The proof of target engagement (TE) is a key element for evaluating potential investment in drug development. The cellular thermal shift assay (CETSA) is expected to facilitate direct measurement of intracellular TE at all stages of drug development. However, there have been no reports of applying this technology to comprehensive animal and clinical studies. This report demonstrates that CETSA can not only quantitatively evaluate the drug-TE in mouse peripheral blood, but also confirm TE in animal tissues exemplified by using the receptor interacting protein 1 kinase (RIPK1) lead compound we have developed. Our established semi-automated system allows evaluation of the structure-activity relationship using native RIPK1 in culture cell lines, and also enables estimation of drug occupancy ratio in mouse peripheral blood mononuclear cells. Moreover, optimized tissue homogenisation enables monitoring of the in vivo drug-TE in spleen and brain. Our results indicate that CETSA methodology will provide an efficient tool for preclinical and clinical drug development.
A large number of drug candidates have failed in clinical trials because of not only lack of efficacy but also non-verification of the predicted pharmacological mechanism of action due to insufficient interpretation of fundamental pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic principles, target engagement (TE), and expression of functional pharmacological activity1,2. TE is one of the key elements to reduce the high failure rates in clinical trials3. Therefore, robustness of the measurements of drug TE from the initial stage of drug discovery through to clinical development can provide a breakthrough for drug development.
The cellular thermal shift assay (CETSA) has recently been reported to monitor the binding of ligand to its target protein in cells and tissue samples. This method is based on the ligand-induced changes in protein thermal stability4,5,6. In pre-clinical and clinical stages, there are several kinds of TE assays, including prediction of potency based on compound concentration in tissue7, use of tracer molecules such as positron emission tomography (PET)8,9, and detection of substrate in the target compartment7. Compared with existing methods, CETSA has the capability to evaluate biophysical binding under physiological and pathological conditions without any special experimental tools. Therefore, this technology is expected to be applied to many stages of drug development. During the initial stages of CETSA application, much work has focused on TE experiments in cultured cells and verified the applicability to a variety of target families. However, there are only a few reports evaluating CETSA technology in animal and clinical studies. In the first of these, Molina et al. demonstrated in vivo TE with TNP-470 which is a covalent inhibitor against methionine aminopeptidase-26. Another group demonstrated qualitative TE in a xenograft model using Michael acceptor inhibitor10. However, covalent drugs are rarely considered in target-directed drug discovery owing to safety concerns11. With regards to TE of a non-covalent compound using intact tissues, one group applied this technology to investigate histone deacetylase isoform selectivity of a compound with human brain homogenate12. Under these situations, one of the present challenges for CETSA technology is to quantitatively demonstrate TE in in vivo tissue with non-covalent compounds. To achieve this goal, maintaining compound concentrations in vivo is a key factor because reversible compounds leave the target protein when the concentration is less than the binding affinity between the compound and the target through the sample preparation processes. Therefore, it is necessary for the performance of challenges to establish the procedures for both tissue excision and sample preparation until the transient heating step.
Receptor interacting protein 1 kinase (RIPK1) is a key mediator of not only a process of regulated necrosis, termed necroptosis, but also promotion of caspase-8-dependent apoptosis and pro-inflammatory gene expression13. Based on kinase-dead knock-in RIPK1 mice and highly selective allosteric Type 3 RIPK1 inhibitors (necrostatin-1 [Nec-1] and optimized analogue Nec-1s)14,15, RIPK1 is implicated in a variety of human diseases, such as ischemia-reperfusion injury in the brain16, heart17, and kidney18, acute and chronic inflammatory diseases19, multiple sclerosis (MS)20, and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis21. Recently, our group has developed a reversible, highly potent lead compound 22, with high kinase-selectivity and excellent pharmacokinetics22. After oral administration of this compound to mice, the unbound concentrations in spleen and brain are sufficient to show in vivo inhibition of mouse endogenous RIPK1. In fact, this compound exhibits activity in an experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) model22, which is the most commonly used experimental model for MS23. Since MS is the prototypical inflammatory demyelinating disease of the central nervous system, these results suggest that compound 22 might bind the endogenous RIPK1 in brain tissue in order to exhibit pharmacological activity. What is particularly interesting is the TE of this compound 22 in the animal brain.
Here, we demonstrate that CETSA is feasible for evaluating the TE of reversible kinase inhibitors in in vivo animal experiments exemplified by our recently developed RIPK1 inhibitors. To our knowledge, there has been no report to demonstrate TE for reversible inhibitors in animal experiments. Using an established semi-automated system, the drug occupancy ratio in peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) is estimated, and direct binding of RIPK1 inhibitor on in vivo RIPK1 is successfully monitored in brain and spleen samples. Therefore, the use of both appropriately-prepared both PBMCs and tissue biopsy samples for TE could be as a biomarker in future clinical trials. Our study verifies that CETSA could serve as a powerful tool for animal and clinical studies.
Semi-automated CETSA evaluating TE in cells
To establish this efficient and feasible detection method, we first tried to develop a sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) to monitor the quantity of RIPK1 protein. However, compound-induced quenching of protein target recognition was observed by both our ELISA assay using several combinations of RIPK1 antibodies and a commercially available ELISA kit. This quenching effect has already been reported4,24 and the effects on RIPK1 protein might be dependent on RIPK1 associated with a variety of proteins14,15,25. Therefore, we focused on establishing a widely used Western blotting method in a semi-automated procedure. The semi-automated system used both an automated pipetting and dispensing system and a 96-well high-speed refrigerated centrifuge. The principle of CETSA technology is to detect the remaining soluble target protein from a background of thermally denatured and precipitated proteins after heat denaturation5,26. The washing process to remove unwanted components from samples is important to reduce the background noise of detection systems, because both animal plasma and cell culture media have high protein concentrations. As outlined in Fig. 1, either culture cells or PBMCs are first treated with compounds in 96-well polymerase chain reaction (PCR) plates. The compound-treated samples are transiently heated in a Takara Dice Gradient PCR (TAKARA), which is able to control a series of different temperatures in one 96-well PCR plate. After heating the intact cells, washing is carried out with a combination of low-speed centrifuge and MW508 liquid handling machines for the 96-well PCR plates. Next, three freeze-thaw cycles using liquid nitrogen are performed on the heat-treated cell suspensions. Finally, a 96-well high-speed refrigerated centrifuge efficiently separates the remaining soluble target protein in the supernatant from the thermally denatured and precipitated proteins. Even though the intact cells were washed, compound-induced quenching of protein target recognition was observed by our ELISA assay. Therefore, a widely used Western blotting method in a semi-automated procedure was essential for our evaluations.
