We describe the coupled straintronic-photothermic effect where coupling between bandgap of the 2D layered semiconductor under localized strains, optical absorption and the photo-thermal effect results in a large chromatic mechanical response in TMD-nanocomposites. Under the irradiation of visible light (405 nm to 808 nm), such locally strained atomic thin films based on 2H-MoS2 embedded in an elastomer such as poly (dimethyl) siloxane matrix exhibited a large amplitude of photo-thermal actuation compared to their unstrained counterparts. Moreover, the locally strain engineered nanocomposites showed tunable mechanical response giving rise to higher mechanical stress at lower photon energies. Scanning photoluminescence spectroscopy revealed a change in bandgap of 30 meV between regions encompassing highly strained compared to the unstrained few layers. For 1.6% change in the bandgap, the macroscopic photo-thermal response increased by a factor of two. Millimeter scale bending actuators based on the locally strained 2H-MoS2 resulted in significantly enhanced photo-thermal actuation displacements compared to their unstrained counterparts at lower photon energies and operated up to 30 Hz. Almost 1 mN photo-activated force was obtained at 50 mW and provided long-term stability. This study demonstrates a new mechanism in TMD-nanocomposites that would be useful for developing broad range of transducers.
Photo-thermal actuation, i.e., the conversion of light into thermal and mechanical work is of significant importance for energy conversion/reconfigurable technologies. Advantages of such photo-thermal mechanisms for transducers include remote energy transfer, remote controllability, control of actuation using number of photons (intensity) and photon energies (wavelength), fast actuation (milliseconds), low signal to noise ratio, high stored elastic strain energy densities with hyperelastic elastomers and scalability at different length scales using batch fabrication and high-volume semiconductor manufacturing. However, only few materials exist that can convert light into mechanical work. Azobenzene liquid crystal elastomers were one of the first materials to exhibit photomechanical effect1. However, their application required two different light sources for reversible thermal switching (420 nm and 365 nm) between an extended trans and a shorter cis configuration2.
Recently, various nanomaterials including nanoparticles, nanowires, carbon nanotubes, and graphene were mixed into different polymers from hyperelastic rubbers3,4, shape memory polymers5 and liquid crystal elastomers6,7,8 and triggered using near infra-red light for photo-thermal actuation. In hyperelastic elastomers, based on the pre-strains, the samples when heated, can either expand, exhibit zero stress or contract in volume and can enable high photo-thermal strain energy densities3,4. Large pre-strains result in large volume contraction on photo-thermal heating due to entropic elasticity. The mechanism of photo-thermal actuation in these nanocomposites is the non-radiative decay of photons resulting in localized thermal effect. While, applications of photo-thermal actuators based on nanomaterials inside thermo-responsive polymers are growing rapidly6,7,9,10,11,12,13,14, there is still a need for material design that is simple, enables tunable optical absorption, and reversible photo-thermal response. Two-dimensional (2D) nanomaterials based on Transition Metal Dichalcogenides (TMDs) encompass large optical absorption (107 m−1)14,15 and strain engineering of such TMDs incorporated into hyperelastic matrix presents new opportunities in photo-thermal transducers which we have explored in this paper.
Strain engineering, i.e., the change in electronic properties using mechanical deformation is an important concept in condensed matter physics and material science that is being exploited in 2D materials due to their ultra-large mechanical strength (capable of withstanding 10–20% strains) and possessing a bandgap16,17,18,19,20,21. Strain engineering in 2D layered materials brings potential benefits such as those explored in graphene including; strain induced bandgap opening22, strain enhanced electron-phonon coupling23,24, non-uniform strain induced pseudo-magnetic field25 and even strain engineered self-assembly of hydrogen on graphene surfaces26 In TMDs strain engineering has brought benefits such as bandgap engineering of single and bi-layers20, exciton funneling effects21, and selective chemical adsorption of gas molecules on strained surfaces27.
Compared to graphene, which is just a layer of carbon atoms and has no bandgap, TMDs are stacks of triple layers with transition metal layer between two chalcogen layers and they also possess an intrinsic bandgap. The elastic modulus and the breaking strength of an ideal defect-free single-layer molybdenum disulfide (MoS2) is expected to be E2D/9, where E2D is the in-plane stiffness as per the theory of rupture and flow in solids28,29. The in-plane stiffness of monolayer MoS2 is reported as 180 ± 60 Nm−1 corresponding to an effective Young’s modulus of 270 ± 100 GPa, which is comparable to that of steel28. Breaking occurs at an effective strain between 6 and 11% with the average breaking strength of 23 GPa28.
The large breaking strength makes strain engineering an interesting prospect in TMDs, as the bandgaps in TMDs are highly sensitive to strains. Bulk form of MoS2 has an indirect band gap of ~1.29 eV30 and strain engineering has no effect on such bulk materials and does not produce any significant chromatic mechanical response. On the other hand, single layer MoS2 has a band gap of 1.8–1.9 eV30; bi-layer has a bandgap of 1.5–1.6 eV20 and strain engineering can modulate electronic and optoelectronic properties. With decreasing thickness, the past experiments have revealed a progressive confinement-induced shift in the indirect gap from the bulk value of 1.29 eV up to 1.90 eV30. The in-plane structure of MoS2 is determined by strong covalent bonds resulting from the overlap between the 4d and 3p electron orbitals of Mo and S, respectively28. In few layer 2H-MoS2, the bandgap goes from direct-to-indirect at >1% strains20 and undergoes semiconductor-to-metal transition at 10–15% strains31.
Several techniques are realized for strain engineering of 2D layered materials including bending/elongating a flexible substrate20, piezoelectric compression32, exploiting thermal expansion mismatch33, creating artificial atoms through indentation/capillary forces34, and controlled wrinkling21. However, large area photo-thermal devices based on these mentioned techniques of strain engineering of 2D layered TMDs are yet to be explored with hyperelastic materials.
Utilizing exfoliated nanoparticle MoS2 suspensions, filtration and layer-by-layer process of nanocomposite fabrication, and strain transfer from polymeric substrate, here we present the first direct evidence of chromatic optical absorption and reduction in bandgap due to localized strains in TMDs directly affecting the photo-thermal response of a nanocomposite at the macroscopic length scales. Our work is also the first locally strain engineered 2D layered device to perform mechanical work using this coupled straintronic-photo-thermic effect.
