Doubled haploid (DH) technology based on in vivo haploid induction (HI) increases the breeding efficiency by enabling the rapid production of homozygous inbred lines, which has been widely applied in modern maize breeding1. Via the selective breeding of the ancestral haploid-inducer Stock 6 (ref. 2), modern plant breeders have created a variety of haploid inducers that have high haploid induction rates (HIR) and excellent agronomic traits, including UH400 (ref. 3), RWS (ref. 4) and CAU5 (ref. 5). These HI lines provide an effective method for the mass production of DH lines in commercial maize breeding programmes. Because of its vital application value in modern breeding, the genetic factors controlling this phenomenon have been widely investigated3,6.

To date, many linkage analyses and genome-wide association studies have been performed on the identification of quantitative trait loci (QTLs) to unveil the genetic architecture of HI. Several QTLs related to HIR were identified by using four biparental populations, among which quantitative haploid induction rate 1 (qhir1) in bin 1.04 and quantitative haploid induction rate 8 (qhir8) in bin 9.01 explained ~66% and ~20% of the genetic variance for HI, respectively3. Fine mapping was conducted to narrow the two major QTLs to smaller genomic intervals of 243 kilobases (kb) in bin 1.04 (ref. 7) and 789 kb in bin 9.01 (ref. 8). In addition to the two major QTLs responsible for HI, other QTLs with weaker effects have also been identified3, which suggested that the genetic architecture of HI is much more complex.

In 2017, three different research groups found that the causative allele for HI of qhir1 in the Stock 6 background was a 4-base pairs (bp) insertion in the fourth exon of MTL/ZmPLA1/NLD9,10,11. Given the conservation of MTL/ZmPLA1/NLD in cereals, knockout of MTL/ZmPLA1/NLD orthologues in rice12 and wheat13 also triggered HI. It has been shown that MTL/ZmPLA1/NLD, encoded a pollen-specific patatin-like phospholipase A expressing specifically in vegetative cell but not sperm cell14. Further analysis of subcellular localization revealed that MTL/ZmPLA1/NLD targeted the endo-plasma membrane, a specific membrane derived from vegetative cell that surrounds the two sperm cells in pollen14,15,16. These results implied that phospholipases highly expressed in pollen might play an important role in sexual reproduction. According to the different sites of bond cleavage in their respective phospholipid substrates17, plant phospholipases have been classified as phospholipase A (PLA), phospholipase C (PLC) and phospholipase D (PLD). Previous studies have shown that multiple phospholipase-mediated membrane lipid metabolism processes are involved in the modulation of pollen development18,19,20,21,22,23,24. Arabidopsis DEFECTIVE IN ANTHER DEHISCENCE1 (DAD1), a chloroplastic PLA, was found to be required for pollen maturation, anther dehiscence and flowering, and associated with the accumulation of jasmonic acid in flower buds18. Furthermore, mutants of NON-SPECIFIC PHOSPHOLIPASE C2 (NPC2) and NON-SPECIFIC PHOSPHOLIPASE C2 (NPC6) in Arabidopsis thaliana presented defective pollen tube growth caused by the suppression of phospholipid hydrolysis and triacylglycerol biosynthesis24. PLD‐produced phosphatidic acid plays a key role in polar expansion of pollen tubes, suggesting that PLD-dependent signalling is vital during tip growth and plant cell expansion19.

Recently, Zhong et al.25 identified that a single-nucleotide change in ZmDMP, which encodes a DUF679 domain-containing protein, was present in the causative allele for HI of qhir8. Mutations in ZmDMP resulted in HI with an HIR of 0.1–0.3%, and the HIR increased to 6–10% in the presence of mtl/zmpla1/nld, which suggested that more than one pathway might be involved in the high HIR observed in commercial haploid-inducer lines. Furthermore, mutations in Arabidopsis orthologous genes AtDMP8 and AtDMP9 could also trigger maternal haploids26, whereas no functional MTL/ZmPLA1/NLD orthologous genes were identified in dicots. These findings implied that HI was triggered by genes in different pathways and pyramiding these causative factors together could improve the HIR sharply. Isolating new genes required for HI will contribute to breeding haploid-inducer lines with high HIR, as well as elucidating the mechanisms underlying HI.