We validated our semi-automated procedure with a trypan blue exclusion test and actual CETSA experiments. To optimize the liquid handling systems, the effluent of the wash process was monitored with a trypan blue exclusion test and no cells were detectable in the effluent. By our calculations, this wash process can provide an almost 200-fold dilution of the protein concentration in cell culture media. Using this automation system, all the experiments for both culture cells and PBMCs were performed in duplicate wells, and the small variations indicated adequate quality for CETSA. Isothermal dose-response fingerprint (ITDRF) experiments in human colorectal adenocarcinoma HT-29 cells demonstrated high reproducibility for two compounds in independent experiments (Supplementary Fig. 1a,b).
Development of CETSA for human RIPK1
In order to confirm the feasibility of CETSA for human RIPK1, we established an ITDRF assay with HT-29 cells using the semi-automated system described earlier. Several types of RIPK1 inhibitors have been reported16,22,27,28,29,30. We validated our assay by investigating the dose response curves of a total of 14 compounds: Nec-1, GSK-compound 27, and twelve 7-oxo-2,4,5,7-tetrahydro-6H-pyrazolo[3,4-c]pyridine derivatives (Fig. 2a, Supplementary Table 1). Firstly, aggregation temperature (Tagg) curves were analysed at a series of different temperatures with 3 or 8 min denaturation at 10 μM fixed dose for three compounds, compound 15, compound 25, and GSK-compound 27 (Fig. 2b). All three compounds showed substantial shifts of the thermal stability of RIPK1 under the two different denaturation times. An 8 min denaturation time results in lower apparent Tagg in comparison with a 3 min denaturation. Over all temperature conditions, the integrity of the cell membrane in HT-29 cells was confirmed with a trypan blue dye exclusion experiment (Supplementary Fig. 2a). Moreover, the total protein of RIPK1 was not changed with treatment of three compounds at room temperature, even in the presence of 10 μM (Fig. 2b). Based on these Tagg curves, denaturation at 47 °C for 8 min was selected for the next evaluation of ITDRF experiments. HT-29 cells were treated with serially titrated compounds for 30 min, after which all samples were heated. Four compounds showed dose-dependent stabilisation of RIPK1 with different half-maximal effective concentration (EC50) values (Fig. 2c,d). The EC50 values were calculated with duplicate data points and the standard error of the mean (SEM) demonstrated small variations. In order to evaluate repeatability of this ITDRF assay, the reproducibility of the EC50 evaluation was performed in multiple experimental runs for two compounds. The ITDRF of compound 25 exhibited an EC50 of 4.9 nM (95% confidence interval [CI] 1.0–24) and 5.0 nM (95% CI 2.8–9.1) (Supplementary Fig. 1a) and GSK-compound 27 resulted in an EC50 of 1,100 nM (95% CI 700–1,700), 640 nM (95% CI 350–1,200), and 1,200 nM (95% CI 810–1,700) (Supplementary Fig. 1b). These results suggested that the ITDRF for human RIPK1 in HT-29 cells is a feasible and robust assay. ITDRF-CETSA methodology depends on the irreversible aggregation of denatured proteins. Our curve fitting formula makes use of equilibrium models for data analysis Therefore, it is not appropriate to estimate the real binding affinities of the compound to intercellular RIPK1. However, there are no consensus formulas. For this reason, we refer to the observed responses as apparent binding affinity.
In order to evaluate the relationship among biophysical binding affinities under both intracellular and in vitro recombinant enzyme conditions, and functional cellular activity, further evaluations were performed with 14 RIPK1 compounds (Fig. 3a,b). The efficacies of RIPK1 compounds were tested in in vitro necroptosis assay using HT-29 cells, which were treated with tumour necrosis factor alpha (TNF-α) in presence of the Smac mimetic birinapant and the pan-caspase inhibitor z-VAD-FMK31. The binding affinities of compounds on recombinant RIPK1 proteins were monitored through fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) competitive binding assay. The values of ITDRF are almost similar to that of the half-maximal inhibitory concentration (IC50) in the necroptosis assay. Significant positive linear correlation between ITDRF and necroptosis assay was demonstrated (decision coefficient: R2 = 0.9120) (Fig. 3a). Moreover, there was a positive correlation for the ITDRF and RIPK1 recombinant enzyme assay (decision coefficient: R2 = 0.7028) (Fig. 3b). The lower values for R2 in enzyme-binding assay are highly dependent on GSK-compound 27 having higher potent affinity for recombinant RIPK1 compared with ITDRF assay. Except for GSK-compound 27, the values of ITDRF show almost the same IC50 values in the RIPK1 enzyme-binding assay. Even though ITDRF is based on the irreversible precipitation of unfolded proteins and our fitting formula is not sufficient for the real binding affinities within cells, the positive correlation among ITDRF, necroptosis assay, and RIPK1 recombinant enzyme assay suggested that ITDRF-CETSA might provide the quantitative interpretation in the case of RIPK1 under our experimental conditions. These results suggested that ITDRF assay in HT-29 cells may allow us to evaluate the intracellular structure-activity relationship (SAR) for RIPK1 in a native cellular environment.
