Strategies for HIV prevention among infants, children, and adolescents have evolved significantly over the past 20 years. These include the global scale-up of simplified multidrug HIV regimens for pregnant women, leading to impressive reductions in new child HIV infections. However, significant gaps remain, especially in high HIV-burden sub-Saharan African countries. For example, many pregnant women living with HIV (WLHIV) are unable to access and sustain HIV testing and treatment partly due to low agency and harmful gender norms. Among pregnant WLHIV, adolescent girls face an additional layer of societal and health-system barriers in accessing care for themselves and their exposed infants. Legal and structural barriers limit access to HIV prevention-related sexual and reproductive health services among high-risk adolescents, including girls and young men who have sex with men. Key ethical issues underlying HIV prevention gaps for infants, children, and adolescents prevail. This narrative review explores these issues and highlights counter-measures for programming and policy, including gender empowerment, improving access to and appropriateness of critical health services, rights-based policy and legislation, closing research gaps, and considering the values and preferences of young people for HIV prevention and treatment services.
Strategies for HIV prevention among infants, children, and adolescents have evolved significantly within the past 20 years. These include the shift of prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV (PMTCT) strategies from the use of a single antiretroviral drug during pregnancy to lifelong antiretroviral therapy (ART) for all pregnant and breastfeeding women living with HIV (WLHIV).1 In spite of this expansive policy,2 optimal maternal access to PMTCT services and maximal benefits for both mothers and HIV-exposed infants have not been realized in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA).3 The ethical tension here is finding ways to increase accessibility and utilization of services without coercion, and without exposing women (and by extension, their HIV-exposed infants) to risks of stigma, discrimination, and violence that could be associated with being known or perceived to be living with HIV.4,5
Unlike PMTCT for infants, the prevention and control of HIV infection in adolescents has only recently been given due attention. This is due to evidence demonstrating rising AIDS-related mortality among adolescents despite decreased mortality in all other populations living with HIV.6 In 2017, nearly 75% of the estimated 256,000 annual new HIV cases among 15–19-year-old adolescents worldwide were in SSA.7 Additionally, ~20% of all new infections among persons aged 15 years and older in this region occurred among 15–19-year-old adolescents.7,8
Adolescent African girls are significantly disproportionately affected by the HIV epidemic; they have persistently higher HIV incidence rates and also acquire HIV infection earlier than their male counterparts.9,10 For example, in 2017, three-quarters of the estimated new adolescent HIV infections among 15 to 19 year olds in SSA were among girls,7 who constitute only 50.6% of that age group.11 Additionally, PMTCT service access, uptake, and outcomes for adolescent girls and their HIV-exposed infants are considerably worse compared to older women.12,13 The ethical issue here is the need for adolescents to be able to access sexual health services as and when they need them, regardless of how that sits with legal age of consent.
In SSA, there is a concentrated HIV epidemic affecting key populations—men who have sex with men (MSM), female sex workers, and people who inject drugs, concurrent with the epidemic in the general population. These key populations are highly stigmatized in several SSA countries, with the circumstances of MSM being especially worse because of legal statutes that outlaw same-gender sexual contact and threaten prosecution for those engaging in such relationships.14,15 This creates the ethical dilemma of how to develop and promote services that welcome key populations without “outing” them in the broader community. Furthermore, similar to adolescent girls having lower access to PMTCT services,12,13 young MSM <26 years of age have poorer access to HIV care, including prevention services, compared to older MSM.15
Finally, children and adolescents in humanitarian emergencies require special attention for HIV prevention. Unfortunately, the SSA region often experiences humanitarian crises, including famine, violent conflict, and infectious disease outbreaks. The risk of HIV transmission often increases in areas experiencing such crises, due to sexual violence and disruption of health systems.16
The rights of children under the age of 18 years are enshrined in the United Nations’ Convention of the Rights of the Child, which was ratified in 1989.17 While many of the Convention’s 54 articles are relevant to child health, Article 24 specifically puts forth that signatory countries “recognize the right of the child to the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of health and to facilities for the treatment of illness and rehabilitation of health. States and Parties shall strive to ensure that no child is deprived of his or her right of access to such healthcare services.”17 Ethical issues include tensions between the need for child protection18 and the recognition of mature minors, their right to participate and have their needs addressed in health planning and service delivery, and the need to “do no harm.”19
Recent reviews have discussed multiple strategies and factors to consider when planning and implementing HIV prevention programs for at-risk infants, children, and adolescents in SSA.9,10,12,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37,38 In this article, we discuss gaps and underlying ethical considerations in the development of strategies, delivery of interventions, and/or establishment of policy regarding HIV prevention among different sub-groups of infants, children, and adolescents. Finally, from a rights-based perspective, we review and present measures to close gaps in HIV prevention for these populations.
Successful PMTCT for infants via optimized healthcare for pregnant women and girls
Successful PMTCT is characterized by HIV-free survival of the HIV-exposed infant and optimal health maintenance for mothers living with HIV.3 To achieve this, there needs to be consistent maternal and infant access to a package of health interventions identified in the PMTCT cascade.32 This package includes maternal HIV testing and initiation of ART before or during pregnancy, postpartum infant antiretroviral prophylaxis, appropriate infant feeding counseling, and infant access to early HIV diagnosis.32 It is evident that an infant’s access to and outcomes in the PMTCT cascade will be significantly dependent on maternal access and outcomes.
