Small, cysteine-rich and cationic proteins with antimicrobial activity are produced by diverse organisms of all kingdoms and represent promising molecules for drug development. The ancestor of all industrial penicillin producing strains, the ascomycete Penicillium chryosgenum Q176, secretes the extensively studied antifungal protein PAF. However, the genome of this strain harbours at least two more genes that code for other small, cysteine-rich and cationic proteins with potential antifungal activity. In this study, we characterized the pafB gene product that shows high similarity to PgAFP from P. chrysogenum R42C. Although abundant and timely regulated pafB gene transcripts were detected, we could not identify PAFB in the culture broth of P. chrysogenum Q176. Therefore, we applied a P. chrysogenum-based expression system to produce sufficient amounts of recombinant PAFB to address unanswered questions concerning the structure and antimicrobial function. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR)-based analyses revealed a compact β-folded structure, comprising five β-strands connected by four solvent exposed and flexible loops and an “abcabc” disulphide bond pattern. We identified PAFB as an inhibitor of growth of human pathogenic moulds and yeasts. Furthermore, we document for the first time an anti-viral activity for two members of the small, cysteine-rich and cationic protein group from ascomycetes.
The increasing incidence of fatal microbial infections due to the development of resistance against licensed antimicrobial drugs raises a strong demand for new antimicrobial treatment strategies. Filamentous ascomycetes are a rich source of antimicrobial bio-molecules that have the potential for wide application in medicine and agriculture to prevent and treat microbial infections1. As such, the industrially relevant fungus Penicillium chrysogenum is not only a well-known producer of the β-lactam antibiotic penicillin, but also secretes small, cysteine-rich and cationic proteins with antimicrobial activity. P. chrysogenum is an ideal producer of bio-products with beneficial potential to mankind as it is fermentable and bulk production is easy and cheap2. Most importantly, it is recognized as a “safe organism” by the US Food and Drug Administration.
The P. chrysogenum strain Q176 is the ancestor of all industrial strains used for penicillin production today2,3 and of the strains Wisconsin 54-12554 and P2niaD185, whose genomes were sequenced and are publicly available. P. chrysogenum Q176 secretes the antifungal protein PAF whose structural and functional properties have been extensively studied6,7,8. PAF represents a promising bio-molecule for novel antifungal drug development as it is stable against proteolytic degradation, thermo-resistant and active within a broad pH range9, and shows no cytotoxic effects in vitro10 or in vivo11,12. Furthermore, PAF could serve as a potential bio-pesticide in agriculture to impede infection by plant-pathogenic fungi13.
Genome mining in the strain Wisconsin 54-1255 for nucleotide (nt) sequences coding for other small, cysteine-rich and cationic proteins revealed that this P. chrysogenum strain harbours - apart from the paf gene (NCBI accession no. Pc24g00380)14 - two more genes that code for proteins with potential antimicrobial activity: Pc21g12970 and Pc12g08290. The product of the first gene (NCBI accession no. XP_002568323) is identical to the Pc-Arctin isolated from the arctic P. chrysogenum strain A09615, which represents an orthologue of the “bubble protein” isolated from the exudate of Penicillium brevicompactum15,16. The product of the second gene (GeneBank accession no. CAP80456) is orthologous to PgAFP identified in the supernatant of P. chrysogenum strain RP42C, originally isolated from dry-cured ham by Rodríguez-Martín et al.17. Thus, the genome of P. chrysogenum Wisconsin 54-1255 and its progenitor strain Q176 contain at least three genes that code for proteins with reported antifungal activity. This represents a unique chance to investigate their function within one organism.
PAF, PgAFP and Pc-Arctin have in common that they are encoded as prepro-proteins containing a signal peptide followed by a pro-sequence, both of which are removed during the protein maturation process for secretion into the culture supernatant14,15,17. The mature proteins are cationic due to a high content of amino acids (aa) with positively charged side-chains. Phylogenetic analyses suggested a classification of the three proteins into different groups, whereby Pc-Arctin is grouped more distantly from PAF and PgAFP1,18.
While the predicted PgAFP-orthologous protein from P. chrysogenum Q176 has not been isolated and characterized to date, a high thermo-, pH- and protease stability has been reported for the mature PgAFP of strain RP42. Potent growth inhibitory activity against toxigenic moulds on dry-ripened sausages renders this protein interesting for the control of unwanted food contamination19.
In the present study, we isolated and studied the PgAFP orthologous protein from P. chrysogenum Q176 and addressed unanswered questions concerning its 3D solution structure, antimicrobial specificity and mode of action. To distinguish between the two proteins originating from the two different P. chrysogenum strains Q176 and RP42 we named the protein from strain Q176 P. chrysogenumAntiFungal protein B (PAFB), in analogy to the nomenclature of the already extensively studied homologous protein PAF from P. chrysogenum Q17614. We adapted the recently described P. chrysogenum-based expression system20 to generate sufficient amounts of PAFB for functional and structural characterization. The use of the paf-deficient P. chrysogenum Q176 strain (∆paf) as recipient ensured optimal high yield PAFB production by avoiding co-expression of the related antifungal protein PAF. We identified a disulphide-bond stabilized and compact β-folded structure of PAFB and found - apart from a growth inhibitory activity against moulds and yeasts - anti-viral activity, which has never been reported before for any member of the small, cationic and cysteine-rich protein group from ascomycetes.
The pafB gene transcription
Our efforts failed so far to identify PAFB in the supernatant or cell extracts of P. chrysogenum Q176 grown under standard conditions (shaking culture in minimal medium MM at 25 °C for up to 6 days) (Fig. 1). The same was true for the P. chrysogenum strain ∆paf that lacks the PAF-encoding gene21. We examined this mutant to increase the chance to identify PAFB in the absence of PAF (data not shown). Therefore, we performed Northern blot analyses to determine the abundance and timing of pafB transcription. Surprisingly, we found that pafB mRNA was detectable in P. chrysogenum Q176 shaking cultures with an expression maximum at 48 h after inoculation and a subsequent decrease in transcript amount upon further incubation time (Fig. 1a).
In contrast, gene transcripts of paf could be detected from 48 h after inoculation onwards and transcription reached its maximum at 72 h (Fig. 1b). This expression pattern correlated with the secretion of PAF protein into the culture broth of P. chrysogenum Q176 during the stationary growth phase as reported14. This result was confirmed by Western blot by using a specific anti-PAF antibody22 (Fig. 1c, Supplementary Methods).
