Pathogenic autosomal recessive variants in CAD, encoding the multienzymatic protein initiating pyrimidine de novo biosynthesis, cause a severe inborn metabolic disorder treatable with a dietary supplement of uridine. This condition is difficult to diagnose given the large size of CAD with over 1000 missense variants and the nonspecific clinical presentation. We aimed to develop a reliable and discerning assay to assess the pathogenicity of CAD variants and to select affected individuals that might benefit from uridine therapy.
Using CRISPR/Cas9, we generated a human CAD-knockout cell line that requires uridine supplements for survival. Transient transfection of the knockout cells with recombinant CAD restores growth in absence of uridine. This system determines missense variants that inactivate CAD and do not rescue the growth phenotype.
We identified 25 individuals with biallelic variants in CAD and a phenotype consistent with a CAD deficit. We used the CAD-knockout complementation assay to test a total of 34 variants, identifying 16 as deleterious for CAD activity. Combination of these pathogenic variants confirmed 11 subjects with a CAD deficit, for whom we describe the clinical phenotype.
We designed a cell-based assay to test the pathogenicity of CAD variants, identifying 11 CAD-deficient individuals who could benefit from uridine therapy.
CAD encodes a multienzymatic cytoplasmic protein harboring four functional domains, each catalyzing one of the initial reactions for de novo biosynthesis of pyrimidine nucleotides: glutamine amidotransferase (GLN), carbamoyl phosphate synthetase (SYN), aspartate transcarbamoylase (ATC), and dihydroorotase (DHO)1,2,3 (Fig. 1). This metabolic pathway is essential for nucleotide homeostasis, cell growth, and proliferation.4 Defects in dihydroorotate dehydrogenase (DHODH) or UMP synthetase (UMPS), the enzymes catalyzing the next steps in the pathway after CAD, are associated with severe human disorders (Miller syndrome [OMIM 263750]5 and orotic aciduria [OMIM 258900]6). In 2015, we identified a single individual with early infantile epileptic encephalopathy and two variants in CAD, one an in-frame deletion of an exon and the other a missense variant (p.R2024Q) in a highly conserved residue.7 Metabolic analysis of subject fibroblasts showed impaired CAD activity–dependent incorporation of 3H-labeled aspartate into nucleic acids and nucleotide sugars, precursors for glycoprotein synthesis. Uridine supplements corrected this CAD-associated congenital disorder of glycosylation (CDG; OMIM 616457), suggesting a simple potential treatment. In two subsequent reports, five affected individuals from four unrelated families with similar symptoms showed likely pathogenic variants in CAD, but no functional studies were done.8,9 However, uridine treatment of three suspected individuals showed striking improvement, with cessation of seizures and significant progression from minimally conscious state to communication and walking. Recently, uridine triacetate (Xuriden) was approved by the FDA to treat hereditary orotic aciduria;10 presumably, it could be used to treat affected individuals with CAD deficiency.
The attractiveness of a simple therapy brought 25 suspected individuals to our attention for evaluation. Unfortunately, the metabolic labeling assay using 3H-labeled aspartate has a low resolution and a narrow dynamic range. To have a more reliable and discerning assay, we tested the ability of each variant to rescue growth of a human CAD-knockout cell line that requires uridine supplements for survival. Surprisingly, only 11 of 25 suspected individuals had pathologic variants and would potentially benefit from uridine supplements. We describe the development of this functional assay, the general clinical phenotype, and analysis of these individuals. We caution about relying on current prediction programs to assess pathogenicity of variants for this large multifunctional enzyme.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Informed consent was provided by all subjects in accordance with each clinician’s individual institution. Additional consent to analyze samples was provided in accordance with Sanford Burnham Prebys Medical Discovery Institute (IRB-2014-038-17).
pSpCas9 (BB)-2A-Puro (PX459) vector (Addgene), encoding Cas9, was digested with BbsI and purified with Qiaquick Gel Extraction kit (Qiagen). Complementary double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) oligonucleotides encoding single guide RNA (sgRNA), designed to target the first exon of CAD, were purchased (Sigma) with 5’ overhangs complementary to the BbsI site and an extra G base to favor transcription11 (Table S1). The oligonucleotides were phosphorylated with T4 polynucleotide kinase (NEB), annealed, and inserted in the linearized vector with T4 DNA ligase (NEB). The construct was amplified in TOP10 E. coli cells (ThermoFisher), verified by sequencing, and purified with a Plasmid Midi kit (Qiagen).
