Explanations of the Classic Maya civilization demise on the Yucatán Peninsula during the Terminal Classic Period (TCP; ~CE 750–1050) are controversial. Multiyear droughts are one likely cause, but the role of the Caribbean Sea, the dominant moisture source for Mesoamerica, remains largely unknown. Here we present bimonthly-resolved snapshots of reconstructed sea surface temperature (SST) and salinity (SSS) variability in the southern Caribbean from precisely dated fossil corals. The results indicate pronounced interannual to decadal SST and SSS variability during the TCP, which may be temporally coherent to precipitation anomalies on the Yucatán. Our results are best explained by changed Caribbean SST gradients affecting the Caribbean low-level atmospheric jet with consequences for Mesoamerican precipitation, which are possibly linked to changes in Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation strength. Our findings provide a new perspective on the anomalous hydrological changes during the TCP that complement the oft-suggested southward displacement of the Intertropical Convergence Zone. We advocate for a strong role of Caribbean SST and SSS condition changes and related ocean-atmosphere interactions that notably influenced the propagation and transport of precipitation to the Yucatán Peninsula during the TCP.
Numerous Classic Maya population centres and political systems on the Yucatán Peninsula disintegrated during the Terminal Classic Period (TCP; CE 750–1050)1,2. Spatially and temporally varying palaeoclimate evidence suggests significant changes in precipitation and hydrology from interannual2,3 to multidecadal3,4,5,6,7,8 timescales during the TCP. However, even with the accumulating climate evidence, researchers are reluctant to assign droughts as the main culprit of demise1,9 due to the oversimplification of various interacting factors. What researchers do sufficiently agree on are the complexities and multi-causality aspects of disintegration ranging from differences in geological and land-use features to social dynamics9,10,11. In addition, the potential to accelerate civil unrest and human conflict due to changes in climate12 may further amplify degradations in agriculture production, productivity, and population decline feedback9,10. Nevertheless, the strong interrelationship evidence between climate records and Maya settlement abandonment and political disintegration2,12 suggests a very powerful connection.
Current discussions surrounding potential climatic influence during the TCP invoke a southward displacement of the summer position of the Intertropical Convergence Zone (ITCZ)5 resulting in pronounced drier conditions across the Maya lowlands2,5. However, the mounting evidence of TCP climate change is exclusively based on terrestrial proxy records of summer precipitation2,3,4,5,6,7,8,13,14, which in part show obvious differences and are often attributed to dating uncertainties and regional climate variability1,2,3,6,7,8 (Figs 1 and 2, and S1). Still ambiguous for the TCP is the influence of the tropical Caribbean Sea, which is known to be an important mediator of Central American and Caribbean climate on seasonal and interannual to decadal timescales15,16,17,18. Understanding the changes in Caribbean sea surface conditions during the TCP on these timescales of relevance to the Maya collapse is particularly important because it is the main atmospheric moisture supply of Central America15. Clearly, palaeoceanographic records resolving interannual to decadal sea surface conditions in the Caribbean Sea during the TCP are essential to enhance our understanding of the underlying mechanisms that resulted in the hydrological changes over Yucatán Peninsula during this key time period in human history.
Here we present snapshots of reconstructed variability in sea surface conditions during the TCP from bimonthly-resolved δ18O and Sr/Ca records of southern Caribbean fossil corals from Bonaire. The climate of Bonaire is influenced by the trade winds and the westward flowing Caribbean Current that is a part of the northward-flowing surface conduit of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC)19. Modelling studies identified the southern Caribbean Sea as a region of strong SST and SSS response in simulations of AMOC slowdown on millennial timescales20,21. Precipitation at Bonaire is characterized by the main rainy season from October to January and a midsummer ‘drought’22,23. This indicates that Bonaire is not influenced by the seasonally migrating ITCZ, because the northernmost ITCZ position that is reached during boreal summer is located south of Bonaire. In contrast, precipitation in the Caribbean Sea and Mesoamerica has been shown to be primarily driven by the changing strength of the Caribbean Low Level Jet (CLLJ)17,22,24,25,26. The CLLJ is a maximum easterly zonal wind (greater than 13 m s−1) observed in the lower troposphere (~925 hPa) as an extension of the Atlantic trade winds propagating atmospheric moisture across this region (Fig. 1).
