The southeastern Mediterranean Sea (SEMS) is a warm and sunlit marine environment with low ambient N concentration, thus considered ideal for diazotrophy by autotrophic diazotrophs such as Trichodesmium. Despite the favorable conditions, N2 fixation rates are often low and Trichodesmium has hardly been spotted in the SEMS. This study reports on the occurrence of a Trichodesmium bloom in the SEMS which was ascribed to T. erythraeum according to DNA fingerprinting of the nifH gene. We found that this bloom (1407 ± 983 cells L−1) was triggered by an intense outburst of raw sewage that supplied high concentrations of N, P and dissolved organic carbon (DOC), which resulted in low N:P (~12:1) and exceptionally high C:P (~1340:1) ratios. We surmise that these conditions provided favorable conditions for Trichodesmium bloom to form via mixotrophic metabolism. As a result, a fourfold increase in N2 fixation was recorded, which contributed ~70% to new primary production and spur a sharp increase in phytoplankton activity and biomass. The conclusions of this study point on a new paradigm for bloom-forming T. erythraeum which is tightly linked to anthropogenic sources and prompt microbial productivity in oligotrophic marine environments such as the SEMS.
Coastal environments are routinely exposed to runoffs from anthropogenic sources, including municipal, industrial and agricultural waste1, 2. These abrupt runoffs are often untreated and contain pathogens, organic and inorganic nutrients, heavy metals and detergents and are thus considered major threats to marine ecosystems3, 4. Such discharges were previously shown to alter food-web dynamics in coastal environments1, 5, 6. For example, sewage outbursts introduce nutrients that can stimulate bottom-up effects7 and shift the phytoplankton community structure to form large blooms of toxic dinoflagellates or other harmful algal species8,9,10.
The surface water of the southeastern Mediterranean Sea (SEMS) is a warm, sunlit marine environment with ultra-oligotrophic conditions, resulting in low bacterial and phytoplankton biomass and low productivity11,12,13. Phytoplankton productivity is considered either N-limited14 or N and P co-limited15, 16, whereas bacteria are either P-limited17 or C-limited14. These conditions are supposedly ideal for diazotrophy to occur by autotrophic diazotrophs that can fix C and N using the sunlight energy18. Although the diazotrophic community in the eastern Mediterranean Sea is highly diverse14, 19, 20, typical N2 fixation rates are constantly low (<0.4 nmol N L−1 d−1)13, 14, 21,22,23, whereas large scale Trichodesmium spp. were only reported once in the northeastern Mediterranean Sea24 and recently in the Gulf of Gabes (Tunisia)25.
Trichodesmium spp. is considered to be one of the most dominant nitrogen-fixing microorganisms in marine systems26, 27. It was previously reported that large Trichodesmium blooms may fix CO2 and N2 at high rates reaching 640 pg C cell−1 d−1 and 29 pg N cell−1 d−1, respectively, thereby prompt the microbial food web28. The formation of Trichodesmium blooms are often hindered by the availability of trace metals (mainly Fe) and other nutrients (mainly P)29, 30, water temperature31, light availability32, 33, high O2 levels34, as well as other physiochemical water characteristics35. However, the conditions restricting the formation of Trichodesmium spp. blooms in the SEMS, which is potentially ideal for diazotrophy, are currently unknown18.
In this study, we focused on the possible links between sewage outburst and the development of Trichodesmium bloom and corresponding microbial community structure. To this end, we followed a Trichodesmium erythraeum bloom in the coastal water of the SEMS which was triggered by an outburst of municipal sewage. During this event, we followed the temporal dynamics of T. erythraeum and N2 fixation, as well as picophytoplankton, diatoms, dinoflagellates, and heterotrophic bacteria. Our results point on the possible impacts of sewage outbursts that flow into ultra-oligotrophic marine environments such as the SEMS.
Material and Methods
Study site and sample collection
Seawater samples (~20 L) were collected from the surface water (~0.5 m) of the southeastern Mediterranean coastline (32°49′34 N, 34°57′20E) during wintertime. Up to ten measurements were carried out; (i) two-three prior the sewage outburst, (ii) five during the event, and (iii) two immediately after the sewage outburst had ended. Seawater was sampled for inorganic nutrients, dissolved organic carbon, chlorophyll-a (as an algae proxy), picophytoplankton abundance including Synechococcus + Prochlorococcus (collectively referred to as autotrophic cyanobacteria) and picoeukaryotes, heterotrophic bacterial abundance and microphytoplankton abundance (diatoms and dinoflagellates). Furthermore, water samples were collected for Trichodesmium spp. abundance, diazotrophic diversity (nifH gene analysis), primary production, bacterial production and N2 fixation measurements.
