News home
 Archive
Specials
Opinion
Features
News blog
Events blog
Nature Journal
 
specials

OSCARS 2006

While Hollywood celebrates the best in movie making from 2005, Nature news has decided to delve into the world of science and cinema. Find out about this year's technical awards, read our reviews of some films, and join the discussion about what movies people ought to be making.

NEWS
DISCUSS
REVIEWS
ARCHIVE

NEWS
Movie technologies get red-carpet treatment
Stunt crash pads and high-tech cameras steal the show.
3 March 2006
Grizzlies, dodos and Gore put science on film
Ex-vice-president taps into trend towards movies with a message.
22 February 2006
DISCUSS
It oughta be a film
Tell us which science stories make you want to see the movie.
3 March 2006
REVIEWS

Nature's staff take a quick look at the science (and the fiction) behind some of the films we saw in 2005.

The Constant Gardener

Grizzly Man

The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy

The Island

King Kong

 

Proof

Wallace & Gromit

War of the Worlds

What the Bleep Do We Know!?

 
The Island

Plot summary: A company that offers 'emergency spare parts' for the rich and famous has a dirty secret: the clones they grow for these parts are sentient adults, despite a corporate claim to the contrary. When the clones win tickets to what they think is a paradise 'island', they are actually being sent for slaughter. But as the clones develop they become smart enough to work out their fate, and to fight it.

Science review: For those who are frightened or confused: when people talk about 'cloning' in order to help save lives and cure disease, they are NOT talking about making a living, breathing, grown-up twin of the patient. Therapeutic cloning involves making the tiny beginnings of an embryo that is genetically matched to a patient, and extracting stem cells from it (see 'Stem cells in focus'). Some therapeutic-cloning researchers have fought to have their work referred to as 'somatic cell nuclear transfer', in part to help clear up this misconception, but it hasn't really stuck - at least not in the press. There are of course still ethical issues, but not the same ones as in this film.

As for whether or not it's even possible to clone a person, researchers have cloned a sheep, a cat and a dog, to name a few, and, possibly, human embryos. This latter feat, claims for which have been made by only a handful of scientists, has so far proven very hard to do, and even harder to confirm.

Award: Scariest representation of cloning.

Image: © 2005 Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc.

Back to Reviews
ARCHIVE

Science in culture: A bigger picture of apes

Blog: Flock of Dodos

Evolution debates hit the big screen

Book review: The Science of the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy

Science in the movies: Hollywood or bust

Science at the movies: The fabulous fish guy

muse@nature.com: Monster or machine?

Disaster movie makes waves

Disaster movie highlights transatlantic divide

Film review: The Day After Tomorrow

Real experiment stars in Hulk movie

Superheroes make physics fun

ADVERTISEMENT
 
Nature Publishing Group, publisher of Nature, and other science journals and reference works © 2006 Nature Publishing Group | Privacy policy