Incorrect mRNA processing could result in defective protein translation and the production of nonsense protein products that are readily degraded23,24. Therefore, we next investigated if the pafB mRNA was correctly spliced. The verification of the pafB mRNA sequence was done by cDNA synthesis, PCR amplification of the pafB specific transcript and subsequent Sanger sequencing. The obtained sequence matched that of the exons of the pafB fragment (Pc24g00380) from the P. chrysogenum Wisconsin 54-1255 genome4 and yielded an intact pafB open reading frame indicating correct splicing (Supplementary Fig. S1). Similar to the paf gene14, two short introns (63 nt and 62 nt in length, respectively) are present in pafB that contain the consensus 5′-splice donor site (GT) and the consensus 3′-splice acceptor site (AG). A consensus sequence for the internal putative lariat formation element (RCTRAC) can be found in the first intron, but not in the second non-coding sequence (Supplementary Fig. S1).
The nt sequence of the pafB cDNA (deposited at European Nucleotide Archive (ENA), accession no. LT854946) codes for a 92 aa protein (Supplementary Table S1). Comparison of the PAFB primary sequence with that of the orthologous PgAFP revealed that PAFB differed in three aa, resulting in 97% identity of both proteins (Fig. 2). A histidine to glutamine substitution at position 2 resides in the pre-sequence, serine to asparagine and threonine to arginine substitutions at positions 19 and 23, respectively, occur in the pro-sequence (Fig. 2a). The predicted mature PAFB protein exhibited 100% identity with the mature PgAFP (Fig. 2b). The similarity of PAFB with PAF was 43% for the prepro-proteins and 35% for the mature proteins (Fig. 2b).
Recombinant expression and purification of PAFB
As we could not detect and isolate PAFB from the P. chrysogenum Q176 culture supernatant, we employed the P. chrysogenum-based expression system20 to produce recombinant PAFB for structural analysis and functional tests. To this end, the P. chrysogenum Δpaf strain was transformed with a PstI-linearized plasmid carrying the pafB gene under the control of the strong paf promoter20. Positively transformed, ptrA-resistant P. chrysogenum clones were tested for highest protein secretion over a time course of 96 h using small-scale fermentation (data not shown). Southern blot experiments with the best PAFB producer clone (P. chrysogenum pafB) revealed multiple random integration events of the transforming DNA into the fungal genome (Supplementary Fig. S2). This clone was selected and cultivated under large scale culture conditions.
PAFB was purified from the cell-free culture broth by a single-step chromatography. A protein yield of 61 ± 11 mg/L supernatant was reached. Purity and identity of PAFB were verified by sodium-dodecyl-sulphate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS), respectively (Fig. 3). On the SDS-PA gels one single band for PAFB was visible in the elution fractions (Fig. 3a). ESI-MS detected one main peak corresponding to an average mass of 6.49 kDa, which represented full-length PAFB (Fig. 3b). Two smaller peaks corresponding to 6.37 kDa and 6.29 kDa correlated with two N-terminally truncated PAFB forms: the 6.37 kDa peak corresponded to a variant without the N-terminal leucine and the 6.29 kDa peak to a form that lacked the N-terminal residues leucine and serine (Fig. 3b; Supplementary Table S1). The average molecular masses of all three peaks matched the calculated theoretical molecular masses (ProtParam tool of ExPASy)25 of the oxidized protein forms indicating the presence of three intra-molecular disulphide bonds in all three PAFB protein variants. They all lacked any post-translational modifications, except for the cleavage of the prepro-sequence, as reported for wild-type PAF20.
We used the purified recombinant PAFB to generate polyclonal anti-PAFB antibodies with the aim to identify PAFB at higher specificity and sensitivity in the supernatant and cell extract of P. chrysogenum Q176 shaking cultures by Western blot technique (Supplementary Methods). The polyclonal anti-PAFB antibodies specifically recognized recombinant PAFB, but not PAF in Western blots (Supplementary Fig. S3). However, no PAFB-specific signals could be identified in the P. chrysogenum supernatants and cell extracts at the growth conditions applied, supporting our observation that PAFB was not present at concentrations that were sufficient for detection, although its encoding gene was transcribed (Supplementary Fig. S3).
To obtain structural information on PAFB with atomic resolution, solution nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy experiments were performed. According to the ESI-MS data, three isoforms of unlabelled PAFB were present in solution. MS peak intensities (Fig. 3) and NMR of 15N-labelled PAFB suggested that the full-length PAFB sequence (58 residues) is the dominant form in the mixture. NMR spectra and MS analysis of the 15N/13C-labelled PAFB, however, identified only the shortest sequence (56 aa) (Supplementary Fig. S4). We named this short PAFB variant “short-form PAFB” (sfPAFB) and all aa sequence numbering below refers to this variant. Based on triple resonance NMR spectra, all amide HN and NH atoms could be found and assigned in the 15N-1H heteronuclear single quantum correlation (HSQC) spectrum of sfPAFB (Supplementary Fig. S5) except for Lys1 because the first N-terminal residue of proteins cannot be detected in the 15N-HSQC spectrum. Gly18, which resides in the middle of the big flexible loop 3, adjacent to Gly19 (Fig. 4), did not show a visible amide NH signal. However, other signals belonging to Gly18 were unambiguously assigned (CA and HA2, HA3). We note that for the 15N-labelled sample, the missing Lys1 NH signals could be found. The two overlaid 15N-HSQC spectra of the short (15N/13C-labelled) and full-length (15N-labelled) forms of PAFB exhibited good agreement for most of the peaks (Supplementary Fig. S5). As our structure calculations were based on measurements of the 15N/13C form, we decided to solve the structure of sfPAFB. As discussed below in more detail, there is no indication that the structures of PAFB and sfPAFB would exhibit differences except for the N-terminus.
The extent of backbone assignment (considering HN, HN, C’, Cα and Hα atoms in sfPAFB) reached 94.3%, and the extent of assigned protons including side chain hydrogens was 78.1%. During the ATNOS-CANDID-Cyana run 976 nuclear Overhauser effects (NOEs) were considered in the seventh cycle which resulted in an average of 17.4 NOEs/residue. The abundant distance information compared to the size of the protein resulted in a well-defined structure with very low backbone RMSD value of the final model (0.3 Å). Chemical shift data and NMR experimental parameters were submitted to the BMRB (entry no. 26001) and the structure model of sfPAFB was deposited in the Protein Data Bank (ID: 2NC2).