Enhanced green fluorescent protein (GFP) coding sequence was obtained by HindIII and KpnI digestion of pPEU2 vector (kindly provided by Dr. Nick Berrow, IRB Barcelona), and ligated into pCDNA3.1 (Promega) linearized with same restrictions enzymes. The resulting plasmid (pcDNA3.1-GFP) was verified by sequencing. Human CAD was polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplified from complementary DNA (cDNA) (Open Biosystems clone ID 5551082) using specific primers (Table S1) and ligated with In-Fusion (Clontech) into NotI linearized pcDNA3.1-GFP. The resulting plasmid (pcDNA3.1-GFPhuCAD) encodes an N-terminal histidine-tagged GFP followed in-frame by human CAD. Site-directed mutagenesis was carried out following the QuickChange protocol (Stratagene) and a pair of specific oligonucleotides (Table S1) and PfuUltra High-Fidelity DNA polymerase (Agilent).
Generating a CAD-knockout cell line
Human U2OS (bone osteosarcoma) cells were grown in DMEM (Lonza), 10% fetal bovine serum (FBS; Sigma), 2 mM L-glutamine (Lonza), and 50 U·ml−1 penicillin and 50 μg·ml−1 streptomycin (Invitrogen), at 5% CO2 and 37 °C. One day before transfection, 1.5–2 × 105 U2OS cells in a final volume of 500 µl of medium were transferred to 24-well plates to reach approximately 50–80% confluence. For transfection, 2 µg of DNA in 50 µl of DMEM and 50 µl of FuGene6 transfection reagent (Promega) at 1 mg·ml−1 in DMEM were incubated separately for 5 minutes at room temperature, and then mixed together and incubated at room temperature for an additional 10 minutes. The 100 µl mix was added to the wells drop by drop, followed by a 16-hour incubation at 37 °C and 5% CO2. Twenty-four hours post transfection, puromycin was added for one week to select transfected cells and enhance Cas9 cleavage. Media was supplemented with 30 µM uridine (Sigma) to allow growth of CAD-deficient cells. Individual cells were isolated by serial dilution in 96-well plates, seeded into 24-well plates, and expanded for 2–3 weeks. To identify CAD-deficient clones, a replica of the plate was grown in media with 10% fetal bovine macroserum (FBM) without uridine, instead of FBS. FBM was prepared as reported.12 In brief, 50 ml of heat-inactivated FBS were dialyzed against 1 L of tap water for 1 day at 4 °C using SpectraPor #3 dialysis tubing with a molecular weight cutoff of 3500 Da (Spectrum Laboratories, Inc., USA), supplemented with NaCl (9 g per liter), sterilized with a 0.22-µm filter, and stored at −20 °C. Disruption of CAD was confirmed by Sanger sequencing. For this, exon 1 of CAD was PCR amplified with specific primers (Table S1), inserted in ZeroBlunt vector (Invitrogen) and sequenced with M13 primer. CAD-deficient cells were confirmed by western blot and immunofluorescence microscopy using a monoclonal antibody (Cell Signaling Technology, #93925).
Growth complementation assay
U2OS CAD-KO cells were transfected with wild-type (WT) or mutated pcDNA3.1-GFPhuCAD using FuGene6 as detailed above. One day after transfection, 1 × 105 cells were seeded by duplicate in 24-well plates using media supplemented with 10% FBM (without uridine). Every 24 hours, cells from one well were trypsinized and counted using a Countess II FL Automated Cell Counter (Thermo) or a Neubauer chamber. Doubling time was calculated using an online tool (http://www.doubling-time.com/compute.php).
Validation of a growth complementation assay in CAD-knockout cells
We wanted to create a CAD-knockout (KO) cell line that could be used to assess the pathogenicity of CAD variants. Using CRISPR/Cas9 technology, we knocked out CAD in human U2OS cells by selecting an isogenic clone that introduced a homozygous c.70delG frameshift (p.Ala24Profs*27) within exon 1 (Fig. 2a–c). We verified by western blot and immunofluorescence that CAD-KO cells do not express CAD (Fig. 2c, d). As expected, these cells are unable to grow in absence of uridine, but proliferate at similar rate as WT cells in media supplemented with 30 µM exogenous uridine (Fig. 2e). Next, we transiently transfected KO cells with a plasmid encoding human CAD fused to the enhanced GFP at the N-terminus (Fig. 2f). CAD-KO cells expressing GFP-CAD proliferated in uridine-deprived conditions at a normal rate (doubling time ∼1 day), whereas cells transfected with GFP alone did not grow (Fig. 2g).