The Global Plan towards the elimination of new HIV infections among children by 2015 and keeping their mothers alive (Global Plan) initiative targeted 21 priority SSA countries to reduce new HIV infections among children by 90% and to reduce the MTCT rate to ≤2% and ≤5% among non-breastfeeding and breastfeeding women, respectively.3 By 2015, Global Plan countries had reduced new child HIV infections by only 60%; MTCT rate among breastfeeding infants fell from 22.4% to 8.9%, but did not reach the ≤5% target.3 The prevailing gaps were ascribed to poor maternal ART adherence and low retention in care, and notably, the risk of MTCT was particularly high among women who accessed neither HIV testing nor treatment.3
Poor access to and uptake of HIV testing and ART among pregnant WLHIV in Africa is influenced by multiple factors, including limited service accessibility, low level of maternal education, poor community/male partner support, stigma, fear of disclosure, and gender-based violence.39,40 These barriers still persist several years following the introduction of PMTCT programs, making eliminating MTCT in the region an elusive goal, to date.1,39
Particularly challenging barriers are gender inequity and low agency,41,42 often perpetuated by harmful gender norms subscribed to by women, male partners, families, communities, health systems, and/or health policy. These gender-related barriers undermine maternal access to, uptake of, and adherence to PMTCT services.1,43,44,45,46,47 Such health inequities have been identified as a central problem in public health ethics, and analysis of the relationships between gender, disadvantage, and health shows how lack of agency is correlated with poorer health access.48 There is data to suggest that improving women’s agency significantly improves infants’ receipt of HIV testing, maternal ART uptake, and other sexual and reproductive health (SRH) service utilization.41,49
Robinson et al.’s systematic review49 focused on strategies to improve the decision-making capacity of WLHIV for SRH services. These interventions were typically behavioral, and included content delivered individually or to groups by peer WLHIV or trained healthcare personnel.49 There were encouraging results with regard to significant decreases in the incidence of sexually transmitted infections (STIs).49 Ford et al.41 investigated whether a woman’s role in household decision-making was associated with uptake of PMTCT services. Women who reported having active domestic decision-making roles were two to almost three times more likely to utilize infant HIV testing services; those who specifically reported making decisions about their own health care were nearly twice more likely to receive and use maternal ART.41 In spite of this and similar supportive data, gender inequity continues to limit optimization of PMTCT services among eligible women and girls and their infants.1,50
Adolescent girls living with HIV have poorer access to and experience worse PMTCT outcomes when compared to older women.13,51,52,53,54,55,56,57 They are significantly less likely to have a planned pregnancy, complete four antenatal care visits, be on ART pre-pregnancy, or have HIV-exposed infants receiving HIV prophylaxis.58 They are more likely to present with unknown HIV status or to test later during pregnancy, and experience higher MTCT rates, compared to older women.52,54,55,56 Many of the unique issues adolescent women face stem from stigma and judgment about their sexuality, independent access to services as legal minors, and economic dependence/instability.23,59 These issues raise additional concerns about appropriate programming for adolescents and young women who need accessible, age-appropriate, respectful services that cater to their unique social, physiological, and medico-legal vulnerabilities. Integration of rights-based approaches to delivery of adolescent PMTCT care is critically needed, in order to improve outcomes for these young women and their infants.59,60
Management of STIs in the context of HIV prevention among adolescents
Nearly 90% of the world’s estimated 1.8 million adolescents living with HIV are in SSA,7 where sub-populations of young persons remain at persistently high risk of incident HIV infection. Multiple studies have associated the high proportion of untreated STIs with increased risk of acquiring and transmitting HIV infection in these sub-populations.61 Moreover, a significant proportion of STIs are asymptomatic, making diagnosis challenging: in a study among 16–24-year-old South Africans, 80% of young women and 100% of young men diagnosed with at least one laboratory-confirmed STI were asymptomatic.62 Five percent of this cohort was newly diagnosed with HIV. Similar findings have been reported from other SSA studies among adolescents, young adults, and (young) pregnant women.63,64,65,66 These reports have implications for the management of STIs as an HIV prevention strategy for adolescents and young persons in SSA: widely accessible and affordable, stigma-free STI screening and treatment based on accurate, laboratory-confirmed diagnoses.
In the context of the high HIV burden and incident infection in this population, there is an ethical obligation for African nations to make HIV prevention services and tools accessible to adolescents.23,34 However, adolescents under 18 years of age are considered minors in several national constitutions.23,34 These laws are either silent on, explicitly exclude, or limit independent access to HIV/SRH services by adolescents.34 Healthcare providers have often translated these legal deficiencies to imply that adolescents need parental consent to access HIV/SRH services, including HIV prevention services.67 While the World Health Organization has not issued specific recommendations regarding self-consent for SRH services (including HIV testing) by adolescents, it provides a human rights framework for HIV/SRH service delivery to young people and urges policy-makers to review legislation towards facilitating access to services for this population.1,60,68
Reducing HIV incidence among high-risk young populations
Men who have sex with men
The criminalization of, and stigma associated with male-to-male sex are major structural barriers to HIV risk reduction. Criminalization limits the exchange of information and skill development for safer sex practices, especially for adolescent and young adult MSM <26 years of age.15 Blackmail, homophobia, and rape are additional structural drivers of HIV infection for MSM,69 and inhibit their access to HIV prevention services.70,71 In a recent prospective study, HIV incidence was found to be four-fold higher in young Nigerian MSM aged 16–19 years and nearly three-fold higher among those aged 20–24 years compared to MSM over 25 years old, demonstrating the increased vulnerability of youth in this population.71 A critical ethical tension regarding service provision for (young) MSM in the context of criminalization is how to design and deliver appropriate and welcoming services that are discreet and confidential, so as not to increase risks of harm. As has been noted in some country contexts, rights-limiting laws not only constrain access to services but also may increase vulnerability and stigma, and amplify risk in both key and general populations.70,72,73
Adolescents and young people engaging in transactional sex
Factors such as poverty, harmful gender and cultural norms and sexual abuse exacerbate HIV risk among young people74 by creating intersectional vulnerability and perpetuating inequity.75 For people of all genders, including young women and young MSM, unprotected receptive anal sex carries the highest risk of HIV acquisition.76 Transactional sex is defined as “non-marital, noncommercial sexual relationships motivated by the implicit assumption that sex will be exchanged for material benefit or status.”77 Transactional sex has been associated with a higher risk for HIV acquisition young African women 15 to 24 years of age, whereas analysis for this association among men (including young men) has been inconclusive.78 Additionally, socio-cultural factors further increase both adolescent girls’ and adolescent MSMs’ vulnerability to HIV acquisition and limit their ability to make decisions about their sexual lives and exercise their sexual rights.79 The biology of an adolescent woman increases her risk for HIV infection: transmission risk during vaginal sex is high, due to the large surface area and permeability of the vaginal tract exposed to HIV-infected seminal fluid.79 For adolescent girls, transactional sex relationships with more sexually experienced older men increase the risk for HIV transmission.79 Within their layered vulnerabilities, access to education increases autonomy and decision-making abilities for HIV prevention among adolescent girls.79,80 However, improving access to, and quality of information would not necessarily appreciably reduce HIV risk in the absence of respect for young women’s rights to greater decision making with regard to their sexual health.
