Latest Reply:
There is some evidence that suggests that there is a certain component of intelligence, measured by "IQ" scores, that is genetic. Depending on what you read, the results might seem confusing. But, many reports suggest that there is at least some genetic component to IQ but the heritability of this trait is not as clear as for some other polygenic traits, like height. Most of the studies examining the genetic vs. environmental component of cognition are done by comparing the IQs of monozygotic (identical) twins raised together (considered same environment) or raised apart and dizygotic (fraternal) twins raised together or apart. One complication of some of this data is the fact that much of it comes from scientists comparing many DISTINCT studies in a single comparison. This means that while a scientist reports looking at hundreds of twin comparisons, these may come from multiple different published reports. While there are statistical methods that enable scientists to perform this type of analysis, there are always problems in comparing different studies performed by different investigators under different conditions. It seems clear from all these studies that IQ is incredibly complex. It is a continuous trait, like height, where there are MANY different normal phenotypes. You wouldn't expect everyone to have the same height, right? Remember also that IQ is just one measure of intelligence. Nevertheless, it is still a widely accepted measure. We still do not have techniques that allow us to both identify the many genes that contribute to polygenic, continuous traits and how those genes/alleles interact with the environment. Recent studies have even examined the potential contribution of "maternal effect" on IQ, that is the environment of the womb during gestation. This study (see link below) suggests that the maternal affect may indeed play a very significant role in determination of IQ. It is easy to imagine that if a trait as "simple" as human height (which does clearly exhibit high heritability) is estimated to be controlled by dozen(s) of genes, that something as complex as human intelligence might be controlled by even more. This could then be complicated by maternal environment, age, nutrition, home environment, etc. and it becomes an immense problem to tease out the individual components. As genome-wide association studies become more powerful and more rigorous, digging into complex traits will likely become a more tractable issue. Two articles might help provide some perspective on your question: http://www.nature.com/scitable/content/The-heritability-of-IQ-26372 http://www.nature.com/scitable/topicpage/Heritability-of-Human-Intelligence-IQ-and-Eugenics-796 For a good review on heritability of height, see Weedon and Frayling, 2008 (Trends in Genetics Volume 24, Issue 12, December 2008, Pages 595-603 )
Reply From:
Kenna Shaw
Jan 26, 2009 11:54AM