The concept of using stimuli-responsive hydrogels to actuate fluids in microfluidic devices is particularly attractive, but limitations, in terms of spatial resolution, speed, reliability and integration, have hindered its development during the past two decades. By patterning and grafting poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) PNIPAM hydrogel films on plane substrates with a 2 μm horizontal resolution and closing the system afterward, we have succeeded in unblocking bottlenecks that thermo-sensitive hydrogel technology has been challenged with until now. In this paper, we demonstrate, for the first time with this technology, devices with up to 7800 actuated micro-cages that sequester and release solutes, along with valves actuated individually with closing and opening switching times of 0.6±0.1 and 0.25±0.15 s, respectively. Two applications of this technology are illustrated in the domain of single cell handling and the nuclear acid amplification test (NAAT) for the Human Synaptojanin 1 gene, which is suspected to be involved in several neurodegenerative diseases such as Parkinson’s disease. The performance of the temperature-responsive hydrogels we demonstrate here suggests that in association with their moderate costs, hydrogels may represent an alternative to the actuation or handling techniques currently used in microfluidics, that are, pressure actuated polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) valves and droplets.
Over the past 20 years, much progress has been made in the handling of liquids at the microscale. Since Terry’s valve (1979)1, tens of micro-actuators of different types have been invented2. Pressure actuated polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) microvalves3 deserve particular attention because, owing to their simplicity, thousands of units can be integrated on a single device, linking microfluidics and microelectronics4. PDMS valves currently represent an important tool for biology research5,
In this context, responsive hydrogels represent an interesting technological pathway. Their physical principle relies on their ability to undergo large volume changes when a stimulus (for example, thermal, photonic, chemical or electrical) is applied. The potential of these hydrogels is important because hydrogels possess properties13,
Materials and methods
Photo-patterning of hydrogel films
A temperature-responsive hydrogel (poly(N-isopropylacrylamide), PNIPAM) is covalently grafted onto a flat substrate that forms the bottom wall of the microfluidic device. This process is an ex situ synthesis. Specifically, the hydrogel ‘grafting onto’ synthesis consists of simultaneous surface-grafting and cross-linking functionalized polymers through thiol-ene click chemistry. The surface-attached hydrogel films are obtained by coating the ene-functionalized polymers in the presence of dithiol molecules as cross-linkers on thiol-modified substrates. One advantage of this process is that it has been shown to allow both chemical cross-linking of the polymer chains and their covalent attachment to the surface with accurate and systematic control35. Ene-modified PNIPAM is dissolved in a 1:1 mixture of methanol and butanol at 10 wt%. The cross-linker, dithioerythritol, is later added to this solution at 6 wt%.
Patterning of the hydrogel is accomplished by exposure to deep UVs (~250 nm). This can be achieved either by using standard photolithographic techniques, that is, with masks and UV lamps (8 Watt, 254 nm wavelength), or with a direct laser writing equipment (Dilase650 Kloe, Montpellier, France) using a 266 nm wavelength and 50 mW output-power source. After exposure, the non-attached polymer chains are removed by washing (with ultrapure water). The lateral resolution is 5 μm with the standard lithographic technique, whereas it is 2 μm with the direct laser writing. These scales control the minimum size of the structures we produce. In all cases, the height of the patterned structures can be selected to be between 100 nm and 7 μm.
Preparation of thiol-modified substrates and integration of microheaters
In the first version, called Method 1, a thiol-modified glass substrate was used. Specifically, the glass slides are cleaned with a Piranha solution (3:1 mixture of sulfuric acid and hydrogen peroxide heated at 200 °C for 20 min). Silanization with 3-mercaptopropyltrimethoxysilane is carried out on the freshly cleaned substrates to perform the thiol-modification of the surface. A solution of anhydrous toluene with a 3 vol% of mercaptopropyltrimethoxysilane (ABCR Gelest) is put in contact with the substrates for 3 h inside a reactor under nitrogen. The solid substrates are rinsed and sonicated in toluene and finally dried with a nitrogen flow. In this version, the hydrogel is heated by placing the entire device on a PTC-200 Peltier thermocycler (MU Research) and applying a thermal paste (Radiospares) between the support and the glass slide of the microfluidic device to improve thermal contact.
