Abstract
Constitutional heterozygous mutations in CHEK2 gene have been associated with hereditary cancer risk. To date, only a few homozygous CHEK2 mutations have been reported in families with cancer susceptibility. Here, we report two unrelated individuals with a personal and familial cancer history in whom biallelic CHEK2 alterations were identified. The first case resulted homozygous for the CHEK2 c.793-1 G > A (p.Asp265Thrfs*10) variant, and the second one was found to be compound heterozygous for the c.1100delC (p.Thr367Metfs*15) and the c.1312 G > T (p.Asp438Tyr) variants. Multiple cytogenetic anomalies were demonstrated on peripheral lymphocytes of both patients. A literature revision showed that a single other CHEK2 homozygous variant was previously associated to a constitutional randomly occurring multi-translocation karyotype from peripheral blood in humans. We hypothesize that, at least some biallelic CHEK2 mutations might be associated with a novel disorder, further expanding the group of chromosome instability syndromes. Additional studies on larger cohorts are needed to confirm if chromosomal instability could represent a marker for CHEK2 constitutionally mutated recessive genotypes, and to investigate the cancer risk and the occurrence of other anomalies typically observed in chromosome instability syndromes.
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
A hereditary cancer syndrome is present when an individual has an increased cancer risk due to an inherited genetic variant. Among the known monogenic cancer risk factors, dominant mutations in CHEK2 gene, which is involved in the preservation of genomic integrity, have been associated to breast, prostate, colorectal, thyroid, gastric and kidney cancers [1]. CHEK2 codes for the checkpoint kinase 2 (CHK2) protein, that is involved in cell cycle regulation through the ATM-CHK2-p53 pathway [1]. In response to DNA damage (Double Strand Breaks, DSBs), CHK2 prevents the entry into mitosis, leading to cell cycle arrest. In addition, CHK2 phosphorylates BRCA1 and allows this protein to intervene in the Homologous Recombination (HR) repair of DSBs to restore cell survival after DNA damage [2]. CHEK2 alterations are most frequently found in heterozygosity [1], but few cases of homozygous CHEK2 mutations have been described in patients with hereditary cancer syndromes [3,4,5,6,7].
Here we present two unrelated individuals with personal and familial history of different neoplasms, carrying biallelic CHEK2 alterations: one homozygous case for the CHEK2 NM_007194.3:c.793-1 G>A (p.Asp265Thrfs*10), and one compound heterozygous case for the c.1100delC (p.Thr367Metfs*15) and the c.1312 G>T (p.Asp438Tyr). Both cases presented with chromosomal instability in peripheral lymphocytes.
Materials and methods
The probands (Fig. 1: Family A case III:2; Family B case III:4) were selected from those patients attending an outpatient service at San Camillo-Forlanini hospital (Rome, Italy). They gave informed consent for the genetic analyses, approved by local ethic committees in accordance with the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki. Genomic DNA and RNA from peripheral blood were extracted by standard methods. The probands were tested for 113 genes related to cancer susceptibility by the TruSight Hereditary Cancer Panel on NextSeq550Dx sequencer (Illumina, San Diego, USA). Sequencing reads were aligned to the human reference genome (UCSC hg19) by BWA (v0.7.7-isis-1.0.2). Variant calling was performed by GATK Variant Caller (v1.6-23-gf0210b3). DNA changes were filtered by MAF < 0.05 (GnomAD v2.1) and classified according to ACMG-AMP criteria [8]. Filtered variants were validated and tested in other family members by Sanger sequencing. The RNA from case III:2 (Family A) was retro-transcribed and then sequenced by Sanger technique.
Cytogenetic analysis was performed on heparinised peripheral blood sample. Two cell cultures were set up for each patient. In the first one, lymphocyte analysis was performed by standard methods: whole blood was incubated for 72 h in a culture medium containing phytohemagglutinin (PHA). The second cell culture was performed by a synchronization of the cell cycle: whole blood was incubated for 48 h in a culture medium. Then, a methotrexate solution (Amethopterin, 10-5 M, Top Syncro) was added. Thymidine was supplemented after 17 h. Finally, colcemid solution was added, and cells were resuspended in hypotonic solution, fixed and G-stained. For each cell culture, 100 metaphases were studied with Nikon microscope and Genikon software.
