BACKGROUND: The Case Management Conference (CMC) is a multi-disciplinary meeting that is widely used to achieve consensus about treatment (including end-of-life) decisions in complex, critically ill patients. However, little is known about the attitudes of health care providers and patients toward using CMC to make end-of-life treatment decisions, and about their perceptions concerning whether the process works well.
AIMS/METHODS: We therefore surveyed 26 physicians and 163 nurses at the tertiary level NICU at Children's & Women's (C&W) Health Centre of B.C. in December 1996, for their attitudes and perceptions about the use of CMC as a decision making process for withdrawing/witholding active treatment in the NICU. As part of another study, we also surveyed parents of 26 C&W NICU patients who had CMCs held in 1997.
RESULTS: Most nurses (55%) but few physicians (12%) believed that no infant should have treatment withdrawn/witheld without a CMC (p<0.05). Nurses and physicians also differed about whether CMCs were usually held too late (84% vs 38%), and about whether decisions to withdraw/withold active treatment were generally handled in a consistent manner (12% vs 23%)(p<0.05). Only 17% of physicians and 17% of nurses believed that parents should be present at a CMC, compared to 38% of parents. While 36% of parents did not think that parents have the right to withold active treatment if the infant has a high risk of severe handicap, only 4% of health care providers agreed with this.
CONCLUSIONS: Nurses, physicians and parents differ in attitudes and perceptions about the use of CMC as a decision making process for withdrawing/witholding active treatment in the NICU. These differences have important implications for end-of-life treatment decision making and demonstrate a need for review and improvement of the CMC as a process for this purpose.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
(Spon by: Judith Hall) (funded in part by MRC, BCWH Foundation, and BCRICWH)
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Regan, S., Corcoran, J., Sale, J. et al. Evaluation of Case Management Conference as a Decision Making Process for Withdrawing or Witholding Active Treatment in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit(NICU) 165. Pediatr Res 43 (Suppl 4), 31 (1998). https://doi.org/10.1203/00006450-199804001-00186
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1203/00006450-199804001-00186