Development of CETSA for mouse RIPK1
Before applying the CETSA method to in vivo experiments, the feasibility of CETSA for mouse RIPK1 was evaluated with mouse L-cells NCTC 929 (L929). The assay development was conducted in the similar way to that of the human RIPK1 CETSA assay. Up to 60 °C, the integrity of the cell membrane of L929 cells was confirmed by trypan blue dye exclusion, even with 10 μM representative RIPK1 inhibitors (Supplementary Fig. 2b). Tagg curves were analysed with 3 or 8 min denaturation at a series of different temperatures at 10 μM fixed dose of compound 25 (Supplementary Fig. 3a–c). In the same way as Tagg curves in human RIPK1, compound 25 showed substantial shifts of the thermal stability of mouse RIPK1 under the two different denaturation times. Based on these Tagg curves, the experimental condition for mouse RIPK1 was set at the same experimental conditions as for human RIPK1 for the next evaluation of ITDRF experiments, i.e. denaturation at 47 °C for 8 min. The derivatives of 7-oxo-2,4,5,7-tetrahydro-6H-pyrazolo[3,4-c]pyridine have much lower inhibitory activity on mouse RIPK1 than human RIPK1 in recombinant enzyme assays (Supplementary Table 1). Therefore, a representative six compounds were analysed with the ITDRF assay in L929 cells. L929 cells were also treated with serially titrated compounds for 30 min, after which all samples were heated. These six compounds also exhibited dose-dependent stabilization of mouse RIPK1 with different EC50 values (Supplementary Fig. 3d–f). The EC50 values for 7-oxo-2,4,5,7-tetrahydro-6H-pyrazolo[3,4-c]pyridine derivatives and Nec-1 showed almost similar Ki values to recombinant mouse RIPK1, although GSK-compound 27 showed an almost 500-fold lower Ki value in comparison with the EC50 in mouse ITDRF assay (Supplementary Table 1). This result is correlated with the assay results of ITDRF assay for human RIPK1. ITDRF for mouse RIPK1 might also suggest the quantitative interpretation under our experimental conditions.
In order to evaluate the relationship between intracellular biophysical binding affinity and functional cellular activity, further evaluations were performed with two types of cellular assays, necroptosis assay and phospho (Ser-345)- Mixed lineage kinase domain-like protein (MLKL) ELISA assay. The efficacies of RIPK1 compounds were tested in vitro necroptosis assay using L929 cells, which were treated with necroptosis inducer containing mouse TNF-α and Z-VAD-FMK31. RIPK1 regulates RIPK3-MLKL-driven necroptosis and RIPK3 phosphorylates MLKL at Ser34525,32. Therefore, we developed the phospho (Ser-345)-MLKL ELISA assay as a proximal pharmacodynamics marker and the effects of inhibitors on this event were evaluated with representative RIPK1 compounds. All three 7-oxo-2,4,5,7-tetrahydro-6H-pyrazolo[3,4-c]pyridine derivatives (compound 22, 23, and 25) showed inhibitory activities on cellular functional assays (Table 1). The high correlation between L929 necroptosis assay and p-MLKL assay were observed (Table 1). The differences in IC50 values for each compound were less than 2.5-fold. Moreover, the order of inhibitory activities on recombinant enzyme assay also correlated with two types of cellular functional assays, even though IC50 values in cellular assays were almost 10-fold lower than Ki values with mouse recombinant enzyme (Table 1). These results suggested that ITDRF assay in mouse L929 cells can also be used to evaluate the SAR for mouse RIPK1 in a native cellular environment.
Ex vivo mouse PBMC evaluation
To expand the CETSA application to comprehensive animal studies, we first selected the use of PBMCs for future preclinical and clinical drug development. Whole blood contains ~45% by volume of red cells, and these cells contain haemoglobin, a complex protein containing iron that carries oxygen through the body. To reduce the influence of the abundant protein derived from red cells, we used PBMCs in blood. In order to monitor the TE of mouse RIPK1 in PBMCs, PBMCs were isolated by density gradient media of Ficoll-fluid. The PBMCs were treated with serially titrated compounds for 30 min, and were then heat-denatured at 47 °C for 8 min. To improve accuracy, both whole protein and the remaining soluble target protein samples were analysed for Western blot analysis (Fig. 4a) and the thermal stabilities were estimated supernatant per whole ratios for heat-denatured samples.
ITDRF EC50 valuation of compound 22 was performed for PBMCs derived from three separate mouse plasma samples and that of compound 25 was evaluated with two separate mice-derived PBMC samples (Fig. 5a,b) The corresponding ITDRFs of compound 22 for three mice resulted in EC50 of 660 nM (95% CI 150–3,000), 680 nM (95% CI 360–1,300), and 700 nM (95% CI 390–1,300). The ITDRFs of compound 25 for two mice resulted in EC50 of 7,400 nM (95% CI 2,000–27,000) and 5,100 nM (95% CI 1,500–17,000). There seemed to be not much differences between PBMCs derived from different mice. In comparison with ITDRF EC50 values in L929 cells, the EC50 values in mouse PBMCs exhibited almost 5-fold lower values, but the order of the affinities in PBMCs correlated with those in L929 cells (Fig. 5a,b, Table 1). Unbound fractions in plasma of compound 22 and compound 25 were 0.060 and 0.13, respectively (Supplementary Table 2). The culture media of L929 contains 10% foetal bovine serum (FBS), but PBMCs were cultured in 100% plasma. With the correction for dilution factor according to the Kalvass and Maurer proposed equation33, unbound fractions of compound 22 and compound 25 in 10% plasma were 0.39 and 0.60, respectively. Even though L929 cells were cultured in 10% FBS, the almost 5-fold difference in EC50 values might be due to the unbound fraction of the compounds. In another aspect, the thermal stability of intracellular RIPK1 might be due to the type of cells, although heat-denaturing condition was same for both PBMCs and L929 cells. Moreover, no change of RIPK1 protein in whole samples was observable at all compound concentration ranges in PBMCs, demonstrating that the thermal stabilization data were not influenced by drug-induced change in total protein level.
To evaluate the relationship between ITDRF values and functional cellular activity in PBMCs, further evaluations were performed with whole blood necroptosis assay. This assay monitors the inhibition of monocyte cell death when whole mouse blood is treated with both RIPK1 compound and necroptosis inducers (Supplementary Figs 4 and 5). The IC50 values of compound 22 and compound 25 were 210 nM (95% CI 160–280) and 1,200 nM (95% CI 840–1,700), respectively (Fig. 5c). The ITDRF values for the two compounds in PBMCs were in the same order as the IC50 values in whole blood assay. These data suggested that a combination of CETSA and PBMCs is a promising technology to evaluate TE in animal blood.
