Abstract
Studies of the health impacts of airborne particulates’ chemical constituents typically assume spatial homogeneity and estimate exposure from ambient monitors. However, factors such as local sources may cause spatially heterogeneous pollution levels. This work examines the degree to which constituent levels vary within communities and whether exposure misclassification is introduced by spatial homogeneity assumptions. Analysis considered PM2.5 elemental carbon (EC), organic carbon matter, ammonium, sulfate, nitrate, silicon, and sodium ion (Na+) for the United States, 1999–2007. Pearson correlations and coefficients of divergence were calculated and compared to distances among monitors. Linear modeling related correlations to distance between monitors, long-term constituent levels, and population density. Spatial heterogeneity was present for all constituents, yet lower for ammonium, sulfate, and nitrate. Lower correlations were associated with higher distance between monitors, especially for nitrate and sulfate, and with lower long-term levels, especially for sulfate and Na+. Analysis of colocated monitors revealed measurement error for all constituents, especially EC and Na+. Exposure misclassification may be introduced into epidemiological studies of PM2.5 constituents due to spatial variability, and is affected by constituent type and level. When assessing health effects of PM constituents, new methods are needed for estimating exposure and accounting for exposure error induced by spatial variability.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution
Access options
Subscribe to this journal
Receive 6 print issues and online access
$259.00 per year
only $43.17 per issue
Buy this article
- Purchase on Springer Link
- Instant access to full article PDF
Prices may be subject to local taxes which are calculated during checkout
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Athanassiadis G.A., and Rao S.T. Spatial and temporal variations in the trace elemental data over the northeastern United States. Environ Poll 2003: 123: 439–339.
Baxter L.K., Wright R.J., Paciorek C.J., Laden F., Suh H.H., and Levy J.I. Effects of exposure measurement error in the analysis of health effects from traffic-related air pollution. J Expo Sci Environ Epidemiol 2010: 20: 101–111.
Belanger K., Gent J.F., Triche E.W., Bracken M.B., and Leaderer B.P. Association of indoor nitrogen dioxide exposure with respiratory symptoms in children with asthma. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2006: 173: 297–303.
Bell M.L., Dominici F., Ebisu K., Zeger S.L., and Samet J.M. Spatial and temporal variation in PM2.5 chemical composition in the United States for health effects studies. Environ Health Perspect 2007: 115: 989–995.
Bell M.L., Ebisu K., Peng R.D., Samet J.M., and Dominici F. Hospital admissions and chemical composition of fine particle air pollution. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2009: 179: 1115–1120.
Bell M.L. The use of ambient air quality modeling to estimate individual and population exposure for human health research: a case study of ozone in the Northern Georgia region of the United States. Environ Int 2006: 32: 586–593.
Blanchard C.L., Carr E.L., Collins J.F., Smith T.B., Lehrman D.E., and Michaels H.M. Spatial representativeness and scales of transport during the 1995 integrated monitoring study in California's San Joaquin Valley. Atmos Environ 1999: 33: 4775–4786.
Brauer M., Lencar C., Tamburic L., Koehoorn M., Demers P., and Karr C. A cohort study of traffic-related air pollution impacts on birth outcomes. Environ Health Perspect 2008: 116: 680–686.
Burton R.M., Suh H.H., and Koutrakis P. Spatial variations in particulate concentrations within metropolitan Philadelphia. Environ Sci Technol 1996: 30: 440–407.
Caffo B., Peng R.D., Dominici F., Louis T.A., and Zeger S. Parallel Bayesian MCMC imputation for multiple distributed lag models: a case study in environmental epidemiology In: Brooks, Gelman, Jones, and Meng (eds). The Handbook of Markov Chain Monte Carlo (in press).
Carroll R.J., Ruppert D., Stefanski L.A., and Crainiceanu C.M. Measurement Error in Nonlinear Models: A Modern Perspective, 2nd edn. Chapman & Hall/CRC: New York, 2006.
Chow J.C., Doraiswamy P., Watson J.G., Chen L.W.A., Ho S.S.H., and Sodeman D.A. Advances in integrated and continuous measurements for particle mass and chemical composition. J Air Waste Manag Assoc 2008: 58: 141–163.
de Hartog J.J., Lanki T., Timonen K.L., Hoek G., Janssen N.A., Ibald-Mulli A., Peters A., Heinrich J., Tarkiainen T.H., van Grieken R., van Wijnen J.H., Brunekreef B., and Pekkanen J. Associations between PM2.5 and heart rate variability are modified by particle composition and beta-blocker use in patients with coronary heart disease. Environ Health Perspect 2009: 117: 105–111.