Inorganic nutrients and dissolved organic carbon (DOC)
Water samples for NO2 + NO3, PO4 and Si(OH)4 concentrations were collected in 15 mL acid-washed plastic scintillation vials and placed immediately in a −20 °C freezer until analysis. Inorganic nutrient values were determined using the segmented flow Seal Analytical AA-3 system36.
Samples for DOC concentrations (40 mL) were collected in septum-cap glass vials and were acidified with concentrated (32%) hydrochloric acid (HCl) at a ratio of 1:1000 and stored in the dark at 4 °C until analysis. Samples were analyzed on a Shimadzu TOCV analyzer with a precision of 2 μmol L−1.
Seawater samples (300 mL) were filtered through a Whatman GF/F filter (~0.7 μm nominal pore size) and kept at −20 °C in the dark. Filters were extracted overnight in acetone (90%) and determined by the non-acidification method37 using a Turner Designs (Trilogy) fluorometer with 436-nm excitation and 680-nm emission filters.
Water samples (1.7 mL) were fixed with 50% glutaraldehyde (Sigma-Aldrich G7651), snap-frozen in liquid nitrogen and stored at −80 °C. Picophytoplankton abundance was determined based on the orange auto-florescence of phycoerythrin and the red auto-florescence of chl-a38. Heterotrophic bacterial abundance was measured by staining the sample with 1 μl of SYBR green (Applied Biosystems cat #S32717) followed by a 10-min incubation in the dark. All samples were analyzed by an Attune® Acoustic Focusing Flow Cytometer (Applied Biosystems) equipped with 488-nm and 405-nm lasers. For the size standard, 1-μm beads (Polysciences) were used.
Trichodesmium, diatom and dinoflagellate abundance
Cell densities were determined after concentrating 1–5 L of surface seawater and counting three subsamples. Cell numbers were estimated using a Sedgewick-Rafter Cell (S50) and an epi-fluorescence light microscope (Olympus BH-2) using 20–40X magnification.
Extraction and sequencing of the nifH gene
Samples (1–5 L) were filtered through 0.2-μm Supor filters (PALL Corp.) and placed in a sterile DNase/Rnase Free Whirl-Pak bag. The samples were snap-frozen in liquid nitrogen and stored at −80 °C. DNA was extracted using the phenol-chloroform method according to Man-Aharonovich19. Nitrogenase Fe protein transcripts (nifH) were amplified using a nested PCR strategy39. A paired-end sequencing of DNA was performed on an Illumina MiSeq platform at the Research and Testing Laboratories (Lubbock, TX, USA).
Merged Illumina reads were quality filtered and analyzed with the Quantitative Insights Into Microbial Ecology (QIIME) pipeline40. The remaining reads were binned into operational taxonomic units (OTUs) and defined at 97% similarity using the UCLUST algorithm41. Taxonomy was assigned with BLAST and a database of nifH sequences from Heller et al.42. Phylogenetic trees were generated with FastTree in QIIME43 and visualized with the Interactive Tree of Life (IToL) and Topiary Explorer v1.0 packages.
Primary production (PP)
Photosynthetic carbon fixation rates were estimated using 14C incorporation44. Water samples were analyzed in triplicates with dark and zero-time controls. Samples (50 mL) collected at each time point were added to polycarbonate bottles (Nalgene) containing 5 μCi of NaH14CO3 (Perkin Elmer, specific activity 56 mCi mmol−1) and incubated for 4 h under ambient natural illumination and temperature. To determine the quantity of the added radioactivity, 50 μl of each sample was immediately mixed with 50 μl of ethanolamine and stored for analysis. The incubations were terminated by filtering the spiked seawater through GF/F filters (~0.7 μm nominal pore size) at low pressure (~50 mmHg). The filters were incubated overnight in 5-mL scintillation vials containing 50 μl of 32% HCl in order to remove excess 14C-bicarbonate. After adding 5 mL of scintillation cocktail (Ultima-Gold) to each vial, the radioactivity was measured using a TRI-CARB 2100 TR (Packard) liquid scintillation counter.
Bacterial production (BP)
Rates were estimated using the [4,5-3H]-leucine incorporation method45. Three aliquots (1.7 mL each) from each water sample were incubated with 100 nmol of leucine L−1 (Amersham, specific activity 160 Ci mmol−1) for 4 h at ambient temperature in the dark. Samples treated with trichloroacetic acid (TCA) were used as a control. The incubations were terminated with 100 μL of TCA (100%), followed by micro-centrifugation. After adding 1 mL of scintillation cocktail (Ultima-Gold) to each vial, the samples were counted using a TRI-CARB 2100 TR (Packard) liquid scintillation counter. A conversion factor of 3 kg C per mole leucine incorporated was used, assuming an isotopic dilution of 2.046.