Modern calibration studies of the Caribbean and Atlantic coral Orbicella annularis sensu lato (Orbicella annularis ‘species complex’) have demonstrated the applicability of the Sr/Ca and δ18O values to record sea surface temperature (SST) variability27,28,29,30. Because coral δ18O reflects a combination of SST and the ambient δ18O of seawater (δ18Osw), the combination of both δ18O and Sr/Ca facilitate the reconstruction of δ18Osw by removal of the coevolving temperature component31,32. Moreover, the variability of δ18Osw has been shown to be linearly related to sea surface salinity (SSS) in the Caribbean33. Thus, our results derived from fossil corals of Bonaire can be used to discuss the crucial role of large-scale ocean circulation and Caribbean Sea ocean-atmospheric interaction processes in modulating moisture transport and hydrological cycle changes of Mesoamerica during the TCP. As evidence indicating dry conditions on the Maya Lowlands of Mesoamerica continues to build, ocean circulation and ocean-atmospheric interaction processes have often been overlooked that likely complement the often-suggested southward displacement of the ITCZ2,5.
Our reconstruction of southern Caribbean Sea surface conditions variability is based on the analysis of coral cores collected at Bonaire (12°N, 68°W; Fig. 1). Fossil coral skeletal preservation analyses by x-radiograph imaging (Fig. S2), powder x-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis (Table 1), and thin-section microscopy (Fig. S3) are prerequisites for palaeoclimate reconstructions with fossil corals from any region34,35,36,37 and indicate excellent aragonite preservation. XRD results are all well within the limit of minor alteration in fossil corals for palaeoclimate studies from the undetectable to less than 2% calcite (Table 1). Verification of the fossil corals’ suitability for palaeoclimate research by representative thin-section analyses indicate excellent preservation of primary porosity, clear dissepiments, and well-defined centres of calcification with no evidence of secondary aragonite or calcite cements near regions of micro-sampling (Figs S2 and S3).
The fossil coral 230Th/U-ages with corresponding 2σ-uncertainty range from CE 865 ± 8 years to CE 956 ± 8 years (Table 2) places the entire coral collection precisely in the TCP (Fig. 2 and S1). Due to inter-colony offsets in mean Sr/Ca and δ18O (Table 1), all bimonthly-resolved coral records are reported as anomalies (departures from the mean monthly climatology) over each individual record to facilitate comparison (Fig. 3). The mean propagated Sr/Ca-SST reconstruction (relative SST) uncertainty of all individual corals is ±1.0 °C (1σ) incorporating the analytical and Sr/Ca-SST calibration errors38 (Fig. S4). The propagated uncertainty of reconstructed δ18Osw (±0.16‰; 1σ)38 is smaller compared to published studies from the Caribbean39 (Fig. S4). Furthermore, bimonthly-resolved records (Sr/Ca, δ18O, and δ18Osw) from Bonaire fossil corals reveal significant variance at interannual timescales and enhanced variance at decadal timescales (Figs S4 and S5).
Based on the location of the 230Th/U-dating sampling (Fig. S2) and our internal chronology calculations (Table 1), possible overlapping time windows exist between the fossil coral collection. Two possible minor overlapping time windows exist with either 2–3 or 6–7 years of overlap when the ages are set at the extremes of the 2σ 230Th/U-dating uncertainty. This thus only accounts for < 2–8% of overlap when merged (Fig. S6). It is therefore inappropriate to splice together these very short overlapping time windows at either annual or interannual resolution with insignificant overlap within the 2σ-age uncertainties. However, when shifted towards the other end of the extremes of the 2σ-age uncertainties, we acknowledge the lack of flawless ‘match’ between individual proxy records (Fig. S6). Coral vital or calcification effects can be ruled out for the apparently imperfect ‘splicing’ of these records because the corresponding δ13C and growth rate records do not show suspicious shifts or jumps (not shown), and the growth rates of all TCP colonies of >9 mm per year are relatively high (Table 1). Due to these limitations, we consider the presentation as individual coral time windows and not as spliced records to be the most accurate representation of our results that minimizes the inherent age-errors.
