Abstract
Purpose To analyze the visual acuity (VA) of patients with and without vitreous loss, while concurrently analyzing the effects of the pre-existing pathologies of glaucoma and diabetes on VA.
Methods A retrospective study on 1013 cataract extractions from 1995 to 1999 was performed. Patients included in this study had intraocular lens implantation during phacoemulsification surgery, no intraoperative complications besides vitreous loss, had no other prior ophthalmic condition other than glaucoma or diabetes, and had a postoperative follow-up interval between one and 4 months. When indicated, vitrectomy was performed concurrently with phacoemulsification following vitreous loss. Patients diagnosed with both glaucoma and diabetes were excluded. The identified subjects were then placed into six groups: (1) patients with uncomplicated surgery; (2) patients with surgery complicated by vitreous loss; (3) glaucoma patients with uncomplicated surgery; (4) glaucoma patients with surgery complicated by vitreous loss; (5) diabetic patients with uncomplicated surgery; and (6) diabetic patients with surgery complicated by vitreous loss. A two-tailed, heteroscedastic t-test and power calculation were performed on the preoperative and postoperative visual acuities of the groups.
Results There were statistically significant differences (P < 0.05) in the postoperative VA between patients with and without vitreous loss at the time of surgery. Patients with the pre-surgical conditions of diabetes or glaucoma did not display a statistically significant difference in postoperative VA when compared to controls. However, the pre-surgical condition of glaucoma displayed a trend, which showed it may contribute to a poorer postoperative VA (P = 0.072, power = 0.430).
Conclusions Vitreous loss is a risk factor for a decreased postoperative VA. Also while the pre-surgical condition of glaucoma may play a role in decreasing postoperative VA, diabetes does not.
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
Vitreous loss is the most prevalent complication of cataract surgery. The occurrence of vitreous loss is associated with an increased frequency of retinal detachment, cystoid macular edema, corneal decompensation, and pseudophakic glaucoma, among other complications.1,2,3,4,5 However, previous studies show conflicting results concerning the effect of vitreous loss on visual acuity (VA). Claoue and Steele showed a significant difference in VA between vitreous loss and non-vitreous loss patients during cataract surgery while Nishi and Bowbrow did not.5,6,7
There is little recent literature discussing the effect of specific preoperative diseases on VA during cataract surgery. Although studies have shown pre-existing eye disease contributes to a poorer postoperative VA, no study to date has focused specifically on the influence of pre-existing glaucoma or diabetes on postoperative VA.8 For example, it is known that cases of cataract and glaucoma are surgically difficult to manage because patients often have small pupils and uncontrolled intraocular pressures.1,2,9,10,11 Also, diabetic eyes often resist dilatation of the pupil. Because cases with these pre-existing pathologies frequently are surgically more cumbersome, the frequency of complications such as vitreous loss may increase. It is thus vital to understand whether vitreous loss is a risk factor for decreased improvement in VA postoperatively, and if so, how prior conditions such as glaucoma and diabetes complicate the outcome of cataract surgery. The final VA could be an important factor for both the physician and patient in deciding whether this postoperative acuity is worth the risk of surgery. In this report, we conduct a retrospective analysis of cases to evaluate the VA of patients with and without vitreous loss, while concurrently analyzing the effects of the pre-existing pathologies of glaucoma and diabetes on VA.
Materials and methods
Both patients with uncomplicated cataract surgery, and those with cataract surgery complicated by vitreous loss, were identified from medical records in the Department of Ophthalmology and Visual Science at the University of Chicago. Data from 1995 through 1999 were collected on a standard form detailing preoperative and postoperative VA and intraoperative complications, among other information. All the relevant data were assimilated and abstracted onto a spreadsheet for analysis. The patients included in the study underwent cataract extraction by phacoemulsification and intraocular lens implantation. The patients did not have planned vitreous surgery, had no intraoperative complications besides vitreous loss, no secondary surgical intervention, no report of postoperative glaucoma, had no other prior ophthalmic condition other than glaucoma or diabetes, and had a postoperative follow-up interval between one and 4 months.5,12 Vitrectomy was performed concurrently with phacoemulsification, when indicated, following vitreous loss. Patients diagnosed with both glaucoma and diabetes were excluded.
We define visual acuity (VA) using the standard Snellen charts. Intraocular pressure (IOP) was measured using standard tonometry. In this study, glaucoma is defined as a combination of elevated IOP (>22 mmHg), increased cup-to-disc ratio, and glaucomatous visual field changes, necessitating treatment. Finally, we define diabetics as those patients receiving treatment for elevated blood glucose levels.