In vivo mouse PBMC evaluation
Since mouse RIPK1 ITDRF assay is applicable using ex vivo PBMCs, we applied this methodology to RIPK1 occupancy analysis for compound 22 in the oral dosing of mice. Compound 22 is a highly potent, highly kinase selective lead compound with excellent pharmacokinetic qualities. Furthermore, this compound has shown activity in an EAE model and pharmacokinetic studies have demonstrated the brain permeability of the compound22. With respect to cellular thermal stability, this compound increased only the thermal stability of intracellular RIPK1, but not RIPK2, RIPK3, or β-actin using HT-29 cells (Supplementary Fig. 6a).
Based on the ex vivo results (Fig. 5a–c), the EC50 values of compound 22 in the ITDRF assay were almost the same as for the bloods derived from three different mice, but the Bmax of supernatant per whole ratios were slightly different for each animal’s peripheral blood. To calculate the occupancy of native RIPK1 by compound 22, a part of the isolated PBMCs was incubated with 30 μM compound 22 for 30 min at 37 °C for each sample, at which concentration the RIPK1 in the PBMCs should be completely occupied. Mice were divided into two groups of four animals each, vehicle control and experimental mice, orally dosed with 50 mg/kg compound 22. One hour after drug administration, the mice were euthanized and blood was collected. Western blot analysis was performed for isolated PBMCs and compound 22 spike-injected samples in the same way as for ex vivo PBMC evaluation (Fig. 6a). The averages of the supernatant per whole ratios for vehicle, 50 mg/kg compound 22, and 50 mg/kg compound 22 plus 30 μM compound 22 spike-injected samples, were 0.30, 0.59, and 0.77, respectively (Fig. 6b). Occupancy rate for each animal is calculated from supernatant per whole by using the following formula: % of control = (X − B) × 100/(A − B); A, 30 μM compound 22 spike-injected sample; B, average of vehicle controls; X, compound-administered sample. The average occupancy was 63.4% of endogenous RIPK1 in PBMCs. An ex vivo PBMC ITDRF assay demonstrated that average of EC50 value for compound 22 was 680 nM (Fig. 5a). Therefore, 63.4% occupation of intracellular RIPK1 suggested that almost 1 μM of the compound dissolved in blood plasma. In fact, the concentration of compound 22 at 1 h after oral administration showed a similar value, i.e. 2.031 μg ml−1 (4.4 μM) (Supplementary Table 3). In the same dosing samples, the compound in mouse blood reasonably inhibited monocyte cell deaths in a whole blood necroptosis assay (Fig. 6d).
These results suggest that the thermal stability of mouse RIPK1 in plasma is predictive marker to determine the target occupancy in vivo.
In vivo mouse spleen and brain evaluation
The feasibility of this technology was evaluated with both spleen and brain extracted from mice orally dosed with compound. Both lipid and amino acid composition patterns are strikingly different for the brain and other tissues34,35. Therefore, extraction procedures of target protein have to be optimised for each tissue. As illustrated in Fig. 4b, dissected spleen and brain samples were divided into four approximately equal parts. The samples were independently treated at room temperature, or heated at 43, 45, and 47 °C for 8 min. The following sample procedures were similar for spleen and brain, but initial frozen and ultrasound homogenisation steps were required for brain sample preparation to improve RIPK1 protein extraction to the supernatant. In the same way as PBMC CETSA, thermal stability is estimated as supernatant per whole ratio.
The spleen and brain samples were extracted from the same mice used in the previous in vivo mouse PBMC evaluation section, and were added to almost equal parts of pre-warmed PBS to avoid dilution of the reversible inhibitors. At 45 and 47 °C heat-denaturing conditions, 50 mg/kg compound 22-treated spleen samples showed a significant increase in the thermal stability of mouse RIPK1 (Fig. 7a,c). Moreover, 50 mg/kg compound 22-treated brain samples showed a significant increase in thermal stability of mouse RIPK1 at 43, 45, and 47 °C (Fig. 7b,d). The unbound concentrations in plasma and brain were 0.26 μM and 0.31 μM (Supplementary Tables 2 and 3), respectively. The unbound concentration in spleen was presumed to be almost equal to plasma, because unbound concentrations in plasma and brain are equal suggesting that unbound plasma concentration can be a surrogate of unbound concentration in tissues. These unbound concentrations were above the EC50 value of compound 22 in mouse L929 ITDRF assay (0.12 μM, Table 1). Therefore, our experimental procedure successfully evaluated the TE of mouse RIPK1 with in vivo spleen and brain samples.
Drug TE in a physiologically native condition is essential for preclinical and clinical drug development4,5. Although a number of reports have described that some potent irreversible inhibitors effectively exhibited cellular thermal shift in animal experiments5, there have been no reports, to our knowledge, suggesting that reversible drug leads show the promising CETSA effect in animal experiments accompanied by drug target occupancy. In this study, a 96-well-based semi-automated procedure and preparation methods for PBMCs, spleen, and brain were established, and the availability of SAR analysis with RIPK1 ITDRF assay was also demonstrated with cultured cells. Moreover, all our experimental procedures were performed under compound existence conditions before heating the samples, because the reversible compounds release from target proteins when the compound is diluted through the sample preparation processes. These experimental procedures demonstrate that CETSA is feasible to monitor the direct assessment of TE in animal studies using our recently developed reversible RIPK1 inhibitors.
To establish a robust and feasible CETSA for manipulating multiple samples, we developed a semi-automated system using automated pipetting and dispensing and a 96-well high-speed refrigerated centrifuge. The wash process for removing unwanted components in samples is a key element for reducing the background noise of detection systems, because both animal plasma and cell culture media have high protein concentrations. In fact, total plasma protein concentration is almost 100 mg ml−1; the capacity of Immun-Blot PVDF membrane retains 140–150 μg cm−2 based on BioRad supplier information36. This information suggests that almost 100-fold dilution is necessary to reduce the background. Using our semi-automated system, we are able to make almost 200-fold dilutions of protein concentrations and establish a feasible and reproducible method to evaluate SAR analysis in intricate physiological conditions with ITDRF experiments in a highly reproducible manner.