Over a recent 42-year period, CE 1923–1965, the interannual to decadal variations in the Hadley Centre SST anomaly record40 for the 1° by 1° grid over Bonaire (11.5°N, 67.5°W) agree well with the Sr/Ca-derived SST anomaly record overlapping the sub-modern coral (CE 1945 ± 7 years; Fig. 3). Even though the full magnitude of the sub-modern coral-derived SST anomaly slightly overestimates the instrumental record based on the previously published calibrations, the close agreement between the sub-modern coral and gridded instrumental SST anomaly records indicates that the reconstruction of relative SST changes on interannual to decadal timescales during the TCP is possible from our fossil Bonaire corals using the sub-modern coral as benchmark. We note that the maximum magnitude of interannual to decadal variability in the instrumental SST anomaly record40 is ±0.6 °C, which is less than the ±1.4 °C maximum interannual to decadal oscillation magnitude of the coral Sr/Ca-derived SST anomaly record of the entire fossil coral collection (Figs 3 and 4).
The inferred changes of SSS from the reconstructed δ18Osw indicate pronounced high-amplitude interannual to decadal variability of SSS during the TCP that are concomitant to those of SST (Fig. 4). This interannual to decadal-scale change of 0.63‰ during the TCP is twice the magnitude of the subtle variability from sub-modern coral condition (0.32‰). Based on modern calibrations of northern Caribbean Orbicella spp. linear SSS-δ18Osw relationship of 0.20‰ per psu33, the interannual to decadal SSS variability during the TCP is appreciably elevated by at least 1.5 psu compared to the early twentieth century (Figs 3 and 4). Unfortunately, continuous and replicable modern instrumental SSS datasets going back to the 1940s are not currently available41,42 for verification against our sub-modern coral-based reconstruction (Fig. S7). Differences between individual gridded instrumental datasets (Fig. S7) can produce a difference of up to 1.3 psu (e.g. September 1989) equating to a 0.26‰ change in Caribbean Orbicella spp. coral reconstructed δ18Osw based on Orbicella sp. SSS-δ18Osw relationship33 hindering our ability for a thorough calibration and validation. These larger instrumental differences than our propagated δ18Osw uncertainty of the Bonaire fossil corals (±0.25‰)(Figs 3 and 4) validates the ability of corals to accurately record the possible magnitude and range of local SSS change. The pronounced oscillations in δ18Osw and intense decadal-scale climate trends during the TCP that are significantly larger than the modern baseline record exemplifies the peculiar climate differences from ~1100 years ago. Moreover, the reconstructed δ18Osw variability around CE 872 and CE 956 is also the largest observed since the mid-Holocene43 showing the intriguing perturbations of climate during the TCP.
Our most striking find is that the Bonaire coral records indicate a stronger interannual to decadal variability of SST and especially SSS in the southern Caribbean Sea during the TCP compared to the modern baseline (Figs 3 and 4). Importantly, the coral records of ~CE 865, ~CE 872, and ~CE 956 indicate periods of significant anomalously high SST and SSS on these timescales that may be considered as temporally coherent to the TCP precipitation anomalies (droughts and decreased rainfall) in the Yucatán documented by a Belize speleothem record2 (Fig. 4). These periods of SSS extremes on interannual to decadal timescales are accompanied by anomalously high SST (corals ~CE 865, ~CE 872, and ~CE 956). Moreover, instances of significant coherence (r = 0.70–0.72; P < 0.001) are observed with long-term secular freshening trends in the southern Caribbean (~CE 865 and ~CE 956) corresponding to increasing precipitation in Belize following the drought periods of ~CE 850 and ~CE 955 (Fig. 4).