In the second version, called Method 2, the hydrogels are locally heated by depositing a patterned chromium/gold bilayer onto the flat substrate. Glass wafers (2′′) are coated with a 100 nm layer of gold above a few nanometer-thick chromium adhesion layer. A layer of S1813 G2 (Shipley) is spin-coated and processed with a standard photolithography protocol to pattern the micro-heater structure. To ensure adhesion of the gel to the gold, a thiol modification of the surfaces is performed by immersing the gold substrates in a 1 mM solution of dithioerythritol (Sigma-Aldrich, St Louis, MO, USA) in chloroform for 2 h followed by rinsing in clear chloroform and sonicating for one minute. COMSOL numerical studies show that the temperature field extends around the heater for ~50 μm, independently of the temperature.
Closure of the device
Two materials are used for closing the systems and producing the microfluidic devices. The first one is PDMS. In this case, the chips are fabricated following the standard soft lithography technique36. Bonding between the flat substrate and the PDMS chip is achieved by using an O2 plasma treatment for 45 s. The second material used is the Norland Optical Adhesive (NOA 81 (ThorLabs)). In the case of NOA, the microfluidic stickers procedure is used37. NOA chips are obtained by stamping uncured NOA with a PDMS stamp and cured with UV exposure (LC8, Hamamatsu). Bonding between the substrate and the NOA chip is achieved with the presence of an uncured residual film after the first UV exposure. Sealing is then strengthened by a second UV exposure followed by a 30-minute curing at 90 °C.
Control of the hydrogel film along with its functionality
The functionality of the hydrogel is evaluated by ellipsometric measurements of the swelling ratio (ratio between the hydrogel thickness in water and the dry thickness in air) performed at the polymer synthesis stage. The thickness of the hydrogel films is measured with a spectroscopic ellipsometer Nanofilm EP3 (Accurion GmbH, Goettingen, Germany). Thicknesses range between 100 nm and 7 μm. Following dry thickness measurements, measurements in water are performed using a temperature-controllable liquid cell with thin glass walls fixed perpendicularly to the light path (the angle of incidence is fixed at 60°). The swelling ratio is the same (value of 1.5) for all PNIPAM films above the Lower Critical Solution Temperature LCST. Below the LCST, the value of 4 has been obtained with 2% ene-reactive polymers38,
For amplification experiments, we use RCA amplification of a target Human Synaptonjanin 1 gene, which is considered to be potentially involved in Parkinson’s disease. The amplification is performed with the Illustra Genomiphi V2 kit (GE Healthcare, Little Chalfont, UK). The amplification mixture is supplemented with 1 μl of a qPCR gene expression primer/probe set (ThermoScientific, SYNJ1 FAM-MGB, 20×). Here the fluorescent probe acts as a hydration probe rather than a Taqman probe. The DNA concentration is 84 pg μl−1, corresponding statistically to 7 DNA molecules per 8 pl hydrogel cage. The microchip is first filled with a solution of Pluronic F127 (2%, Sigma Aldrich) and cycled between 20 °C and 50 °C on a PTC-200 Peltier device for 1 h. The amplification mixture is then injected with an MFCS pressure controller (Fluigent) at 40 °C and the temperature was switched to 28 °C to begin the 2 h long incubation. The time between the end of the sample preparation and the beginning of the incubation is less than 5 min. Control experiments are performed in parallel. Hydrogel cage fluorescence is monitored using a shuttered UV lamp and a camera as described in the following section.
Optical observation and in situ determination of the hydrogel landscape
The optical observations are performed with various techniques: interferometric microscopy, bright field microscopy or epifluorescence microscopy, using inverted microscopes (usually with 2.5× or 5× objectives) or a 0.8–9.2× binocular microscope. For fluorescence studies, the dyes are 0.8 mM solution of fluorescein in Milli-Q water and 0.1 mM solution of rhodamine B and we used two-color microscopy. Images are taken using sensitive cameras (Hamamatsu ImageEM and OrcaER) and processed using Matlab software.
To measure the hydrogel topography in situ, we use a fluorescence-based technique that consists of filling the device with a dilute fluorescein solution and measuring the intensity field. Supplementary Information 2 shows that in the range of the concentration used, this intensity is proportional to the difference between the hydrogel and the channel heights. By converting intensities into heights, we determine the topography of the hydrogel structure in situ in real time with an accuracy estimated to be in the order of 1–2 microns (for experiments lasting several seconds). This technique allows direct visualization of the dynamics of the hydrogel actuators.