DeGaetano A.T., and Doherty O.M. Temporal, spatial and meteorological variations in hourly PM2.5 concentration extremes in New York City. Atmos Environ 2004: 38: 1547–1558.
Dominici F., Peng R.D., Bell M.L., Pham L., McDermott A., Zeger S.L., and Samet J.M. Fine particulate air pollution and hospital admission for cardiovascular and respiratory diseases. J Am Med Assoc 2006: 295: 1127–1134.
Flanagan J.B., Jayanty R.K.M., Rickman E.E., and Peterson M.R. PM2.5 speciation trends network: evaluation of whole-system uncertainties using data from sites with collocated samplers. J Air Waste Manag Assoc 2006: 56: 492–499.
Franklin M., Koutrakis P., and Schwartz J. The role of particle composition on the association between PM2.5 and mortality. Epidemiology 2008: 19: 680–689.
Graney J.R., Landis M.S., and Norris G.A. Concentrations and solubility of metals from indoor and personal exposure PM2.5 samples. Atmos Environ 2004: 38: 237–247.
Grivas G., Chaloulakou A., and Kassomenos P. An overview of the PM10 pollution problem, in the metropolitan area of Athens, Greece. Assessment of controlling factors and potential impacts of long range transport. Sci Total Environ 2008: 389: 168–177.
Grivas G., Chaloulakou A., Samara C., and Spyrellis N. Spatial and temporal variation of PM10 mass concentrations within the greater area of Athens, Greece. Water Air Soil Poll 2004: 158: 357–371.
Gryparis A., Paciorek C.J., Zeka A., Schwartz J., and Coull B.A. Measurement error caused by spatial misalignment in environmental epidemiology. Biostatistics 2009: 10: 258–274.
Hogrefe C., Lynn B., Goldberg R., Rosenzweig C., Zalewsky E., Hao W., Doraiswamy P., Civerolo K., Ku J.Y., Sistla G., and Kinney P.L. A combined model-observation approach to estimate historic gridded fields of PM2.5 mass and species concentrations. Atmos Environ 2009: 43: 2561–2570.
Holford T.R., Ebisu K., McKay L.A., Gent J.F., Triche E.W., Bracken M.B., and Leaderer B.P. Integrated exposure modeling: a model using GIS and GLM. Stat Med 2010: 29: 116–129.
Hyslop N.P., and White W.H. An empirical approach to estimating detection limits using collocated data. Environ Sci Tech 2008: 42: 5235–5240.
Ito K., De Leon S., Thurston G.D., Nádas A., and Lippmann M. Monitor-to-monitor temporal correlation of air pollution in the contiguous US. J Exp Anal Environ Epidemiol 2005: 15: 172–184.
Ito K., Kinney P.L., and Thurston G.D. Variations in PM-10 concentrations within two metropolitan areas and their implications for health effects analyses. Inhal Toxicol 1995: 7: 735–745.
Ito K., Thurston G.D., Nádas A., and Lippmann M. Monitor-to-monitor temporal correlation of air pollution and weather variables in the North-Central US. J Exp Anal Environ Epidemiol 2001: 11: 21–32.
Ito K., Xue N., and Thurston G. Spatial variation of PM2.5 chemical species and source-apportioned mass concentrations in New York City. Atmos Environ 2004: 38: 5269–5282.
Karr C.J., Rudra C.B., Miller K.A., Gould T.R., Larson T., Sathyanarayana S., and Koenig J.Q. Infant exposure to fine particulate matter and traffic and risk of hospitalization for RSV bronchiolitis in a region with lower ambient air pollution. Environ Res 2009: 109: 321–327.
Kim B.M., Teffera S., and Zeldin M.D. Characterization of PM2.5 and PM10 in the south coast Air Basin of Southern California: Part 1 — spatial variations. J Air Waste Manag Assoc 2000: 50: 2034–2044.
Kim S.B., Temiyasathit C., Chen V.C.P., Park H.S., Sattler M., and Russell A.G. Characterization of spatially homogeneous regions based on temporal patterns of fine particulate matter in the continental United States. J Air Waste Manag Assoc 2008: 58: 965–975.
