Abstract
Magnetic reconnection is a process by which oppositely directed magnetic field lines passing through a plasma undergo dramatic rearrangement, converting magnetic potential into kinetic energy and heat1,2. It is believed to play an important role in many plasma phenomena including solar flares3,4, star formation5 and other astrophysical events6, laser-driven plasma jets7,8,9, and fusion plasma instabilities10. Because of the large differences of scale between laboratory and astrophysical plasmas, it is often difficult to extrapolate the reconnection phenomena studied in one environment to those observed in the other. In some cases, however, scaling laws11 do permit reliable connections to made, such as the experimental simulation of interactions between the solar wind and the Earth’s magnetosphere12. Here we report well-scaled laboratory experiments that reproduce loop-top-like X-ray source emission by reconnection outflows interacting with a solid target. Our experiments exploit the mega-gauss-scale magnetic field generated by interaction of a high-intensity laser with a plasma to reconstruct a magnetic reconnection topology similar to that which occurs in solar flares. We also identify the separatrix and diffusion regions associated with reconnection in which ions become decoupled from electrons on a scale of the ion inertial length.
Similar content being viewed by others
Main
A major objective of laboratory astrophysics is to simulate the fundamental nature of astrophysical plasma physics processes in a laboratory environment so that certain astrophysical phenomenon can be studied in a controlled manner13. High energy density facilities, such as high-powered lasers and Z-pinches, can provide such opportunities14, for example, direct measurements of opacity15, equations of state16, and photoionized plasmas17,18, as well as the similarity of physics, such as certain hydrodynamic phenomena of jets19 and shocks20 where a scaling law between astrophysical and laboratory plasma systems can be applied.
As a fundamental cause of many plasma energy conversion processes, magnetic reconnection (MR) is certainly a high priority of such studies. Masuda et al.21 observed the loop-top X-ray source in solar flares using the YOHKOH satellite and proposed that two antiparallel magnetic fields were merged above an arcade of closed loops as outflow jets from the reconnection point collided with high-density plasmas on the loop to produce a hot X-ray region. Ultraviolet22 and X-ray23,24 observations of plasma jets ejected from the regions above the solar surface were also reported, and further confirm theoretical models of MR. Because of the great similarity of phenomena relating to MR in solar flares and laser-produced plasmas, here, by applying the scaling law of magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), we try to reproduce the reconnection outflow/jet and the loop-top X-ray source in the laboratory using a high-power laser facility.
Previous simulations and experiments7,8,25,26 showed that a mega-gauss (MG) magnetic field B could be generated in hot, high-density plasmas by irradiating a solid target using high-power laser beams. The B-field was approximately ‘frozen’ in the plasma bubbles. As the two bubbles expanded laterally and encountered each other with oppositely directed B-fields, MR occurred as the B-field lines became topologically rearranged in the diffusion region. It thus enabled us to simulate the solar flare loop-top X-ray source generation process in the laboratory.
The experiment was performed at the Shenguang (SG) II laser facility, which can deliver a total energy of 2.0 kJ in a nanosecond square pulse. The eight SG II laser beams, with a wavelength of λL=0.351 μm, are divided into four bunches. Each bunch then consists of two laser beams. The geometric configuration, as shown in Fig. 1, is designed to be similar to the scheme of a loop-top X-ray source in the solar flares depicted in Fig. 2a. Two synchronized laser bunches separated by 400–600 μm are focused onto one side of the Al foil with the other two laser bunches symmetrically irradiating the other side simultaneously. Each bunch is focused to a focal spot diameter of 50–100 μm full width at half maximum (FWHM), giving an incident laser intensity of ∼5×1015 W cm−2. A Cu target is set 250 μm away from one foil edge. The Al foil is 1,600 μm×500 μm with a thickness of 10–50 μm. The Cu target is 1,600 μm×250 μm with a thickness of 150 μm. The X-ray emission is measured using three X-ray pinhole cameras in the forward, side and reverse directions, to investigate the reconnection jets as well as their impact on the copper target. The image is taken through a 10 μm pinhole, filtered with 50 μm of beryllium, allowing all X-rays above ∼1 keV to pass. Most of the signal from the high-energy continuum is recorded using time-integration on an X-ray film with its highest sensitivity to X-rays in the 1–10 keV range. A flat crystal spectrometer is set in front of the targets to record the X-ray spectra from the heated plasmas. Shadowgraphy and interferometry with a 120 ps green (λL=0.53 μm) laser beam are also used to investigate the evolution of the plasma.