Figure 1 describes the straintronic-photothermal effect. This effect arises due to coupling of electronic properties of semiconductors, thermal properties of polymers and photoexcitation. The mechanism is the coupling between localized strains, change in the bandgap and optical absorption of 2D TMDs transducing into a thermal effect that expands/contracts the hyperelastic molecular chains. This effect is chromatic (depends on the wavelength of light), fully reversible, bandgap dependent and produces elastic mechanical response. This effect only happens in layered semiconductors and not in bulk materials. The strain induced lowering of the bandgap in 2D layered semiconductor is coupled to the enhanced optical absorption. The thermal energy generated during the process of photoexcitation across the bandgap is coupled to the hyperelastic molecular chains that make them highly mobile internally. In zero strain and strained semiconductor nanocomposites, we observed chromatic mechanical response.
The High-Resolution Transmission Electron Micrograph (HRTEM) of the MoS2 structure is presented in Fig. 2(a) with atoms of S and Mo indicated. The distances a1, a2 and a3 measured from this image are close to the 2.8 Å value of the Mo–Mo interatomic distances in 2H-MoS2 35. The insert in Fig. 2(a) presents the Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) of the HRTEM image indexing the crystallographic planes of the single layer 2H-MoS2. Small distortions and apparent non-uniform intensity distribution of the spots in FFT are due to a slight tilt of the flake normal to the electron beam. In the 2H-MoS2 lattice, each Mo atom is located at the center of a trigonal prism created by six S atoms. The lattice constant of 2H-MoS2 was reported to be: a = b = 3.14 Å36 and c = 12.3 Å37. In the bulk form of MoS2 with an indirect band gap of ~1.29 eV30, the photon absorption process is dominated by electronic polarization, and as a result, no wavelength selective optical absorption is observed since no significant electronic transition happens from the valence to the conduction band. However, as the number of MoS2 layers decreases, the indirect band gap becomes large and the material changes into a direct band gap semiconductor with Eg ~1.9 eV in a single layer30 with intrinsic photoluminescence38. Figure 2(b) presents the schematic of the band structure of flat versus locally strained architecture for 2H-MoS2. Inserts next to the band structures show the flat and strained honeycomb structure of the semiconducting phase of 2H-MoS2. Figure 2(c) presents the schematic of the strained versus flat actuators. Local strain engineering creates wrinkles. The schematic of a flat sheet with polymer chains in contact is also presented in Fig. 2(d). Since these are layered structures that is transferred from the filter membrane to the polymer, it is expected that the contact between the MoS2 and polymer is primary adhesion and the molecular chains are interacting with MoS2 layers entropically. This contact enables the thermal energy be transferred from the MoS2 additive to the polymer chains enabling a photo-thermal response due to entropic elasticity.
Figure 3 shows the fabrication schematic, strain transfer and optical images of the samples in Polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS). The starting point of the photo-thermal actuators is the filtration of commercially available 2H-MoS2 suspensions to form a film14. Initial characterization revealed few layered MoS2 nanoparticle suspensions had a particle size of ~100 nm. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) measurements suggested from 1–6 layers14 and were used for preparing the photomechanical actuators. The suspensions were filtered through a membrane using simple filtration (no vacuum is applied). Filtration resulted in optically smooth layers on top of the filter membrane of a specific thickness. A layer of PDMS is then spin coated onto a glass slide, cured and peeled off. The peeled off layer of PDMS is then set up between clamps and strain of 70%, is applied to the PDMS layer by stretching the sample. The filter membrane consisting of 35 nm or 70 nm 2H-MoS2 thin film is transferred to the strained layer, and the membrane is dissolved in acetone, leaving behind the thin film of 2H-MoS2 on the strained PDMS layer. We made two different thickness of film namely 35 nm and 70 nm film to assess the straintronic-photothermal response. Releasing the strains suddenly results in the formation of wrinkles. Figure 3(b) and (c) presents the clamps with PDMS thin film before, and after releasing the strain, respectively. Once the strain is released as presented in Fig. 3(c), lamellar structures are seen under an optical microscope suggesting the appearance of the wrinkles.
Figure 4(a–d) presents the scanning electron micrograph (SEM) of the wrinkled architecture at different magnification. Strain transfer from an elastomeric substrate such as PDMS resulted in thousands of wrinkles at a large scale. Here we have used the same strain transfer from a polymer substrate at a large scale. Figure 4(d) presents the SEM image of a single wrinkle between flat layers, measuring 520 nm in height and 970 nm in width. Figure S2 (Suppl.) presents the AFM image of the wrinkles on the polymer substrate. The lamellar structure is seen from the top extending to several microns. The height image from the AFM is presented for different regions showing ~70–80 nm consistently in height. The height and width of over 100 wrinkles are listed in Table S1 (Suppl.), reporting average values of 87 nm and 553 nm for height and width of wrinkles in 35 nm film. Castellanos-Gomez et al. showed such wrinkles are generated from a single sheet of MoS2 consisting of 3–4 layers using the strain transfer from polymer for studying bandgap engineering in mechanically exfoliated samples21. We have used this process to transfer strains into nanoparticles of MoS2 formed into a thin film. The films, therefore, are not one continuous sheet, but quasi-continuous sheets consisting of few layer nanoparticles ~100 nm in diameter each. Such films also create stable wrinkles without disintegrating into the substrate. Releasing the strain from the elastomeric substrate results in delamination induced buckling, of our quasi-continuous sheets39. We were able to produce wrinkles that were 12–170 nm in height and 300 to 700 nm in width. Previous work has shown that, the maximum uniaxial tensile strain ε accumulated on top of the winkles is estimated as39:
where σ is the Poisson’s ratio of MoS2 (0.125), h is the thickness of the flake and δ and λ are the height and width of the wrinkle respectively. However, this model assumes the sheet to be continuous and the strains are often overestimated for thin films of nanoparticles. A modification of this model is thus necessary to accurately predict the strain profile in our quasi-continuous sheets. The analytical strain model for van der Waals packed films was developed based on the original work by Vella et al.39. The new strain relationship for the nanoparticle films is thus given as:
where, x is the horizontal distance from apex of the wrinkle and z the distance from the mid-plane of each individual nanoparticle. The details of this model can be found in the supplementary document and Figure S1 .