HIV prevention for children and adolescents in humanitarian emergencies
Humanitarian crisis results in breakdown of governance, rule of law, and social structures, and is characterized by the destruction of public infrastructure including health systems, massive population displacement, and insecurity.81 These crises exacerbate existing vulnerabilities and inequalities, with some of the worst-affected persons being children, who are more in need of humanitarian assistance and are at significantly high risk of dying in a disaster.82,83,84,85 Children and adolescents are likely to be most at risk as their needs are often deprioritized when pre-existing forces of marginalization intensify during emergencies.86
Adolescent girls and young women especially face sexual- and gender-based violence, gender-based exclusion and exploitation, and are at increased risk for rape and transactional sex for access to daily needs, often resulting in early/unplanned pregnancies.86,87,88,89,90,91 During conflict, children and adolescents, especially males, are conscripted into militant groups. They become sexually active at a young age and may commit sexual violence that puts them at increased risk of HIV infection.86,92,93 Their awareness and use of SRH services during crises is also sub-optimal.89,90,94 Psychological trauma resulting from events associated with these crises may also drive high sexual-risk behaviors such as drug and alcohol abuse and unsafe sex.86,93 Adolescent boys also face increased risk of rape, coercion, and transactional sex, and their access to SRH services may be impacted by codes of stigma and silence that accompany these abuses.95,96
Although there has been some data to the contrary,92,97,98 the aforementioned risks can potentially contribute to increased HIV incidence during humanitarian emergencies.86 Unfortunately, access to critical HIV prevention services and commodities such as pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP), post-exposure prophylaxis (PEP), STI treatment, condoms, and HIV testing kits is often compromised at these times.86,99 Access to HIV treatment services is also compromised as disruption of health-system and supply chain structures affect availability of medicines, including antiretroviral drugs for persons already HIV infected.86 For nursing mothers living with HIV, this also means that safe infant feeding may be compromised due to the lack of ART or appropriate breastmilk substitutes.100 Overall, disruptions in HIV treatment infrastructure increase the risk for virological non-suppression among persons living with HIV, thereby increasing risk for onward HIV transmission.
It is therefore ethically imperative for SSA countries to have robust emergency plans for humanitarian emergencies, especially given the propensity and chronicity of these events on the continent.83,86,99,101 Such plans should prioritize vulnerable populations such as pregnant and postpartum women, children, and adolescents for HIV prevention, as well as treatment-as-prevention services.99,101,102 This includes supporting healthcare systems to be more resilient to crisis, particularly in maintaining consistent access to quality pregnancy, STI, and HIV prevention services and commodities.81
Cross-cutting issues for adolescents: independent access to HIV/SRH services among minors
Requirements for parental consent are often justified on the grounds that young people lack the experience and judgment to make fully informed decisions.67,103 However, emancipated minors—individuals who have not attained the age of majority, but due to marital status, pregnancy, or otherwise are deemed no longer dependent on parental control—are empowered to make autonomous decisions in several contexts.104 These emancipated minors can make decisions about their own health care.104,105,106 With emancipation, minors are also assumed to have the competency to be able to make rational decisions about risks and benefits in health research. Empowerment for decision making among emancipated minors considers their evolving capacity and autonomy,104 while not necessarily dismissing the roles that supportive adults, including parents, can still provide in the decision-making process.107,108 We argue that this consideration of evolving capacity and autonomy be applied to minor adolescents seeking HIV/SRH services, in order to increase their access and uptake of available services. There is consensus in the literature that adolescents aged 12 to 14 years old have the cognitive ability to comprehend language and information necessary for informed consent.109,110,111,112
Despite efforts to improve diagnosis, treatment, and healthcare system capacity to deliver services, STI rates, especially among young people, remain high.113 This is concurrent with high HIV incidence and mortality, particularly in SSA.6 Clearly, practical, rights-based strategies are need to improve access and uptake. There is currently no specific guidance on an appropriate minimum age for independent access to HIV/SRH services.60,68 There is however qualitative data and expert consensus supporting reduced age of consent to encourage adolescent access and uptake of HIV/SRH services.34,114,115,116,117 SSA countries that have reduced age of consent for HIV testing to under 18 years include South Africa, Lesotho, and Uganda (12 years), Malawi (13 years), Ethiopia, Kenya, and Rwanda (15 years), Mozambique, Namibia, Zambia, and Zimbabwe (16 years).23,34,112
A recent empiric study may provide some concrete guidance. McKinnon and Vandermorris112 analyzed 2011–2016 Demographic and Health and AIDS Indicator Survey data from 15 SSA countries. They compared countries with less restrictive (≤15 years) vs. more restrictive (≥16 years) age-of-consent laws. Findings showed that HIV testing rates for adolescents in countries with less restrictive age-of-consent laws were significantly higher, at +11% overall, posting 14% points higher among females and 6.9% points higher among males. To further guide policy, more empirical evidence is needed on the impact of lowering age of consent, not only for HIV/STI testing but also for HIV/SRH service access and uptake, and all related research.
Ethical considerations for addressing gaps in HIV prevention for infants, children, and youth in SSA
Table 1 summarizes major ethical issues faced in HIV prevention for the populations and the contexts discussed in this article. It also highlights key strategies and recommendations for addressing these issues, some of which are already being implemented in some SSA countries.