To confirm that all four enzymatic activities of CAD were needed for de novo pyrimidine synthesis and cell growth in absence of uridine, we measured the proliferation of CAD-KO cells transfected with GFP-CAD bearing well-known inactivating variants for each activity (Fig. 2g). The transfected inactivated variants in the SYN (p.H627N, p.E682Q),13,14 DHO (p.D1686N),15 and ATC (p.R2024Q)7,16 domains failed to rescue the growth of CAD-KO cells. In turn, the GLN inactive mutant (p.C252S)17 showed a partial rescue, with transfected cells doubling every ∼2.5 days, suggesting that free ammonia can, to some extent, contribute to the synthesis of carbamoyl phosphate (Fig. 1).
Identification and impact of potential CAD variants
Since CAD encodes a large protein with 2225 amino acids covering 44 exons (Fig. 2a), it is not surprising that all previously reported (n = 6) affected individuals were identified using next-generation sequencing (NGS).7,8,9 Likewise, using NGS we identified 25 potential CAD-deficient individuals based on the presence of biallelic variants and a clinical phenotype similar to previously reported individuals (Table 1). Ultimately, we tested 34 variants of uncertain significance (VUS) in our validated knockout assay.
To assess the damaging potential of variants found in subjects, we transfected CAD-KO cells with GFP-CAD bearing the clinical variants and monitored proliferation in uridine-deprived conditions (Fig. 3a–d). Each newly constructed plasmid carrying an individual-specific variant required complete sequencing of the ∼8 kb GFP-CAD cDNA to ensure no additional changes were introduced during PCR. We also verified the efficiency of the transfection (>95%) and that the mutated proteins were being expressed by imaging the GFP fluorescence signal in the CAD-KO cells two days after transfection (data not shown).
Three of the seven variants found in the GLN domain, p.M33R, p.G296E, and p.N320S, showed a partial rescue (Fig. 3a). The doubling time was similar to the cells transfected with the GLN inactivating variant p.C252S (Fig. 2g), indicating that these variants impair the GLN domain. On the other hand, cells transfected with SYN variants p.G526R, p.R742Q, p.P796T, p.V999M, and p.R1033Q failed to proliferate, whereas the variant p.P1171Q showed a partial rescue (Fig. 3b). Of the eight variants of the DHO domain tested, only two, p.K1556T and p.R1785C, failed to restore cell growth (Fig. 3c). For the ATC variants, three variants, p.R1986Q, p.L1987V and p.P2186S, failed to rescue the cells, whereas p.R2110L and p.E2128K allowed a partial rescue (Fig. 3d). Finally, transfection with the two variants found at the linker between the DHO and ATC domains (p.R1854Q and p.R1857Q) restored normal growth (Fig. 3d).
Based on these results, we concluded that the failure to rescue the growth phenotype of CAD-KO cells in absence of uridine indicates that 16 of the 34 variants tested have a deleterious effect on CAD activity and therefore are pathogenic.
Interestingly, significant differences were seen when comparing the results of the KO assay with three popular in silico prediction programs (SIFT,18 PolyPhen-2,19 CADD20) (Table 1). All three prediction programs agreed with each other for 20/34 variants (59%; 15/34 pathogenic, 5/34 benign variants). Yet only 38% (13/34) (9/34 pathogenic, 4/34 benign) of the variants agreed in all three prediction programs and the complementation assay. We used a CADD PHRED score of above 20, which places a variant in the top 1% deleterious variants in the human genome as potentially pathogenic. Below 20, we considered likely benign.
The mechanisms of inactivation of the pathogenic variants will be described in a separate study.
To date, only six affected individuals from five unrelated families have been identified with CAD deficiencies.7,8,9 The clinical presentation is general in nature, but all these individuals showed varying severities of neurological involvement including developmental delays and/or seizures. Furthermore, all had hematological abnormalities including abnormal red blood cells (anisopoikilocytosis) and anemia. Two of the six are reported to be deceased, while the remaining four received uridine.
In this study, we identified 25 individuals with biallelic variants in CAD, who presented with a phenotype potentially consistent with CAD deficiency. We used the CAD-KO complementation assay described above to determine the pathogenicity of each variant identified and ultimately confirmed 11 CAD-deficient subjects (Table 1, Fig. 3e).
Detailed clinical information was available and provided for 10 of the 11 confirmed individuals (Fig. 4). Consistent with the initial CAD-deficient individuals,7,8 all ten individuals presented here showed varying neurological abnormalities. All had intellectual and developmental disability, while 9/10 (90%) had seizure activity. Gastrointestinal complications ranging from feeding problems, reflux, and recurrent vomiting were seen in half (5/10) of the individuals, as was facial dysmorphism, hypotonia, and ataxia. All five of the previously identified subjects showed hematological abnormalities, while in our cohort this was 4/10 (40%). Less affected systems included the skeleton (3/10) and the heart (2/10).