The structure of sfPAFB contains two orthogonally packed triple-stranded β-pleated sheets (Fig. 4). It should be noted that there are only five strands present in the protein, because the first β-strand is shared by the sheets. They are located between residues Gly4 and Cys6, Thr12 and Leu16, Asn21 and Asn25, His40 and Asp44 as well as Arg49 and Asp51, respectively. The strands are connected by three small loops (1, 2, 4) and one large loop (3) comprising β-turn motives (Fig. 4). Finally, the two β-pleated sheets have the following β-strand pattern: β1-β2-β3 and β1-β4-β5, respectively. There are six highly conserved cysteines in the amino acid sequence of sfPAFB in the form of three disulphide bonds between the cysteines 6 and 34, 13 and 41 as well as 26 and 52. Note that this pattern (abcabc) creates a hidden central core region. While loops 1 and 4 form turn conformations, the secondary structure analysis showed the presence of a bend in the flexible glycine-glycine motives containing loop 2. The second and third β-strands are relatively hydrophobic compared to the other parts of the protein having no charged residues. In contrast, the central part of loop 3, the so-called large loop, contains three (32, 33 and 35) conserved lysine residues, which, together with Lys9, form a positively charged surface region. In general, the large loop adopts a bent conformation, but at its C-terminal end (Asp37-Arg38) a β-turn structure is formed. The side-chain of Asp37 is close to those of Arg38 and Lys9, respectively. Interestingly, strand β4 in the middle of the second β-sheet exhibits high negative charge density. Nevertheless, there are several basic amino acids in its vicinity that potentially also form salt-bridges. Although both strands, β1 and β5, are relatively short, several H-bonds can be found between them and strand β4, stabilizing the second β-sheet. The side-chains of Tyr43 and Tyr15 interact with each other, and together with other apolar amino acids they form a hydrophobic core in sfPAFB. Finally, after the fifth, amphipathic β-strand, the C-terminal region of sfPAFB does not adopt any particular regular secondary structure.
Despite the relatively low sequence similarity (35.2%), the structure of sfPAFB is highly similar to that of PAF determined previously (Protein Data Bank ID: 2MHV). Both proteins adopt a Greek key super-secondary structure and β-barrel global fold with identical disulphide bond pattern (abcabc). In order to compare their local conformation, the structures of the two proteins were superimposed. Their RMSD values were below 0.5 Å overall and 0.2 Å in the β-strands (Fig. 4) except for the N-terminus. However, it turned out that the conformation of loop 3 also shows substantial differences between PAF and sfPAFB. This was unexpected because the second half of loop 3 is one of the most highly conserved regions in these proteins with the longest patch of conserved residues (asparagine-lysine-lysine-cysteine) located here (Fig. 4), whereas the β-strands generally show a lower level of sequence conservation. While both of the proteins adopt a bent structure in this region, in PAF it resulted in a turn-like conformation both at residues Asp32-Asn33 and Asp39-Asn40 amino acids, respectively. In contrast, only the latter turn is present in sfPAFB at positions Asp37-Arg38. It should also be noted that although the high density of positive surface charges is believed to be a major contributor to the activity of PAF8, only four lysine residues are conserved between PAF and PAFB. Furthermore, PAFB lacks a ‘belt’ of structurally aligned lysine residues (Lys 6, 15, 42 in PAF) and has generally lower overall positive surface charge and a different surface electrostatic potential (Fig. 4). To assess the possible differences between sfPAFB and the full-length protein, we built a first-approximation structural model of full-length PAFB by adding a leucine-serine segment to the N-terminus of the experimental sfPAFB structure. Short molecular dynamics (MD) runs suggest that the full-length N-terminus might align to strand β4 (residues 41–45) to form an N-terminal β-strand longer than in the sfPAFB form similar to the case of PAF (Supplementary Fig. S6). This is also plausible based on the favourable interaction between Lys1 and Asp42 (sfPAFB numbering) formed during the MD calculations. Nevertheless, we do not expect that the structures of sfPAFB and full-length PAFB exhibit substantial differences. Finally, the variation of the N-terminus does not dramatically change the biophysical features of the PAFB forms, such as isoelectric point (pI), net charge and the grand average of hydropathy (GRAVY) (Supplementary Table S1).
Antifungal activity of PAFB
The growth inhibitory activity of PAFB was tested on filamentous fungi, yeasts and bacteria in 96-well microtiter plate assays by determination of the minimal inhibitory concentration (MIC) (Table 1). PAF was used as a control and for comparison. Among the filamentous fungi tested, the model organism Neurospora crassa showed the highest PAFB-sensitivity (MIC 0.12 µM in 0.1 × PDB), followed by the opportunistic human pathogens Aspergillus fumigatus (MIC 0.25 µM), Trichophyton rubrum (MIC 0.5 µM), and Aspergillus terreus (1 µM). Interestingly, low doses of PAFB (0.5 µM) had self-inhibition activity on the producing strain P. chrysogenum Q176 in 0.1 × PDB. This stands in contrast to PAF, which did not affect the germination of P. chrysogenum at the concentrations tested.
So far, no anti-yeast activity has been reported for PgAFP in malt extract broth19 and for PAF in YPD medium26. We found, however, a clear inhibitory activity for PAFB and PAF at MICs of 1 µM and 2–4 µM on the model yeast Saccaromyces cerevisiae and the opportunistic human pathogen Candida albicans, respectively, when cultivated in 0.1 × PDB. In contrast, no anti-bacterial activity of PAFB could be observed in the administered concentration range (0–32 µM) on the Gram-negative Escherichia coli and the Gram-positive Bacillus subtilis, which is similar to what is found for PAF.