We calculated strains from >100 different wrinkles based on the height, width and thickness measurements as per equation 2. Supplementary Tables S 1–S4 presents the statistical information on the width, height and length of each wrinkle measured from the AFM images. The tabulated results show anywhere between 0.2–1.3% strains were achieved in the wrinkles. For the 35 nm film (Table S1 ), average strains from >100 different places suggested a 0.6% and for 70 nm film (Table S3 ), strains of 0.3% calculated using equation 2.
Figure 5 presents the Raman spectroscopic measurements between flat and wrinkled actuator samples. Raman spectroscopy is a powerful tool to characterize 2D nanomaterials such as graphene and MoS2 subjected to a uniaxial strain. Initial work by Li et al., showed coupling between electronic transitions and phonons are found to become weaker when the layer number of MoS2 decreases, attributed to the elongated intralayer atomic bonds in ultrathin MoS2 40. Figure 5(a) presents the Raman measurements between flat and wrinkle samples measured using 532 nm laser wavelength. Clear changes in the E1 2g and the A1g, modes are seen between the flat and wrinkled actuators. The A1g mode that corresponds to the sulfur atoms oscillating out-of-plane is less affected than the E1 2g mode which is the sulfur and molybdenum atoms oscillating parallel to the crystal plane. The slight shift of the A1g peak observed on the wrinkled MoS2, and the larger Raman shift of the E1 2g peak (~0.75 cm−1) are in good agreement with recent reports on strain engineered MoS2 21. In the past, in our few layer nanocomposites, applying global macroscopic uniaxial tensile strain of 10% using a custom made strain gadget resulted in the shift of the E2g mode by about −1.7 cm−1 and negligible change in A1g 14. However, those experiments were performed by measuring the Raman shift versus intensity while the strain was still held by the gadget. In the localized strain engineered sample as reported here, the Raman shift versus intensity was measured after the strain was removed from the samples. The smaller change in Raman wavenumbers is expected due to relaxation of the samples after removal of the strain resulting in lowering of Raman wave numbers and due to higher thickness of the film compared to single sheet of few layers.
Raman mapping was conducted over large area to understand the shift in E2g/A1g between strained and unstrained samples. Resonant Raman scattering studies were performed at room temperature as presented in Fig. 5(b). Figure 5b(b1–b2) are the optical images of unstrained (flat) and locally strained actuators showing the visible roughness of the strained sample. Figure 5b(b3) is the resonant Raman scattering (measured using 633 nm laser) of the strained few layer 2H-MoS2 samples. We have studied resonant Raman scattering of MoS2 few layers based on number of layers in our past reports14. Resonant Raman spectra of the MoS2 films, both wrinkled as well as flat, showed a complex vibrational modes structure with the same Raman features as the few-layer MoS2. In addition to the first order E1 2g (~384 cm−1) and A1 g (~409 cm−1) peaks, the spectra contained a number of intense second-order peaks located between 360 cm−1 and 660 cm−1 Raman shifts. This includes the “b” (~420 cm−1) peak associated with the emission of a dispersive quasi-acoustic phonon and simultaneously an optical E2 1u phonon along the c-axis, the “c” (~380 cm−1) peak due to the emission of a E2 1u (Γ) phonon, and the B1u (Γ) (~404 cm−1) peak, which together with the A1g (Γ) peak form a Davydov couple. Several significant changes of the spectrum are observed with strains for the few layer nanocomposite. Compared to the flat samples in Fig. 5b(b4), and Fig. S3 (suppl.), the A1g, E1g + XA, and “b” peak intensities are partially increased in the strained samples. Fig. S3 (suppl.) shows the Raman mapping of flat and wrinkled sample corresponding to the region represented by white lines in Figure 5(b4–b5). For example, the “b” peak shows higher intensity for the locally strained sample compared to the unstrained flat counterparts which is an indicative of the phonon involved that has a wave vector along the c-axis. Similarly, the A1g is the out-of-plane vibrational mode is affected by the strain. The non-uniformity between resonant Raman spectra of the strained samples suggests the non-homogeneity of strain in the wrinkled samples.
Raman mapping was performed, and 21 × 21 spectral maps were collected from 20 µm × 20 µm regions of flat and wrinkled samples over 16 hours as presented in Figure 5b(b4–b5). The mapping of the large area of the sample showed an unambiguous reduction of E2g/A1g intensity ratio in wrinkled samples compared to flat actuators (Figure 5b(b6)). The histograms of E2g/A1g intensity ratio values measured from three Raman maps: one flat, and two wrinkled ones, showed a good statistical evidence of this change. The average shift in E2g/A1g intensity ratio is about 0.2 (a change of ~11%). The decrease in E2g/A1g intensity ratio is indicative of strain transfer to the additives across a large area of the substrate, suggesting that this process is highly scalable for future device applications.
