islands. Sometime between late CE 1452 and early CE 1453, Kuwae produced ~32–39 km3 of magma and a stratospheric injection of ~175–700 Mt of H2SO414. Kuwae’s cataclysmic eruption (VEI 7) is considered one of the most explosive volcanic events of the Holocene. Evidence of the Kuwae volcanic eruption is represented in 13 Greenland and 20 Antarctic ice cores as an anomalous sulfate spike15. The high magnitude of the Kuwae eruption is based on ~93 kg SO4/km3 in Antarctica ice cores and ~45 kg SO4/km3 in the Greenland ice cores16.

The Laki volcanic system is located in southern Iceland and includes the Lakagígar volcanic vent or fissure, the Grímsvötn caldera, and the subglacial Thordarhyrna volcano. Explosive eruptions (VEI 6) in the Laki volcanic system occurred between June 1783 and February 178416. During this time, the Laki system produced a convective column of ~120 Mt of SO2 into the stratosphere and erupted ~14 km3 of basalt lava16. The large volume of volcanic ash, water vapor, and reflected solar radiation and absorbed terrestrial radiation resulted in one the longest and coldest drops in historically recorded global temperatures17.

Eldgjá is part of the southern Iceland Laki volcanic system, and includes the Katla volcano18. Eldgjá’s colossal eruption (VEI 6) originated from a ~200-m deep rift at ~CE 93418,19,20. The eruption produced ~219 Mt of SO2, a ~6 km3 terrestrial ash fall, and erupted ~19.6 km3 of basaltic lava. These are conservative estimations because they do not include ash fall in the ocean or portions of lava flows, which are now covered by late Holocene sediments. Eldgjá was the largest volcanic eruption historically recorded and it produced the largest lava flow during the late Holocene19. Written records from Iceland, Western Europe, the Middle East, and Asia document global cooling, famine, and epidemics for ~9 years following the eruption20.

We hypothesized that Pt anomalies resulting from three late Holocene high magnitude volcanic events should be present in contemporary sediments across the Western Hemisphere given that Soyol-Erdene et al.1 found a Pt anomaly in Antarctic snow samples that was associated with a paroxysmic volcanic eruption. Our investigation aims to: a) determine if Pt anomalies from the Laki (CE 1783–1784), Kuwae (CE 1452–1453), and Eldgjá (CE 934) volcanic events might be present in sediments: and b) ascertain if Pt anomalies can be used to distinguish certain high-magnitude volcanic events (VEI ≥ 5) at locations with less precise chronostratigraphic control.

We tested our hypothesis that late Holocene high-magnitude volcanic events would reveal Pt anomalies in sediments obtained from eight well-stratified and chronometrically dated sites across the Western Hemisphere. These sites include: the Temple Reservoir tank at the Maya city of Tikal in the Petén District of northern Guatemala; Nonsuch Bay on the island of Antigua in the West Indies region of the Caribbean; an Ancestral Puebloan canal in Chaco Canyon, New Mexico; the Albert Porter Pueblo and Wallace Ruin, two Ancestral Puebloan Great Houses in southwestern Colorado; Big Bone Lick, Kentucky, a historic contact Fort Ancient bison kill site and a critical geologic site in the historical development of North American Quaternary science and vertebrate paleontology; a sinkhole at Serpent Mound, a 411 m-long earthwork on a karst plateau in southern Ohio; and Wynema, a historic contact Fort Ancient village site in southwestern Ohio (Fig. 1 and Supplementary Information).

Figure 1
Figure 1

Map showing volcanic centers (red triangles) for late Holocene high-magnitude eruptions (black triangles) for Laki volcanic system (#1), Eldgjá volcanic fissure (#2) and Kuwae volcano (#3). Study sites for platinum (black triangles) include: Temple Reservoir tank, Tikal, Guatemala (#4); Nonsuch Bay, Antigua (#5); Chaco Canyon, New Mexico (#6); Albert Porter Pueblo, Colorado (#7); Wallace Ruin, Colorado (#8); Big Bone Lick, Kentucky (#9); Wynema, Ohio (#10); and Great Serpent Mound, Ohio (#11).