Micro-valving is a fundamentally important microfluidic functionality that is well achieved with our hydrogel technology. The fabrication process of a microfluidic valve is shown in Figure 1a. We integrate a rectangular patch of gel, similar to Figure 1b (upper figure), in a micro-channel normal to its length using the NOA closure technique explained previously. To seal the valve, the hydrogel patch length slightly exceeds the channel width. Closing is achieved by applying a force of a few newtons on the material that is pressed onto the bottom plate to close the channel so that the excess hydrogel is squeezed between this material and the bottom plate. This construction prevents the presence of dead volumes and the advent of leaks. Figure 1c shows the fluorescence microscopy images and the corresponding topographies of a valve in the open and closed positions (see Materials and Methods, and Supplementary Information 2). At 40 °C, that is, above the LCST, the valve is open. The gel occupies a fraction of the microchannel height, or 40% in this particular case. As the temperature is lowered to 25 °C, the hydrogel film swells and the valve closes. Supplementary Information 3 shows the movie corresponding to Figure 1c.
Physically, the closure of the valve is a result of the considerable increase of the local hydrodynamic resistance caused by the obstruction of the channel with the hydrogel. The obstruction is due to the design (the channel or chamber height is 80–90% of the height of the swollen gel in free conditions). Diffusion measurements are presented later in the paper. In such conditions, calculations based on hydrodynamics show the increase of resistance between the open and the closed states on the order of (h/r)4, where h is the channel height and r is the pore size. With h~10 μm and r ~1 nm, this ratio is on the order of 1016. In such conditions, without diffusion, it would take years for a water molecule to cross the gel barrier under the action of a pressure gradient. For solutes of comparable size or larger than the gel pore, this time is much longer. In all cases, the increase of resistance is so large that the circuit can be considered hydrodynamically closed. This does not preclude diffusive exchanges across the gel barrier, which will be presented in the following section.
Figure 2a presents the temporal evolution of the flow-rate, for an isolated valve subjected to a constant pressure of 500 mbar and actuated periodically in time, with a period of 5 min; the experiments lasted for 10 h. Beyond demonstrating that the actuation is reproducible, the graphs show that leaks are so small that they are not measurable. Further studies show that in this system, the burst pressure (that is, the pressure above which closed valves are forced to open), is above three bars, a figure well compatible with the vast majority of microfluidic applications. Added to these characteristics, one must recall the absence, by construction, of dead volumes. The micro-valves we report here therefore possess excellent performance.
Figure 2b represents devices with two valves actuated independently (see Supplementary Information 4 for detail). They are designed to measure the switching time and demonstrating that fluids can be distributed in a microfluidic system with a local control. In the resting state when no local heating is applied (room temperature 21 °C), the valves are closed, while they open independently when local heating is applied. For the sake of visualization, the two aqueous solutions driven in the system are labeled, respectively, by fluorescein and rhodamine, and observed with a two-color microscope. Figure 2b shows that, as expected, two different fluids can be transported sequentially in the same collecting channel, by actuating two valves. In Figure 2b (iii), two aqueous solutions are injected, one is a 0.8 mmol l−l fluorescein solution and the other is pure water. The two valves are actuated with a 180° phase shift, at a frequency of 2 Hz. In such circumstances, fluorescein waves develop. They are advected by the main stream and propagate downstream (see Supplementary Information 4). Measurements of the amplitude of these waves, plotted as a function of the frequency, exhibit a low pass-band behavior, with a cutoff frequency of 5 Hz. The switching time of the valves can in fact be inferred from Figure 2b (iv). This figure, extracted from the video corresponding to Figure 2b (i), (ii), shows the temporal evolution of the green/red interface position Ai, divided by half the channel width w, as the upper (red) valve is subjected to sudden heating of the micro-heater, or to sudden turn off of the heating. In all these experiments, the lower (green) valve is maintained open. Initially, the (red) valve is heated above 32 °C, the two valves are thus open and consequently the red/green interface lies at the center of the channel, for which Ai=0. At t=4.2±0.1 s, the heating of the red valve is turned off, the gel swells, the (red) valve closes, and the interface displaces rapidly towards the channel wall, for which . Figure 2b (iv) shows that this process takes <1 s. Using an exponential fit, we find a time constant equal to 0.6±0.1 s. A similar measurement, carried out with the turn-on of the heating at t=8.9±0.1 s, leads to a time constant of 0.25±0.15 s for the opening of the valve, a value substantially smaller than the closing time. One may speculate that these switching times can favorably be compared with the characteristic time (Ref. 41), where h is the channel height and Dgel~10−10 m2/s, a plausible value for a diffusion constant in this context. From a practical prospective, the sub-second switching times we find are well adapted to biotechnological applications.