Laden F., Neas L.M., Dockery D.W., and Schwartz J. Association of fine particulate matter from different sources with daily mortality in six US cities. Environ Health Perspect 2000: 108: 941–947.
Magari S.R., Schwartz J., Williams P.L., Hauser R., Smith T.J., and Christiani D.C. The association of particulate air metal concentrations with heart rate variability. Environ Health Perspect 2002: 110: 875–880.
Martuzevicius D., Grinshpun S.A., Reponen T., Górny R.L., Shukla R., Lockey J., Hu S., McDonald R., Biswas P., Kliucininkas L., and LeMasters G. Spatial and temporal variations of PM2.5 concentration and composition throughout an urban area with high freeway density — the Greater Cincinnati study. Atmos Environ 2004: 38: 1091–1105.
Martuzevicius D., Luo J., Reponen T., Shuka R., Kelley A.L., St Clair H., and Grinshpun S.A. Evaluation and optimization of an urban PM2.5 monitoring network. J Environ Monitoring 2005: 7: 67–77.
Moreno T., Querol X., Pey J., Minguillón M.C., Pérez N., Alastuey A., Bernabé R.M., Blanco S., Cárdenas B., Eichinger W., Salcido A., and Gibbons W. Spatial and temporal variations in inhalable CuZnPb aerosols within the Mexico City pollution plume. J Environ Monitoring 2008: 10: 370–378.
Nerriere Ė., Guegan H., Bordigoni B., Hautemaniere A., Momas I., Ladner J., Target A., Lameloise P., Delmas V., Personnaz M.B., Koutrakis P., and Zmirou-Navier D. Spatial heterogeneity of personal exposure to airborne metals in French urban areas. Sci Total Environ 2007: 373: 49–56.
Noll J., and Birch M.E. Effects of sampling artifacts on occupational samples of diesel particulate matter. Environ Sci Tech 2008: 42: 5223–5228.
Ostro B., Feng W.Y., Broadwin R., Green S., and Lipsett M. The effects of components of fine particulate air pollution on mortality in California: results from CALFINE. Environ Health Perspect 2007: 115: 13–19.
Peng R.D., Bell M.L., Geyh A.S., McDermott A., Zeger S.L., Samet J.M., and Dominici F. Emergency admissions for cardiovascular and respiratory diseases and the chemical composition of fine particle air pollution. Environ Health Perspect 2009: 117: 957–963.
Peng R.D., and Bell M.L. Spatial misalignment in time series studies of air pollution and health data. Biostatistics (in press).
Pinto J.P., Lefohn A.S., and Shadwick D.S. Spatial variability of PM2.5 in urban areas in the United States. J Air Waste Manag Assoc 2004: 54: 440–449.
Pun B., Seigneur C., and Edgerton E. Creation of an Air Pollutant Database for Health Effects Studies: Phase I Report — Collection of PM Speciation and Related Data. Atmospheric and Environmental Research, Inc.: San Ramon, CA report submitted to Health Effects Institute, 2004.
Pun B.K., and Seigneur C. Organic aerosol spatial/temporal patterns: perspectives of measurements and model. Environ Sci Tech 2008: 42: 7287–7293.
Röösli M., Theis G., Künzli N., Staehelin J., Mathys P., Oglesby L., Camenzind M., and Braun-Fahrländer C. Temporal and spatial variation of the chemical composition of PM10 at urban and rural sites in the Basel area, Switzerland. Atmos Environ 2001: 35: 3701–3713.
Sarnat S.E., Klein M., Sarnat J.A., Flanders W.D., Waller L.A., Mulholland J.A., Russell A.G., and Tolbert P.E. An examination of exposure measurement error from air pollutant spatial variability in time-series studies. J Exp Sci Environ Epidemiol 2010: 20: 135–146.
So K.L., Guo H., and Li Y.S. Long-term variation of PM2.5 levels and composition at rural, urban, and roadside sites in Hong Kong: increasing impact of regional air pollution. Atmos Environ 2007: 41: 9427–9434.
Suh H.H., Nishioka Y., Allen G.A., Koutrakis P., and Burton R.M. The Metropolitan Acid Aerosol Characterization Study: results from the summer 1994 Washington, DC field study. Environ Health Perspect 1997: 105: 826–824.
Touma J.S., Isakov V., Ching J., and Seigneur C. Air quality modeling of hazardous pollutants: current status and future directions. J Air Waste Manag Assoc 2006: 56: 547–558.