We postulated that if these stratified late Holocene sites contained sediments that were deposited at the time of the Laki (CE 1783–1784), Kuwae (CE 1452–1453), and Eldgjá (CE 934) volcanic events, then we should expect to find Pt anomalies. The sediment sample sites have been well-described elsewhere and are also presented in the Supplementary Information. While the sites varied greatly in their age range and geologic setting, all of the sample sites dated to one or more of the late Holocene volcanic events and the sediments were deposited in low energy environments. Sediment samples from the Temple Reservoir tank consisted of aggrading clays21,22. The Nonsuch Bay sediment samples consisted of well stratified hemic and sapric organic clays23. The American Southwestern samples were poorly consolidated clay, silt, and coarse to medium sand and sandy silty alluvium from Chaco Canyon and a fine-textured silt and fine to medium sandy alluvium overlying an iron-stained clayey silt and fine sandy loess at the Albert Porter Pueblo and Wallace Ruin24,25,26. The Midwestern samples from Big Bone Lick and the Wynema site consisted of a deep and uniformly finely laminated silty alluvium27. The Serpent Mound samples consisted of well-stratified silt, silty clay, and clay karst sinkhole deposits28.

Results and Discussion

The ages of the sediments at our six late Holocene temperate latitude (36–39°N) sample sites in North America (Albert Porter Pueblo, Colorado; Big Bone Lick, Kentucky; Chaco Canyon, New Mexico; Serpent Mound, Ohio, Wallace Ruin, Colorado; Wynema, Ohio; Figs 2 and 3) and our two tropical latitude (17°N) sites (Nonsuch Bay, Antigua; Temple Reservoir tank Tikal, Guatemala; Fig. 3) are based on multiple dating techniques including AMS radiocarbon, optically stimulated luminescence (OSL), dendrochronology, tephra, and artifact typologies. Our analyses identified Pt anomalies at each site in dated strata, which correlated with one or more late Holocene high-magnitude volcanic event.

Figure 2
Figure 2

Site graphs for northern latitude (36–390) study sites showing abundance of Pt in ppb (±0.1 ppb), depth, and AMS radiocarbon ages (calibrated years CE with 2 σ uncertainty): (a) Albert Porter Pueblo, Colorado; (b) Big Bone Lick, Kentucky; (c) Chaco Canyon, New Mexico; (d) Serpent Mound, Ohio. See Supplementary Information for additional chronostratigraphic details. Zero values represent below detection levels.

Figure 3
Figure 3

Site graphs for northern latitude (36–390) and tropical latitude (170) study sites showing abundance of Pt in ppb (±0.1 ppb), depth, and radiocarbon ages (calibrated years CE with 2 σ uncertainty); (a) Wallace Ruin, Colorado; (b) Wynema, Ohio. (c) Nonsuch Bay, Antigua, (d) Temple Reservoir Tank, Tikal, Guatemala. See Supplementary Information for additional chronostratigraphic details. Zero values represent below detection levels.

Our reported results from 39–17o N latitudes and 108–61o W longitudes provide evidence of Pt enrichment in sediments that date to the timing of the high magnitude Laki, Iceland (CE 1783–1784), Kuwae, Vanuatu (CE 1452–1453), and Eldgjá, Iceland (CE 934) volcanic eruptions (Figs 2 and 3; Supplementary Information). Pt anomalies averaged 2.3 ppb at our study sites (range: 1.1 to 5.3 ppb) compared to background abundances (0.0–0.5 ppb) above and below the late Holocene anomalies for these high magnitude volcanic eruptions. They are 5x higher than crustal abundance of 0.5 ppb.

A Pt anomaly was detected in sediments that date to the time of the Laki volcanic system eruption at seven of the sites we sampled (Albert Porter Pueblo, Big Bone Lick, Chaco Canyon, Nonsuch Bay, Serpent Mound, Wallace Ruin, Wynema) and averaged 2.4 ppb and ranged from 1.8 to 2.9 ppb. Another Pt anomaly was found in sediments that date to the time of the Kuwae volcanic eruption at five of the sites we sampled (Albert Porter Pueblo, Big Bone Lick, Nonsuch Bay, Serpent Mound, Wynema) and averaged 2.9 ppb and ranged from 0.6 to 5.2 ppb. A Pt anomaly was also recovered in sediments that date to the time of the Eldgjá volcanic eruption at four of the sites we sampled (Albert Porter Pueblo, Serpent Mound, Temple Reservoir, Wynema) and averaged 2.2 ppb and ranged from 1.1 to 5.1 ppb.