Photoluminescence spectroscopy (PL) is a powerful technique to unambiguously show the reduction in bandgap in TMDs with strains. Here, we see that the nanoparticle sheets does exhibit distinct PL spectrum with and without strains. Figure 6(a) presents the schematic of the funnel effects due to exciton drift due to the strains. The top of the wrinkle is the point of the highest strain and the bottom of the wrinkle, where the strain is lowest. Thus, the wrinkle is a geometric structure where strain gradients are established from top to bottom and thus can enable exciton funneling from regions of low strain towards high strain regions21. Figure 6(b) presents the photoluminescence spectra of the flat and wrinkled nanoparticle sheets. Both the samples were prepared identically, and the only difference was, application of strain for the sample exhibiting the wrinkle architecture. Since these sheets were 35 nm thick, we expected the photoluminescence to be small compared to single layers, to begin with even for flat sheets. However, they do exhibit distinct photoluminescence as seen in the spectra in Fig. 6(b). The flat sheets had small PL intensity. However, there was an increase in intensity and red shifting of the direct electron bandgap for the wrinkled samples. Bulk MoS2 exhibits negligible photoluminescence as there is no direct electron transition and thus, the first thing we can observe is these sheets; they do not act like bulk materials. The photoluminescence intensity was three times stronger for the strained wrinkle architecture for the same thickness suggesting direct electron transition increased due to the application of mechanical deformation. Although few-layer MoS2 is an indirect bandgap semiconductor, its photoluminescence spectrum is dominated by the direct gap transitions, at the K point of the Brillouin zone, between the valence band and the conduction band. Here, we see that the A peak is red shifted in the photoluminescence spectra of the flat and the wrinkled samples in line with previous reports on strain engineered few layer MoS2. Figure 6(c) presents the bandgap shifts measured using scanning photoluminescence spectroscopy in three regions namely: top of the wrinkle, the bottom of the wrinkle and in a flat film. The insert in this figure presents a wrinkle with regions of low and high strains identified. The strain values for over 100 wrinkles were studied and listed in Table S1 , reporting strains from 0.2% to 1.3% in our wrinkles. These suggest unambiguously that the bandgap decrease of 30 meV is due to the localized strain engineering and our results agree with the literature reports21. The calculated values of local strain based on Equation 2 and the bandgap change in Fig. 6(c) are in good agreement with previous studies; according to the experimental data and tight binding (TB) model presented earlier by Castellanos-Gomez et al.21 a change of −30 meV in the bandgap (A exciton) corresponds to a strain of ~1.0%. The flat samples showed a bandgap of ~1.82 eV and the strain-induced bandgap was measured as ~1.79 eV, suggesting ~1.6% change in the bandgap due to mechanical deformation. Figure S4 (suppl.) presents the PL measurements for both plain PDMS and MoS2/PDMS. One can clearly see the A and B peaks in MoS2/PDMS sample and not seen in plain PDMS sample.
Having characterized the actuators with and without strains, we investigated photo-thermal effects of flat (unstrained) and wrinkle (strained) actuators as presented in Fig. 7. Photo-thermal stress measurements were investigated both for flat and wrinkled architectures which are presented in Suppl. S5 . The power transmitted through the sample at different wavelengths is also presented in Figure S6 . Both flat and wrinkle based actuators gave rise to chromatic mechanical response, i.e. a differential mechanical response at different wavelengths of light arising due to the optoelectronic transitions across the bandgap. This does not happen in bulk MoS2 photomechanical actuators, where the mechanical response is insensitive to the wavelength of light41 suggesting that these actuators made from nanoparticle sheets do not act like bulk materials. The chromatic absorption and subsequent mechanical response are first evidence that the semiconductor bandgap is intimately connected to the mechanical response, thus the straintronic-photo thermal effect. This effect also does not happen in thin film semiconductors. For these measurements, no external pre-strains was applied to the sample. At 405 nm, we see that the stress was identical for both unstrained (flat) and strained (wrinkle) architectures. However, for the wrinkle samples, the stress was enhanced at lower photon energies between 532 nm to 808 nm. This enhancement in stress at lower photon energies can only arise from the reduction in bandgap due to strains. The thermal and mechanical effect also follows the reduction in the bandgap. The power transmitted through the samples were higher for the unstrained (Fig. S6 ) samples suggesting more light is absorbed by the highly strained samples at all wavelengths. What is striking is the large values of mechanical stress that can be achieved.
The straintronic-photothermal effect is highly useful for Millimeter scale and Micro-Opto-Mechanical Systems (MOMS). Figure 7 presents the photomechanical response of a millimeter scale bending actuator. Figure 7(a) presents the schematic of the bending actuator. A laser displacement sensor was used to monitor the change in deflection of the cantilever. The actuators consisted of a layer of PDMS and thin layer of MoS2. The thickness of the layers was 80 µm for PDMS, and 35 nm for the 2H-MoS2 and the length of the actuator was 12 mm. The SEM image presents the cross-section of the PDMS and MoS2 layers. The insert in the tilted SEM image presents the thousands of wrinkles. Figure 7(b) presents the displacement of the actuator between 405 nm to 808 nm of the flat nanosheet actuators and Fig. 7(c) presents the displacement of the wrinkled actuators respectively. Remarkably, both the actuators gave rise to the same displacement at 405 nm (energy above the bandgap). Since 405 nm is much larger than the bandgap, this was expected. As we go down the photon energy, the 532 nm, 640 nm and 808 nm excitation resulted in smaller displacement for the flat actuators. The displacements between the 405 nm and 808 nm excitation are almost ten times for the flat actuators. Now coming to the wrinkle actuator sample as presented in Fig. 7(c), we see the same chromatic mechanical response. For the wrinkle architecture, the mechanical response was enhanced at 532 nm, 640 nm, and 808 nm excitations. The mechanical response enhancement was twice at 532 nm, 640 nm, and 808 nm. As the PL spectroscopy suggested a decrease in bandgap of 30 meV, this resulted in improved optical absorption at lower wavelengths resulting in enhanced photo-thermal response. For 1.6% change in the bandgap, the mechanical response enhancement factor is almost two. The results suggest that for lower laser energy input; we get a significantly improved mechanical output compared to the flat actuators. This type of strain induced photo-tunability of mechanical response at lower light energies has not been achieved in other photomechanical materials namely azobenzene liquid crystal elastomers (LCE), carbon nanotubes and nanoparticle based LCEs and this effect opens a new window in the design of photo-thermal systems based on coupled straintronic-photothermic effects. A practical application of this effect would be in tunable photo-thermal nanopositioning42.
Figure 8 presents the frequency response of the millimeter scale actuators. These actuators were 12 mm in length. The thickness of the PDMS layer was 80 µm. Figure 8(a) presents the mechanical response amplitude versus excitation frequency for both strained and unstrained samples. An exponential decrease was observed in frequency versus mechanical response for both samples. The locally strained samples showed larger response compared to their unstrained flat counterparts at low frequencies. These actuators could be operated up to 30 Hz quite easily (Fig. S7 (suppl.)) which is a record by itself for photo-thermal actuators at the millimeter-scale. While these are first demonstrations, with scaling down the actuators to microscopic scales and depending on the thermal mass, one can improve the operability of these actuators to >100 Hz. The relationship between vibrational amplitude (δ) and excitation frequency (v) for both flat and wrinkled actuators is interpolated as:
Figure 8(b) presents the photothermal vibration response of unstrained actuators at 0 and 5 Hz. Insert is the magnified image of the laser input and the mechanical output. The amplitude of the photothermal response is smaller for the 5 Hz actuation. The results also suggest that one can pulse the photo-thermal actuators that would be useful for programmed sensing applications using optical methods.