Successful HIV prevention for exposed infants is significantly influenced by maternal factors, including social support, and PMTCT knowledge, access, uptake, and retention in care.35,37,50,118,119,120,121 Considerations for adult women and adolescent girls in the elimination of MTCT must include comprehensive gender empowerment approaches addressing context-specific gender inequalities in access to HIV and SRH care49,122 as highlighted in Table 1. The UNAIDS HIV Prevention 2020 roadmap supports a multicomponent biomedical, behavioral, and structural approach, where healthcare workers, male partners, peers, and other community stakeholders are engaged in transforming harmful gender norms, improving decision-making opportunities and capacity for WLHIV, and revising policy to better integrate SRH and rights into PMTCT care for women and infants.16
Adolescents can benefit from increased access to HIV prevention services through legislative reform, policy formulation and revision, and program design and implementation that is non-punitive with respect to sexual activity or orientation, and facilitates access to stigma-free HIV testing, STI screening and treatment, and PEP and PrEP services15,23,34 (Table 1). One of such approaches is the design of rights-based prevention programs that increase access of young persons often at high risk for stigma and exclusion.12,23,34,117,123,124
However, there is currently mixed evidence on what works to increase access to HIV/SRH prevention services and reduce HIV incidence among adolescents. Strategies incorporating gender-based violence prevention, support, and care have had encouraging impact.60 However, service integration and compliant implementation of these strategies, and of related laws and policies, need to be strengthened.
Another strategy to increase adolescents’ access to HIV/SRH services is to reduce the age of consent, which is often inferred from age of majority laws.34 A few African countries have empowered medical personnel to determine appropriateness of service provision by the capacity and maturity of the adolescent, while others have lowered the age of consent to as low as 12 years.23,34 However, the age of consent for HIV/SRH services is often inconsistent with the legal age to engage in sexual activity or marriage, creating challenges for healthcare workers to interpret and apply these laws.23,34 Unfortunately, the use of media and information and communications technology to change norms, attitudes, and behaviors of communities and families towards adolescents’ access to HIV/SRH services have not been effective so far.125
Adolescent-friendly services, while desirable, have not worked effectively, as they are only able to reach a relatively small proportion of young persons, are more often used by older adolescents, and service uptake at these sites is low in spite of the high setup costs.126 There is need for robust evidence on adolescents’ values and preferences with regards to engagement in HIV programs and service uptake and utilization, and on strategies to improve benefit perceptions in the use of these services.12,123,124,127
For children and adolescents of all genders in humanitarian emergencies, a major prevailing issue is inadequate preparedness of response systems to address their unique vulnerabilities in the context of HIV prevention. Strategies for these populations include addressing access to services, supply chain challenges, and healthcare worker HIV prevention and treatment competencies in the context of humanitarian crises.101,102 Anticipatory social protections, and promptly accessible post-violence social, counseling, HIV, STI, and SRH services also need to be put into emergency programs, given the extreme vulnerability of children and adolescents to gender-based and sexual violence in these situations.86,89,101,102
Given its high HIV incidence and burden within a large and expanding child and youth population, SSA is of prime importance in the global HIV elimination agenda. However, ethics and rights-based approaches have not been optimally applied to the development and implementation of HIV prevention services that are relevant for this population. This is contributing to continued challenges with accessing and optimizing benefits from testing, prophylaxis, and other available, evidence-based HIV prevention tools and services. Prevailing ethical considerations include adolescent protections vs. independent access to care, maternal empowerment for health decision making vs. further exposure to stigma/discrimination and gender-based violence, and for young MSM, discreet and confidential care while expanding access. Policy- and law-makers, healthcare workers, community members (including youth and adults living with HIV), researchers, and other stakeholders must collectively advocate for, and contribute to rights-based care and relevant revisions to policy and programming.
World Health Organization. Consolidated Guideline on Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights of Women Living with HIV (2017). https://www.who.int/reproductivehealth/publications/gender_rights/srhr-women-hiv/en/. Accessed 30 Apr 2019.
World Health Organization. Countries which have Received WHO Validation (2019). https://www.who.int/reproductivehealth/congenital-syphilis/WHO-validation-EMTCT/en/. Accesed 30 Apr 2019.
UNAIDS. On the Fast Track to an AIDS Free Generation: The Incredible Journey of the Global Plan Towards the Elimination of New HIV Infections Among Children by 2015 and Keeping Their Mothers Alive (2016). http://emtct-iatt.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/GlobalPlan2016_en.pdf. Accessed 14 Jan 2019.
Jewkes, R. K., Dunkle, K., Nduna, M. & Shai, N. Intimate partner violence, relationship power inequity, and incidence of HIV infection in young women in South Africa: a cohort study. Lancet 376, 41–48 (2010).
Maeri, I. et al. “How can I tell?” Consequences of HIV status disclosure among couples in eastern African communities in the context of an ongoing HIV “test-and-treat” trial. AIDS Care 28(Suppl. 3), 59–66 (2016).
Idele, P. et al. Epidemiology of HIV and AIDS among adolescents: current status, inequities, and data gaps. J. Acquir. Immune Defic. Syndr. 66(Suppl. 2), S144–S153 (2014).
UNICEF. HIV/AIDS Data: HIV Epidemiology among Children and Adolescents, 2017 (2018). https://data.unicef.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/HIV_Epi_Children_Adolescents_2017.xlsx. Accessed 31 Mar 2019.
UNAIDS. HIV Estimates with Uncertainty Bounds 1990–2017 (2018). http://www.unaids.org/en/resources/documents/2018/HIV_estimates_with_uncertainty_bounds_1990-present. Accessed 31 Mar 2019.
Baxter, C. & Abdool Karim, S. Combination HIV prevention options for young women in Africa. Afr. J. AIDS Res. 15, 109–121 (2016).
Abdool Karim, Q., Baxter, C. & Birx, D. Prevention of HIV in adolescent girls and young women: key to an AIDS-free generation. J. Acquir. Immune Defic. Syndr. 75(Suppl. 1), S17–S26 (2017).
Population Pyramid.Net. Sub-Saharan Africa Population Pyramid (2017). https://www.populationpyramid.net/sub-saharan-africa/2017/. Accessed 13 Apr 2019.
Rotheram-Borus, M. J., Davis, E. & Rezai, R. Stopping the rise of HIV among adolescents globally. Curr. Opin. Pediatr. 30, 131–136 (2018).
Callahan, T., Modi, S., Swanson, J., Ng’eno, B. & Broyles, L. N. Pregnant adolescents living with HIV: what we know, what we need to know, where we need to go. J. Int. AIDS Soc. 20, 21858 (2017).
Amnesty International UK. Mapping Anti-Gay Laws in Africa (2018). https://www.amnesty.org.uk/lgbti-lgbt-gay-human-rights-law-africa-uganda-kenya-nigeria-cameroon. Accessed 13 Apr 2019.