In order to understand the relationship among biophysical binding affinities under both in vitro recombinant and intracellular native conditions, and functional cellular activity, the 14 representative RIPK1 compounds were evaluated with three kinds of assay: human recombinant binding assay, HT-29 ITDRF assay, and HT-29 necroptosis assay. A significant positive linear correlation between ITDRF and the necroptosis assay was shown, with a similar positive correlation between ITDRF and the RIPK1 recombinant enzyme assay. The EC50 values of ITDRF were almost similar to those of the IC50 in the necroptosis assay and also showed similar IC50 values to the recombinant RIPK1 binding assay, except for GSK-compound 27. GSK-compound 27 (furo[2,3-d]pyrimidine 27) is distinct type 2 inhibitor occupying the ATP binding pocket with the kinase adopting a DLG-out conformation28. On the other hand, our developed compounds22 and Nec-1 are type 3 kinase inhibitors37 that bind to an allosteric pocket stabilizing a DLG-out conformation but not to the kinase hinge region and this results in excellent kinase selectivity. The reduction of binding affinity and cell-functional activity for GSK-compound 27 might be attributable to ATP competitiveness in the physiological environment of intracellular ATP concentration ranging from 0.5 to 5 mM38. These evaluations indicate that the RIPK1 ITDRF assay supports the interpretation of the physiological binding conditions within human cells.
In the case of mouse RIPK1, the EC50 values in mouse RIPK1-ITDRF assay of L929 cells for 7-oxo-2,4,5,7-tetrahydro-6H-pyrazolo[3,4-c]pyridine derivatives and Nec-1 also showed the almost similar Ki values on recombinant mouse RIPK1 except for GSK-compound 27. This result is correlated with the assay results of human RIPK1. Furthermore, the order of inhibitory activity on recombinant enzyme assay is also correlated with two types of cellular functional assays, such as L-929 necroptosis assay and phospho (Ser-345) -MLKL ELISA assay. One question is that IC50 values in cellular assays were almost 10-fold lower than Ki values with mouse recombinant enzyme. In the case of L929 cells, TNF-α prominently causes necrosis instead of apoptosis, and this response is different from the other cell lines39. In fact, HT-29 cells require TNF-α, cIAP inhibitor, and a pan-caspase inhibitor to induce necroptosis31. Therefore, the necroptosis-inducible conditions are highly dependent on the kind of cell line. The L929 cells might be sensitive to necroptosis inducer and not require full target occupation of endogenous RIPK1.
To evaluate the feasibility of this methodology for in vivo animal experiments, we initially conducted the ex vivo analysis with PBMCs in addition to spike-injected tool compounds. There were no significant differences in the EC50 of ITDRFs for tool compounds among PBMCs derived from different mice. Since mouse ITDRF CETSA are applicable using ex vivo PBMCs, we applied this methodology to in vivo RIPK1 occupancy analysis for compound 22 orally dosing mice. Occupancy rate for each animal is calculated from supernatant per whole ratio by setting the full occupied control sample with spike-addition of high concentration of objective compounds. The 63.4% occupation of intracellular RIPK1 indicated that almost 1 μM compound dissolved in blood plasma and the concentration was similar values measured by the LC-MS method (4.4 μM). Therefore, the occupancy rate of in vivo mouse RIPK1 in PBMCs was successfully evaluated. To achieve the TE in animal tissues, the sample procedures have to be optimized for spleen and brain for improving RIPK1 protein extraction to the supernatant. Under optimized tissue disruption and thermal conditions, we successfully demonstrated the TE in both brain and spleen.
From a translational point of view, it is essential to show TE in humans. Without TE, it is difficult to conclude whether failures in clinical trials are due to poor drug potency or inappropriate selection of the target itself1,2,3. We have also confirmed the thermal stability of human RIPK1 when human PBMCs in plasma were treated at 1 μM of compound 22 for 30 min in the similar way to mouse PBMCs (Supplementary Fig. 7).
There are no consensus formulas to estimate the real binding affinities of the compound within cells based on ITDRF. Therefore, the establishment of formulas is a future challenge for this method.
This study demonstrates that CETSA is feasible to conduct comprehensive animal studies that enable to interpret the TE of a reversible kinase inhibitor in in vivo animal experiments, although a few groups have used this technology for tissue lysates12 and animal experiments treated with irreversible compounds5 and Michael acceptor inhibitor10. For clinical application, peripheral blood is easily accessible and widely used in research and toxicology. Our semi-automated system successfully evaluates drug TE and target occupation in both human and mouse PBMCs. Moreover, our optimised procedure for homogenisation of tissues allows us to monitor the TE in animal tissues, indicating the possibility of assessing TE in animal models. Our result indicates that CETSA will serve as an efficient tool for preclinical and clinical drug discovery.
Necrostatin-1 (Nec-1) was purchased from Sigma (M6006). The other chemical inhibitors including the fluorescent-labelled ligand 3-(3-((3-(4-amino-5-(4-(3-(2-fluoro-5-(trifluoromethyl)phenyl)ureido)phenyl)-7H-pyrrolo[2,3-d]pyrimidin-7-yl)propyl)amino)-3-oxopropyl)-5,5-difluoro-7,9-dimethyl-5H-dipyrrolo[1,2-c:2′,1′-f][1,3,2]diazaborinin-4-ium-5-uide were synthesised by Takeda Chemical Industries, Ltd22. Z-VAD-FMLK at a 20 mM stock solution in neat dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) was purchased from Promega (G7232) and Smac mimetic (AT-406) was from AdooQ BioScience (A11163-10). Recombinant mouse and rat TNF-α were purchased from Wako and R&D systems (410-MT-050 and 510-RT-050, respectively). The following antibodies were used for ELISA: mouse MLKL (MABC604, Millipore), mouse phospho-MLKL/S345 (ab196436, Abcam), and rabbit IgG HRP (711-035-152, Jackson ImmunoResearch). TMB was purchased from KPL (53-00-0302). The following antibodies were used for fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) experiments: mouse anti-CD11b (553310, BD Biosciences; 1:200 dilution), and Ly-6G (127608, Biolegend; 1:400).