In our present study, we demonstrated that knockout of ZmPLD3, a PLD expressed specifically in pollen, triggered HI in maize. Moreover, it enhanced HIR by threefold in the presence of mtl/zmpla1/nld. In addition, pollen transcriptome analysis of zmpld3 and mtl/zmpla1/nld indicated that plenty of pollen-specific genes related to cell communication were differentially expressed in these mutants. Collectively, these findings suggested that ZmPLD3 acted as a synergistic factor together with MTL/ZmPLA1/NLD in HI.


ZmPLD3 encodes a phospholipase expressed specifically in pollen

To characterize the effects of phospholipase-mediated HI in maize, we used RNA-seq data27 from different tissues of maize B73 to identify pollen-specific members of this gene family expressed specifically in pollen (Supplementary Tables 1 and 2). We found that only one member (ZmPLD3) was expressed specifically in pollen (Extended Data Fig. 1) and significantly upregulated in mtl/zmpla1/nld9, which suggested that ZmPLD3 played a role similar to that of MTL/ZmPLA1/NLD. Quantitative PCR with reverse transcription (qRT–PCR) analysis revealed that ZmPLD3 was highly expressed in mature pollen compared with anthers at different developmental stages (Fig. 1c), suggesting that ZmPLD3 might play a role late in pollen developmental stage. ZmPLD3 encodes a putative PLD, which is named for its hydrolytic active-site region (HKD motif, HxKxxxxD)17. Further analysis indicated that two HKD domains are present in ZmPLD3 (Fig. 1a and Extended Data Fig. 2). In addition, we aligned the full-length sequences of PLD family proteins and constructed a phylogenetic tree for all members from the genomes of Zea mays, Oryza sativa and A. thaliana, respectively (Fig. 1b, Extended Data Fig. 2 and Supplementary Table 3). On the basis of their conserved domains and phylogenetic relationships, all these PLDs were classified into three clades (C2-PLD, PXPH-PLD and SP-PLD). ZmPLD3 was grouped into the C2-PLD subfamily, which was consistent with its predicted C2 domain that binds to Ca2+ cofactors17. On the basis of their molecular and enzymatic characteristics, PLD proteins could also be divided into different clades28 and phylogenetic analysis showed that ZmPLD3 clustered on a clade together with the α subfamily of PLD in O. sativa and A. thaliana, of which orthologous genes in Brassica napus were reported to be involved in reproductive development22. The amino acid alignment of ZmPLD3 orthologues in several species showed that ZmPLD3 was highly conserved among cereal crop species (Extended Data Fig. 3). The integration of expression data and the phylogenetic data suggested that pollen-specific ZmPLD3 might have a unique function in male reproductive processes. Thus, we considered ZmPLD3 as a candidate gene responsible for HI for following research.

Fig. 1: Expression characteristics of ZmPLD3.
figure 1

a, Schematic diagram of conserved domains in the ZmPLD3 protein, predicted by Pfam and SMART. The C2 box refers to protein kinase C-conserved region 2; the HKD (HxKxxxxD) boxes refer to conserved catalytic regions. b, Phylogenic analysis of PLD in maize, rice and A. thaliana. The C2-PLD, PXPH-PLD and SP-PLD subfamilies are indicated by blue, green and yellow backgrounds, respectively. c, Relative expression analysis of ZmPLD3 of anther and mature pollen at different developmental stages from the wild type was determined by qRT–PCR. The values are the means ± s.d. of three biologically independent samples (each sample involved three technical repetitions).

Knockout of ZmPLD3 triggered maternal HI in maize

To further investigate its function, we used CRISPR-Cas9 system to knockout ZmPLD3. For CRISPR-Cas9 vector construction, we designed two target sites in different exons of ZmPLD3, one (Target 1) within the second exon, which contains predicted conserved domains, and the other (Target 2) within the first exon (Fig. 2a). The vector construct was subsequently transformed into the inbred line LH244 (a non-inducer) to generate mutant lines. Two mutant lines, zmpld3-1 and zmpld3-2, were screened for further study. Gene zmpld3-1 had a 1-bp insertion in its target region, changing 35 altered amino acids behind the insertion site and truncating 170 amino acids in the protein, whereas zmpld3-2 had both a 5-bp deletion and a 1-bp insertion in its target region, causing seven changed amino acids starting from the mutation site and resulting in premature translation termination (Fig. 2b and Extended Data Fig. 4). Meanwhile, we exploited CRISPR-Cas9 system to generate single-gene mutants of mtl/zmpla1/nld and zmdmp to evaluate their HI efficiency in LH244 genetic background (Extended Data Fig. 5). It was worth noting that zmpld3 mutation showed severe segregation distortion in the population derived from the selfed progeny of heterozygous single mutant, which was similar to that of mtl/zmpla1/nld mutation (Supplementary Table 4).