Beyrer, C. et al. The global response to HIV in men who have sex with men. Lancet 388, 198–206 (2016).
UNAIDS. HIV Prevention 2020 Roadmap: Accelerating HIV Prevention to Reduce New Infections by 75% (2017). http://www.unaids.org/sites/default/files/media_asset/hiv-prevention-2020-road-map_en.pdf. Accessed 13 Apr 2019.
United Nations Human Rights Office ef the High Commissioner. Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989). https://www.ohchr.org/Documents/ProfessionalInterest/crc.pdf. Accessed 30 Apr 2019.
Sheehan, R., Rhoades, H. & Stanley, N. Vulnerable Children and the Law: International Evidence for Improving Child Welfare, Child Protection and Children’s Rights 368 (Jessica Kingsley Publishers, 2012).
Bennouna, C., Mansourian, H. & Stark, L. Ethical considerations for children’s participation in data collection activities during humanitarian emergencies: a Delphi review. Confl. Health 11, 5 (2017).
Tuthill, E. L., Chan, J. & Butler, L. M. Challenges faced by health-care providers offering infant-feeding counseling to HIV-positive women in sub-Saharan Africa: a review of current research. AIDS Care 27, 17–24 (2015).
Toska, E. et al. Resourcing resilience: social protection for HIV prevention amongst children and adolescents in Eastern and Southern Africa. Afr. J. AIDS Res. 15, 123–140 (2016).
Schuster, R. C., McMahon, D. E. & Young, S. L. A comprehensive review of the barriers and promoters health workers experience in delivering prevention of vertical transmission of HIV services in sub-Saharan Africa. AIDS Care 28, 778–794 (2016).
Sam-Agudu, N. A., Folayan, M. O. & Ezeanolue, E. E. Seeking wider access to HIV testing for adolescents in sub-Saharan Africa. Pediatr. Res 79, 838–845 (2016).
Govindasamy, D. et al. Uptake and yield of HIV testing and counselling among children and adolescents in sub-Saharan Africa: a systematic review. J. Int. AIDS Soc. 18, 20182 (2015).
Geldsetzer, P. et al. A systematic review of interventions to improve postpartum retention of women in PMTCT and ART care. J. Int. AIDS Soc. 19, 20679 (2016).
Al-Mujtaba, M., Sam-Agudu, N. A. & Khatri, R. Barriers to the practice of exclusive breastfeeding among HIV-positive mothers in sub-Saharan Africa: A scoping review of counselling, socioeconomic and cultural factors. J. AIDS HIV Res. 8, 70–79 (2016).
Radin, A. K. et al. Confronting challenges in monitoring and evaluation: innovation in the context of the global plan towards the elimination of new HIV infections among children by 2015 and keeping their mothers alive. J. Acquir. Immune Defic. Syndr. 75(Suppl. 1), S66–S75 (2017).
Ngidi, W. H., Naidoo, J. R., Ncama, B. P., Luvuno, Z. P. B. & Mashamba-Thompson, T. P. Mapping evidence of interventions and strategies to bridge the gap in the implementation of the prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV programme policy in sub-Saharan countries: a scoping review. Afr. J. Prim. Health Care Fam. Med. 9, e1–e10 (2017).
Ngambi, P. G. et al. Evidence on the cost-effectiveness of lifelong antiretroviral therapy for prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV: implications for resource-limited countries in sub-Saharan Africa. Expert Rev. Pharmacoecon. Outcomes Res. 17, 459–467 (2017).
Mutabazi, J. C., Zarowsky, C. & Trottier, H. The impact of programs for prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV on health care services and systems in sub-Saharan Africa—a review. Public Health Rev. 38, 28 (2017).
Kalua, T. et al. Lessons learned from option B+ in the evolution toward “test and start” From Malawi, Cameroon, and the United Republic of Tanzania. J. Acquir. Immune Defic. Syndr. 75(Suppl. 1), S43–S50 (2017).
Hamilton, E. et al. Using the PMTCT cascade to accelerate achievement of the global plan goals. J. Acquir. Immune Defic. Syndr. 75(Suppl. 1), S27–S35 (2017).
Essajee, S. et al. Scale-up of early infant HIV diagnosis and improving access to pediatric HIV care in global plan countries: past and future perspectives. J. Acquir. Immune Defic. Syndr. 75(Suppl. 1), S51–S58 (2017).
Eba, P. M. & Lim, H. Reviewing independent access to HIV testing, counselling and treatment for adolescents in HIV-specific laws in sub-Saharan Africa: implications for the HIV response. J. Int. AIDS Soc. 20, 21456 (2017).
Bispo, S., Chikhungu, L., Rollins, N., Siegfried, N. & Newell, M. L. Postnatal HIV transmission in breastfed infants of HIV-infected women on ART: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J. Int. AIDS Soc. 20, 21251 (2017).
Whembolua, G. S., Muvuka, B., Tshiswaka, D. I. & Conserve D. F. Socio-structural factors influencing the prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV in the Democratic Republic of the Congo: a systematic review. Matern. Child Health J. 23, 880–889 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10995-018-2688-6.
Vrazo, A. C. et al. Interventions to significantly improve service uptake and retention of HIV-positive pregnant women and HIV-exposed infants along the prevention of mother-to-child transmission continuum of care: systematic review. Trop. Med. Int. Health 23, 136–148 (2018).
Takah, N. F., Atem, J. A., Aminde, L. N., Malisheni, M. & Murewenhema, G. Male partner involvement in increasing the uptake of infant antiretroviral prophylaxis/treatment in sub Saharan Africa: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Public Health 18, 249 (2018).
Gourlay, A., Birdthistle, I., Mburu, G., Iorpenda, K. & Wringe, A. Barriers and facilitating factors to the uptake of antiretroviral drugs for prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV in sub-Saharan Africa: a systematic review. J. Int. AIDS Soc. 16, 18588 (2013).
Olakunde, B. O. et al. Correlates of antiretroviral coverage for prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV in sub-Saharan Africa. AIDS Care 31, 1255–1260 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1080/09540121.2019.1587364.
Ford, C. E. et al. Maternal decision-making and uptake of health services for the prevention of mother-to-child HIV transmission: a secondary analysis. Matern. Child Health J. 23, 30–38 (2019).