Results
Family A
The proband was an Italian 63-year-old woman. She was born to a consanguineous mating. Both her mother and father survived old age (81 and 85-years respectively), without any cancer. Her personal and familial history of neoplasms is described in Fig. 1. The proband was found to carry the CHEK2 c.793-1 G>A variant in homozygosity, while one of her brother and her sister were found to be heterozygous carriers. cDNA sequencing of the proband revealed, as previously demonstrated by Agiannitopoulos and colleagues [9], that the presence of the c.793-1 G>A allele led to the loss of the first nucleotide of exon 7, determining the formation of a premature termination codon ten residues downstream (p.Asp265Thrfs*10) (Supplementary Fig. 1A, B). Karyotype analysis on 100 metaphases of the proband revealed different chromosomal alterations (Table 1 and Supplementary Fig. 2). Karyotype analysis on 100 metaphases of case III:5 did not show any chromosomal alteration.
Family B
The proband was a 65-year-old Italian woman who was diagnosed with papillary thyroid cancer at the age of 48. She had been previously diagnosed with unilateral metachronous breast carcinoma respectively at age 34 and 47. Both breast lesions resulted hormone receptor positive and HER2 negative. In addition, in the patient a hamartoma in the right middle lung lobe was incidentally found after the first diagnosis of breast cancer. The proband’s family is described in Fig. 1. The proband as well as two out of her three sisters were found to carry the CHEK2 c.1100delC (p.Thr367Metfs*15) and the c.1312 G>T (p.Asp438Tyr) variants in compound heterozygosity, while the daughter and mother were monoallelic carriers of respectively the c.1100delC and the c.1312 G>T. Karyotype analysis on 100 metaphases from the proband, her sisters and her daughter, revealed in each, different proportions of chromosomal alterations (Table 1 and Supplementary Fig. 2). At physical examination, both the probands did not show any remarkable phenotypic features.
Discussion
In this study, we described two unrelated cases with biallelic pathogenic variants in CHEK2. The proband of family A was homozygous for the c.793-1 G>A and developed multiple breast cancer and multiple meningiomas. The proband of family B, as well as two of her sisters, were found compound heterozygotes for the c.1100delC (p.Thr367Metfs*15) and the c.1312 G>T (p.Asp438Tyr), and developed different neoplasms including, breast, thyroid and desmoid tumor. To date, six others different CHEK2 variants have been reported in homozygosity in patients with multiorgan tumorigenesis (Table 2).
Our probands’ history of neoplasms reflects what has been already reported in women with biallelic CHEK2 mutations, in whom the risk for invasive breast cancer is higher compared to monoallelic CHEK2 deleterious variant carriers [10, 11]. Nevertheless, even if a recent study reported that in a large cohort of cases carrying CHEK2 alterations, the prevalence of breast and colorectal cancer was higher in the biallelic cohort compared to the heterozygous cohort, the difference was not statistically significant [12]. However, some evidence suggests possible genotype-phenotype correlations that might modulate the penetrance of CHEK2 alterations [12, 13]. For instance, in family A, the CHEK2 c.793-1 G > A variant, when present in heterozygosity, seems to display incomplete penetrance as highlighted by case III:3.
The present probands developed neoplasms other than breast cancer. While thyroid cancer has been already associated to CHEK2 mutations [7], meningeal tumors have not been previously associated to these mutations. Nevertheless, 22q deletions, which is often observed in meningiomas as somatic mutations, frequently involve codeletion of NF2 and CHEK2. When this happens, the meningioma tends to show chromosomal instability further probing a possible role of CHK2 in genomic instability [14]. Remarkably, in family B, the father of the proband developed a meningioma, but his genotype remains unknown.
Interestingly, lymphocytes of both probands exhibited multiple chromosomal structural rearrangements. The addition of the methotrexate to the cell culture seemed to increase the rate of chromosomal rearrangements (Table 1). This finding is in line with the known role of methotrexate in inducing DNA damage [15]. In the heterozygous carrier of the c.793-1 G>A, the karyotype analysis did not show any alteration, suggesting that the expression of the wild type allele might protect against genomic instability. The homozygosity for the c.793-1 G>A, compared to the c.1100delC/c.1312 G>T compound heterozygosity, seemed to associate to a higher chromosomal rearrangements rate. While the c.1100delC and the c.793-1 G > A are established pathogenic CHEK2 variants, the functional role of the c.1312 G>T is still uncertain, with some studies reporting a residual CHK2 activity [16]. We assume that the c.1100delC variant in the context of CHK2 dimerization might hinder the residual kinase activity of the c.1312 G>T variant. We hypothesize that the c.1312 G>T is a low penetrance allele that, when acting together with a pathogenic CHEK2 variant, modulates its function also according to interindividual differences. Indeed, between the three compound heterozygous cases, only one had a significant rate of chromosomal imbalances. Moreover, as for case II:4 in family B, we cannot exclude that the c.1312 G>T might per se increase the cancer susceptibility.