PAFB efficiently prevented the conidial germination of all tested filamentous fungi at the respective MIC, except for N. crassa. Similar to previous observations with PAF27, N. crassa conidia still germinated in the presence of PAFB, but the elongation of the germ tubes was inhibited irrespective of the culture medium applied (0.1 × PDB or 0.2 × Vogel’s). The growth inhibitory activity of PAFB was further characterized for N. crassa 0.2 × Vogel’s medium, in which PAFB exhibited a comparable MIC as in 0.1 × PDB (Table 1). N. crassa conidia exposed to 0.25 μM PAFB for 6 h in 0.2 × Vogel’s medium germinated at a significantly lower rate (53.14 ± 5.70%, p < 0.0001) than the untreated control (83.30 ± 2.69%) (Table 2). PAF-exposure, by contrast, did not influence the germination efficiency, as 85.56 ± 1.07% of the conidia germinated in the presence of 0.06 µM PAF compared to the untreated control (Table 2).
Furthermore, PAFB significantly reduced the germ tube length of 6 h old germlings to 17.99 ± 2.41 µm at its MIC, which corresponded to a reduction of −70% compared to the untreated control (60.32 ± 10.04 µm, p < 0.0001). By contrast, PAF reduced the germ tube length less severely at its MIC (48.22 ± 7.34 µm; p ≤ 0.05; −20% compared to control) (Table 2). The increase of the PAFB and PAF concentration to 2 × MIC, respectively, did not further aggravate these effects on N. crassa (data not shown). Thus, our findings indicated that PAFB affects colony establishment of N. crassa more effectively than PAF.
It is of great relevance that an antifungal drug acts fungicidal rather than fungistatic to reduce the risk of resistance development, which occurs more readily with drugs showing fungistatic activity. We therefore tested the fungicidal potential of PAFB and PAF on the wide-spread human opportunistic pathogen C. albicans, which causes candidiasis. To this end, C. albicans cells were incubated with the antifungal proteins at concentrations corresponding to 0.25–4 × MIC for 0 h (control), 6 h and 24 h in 0.1 × PDB and were then plated in appropriate dilutions onto PDA plates to allow surviving cells to establish colonies.
As shown in Fig. 5a, viability was significantly reduced after 6 h of incubation in the presence of PAFB in a dose-dependent manner. The survival rate was 38.33 ± 4.49% (p < 0.0001) at 0.25 µM, 13.74 ± 3.16% (p < 0.0001) at 1 µM and 9.81 ± 7.24% (p < 0.0001) at 4 µM compared to the viability of the respective controls (0 h of incubation) which were set to be 100%, respectively. The fungicidal potential was further increased when C. albicans cells were exposed to PAFB for 24 h. Compared to the survival rate of the controls (100%), only 11.24 ± 3.07% (p < 0.0001), 13.45 ± 10.79% (p < 0.0001) and 3.08 ± 2.99% (p < 0.0001) cells survived when exposed to 0.25, 1 and 4 µM, respectively (Fig. 5a).
Similarly, C. albicans cells exposed to PAF showed reduced viability after 6 h of incubation (Fig. 5b). The fungicidal effect of PAF, however, was less pronounced than that with PAFB. The survival rate was 70.21 ± 10.17% (p < 0.001) at 1 µM PAF, 38.35 ± 7.92% (p < 0.001) at 4 µM PAF and 24.21 ± 6.88% (p < 0.0001) at 16 µM PAF, which corresponded to 0.25 × MIC, 1 × MIC and 4 × MIC, respectively, compared to the control cells (100% survival at 0 h of incubation) (Fig. 5b). This fungicidal effect was detectable with 4 µM and 16 µM PAF at longer incubation times (survival rates after 24 h: 31.48 ± 15.05% (p < 0.001) and 19.65 ± 17.68% (p < 0.001), respectively) (Fig. 5b), whereas PAF was less effective at low concentration (0.25 × MIC) and with shorter incubation times (6 h). Candida cells exposed to 1 µM PAF proliferated further when cultivated for 24 h in liquid 0.1 × PDB, which became evident from the increased number of colony forming units when plated on PDA plates.
Our results indicate that PAFB acts fast and efficiently in a fungicidal way on C. albicans at a sub-MIC concentration.
Localization of PAFB in fungi
In previous studies, we reported that PAF toxicity in sensitive fungi is closely linked with its active internalization into the cell8,22. Therefore, we examined the uptake and localization of PAFB in comparison to PAF in N. crassa, P. chrysogenum and C. albicans. For this purpose, PAFB and PAF were labelled with the green fluorescent dye BODIPY. Both proteins had comparable labelling efficiencies and the antifungal activity was similar to that of the unlabelled proteins (data not shown). To visualize the fluorescence signals 8 µM of protein conjugates were applied.
The conidia of N. crassa and P. chrysogenum were allowed to germinate for 12 h, the cells of C. albicans to grow for 6 h in the presence of BODIPY-PAFB and BODIPY-PAF, respectively, before the fungal cells were co-stained with propidium-iodide (PI) to test cell viability. As shown in Fig. 6(b,c), both BODIPY-labelled proteins localized in germlings of N. crassa and in C. albicans cells, which undoubtedly showed signs of cell death by positive PI staining. The same was observed with P. chrysogenum germlings, in which BODIPY-PAFB uptake correlated with PI staining. By contrast, we did neither detect BODIPY-PAF uptake nor PI staining in P. chrysogenum (Fig. 6a). These observations matched with the different susceptibilities of P. chrysogenum for PAFB and PAF described above (Table 1) and provide further evidence that antifungal toxicity of PAFB and PAF is closely linked to their uptake into fungal cells.
We further analysed the uptake mechanism of BODIPY-PAFB in N. crassa in time course experiments. After 30 min of incubation, BODIPY-PAFB had already attached to the envelope of N. crassa conidia and intracellular signals were visible (Fig. 7). With prolonged incubation time (>2 h), the PAFB signals in the cytoplasm steadily increased which coincided with positive PI staining (Fig. 7). Interestingly, fungal cells showed no signs of cell death as long as BODIPY-PAFB resided in vacuoles (Fig. 7).
We investigated in the next step whether PAFB enters the cells actively or passively, e.g. by diffusion. To this end, we exposed 4.5 h-old germinated conidia to NaN3 and carbonyl cyanide m-chloropheylhydrazone (CCCP), which are inhibitors of oxidative phosphorylation and ATP production, respectively, for 30 min before BODIPY-PAFB was added for further 1.5 h of incubation.