Figure 9(a) and (b) are the photomechanical stress response of the flat and wrinkled actuators at various wavelengths. The average ratio of σUV/NIR (i.e. σ405/808) in Fig. 9(a) and (b) is an indication of the amplitude of the chromatic mechanical response. For a 35-nm thick film, a value of 12.09 indicates higher chromatic response compared to 70-nm film with a value of 6.42, also suggesting a higher yield of few layer regions in the 35-nm sample. From these figures, different behaviors of flat versus wrinkle samples are noted; while in 35-nm film, there is a merging point between flat and wrinkle samples at 405 nm, there is not such a point in the 70-nm film. Thus, the thickness plays an important role and the mechanism is gradually changing from layered effect to bulk when increasing the thickness, resulting in disappearance of the merging point.
The insert in Fig. 9(a) and (b) is the ratio of the mechanical stress response of wrinkled versus flat samples. Both the flat and wrinkled architecture has the same pattern of the stress response versus wavelength of light. However, the increase in the ratio of mechanical stress response between wrinkled and flat samples by a factor of two in 35 nm film suggests that the wrinkle architecture samples were unambiguously effective in converting light into thermal energy and mechanical work. We also see that the ratio of the mechanical stress response between wrinkled and flat samples depends on the thickness. For the 35 nm film, a near exponential increase in stress ratio with a decrease in photon energies is seen. However, for the 70 nm film, the increase in stress ratio is approaching a linear behavior. If we plot the ratio of wrinkled to flat actuators with respect to incident wavelength and interpolate the experimental data with the following equation:
The coefficient b for the 35 nm and 70 nm films is 0.00178 and 0.00084, respectively. A decrease in the coefficient with the increase in thickness of thin film is observed. This shows diminishing effect of wrinkling as the thickness of nanoparticle film increases. The exponent coefficient should approach zero for adequately thick film of nanoparticles (>100 nm), where there would not be any improvement in photoactivated stress due to wrinkling. This suggests the thickness limits for the straintronic-photothermal effect is ≤100 nm. It is expected that below 35 nm thickness, this effect will be highly dominant with large amplitudes of stress and exponential mechanical response between UV and NIR wavelengths. Figure 9(c) represents the internal force in different intensity of 640 nm light for both wrinkled and flat samples. Almost 1 mN force was achieved for the wrinkled actuators and they showed higher force compared to flat actuators at all light intensities.
To determine the robustness of this actuator, we did long term experiments in line with previous reports. Figure 9(d) presents the photomechanical stress versus time over 4 hours of continuous operation of the actuators. No drift observed, and we observe that the large-scale wrinkle actuators were stable over long periods. There are conclusions that are deduced from these long-term experiments. First, the photomechanical actuation of the locally strain engineered 2H-MoS2 nanocomposite is fully reversible and exhibits a robust actuation mechanism. Second, the photomechanical experiments over long periods of time did not alter the structure of the wrinkles, which would otherwise cause an irreversible change in the amplitude of photomechanical actuation stress (a significant reduction in stress). This also means that the wrinkles are highly stable on the surface of the polymer substrate. Figure S8 presents the high angle SEM image of before and after applying cycles of external strains of 60% to a wrinkled sample. The resulting morphology looks the same suggesting no slip, collapse, or permanent changes to the wrinkles. We believe that as long the external strain does not exceed the initial fabrication strains of the wrinkles, they should be stable.
To further understand the mechanism of photo-actuation of MoS2/PDMS nanocomposites, iso-strain tests have been done in Dynamic Mechanical Analyzer (DMA-Q800 TA Instruments). A pristine PDMS sample of ~140 µm thick was cut into 8 mm × 30 mm strip and placed in between DMA tension clamps. The sample was stretched to different strain levels. At each of these strain levels, a temperature ramp from room temperature to 60 °C was applied to uniformly heat up the polymer sample and measure the change in the internal force of the sample due to the thermal actuation of PDMS at a fixed length.
In Figure S9 (Suppl.), the trend in thermal actuation of pristine PDMS is very similar to photo-actuation of MoS2/PDMS nanocomposites. This suggests that MoS2 wrinkles act as photo-thermal energy transducing agents that absorb the light energy depending on the bandgap and convert it to thermal energy. The thermal energy is transferred to polymer chains of PDMS, making them expand or contract due to entropic elasticity. Similar to photo-actuation behavior43, there are three different regimes in the thermal actuation process: expansion, contraction, and zero-actuation regions. In small pre-strains (0–5%), heating of the sample leads to increase in length, i.e. decrease in the internal stress of the PDMS strip. At medium pre-strains (5–10%), heating does not have a significant effect due to the balance between entropic forces and thermal energy keeping the stress level at zero. At high pre-strain values (10–60%), heating results in significant contraction of the sample, i.e. an increase in the internal stress of the polymer strip. PDMS is a hyperelastic polymer where the stress is derived from the strain energy function. Combining such hyper elastic material with ultra-large strength 2D nanomaterials can enable a significant amount of stored strain energy that is released on photo-excitation.
We developed a new mathematical model for the thermal and photo-thermal actuations to predict the temperature profile of unstrained and strained actuators. In photo-actuation, the temperature profile in the sample can be expressed as a Gaussian distribution14:
where µ is the mean and σ the standard deviation. This leads to a relationship between purely thermal and photothermal actuations with the following equation (for more details on this model, see part 2 of the supplementary document):
where ΔT n denotes the temperature change in photo-actuation and ΔT u the temperature change in thermal actuation. It should be noted that the thermal actuation takes almost 20 minutes for uniform temperature equilibration in DMA compared to photo-actuation which takes about 5–10 s for stress to saturate.