Reciprocal translocations generally result from a Double Strand Break followed by the swapping of chromosomal arms between heterologous chromosomes and subsequent repair of the DSB. Two major pathways for DSBs repair have been described: HR and non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) [17]. Furthermore, single strand annealing (SSA) and alternative end joining (alt-EJ) have been reported as parallel and more error-prone repairing processes [17]. The exact contribution to genome rearrangements [18]. In the context of a biallelic CHEK2 alteration, HR could be compromised [2] and then superseded by other repair processes [19].
We suggest that genome instability, revealed by multiple rearrangements in peripheral blood karyotype, could be a marker of CHEK2 biallelic germline alterations, thus expanding the group of chromosomal instability syndromes. These are recessively inherited conditions associated with defects in DNA repair and increased cancer risk [20], including: Fanconi anemia, ataxia telangiectasia, Nijmegen syndrome and Bloom syndrome [20]. In patients with biallelic mutations, these syndromes are diagnosed by a personal/familial cancer history, as well as by small body size, congenital anomalies, and quite distinct chromosomal alterations. Notably, the heterozygous carriers may have an increased cancer risk, but do not show neither congenital anomalies nor karyotype alterations [20].
In conclusion, we propose to perform karyotype analysis in biallelic carriers of CHEK2 constitutional changes. In addition, CHEK2 should be sequenced in those individuals with multiple chromosomal rearrangements at karyotype analysis, as well as in all patients with oncological personal/family history and a clinical phenotype including the anomalies observed in chromosome instability syndromes.
Data availability
The data generated and analysed during this study can be found within the published article.
References
Stolarova L, Kleiblova P, Janatova M, Soukupova J, Zemankova P, Macurek L, et al. CHEK2 germline variants in cancer predisposition: stalemate rather than checkmate. Cells. 2020;9:2675.
Zhang J, Willers H, Feng Z, Ghosh JC, Kim S, Weaver DT, et al. Chk2 phosphorylation of BRCA1 regulates DNA double-strand break repair. Mol Cell Biol. 2004;24:708–18.
Paperna T, Sharon-Shwartzman N, Kurolap A, Goldberg Y, Moustafa N, Carasso Y, et al. Homozygosity for CHEK2 p.Gly167Arg leads to a unique cancer syndrome with multiple complex chromosomal translocations in peripheral blood karyotype. J Med Genet. 2020;57:500–4.
Kukita Y, Okami J, Yoneda-Kato N, Nakamae I, Kawabata T, Higashiyama M, et al. Homozygous inactivation of CHEK2 is linked to a familial case of multiple primary lung cancer with accompanying cancers in other organs. Cold Spring Harb Mol Case Stud. 2016;2:a001032.
van Puijenbroek M, van Asperen CJ, van Mil A, Devilee P, van Wezel T, Morreau H. Homozygosity for a CHEK2*1100delC mutation identified in familial colorectal cancer does not lead to a severe clinical phenotype. J Pathol. 2005;206:198–204.
Janiszewska H, Bak A, Skonieczka K, Jaskowiec A, Kielbinski M, Jachalska A, et al. Constitutional mutations of the CHEK2 gene are a risk factor for MDS, but not for de novo AML. Leuk Res. 2018;70:74–8.
Kaczmarek-Rys M, Ziemnicka K, Hryhorowicz ST, Gorczak K, Hoppe-Golebiewska J, Skrzypczak-Zielinska M, et al. The c.470 T > C CHEK2 missense variant increases the risk of differentiated thyroid carcinoma in the Great Poland population. Hered Cancer Clin Pr. 2015;13:8.
Richards S, Aziz N, Bale S, Bick D, Das S, Gastier-Foster J, et al. Standards and guidelines for the interpretation of sequence variants: a joint consensus recommendation of the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics and the Association for Molecular Pathology. Genet Med. 2015;17:405–24.
Agiannitopoulos K, Papadopoulou E, Tsaousis GN, Pepe G, Kampouri S, Kocdor MA, et al. Characterization of the c.793-1G > A splicing variant in CHEK2 gene as pathogenic: a case report. BMC Med Genet. 2019;20:131.
Adank MA, Jonker MA, Kluijt I, van Mil SE, Oldenburg RA, Mooi WJ, et al. CHEK2*1100delC homozygosity is associated with a high breast cancer risk in women. J Med Genet. 2011;48:860–3.