UNAIDS. Women and Girls and HIV (2018). http://www.unaids.org/sites/default/files/media_asset/women_girls_hiv_en.pdf. Accessed 23 Apr 2019.
Katirayi, L. et al. HIV-positive pregnant and postpartum women’s perspectives about Option B+ in Malawi: a qualitative study. J. Int. AIDS Soc. 19, 20919 (2016).
Flax, V. L. et al. “If my husband leaves me, I will go home and suffer, so better cling to him and hide this thing”: the influence of gender on Option B+ prevention of mother-to-child transmission participation in Malawi and Uganda. PLoS ONE 12, e0178298 (2017).
Nyamhanga, T., Frumence, G. & Simba, D. Prevention of mother to child transmission of HIV in Tanzania: assessing gender mainstreaming on paper and in practice. Health Policy Plan 32, v22–v30 (2017).
Kumar, S., Gruskin, S., Khosla, R. & Narasimhan, M. Human rights and the sexual and reproductive health of women living with HIV-a literature review. J. Int. AIDS Soc. 18, 20290 (2015).
Narasimhan, M. et al. Sexual and reproductive health and human rights of women living with HIV: a global community survey. Bull. World Health Organ. 94, 243–249 (2016).
Rogers, W. A. Feminism and public health ethics. J. Med. Ethics 32, 351–354 (2006).
Robinson, J. L. et al. Interventions to address unequal gender and power relations and improve self-efficacy and empowerment for sexual and reproductive health decision-making for women living with HIV: a systematic review. PLoS ONE 12, e0180699 (2017).
UNICEF. Women: At the Heart of the HIV Response for Children (2018). https://data.unicef.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/Women-at-the-heart-of-the-HIV-response-for-children-report.pdf. Accessed 30 Apr 2019.
Dellar, R. C., Dlamini, S. & Karim, Q. A. Adolescent girls and young women: key populations for HIV epidemic control. J. Int. AIDS Soc. 18, 19408 (2015).
Musarandega, R. et al. PMTCT service uptake among adolescents and adult women attending antenatal care in selected health facilities in Zimbabwe. J. Acquir. Immune Defic. Syndr. 75, 148–155 (2017).
Groves, A. K. et al. Addressing the unique needs of adolescent mothers in the fight against HIV. J. Int. AIDS Soc. 21, e25155 (2018).
Horwood, C., Butler, L. M., Haskins, L., Phakathi, S. & Rollins, N. HIV-infected adolescent mothers and their infants: low coverage of HIV services and high risk of HIV transmission in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa. PLoS ONE 8, e74568 (2013).
Ramraj, T. et al. Adolescent access to care and risk of early mother-to-child HIV transmission. J. Adolesc. Health 62, 434–443 (2018).
Fatti, G., Shaikh, N., Eley, B., Jackson, D. & Grimwood, A. Adolescent and young pregnant women at increased risk of mother-to-child transmission of HIV and poorer maternal and infant health outcomes: a cohort study at public facilities in the Nelson Mandela Bay Metropolitan district, Eastern Cape, South Africa. S. Afr. Med. J. 104, 874–880 (2014).
Kiwanuka, G. et al. Retention of HIV infected pregnant and breastfeeding women on option B+ in Gomba District, Uganda: a retrospective cohort study. BMC Infect. Dis. 18, 533 (2018).
Ronen, K. et al. Gaps in adolescent engagement in antenatal care and prevention of mother-to-child HIV transmission services in Kenya. J. Acquir. Immune Defic. Syndr. 74, 30–37 (2017).
Pretorius, L., Gibbs, A., Crankshaw, T. & Willan, S. Interventions targeting sexual and reproductive health and rights outcomes of young people living with HIV: a comprehensive review of current interventions from sub-Saharan Africa. Glob. Health Action 8, 28454 (2015).
World Health Organization. WHO Recommendations on Adolescent Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights (2018). https://www.who.int/reproductivehealth/publications/adolescent-srhr-who-recommendations/en/. Accessed 28 Apr 2019.
Champredon, D. et al. The effect of sexually transmitted co-infections on HIV viral load amongst individuals on antiretroviral therapy: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Infect. Dis. 15, 249 (2015).
Kaida, A. et al. A high burden of asymptomatic genital tract infections undermines the syndromic management approach among adolescents and young adults in South Africa: implications for HIV prevention efforts. BMC Infect. Dis. 18, 499 (2018).
Blankhart, D., Muller, O., Gresenguet, G. & Weis, P. Sexually transmitted infections in young pregnant women in Bangui, Central African Republic. Int. J. STD AIDS 10, 609–614 (1999).
Mudau, M. et al. High prevalence of asymptomatic sexually transmitted infections among human immunodeficiency virus-infected pregnant women in a low-income South African community. Int. J. STD AIDS 29, 324–333 (2018).
Barnabas, S. L. et al. Converging epidemics of sexually transmitted infections and bacterial vaginosis in southern African female adolescents at risk of HIV. Int. J. STD AIDS 29, 531–539 (2018).
Kerubo, E. et al. Prevalence of reproductive tract infections and the predictive value of girls’ symptom-based reporting: findings from a cross-sectional survey in rural western Kenya. Sex. Transm. Infect. 92, 251–256 (2016).
World Health Organization. The Voices, Values and Preference of Adolescents on HIV Testing and Counselling (2013). http://www.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/95143/1/WHO_HIV_2013.135_eng.pdf. Accessed 28 Apr 2019.
World Health Organization. HIV and Adolescents: Guidance for HIV Testing and Counselling and Care for Adolescents Living with HIV (2013). http://www.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/95141/1/WHO_HIV_2013.133_eng.pdf. Accessed 28 Apr 2019.
Baral, S. et al. HIV risk and associations of HIV infection among men who have sex with men in peri-urban Cape Town, South Africa. BMC Public Health 11, 766 (2011).
Sekoni, A. O. et al. Provision of healthcare services to men who have sex with men in Nigeria: students’ attitudes following the passage of the Same-Sex Marriage Prohibition Law. LGBT Health 3, 300–307 (2016).
Nowak, R. G. et al. Individual and sexual network predictors of HIV incidence among men who have sex with men in Nigeria. J. Acquir. Immune Defic. Syndr. 80, 444–453 (2019).