As shown in Fig. 8, BODIPY-PAFB remained attached to the outer layers and was not taken up into the N. crassa cells in the presence of the inhibitors (Fig. 8). In contrast, BODIPY-PAFB localized in the vacuoles of germlings that were not exposed to the inhibitors (Fig. 8). PAFB uptake was also inhibited at 4 °C, which reduces cell metabolism (data not shown).
These observations proved the staining specificity of BODIPY-PAFB and indicate that the internalization of BODIPY-PAFB depends on an active cellular metabolism. Negative PI staining confirmed the viability of the cells under the applied test conditions.
Recently, Holthausen et al. (2017) reported about the efficacy of host defense peptides from the skin of the South Indian frog to treat respiratory viral infections, as in the case of human influenza A viruses28. In this study, we examined the selective anti-viral potential of PAFB and PAF to reduce the infection of human epithelial cell line L132 by the human coronavirus strain 229E (HCoV 229E) in vitro. First, we confirmed that PAFB, similarly to PAF, showed no cytotoxic effects on the host cells in the applied concentration range (0–32 μM) (Supplementary Fig. S7). The anti-viral activity of the proteins was expressed in terms of protein concentration that protects against virus-induced cytopathogenic effects (CPE) in L132 cells, such as syncytia formation, vacuolization, cell rounding, detachment and cell death (Fig. 9a). We determined 8 μM as the minimum effective protein concentration that reduced virus-induced CPE and preserved cell monolayer integrity (Fig. 9a,b). The anti-viral efficiency could be observed in virus infected L132 cells at different viral titres (multiplicity of infection (MOI) 1–0.01) (Supplementary Fig. S8), but reached a maximum inhibition value of 21.07% with PAFB against HCoV 229E at MOI 0.01 (Fig. 9b). PAF in contrast, inhibited HCoV 229E-induced CPE less effectively than PAFB, while still exhibiting antiviral activity, especially at lower viral titers: 8 μM PAF reduced the viral CPE to 11.89% at MOI 0.01 (Fig. 9a,b). The application of higher protein concentrations (16 μM and 32 μM), however, did not further increase the anti-viral effect of PAFB and PAF (Supplementary Fig. S8). The anti-viral efficacy of both proteins was also confirmed by immunofluorescence experiments, where 8 μM PAFB and PAF successfully reduced the number of HCoV 229E infected L132 cells (Fig. 9c). HCoV 229E localization was examined with a virus-specific antibody at 72 h post infection when viral replication and transcription was underway. As shown in Fig. 9c, a strong virus-specific green fluorescent signal was observed in the majority of HCoV 229E infected cells (MOI 0.01) without PAFB or PAF treatment. The signal intensity and the number of virus infected cells significantly decreased in the presence of PAFB or PAF (Fig. 9c). This observation suggests that the antiviral effect of the proteins may reduce not only the final stages of the viral replication cycle and CPE, but also the earlier steps of the infection and/or the spread of the viral particles.
In this study, we provide detailed insight into the antimicrobial activity and the structure of the secreted PAFB protein from the penicillin-producing mould P. chrysogenum Q176. This protein belongs to the group of small, cysteine-rich and cationic proteins from ascomycetes. Although the PAFB encoding gene was abundantly transcribed, we could not detect the translated gene product under the cultivation conditions applied. This phenomenon is not unique. Only recently, Garrigues et al. (2016) reported that the identification of the genome encoded antifungal protein AfpB from Penicillium digitatum had failed, although the gene was transcribed at high level18. Instead the antifungal activity of this cryptic protein was successfully analysed by mapping the antifungal motifs of AfpB with synthetic cysteine-containing peptides29 before recombinant, full-length AfpB was generated recently for functional analysis applying the P. chrysogenum-based expression system20,30. The reason remains obscure, why the timely expressed and correctly processed pafB mRNA was not translated into detectable protein amounts by P. chrysogenum Q176. As conidia of P. chrysogenum were PAFB susceptible, it seems that the production of PAFB needs strict regulation to avoid self-limitation. On the other hand, the pre-existing pool of mRNA may serve as a reservoir allowing for fast availability in case of urgent needs, e.g. a fast response to changing environmental or developmental stimuli. Indeed, a function of cysteine-rich, cationic proteins beyond fungal growth inhibition, such as stress response and asexual development, supporting the fitness of the producing moulds has been reported earlier21,31. A recently published transcriptome meta-analysis for the expression regulation of the Aspergillus niger antifungal protein AnAFP further underlines the role of these proteins in stress response, growth and development, nutrient recycling, and autophagy32. Thus, the pafB mRNA may be stored, for example in processing bodies or stress granules as described for S. cerevisiae and mammalian cells, until the PAFB protein is needed33,34,35. We are currently investigating this assumption.
We applied the P. chrysogenum-based expression system to generate PAFB in sufficient quantity and high quality for functional and structural analyses. The strong paf promoter, the presence of multiple gene copies and/or possibly the genomic integration site are responsible for the bulk production of recombinant PAFB20,36. The fact that recombinant PAFB was produced in P. chrysogenum ∆paf without problems indicates that regulatory elements, likely present in the 5’- and/or 3’- regions of the pafB mRNA and responsible for controlling mRNA translation and/or storage in the wild-type, were replaced in the pafB expression cassette.
Mature PAFB was purified in a major full-length form with 58 aa, and two less abundant short variants with 57 aa and 56 aa, respectively. Another member of this protein group, the Aspergillus giganteus AFP, is secreted in two naturally occurring N-terminal variants, the major short form (51 aa) and in lower amounts the larger form (lf-AFP), containing six additional N-terminal amino acids37. Lf-AFP remarkably differs from AFP in pI, GRAVY and net charge and shows lower antifungal activity37,38. To date, we cannot tell whether the N-terminal PAFB variants occur naturally, e.g. by autocatalytic activities, or whether they are a consequence of overexpression conditions. The latter has been observed for example, for the expression of the recombinant bovine chymosin in Aspergillus awamori, which resulted in products with variable N-termini, most likely due to proteolysis in the culture supernatant39. Recombinant PAF produced in high yields in P. chrysogenum showed no N-terminal variations whereas subtle N-terminal differences were detected when expressed in P. digitatum20. Similarly, AfpB expression in P. digitatum using the paf-derived expression cassette resulted in gene products with N-terminal variations30. In none of these cases, however, the antifungal activity of the N-terminal variants was affected20,30. Proteolysis of the PAFB N-terminus might be influenced by the nutrient composition of the fermentation broth. For double isotope labelling (15N/13C) of PAFB, sucrose was replaced with 13C-glucose as carbon source in the growth medium, which might be responsible for the generation of sfPAFB (56 aa). This assumption requires further analysis in the future. In one of our recent studies, we demonstrated that the N-terminal aa regulate the stability, folding and antifungal function of the recombinant NFAP protein from Neosartorya fischeri40. By contrast, we found here, that the N-terminal PAFB variants do not differ significantly in their overall solution structure and physico-chemical features. We therefore assume that the antifungal activity is not affected.