Importantly, the pronounced interannual to decadal δ18Osw, therefore SSS, perturbations in the southern Caribbean Sea during the TCP indicated by the coral records cannot be explained by local ITCZ-related precipitation changes because Cariaco Basin sediments suggest that the mean northernmost position of the summer ITCZ during the TCP was similar to today5,44, i.e., located south of Bonaire over the South American continent. This is consistent with coral evidence suggesting that ITCZ-related summer precipitation at Bonaire has not occurred since the mid-Holocene43. Furthermore, we can exclude an advected ITCZ-related summer precipitation signal from the Orinoco River as the Orinoco plume exhibits a maximum trajectory towards the northern Caribbean45,46 spreading minimally into our research area today. We therefore conclude that the pronounced changes in southern Caribbean SSS during the TCP are not the result of local summer precipitation changes. Alternatively, we suggest that large-scale ocean circulation processes may be the potential driver of the anomalously pronounced interannual to decadal SSS and concomitant SST variations in the southern Caribbean Sea during the TCP.
Modelling studies identified the southern Caribbean Sea as a region of strong SST and SSS response in simulations of AMOC slowdown on millennial timescales20,21. Interestingly, our reconstructed interannual to decadal anomalies of concomitant high SSS and high SST that are potentially linked to the Yucatán precipitation anomalies of the TCP have the same sign as the southern Caribbean SSS and SST response to a weakened AMOC in simulations mimicking the Younger Dryas event20,21 (Fig. 5). Although changes in AMOC strength over time has frequently been attributed in causing millennial-scale climate perturbations in the Atlantic region47, the behaviour of this large-scale ocean current system over interannual to decadal timescales remains uncertain48. We speculate that our reconstructed interannual to decadal periods of anomalously high SSS and high SST in the southern Caribbean are possibly due to a weakened AMOC on these timescales. The potential for decadal to multidecadal changes in AMOC strength is evident from modelling studies48,49 and modern observations50,51, providing support for our hypothesis of a potentially enhanced interannual to decadal variability of the AMOC during the TCP.
Interestingly, in the above mentioned model simulations20,21, AMOC weakening on millennial timescales results in a narrow strip of anomalously warmer surface water that appears off the northern coast of South America, extending into the Southern Caribbean (Fig. 5). This warming is surrounded by wide spread surface cooling of the North Atlantic, with the latter representing the well-known response in simulations of a weakened AMOC20,21. Importantly, the weakened AMOC induces strong meridional SST gradient anomalies in the Caribbean Sea with warmer SST at Bonaire and cooler SST in the north (Fig. 5)20. Modern Caribbean Sea SST anomalies52 also indicate a robust relationship to regional precipitation53 over the entire southern Caribbean Sea (Fig. S8). This contrast in Caribbean SST (strong meridional SST gradient) in turn leads to the changing strength of the CLLJ24,54. These geostrophic relationships of the ocean and atmosphere suggest an intense dynamic feedback, which reinforces the strength and condition of the CLLJ24,55.
An increased CLLJ strength can significantly impact the propagation of atmospheric moisture for rainfall over Mesoamerica and the greater Caribbean region by suppressing deep convection due to high vertical wind shear24,55,56. Moreover, modern reanalysis studies have linked anomalous Mesoamerican droughts throughout the last century to decreased tropical convection resulting from decreased easterly waves due to strengthened CLLJ56. These results indicate that the CLLJ is a major contributor to droughts and precipitation anomalies over the recent centuries57 by changes in the moisture flux divergence in the Caribbean. Changes in CLLJ strength over Bonaire and the Caribbean Sea from modern reanalysis also reveal synchronous significant coherence to precipitation on the Yucatán Peninsula (Fig. S8). The amount of precipitation recorded on the Yucatán Peninsula is directly related to the increase or decrease in east to west winds at Bonaire (Fig. S8). This process demonstrates the possible extremes in anomalous precipitation events during the TCP due to the movement of precipitation from the Caribbean Sea based on CLLJ strength (Fig. S8).