Laar, A. & DeBruin, D. Key populations and human rights in the context of HIV services rendition in Ghana. BMC Int. Health Hum. Rights 17, 20 (2017).
Schwartz, S. R. et al. The immediate eff ect of the Same-Sex Marriage Prohibition Act on stigma, discrimination, and engagement on HIV prevention and treatment services in men who have sex with men in Nigeria: analysis of prospective data from the TRUST cohort. Lancet HIV 2, e299–e306 (2015).
Onokerhoraye, A. G., Maticka-Tyndale, E. & Team, H. R. HIV prevention for rural youth in Nigeria: background overview. Afr. J. Reprod. Health 16, 25–38 (2012).
Luna, F. Identifying and evaluating layers of vulnerability—a way forward. Dev. World Bioeth. 19, 86–95 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1111/dewb.12206.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. HIV Risk and Prevention: Anal Sex and HIV Risk (2019). https://www.cdc.gov/hiv/risk/analsex.html.
Stoebenau, K., Heise, L., Wamoyi, J. & Bobrova, N. Revisiting the understanding of “transactional sex” in sub-Saharan Africa: a review and synthesis of the literature. Soc. Sci. Med. 168, 186–197 (2016).
Wamoyi, J., Stobeanau, K., Bobrova, N., Abramsky, T. & Watts, C. Transactional sex and risk for HIV infection in sub-Saharan Africa: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J. Int. AIDS Soc. 19, 20992 (2016).
UNAIDS. Hiv Prevention Among Adolescent Girls and Young Women: Putting HIV Prevention Among Adolescent Girls and Young Women on the Fast-Track and Engaging Men and Boys (2016). http://www.unaids.org/sites/default/files/media_asset/UNAIDS_HIV_prevention_among_adolescent_girls_and_young_women.pdf. Accessed 29 Apr 2019.
Phillips, S. J. & Mbizvo, M. T. Empowering adolescent girls in Sub-Saharan Africa to prevent unintended pregnancy and HIV: a critical research gap. Int. J. Gynaecol. Obstet. 132, 1–3 (2016).
Zeid, S. et al. Women’s, children’s, and adolescents’ health in humanitarian and other crises. BMJ 351, h4346 (2015).
Peterson, K. From the field: gender issues in disaster response and recovery. Natural Hazards Observer 21, 3–4 (1997).
United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs. Overview of Global Humanitarian Response, 2014 (2014). https://www.unocha.org/sites/unocha/files/GHO2014_1.pdf. Accessed 27 Apr 2019.
Hirani, S. A. A. & Richter, S. Maternal and child health during forced displacement. J. Nurs. Scholarsh. 51, 252–261 (2019).
Nelson, B. D. et al. Impact of sexual violence on children in the Eastern Democratic Republic of Congo. Med. Confl. Surviv. 27, 211–225 (2011).
AVERT. Humanitarian Emergencies, Armed Conflict and the HIV Response (2017). https://www.avert.org/professionals/hiv-programming/emergencies-conflicts-and-hiv-response#footnote27_a34yj4j.
United Nations High Commission for Refugees and Population Fund. Adolescent Sexual and Reproductive Health Programs in Humanitarian Settings: An In-depth Look at Family Planning Services (2012). https://www.unfpa.org/sites/default/files/resource-pdf/AAASRH_good_practice_documentation_English_FINAL.pdf.
United Nations High Commission for Refugees, Inter-governmental Authority on Development. HIV Behavioural Surveillance Survey in Dadaab Refugee Camps, Kenya (2010). https://www.unhcr.org/4d231ca09.pdf. Accessed 27 Apr 2019.
Ivanova, O., Rai, M. & Kemigisha E. A systematic review of sexual and reproductive health knowledge, experiences and access to services among refugee, migrant and displaced girls and young women in Africa. Int. J. Environ. Res Public Health 15, pii: E1583 (2018). https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph15081583.
Roxo, U., Mobula, M. L., Walker, D., Ficht, A. & Yeiser, S. Prioritizing the sexual and reproductive health and rights of adolescent girls and young women within HIV treatment and care services in emergency settings: a girl-centered agenda. Reprod. Health 16, 57 (2019).
Peterman, A., Palermo, T. & Bredenkamp, C. Estimates and determinants of sexual violence against women in the Democratic Republic of Congo. Am. J. Public health 101, 1060–1067 (2011).
Patel, S. et al. Comparison of HIV-related vulnerabilities between former child soldiers and children never abducted by the LRA in northern Uganda. Confl. Health 7, 17 (2013).
Patel, S. et al. War and HIV: sex and gender differences in risk behaviour among young men and women in post-conflict Gulu District, Northern Uganda. Glob. Public Health 9, 325–341 (2014).
Casey, S. E. Evaluations of reproductive health programs in humanitarian settings: a systematic review. Confl. Health 9, S1 (2015).
Chynoweth, S. K., Freccero, J. & Touquet, H. Sexual violence against men and boys in conflict and forced displacement: implications for the health sector. Reprod. Health Matters 25, 90–94 (2017).
Christian, M., Safari, O., Ramazani, P., Burnham, G. & Glass, N. Sexual and gender based violence against men in the Democratic Republic of Congo: effects on survivors, their families and the community. Med Confl. Surviv 27, 227–246 (2011).
Bennett, B. W., Marshall, B. D., Gjelsvik, A., McGarvey, S. T. & Lurie, M. N. HIV incidence prior to, during, and after violent conflict in 36 sub-Saharan African nations, 1990–2012: an ecological study. PLoS ONE 10, e0142343 (2015).
Spiegel, P. B. et al. Prevalence of HIV infection in conflict-affected and displaced people in seven sub-Saharan African countries: a systematic review. Lancet 369, 2187–2195 (2007).
Spiegel, P. B. HIV/AIDS among conflict-affected and displaced populations: dispelling myths and taking action. Disasters 28, 322–339 (2004).
Leyenaar, J. Human immuno-deficiency virus and infant feeding in complex humanitarian emergencies: priorities and policy considerations. Disasters 28, 1–15 (2004).