Pt anomalies, which date to the timing of all three of the high-magnitude late Holocene volcanic eruptions, were found in sediment samples from the Albert Porter Pueblo, Serpent Mound, and Wynema sites. Pt anomalies, which correspond to the age of the eruption of the Laki volcanic system, were found in sediment samples from seven of the sites sampled (Albert Porter Pueblo, Big Bone Lick, Chaco Canyon, Nonsuch Bay, Serpent Mound, Wynema). The Pt concentrations between the sites have a relatively small sample variance (0.2), that is, the variation of Pt values. The recent age (CE 1783–1784) of the Laki volcanic event may be the reason for the inter-site consistency of the Pt concentration. That is, it is less likely that post-depositional processes have altered the original Pt content of younger sediments.

Measured concentrations of Pt in late Holocene sediments likely depend upon the distance between the sample site location and the volcano, eruption strength, ash composition, and distribution area of the ejecta. Pt-rich ash, which reached the stratosphere would have had the broadest geographic distribution1. Depletion of Pt concentrations at some of the sample sites may have been the result of the size of the site catchment basin, discontinuous deposition, and/or post-depositional erosional processes7. Nonetheless, the average Pt anomalies described here for temperate and tropical latitude sites in the Western Hemisphere are relatively consistent in magnitude with regard to the VEI magnitudes of the Laki (mean 2.4 ppb Pt, VEI 6), Kuwae (mean 2.9 ppb Pt, VEI 7), and Eldgjá (mean 2.2 ppb Pt, VEI 6) events. Consequently, Pt concentrations provide an important new tracer for the age of these events and ultimately new chronostratigraphic markers. The widespread distribution of Pt in late Holocene sediments further illustrates the global impact of high magnitude volcanic eruptions, and possibly their role in periods of climatic change such as those experienced during the Little Ice Age.

Conclusion

Pt anomalies occur in sediments from geographically widely separated sites across the Western Hemisphere, which date to the Laki (CE 1783–1784), Kuwae (CE 1452-1453), and Eldgjá (CE 934) volcanic eruptions. Despite inter-site variances, which likely resulted from post-depositional erosional processes, Pt anomalies provide an effective tracer for certain late Holocene high-magnitude (VEI ≥ 6) volcanic events and ultimately provide three new chronostratigraphic markers on archaeological, geological, palynological, and paleontological sites. The concentrations of Pt from well-dated and well-stratified late Holocene sites provide an opportunity for more vigorous evaluations of the impact of high magnitude volcanic eruptions on climate change and society.

Methods

Sediment samples were collected from each site in continuous manner by depth. Supplementary Information provides detailed chronostratigraphic information for each of the sites sampled and detailed data are provided for each site related to stratigraphy, age, sampling provenience, and cultural components in Tables 117 and Figs 1–3.

Selected aliquots of sediment from late Holocene sites were transferred to pre-weighed digestion vessels. All solutions were prepared with certified trace-metal grade HNO3 (67–70% w/w) and HCl (36% w/w) and ultra-pure (18MΩ) water. Sediment aliquots were homogenized and digested with Aqua Regia (3:1 HCl:HNO3 mol/mol) in Savillex PFA containers and heated at 90 °C for 1 hour on a heating block. After cooling, the solutions were then diluted with 18 MΩ water and analyzed by ICP-MS29. The certified reference material (SARM-7, SACCRM) was digested using the same procedure as a means of corroboration. The value of the certified reference material (SARM-7, SACCRM) was 3.74 ± 0.05 ppm and the measured value was 4.27 ± 0.13 ppm.

ICP-MS analyses were completed on a Thermo Scientific X Series II instrument. A peristaltic pump using a Cetac ASX 520 auto-sampler pumped sample solutions. The internal standard was added in-line using a Trident Internal Standard Kit. The sample was introduced into the plasma using a MicroMist EzyFit nebulizer, which reduced oxide formation with a high total dissolved solids tolerance, and reduced the sample uptake rates. The cyclonic spray chamber was kept at 3 °C, minimizing oxide formation. Ion lens voltages, nebulizer flow, and stage positioning were optimized every 24 hours using a tuning solution to maximize the ion signal and stability and minimize oxide levels (CeO+/Ce+) and doubly charged ions (Ba2+/Ba+). A calibration check of the standards was analyzed following initial calibration, at the end of the sample run, and after every 12 samples.