Fig. 2: Haploid induction phenotypes of ZmPLD3 mutants.
figure 2

a, ZmPLD3 structure with the CRISPR-Cas9 target sites shown. b, The insertion and deletion sites of two allelic mutations (zmpld3-1 and zmpld3-2) are shown in the alignment comparison with the wild-type (WT) sequence. c, Phenotype of the transgenic receptor LH244 (WT) and two allelic mutations (zmpld3-1 and zmpld3-2) of ears produced via self-crossing. The arrows indicate aborted kernels. Scale bars, 1 cm. d, The rates of endosperm aborted kernels (EnAR) were significantly different between the knockout lines and WT in both the self-pollinated and crossed ears. I-1, transgenic receptor line (WT); I-2, zmpld3-1; I-3, zmpld3-2; II-1, ZD958 × transgenic receptor line (WT); II-2, ZD958 × zmpld3-1; II-3, ZD958 × zmpld3-2. Value n indicates the number of ears used for evaluating the HIR and the EnAR and the seed setting rate of each genotype. The plot values are the means ± s.d.; **P < 0.01, ***P < 0.001 (two-sided Mann–Whitney test). e, PCR products of haploid and diploid plants with polymorphic markers between the transgenic receptor line and tester. A DNA marker is shown in the far right lane. H, haploid; D, diploid; LH244, transgenic receptor; ZD958, hybrid tester. f–i, Flow cytometry results (f), overall phenotypes (g), 12th leaves (h) and anthers (i) of representative haploid (left) and diploid (right) plants among the progeny of ZD958 pollinated by ZmPLD3 knockout plants (as males). Scale bars, 10 cm (f), 2 cm (g) and 1 mm (h). In ei, experiments were repeated 206 times and similar results were obtained.

Source data

Both the mutants and wild-type (WT) LH244 were grown in a greenhouse and no obvious differences were observed in their morphological phenotypes from the seedling stage to the mature stage during pollen scattering (Extended Data Fig. 6). However, their self-pollinated ears displayed significant kernel abortion (Fig. 2c,d), which is a key predictor of HI, suggesting that mutation in ZmPLD3 might trigger HI. These homozygous mutants were then used as males to pollinate the ZD958 tester line and haploid kernels were identified via seven polymorphic molecular markers randomly distributed across six chromosomes (Fig. 2e and Extended Data Fig. 7), flow cytometry (Fig. 2f and Extended Data Fig. 8) and phenotypic evaluations (Fig. 2g–i), respectively. The HIR of zmpld3-1 and zmpld3-2 were 0.96% and 0.85% respectively, which did not significantly differ from that of mtl/zmpla1/nld, whereas no haploids were detected among 2,041 individuals from hybrid offspring of ZD958 crossed with the WT (Fig. 3b and Supplementary Table 5). The diversity of the HIR of mtl/zmpla1/nld might be caused by the distinct genetic background and mutation types and a comparison of the HI ability of different genes should exclude these factors. In addition, there was no significant difference in HIR between zmpld3-1 and zmpld3-2, which indicated that the absence of the second HKD domain of ZmPLD3 was sufficient to trigger HI.