The process can be reasonably described by MHD, as the magnetic Reynolds number is very high. Ryutov et al. 13 demonstrated the scaling relations of two ideal MHD systems (ReM≫1), in which the variables of the systems remain invariant under such transformations, as r=a r1, ρ=b ρ1, p=c p1, , , , where r is the characteristic length, ρ is the mass density, p is the pressure, v is the velocity, B is the magnetic field of the systems, and a, b, c are transformation coefficients. By choosing laser parameters and target materials properly, the magnetic Reynolds number is around 4,000 (for Z=13, A=27, L=0.1 cm, T=1,000 eV), which makes the MHD processes in laser plasmas and solar flares (ReM∼5×108) comparable.
The similarity of the MHD in solar flares and laser-produced plasmas is shown in Table 1, with the transformation coefficients a=10−11, b=108, and c=1010. The scaled parameters of the solar coronal plasmas in the third column are very similar to those of the laser-produced plasmas in the second column.
Two bright X-ray spots are clearly observed resulting from the laser heating the Al foil target. In Fig. 2b, the two laser spots are separated by 600 μm, nearly 6–7 laser focus diameters, in vacuum to reproduce a previously studied geometry of laser driven magnetic reconnection8. The spontaneous magnetic field has an estimated MG strength based on hydrodynamic simulations and similar experimental measurements7,8. When two plasma bubbles expand on the Al foil surface, two toroidal MG magnetic fields ‘frozen’ in the bubbles merge accordingly with each other. The breakdown of the ‘frozen in’ condition occurs when the oppositely directed fields B1 and B2 encounter each other between the spots, where a diffusion region can be clearly seen with two significant X-ray patterns showing the release of magnetic energy. The width across each pattern is on the order of the ion inertial length c/ωpi=2.28×107 z−1(μ/ni)1/2 (cm)≈100 μm, with an ion density of 1018 cm−3. In this region electrons and ions are decoupled, and MR occurs. Note that there is also a clear interface between the two X-ray emission patterns, which is possibly a magnetic separatrix between two plasmas with the dominant magnetic field component tangential to it. A similar experiment, however, was carried out with two imbalanced laser beams separated by 400 μm, as shown in Fig. 2c. Consequently, the upflow is not vertical but has an inclination of ∼10°, providing an interpretation for the plasma jet inclination in solar flares. The X-ray intensity, on the other hand, is greatly enhanced in comparison with that in Fig. 2b as a result of the small separation. The diffusion region can hardly be defined here because the emission in the region is too high to distinguish from the spots.
The most striking feature in both experiments is that a bright X-ray spot at the centre of the Cu target is observed just below the downward outflow/jet. The position and the arc shape of the spot is solid evidence that there is a high-speed outflow/jet on the Al foil impacting the plasma generated on the Cu target, a picture clearly resembling the loop-top X-ray source in solar flare observations. In Fig. 2c, the upflow ejected out of the Al target due to MR can also clearly be seen. It is more than 2 mm with a width of 300 μm, or 2×105 km with width of 3×104 km when scaled for a solar plasma; this is on the order of the typical lengths and widths of X-ray jets observed in solar flares23. The flow velocity was measured to be 400 (±50) km s−1 from time-resolved shadowgrams in the laboratory, which agrees well with the typical Alfvén speed of VA≈400 km s−1, in a magnetic field of 106 G for the experiment as well as the transverse velocity for bi-directional plasma jets of ∼150–300 km s−1 scaled from observations22. Here we assume the scaling law is valid during the whole reconnection process.