To corroborate the model, both wrinkle and flat MoS2/PDMS nano composites were tested for heat-induced actuation in DMA TA-Q800 as presented in Figure S11 . Obviously, both samples show similar thermal actuation, as in heat-induced actuation the polymer chains are responsible for induced stress, which is the same in both samples. From these results, a corresponding ΔTn for each of photoinduced stress values of wrinkle and flat samples is obtained.
Figure 10 presents the predicted temperature profiles based on our mathematical model for the unstrained and strained actuators at different wavelengths. The temperature of the sample as a function of the wavelength of the light for unstrained actuators was predicted as 35 °C (405 nm), 29 °C (532 nm), 27 °C (640 nm) and 23.9 °C (808 nm). The room temperature is 23 °C as a reference. For the strained actuators, the temperature of the sample as a function of the wavelength of the light is 35 °C (405 nm), 29.9 °C (532 nm), 29 °C (640 nm) and 24.6 °C (808 nm). At 405 nm both give rise to the same temperature profile according to Equation 7. However, between 532 nm to 808 nm, the locally strain engineered wrinkle samples gave rise to a higher temperature profile compared to the unstrained actuators. At the nanoscale, it is expected that the apex region of the wrinkle may enable higher temperature compared to flat surface. It is expected that thermal gradients exist between apex and base and heat is flowing from the apex to the base. The wrinkles have MoS2 layers partially directed with an angle to the surface of the polymer, which directs the generated heat of highly strained regions of the apex to the flat region, and to the polymer underneath.
Looking into the stress data further in Figure S5 (Suppl.), for instance, a photo-actuation of around 0.65 kPa for both flat and wrinkle actuators at 405 nm excitation wavelength will lead to a 2.2 °C temperature rise for ΔTu. This temperature rise is the uniformly distributed temperature, which is needed to generate an actuation of 0.65 kPa in heat-induced actuation. Using Equation 7 and the corresponding µ and σ values for these experiments, the equivalent temperature profile along the sample can be easily obtained. Table 1 lists the change in temperature values for wrinkle and flat samples at different excitation wavelengths at the center of samples (x = y = 0). The temperature profiles along the length of the samples are also depicted and compared for both wrinkle and flat photo-actuators. The wrinkled sample is predicted to give rise to a significantly increased temperature compared to their flat counterparts on photoactivation, resulting in improved mechanical response.
In this paper, we present a new effect called the straintronic-photothermal effect, which is the intimate coupling of strains, band gaps, optical absorption and photothermal response in 2H-MoS2 hyperelastic nanocomposites. Compared to applying globalized strains with a mechanical gadget, localized nanoscale strain engineering through strain transfer from a polymer or other means is highly desirable. While change in band gaps has been used to modulate electronic properties of devices, our results are the first application of band gap effects and straintronic effects in MoS2 for mechanical actuation. As the bandgap of 2H-MoS2 is decreased due to localized strains, the optical absorption and the thermal and mechanical response is enhanced. The localized strains were estimated in the wrinkles accurately through an analytical strain model for van der Waals packed films based on the original work by Vella et al.39. The strains from 100 wrinkles showed anywhere between 0.2–1.3% strains. This model is useful for quasi-continuous/nanoparticle films based on liquid exfoliated TMDs. The photoluminescence study shows that the direct electron transition is still dominant in local strain engineered few layer additives. The shift in the A exciton resonance peak by 30 meV is clear evidence of the mechanism that the strength of the A-exciton resonance is responsible for the overall chromatic mechanical effect. Straining the layers also increased the PL intensity suggesting strains have a direct effect on the band structure in 2H-MoS2. A new model that relates the purely thermal effect versus Gaussian photomechanical effect suggests that photomechanical actuation in TMD based nanocomposites is a chromatic thermal effect coupled to the optical absorption of the semiconductor under strains. The straintronic-photothermal effect only occurs at thickness below 100 nm, and therefore access to nanoscale property is necessary to see this effect. Above 100 nm, bulk behavior dominates, and thus this effect vanishes completely, and strain engineering has no effect on subsequent photo-thermal response.
Combining 2D nanomaterials with hyperelastic materials provides new opportunities in photo-thermal transducers due to the high strain energy densities, high elastic modulus, and enhanced light matter interactions in these materials. We believe that 2D TMD based nanocomposites are one of the few materials to show intrinsic chromatic mechanical response as well as well as a straintronic photomechanical response with tunability of stress due to change in band gap effects, all of which can be exploited for light driven transducers on the macroscopic, millimeter and microscopic scales. In the past, graphene based hyperelastic nanocomposites have shown tunable photo-thermal response43,44. However, they do not exhibit chromatic mechanical response. Compared to that, TMDs are exciting materials as they possess an intrinsic band gap at 1.8–1.9 eV, which is tunable with strains. While the wrinkles are not periodic in our study and the strain distribution is non-uniform, making the wrinkles periodic using chemical vapor deposition (CVD) of TMDs with precise control of number of layers and strain transfer can enable more repeatable wrinkled architectures for tunable photo-thermal actuation. Further, the thermal gradients between the apex and base of the wrinkles enables heat transfer into the polymer. One can also tune the thermal and mechanical response to larger wavelengths through traditional plasmonic architectures by coating the wrinkles with 10–30 nm noble metals, resulting in exciton-plasmon interactions that can also tune optical absorption and mechanical response. This new straintronic-photothermic effect in TMD nanocomposites will be useful for the future development of microscopic transducers based on light, flexible straintronic devices, optoelectronic and photovoltaic devices/skins, substrates for surface enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS), chem-biosensing and energy harvesting.