However, geographical differences contributing to anomalous precipitation occurrences in Mesoamerica can and do occur55. Observational studies of the CLLJ have shown both enhanced and decreased rainfall across Mesoamerica due to orographic enhancement with difference ranging from the north to the south and from the Pacific to the Caribbean coasts55,58. Importantly, these modern differences of the CLLJ can potentially explain the obvious differences in palaeo-observations1,2,3,6,7,8 during the TCP that has not been previously investigated. Therefore, it is apparent that not a single major drought event (or several drought events) impacted the entire Yucatán Peninsula at the same time but rather a series of high amplitude hydroclimatic changes on interannual to decadal timescales, which affected different areas of the Maya Lowlands in different ways. Thus, we suggest that the physical mechanism that connects the pronounced interannual to decadal SST and SSS variability in the southern Caribbean Sea with the Yucatán precipitation anomalies of the TCP involves changes in the meridional gradient of Caribbean SST leading to changes in the strength of the CLLJ that controls the propagation or suppression of atmospheric moisture towards the Yucatán Peninsula.
Our results may be reconciled with summer precipitation reconstruction studies that invoke the southward excursion of the ITCZ2,5 during the TCP, because one prominent outcome in modelling studies of AMOC slowdown is the anomalous southern position of the ITCZ59,60. We do not rule out the temporary southward excursion of the ITCZ over this region, but rather suggest that it cannot be the simple sole mechanism for explaining the observed hydrological anomalies of the Yucatán Peninsula during the TCP. For example, exacerbating the negative rainfall anomalies over Mesoamerica during the TCP may include the influence of El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO) warm events that are linked to times of stronger CLLJ24. Interestingly, fossil coral spectral analysis results indicate the presence of significant periods between 5.7–6.6 years in both Sr/Ca and δ18O variability (Fig. S5) with the 5.7 years period identified as the most prominent variability in the cospectrum of ENSO and the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO)61. Thus, the combined ENSO-NAO interactions as indicated by the prominent 5–6 year oscillation61 in the Bonaire coral records suggest NAO-ENSO teleconnections were probably impacting SST and SSS variability in the Caribbean region during the TCP, similar to today62.
Our findings provide evidence for anomalously strong interannual to decadal SSS and SST variability in the Caribbean Sea during the TCP, a time interval known for the decline of the Classic Maya civilization on the Yucatán Peninsula. We find that extremes of SSS and SST in the southern Caribbean on these timescales can be considered to coincide with prominent precipitation anomaly events of the TCP in the Yucatán. The concomitant SSS and SST variations on interannual to decadal timescales reflect ocean circulation processes, which may be fundamentally linked to an enhanced variability of the AMOC at that time. We suggest that changes in the Caribbean meridional SST gradient and associated changes in the strength of the Caribbean low-level atmospheric jet that significantly controls the moisture transport from the Caribbean Sea to Mesoamerica22,24 provide a physical mechanism linking the anomalous interannual to decadal variability of SSS and SST in the southern Caribbean and of precipitation in the Yucatán during the TCP. Our results advocate for a strong role for regional ocean-atmosphere interactions, and provide a new perspective on the hydrological changes in the Yucatán during the TCP that is an addition to the oft-suggested southward displacement of the ITCZ2,5 at that time.
Coral Sampling and Background
Six large fossil coral boulders were cored from coastal deposits at the northwestern shore of Bonaire (Netherlands Antilles; 12.13°N, 68.23°W; Fig. 1). These coral boulders were most likely deposited by extreme wave events such as palaeo-tsunamis or severe storms63,64. Previous study discuss in detail the location and coral core extraction methods36. Additionally, one sub-modern coral colony (42 years of growth) was collected for calibration purposes. Bonaire is located ~100 km north of the Venezuelan coastline and ~400 km northwest of Cariaco Basin in the Caribbean Sea experiencing open-ocean conditions as part of the Leeward Antilles. A total of 5.1 meters of coral cores were retrieved and cut following previously detailed coral core extraction and slabbing methods36,43.