Data Availability

All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article (and its Supplementary Information files).

Additional information

Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

References

  1. 1.

    Soyol-Erdene, T., Huh, Y., Hong, S. & Hur, S. D. A 50-Year Record of Platinum, Iridium, and Rhodium in Antarctic Snow: Volcanic and Anthropogenic Sources. Environmental Science and Technology 45, 5929–5935 (2011).

  2. 2.

    Moune, S., Faure, F., Gauthier, P. J. & Sims, K. W. W. Pele’s hairs and tears: natural probe of volcanic plume. Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research 164, 244–253 (2007).

  3. 3.

    Giammanco, S., Sims, K. W. W. & Neri, M. Measurements of 220Rn and 222Rn and CO2 emissions in soil and fumarole gases on Mt. Etna volcano (Italy): Implications for gas transport and shallow ground fracture. Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems 8(10), 1644 (2007).

  4. 4.

    Villemant, B., Salaün, A. & Staudacher, T. Evidence for a homogeneous primary magma at Piton de la Fournaise (La Réunion): A geochemical study of matrix glass, melt inclusions and Pélé's hairs of the 1998–2008 eruptive activity. Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research 184, 79–92 (2009).

  5. 5.

    Stohl, A. et al. Determination of time- and height-resolved volcanic ash emissions and their use for quantitative ash dispersion modeling: the 2010 Eyjafjallajökull eruption. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics 11, 4333–4351 (2011).

  6. 6.

    Lorand, J. P., Luguet, A. & Alard, O. Platinum-group elements: a new set of key tracers for the Earth’s interior. Elements 4, 247–252 (2008).

  7. 7.

    Moore, C. R. et al. Widespread platinum anomaly documented at the Younger Dryas onset in North American sedimentary sequences. Scientific Reports 7, (44031),https://doi.org/10.1038/srep44031 (2017).

  8. 8.

    Peucker-Ehrenbrink, B. & Ravizza, G. The effects of sampling artifacts on cosmic dust flux estimates: a reevaluation of nonvolatile tracers (Os, Ir). Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 64(11), 1965–1970 (2000).

  9. 9.

    Gabrielli, P. et al. Meteoric smoke fallout over the Holocene epoch revealed by iridium and platinum in Greenland ice. Nature 432, 1011–1014 (2004).

  10. 10.

    Karner, D. B. et al. Extraterrestrial accretion from the GISP2 ice core. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 67(4), 751–763 (2003).

  11. 11.

    Miller, G. H. et al. Abrupt onset of the Little Ice Age triggered by volcanism and sustained by sea-ice/ocean feedbacks. Geophysical Research Letters 39(31), L02708, https://doi.org/10.1029/2011GL050168 (2012).

  12. 12.

    Robock, A. The Little Ice Age: Northern Hemisphere Average Observations and Model Calculations. Science 206(4425), 1402–4 (1979).

  13. 13.

    Jonathan, C. Climate change : biological and human aspects. Cambridge University Press (2007).

  14. 14.

    Crowley, T. J. & Lowery, T. S. How Warm Was the Medieval Warm Period? AMBIO: A Journal of the Human Environment 29, 51 (2000).

  15. 15.

    Gao, C. et al. The 1452 or 1453 AD Kuwae eruption signal derived from multiple ice core records: Greatest volcanic sulfate event of the past 700 years. Journal of Geophysical Research 111(D12), D12107 (2006).

  16. 16.

    Gudmundsson, M. T. & Högnadóttir, T. Volcanic systems and calderas in the Vatnajökull region, central Iceland: Constraints on crustal structure from gravity data. Journal of Geodynamics. 43(1), 153–169 (January 2007).

  17. 17.

    Robock, A. Volcanic eruptions and climate. Reviews of geophysics 38(2), 191–219 (2000).

  18. 18.

    Simkin, T. & Siebert, L. Volcanoes of the World. (Geoscience Press, Tucson, Arizona, 1994).

  19. 19.

    Árni Hjartarson, A. Víðáttumestu hraun Íslands. Náttúrufræðingurinn 81, 37–49 (2011).

  20. 20.