There were a total of 404 patients, placed into six groups: (1) patients with uncomplicated surgery (n = 268); (2) patients with surgery complicated by vitreous loss (n = 26); (3) glaucoma patients with uncomplicated surgery (n = 25); (4) glaucoma patients with surgery complicated by vitreous loss (n = 7); (5) diabetic patients with uncomplicated surgery (n = 67); and (6) diabetic patients with surgery complicated by vitreous loss (n = 11). A two-tailed, heteroscedastic t-test and power calculation were performed on the preoperative and postoperative visual acuities of the groups (P-values less than 0.05 were considered significant).
Results
During the study period, there were a total of 1013 cataract extractions. This study focuses on 44 cases, all of which had vitreous loss. The patient group consisted of 16 males with an average age at time of surgery of 69.8 ± 11.5 (SD) years (range 41–85 years) and of 28 females with an average age at time of surgery of 74.0 ± 14.0 (SD) years (range 40–92 years). Because diabetes and glaucoma can complicate cataract surgery, patients who had these diseases were identified. Eleven cases of diabetes and seven cases of glaucoma from the 44 cases were analyzed. The best-corrected preoperative and postoperative VA of these patient groups are summarized in Table 1 (decimal notation was used for visual acuity). A two-tailed, heteroscedastic t-test of the data comprising the averages listed in Table 1 was performed. The preoperative and postoperative P-values are reported in Tables 2 and 3, respectively.
Table 2 shows that none of the preoperative P-values were significant; hence, differences between the groups can be attributed to the significance of their postoperative values. However, the three P-values less than 0.10 indicate that patients with diabetes may have a disposition toward a poorer preoperative VA.
In comparison to non-vitreous loss cases, it was demonstrated that the complication of vitreous loss contributed to a lower postoperative VA (P = 0.014, power = 0.716). Glaucoma itself displayed a trend which showed that it may contribute to a lower postoperative VA even though this value was not statistically significant (P = 0.072, power = 0.430). More support for the previous statement was garnered by the comparison of subsets 2 and 3, which indicate that similar postoperative VA outcomes were obtained for either patients with glaucoma or patients with a vitreous loss complication (P = 0.322, power = 0.160). However, the hypothesis that both glaucoma and vitreous loss produced a combined deleterious effect on postoperative VA, was not confirmed (P = 0.358, power = 0.122 and P = 0.141, power = 0.261). Of note, although glaucoma patients may display a trend toward a lower postoperative VA, the low power values indicate that the data may have been susceptible to Type II error. Diabetic patients did not appear to have a different postoperative VA, compared to their non-diabetic counterparts (P = 0.341, power = 0.154). The disparity in postoperative VA in cases of both vitreous loss and diabetes could be solely attributed to vitreous loss (P = 0.032, power = 0.599). Interestingly, when patients with vitreous loss and diabetes were contrasted with patients with glaucoma, the postoperative VA was not significant (P = 0.086, power = 0.387). This was not surprising because although the VA was near the significance level, glaucoma itself may contribute to a lower postoperative VA. The low power values might suggest an increased probability of Type II error.
Discussion
It is known that vitreous loss increases the frequency of certain complications such as retinal detachment, cystoid macular edema, corneal decompensation, and pseudophakic glaucoma.1,2,3,4,5 However, conflicting results are observed in the literature regarding the effect of vitreous loss and postoperative VA. Some studies show no significant difference in postoperative VA for surgeries complicated with and without vitreous loss, while others show a decrease in postoperative VA.5,6,7
In this study, we observe that vitreous loss is a risk factor for decreased postoperative VA regardless of a vitrectomy. This poorer vision could be due to a complication such as cystoid macular edema occurring as a result of an ‘incomplete vitrectomy,’ a procedure characterized by the unintentional retention of vitreous due to surgical error.4,5 Also, it has been shown that excessive surgical manipulations cause more complications, which in turn can lead to a poorer visual prognosis. For example, when a vitrectomy has to be performed, the patient is immediately placed at risk for a lower postoperative VA.1,6
The pre-existing pathology of glaucoma is known to complicate cataract procedures. Reasons for the increased complication rate are uncontrolled IOP and small pupils. Previous studies described that small pupils make the procedure more challenging for the surgeon, and place tissues such as the iris at greater risk for damage.1,2,9,10,11 Although the result was not significant, the data indicate that the prior condition of glaucoma might place the patient at risk for a decreased postoperative VA. It again could be implied that because the cataract procedure for a glaucoma patient often involves more surgical manipulation, increased complications and a poorer postoperative VA are inevitable. However, glaucoma patients with a satisfactory surgery generally have lower postoperative VA than non-glaucoma patients with a similar surgery.5 This supports the notion that glaucoma may play a role in decreasing the postoperative VA of cataract patients. On the other hand, the same is not true for diabetes. Although diabetes may increase the difficulty of cataract surgery by affecting the microvasculature, no correlation is shown to exist between diabetes and a decreased postoperative VA. Despite the relationships elucidated above concerning glaucoma and diabetes and their correlation with postoperative VA, the low power values suggest an increased probability of producing a Type II error.