Caging is a new functionality that is achieved by patterning hydrogel in the shape of square enclosures, as shown in Figure 3. This Figure shows the 3D topography of a 100×100 μm square cage, 3 μm-high in the dry state, confined in a microfluidic chamber, 10 μm-high, at different temperatures, above and below the LCST. At low temperature (25 °C), walls are raised, forming a cage that fills entirely the chamber height, while at higher temperature (40 °C), walls collapse down to 4 μm, opening the cage. The movie presented in Supplementary Information 5 shows the dynamics of opening and closing of such cages. Furthermore, the movie shown in the Supplementary Information 6 shows two cages separated by 300 μm actuated independently.
Cages can be used to isolate entities, such as molecules, cells (see the following section), particles, and deliver them on demand them. For the sake of visualization, this functionality can be illustrated with fluorescein and rhodamine. In Figure 3a, twenty-five square cages (10×200×200 μm) are integrated in a shallow NOA chamber through which different aqueous solutions are driven. First, the chamber is washed with a fluorescein solution and the temperature is increased to 50 °C. The cage walls (appearing as red in the figure due to rhodamine labelling) are in a low position. Then, the flow is maintained while the temperature is decreased: because the cages are thicker, they appear as dark zones, whereas the premises of photobleaching appear inside the cages as a result of the isolation and immobilization of the fluorescein (Figure 3a (ii)). Finally, Figure 3a (iii) shows that, after flushing the system, the fluorescein is trapped in the cages. Isolation is efficient because, as shown in Figure 3b, there is no observable fluorescein exchange between the inside and the outside of the cages within the time scale we have considered (minutes). The fluorescein can later be released with further heating (shown in Supplementary Information 6).
The question of the permeability of the gel barrier is addressed in Figure 3b and developed in Supplementary Information 7. We performed diffusion of fluorescein experiments through the walls of a single rectangular trap. In these experiments, fluorescein is initially outside the wall and we measure the kinetics of diffusion of this solute through the four walls of the cage by tracking the fluorescence intensity level of the fluorescein in the cage as a function of time, averaged over the cage area. The plot in Figure 3b shows that the normalized intensity (where Imax is the intensity outside the cage) increases with time but at a very slow rate—10 h is required to reach a concentration comparable to that of outside the cage. By fitting the curve with a diffusion model (Supplementary Information 7), we find an effective diffusion constant of 2.5×10−13 m2/s, which is three orders of magnitude below the free diffusion constant of fluorescein. This slowing down of the diffusion process due to confinement (pore sizes are 1–2 nm, which is comparable to the fluorescein molecule), is consistent with models published in the literature42. This experiment shows that barriers can be used as membranes with controlled transport properties, a property potentially interesting for microbiology applications.
The concept of high density, that is, the capacity of the hydrogel technology to operate with a large number of cages, is illustrated in Figure 3c (see Supplementary Information 8 for details). Here, we produced a device with 3000 circular chambers and perform a series of experiments identical to those in Figure 3a. Figure 3c shows the design of the device and an enlargement of the array containing 130 cages on a surface of 3 mm2, which is a density of 44 cages par mm2, that is, roughly one cage per 100 μm2. This density is comparable to the state-of-the-art achieved with PDMS valves and droplet technology. The figure on the right shows the details of the system: the fluorescein is trapped in 23 cages similarly to Figure a (iii). This demonstrates that hydrogel caging technology enables the fabrication of functional high-density devices.