Material and Methods
Few-layer MoS2 nanoflakes dispersed in ethanol solution was purchased from Graphene Supermarket. The lateral size of flakes was 100–400 nm, according to the manufacturer. Standard vacuum filtration process was used to deposit thin films of MoS2 nanoflakes with different thicknesses of 25–35 nm and 60–70 nm on mixed cellulose membranes with 25 nm pore size (EMD Millipore VSWP04700). The vacuum filtration process self-regulates the deposition rate of nanoflakes on the filter membrane to produce an evenly distributed thin film of MoS2. The thin film of MoS2 was subsequently transferred to strained and non-strained Polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) substrate using an acetone bath that dissolved the overlaying filter membrane. PDMS silicone elastomer was obtained from Dow Corning (Sylgard 184). PDMS is a two part solvent-free flexible silicone organic polymer in the form of a base compound with a separate hydrosilane curing agent that acts as a cross-linker. The term cross-linking ratio refers to the ratio of PDMS cross-linker to the base compound. The PDMS base was mixed in 1:10 ratio to the cross-linker and then deposited on a glass slide. A standard spin coating process at 600 rpm for 30 seconds produces ~140 μm thick film of PDMS on the glass slides. The PDMS films are then cured at 120 °C for 20 minutes and post-cured for an additional 12 hours at room temperature before they were cut into 50 mm × 8 mm strips and installed in a hand-made setup for the transfer process under strain. After successfully transferring a thin and continuous film of MoS2 to the PDMS substrate, the strain is released, resulting in a wrinkled film of 2D material on top of elastomeric substrate.
HRTEM was conducted using an FEI Titan transmission microscope operating at 300 kV at Brookhaven National Laboratory. The sample was prepared by dropping one drop of exfoliated MoS2 in ethanol solution on lacey-carbon Cu grids (Ted Pella Inc., CA). The Cu grids were dried in air to make sure there are sufficient isolated flakes to be observed. SEM images were obtained using a JEOL JSM-7000F instrument at 4 kV of power and under an ultra-high vacuum, 10−5 Pa. Secondary electron detector was utilized at 10 mm working distance to capture high-resolution images of MoS2 features at magnifications as high as 100,000X. The AFM images were taken using a NaioAFM of Nanosurf in intermittent mode with a cantilever resonance frequency of ~148 kHz.
Raman and Photoluminescence Spectroscopy
The Raman measurements were performed by the excitation laser line of 532 nm using a Horiba XploRA Raman system in ambient air environment. The power of the excitation laser line was kept below 1 mW to avoid inducing any heating effects. The laser beam was focused onto the surface of the samples using a 100X objective lens. The photoluminescence measurements were conducted by a Horiba Multiline Raman Spectrometer LabRAM HR Evolution with a 100x objective lens, 600 gr/mm, and 1% ND filter with a 532 nm excitation laser and laser power of 0.2 mW to avoid any damages to the samples.
Resonant Raman Scattering and Raman Maps
Raman analysis and mapping was performed using a Renishaw inVia Raman microscope system, equipped with a multi-channel high-resolution Si-CCD camera. The measurements were performed in backscattering geometry, with a 632 nm He-Ne laser as the excitation source, and an optical filter with an incident power of ~1 mW. Raman mapping was carried out in a point-by- point mode, i.e. a full Raman spectrum was collected from each position in the selected area. The Raman maps were collected using an Leica microscope objective (50 X), and the laser spot focused on the sample to a diameter of ~1 µm. While a motorized stage moved the sample under the laser beam, spectra were successively acquired from the defined region of interest. The maps, acquired with the 1 µm step, from regions of 20 µm × 20 µm, consisted of 441 (=21 × 21) pixels. A full Raman spectrum was collected at each pixel and the data acquisition time for a typical map was ~16 hours. Such maps were then analyzed, and the desired spectral maps were generated. First, the curve fit parameters method based on a theoretical curve fitting was simultaneously employed to all 441 Raman spectra, and a full set of spectra parameters (peak intensities, peak widths, etc.) was calculated. Then, specific maps were generated by plotting the specific fitting parameters or their combinations, such as peak intensity ratios.
Stress and Bending Test Experiments
The stress test experiments were done using a self-made automatic photomechanical test assembly, as was reported earlier on14. The bending test samples consist of nanocomposites made of one 80-μm-thick PDMS layer and one 35-nm-MoS2 layer in wrinkled and flat structures. The nanocomposites were cut in 12 mm × 4 mm strip, and have been clamped in one end, as shown in Fig. 7. The clamping end was illuminated with different wavelengths of lasers with the same laser power of 30 mW. The displacement at the free end of the samples was measured using a high-speed MicroTrak II laser displacement sensor (LTC-025-02). A custom LabVIEW program was developed to control the test equipment and collect/monitor the experimental data acquisition. All experiments were conducted in a climate-controlled laboratory.
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Eisenbach, C. D. Isomerization of Aromatic Azo Chromophores in Poly(Ethyl Acrylate) Networks and Photomechanical Effect. Polymer 21, 1175–1179 (1980).
Hugel, T. et al. Single-molecule optomechanical cycle. Science 296, 1103–1106 (2002).
Ahir, S. V. & Terentjev, E. M. Photomechanical actuation in polymer-nanotube composites. Nature Materials 4, 491–495 (2005).
Loomis, J., King, B. & Panchapakesan, B. Layer dependent mechanical responses of graphene composites to near-infrared light. Applied Physics Letters 100, 073108 (2012).
Koerner, H., Price, G., Pearce, N. A., Alexander, M. & Vaia, R. A. Remotely actuated polymer nanocomposites - stress-recovery of carbon-nanotube-filled thermoplastic elastomers. Nature Materials 3, 115–120 (2004).
Liu, X. Y. et al. Reversible and Rapid Laser Actuation of Liquid Crystalline Elastomer Micropillars with Inclusion of Gold Nanoparticles. Advanced Functional Materials 25, 3022–3032 (2015).
Xiao, Z. W. et al. Shape Matters: A Gold Nanoparticle Enabled Shape Memory Polymer Triggered by Laser Irradiation. Particle & Particle Systems Characterization 30, 338–345 (2013).
Sun, X. M. et al. Unusual Reversible Photomechanical Actuation in Polymer/Nanotube Composites. Angewandte Chemie-International Edition 51, 8520–8524 (2012).
Lu, S. X. & Panchapakesan, B. Nanotube micro-optomechanical actuators. Applied Physics Letters 88 (2006).
Lu, S. X., Liu, Y., Shao, N. & Panchapakesan, B. Nanotube micro-opto-mechanical systems. Nanotechnology 18 (2007).
Lu, S. & Panchapakesan, B. All-optical micromirrors from nanotube MOMS with wavelength selectivity. Journal of Microelectromechanical Systems 16, 1515–1523 (2007).