US Census Bureau. Census 2000, Summary File 1. US Census Bureau, Washington, DC, 2000.
US Environmental Protection Agency. Quality Assurance Project Plan: PM2.5 Speciation Trends Network Field Sampling. US EPA Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards: Research Triangle Park, NC, 2000.
US Environmental Protection Agency. Quality Management Plan for the Fine Particle Speciation Trends Monitoring Program. US EPA Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards: Research Triangle Park, NC, 2001.
Vallejo M., Ruiz S., Hermosillo A.G., Borja-Aburto V.H., and Cárdenas M. Ambient fine particles modify heart rate variability in young healthy adults. J Exp Sci Environ Epidemiol 2006: 16: 125–130.
Vecchi R., Valli G., Fermo P., D’Alessandro A., Piazzalunga A., and Bernardoni V. Organic and inorganic sampling artefacts assessment. Atmos Environ 2009: 43: 1713–1720.
Vega E., Ruiz H., Martínez-Villa G., Sosa G., González-Ávalos E., Reyes E., and García J. Fine and coarse particulate matter chemical characterization in a heavily industrialized city in Central Mexico during Winter 2003. J Air Waste Manag Assoc 2007: 57: 620–633.
Venkatachari P., Zhou L., Hopke P.K., Felton D., Rattigan O.V., Schwab J.J., and Demerjian K.L. Spatial and temporal variability of black carbon in New York City. J Geophysical Res D Atmospheres 2006: 111. doi:10.1029/2005JD006314.
Von Klot S., Gryparis A., Tonne C., Yanosky J., Coull B.A., Goldberg R.J., Lessard D., Melly S.J., Suh H.H., and Schwartz J. Elemental carbon exposure at residence and survival after acute myocardial infarction. Epidemiology 2009: 20: 547–554.
Wade K.S., Mulholland J.A., Marmur A., Russell A.G., Hartsell B., Edgerton E., Klein M., Waller L., Peel J.L., and Tolbert P.E. Effects of instrument precision and spatial variability on the assessment of the temporal variation of ambient air pollution in Atlanta, Georgia. J Air Waste Manag Assoc 2006: 56: 876–888.
Wilson J.G., Kingham S., Pearce J., and Sturman A.P. A review of intraurban variations in particulate air pollution: implications for epidemiological research. Atmos Environ 2005: 39: 6444–6462.
Wilson J.G., Kingham S., and Sturman A.P. Intraurban variations of PM10 air pollution in Christchurch, New Zealand: Implications for epidemiological studies. Sci Total Environ 2006: 367: 559–572.
Wongphatarakul V., Friedlander S.K., and Pinto J.K. A comparative study of PM2.5 ambient aerosol chemical databases. Environ Sci Tech 1998: 32: 3926–3934.
Zeger S.L., Thomas D., Dominici F., Samet J.M., Schwartz J., Dockery D., and Cohen A. Exposure measurement error in time-series studies of air pollution: concepts and consequences. Environ Health Perspect 2000: 108: 419–426.
Zou B., Wilson J.G., Zhan F.B., and Zeng Y. Air pollution exposure assessment methods utilized in epidemiological studies. J Environ Monitoring 2009: 11: 475–490.
Acknowledgements
This study was funded by the US Environmental Protection Agency (RD-83241701), the Health Effects Institute (4720-RFA04-2/04-16), and the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences (5R01ES015028).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bell, M., Ebisu, K. & Peng, R. Community-level spatial heterogeneity of chemical constituent levels of fine particulates and implications for epidemiological research. J Expo Sci Environ Epidemiol 21, 372–384 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1038/jes.2010.24
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/jes.2010.24
Keywords
This article is cited by
-
Effects of in-utero personal exposure to PM2.5 sources and components on birthweight
Scientific Reports (2023)
-
Impact of Fine-Mode Fraction on the Relationship Between MODIS AOD and Ground-Based Particulate Matter
Journal of the Indian Society of Remote Sensing (2022)
-
Evaluating deciduous tree leaves as biomonitors for ambient particulate matter pollution in Pittsburgh, PA, USA
Environmental Monitoring and Assessment (2019)
-
Spatial measurement errors in the field of spatial epidemiology
International Journal of Health Geographics (2016)
-
Framework for using deciduous tree leaves as biomonitors for intraurban particulate air pollution in exposure assessment
Environmental Monitoring and Assessment (2016)