Importantly, the mature full-length PAFB is identical to the mature PgAFP described from P. chrysogenum RP42C, originally isolated from cured ham41. PgAFP was shown to be sensitive to the ionic strength of the fungal culture medium42, and highly stable under extreme pH, high temperature and against proteolysis19. This is also true for other members of this antifungal protein group, such as PAF, AFP, or NFAP, which possess a highly stable disulphide-bond mediated, compact, β-fold structure9,40,43.
PAFB showed potent antifungal activity against model fungi and human fungal pathogens in low concentrations (µM range). PAFB prevented more effectively than PAF the germination and colony establishment of N. crassa, and significant differences in the susceptibility of some tested fungi, e.g. A. terreus, P. chrysogenum, point towards different modes of action of these two proteins. Variations in the antifungal spectrum and the mode of action were reported for the structurally very similar, related antifungal proteins PAF, AfpB, NFAP and AFP26,30,44,45. We propose that the presence and activity of host interaction molecules that regulate the uptake mechanism, the processing of signals and the ability to cope with detrimental effects triggered by the antifungal proteins determine the susceptibility of fungal species. Furthermore, the importance of protein surface charges and their distributions described for PAF function need to be considered to explain differences in the antifungal activity8.
Recombinant PAFB was identified after 72 h of cultivation and reached its maximum amount after 96 h in the standard medium MM, which perfectly coincided with the onset of production of PAF and other recombinant PAF variants that had been generated with this expression system under the control of the paf promoter20. Interestingly, the overproduction of recombinant PAFB did not affect the proliferation of the producer strain P. chrysogenum pafB, although an inhibitory activity was observed on conidia in the microdilution assays (Table 1). One possible explanation for this phenomenon could be that under PAFB expression conditions (established hyphal growth and MM), P. chrysogenum hyphae lack any PAFB susceptibility determinants, which, in contrast, must be present in 0.1 × PDB. Indeed, we proved that PAFB, similarly to PAF, did not interact with P. chrysogenum hyphae cultivated in MM (Supplementary Fig. S9). Only when grown in 0.1 × PDB, hyphal proliferation was inhibited and PAFB was taken up by the cells (Supplementary Fig. S9). PAF, on the other hand, neither interacted with P. chrysogenum conidia nor hyphae, irrespective of the culture medium applied (Table 1 and Supplementary Fig. S9).
Similar nutrient dependent susceptibility for PAFB and PAF was observed with yeasts. Up to date, potent anti-yeast activity was only reported for the N. fischeri protein NFAP2, which killed yeast cells within minutes by plasma membrane disruption1. Neither for PgAFP19, nor for the related proteins AFP, NFAP and PAF any yeast inhibitory activity was ever found1,46. Most interestingly, in this study we show for the first time, anti-yeast activity of PAFB and PAF in 10 × diluted PDB. Apparently, yeast cells exhibit susceptibility determinants for both proteins when cultivated in this “starvation” medium. The time course experiments indicated that C. albicans cells were not killed immediately after administration of PAFB and PAF, but that cell death occurred in a time and concentration dependent manner, supporting our observations made so far that exclude a fast killing mechanism, e.g. by pore formation, but point towards more complex interaction mechanisms with the target cell8,27.
Indeed, cell toxicity of PAFB in all susceptible fungi studied correlated with active protein internalization and its subsequent distribution in the cytoplasm, which coincided with PI positive staining as observed with PAF and other antifungal peptides and proteins in previous studies8,22,47,48,49. Higher fungicidal activity of PAFB over that of PAF might result from differences in efficient uptake and/or reaching an effective killing concentration within the cell. Further investigations are needed to elucidate the mechanisms that regulate fungal susceptibility and killing kinetics of members of this protein group.
Few studies were published on the anti-viral activity of antimicrobial peptides and proteins expressed by animals and plants, e.g. defensins50,51,52. A surprising and novel observation for small, cysteine-rich, cationic and antimicrobial proteins of fungal origin was the efficacy of PAFB and PAF against HCoV 229E virus. This virus is highly contagious and can cause mild, cold-like respiratory illness. However, highly pathogenic HCoVs such as severe acute respiratory syndrome CoV (SARS-CoV) and Middle East respiratory syndrome CoV (MERS-CoV) predominantly infect lower airways and cause fatal pneumonia with high morbidity and mortality during an epidemic53. Anti-HCoV drugs and vaccines are in different stages of development, but they are still lacking today54. PAFB and PAF, preferentially at low MOI, reduced the virus-induced CPE of infected human L132 cells, thus promising a potential alternative therapeutic approach against human coronaviruses. Based on the data collected in this study, we suggest that PAFB and PAF directly - or indirectly by influencing the host cell metabolism - inhibit the release and spread of progeny virus particles, or destroy the HCoV virions. The observed slight differences in the anti-viral activity between PAFB and PAF may result from different virus or host cell susceptibility towards both proteins, or from differences in the protein surface charge distributions as outlined above. The observation that anti-viral efficacy could not be further increased with higher protein concentrations than 8 µM could be attributed to low bioavailability of the proteins at higher concentrations, a partial clustering or hampered crossing of bio-membranes as shown for antimicrobial proteins in previous studies55,56. Work is currently in progress to get detailed insight into the mode of the anti-viral action of PAFB and PAF.
Importantly, lethal activity of the potential drugs towards human cells has to be excluded and harmful side effects need to be kept to a minimum for future antimicrobial drug development. Similar to AFP and PAF10,57, no toxic activity on mammalian cells was detected for PAFB in vitro (Supplementary Fig. S7). This feature and the antifungal/antiviral potential render PAFB a promising candidate for the development of novel antimicrobial treatment strategies.