In our cohort, one individual was noted to have died (CDG-0118). However, four families (0017, 0104, 0118, 0123) were noted to have a family history of multiple affected siblings with a similar presentation. From these four families, three had at least one sibling with a similar disorder who expired.
Due to the lack of detailed clinical information, CDG-0117 was not included in the final summary. However, he was noted to have structural brain abnormalities and a family history significant for premature death in two affected female siblings. Importantly, genomic DNA was available for one of the two deceased siblings and was found to also carry the same homozygous c.5957G>A [p.R1986Q] CAD variant.
One family (CDG-0112) had a dual diagnosis of CAD deficiency and a recessive intellectual developmental disorder with cardiac arrhythmia (OMIM 617173). Within this family, both affected siblings harbored a homozygous pathogenic c.249+3A>G [p.Asp84Valfs31*] variant in GNB5,21 but only the male sibling carried the pathogenic homozygous c.3098G>A [p.R1033Q] variant in CAD. Given the clinical similarities of these two disorders, especially the neurological features, we cannot determine which symptoms are due to specifically the CAD variant alone.
The prospect of a simple, nontoxic therapy for a potentially lethal disorder excites all stakeholders: patients, caretakers, physicians, and scientists. Identifying the first CAD-deficient individual and showing that uridine corrects cellular defects set the stage for the highly successful use of uridine in two CAD-deficient individuals.7,8 As a result, and given the nonspecific clinical presentation of CAD-deficient individuals, we received many requests to test subject fibroblasts in a functional assay that involves labeling cells with 3H-aspartate to measure the CAD-dependent contribution to de novo pyrimidine synthesis (Fig. 1). However, the assay has a limited dynamic range (~2-fold) and many determinations left us ambivalent and uncertain about the diagnosis. Thus, a new robust and reliable biochemical assay was required to evaluate the pathogenicity of CAD variants.
We designed a CAD-knockout cell line whose growth was dependent on added uridine (Fig. 2) and then tested each variant for its ability to rescue uridine-independent growth (Fig. 3a–d). Most of the variants either fully rescued growth, meaning the variants were benign, or were unable to rescue growth completely, showing they were pathologic variants. Only a few showed partial rescue, which we interpret to mean a damaging variant that decreases, but does not eliminate the activity. When each variant was combined based on individual-specific genotyping, we determined which individuals indeed had a CAD deficiency and therefore predict which ones would benefit from uridine therapy (Fig. 3e and Table 1). This is a stringent prediction based on each single variant. It does not test the specific combination of alleles found in each individual, but we assume the combination of two variants would not cancel each other to generate a fully capable CAD protein. If this were the case, it is unlikely that the individuals themselves would show the expected clinical phenotype. Surprisingly only 11 of the 25 suspected individuals appeared to be authentic cases based on this functional assay.
We also compared our assay results with three prediction programs designed to assess the pathogenicity of each variant (Table 1). There was considerable disagreement between the programs for many variants, and the programs produced both false positive and false negative results. Based on these findings, we suggest that any suspected CAD cases first be validated using this (or similar) biochemical assay. And it is likely that more putative CAD-deficient cases will be suspected, since CAD has ~1020 missense rare variants in the public gnomAD browser (Ver2.1.1) database (https://gnomad.broadinstitute.org; accessed 23 January 2020 with 125,748 exomes and 15,708 genomes). Some families may choose to start uridine therapy without benefit of these results. That is certainly possible since the uridine is available to families and subjects over the Internet. Barring the consumption of impure products, uridine is unlikely to be harmful. On the other hand, using uridine supplements in unconfirmed subjects may offer false hopes and complicate the interpretation of successful uridine therapy.
Del Cano-Ochoa F, Moreno-Morcillo M, Ramon-Maiques S. CAD, a multienzymatic protein at the head of de novo pyrimidine biosynthesis. Subcell Biochem. 2019;93:505–538.
Del Cano-Ochoa F, Ramon-Maiques S. The multienzymatic protein CAD leading the de novo biosynthesis of pyrimidines localizes exclusively in the cytoplasm and does not translocate to the nucleus. Nucleosides Nucleotides Nucleic Acids. 2020 Jan 30; https://doi.org/10.1080/15257770.2019.1706743 [Epub ahead of print].
Jones ME. Pyrimidine nucleotide biosynthesis in animals: genes, enzymes, and regulation of UMP biosynthesis. Annu Rev Biochem. 1980;49:253–279.