Yamada, M. et al. Photomobile polymer materials: Towards light-driven plastic motors. Angewandte Chemie-International Edition 47, 4986–4988 (2008).
Zhang, X. et al. Photoactuators and motors based on carbon nanotubes with selective chirality distributions. Nature Communications 5 (2014).
Rahneshin, V., Khosravi, F., Ziolkowska, D. A., Jasinski, J. B. & Panchapakesan, B. Chromatic Mechanical Response in 2-D Layered Transition Metal Dichalcogenide (TMDs) based Nanocomposites. Scientific Reports 6 (2016).
Britnell, L. et al. Strong Light-Matter Interactions in Heterostructures of Atomically Thin Films. Science 340, 1311–1314 (2013).
Johari, P. & Shenoy, V. B. Tuning the Electronic Properties of Semiconducting Transition Metal Dichalcogenides by Applying Mechanical Strains. Acs Nano 6, 5449–5456 (2012).
He, X. et al. Strain engineering in monolayer WS2, MoS2, and the WS2/MoS2 heterostructure. Applied Physics Letters 109 (2016).
Lloyd, D. et al. Band Gap Engineering with Ultralarge Biaxial Strains in Suspended Monolayer MoS2. Nano Letters 16, 5836–5841 (2016).
Su, X. Y. et al. Bandgap engineering of MoS2/MX2 (MX2=WS2, MoSe2 and WSe2) heterobilayers subjected to biaxial strain and normal compressive strain. Rsc Advances 6, 18319–18325 (2016).
Conley, H. J. et al. Bandgap Engineering of Strained Monolayer and Bilayer MoS2. Nano Letters 13, 3626–3630 (2013).
Castellanos-Gomez, A. et al. Local Strain Engineering in Atomically Thin MoS2. Nano Letters 13, 5361–5366 (2013).
Ni, Z. H. et al. Uniaxial Strain on Graphene: Raman Spectroscopy Study and Band-Gap Opening. Acs Nano 2, 2301–2305 (2008).
Si, C., Liu, Z., Duan, W. H. & Liu, F. First-Principles Calculations on the Effect of Doping and Biaxial Tensile Strain on Electron-Phonon Coupling in Graphene. Physical Review Letters 111 (2013).
Mohiuddin, T. M. G. et al. Uniaxial strain in graphene by Raman spectroscopy: G peak splitting, Gruneisen parameters, and sample orientation. Physical Review B 79 (2009).
Yeh, N. C. et al. Strain-induced pseudo-magnetic fields and charging effects on CVD-grown graphene. Surface Science 605, 1649–1656 (2011).
MacLeod, J. M. & Rosei, F. Molecular Self-Assembly on Graphene. Small 10, 1038–1049 (2014).
Kou, L. Z., Du, A. J., Chen, C. F. & Frauenheim, T. Strain engineering of selective chemical adsorption on monolayer MoS2. Nanoscale 6, 5156–5161 (2014).
Bertolazzi, S., Brivio, J. & Kis, A. Stretching and Breaking of Ultrathin MoS2. Acs Nano 5, 9703–9709 (2011).
Griffith, A. A. The phenomenon of rupture and flow in solids. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of Lonon, Series A 221, 163–198 (1921).
Mak, K. F., Lee, C., Hone, J., Shan, J. & Heinz, T. F. Atomically Thin MoS2: A New Direct-Gap Semiconductor. Physical Review Letters 105 (2010).
Scalise, E., Houssa, M., Pourtois, G., Afanas’ev, V. V. & Stesmans, A. Strain-induced semiconductor to metal transition in the two-dimensional honeycomb structure of MoS2. Nano Research 5, 43–48 (2012).
Hui, Y. Y. et al. Exceptional Tunability of Band Energy in a Compressively Strained Trilayer MoS2 Sheet. Acs Nano 7, 7126–7131 (2013).
Plechinger, G. et al. Control of biaxial strain in single-layer molybdenite using local thermal expansion of the substrate. 2d Materials 2 (2015).
Li, H. et al. Optoelectronic crystal of artificial atoms in strain-textured molybdenum disulphide. Nature Communications 6 (2015).
Qin, X. R., Yang, D., Frindt, R. F. & Irwin, J. C. Real-Space Imaging of Single-Layer Mos2 by Scanning Tunneling Microscopy. Physical Review B 44, 3490–3493 (1991).
Young, P. A. Lattice parameter measurements on molybdenum disulphide. British Journal of Applied Physics (J. Phys. D) 1, 936–938 (1968).
Dickinson, R. G. & Pauling, L. Crystal Structure of Molybdenite. Journal of American Chemical Society 45, 1466–1471 (1923).
Splendiani, A. et al. Emerging Photoluminescence in Monolayer MoS2. Nano Letters 10, 1271–1275 (2010).
Vella, D., Bico, J., Boudaoud, A., Roman, B. & Reis, P. M. The macroscopic delamination of thin films from elastic substrates. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 106, 10901–10906 (2009).
Li, H. et al. From Bulk to Monolayer MoS2: Evolution of Raman Scattering. Advanced Functional Materials 22, 1385–1390 (2012).
Fan, X. M. et al. MoS2 actuators: reversible mechanical responses of MoS2-polymer nanocomposites to photons. Nanotechnology 26 (2015).
Loomis, J. et al. Graphene/elastomer composite-based photo-thermal nanopositioners. Scientific Reports 3 (2013).
Loomis, J. et al. Graphene-nanoplatelet-based photomechanical actuators. Nanotechnology 23 (2012).
Loomis, J., King, B. & Panchapakesan, B. Layer dependent mechanical responses of graphene composites to near-infrared light. Applied Physics Letters 100 (2012).
This work was supported partially by the following grants from the US National Science Foundation (CMMI: 1463869, ECCS: 1463987 and DMR: 1410678) for B.P. DAZ and JBJ acknowledge the Conn Center for Renewable Energy Research and funding from the US National Science Foundation EPSCoR Program (sub-award no. 3048111570-15-016). DAZ acknowledges the support from the Mobility Plus Program funded by the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Poland. The authors would like to thank Drs Dmitri Zakharov and Eric Stach for the assistance with TEM imaging.