Strains, media and cultivation conditions
The propagation of vectors and plasmids was carried out in E. coli DH5α, grown in lysogeny broth medium (LB), supplemented with 100 µg/mL ampicillin. Yeasts were grown on potato dextrose agar (PDA, Becton Dickinson) or on solid yeast extract peptone dextrose medium (YPD) at 37 °C.
For the generation of conidia, P. chrysogenum was cultivated on solid defined minimal medium (MM) at 25 °C, N. crassa on Vogel’s agar plates at 37 °C under continuous light and A. fumigatus, A. niger and A. terreus were grown on PDA (Becton Dickinson) at 37 °C. T. rubrum was grown on oatmeal agar. Conidia were harvested in spore buffer (0.9% NaCl (w/v), 0.01% Tween 80 (v/v)). For transformation, 108 conidia of P. chrysogenum Δpaf21 were grown in 200 mL CM for 38 h at 25 °C under continuous shaking (210 rpm). Conidia (1–2 × 108) of P. chrysogenum Q176 and P. chrysogenum pafB were cultivated in 200 mL MM for 24–144 h at 25 °C under continuous shaking for Northern, Southern and Western blot analyses and PAFB production, respectively. PAFB single (15N) or double (15N/13C) isotope-labelling for NMR analysis was carried out by replacing the nitrogen and/or carbon source in MM by 0.3% Na15NO3 and/or 1% 13C-glucose (w/v) (Euriso-Top), respectively.
Total RNA was isolated from P. chrysogenum Q176 liquid cultures using TRI Reagent (Sigma-Aldrich). Ten µg RNA per lane were loaded on 1.2% formaldehyde-agarose gels, blotted onto Hybond-N membranes (Amersham Biosiences) and hybridized with digoxigenin (DIG)-labelled probes (Roche). The primer pair opafB_fw/opafB_rev and opaf1_fw/opaf_rev was used for PCR-based amplification of the pafB and paf specific hybridization probes, respectively (Supplementary Table S4).
Fungal transformation and verification of plasmid integration
For the generation of a PAFB-overproducing P. chrysogenum strain, the paf deletion mutant P. chrysogenum Δpaf 21 was transformed with pSK275pafB. Protoplast formation and transformation of 10 µg PstI linearized pSK275pafB was carried out according to Cantoral et al.58. Transformants were single spored three times on MM agar supplemented with 0.3–0.6 µg/mL pyrithiamine hydrobromide (Sigma-Aldrich).
Positive transformants were analysed by Southern blotting for the genomic integration of pSK275pafB20. A detailed description is given in the Supplementary Methods.
Protein expression, purification and verification
PAFB and PAF were produced and purified from the cell-free supernatant as recently described20. To verify the identity of purified PAFB, the protein mass was determined by ESI-MS at the Protein Micro-Analysis Facility (Medical University of Innsbruck)20. In addition, protein solution was size-fractionated on a 18% (w/v) SDS-PAGE as described20.
Three PAFB samples were prepared for NMR studies: an unlabelled, a 15N-labelled and a 15N/13C-labelled as described recently20. Lyophilized protein was dissolved in 20 mM acetate buffer (prepared with deuterated acetic acid, pH = 4.5) and filled into Shigemi NMR sample tube (250 µl). Protein concentration was set to 1.5 mM. Protein resonance assignment was accomplished with the same strategy that was applied previously for double-labelled PAF6. Briefly, 2D 15N-HSQC served as the root for the following 3D triple resonance experiments: HNCO, HN(CA)CO, HNCA, HN(CO)CA, HNCACB, HNHA, HBHA(CO)NH and HN(CO)CACB, which were used for obtaining backbone signal assignments59. For resonance assignment of side chains the combination of HC(C)H COSY, HC(C)H TOCSY, HCC(CO)NH and (H)CCH-TOCSY experiments were used, and aromatic protons were identified with the aid of 2D CB(CGCD)HD and CB(CGCDCE)HE spectra. The applied experiment versions were identical with those described in our previous study6. To collect NOE distance restraints, 15N- and 13C-resolved 3D NOESY spectra were recorded as well as a 2D 1H-1H NOESY this latter experiment was performed on the unlabelled PAFB sample. All the above listed measurements were recorded on a Bruker Avance II 500 spectrometer equipped with TXI z-gradient probe-head. The NOESY-type experiments were repeated on a 700 MHz spectrometer with similar configuration. The higher spectral resolution of the NOESY spectra with less overlapping cross-peaks help obtaining more distant restraints for structure calculation. All spectra were acquired at 298 K and data was processed with Topspin 3.0 software. Sequential resonance assignment was performed with the aid of CARA 1.8.4 software from which chemical shift data was exported to other software. Cyana 2.1 torsion angle dynamics package60,61 was used for de novo structure determination in combination with the ATNOS-CANDID algorithm (the latter was used for peak picking and NOE assignment). Setup files for Cyana were prepared manually. Disulphide connections were defined in the Cyana input assuming abcabc disulphide pattern as in PAF (linking cysteine 8–36, 15–43 and 28–54). Diastereotopic protons for non-equivalent CH2 groups were considered as stereo-chemically ambiguous assignments. Backbone torsional angle constraints were predicted according to TALOS+62 and were used for the refinement of the structure model. Seven cycles of Cyana iterations were performed, and the 20 lowest energy conformers were considered as a final structure model. Chemical shift data and NMR experimental parameters were submitted to the BMRB databank and the structural ensemble was uploaded to Protein Data Bank (ID: 2NC2).
Antibacterial and antifungal activity assays
Growth inhibition assays were performed in 96-well microtiter plates (Nunclon Delta, Thermo Scientific). Conidia or yeast cells (104/mL) were incubated in 0.1 × PDB (Becton Dickinson) with increasing concentrations of PAFB (0–32 µM) in a total volume of 200 µL at 25–30 °C. Bacteria were pre-cultivated in 0.1 × LB or 0.1 × PDB to reach OD620 of 0.05 and then exposed to antimicrobial treatment (0–32 µM PAFB) at 37 °C. Microbial growth was monitored after 24–48 h by measuring the OD620 with a Fluostar Omega microplate reader (BMG Labtech) and microscopically using an inverted microscope (Leica DM IL Led, Leica Microsystems). Images were taken with an AxioCam MR digital camera (Carl Zeiss GmbH) and processed with AxioVision software (Carl Zeiss GmbH). The MIC was defined as the minimal protein concentration that inhibited growth by ≥90% compared to the untreated control which was referred as 100% growth.