Human colorectal adenocarcinoma (HT-29) and mouse L-cells NCTC 929 (L929) cells were acquired from ATCC (HTB-38 and CCL-1, respectively). HT-29 and L929 were cultured in McCoy’s 5 A medium (16600108, Invitrogen) and RPMI1640 medium (189-02025, WAKO), respectively, which were supplemented with 10% FBS, 100 U ml−1 penicillin, and 100 μg ml−1 streptomycin.
In vivo mice experiment
C57BL/6 J (female, 10-week-old, Charles River Japan) were used for tissue CETSA experiments as well as ex vivo whole blood assay. The mice were housed on white chip. All procedures were performed in accordance with the standards for humane care, and treatment of research animal was approved by the Takeda Institutional Animal Ethics Committee (Approval No. 10805). RIPK1 inhibitor was suspended in 0.5% methyl cellulose and administered to mice orally. One hour after drug administration, mice were euthanized; blood was collected from the abdominal aorta with a heparin syringe (AY Pharma) and used for pharmacokinetic studies, FACS analysis, and CETSA assay; spleens and brains were extracted and used for pharmacokinetic studies and CETSA assay.
Thermal shift experiments for culture cells and PBMCs
HT-29 and L929 cells were harvested and suspended with culture media containing 10% FBS to a cell density of 2 × 106 cells ml−1. Mouse peripheral blood was collected from C57BL/6 J (female, 10-week-old, Charles River Japan) and PBMCs were isolated by density centrifugation over Lympholyte®-Mammal Cell Separation Media, Mammalian (CL5110, Cedarlane Laboratories) according to manual instructions. Briefly, approximately 500 μl of blood was carefully overlaid on 250 μl of the separation media so as not to disturb the layer. The samples were immediately spun at 800 g for 20 min at room temperature. After centrifugation, the buffy coat containing the PBMCs was collected with almost 350 μl of plasma to a cell density of approximately 1 × 106 cells ml−1. Compounds were diluted from DMSO stock solutions at 10-fold concentrate in supplemental cell culture medium (final DMSO content 1%).
For the in-cell thermal aggregation curve experiments, the compound solution was mixed with 9-fold volume of the suspension of cells at approximately 2 × 106 cells ml−1 and the cells were incubated for 30 min at 37 °C, 5% CO2. Cell suspension (culture cells, 100 μl/well; PBMCs, 30 μl/well) was then divided into each well of a 96-well PCR plate. The cells were transiently heated to different temperatures ranging from 40 to 60 °C for 3 or 8 min using a TaKaRa PCR Thermal Cycler Dice® Gradient (TAKARA), followed by cooling at room temperature for 3 min. After the heating step, the plate was centrifuged at 800 g for 5 min at room temperature. In the case of culture cells, a volume of 70 μl of the supernatant was removed with MW508 (MS Technos). After that, 120 μl of PBS containing protease inhibitor cocktail (PBS wash buffer, 11873580001, Roche) was added to each well using MW508 for both culture cells and PBMCs. This wash procedure was repeated twice. After the final wash, 35 μl of PBS wash buffer was added to each well. The heat-treated cell suspensions were freeze-thawed three times using liquid nitrogen. For PBMC experiments, the PCR plate was gently vortexed and a volume of 12 μl of the cell lysate was transferred to a 96-well PCR plate as whole cell lysate samples. For both culture cells and PBMCs, the resulting cell lysates were centrifuged at 13,000 g for 30 min at 4 °C in order to separate the soluble proteins from the cell debris and aggregates in 96-well format using CR21G (HITACHI). A volume of 36 μl of supernatant containing the remaining soluble proteins was transferred to a 96-well PCR plate with MW508. Both whole and supernatant samples were analysed by sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) followed by Western blotting.
For the ITDRF in cell experiments, compounds were serially diluted to generate dose response curves. Cells were treated with each compound concentration and one vehicle as control in 100 μl of cell suspension in a 96-well PCR plate for 30 min at 37 °C, 5% CO2. The cell suspensions were heated at indicated temperatures. The heat-treated samples were treated as for the sample preparation and analysed with Western blotting following the procedure described above.
Thermal shift experiments for in vivo tissue samples
Dissected spleen and brain samples were divided into four approximately equal parts in 2 ml Eppendorf tubes, and these tubes were put on ice. Within 15 min, the samples were added to 200 μl of pre-warmed PBS containing protease inhibitor. Immediately, the tubes were incubated for 8 min at regulated temperatures. The heat-treated brain samples were frozen using liquid nitrogen, and were homogenised with bead beaters (Shake-Master, Biomedical Science) using both 0.6 mm zirconium (ZS06-0001, Biomedical Science) and 3.0 mm stainless steel beads (SS30-0003, Biomedical Science) for 5 min under chilled conditions. After bead homogenisation, the samples were freeze-thawed three times, and then homogenised with ultrasonic tissue homogenisation (UH-50, SMT Company) on ice. As whole cell lysate samples, the sample tubes were vortexed and a volume of 100 μl of the homogenate was transferred to a 96-well PCR plate. The resulting homogenates were then centrifuged at 20,000 g for 20 min at 4 °C. The supernatant was removed from the tissue debris and aggregates. These samples were analysed with Western blotting. In the case of spleen samples, extraction efficiency of tissue RIPK1 was higher than that of the brain samples. Procedure for sample preparation of spleens excluded the processes of initial sample freezing and ultrasonic tissue homogenisation.