Fig. 3: The synergistic effects of zmpld3 and mtl/zmpla1/nld on haploid induction phenotypes.
figure 3

a, Phenotypes of ZD958 ears pollinated by LH244 (wild type), zmpld3-1, mtl/zmpla1/nld, zmdmp, zmpld3-mtl, mtl-zmdmp, zmpld3-zmdmp or zmpld3(+/–)-mtl-zmdmp. The arrows indicate aborted kernels. Scale bars, 2 cm. b, HIR of ZD958 ears pollinated by zmpld3-1, mtl/zmpla1/nld, zmdmp, zmpld3-mtl, mtl-zmdmp, zmpld3-zmdmp or zmpld3(+/–)-mtl-zmdmp. Value n indicates the number of ears used for evaluating the HIR and the EnAR and the seed setting rate of each genotype. c, The EnAR of ZD958 ears pollinated by zmpld3-1, mtl/zmpla1/nld, zmdmp, zmpld3-mtl, mtl-zmdmp, zmpld3-zmdmp or zmpld3(+/–)-mtl-zmdmp. d, The seed setting rate of ZD958 ears pollinated by LH244, zmpld3-1, mtl/zmpla1/nld, zmdmp, zmpld3-mtl, mtl-zmdmp, zmpld3-zmdmp or zmpld3(+/–)-mtl-zmdmp. The values are the means ± s.d.; *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01, ***P < 0.001 (two-sided Mann–Whitney test) (bd).

zmpld3 exhibited synergistic effects with mtl/zmpla1/nld on enhancing the HIR

To determine the effects between zmpld3 and reported genes on HI, we generated double mutants of zmpld3-mtl, zmpld3-zmdmp and mtl-zmdmp via hybridization of the corresponding single-gene mutants. Genotyping of individuals in the segregating population from selfing of heterozygous double mutants revealed that there were different levels of segregation distortion among the three mutants. Mutations of ZmPLD3 and MTL/ZmPLA1/NLD showed severe segregation distortion with similar degree, while mutation of ZmDMP showed slight segregation distortion in the segregating population (Supplementary Table 4). Afterward, F1 individuals derived from ZD958 ears pollinated by homozygous zmpld3-mtl, zmpld3-zmdmp or mtl-zmdmp were screened for their phenotypes related to HI. The statistical data revealed that zmpld3 and mtl/zmpla1/nld exhibited synergistic effects, as the double mutants of zmpld3 and mtl/zmpla1/nld could increase the HIR up to ~4% (Fig. 3b), whereas the HIR of the single mutation in mtl/zmpla1/nld was 1.2%. Meanwhile, the statistical data on average HIR indicated that there was no significant difference between the two genotypes of mtl-zmdmp and zmpld3-mtl (Fig. 3b). However, the average HIR of zmpld3-zmdmp did not significantly increase compared to that of zmpld3, while the HIR of zmpld3 was significantly higher than that of zmdmp (Fig. 3b), implying that little interaction occurred between ZmPLD3 and ZmDMP. The aborted-kernel phenotype of the hybrid ears among the single mutants and double mutants showed concordant effects. The hybrid ears of zmpld3-mtl had significantly more aborted kernels than those of zmpld3-1, whereas no differences were observed between zmpld3-zmdmp and zmpld3-1 (Fig. 3a,c). These findings indicated that zmpld3 and mtl/zmpla1/nld had synergistic effects on improving the HIR rather than functional redundancy, although both ZmPLD3 and MTL/ZmPLA1/NLD belong to the phospholipase family. Notably, double mutant of zmpld3-mtl also resulted in a dramatic decrease in seed setting rate—down to ~70% (Fig. 3d). Pollen fertility via KI staining and pollen viability via pollen germination were measured for both the single and double mutants and no significant differences were observed between these mutants and the WT (Extended Data Fig. 9).

As both of zmpld3 and zmdmp could enhance HIR in the presence of mtl/zmpla1/nld, it would be probable that combination of zmpld3 and mtl/zmpla1/nld and zmdmp could generate an HI line with higher HIR. Among 2,725 individual plants from selfed progeny of heterozygous zmpld3-mtl-zmdmp, we did not obtain the homozygous triple mutant of zmpld3-mtl-zmdmp. Then we found that extreme segregation distortion was only observed for zmpld3 mutation in the population (21 homozygous individuals in the 2,725 selfed offsprings), whereas the segregation-distortion pattern of mtl/zmpla1/nld mutation and zmdmp mutation in triple mutant background resembled that of corresponding single and double mutants (Supplementary Table 4). However, we identified three zmpld3 (+/–)-mtl-zmdmp (mutation of zmpld3 was heterozygous, while mutations of mtl and zmdmp were homozygous), of which pollens were used to pollinate ZD958 ears to evaluate their HIR; the results indicated that the HIR of zmpld3 (+/–)-mtl-zmdmp was significantlly enhanced compared with that of zmpld3-mtl and mtl-zmdmp (Fig. 3b). Further screening of the inbred progeny of the three zmpld3 (+/–)-mtl-zmdmp still did not yield homozygous triple mutant (Supplementary Table 6). It might be caused by pollen defects which were not detected by the standard pollen assays (Extended Data Fig. 9) or fertilization failure of gametes containing zmpld3 mutation in triple mutant background. Therefore, getting the homozygous triple mutant could be very difficult or even impossible.