    Stothers, R. B. Far reach of the tenth century Eldgjá eruption, Iceland. Climatic Change 39, 715–726 (1998).

  21. 21.

    Dunning, N. P., et al. Life on the Edge: Tikal in a BajoLandscape. Lentz, D., N. Dunning, and V. Scarborough (eds). Tikal: Paleoecology of an Ancient Maya City, Pp. 95–123, Cambridge University Press (2015).

  22. 22.

    Scarborough, V., et al. Water and Sustainable Land Use at the Ancient Tropical City of Tikal, Guatemala. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 12408–12413 (2012).

  23. 23.

    Wells, E. C. et al. Plantation Soilscapes: Initial and Cumulative Impacts of Colonial Agriculture in Antigua, West Indies. Environmental Archaeology 22, 23–35 (2018).

  24. 24.

    Tankersley, K. B., Huff, W. D., Dunning, N. P., Owen, L. A. & Scarborough, V. L. Volcanic minerals in Chaco Canyon, New Mexico and their archaeological significance. Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports 17, 404–421 (2018).

  25. 25.

    Ryan, S. C. The archaeology of Albert Porter Pueblo (Site 5MT123): excavations at a Great House community center in southwestern Colorado. (Crow Canyon Archaeological Center, Cortez, Colorado, 2015).

  26. 26.

    Bradley, B. Excavations at Wallace Ruin (5MT6970) Montezuma County, Colorado 1998–2010 University of Exeter (2010).

  27. 27.

    Tankersley, K. B. et al. Quaternary chronostratigraphy and stable isotope paleoecology of Big Bone Lick, Kentucky, USA. Quaternary Research 83, 479–487 (2015).

  28. 28.

    Dalby, T. S. Geological Aspects of Key Archaeological Sites in Northern Kentucky andSouthern Ohio, edited by Timothy S. Ohio Geological Survey, Columbus, Ohio (2007).

  29. 29.

    Cicchella, D., De Vivo, B. & Lima, A. Palladium and platinum concentrations in soils from the Napoli metropolitan area, Italy: possible effects of catalytic exhausts. Science of the Total Environment 308, 121–131 (2003).

Download references

Acknowledgements

This research was made possible with support from the Charles Phelps Taft Foundation, the Court Family Foundation, and the University of Cincinnati Research Council. We are especially grateful to Mark Varian, Bruce Bradley, Bradley Lepper, Kathy Loftus, Peter Siegel, Vernon Scarborough, the Antigua and Tikal research teams, the Crow Canyon Archaeological Center, Chaco Culture National Historical Park, National Park Service, the Navajo Nation, members of the American Indian Advisory Council, and the Center for Applied Isotope Studies.

Author information

Affiliations

  1. Department of Anthropology and Department of Geology, Braunstein Hall, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio, 45220, USA

    • Kenneth Barnett Tankersley
    •  & Dominique Sparks-Stokes
  2. Department of Geography, Braunstein Hall, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio, 45220, USA

    • Nicholas P. Dunning
    •  & Changjoo Kim
  3. Department of Geology, Geology and Physics Building, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio, 45220, USA

    • Lewis A. Owen
  4. Department of Geography Education, Kongju National University, Chungcheongnam-do, 32588, South Korea

    • Warren D. Huff
    •  & Ji Hoon Park
  5. Department of Biology, Rieveschl Hall, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio, 45221, USA

    • David L. Lentz

Authors

  1. Search for Kenneth Barnett Tankersley in:

  2. Search for Nicholas P. Dunning in:

  3. Search for Lewis A. Owen in:

  4. Search for Warren D. Huff in:

  5. Search for Ji Hoon Park in:

  6. Search for Changjoo Kim in:

  7. Search for David L. Lentz in:

  8. Search for Dominique Sparks-Stokes in:

Contributions

K.B.T. conceived the project. K.B.T., N.P.D., L.A.O., W.D.H. wrote most of the manuscript. K.B.T., N.P.D., D.L.L., L.A.O., J.H.P., C.K. directed most of the fieldwork and D.S.S contributed laboratory data. L.A.O. did the OSL dating.

Competing Interests

The authors declare no competing interests.

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Kenneth Barnett Tankersley.

Electronic supplementary material

About this article

Publication history

Received

Accepted

Published

DOI

https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-29741-8

Comments

By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.