For the experiment, the initial state is not in equilibrium. On the edge of the plasma, the force balance is broken down because of an imbalance between the pressure gradient and the Lorentz force. Therefore, the reconnection process is extremely strongly driven. Next, we numerically simulated the experiment with a two-dimensional/3-component Hall MHD code, for the balanced beams with a 600 μm separation (Case 1), and for the imbalanced beams with a 400 μm separation (Case 2). The X-ray emission obtained in both the simulations agrees well with experimental results, as shown in Fig. 3a, and b. The reconnection geometry is found to be ‘Y-type’ (Fig. 3d), justifying the Sweet–Parker geometry, and the decoupling of ion and electron flows is also clearly shown by the black arrows (Fig. 3c) in the region with the ion inertia scale of di=c/ωpi≈100 μm, which is in good agreement with the experiment. A one dimensional cross section of the experimentally observed X-ray images between the two focal spots is also plotted for comparison to the numerical result. It can be seen that the X-ray signal patterns in the regions denoted by black arrows are also where the ion and electron flows are decoupled most significantly in the numerical simulation. The interface between the two X-ray peaks illustrated with red arrows shows a possible electron diffusion region around 10c/ωpe, larger than the theoretical prediction but in a good agreement with a recent MRX measurement29. We also find that reconnection is much faster (t=0.8 ns) than typical Sweet–Parker resistive reconnection, clear evidence of fast reconnection due to both the Hall effect and the boundary conditions30. The simulation of the imbalanced Case 2, as shown in Fig. 3b and d, also reproduced the experimental result in Fig. 2c well.
The experiment reported here is the first laboratory simulation of a MR induced loop-top X-ray source and outflow/jet with high-power lasers. MG magnetic fields and high-energy-density plasmas generated by intense laser pulses allow us to study astrophysical MR on a laboratory scale. Such measurements with the controlled parameters of laser-produced plasmas should greatly benefit the understanding of not only explosive energy release and particle acceleration processes such as solar flares, but also many other astrophysical phenomena related to MR.
Change history
11 October 2010
In the version of this Letter previously published online, the name of the satellite, YOHKOH, was incorrectly spelt. This has now been corrected in all versions of the Letter.
References
Yamada, M. Progress in understanding magnetic reconnection in laboratory and space astrophysical plasmas. Phys. Plasmas 14, 058102 (2007).
Zweibel, E. & Yamada, M. Magnetic reconnection in astrophysical and laboratory plasmas. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 47, 291–332 (2009).
Sweet, P. A. in The Neutral Point Theory of Solar Flares, IAUsymp.6 (ed. Lehnert, B.) 123 (Cambridge Univ. Press, 1958).
Parker, E. N. Sweet’s mechanism for merging magnetic fields in conducting fluids. J. Geophys. Res. 62, 509 (1957).
Kulsrud, R. M. Magnetic reconnection in a magnetohydrodynamic plasma. Phys. Plasmas 5, 1599 (1998).
Goodman, J. & Uzdensky, D. Reconnection in marginally collisionless accretion disk coronae. Astrophys. J. 688, 555–558 (2008).
Nilson, P. M. et al. Magnetic reconnection and plasma dynamics in two-beam laser–solid interactions. Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 255001 (2006).
Nilson, P. M. et al. Bidirectional jet formation during driven magnetic reconnection in two-beam laser-plasma interactions. Phys. Plasmas 15, 092701 (2008).
Li, C. K. et al. Observations of electromagnetic fields and plasma flow in hohlraums with proton radiography. Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 205001 (2009).
Taylor, J. B. Relaxation and magnetic reconnection in plasmas. Rev. Mod. Phys. 58, 741–763 (1986).
Ryutov, D. D., Drake, R. P. & Remington, B. A. Criteria for scaled laboratory simulations of astrophysical MHD phenomena. Astrophys. J. 127 (suppl.), 465–468 (2000).
Brady, P., Ditmire, T., Horton, W., Mays, M. L. & Zakharov, Y. Laboratory experiments simulating solar wind driven magnetospheres. Phys. Plasmas 16, 043112 (2009).
Remington, B. A., Drake, R. P. & Ryutov, D. D. Experimental astrophysics with high power lasers and Z pinches. Rev. Mod. Phys. 78, 755–807 (2006).
Takabe, H. Astrophysics with intense and ultra-intense lasers “laser astrophysics”. Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl. 143, 202–265 (2001).
Rogers, F. J. & Iglesias, C. A. Astrophysical opacity. Science 263, 50–55 (1994).