ZmPLD3 localized to endoplasmic reticulum, plastids, Golgi apparatus and cytosol in maize protoplasts

It has been shown that α subfamily of PLD is present in soluble and membrane-associated fractions and its relative distribution between the two fractions depends on the tissues and developmental stages29. We used markers of different cellular compartments to characterize the subcellular localization of ZmPLD3 using maize protoplast system. The results indicated that ZmPLD3 could localize to the endoplasmic reticulum, plastids, Golgi apparatus and cytosol but probably not the plasma membrane, mitochondria, prevacuolar compartment, nuclear or peroxisome (Fig. 4 and Extended Data Fig. 10). Since transient protoplast expression could not identify the exact localization of ZmPLD3 in pollen, it would be worthwhile to conduct further studies such as stable transformation with its endogenous promoter to confirm the endogenous localization of ZmPLD3 in pollen.

Fig. 4: The subcellular localization of ZmPLD3.
figure 4

a–d, Transient co-expression of 35S::ZmPLD3-eGFP (at the top) or 35S::eGFP (at the bottom) with mCherry-labelled markers of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) (a), plastids (b), Golgi apparatus (c) or cytosol (d) in maize protoplast cells, as determined by confocal laser-scanning microscopy. The experiments were repeated three times and similar results were obtained. Scale bars, 1 μm.

Transcriptome analysis of mutants involved in HI

To identify genes involved in HI affected by the single and double mutations mentioned above, we conducted RNA-seq analysis on mature pollen collected from LH244 (WT), zmpld3, mtl/zmpla1/nld and zmpld3-mtl. Differentially expressed genes (DEGs) in these mutants were identified (false discovery rate (FDR) < 0.05; Fig. 5a and Supplementary Table 7). Gene ontology (GO) functional enrichment analysis of three types of overlapping DEGs among zmpld3 and mtl/zmpla1/nld and zmpld3-mtl revealed that terms related to gametogenesis processes were enriched, such as pollen tube development and multi-organism reproductive processes (FDR < 0.05; Fig. 5c and Supplementary Tables 810). As the detection of pollen viability and germination rate showed no significant difference between the mutants and WT (Extended Data Fig. 9), the pollen of zmpld3 might have altered the polar growth of pollen tubes or disrupted communication with female gametocytes; as such, investigating the changes in zmpld3 pollen is worth further study. Furthermore, we investigated the pollen-specific DEGs in these mutants and 66 out of 210 overlapping DEGs in all three mutants were expressed specifically in pollen (Fig. 5b and Supplementary Table 11). Interestingly, we found that two pollen-specific DEGs (Zm00001d039429 and Zm00001d015414), which colocalized with previously reported QTLs for HI, qhir2 and qhir6, respectively (Table 1), were predicted to be involved in the maintenance of pollen tube integrity30 or pollen tip growth during fertilization31. In addition, five pollen-specific DEGs acted in the maintenance of the degree of pectin methylesterification, the process of which is relevant to pollen tube growth or pollen tube attraction during fertilization32,33. These results suggested that genes involved in cell communication between the two gametophytes during double fertilization might be involved in HI. In addition, we have performed comparative analysis between the overlapping DEGs in our research and that of previous research of MTL9, which showed that only two genes of Zm00001d017246 and Zm00001d044227 from our overlapping DEGs in three mutants (zmpld3, mtl/zmpla1/nld and zmpld3-mtl) were identical to the previous research of MTL1. Zm00001d017246 was pollen-specific and annotated as lung seven transmembrane receptor family protein, whereas Zm00001d044227 was constitutively expressed and unannotated.