In vitro necroptosis assay
The efficacies of RIP1 inhibitors were tested in vitro using HT-29 cells and L929 cells in a necroptosis assay31. For HT-29 necroptosis assay, frozen HT-29 cells were thawed and diluted to 1.5 × 105 cells ml−1 in McCoy’s 5 A Medium (16600108, Invitrogen) supplemented with 10% FBS, 100 U ml−1 penicillin, and 100 μg ml−1 streptomycin. A 20 μl aliquot of cell suspension was added to each well of a 384-assay plate and the cell culture plates were incubated for 16–20 h at 37 °C, 5% CO2. After overnight incubation, 2.5 μl of inhibitor dissolved in culture medium was added to each well of the cell plates, and then each well was treated with 2.5 μl of necroptosis inducer containing rat TNF-α, AT-406, and zVAD-FMK solution at final concentrations of 200 ng ml−1, 10 μM, and 200 μM, respectively. Lidded plates were incubated for 16–20 h at 37 °C, 5% CO2. The next day, the supernatant of culture medium in each well was evaluated with CytoTox 96 Non-Radioactive Cytotoxicity Assay (G1780, Promega) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. The absorbance of the test plate was measured by 2103 EnVision Multilabel plate reader.
For mouse L929 necroptosis assay, L929 cells were seeded to a 96-assay plate at 3.0 × 104 cells/120 μl in RPMI1640 medium (189–02025, WAKO) supplemented with 10% FBS, 100 U ml−1 penicillin, and 100 μg ml−1 streptomycin and the cells were cultured for 16–20 h at 37 °C, 5% CO2. After overnight incubation, the cells were treated with 15 μl of inhibitor containing media followed by the treatment with 15 μl of necroptosis inducer containing mouse TNFα and Z-VAD-FMK at final concentration of 20 ng ml−1 and 20 μM, respectively, and incubated for 4 h. The cytotoxicity assay was conducted in the same way as the HT-29 necroptosis assay. Percentage inhibition was calculated from the signal intensity of CytoTox assay by using the following formula; % inhibition = 100 − (A − X) × 100/(A − B).
A, no necroptosis inducer; B, necroptosis inducer; X, necroptosis inducer plus test inhibitor. IC50 values were calculated with XLfit software (IDBS) using a four-parameter logistic curve.
SDS-Page, Western blot, and densitometry analysis
Lysates of culture cells, PBMCs, and tissue samples were mixed with 4-fold loading buffer (0.25 mM Tris-HCl, 8 w/v% SDS, 40 w/v% glycerol, 0.02 w/v% BPB, and 20 v/v% 3-mercapto-1,2-propandiol) and heated to denature the protein at 95 °C for 5 min. SDS-page was performed using standard protocol with BioRad Gel Croteropm TGX Any-KD 26 well (BioRad). Transfer of proteins to PVDF membranes was conducted with Tras Blot Turbo (Bio Rad) according to manufacturer’s protocols. Protein was detected using primary antibodies anti-monoclonal RIPK1 (610459, BD Transduction Laboratories™), anti-monoclonal RIPK2 (612348, BD Transduction Laboratories™), anti-RIPK3 polyclonal antibody (sc-135170, Santa Cruz Biotechnology) and β-actin antibody (#4967 L, Cell Signaling Technology); secondary antibodies anti-mouse IgG HRP conjugated antibody (#7076 S, Cell Signaling Technology) and anti-rabbit IgG HRP conjugated antibody (711-035-152, Jackson Immuno Research Laboratories). All membranes were blocked with blocking buffer and protein blots were imaged by ECL Pro (NEL121001EA, PerkinElmer) and detected with ImageQuant LAS 4000 (GE Healthcare). Protein bands in the membranes were quantified by ImageQuantTL v8.1.
IC50 and EC50 values were calculated with either GraphPad Prism software (Version 5.03, Graph Pad Software) or XLfit software (IDBS) using a four-parameter logistic curve. All of the data are shown as mean ± SEM. For the Tagg shift and the ITDR experiments, data were analysed in GraphPad Prism using the Boltzmann sigmoid equation and the four-parameter logistic curve4,24. Student’s t-test was used to calculate P values with Microsoft Excel.
The authors declare that data supporting the findings of this study are available within the article.
Waring, M. J. et al. An analysis of the attrition of drug candidates from four major pharmaceutical companies. Nat. Rev. Drug Discov. 14, 475–486 (2015).
Morgan, P. et al. Can the flow of medicines be improved? Fundamental pharmacokinetic and pharmacological principles toward improving Phase II survival. Drug Discov. Today 17, 419–424 (2012).
Bunnage, M. E., Chekler, E. L. & Jones, L. H. Target validation using chemical probes. Nat. Chem. Biol. 9, 195–199 (2013).
Jafari, R. et al. The cellular thermal shift assay for evaluating drug target interactions in cells. Nat Protoc 9, 2100–2122 (2014).
Martinez Molina, D. et al. Monitoring drug target engagement in cells and tissues using the cellular thermal shift assay. Science 341, 84–87 (2013).
Martinez Molina, D. & Nordlund, P. The Cellular Thermal Shift Assay: A Novel Biophysical Assay for In Situ Drug Target Engagement and Mechanistic Biomarker Studies. Annu. Rev. Pharmacol. Toxicol. 56, 141–161 (2016).
Durham, T. B. & Blanco, M. J. Target engagement in lead generation. Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 25, 998–1008 (2015).
Hargreaves, R. J. & Rabiner, E. A. Translational PET imaging research. Neurobiol Dis 61, 32–38 (2014).
Matthews, P. M., Rabiner, E. A., Passchier, J. & Gunn, R. N. Positron emission tomography molecular imaging for drug development. Br. J. Clin. Pharmacol. 73, 175–186 (2012).
Qin, D. et al. CDDO-Me reveals USP7 as a novel target in ovarian cancer cells. Oncotarget 7, 77096–77109 (2016).
Singh, J., Petter, R. C., Baillie, T. A. & Whitty, A. The resurgence of covalent drugs. Nat. Rev. Drug Discov. 10, 307–317 (2011).
Wey, H. Y. et al. Insights into neuroepigenetics through human histone deacetylase PET imaging. Sci Transl Med 8, 351ra106 (2016).
Wegner, K. W., Saleh, D. & Degterev, A. Complex Pathologic Roles of RIPK1 and RIPK3: Moving Beyond Necroptosis. Trends Pharmacol. Sci. 38, 202–225 (2017).