Dinitrogen (N2) fixation
Rates were measured in triplicates using the 15N2-enriched seawater protocol47. 15N2-enriched seawater was prepared by injecting 1:100 (vol:vol) 15N2 gas (99%) into degassed (MiniModule G543) and filtered (Polycarbonate 0.2 μm) seawater collected at the study site. The enriched seawater stock was shaken vigorously in order to completely dissolve the 15N2 gas, and aliquots (225 mL) were then added to triplicate experimental Nalgene bottles (4.6 L). Following 24 h of incubations under ambient light and temperature conditions, the samples were filtered through pre-combusted (450 °C, 4.5 h) GF/F filters and dried in an oven at 60 °C overnight. The samples were then analyzed using a CE Instruments NC2500 elemental analyzer interfaced to a Thermo-Finningan Delta Plus XP isotope ratio mass spectrometer (IRMS). For isotope ratio mass spectrometry, a standard curve to determine N mass was performed with each sample run.
Data are displayed as averages; error bars signify one standard deviation (n = 3–5). The relationships between the different environmental and physiological variables were determined with a Pearson correlation test (P < 0.05). All tests were performed using the XLSTAT software.
Results and Discussion
Untreated sewage outbursts into the SEMS coastal environment occur a few times every winter, usually due to deficiencies in the sewage network and/or overloading of the sewage drainage system by storm-water runoffs (Fig. 1A). The introduction of high loads of organic matter and nutrients into oligotrophic coastal environments such as the SEMS may often result in the formation of phytoplankton blooms (Figs 1B,C and 2). The formation of these blooms may alter microbial food-web dynamics48 and release different harmful toxins49, as well as hinder the performance of large-scale seawater desalination and power plants50.
Environmental conditions of the study site during wintertime
The coastal water prior to the outburst event exhibited typical SEMS wintertime characteristics (Table 1), with cold (18.3 ± 0.7 °C), windswept (10 ± 3 knots) and well-oxidized (190 ± 10 μM) water. Inorganic nutrient levels, namely NO2 + NO3, PO4 and Si(OH)4), were low (close to detection limit for P and up to ~2 μM) as well as dissolved organic carbon (DOC, 10 ± 5 μM). These physicochemical conditions resulted in low phytoplankton biomass (0.32 ± 0.05 μg chl-a L−1), which is typical for this region14, 23. Synechococcus were the most abundant phototroph (3.9 ± 1.2 cells × 107 L−1), whereas diatom (116 ± 43 cells L−1, mostly Chaetoceros spp.) and dinoflagellate (34 ± 13 cells L−1, mostly Ceratium spp.) abundances were 5–6 orders of magnitude lower (Fig. 2A,B). At this time, Trichodesmium spp. could not be detected (Fig. 2C). The low phototrophic abundance resulted in scant PP rates (3.3 ± 0.6 μg C L−1 d−1, Fig. 2D). Heterotrophic bacterial abundance was higher by ~tenfold relative to Synechococcus (64 ± 14 cells × 107 L−1, Fig. 2B). However, BP rates were low (0.8 ± 0.2 μg C L−1 d−1) and constituted ~25% of the PP (Fig. 2D). N2 fixation rates were also low (0.15 ± 0.02 nmol N L−1 d−1, Fig. 2D) and similar to previously reported values from this study area14, 23. We attribute the low N2 fixation rates to alpha, gamma and delta—proteobacteria diazotrophs as recently reported for the coastal SEMS14.
Coastal conditions in the SEMS during a sewage outburst event
During February 2015, raw and untreated domestic sewage was continuously and intensely (thousands of L h−1) discharged for five days into the coastal water of the SEMS due to various impairments in the municipal drainage system of Haifa, Israel (Fig. 1A). During this period, water temperature and salinity were not affected and remained typical to the season, and only a weak breeze (<4 knots) was recorded throughout the sewage outburst event (Table 1). Concurrently, NO2 + NO3 (2.3 ± 0.2 μM) and PO4 (0.2 ± 0.1 μM) levels increased by twofold and fourfold respectively (Table 1). This change in NO2 + NO3 and PO4 resulted in a reduced N:P ratio (~12), which is lower than the colonial 16:1 Redfield ratio. DOC levels have also increased by 25-fold relative to the ambient pre-sewage conditions (268 ± 56 μM).