Fig. 5: Transcriptional profiling of multiple pathways involved in haploid induction regulated by zmpld3 and mtl/zmpla1/nld.
figure 5

a, Venn diagram illustrates the overlap of DEGs shared among zmpld3, mtl/zmpla1/nld and zmpld3-mtl. The data are derived from RNA-seq of zmpld3 and mtl/zmpla1/nld and zmpld3-mtl pollen samples, each comprising two biologically independent replications. b, Venn diagram illustrates 66 pollen-specific DEGs shared among zmpld3, mtl/zmpla1/nld and zmpld3-mtl. c, GO analyses using a hypergeometric distribution of the top ten significantly enriched GO terms (FDR < 0.05) among the overlapping DEG sets was performed; those shared between zmpld3 and zmpld3-mtl, between mtl and zmpld3-mtl and between zmpld3 and mtl are shown. Colour bar, FDR.

Table 1 Overlapping DEGs identified in zmpld3, mtl and zmpld3-mtl that colocalized with HI-related QTLs


We isolated ZmPLD3 by analysing publicly available RNA-seq data from multiple tissues, including pollen tissue and verified that the loss of function of ZmPLD3 triggered maternal HI in maize. Meanwhile, we have not found that this locus overlaps with previously reported QTLs underlying HI3, suggesting that the ZmPLD3 locus might have not been selected by haploid-inducer breeders. Further research revealed that zmpld3 and mtl/zmpla1/nld showed synergistic effects rather than functional redundancy on improving HI, which implied that ZmPLD3-mediated pathways might interact synergistically with those of MTL/ZmPLA1/NLD in HI. Intracellular localization of ZmPLD3 indicated the possibility that endomembrane transport signalling and lipid metabolism might also be involved in HI. It has been speculated that the mutation in ZmDMP impaired double fertilization and created additional single-fertilization events, thereby enhancing HIR in the presence of mtl/zmpla1/nld6,34. Considering the distinct effects of ZmPLD3 and ZmDMP on HI (Fig. 3), the mechanism underlying HI is more complex than the oversimplified accumulation of components of distinct regulatory pathways. Overall, we inferred that ZmPLD3 might function in distinct pathways paralleling with those of MTL/ZmPLA1/NLD, giving rise to their synergistic effects on HI.

Previous studies have provided compelling evidence for the hypothesis concerning genome elimination in HI35,36,37,38; mutations in MTL/ZmPLA1/NLD might cause all or partial genome instability and continuous chromosome fragmentation. Successful screening of haploid progeny via CRISPR-Cas9-induced mutations through HI editing (HI-Edit)37 or haploid-inducer mediated genome editing (IMGE)38 directly proved that a transient fusion state of sperm and egg cell genomes happened before paternal genome elimination. Although HI-Edit/IMGE enabled the universal application of genome-editing technologies in commercial crop improvement, the average editing efficiency of haploids by the HI-Edit/IMGE system was ~3–4% in maize. In combination with the low HIR of the haploid inducers, the HI-Edit/IMGE system is still inefficient for practical breeding processes. Thus, increasing chromosome elimination-mediated HI would theoretically improve the efficiency of HI-Edit/IMGE. Our RNA-seq data revealed that multiple genes involved in pathways of cell communication between male gametophytes and female gametocytes were significantly changed in zmpld3 and mtl/zmpla1/nld and the altered expression of these genes might lead to male-specific developmental defects and genome elimination during double fertilization, implying that uniparental chromosome elimination might be enhanced in the zmpld3 and mtl/zmpla1/nld double mutants. More data are needed to verify whether altered composition of the pollen of phospholipase-related mutants triggers chromosome fragmentation in sperm cells during fertilization.

In our present study, a reverse genetic strategy such as that for ZmPLD3 represented a novel approach to expand genetic resources for the potential of breeding super haploid inducers. Further studies on pollen-specific DEGs involved in HI will not only contribute to elucidating the molecular network of HI but also offer a high probability that pyramiding these genes via genome editing would generate new haploid inducers with higher HIR. However, additional study is needed to determine whether and how the enhancement of HIR would lead to high cost of reproductive fitness. Moreover, high conservation of ZmPLD3 in cereals might extend its applications to other crops.