The germination efficiency and germ tube length of N. crassa in the presence of PAFB at its MIC was determined as described8.
Fungistatic and fungicidal effects on C. albicans were determined by incubating 2 × 104 cells per mL in 0.1 × PDB with 0–4 µM PAFB at 30 °C with shaking for up to 24 h. Samples were taken after 0 h, 6 h and 24 h, diluted in 0.1 × PDB and plated on PDA plates in duplicates. The number of colony forming units was determined after incubating the plates for 24–48 h at 37 °C. The survival rate was calculated by setting the colony forming units at time point 0 h as 100%.
In all experiments 0–32 µM PAF was applied for comparison. Experiments were prepared in technical triplicates and performed at least twice.
Uptake and localization studies
The green fluorophore BODIPY FL EDA (Life Technologies) was used for protein labelling as described by Sonderegger et al.8.
To study the protein uptake into C. albicans, P. chrysogenum and N. crassa, 106 yeast cells/mL or conidia/mL were incubated with 8 µM BODIPY-labelled proteins in the respective media (0.1 × PDB, 0.2 × Vogel’s) at 25–30 °C and analysed within an incubation time of 30 min to 12 h. To investigate PAFB uptake into P. chrysogenum hyphae grown in MM, 24 h old mycelia were stained with 8 µM BODIPY-labelled PAFB for 2.5 h.
Co-staining with 5 µg/mL PI for 10 min at room temperature was carried out to monitor the viability of fungal cells. For positive staining controls, samples were treated with 50% (v/v) ethanol for 30 min.
PAFB-transport into hyphae was investigated in N. crassa. Conidia (5 × 105/mL) were grown in 0.2 × Vogel´s medium for 4.5 h at 25 °C and then further incubated at 4 °C or with 2.5 mM NaN3 (Sigma-Aldrich) or 100 µM CCCP (Sigma-Aldrich) for 30 min, respectively. BODIPY-labelled PAFB (8 µM) was added and the samples were microscopically analysed after 1.5 h of incubation.
Microscopic imaging was performed with a fluorescence microscope (Axioplan, Carl Zeiss GmbH), equipped with an AxioCam MR3 camera (excitation/emission filters 500/535 nm for green fluorescence, 546/590 or 565/620 nm for red fluorescence, Carl Zeiss GmbH). Image processing and editing was done with Axiovision (Carl Zeiss GmbH), GIMP (GNU Image Manipulation Program, version 2.8.20; www.gimp.org) and Microsoft Power Point (Microsoft Corp.).
Antiviral activity assays
Cultivation of human epithelial cell line L132
For virus propagation L132 cells were grown in antibiotic-free Dulbecco’s Modified Eagle Medium with nonessential amino acids (Thermo Fisher Scientific) complemented with 10% fetal bovine serum (FBS, Eurobio). For the antiviral assays the same medium was used, containing only 2% FBS.
The human coronavirus HCoV 229E was propagated and quantified in L132 cells. Initial virus titers were calculated as 50% cell culture infectious doses (CCID50/mL), according to Reed and Muench (1938)63. All virus stocks were stored at −70 °C until used.
The antiviral activity of PAFB and PAF was determined by evaluating the reduction of the virus-induced CPE, characterized by rounding, vacuolization, syncytia formation and cell death of the cell monolayer. One day before infection, 1 × 104 L132 cells/well were seeded into a 96-well culture plate. The next day, medium was replaced by fresh medium containing diluted virus suspension at MOI 0.01–1.0 was added to the cell culture, followed by the immediate addition of cell culture medium supplemented with 2% FBS and 0–32 µM PAFB or PAF. Plates were then incubated at 33 °C, 5% CO2, for HCoV 229E strain, and checked for virus-induced CPE after 24 h and 72 h, using an inverted light microscope AE2000 (Motic).
The antiviral activity of the proteins was determined by the crystal violet assay, adapted from Feoktistova et al.64. Antiviral activity was expressed as the percentage effective CPE-inhibitory concentration. Modification of the cell morphology and reduction of the virus-induced CPE were also microscopically determined. Three independent experiments were carried out in triplicate.
For immunofluorescence staining, L132 cells were fixed in 3.7% (v/v) formaldehyde (Sigma-Aldrich) and subsequently immersed in PBS containing 0.1% (v/v) Triton X-100 for cell permeabilization. Samples were blocked in PBS/3% BSA (w/v) (Sigma-Aldrich). Hoechst 33342 (Thermo Fischer Scientific) was used as nuclear counterstains for fixed cells. The viral capsid was detected by mouse monoclonal anti-hexon antibody (1:100) (Santa Cruz Biotechnology) diluted in PBS/3% (w/v) BSA. Primary antibodies were incubated on the fixed cells for 90 min at room temperature, washed, and the antigen-antibody complexes were detected with goat anti-mouse FITC-labelled secondary antibody (1:1,000) (Santa Cruz Biotechnology) according to Grigorov et al.65. Images were acquired using an inverted epifluorescence microscope (Axio Observer 3, Carl Zeiss GmbH). Imaging and image processing was routinely performed with ZEN software (2009, Carl Zeiss GmbH) or ImageJ (The ImageJ ecosystem: An open platform for biomedical image analysis)66.
Statistical analysis was performed using Microsoft Excel 2010 software (Microsoft Corp.). Two sample t-test with equal variance and one-tailed distribution was used.
All data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article (and its Supplementary Information files).
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
We thank Julia Brindlinger and Evi Sirabella for technical assistance. This study was financially supported by the Austrian Science Fund FWF (I1644-B20 to FM), the Hungarian Science Fund OTKA (ANN 110821 to GB and NF 104198 to ZG) and the EU, co-financed by the European Regional Development Fund under the project GINOP-2.3.2-15-2016-00008. LG was financed with a Lise Meitner Fellowship from the FWF (M1776-B20) and a Postdoctoral Excellence Programme (PD 12808) from the Hungarian National Research, Development and Innovation (NKFI) Office. The research was further supported by the 700 MHz NMR spectrometer time provided by the MedInProt project of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.
Electronic supplementary material
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.