Following the sewage outburst, a large tuff-like Trichodesmium spp. bloom developed, reaching densities of 1407 ± 983 trichomes L−1 (Figs 1B and 2C). Genetic fingerprinting of nifH indicated that the most abundant diazotrophic specie was Trichodesmium erythraeum (T. erythraeum), constituting >70% of all the diazotrophic OTUs in the sewage plume (Fig. 2C). Concurrently, the relative OTUs of other diazotrophs, such as heterotrophic proteobacteria (i.e., Desulfobacter sp.) and cyanobacteria (i.e., Leptolyngbya sp.), were significantly lower (<1%). Our measured T. erythraeum densities were in agreement with those previously reported in the northeastern Mediterranean Sea (Aegean Sea) in September 201024 and from a three-year survey in the Gulf of Gabes (Tunisia)25. However, these cell numbers were below the densities reported for large-scale Trichodesmium spp. blooms in other marine environments that ranged from 3000 to >10000 trichomes L−1 51,52,53.
Together with the sharp and significant rise in T. erythraeum, N2 fixation rates increased by ~fourfold (Fig. 2D). Therefore, we attributed the lion’s share of the corresponding N2 fixation rates to T. erythraeum (Table 2). This relationship yielded specific N2 fixation rates per trichome of ~3.5 nmol N trichome−1 d−1, which are at the lower end of the values reported from other oceanic systems where Trichodesmium spp. prevails53,54,55, or from T. erythraeum monocultures56. Still, it should be noted that not all cells within a Trichodesmium filament take an active role in N2 fixation34. Therefore, it is possible that the T. erythraeum filaments observed here had fewer N2-fixing cells (out of all vegetative cells) than in other marine systems, which would result in lower specific N2 fixation rates compared with other marine systems.
Concomitant with the sewage outburst event and the T. erythraeum bloom, chl-a levels positively and linearly increased by 60% (0.51 ± 0.06 μg L−1) and PP by 230% (7.77 ± 0.97 μg C L−1 d−1) compared with the ambient concentrations (Tables 1 and 2), indicating a significant increase in phototrophic biomass. Specifically, these changes were even more evident in the increased abundances of diatoms (~fourfold, mostly Asterionellopsis glacialis and Leptocylindrus danicus) and dinoflagellates (~sevenfold, mostly Ceratium spp.) following the development of the T. erythraeum bloom (Fig. 2A–C, Table 2). In contrast to the significant rise in microphytoplankton abundance, heterotrophic bacteria only increased by 1.9-fold (Fig. 2B); however, BP rates increased by threefold relative to pre-discharge production rates. This decoupling between the moderate rise in total heterotrophic bacteria and the significant increase in BP rates, along with the high DOC levels that were introduced with the sewage (Table 1), suggests that some phototrophs might also utilize these organic substrates by switching to mixotrophic nutrition57, 58.
The importance of Trichodesmium to new production and microbial biomass in the SEMS
Trichodesmium blooms are known to release bioavailable nitrogen into the surrounding water, leading to enhanced growth of non-diazotrophic cyanobacteria and microphytoplankton22. Indeed, the appearance of T. erythraeum in the SEMS water was positively and significantly coupled with phototrophic biomass (as chl-a), Synechococcus abundance, PP and N2 fixation (Table 2). It was also positively correlated with microphytoplankton abundance, although not significantly (Table 2). We estimated that the contribution of T. erythraeum to PP via N2 fixation (based on C:N Redfield stoichiometry) reached 68 ± 27%. This contribution is ~sevenfold higher than the percentage usually reported in the same study area and season during non-bloom conditions (~10%)23, and 30–140-fold higher than that reported from the offshore waters of the eastern Mediterranean Sea (~0.5–2%)13, 20, 23, 59, 60. We suggest that the new N derived from T. erythraeum N2 fixation, along with the additional nutrients that were introduced by the sewage, may induce primary and bacterial production rates, resulting in prompted microphytoplankton growth (Fig. 2, Table 2). Diatoms and dinoflagellates abundance markedly increased at day 4 of the sewage outburst and 1-2 days since the appearance of Trichodesmium (Fig. 2). Therefore, we surmised that it is likely that microphytoplankton growth was linked to Trichodesmium and the corresponding elevated N2 fixation rates. Similarly, a Trichodesmium bloom in the near-shore waters of Goa (western India) led to Asterionella japonica and Nitzschia closterium blooms61. In the Gulf of Mexico, Trichodesmium spp. triggered a bloom of the toxic dinoflagellate Karenia brevis62. Additionally, recent nanoscale secondary ion mass spectrometry (NanoSIMS) analyses showed that small-size autotrophic picophytoplankton accumulated 15N-derived Trichodesmium spp. in the waters of the southwestern Pacific Ocean around New Caledonia22. Furthermore, large-scale Trichodesmium blooms were reported to swiftly diminish via grazing by harpacticoid copepods63, by viral lysis64 or by a genetically controlled programmed cell death28, 53, 65. These swift bloom demise (~50% of biomass loss within 24 h)28 may fuel higher trophic levels and significantly change the microbial community structure.