In order to minimize the variance between patients and increase the power of the statistical test, more patients should be analyzed and future research is indicated. However, the task of increasing the patient population is extremely challenging because the rarity of vitreous loss is compounded by the search for corresponding pathology such as glaucoma or diabetes. Other limitations of this study include its relatively short follow-up and retrospective analysis. Also, a more conclusive evaluation of factors such as glare, contrast sensitivity, and color appreciation should be analyzed. Because cataract procedures are often aimed toward improving the previous factors, patients who in this study display no improvement in VA may in fact be pleased with their overall visual outcome.13 In addition, many studies focus on the difficulty of analyzing coexistent ophthalmic conditions such as cataracts and glaucoma. Although the analysis of the individual effect of either glaucoma or cataract on the combined visual field is difficult, our measurement of VA is straightforward.9,10
This study demonstrates that vitreous loss automatically places patients at risk for a lower postoperative VA. Vitreous loss is often a complication for residents in training. While residents improved with time and experience, numerous articles detail resident vitreous loss complication rates of 5.5–20%.14,15,16 Therefore, residents should be carefully trained and should practise on eyes and simulation programs before being allowed to perform surgery. Beyond that, residents should be careful in case selections, to further minimize the risk of vitreous loss.
References
Linebarger E, Hardten D, Shah G, Lindstrom R . Phacoemulsification and modern cataract surgery. Surv Ophthalmol 1999; 44: 123–147
Nelson DB, Donnenfeld ED . Small-pupil phacoemulsification and trabeculectomy. In: Dodick JM, Donnenfeld ED (eds). Cataract Surgery Little, Brown and Company: Boston 1994 131–144
Hardten DR, Lindstrom RL . Complications of cataract surgery. In: Smolin G, Friedlaender MH (eds). Complications of Ocular Surgery Little, Brown and Company: Boston 1992 131–155
Spigelman A, Lindstrom R, Nichols B, Lindquist T . Visual results following vitreous loss and primary lens implantation. J Cataract Refract Surg 1989; 15: 201–204
Claoue C, Steele A . Visual prognosis following accidental vitreous loss during cataract surgery. Eye 1993; 7: 735–739
Bobrow J . Visual outcomes after anterior vitrectomy comparison of ECCE and phacoemulsification. Trans Am Ophthalmol Soc 1999; 97: 281–291
Nishi O . Vitreous loss in posterior chamber lens implantation. J Cataract Refract Surg 1987; 13: 424–427
Al-Khaier A, Wong D, Lois N, Cota N et al. Determinants of visual outcome after pars plana vitrectomy for posteriorly dislocated lens fragments in phacoemulsification. J Cataract Refract Surg 2001; 27: 1199–1206
Manoj B, Chako D, Khan MY . Effect of extracapsular extraction and phacoemulsification performed after trabeculectomy on intraocular pressure. J Cataract Refract Surg 2000; 26: 75–78
Kent AR . Phacoemulsification in the glaucoma patient. In: Singh K, Bautista RD (eds). Advances in Glaucoma Therapy Lippincott Williams and Wilkins: Philadelphia 1999 71–86
Editorial: Combined cataract and glaucoma surgery. Br J Ophthalmol 1986; 70: 637
Albanis C, Dwyer M, Ernest JT . Outcomes of extracapsular cataract extraction and phacoemulsification performed in a university training program. Ophthalmic Surg Lasers 1998; 29: 643–648
Raskukas P, Walker J, Wing G, Fletcher D, Elsner A . Small incision cataract surgery and placement of posterior chamber intraocular lenses in patients with diabetic retinopathy. Ophthalmic Surg Lasers 1999; 30: 6–11
Corey P, Olson R . Surgical outcomes of cataract extractions performed by residents using phacoemulsification. J Cataract Refract Surg 1998; 24: 66–72
Thomas R, Naveen S, Jacob A, Braganza A . Visual outcome and complications of residents learning phacoemulsification. Ind J Ophthalmol 1997; 45: 215–219
Snyder RW, Donnenfeld ED . Teaching phacoemulsification to residents and physicians in transition. In: Dodick JM, Donnenfeld ED (eds). Cataract Surgery Little, Brown and Company: Boston 1994 191–199
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Shah, D., Krishnan, A., Albanis, C. et al. Visual acuity outcomes following vitreous loss in glaucoma and diabetic patients. Eye 16, 271–274 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.eye.6700082
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.eye.6700082
Keywords
This article is cited by
-
Delayed vitreous prolapse after cataract surgery: clinical features and surgical outcomes
Scientific Reports (2021)