The coral colonies were determined to be Orbicella annularis sensu lato (O. annularis ‘species complex’) after examination of the outer corallite shape and growth architecture by x-radiographs (Fig. S2) and thin-sections (Fig. S3). The O. annularis ‘species complex’ representation contains the three cryptic Atlantic Orbicella species (O. annularis sensu stricto, O. faveolata, O. franksi). These Atlantic corals have recently been revised from the genus Montastraea to the genus Orbicella 65.
Coral δ18O and Sr/Ca analyses
All Bonaire coral cores were prepared for micro-sampling and sampled under the same conditions. Coral powder samples were acquired sequentially at 1 mm intervals using a micro-drill with a 0.8 mm steel drill bit at ~1 mm depth along the fastest growing axis. The samples were analysed for stable isotope and Sr/Ca measurements following previously described methods34,35,36,43 with the same accuracy and precision. Homogenized skeletal powder samples were split into aliquots for δ18O and Sr/Ca analyses at MARUM-Center for Marine Environmental Sciences, University of Bremen, Germany following previously described methods34,35,36,43,66. Briefly, δ18O values were measured on a Finnigan MAT 251 mass spectrometer with replicate measurements of an internal carbonate standard (Solnhofen Limestone calibrated against NBS-19) better than ±0.07‰ VPDB (1σ)66. δ18O measurements for colonies age CE 1945 ± 7 years, CE 947 ± 9 years, and CE 944 ± 13 years were completed at 1 mm resolution. The colonies with age of CE 956 ± 8 years, CE 874 ± 8 years, CE 872 ± 9 years, and CE 865 ± 8 years were analysed at every-other mm. All measurements were completed to retain at a minimum of 6 samples per year between each density banding pairs.
Sr/Ca analyses for all coral colonies were analysed at every 1 mm resolution on an Agilent 720 series simultaneous axial inductively coupled plasma–optical emission spectrophotometer (ICP-OES) at MARUM. Repeated measurements of a laboratory coral standard with a set Ca concentration allowed for offline instrumental drift correction and yielded Sr/Ca ratios of 8.6–10 mmol mol−1. Relative standard deviation of the entire Sr/Ca analyses was better than 0.2%. 86 aliquots of a Porites coral powder reference material, JCp-167 were analysed as samples with an average Sr/Ca of 8.916 ± 0.019 mmol mol−1 (1σ) obtained during the course of this study.
X-radiographs of the slabs reveal clear annual-density banding patterns, the growth geometry, and guided the micro-sampling tracks (Fig. S2). The internal age chronology of each individual coral colony was developed following a combination of the depths of annual skeletal density banding from the x-radiographs (Fig. S2) and timing of sub-seasonal δ18O and Sr/Ca variability. Since the TCP fossil corals’ internal ages span across a range (32 to 71 years) and contain an average time-window growth length of 44 years, this 42-year sub-modern coral is an adequate representative analogue snapshot of modern southern Caribbean Sea baseline conditions. This typical average 40-year window is also the commonly applied length using sub-modern corals for calibration to reconstruct climate from fossil corals68,69.
Fossil coral skeletal preservation
Subsamples from every individual coral colony were removed close to the micro-sampling transects for fossil coral skeletal preservation analyses (Figs S2–S3). Obvious anomalous density patches on the top and bottom sections of each coral colony that are typical of diagenetic alterations were omitted in the micro-sampling procedure. Prerequisites for palaeoclimatic work on any fossil corals34,35,36,37 include the examination of coral skeletal material by x-radiograph imaging (Fig. S2), powder XRD analysis (Table 1), and thin-section microscopy (Fig. S3), showing good preservation. Powder XRD results in the vicinity of the sampling transects are all within the limit of minor alteration in fossil corals for palaeoclimate studies34,35,36,37 using previously described methods70,71 (Table 1). XRD analyses of the fossil corals revealed pristine or ‘excellent’ preservation with 100% aragonite content for four of the seven colonies (including the sub-modern colony). Two colonies contain calcite content that were ≤1% calcite. The colonies containing less than 1% calcite are considered to be “good” preservation. Calcite content at less than 2% was found in the oldest fossil colony and is considered as “fair” preservation.