Identification of phospholipases in maize and phylogenetic analysis

The amino acid sequences of the members of the phospholipase family in A. thaliana and rice were used as queries to search for homologous sequences in MaizeGDB ( Putative maize phospholipases were further confirmed for the presence of the conserved domains associated with different phospholipase classes (PLA, PLC and PLD) by scanning sequences through the SMART (, Pfam ( and InterPro ( online databases. All maize phospholipases are listed in Supplementary Table 1. The PLD subfamily in A. thaliana, rice and maize was used to construct a phylogenetic tree with the neighbour-joining method by using MEGA-X software. The PLD proteins used to construct the phylogenetic tree are shown in Supplementary Table 3.

Expression and quantitative real-time PCR analysis of ZmPLD3

We used public RNA-seq data from different tissues27 and downloaded them from the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) database ( to identify the expression characteristics of ZmPLD3. Total RNA from 1-mm-long immature anthers, 2-mm-long immature anthers, 3-mm-long immature anthers, 4-mm-long immature anthers and mature pollen from LH244 was extracted using TRIzol reagent (15596026, Invitrogen) and then reverse transcribed into complementary DNA. ZmPLD3-specific primers were designed using Primer-BLAST (the sequences of which are listed in Supplementary Table 12). Quantitative real-time PCR using SYBR Green PCR mix (RR820Q, TaKaRa) was performed with an ABI 7500 system according to the manufacturers’ instructions. Transcript abundance was compared with that of an endogenous control (NADPH) to standardize the starting cDNA amounts and relative expression of ZmPLD3 in each tissue compared with that of the control was calculated via the 2−∆∆CT method.

Subcellular localization of ZmPLD3

The full-length coding sequence of ZmPLD3 without the stop codon was cloned into pCAMBIA1300-35S::eGFP for subcellular localization analysis. The resulting pCAMBIA1300-35S::ZmPLD3-eGFP vector was subsequently cotransformed with AtHDEL-mCherry (an endoplasmic reticulum marker)39, AtSYP61-mCherry (a Golgi marker)40, WxTP-mCherry (a plastid marker)41, AtCBL1-mCherry (a plasma membrane marker)42, AtAHL22-mCherry (a nuclear marker)43, AtVSR2-mCherry (a prevacuolar compartment marker)44, AtPTS1-mCherry (a peroxisome marker)45 or free mCherry (a cytosol marker)46,47 into maize protoplasts. A pCAMBIA1300-35S::eGFP unmodified vector was also cotransformed with the same markers into maize protoplasts, which served as controls. After culturing at 28 °C for 18 h, fluorescent signals were detected using a confocal microscope (Zeiss 880). For observation of mitochondrial localization, only pCAMBIA1300-35S::ZmPLD3-eGFP vector or pCAMBIA1300-35S::eGFP unmodified vector was transformed into maize protoplasts and after culturing at 28 °C for 18 h, protoplasts were incubated with the diluted mitochondrial red fluorescent probe MitoTracker Red (25 nM) (40741ES50; YEASEN) for ~30 min and then detected with confocal microscope.

Plant materials and growth conditions

The transformable line LH244 was provided by the US Department of Agriculture ( All the maize materials were grown in a greenhouse under a 16 h/8 h light/dark photoperiod at 28 °C/24 °C, with the relative humidity held constant. Transgenic plants and ZD958 tester plants were grown in open field in the summer and all the test crosses (include all the mutants and wild type) were carried out in open field in Shangzhuang Experimental Base of China Agricultural University in the same season in Beijing, China. Besides, all the pollinated ears were included in the analysis of kernel abortion and HIR.