Factors controlling the activity and bloom formation of Trichodesmium in the SEMS
Trichodesmium growth and activity may be affected by several physiochemical characteristics and currently remain a matter of debate in many oceanic regions27, 52. Environmental factors, such as sea surface temperature, pCO2, irradiance, a quiescent sea state and the availability of nutrients such as P and Fe, have all been suggested as controlling factors for Trichodesmium blooms29, 30, 33, 66,67,68,69,70. Currently, the reasons why Trichodesmium blooms do not develop in the SEMS, despite being a potentially ideal marine environment with beneficial characteristics for diazotrophy, are still unknown. Our findings suggest that apart from the calm sea, sunlit conditions and the somewhat low N:P ratio (12:1), two mechanisms may have been in play and triggered the development of the T. erythraeum bloom: (i) The high concentrations of N and P (at a low N:P ratio) that were introduced to the coastal environment with the sewage supplied the initial cellular metabolic needs for the growth and proliferation of T. erythraeum cells. (ii) The high DOC concentration that was supplied with the sewage may have provided assimilable carbon source to the coastal environment. A recent study showed that Trichodesmium, as other unicellular diazotrophs71, 72, can utilize DOC as an available carbon source73 and therefore may provide an alternative energy source to fix N2 and form blooms. Assuming that T. erythraeum cells are mixotrophs73, we suggest that Trichodesmium blooms could be stimulated by these types of sewage outbursts in the oligotrophic SEMS. Furthermore, during the bloom, the high concentrations of DOC resulted in an exceptionally high C:N:P ratio (~1340:12:1) relative to the measured ambient ratio during the non-bloom period (~233:25:1). We suggest that these conditions may have induced N-limiting yet C-rich conditions that prioritized mixotrophic metabolism by Trichodesmium. It should be noted that while Benavides et al.73, suggested that natural Trichodesmium populations may use alternative mixotrophic nutrition and assimilate DOC as a primary C source, such an addition will not necessarily trigger a Trichodesmium bloom in the SEMS. In fact, a recent study from the coastal SEMS reported that heterotrophic diazotrophy was stimulated by a DOC + N + P addition, whereas Trichodesmium spp. was not observed14. We propose that additional materials such as trace metals and vitamins were introduced with the sewage outburst and played mutual roles in the formation of the T. erythraeum bloom that was reported here. Still, the reasons as to why Trichodesmium spp. blooms do not develop more often in the SEMS and the Mediterranean Sea (despite being routinely exposed to external organic and inorganic nutrients) remains unknown and merit further research.
Our results provide the first recorded observation of a Trichodesmium (T. erythraeum) bloom in the coastal waters of the SEMS, which was stimulated by a prolonged and intense sewage outburst event. We suggest that the introduction of high amounts of N, P and DOC, as well as the C:N:P ratio measured here, triggered the formation of the Trichodesmium bloom. Specifically, assuming that Trichodesmium are mixotrophs, the high concentrations of DOC may have provided the energy sources to meet the metabolic requirements for N2 fixation and bloom formation. It should be noted that further and dedicated research is merit to test the metabolism strategies of Trichodesmium.
Following the above, our results indicate that anthropogenic contamination such as raw sewage outbursts into oligotrophic environments may not only trigger blooms of T. erythraeum, but also shift microbial community structure. It is likely that these sewage outburst events may have great ecological implications via Trichodesmium blooms in oligotrophic environments such as the SEMS. Yet, we stress that more controlled experiments and in situ monitoring are needed to better understand the dynamics, regulation and formation of Trichodesmium blooms in the SEMS.
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
We would like to thank Galit Ovadia for her assistance in the DNA extractions. This work was supported by grants awarded by the Ministry of National Infrastructure, Energy and Water Resources (grant number 3-11519) to E.R., by the Ministry of Environmental Protection (grant number 145–1–2) to E.R., and by the Israel Water Authority (grant number 4501-284678) to E.B-Z. and E.R.
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.