Sigoillot FD, Berkowski JA, Sigoillot SM, Kotsis DH, Guy HI. Cell cycle-dependent regulation of pyrimidine biosynthesis. J Biol Chem. 2003;278:3403–3409.
Ng SB, Buckingham KJ, Lee C, et al. Exome sequencing identifies the cause of a mendelian disorder. Nat Genet. 2010;42:30–35.
Smith LH, Sullivan M, Huguley CM. Pyrimidine metabolism in man. IV. The enzymatic defect of orotic aciduria. J Clin Invest. 1961;40:656–664.
Ng BG, Wolfe LA, Ichikawa M, et al. Biallelic mutations in CAD, impair de novo pyrimidine biosynthesis and decrease glycosylation precursors. Hum Mol Genet. 2015;24:3050–3057.
Koch J, Mayr JA, Alhaddad B, et al. CAD mutations and uridine-responsive epileptic encephalopathy. Brain. 2017;140 (Pt 2):279–286.
Zhou L, Xu H, Wang T, Wu Y. A patient with CAD deficiency responsive to uridine and lietrature review. Front Neurol. 2020;11:5.
In brief: uridine triacetate (Xuriden) for hereditary orotic aciduria. Med Lett Drugs Ther. 2016;58:e49.
Ran FA, Hsu PD, Wright J, Agarwala V, Scott DA, Zhang F. Genome engineering using the CRISPR-Cas9 system. Nat Protoc. 2013;8:2281–2308.
Patterson D, Carnright DV. Biochemical genetic analysis of pyrimidine biosynthesis in mammalian cells: I. Isolation of a mutant defective in the early steps of de novo pyrimidine synthesis. Somatic Cell Genet. 1977;3:483–495.
Miles BW, Mareya SM, Post LE, Post DJ, Chang SH, Raushel FM. Differential roles for three conserved histidine residues within the large subunit of carbamoyl phosphate synthetase. Biochemistry. 1993;32:232–240.
Stapleton MA, Javid-Majd F, Harmon MF, et al. Role of conserved residues within the carboxy phosphate domain of carbamoyl phosphate synthetase. Biochemistry. 1996;35:14352–14361.
Grande-Garcia A, Lallous N, Diaz-Tejada C, Ramon-Maiques S. Structure, functional characterization, and evolution of the dihydroorotase domain of human CAD. Structure. 2014;22:185–198.
Ruiz-Ramos A, Velazquez-Campoy A, Grande-Garcia A, Moreno-Morcillo M, Ramon-Maiques S. Structure and functional characterization of human aspartate transcarbamoylase, the target of the anti-tumoral drug PALA. Structure. 2016;24:1081–1094.
Rubino SD, Nyunoya H, Lusty CJ. Catalytic domains of carbamyl phosphate synthetase. Glutamine-hydrolyzing site of Escherichia coli carbamyl phosphate synthetase. J Biol Chem. 1986;261:11320–11327.
Sim NL, Kumar P, Hu J, Henikoff S, Schneider G, Ng PC. SIFT web server: predicting effects of amino acid substitutions on proteins. Nucleic Acids Res. 2012;40:W452–W457.
Adzhubei IA, Schmidt S, Peshkin L, et al. A method and server for predicting damaging missense mutations. Nat Methods. 2010;7:248–249.
Rentzsch P, Witten D, Cooper GM, Shendure J, Kircher M. CADD: predicting the deleteriousness of variants throughout the human genome. Nucleic Acids Res. 2019;47(D1):D886–D894.
Lodder EM, De Nittis P, Koopman CD, et al. GNB5 mutations cause an autosomal-recessive multisystem syndrome with sinus bradycardia and cognitive disability. Am J Hum Genet. 2016;99:704–710.
This work was supported by The Rocket Fund, by R01DK99551 to H.H.F., and by grants BFU2016–80570-R and RTI2018–098084-B-100 from the Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation (AEI/FEDER, UE) and with partial support from U54 NS115198. The University of Washington Center for Mendelian Genomics for exome sequencing and analysis of CDG-0117. We thank all the families for providing biological samples and their continued support. We also thank the clinicians who provided information for individuals who were determined not to be CAD-deficient.
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
del Caño-Ochoa, F., Ng, B.G., Abedalthagafi, M. et al. Cell-based analysis of CAD variants identifies individuals likely to benefit from uridine therapy. Genet Med 22, 1598–1605 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41436-020-0833-2
- congenital disorder of glycosylation
- de novo pyrimidine biosynthesis
- carbamoyl phosphate synthetase
- aspartate transcarbamoylase