Gene editing and detection analysis of edited mutations

The CRISPR-Cas9 system was used to generate zmpld3, mtl and zmdmp mutants. The sequences of the gRNAs of each single-gene mutant were inserted into a binary vector (pCAMBIA3301) expressing Cas9 and gRNA48. The primers used for vector construction are listed in Supplementary Table 12. Embryos of LH244 (at 12 d after pollination (DAP)) were used for Agrobacterium-mediated transformation experiments. In brief, the vectors were transformed into strain EHA105 and a single clone was cultured in liquid YEP media. The prepared Agrobacterium containing the target vectors was used to infect embryos at 12 DAP (1.5–1.8 mm) for 30 min, followed by culturing at 22 °C for 3 d. The cultured embryos were then transferred to selection media and allowed to grow at 28 °C for 2 weeks in darkness. All the calli on the selection media were moved to regeneration media for shooting and rooting. Positive transgenic events were identified via herbicide resistance and verified by DNA sequencing at the seedling stage. Knockout lines with frameshift mutations were transferred to a greenhouse and backcrossed twice to LH244 and then self-pollinated to acquire homozygous knockout mutants without transgenic elements of CRISPR–Cas9 through bialaphos resistance gene (bar) strip tests and PCR sequencing analysis.

Characterization of HI-related phenotypes

HI was performed by crossing different knockout lines with the tester line ZD958. WT LH244 was used to pollinate ZD958 as a control. The seedlings of the F1 population were screened for ploidy via PCR assays. The haploid candidates were determined on the basis of polymorphic markers with polymorphisms between the receptor line and ZD958; the candidates which had only an amplified product corresponding to the maternal line were screened out. These haploid candidates were then further confirmed via flow cytometry (ploidy analysis) and the candidates with peaks similar to those of standard haploids were considered as true haploids1. Moreover, the candidates were grown to observe their phenotypes. Compared with the diploid controls, all these haploids were shorter in height, had narrower leaves (the 12th leaf of each plant was measured) and had smaller anthers. In addition to the HIR, the rate of endosperm aborted kernels (EnAR) was also measured according to the methods of Liu et al.10. Statistical analysis via the Mann–Whitney test was used to assess significance by SigmaPlot 12.5 software and the resulting P values are noted in the figures and captions.

Determination of pollen viability and germination

Fresh pollen samples of LH244, zmpld3-1, zmpld3-2, zmpld3-mtl and zmpld3-zmdmp were collected between 10:00 and 11:00 in the greenhouse and three biological replicates were included for each collection. Pollen viability was measured via 1% KI/I2 solution; after 5 min, the viability was checked by microscope examination. Pollen germination assays were conducted on pollen germination media (10% sucrose, 0.01% boric acid, 0.1% yeast extract, 10 mM CaCl2, 50 μM KH2PO4, 15% polyethylene glycol 4000)49; after 1 h of incubation at 28 °C, the pollen germination rate was evaluated via microscopy to determine the percentage of pollen with elongated tubes.

RNA-seq profiling and analysis

Total RNA of the mature pollen was extracted using TRIzol reagent (Invitrogen) and two biological replicates for each sample were collected for RNA extraction. The mRNA-seq libraries were constructed with an mRNA-seq library preparation kit (Vazyme) and sequenced on an Illumina NovaSeq platform for 150-nucleotide paired-end reads. The B73 reference genome (RefGen_v4)50 sequence was downloaded from After removing low-quality reads using FASTP (v.0.20.1;, the raw reads were aligned to the B73 reference genome using HISAT2 (v.2.2.1, The uniquely mapped reads were used to obtain read counts of each gene in the B73 reference genome by parsing the alignment output files from HISAT2 and then normalizing the resulting read counts via fragments per kilobase of exon model per million mapped fragments (FPKM) using Cufflinks (v.2.2.1)51 to measure the gene expression levels. The agriGO52 online tool was subsequently used to perform a GO analysis. For identification of pollen-specific genes, we used publicly available RNA-seq data27 of 23 different tissue samples downloaded from the NCBI database ( The expression levels across all of the samples were normalized according to the log2(FPKM + 0.01). Using normalized expression levels, we then calculated z-scores of the given genes in pollen and compared them with those of genes in other tissue samples. A gene was determined to be expressed specifically in pollen if it had a z-score >3, its FPKM ≥ 1 and its highest FPKM value was for a gene expressed in pollen. The R package DESeq2 ( was used to identify DEGs in each mutant compared with the WT. P values of all the statistical tests were adjusted to q values and an FDR of 5% was applied. The RNA-seq data have been submitted to the NCBI database and the accession number is PRJNA723300.

Reporting Summary

Further information on research design is available in the Nature Research Reporting Summary linked to this article.