Applications: single-cell trapping/release and DNA isothermal amplification
In this section, we illustrate two applications of our hydrogel technology. The first, shown in Figure 4a, is the trapping and release of individual cells. Circulating B cells are injected in a chamber 10 μm high, containing 8 square cages that are 300 μm wide with 50 μm thick hydrogel walls. In Figure 4a (i), the cage is at an expanded state and several cells accumulate at the wall side exposed to the upstream current near the stagnation point. As the system heats up, the walls collapse and a flow above the walls is generated, freeing the accumulated cells. By lowering the temperature, a single cell can be trapped in the cage (Figure 4a (ii)). This cell is released upon further heating (Figure 4a (iii)). Although the protocol is manual, it nonetheless illustrates the potential of the technology regarding capture and release of individual cells.
The application of our hydrogel technology to isothermal amplification and NAAT is illustrated in Figure 4b. Here, the system is filled with a biological sample composed of a buffer containing the Human Synaptojanin 1 gene at concentrations of 84 pg μl−1 and a mix designed for RCA amplification with primers targeting the gene. SYNJ1 mutations are suspected to be involved in several neurodegenerative diseases, such as Parkinson’s disease (see Materials and Methods section). The goal of the experiment illustrated here is to detect its presence. Figure 4b (i) shows 144 cages as part of a system of 7800 cages system after 3 hrs of isothermal amplification. The latter is performed once the chip is filled with the sample and RCA mix at 40 °C and cooled down to 28 °C to seal the cages. The image shows that the gene is amplified homogeneously in each cage. The presence of the hydrogel is not detrimental to RCA amplification. Figure 4b (ii) shows a typical amplification curve along with a negative control containing no DNA. In the control experiment, a small fluorescence signal is produced by the probes. However, the signal over noise ratio remains important. From a NAAT prospective, one can conclude from the inspection of Figure 4b that the gene is present in the sample. This system illustrates the diagnostic capability of our technology.
Discussion and conclusion
In this paper, by using an ex situ hydrogel-based technology, we microfabricated devices with up to 7800 actuated micro-cages that sequester and release solutes, along with valves actuated individually with switching times of 250 and 600 ms for the opening and closing respectively. Two applications of this technology were illustrated in the domain of single cell handling and NAAT for the Human Synaptojanin 1 gene.
From a technological prospective, in the case of isothermal systems (all cages actuated at once), it is not difficult to achieve VLSI (Very large System Integration) by reducing the size of the hydrogel valves or cages to 5 μm. In this case, we can reach a density of 1 million valves or cages per cm2. With cages actuated independently, the situation is more challenging, but densities of thousands of cages per cm2—still a high throughput—can certainly be envisioned.
Caging functionality allows the trapping of entities under high throughput conditions similar to droplet-based technology. However, since gels are permeable, hydrogel walls can also operate as membranes, allowing the exchange of small molecules between the sequestered entity (for example, cells) and the external medium.
From a general perspective, there is room to extend or diversify the range of functionalities of our hydrogel technology by varying the gel chemistry, using different stimuli (for example, light, pH), developing different behaviors (LCST or UCST), or grafting molecules, exploiting specific affinities for analytical purposes.
The biotechnological applications of our responsive hydrogel-based technology are numerous. Digital amplification is an example. In our case, thousands of cages can be integrated on a single system so that high throughput screening or high sensitivity analyses of samples are feasible and with direct readout. Single-cell manipulation, stimulated by a growing recognition of the important role that play genomic heterogeneities in biological systems, provides another example of the applications of our technology. Microbiology is another field where thermo-sensitive hydrogels with well-controlled chemistry offer potential advantages. In this case, the permeability of the gel can be harnessed to deliver therapeutic molecules to cells trapped in cages to screen antibiotics. In addition, most importantly, these applications can be developed under interesting cost conditions because the materials are inexpensive and actuation requires low voltage sources or standard hot plates.
We gratefully thank the Institut Pierre-Gilles de Gennes (IPGG), the French National Research Agency (ANR), EQUIPEX and LABEX IPGG (Grant Nos. ANR-10-IDEX-0001-02, ANR-10-LABX-31,PSL*), the China Scholarship Council (CSC), ESPCI, CNRS, PSL, and the Ministry of Science and Technology of Thailand (MOST) for their financial support. We are grateful to Jacques Prost who initiated the collaboration. We are grateful for the help and discussions with Emilie Bayon, Ghimire Buwan, Luce Dauphinot, Olivier Mesdjian, Jacques Fattacioli, and Marie Caroline Jullien.