Stradella A, Del Valle J, Rofes P, Feliubadalo L, Grau Garces E, Velasco A, et al. Does multilocus inherited neoplasia alleles syndrome have severe clinical expression? J Med Genet. 2019;56:521–5.
Sutcliffe EG, Stettner AR, Miller SA, Solomon SR, Marshall ML, Roberts ME, et al. Differences in cancer prevalence among CHEK2 carriers identified via multi-gene panel testing. Cancer Genet. 2020;246-7:12–7.
Graffeo R, Rana HQ, Conforti F, Bonanni B, Cardoso MJ, Paluch-Shimon S, et al. Moderate penetrance genes complicate genetic testing for breast cancer diagnosis: ATM, CHEK2, BARD1 and RAD51D. Breast. 2022;65:32–40.
Yang HW, Kim TM, Song SS, Shrinath N, Park R, Kalamarides M, et al. Alternative splicing of CHEK2 and codeletion with NF2 promote chromosomal instability in meningioma. Neoplasia. 2012;14:20–8.
Xie L, Zhao T, Cai J, Su Y, Wang Z, Dong W. Methotrexate induces DNA damage and inhibits homologous recombination repair in choriocarcinoma cells. Onco Targets Ther. 2016;9:7115–22.
Delimitsou A, Fostira F, Kalfakakou D, Apostolou P, Konstantopoulou I, Kroupis C, et al. Functional characterization of CHEK2 variants in a Saccharomyces cerevisiae system. Hum Mutat. 2019;40:631–48.
Oh JM, Myung K. Crosstalk between different DNA repair pathways for DNA double strand break repairs. Mutat Res Genet Toxicol Environ Mutagen. 2022;873:503438.
Rodgers K, McVey M. Error-prone repair of DNA double-strand breaks. J Cell Physiol. 2016;231:15–24.
Scully R, Panday A, Elango R, Willis NA. DNA double-strand break repair-pathway choice in somatic mammalian cells. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol. 2019;20:698–714.
Taylor AMR, Rothblum-Oviatt C, Ellis NA, Hickson ID, Meyer S, Crawford TO, et al. Chromosome instability syndromes. Nat Rev Dis Prim. 2019;5:64.
Bahassi el M, Robbins SB, Yin M, Boivin GP, Kuiper R, van Steeg H, et al. Mice with the CHEK2*1100delC SNP are predisposed to cancer with a strong gender bias. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2009;106:17111–6.
Huijts PE, Hollestelle A, Balliu B, Houwing-Duistermaat JJ, Meijers CM, Blom JC, et al. CHEK2*1100delC homozygosity in the Netherlands-prevalence and risk of breast and lung cancer. Eur J Hum Genet. 2014;22:46–51.
Rainville I, Hatcher S, Rosenthal E, Larson K, Bernhisel R, Meek S, et al. High risk of breast cancer in women with biallelic pathogenic variants in CHEK2. Breast Cancer Res Treat. 2020;180:503–9.
Acknowledgements
The authors thank all the patients for participating in this study.
Funding
This study was funded by the Experimental Medicine Department, Sapienza University of Rome.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
BI: conception of the study and drafting the manuscript; SE: acquisition of data and drafting the manuscript; MS and AF: clinical genetic evaluation and revising the manuscript; MC: acquisition of data; VM: clinical genetic evaluation and revising the manuscript; FA: genetic counselling; RV: clinical assessment; SF: clinical assessment; CMP: analysis and interpretation of data; BF: analysis and interpretation of data; GB: acquisition of data; DGG: acquisition of data; BS: analysis and interpretation of data; DD: analysis and interpretation of data; GP: revising the article critically for important intellectual content.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Ethics approval
Informed consent was obtained from all subjects, and study procedures were compliant with the revised Helsinki Declaration of 2000. The study, part of a research project about genetic disorders, was approved by the San Camillo Forlanini Hospital Ethics Board.
Additional information
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Supplementary information
Rights and permissions
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
About this article
Cite this article
Bottillo, I., Savino, E., Majore, S. et al. Two unrelated cases with biallelic CHEK2 variants:a novel condition with constitutional chromosomal instability?. Eur J Hum Genet 31, 474–478 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41431-022-01270-z
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41431-022-01270-z
This article is cited by
-
2023 in the European Journal of Human Genetics
European Journal of Human Genetics (2024)
-
April, again
European Journal of Human Genetics (2023)