Celliers, P. M. et al. Electronic conduction in shock-compressed water. Phys. Plasmas 11, L41–L44 (2004).
Foord, M. E. et al. Charge-state distribution and Doppler effect in an expanding photoionized plasma. Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 055002 (2004).
Fujioka, S. et al. X-ray astronomy in the laboratory with a miniature compact object produced by laser-driven implosion. Nature Phys. 11, 495–497 (2009).
Gregory, C. D. et al. Astrophysical jet experiments with colliding laser-produced plasmas. Astrophys. J. 676, 420–426 (2008).
Foster, J. M. et al. Supersonic jet and shock interactions. Phys. Plasmas 9, 2251–2263 (2002).
Masuda, S. et al. A loop-top hard X-ray source in a compact solar flare as evidence for magnetic reconnection. Nature 371, 495–497 (1994).
Innes, D. E., Inhester, B., Axford, W. I. & Wilhelm, K. Bi-directional plasma jets produced by magnetic reconnection on the Sun. Nature 386, 811–813 (1997).
Cirtain, J. W. et al. Evidence for Alfvén waves in solar X-ray jets. Science 318, 1580–1582 (2007).
Shibata, K. et al. Chromospheric anemone jets as evidence of ubiquitous reconnection. Science 318, 1591–1594 (2007).
Yates, M. A., van Hulsteyn, D. B., Rutkowski, H., Kyrala, G. & Brackbill, J. U. Experimental evidence for self-generated magnetic fields and remote energy deposition in laser-irradiated targets. Phys. Rev. Lett. 49, 1702–1704 (1982).
Li, C. K. et al. Observation of megagauss-field topology changes due to magnetic reconnection in laser-produced plasmas. Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 055001 (2007).
Bray, R. J., Cram, L. E., Durrant, C. & Loughhead, R. E. Plasma Loops in the Solar Corona (Cambridge Univ. Press, 1991).
Lin, J. et al. Features and properties of coronal mass ejection/flare current sheets. Astrophys. J. 658, L123–L126 (2007).
Ren, Y., Yamada, M., Ji, H., Gerhardt, S. & Kulsrud, R. Identification of the electron-diffusion region during magnetic reconnection in a laboratory plasma. Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 085003 (2008).
Wang, X., Bhattacharjee, A. & Ma, Z. W. Scaling of collisionless forced reconnection. Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 265003 (2001).
Acknowledgements
We would like to acknowledge the Shenguang II staff for operating the laser facility, CAEP staff for providing some diagnostics and target fabrication. We also thank J. Lin, Y. Zhang, and J. Wang from NAOC for valuable discussions. This work was supported by the National Basic Research Program of China (973 Program) (Grant Nos. 2007CB815100, 2009GB105004, and 2006CB806300), and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 10821061, 10925421, 10734130, 40731056, 40974104, and 10975012).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
J.Y.Z. proposed the experiment. Q.D. and Y.L. were in charge of the experiment campaign. The experimental data were measured and analyzed by J.Y.Z., Q.D., S.W., X.L., L.Z., L.A. and Y.L. The theoretical analysis was carried out by X.W., J.W., J.Y.Z., C.X. and F.W. X.H. was involved the early part of the discussion. J.Q.Z., Y.G. and their colleagues are responsible for running the laser facility and target area. J.Y.Z., Y.L. and X.W. contributed to writing of the manuscript. J.Z. and G.Z. are the proposers and principal investigators of the laboratory astrophysics project.
Corresponding authors
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Zhong, J., Li, Y., Wang, X. et al. Modelling loop-top X-ray source and reconnection outflows in solar flares with intense lasers. Nature Phys 6, 984–987 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1038/nphys1790
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nphys1790
This article is cited by
-
Turbulent magnetic reconnection generated by intense lasers
Nature Physics (2023)
-
Electron scale magnetic reconnections in laser produced plasmas
Reviews of Modern Plasma Physics (2023)
-
Non-thermal electron acceleration from magnetically driven reconnection in a laboratory plasma
Nature Physics (2023)
-
Direct observations of pure electron outflow in magnetic reconnection
Scientific Reports (2022)
-
Laboratory observation of plasmoid-dominated magnetic reconnection in hybrid collisional-collisionless regime
Communications Physics (2022)