Berger, S. B. et al. Cutting Edge: RIP1 kinase activity is dispensable for normal development but is a key regulator of inflammation in SHARPIN-deficient mice. J. Immunol. 192, 5476–5480 (2014).
Polykratis, A. et al. Cutting edge: RIPK1 Kinase inactive mice are viable and protected from TNF-induced necroptosis in vivo. J. Immunol. 193, 1539–1543 (2014).
Degterev, A. et al. Chemical inhibitor of nonapoptotic cell death with therapeutic potential for ischemic brain injury. Nat. Chem. Biol. 1, 112–119 (2005).
Koudstaal, S. et al. Necrostatin-1 alleviates reperfusion injury following acute myocardial infarction in pigs. Eur J Clin Invest 45, 150–159 (2015).
Newton, K. et al. RIPK3 deficiency or catalytically inactive RIPK1 provides greater benefit than MLKL deficiency in mouse models of inflammation and tissue injury. Cell Death Differ 23, 1565–1576 (2016).
Duprez, L. et al. RIP kinase-dependent necrosis drives lethal systemic inflammatory response syndrome. Immunity 35, 908–918 (2011).
Ofengeim, D. et al. Activation of necroptosis in multiple sclerosis. Cell Rep 10, 1836–1849 (2015).
Ito, Y. et al. RIPK1 mediates axonal degeneration by promoting inflammation and necroptosis in ALS. Science 353, 603–608 (2016).
Yoshikawa, M. Discovery of 7-Oxo-2,4,5,7-tetrahydro-6H-pyrazolo[3,4-c]pyridine Derivatives as Potent, orally available, and Brain-penetrant Receptor Interactiong Protein 1 (RIP1) Kinase Inhitors Guided by Structure Kinetics Relationship. (Under submission).
Constantinescu, C. S., Farooqi, N., O’Brien, K. & Gran, B. Experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) as a model for multiple sclerosis (MS). Br. J. Pharmacol. 164, 1079–1106 (2011).
Almqvist, H. et al. CETSA screening identifies known and novel thymidylate synthase inhibitors and slow intracellular activation of 5-fluorouracil. Nat Commun 7, 11040 (2016).
Rodriguez, D. A. et al. Characterization of RIPK3-mediated phosphorylation of the activation loop of MLKL during necroptosis. Cell Death Differ. 23, 76–88 (2016).
Miettinen, T. P. & Bjorklund, M. NQO2 is a reactive oxygen species generating off-target for acetaminophen. Mol. Pharm. 11, 4395–4404 (2014).
Degterev, A. et al. Identification of RIP1 kinase as a specific cellular target of necrostatins. Nat. Chem. Biol. 4, 313–321 (2008).
Harris, P. A. et al. Discovery of Small Molecule RIP1 Kinase Inhibitors for the Treatment of Pathologies Associated with Necroptosis. ACS Med Chem Lett 4, 1238–1243 (2013).
Najjar, M. et al. Structure guided design of potent and selective ponatinib-based hybrid inhibitors for RIPK1. Cell Rep 10, 1850–1860 (2015).
Harris, P. A. et al. DNA-Encoded Library Screening Identifies Benzo[b][1,4]oxazepin-4-ones as Highly Potent and Monoselective Receptor Interacting Protein 1 Kinase Inhibitors. J. Med. Chem. 59, 2163–2178 (2016).
He, S. et al. Receptor interacting protein kinase-3 determines cellular necrotic response to TNF-alpha. Cell 137, 1100–1111 (2009).
Murphy, J. M. et al. The pseudokinase MLKL mediates necroptosis via a molecular switch mechanism. Immunity 39, 443–453 (2013).
Kalvass, J. C. & Maurer, T. S. Influence of nonspecific brain and plasma binding on CNS exposure: implications for rational drug discovery. Biopharm Drug Dispos 23, 327–338 (2002).
Beach, E. F., Munks, B. & Robinson, A. The amino acid composition of animal tissue protein. J. Biol. Chem. 148, 431–439 (1943).
Cherayil, G. D. & Scaria, K. S. Thin-layer chromatography of tissue lipids without extraction. J. Lipid Res. 11, 378–381 (1970).
Okutucu, B., Dincer, A., Habib, O. & Zihnioglu, F. Comparison of five methods for determination of total plasma protein concentration. J. Biochem. Biophys. Methods 70, 709–711 (2007).
Degterev, A. & Linkermann, A. Generation of small molecules to interfere with regulated necrosis. Cell. Mol. Life Sci. 73, 2251–2267 (2016).
Huang, H. et al. Physiological levels of ATP negatively regulate proteasome function. Cell Res. 20, 1372–1385 (2010).
Chan, F. K. et al. A role for tumor necrosis factor receptor-2 and receptor-interacting protein in programmed necrosis and antiviral responses. J Biol Chem 278, 51613–51621 (2003).
We acknowledge Yuuji Shimizu, Akito Hata, Yukio Toyoda, Yuki Shirai, Harumi Hattori, and Shinichi Niwa (Takeda Pharmaceutical Company, Fujisawa, Japan) for experimental support. We thank Mitsuyo Kondo for protein preparation and Takayuki Tatamiya, Yoshihisa Nakada, Jeong-ho Oak, Takashi Ito, and Masanori Miwa (Takeda Pharmaceutical Company, Fujisawa, Japan) for experimental discussion. We would like to express gratitude to Morihisa Sato, Taisuke Katoh, and Tomohiro Seki (Takeda Pharmaceutical Company, Fujisawa, Japan) for synthesising chemical tool inhibitors. We thank Kimio Tohyama, and Chiharu Fukushi (Takeda Pharmaceutical Company, Fujisawa, Japan) for DMPK experimental design.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Electronic supplementary material
About this article
Cite this article
Ishii, T., Okai, T., Iwatani-Yoshihara, M. et al. CETSA quantitatively verifies in vivo target engagement of novel RIPK1 inhibitors in various biospecimens. Sci Rep 7, 13000 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-017-12513-1
Cellular thermal shift assay for the identification of drug–target interactions in the Plasmodium falciparum proteome
Nature Protocols (2020)
Nature Biotechnology (2020)
Scientific Reports (2019)