UNAIDS. HIV in Emergency Contexts (2015). http://www.unaids.org/sites/default/files/media_asset/20150729_UNAIDS_PCB36_ppt_15-13_HIV_emergency_contexts.pdf. Accessed 28 Apr 2019.
AIDSTAR-One. HIV Treatment in Complex Emergencies (2012). https://www.jsi.com/JSIInternet/Inc/Common/_download_pub.cfm?id=13042&lid=3.
Boonstra, H. & Nash E. Minors and the Right to Consent to Health Care (2000). https://www.guttmacher.org/gpr/2000/08/minors-and-right-consent-health-care. Accessed 28 Apr 2019.
World Health Organization. Guidance on Ethical Considerations in Planning and Reviewing Research Studies on Sexual and Reproductive Health in Adolescents (2018). https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/273792/9789241508414-eng.pdf?ua=1.
Folayan, M. O. et al. Ethical issues in adolescents’ sexual and reproductive health research in Nigeria. Dev. World Bioeth. 15, 191–198 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1111/dewb.12061.
Pillay, B. & Singh, J. Mental capacity’, ‘sufficient maturity’, and ‘capable of understanding’ in relation to children: how should health professionals interpret these terms? South Afr. J. Psychol. 48, 538–552 (2018).
Knopf, A. S., Draucker, C. B., Zimet, G. D. & Thompson, E. A. Socialization and negotiation around HIV risk and sexual relationship development among adolescents in sub-Saharan Africa: three spheres of influence, three conflicting messages. J. Adolesc. Health 56, S51 (2015).
Shah, S. K. et al. Advancing independent adolescent consent for participation in HIV prevention research. J. Med. Ethics 44, 431–433 (2018).
Hein, I. M. et al. Key factors in children’s competence to consent to clinical research. BMC Med. Ethics 16, 74 (2015).
Hein, I. M. et al. Informed consent instead of assent is appropriate in children from the age of twelve: policy implications of new findings on children’s competence to consent to clinical research. BMC Med. Ethics 16, 76 (2015).
Schachter, D., Kleinman, I. & Harvey, W. Informed consent and adolescents. Can. J. Psychiatry 50, 534–540 (2005).
McKinnon, B. & Vandermorris, A. National age-of-consent laws and adolescent HIV testing in sub-Saharan Africa: a propensity-score matched study. Bull. World Health Organ. 97, 42–50 (2018).
Rowley, J. et al. Chlamydia, gonorrhoea, trichomoniasis and syphilis: global prevalence and incidence estimates, 2016. Bull. World Health Organ. 97, 548–562 (2019).
World Health Organization. The Voices, Values and Preference of Adolescents on HIV Testing and Counselling (2013). http://www.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/95143/1/WHO_HIV_2013.135_eng.pdf.
Sam-Agudu, N. A., Folayan, M. O. & Ezeanolue, E. E. Seeking wider access to HIV testing for adolescents in sub-Saharan Africa. Pediatr. Res. (2016).
Taggart, T., Bond, K. T., Ritchwood, T. D. & Smith, J. C. Getting youth PrEPared: adolescent consent laws and implications for the availability of PrEP among youth in countries outside of the United States. J. Int. AIDS Soc. 22, e25363 (2019).
Mark, D. et al. What is it going to take to move youth-related HIV programme policies into practice in Africa? J. Int. AIDS Soc. 20, 21491 (2017).
Ambia, J. & Mandala, J. A systematic review of interventions to improve prevention of mother-to-child HIV transmission service delivery and promote retention. J. Int. AIDS Soc. 19, 20309 (2016).
Wettstein, C. et al. Missed opportunities to prevent mother-to-child-transmission: systematic review and meta-analysis. AIDS 26, 2361–2373 (2012).
Woldesenbet, S. A. et al. Missed opportunities for early infant HIV diagnosis: results of a national study in South Africa. J. Acquir. Immune Defic. Syndr. 68, e26–e32 (2015).
Anaba, U. C. et al. Missed opportunities for early infant diagnosis of HIV in rural North-Central Nigeria: a cascade analysis from the INSPIRE MoMent study. PLoS ONE 14, e0220616 (2019).
Ghanotakis, E., Peacock, D. & Wilcher, R. The importance of addressing gender inequality in efforts to end vertical transmission of HIV. J. Int. AIDS Soc. 15(Suppl. 2), 17385 (2012).
Williams, S., Renju, J., Ghilardi, L. & Wringe, A. Scaling a waterfall: a meta-ethnography of adolescent progression through the stages of HIV care in sub-Saharan Africa. J. Int. AIDS Soc. 20, 21922 (2017).
Koechlin, F. M. et al. Values and preferences on the use of oral pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) for HIV prevention among multiple populations: a systematic review of the literature. AIDS Behav. 21, 1325–1335 (2017).
Rankin, K., Heard, A. & Diaz N. Adolescent Sexual and Reproductive Health: Scoping the Impact of Programming in Low- and Middle-Income Countries (2016). http://www.3ieimpact.org/sites/default/files/2019-01/sp5-asrh.pdf. Accessed 30 Apr 2019.
Zuurmond, M. A., Geary, R. S. & Ross, D. A. The effectiveness of youth centers in increasing use of sexual and reproductive health services: a systematic review. Stud. Fam. Plann. 43, 239–254 (2012).
Rennie, S. et al. The significance of benefit perceptions for the ethics of HIV research involving adolescents in Kenya. J. Empir. Res. Hum. Res. Ethics 12, 269–279 (2017).
We would like to thank all policy-makers, healthcare workers, program implementers, researchers, community members living with and affected by HIV, and other key stakeholders in HIV prevention in SSA for their contributions to the body of evidence that has been reviewed in this article.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Sam-Agudu, N.A., Folayan, M.O. & Haire, B.G. Program implementation gaps and ethical issues in the prevention of HIV infection among infants, children, and adolescents in sub-Saharan Africa. Pediatr Res 87, 406–413 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41390-019-0645-8
Adolescent participation in HIV research: consortium experience in low and middle-income countries and scoping review
The Lancet HIV (2020)
Multilevel modelling and multiple group analysis of disparities in continuity of care and viral suppression among adolescents and youths living with HIV in Nigeria
BMJ Global Health (2020)
Things must not fall apart: the ripple effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on children in sub-Saharan Africa
Pediatric Research (2020)