Because the presence of secondary (inorganic) aragonite cannot be detected by XRD, petrographic thin-sections were produced. The thin-sections indicate excellent skeletal preservation of primary porosity, clear dissepiments, and well-defined centres of calcification72 with no evidence of secondary aragonite overgrowth and without obvious signs of calcite cements near regions of micro-sampling (Fig. S3). A few sections of Sr/Ca values were omitted in the final analysis, discussion, and reconstruction of δ18Osw variability based on possible subtle subaerial diagenesis73 that could not be detected by our thorough examination. Observation of depleted Sr/Ca and enriched Mg/Ca values in the record indicate subtle calcite presence without any systematic impact on coral δ18O values73,74.
Bulk samples for 230Th/U-age determination were removed near the sampling transects (Fig. S2). Due to sample size requirement for analysis, the samples contained between 1 and less than 3 years of coral growth. The sample preparation and 230Th/U-age determination followed established methodology75. 230Th/U-dating for the TCP fossil colonies was performed by multi-collector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (MC-ICPMS) at the Max Planck Institute for Chemistry, Mainz, Germany. Analytical MC-ICPMS procedures involve a standard-sample bracketing procedure to derive correction factors for mass fractionation and Faraday cup to ion counter gain76,77. A detailed description of the calibration of the utilized mixed 233U-236U-229Th spike is given elsewhere78. The sub-modern coral from the last century was dated by thermal ionization mass spectrometry (TIMS) 230Th/U-dating with a MAT 262 RPQ TIMS at the Heidelberg Academy of Sciences, Germany, using the double filament technique following previously described sample preparation and analytical procedures79.
All activity ratios were calculated using the decay constants of ref.80 and corrected for detrital Th assuming a bulk Earth 232Th/238U weight ratio of 3.8 for the detritus and 230Th, 234U and 238U in secular equilibrium. The initial (234U/238U) activity ratios of all samples are in agreement with the initial (234U/238U) activity ratio of the modern coral (Table 2). All criteria for the reliability of fossil coral 230Th/U-ages71,81 are fulfilled and all ages presented herein are considered reliable within their 2σ-error or 95% Confidence Interval (Table 2). Our 230Th/U-ages place the entire coral collection precisely in the TCP (Fig. 2 and S1–S2).
Fossil coral chronology development
The internal age chronology of each individual coral colony was developed using a combination of the depths of annual skeletal density banding from the x-radiographs and the timing of sub-seasonal δ18O and Sr/Ca variability. We concluded that high-density bandings were secreted in the warmest times of each year (September/October) coinciding with minimums in sub-seasonal δ18O and Sr/Ca variability. Thus, annual maximum Sr/Ca was set to March (average month of lowest SST) and annual minimum Sr/Ca was set to September (average month of highest SST). Sub-seasonal age estimates were then linearly interpolated into 6-points per year (bimonthly resolution) based on the δ18O and Sr/Ca results using the ARAND software package82.
Bonaire coral-derived SST and δ18Osw calculations
Sr/Ca ratios in modern Caribbean and Atlantic Orbicella spp. corals have been shown to represent SST variability over multiple timescales without a salinity effect (Table S1). For the calibration of the Sr/Ca records to SST, we use the most conservative, growth-corrected value (−0.092 mmol mol−1 °C−1; ref.30) from a range of published Sr/Ca-SST relationships in literature (Figs 3 and 4; Fig. S4; Table S1). We chose this Sr/Ca-SST calibration slope after considering multiple calibration slopes and sensitivities with this type of coral (Fig. S4 and Table S1). The larger SST calibration slope is considered to be more robust and more appropriate for the examination of mean-state, interannual, and decadal variability in coral-based palaeoclimate studies83,84,85. As demonstrated by the range of published Sr/Ca-SST calibration relationships due to sampling resolution differences, the relative magnitude and scaling of both SST and δ18Osw reconstructions are reshaped but the procedure does not change the overall reconstructed trends of each record (Fig. 3 and S4). The result ranges from the conservative ~1 °C30 to the inconceivable ~9 °C86 (Fig. S4).
The δ18O-SST transfer function of −0.22% °C−1 (ref.29) was chosen for this study because Atlantic and Caribbean Orbicella spp. studies sampled under various resolutions are able to achieve similar calibration results (Table S2). Furthermore, lower sampling resolution has been shown to be just as efficient as higher sampling resolutions with similar δ18O to SST calibration relationships29,33. A Orbicella spp. study29 also suggested that the strategy of using a lower sampling resolution for corals from regions with a restricted annual temperature range such as Bonaire is less likely to experience sampling resolution issues. Moreover, another Caribbean Orbicella spp. study has demonstrated that the annual averages of δ18O obtained from adjusting sampling resolution between six to forty samples per year remained the same for corals living in a restricted temperature range33.
We calculated the instantaneous bimonthly δ18Osw values following accepted methods31,32. In principal, these two essentially identical δ18Osw calculation methods require the transfer functions of both δ18O-SST (−0.22‰ °C−1; ref.29) and Sr/Ca-SST (−0.092 mmol mol−1 °C−1; ref.30). This enable straightforward reconstruction of δ18Osw values using the combination of our fossil coral δ18O and Sr/Ca values32,43,83. Combined analytical uncertainties and compounding errors associated with the various Sr/Ca-SST transfer functions were calculated for both Sr/Ca-derived SST and the reconstructed δ18Osw 38 shown as grey error envelops (Fig. S4). Mean propagated Sr/Ca-SST reconstruction uncertainty of all fossil corals is ±1.5 °C (1σ) and the propagated uncertainty of reconstructed δ18Osw is ±0.25‰ (1σ) (Fig. S4). To be conservative and cautious with our δ18Osw reconstructions, we limit our discussion of Caribbean TCP climate to interannual to decadal variability because the reliability of our δ18Osw reconstruction is most sensitive and dependent on the choice of Orbicella spp. Sr/Ca-SST relationship. Portions of Sr/Ca record from the tops and bottoms of the corals were not used for palaeoclimate reconstruction due to subtle subaerial diagenesis that did not impact δ18O values73,74.
Due to inter-colony offsets and to facilitate comparison, we report coral geochemical records as anomalies based on the departures from the bimonthly mean for the entirety of each individual coral. To highlight the interannual and longer-term lower frequency variability, we applied a 5-year smoothing to the coral δ18O, Sr/Ca, and δ18Osw records (Figs 3 and 4; Fig. S4). Multi-Taper Method (MTM) spectral analysis87 was also completed for all records. The significance was determined relative to a red noise null hypothesis determined with the robust method of noise background estimation88 with mean seasonal cycles removed to estimate the power spectrum of each record (tapers of 3 and resolution of 2; Fig. S5).
The Bonaire fossil coral data reported in this paper has been deposited at the information system PANGAEA (Data Publisher for Earth and Environmental Science; https://doi.pangaea.de/10.1594/PANGAEA.829390).
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
The Government of the Island Territory of Bonaire of the former Netherlands Antilles (now the Caribbean Netherlands) is thanked for research and fieldwork permissions, and E. Beukenboom (STINAPA Bonaire National Parks Foundation) for support. Funding was provided by Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft through DFG-Research Center/Cluster of Excellence “The Ocean in the Earth System” at University of Bremen to T.F. and H.C.W. (MARUM Fellowship and MARUM Incentive Funds with T.F.). T.F. was partly supported by DFG under the Priority Programme INTERDYNAMIK (SPP 1266; CaribClim Project). D.S. is thankful for funding from the Earth System Research Center Geocycles and the DFG (SCHO 1274/9-1). We thank J. Pätzold for logistical assistance; M. Segl, S. Pape, and C. Vogt for analytical support.