Focus
The Origin of the Moon
- Focus
- December 2013 Volume 6 No 12 pp891-986
Credit: Image credited to Julien Salmon and Robin Canup/Southwest Research Institute
Recent research has highlighted problems with our present explanation for how the Moon formed in the giant impact of a large solar system body with the early Earth. In September 2013, London saw the latest in a series of landmark meetings debating theories of the Moon's origin, following others in 1984 (Kona, Hawaii) and 1998 (Monterey, California). These issues are now explored in a Nature Commentary, Nature News & Views forum and Nature Geoscience News & Views article. We also present a selection of recent Nature and Nature Geoscience content related to the age, composition and origin of the Moon.
Commentary
Nature: Planetary science: Lunar conspiracies
Robin Canup
doi:10.1038/504027a
Full text - Information storage | PDF (1,040 KB) - Information storage
News and Views
Nature: Planetary science: Shadows cast on Moon's origin
Tim Elliott & Sarah T. Stewart
doi:10.1038/504090a
Full text - Information storage | PDF (397 KB) - Information storage
Nature Geoscience: Planetary Science: Occam's origin of the Moon - pp996-998
Linda T. Elkins-Tanton
doi:10.1038/ngeo2026
Following almost three decades of some certainty over how the Moon was formed, new geochemical measurements have thrown the planetary science community back into doubt. We are either modelling the wrong process, or modelling the process wrong.
Full text - Information storage | PDF (174 KB) - Information storage
Nature Geoscience: Planetary science: Traces of ancient lunar water
Erik H. Hauri
doi:10.1038/ngeo1752
The presence of water in lunar volcanic rocks has been attributed to delivery after the Moon formed. Water detected in rocks from the ancient lunar highlands suggests that the Moon already contained water early in its history, and poses more challenges for the giant impact theory of Moon formation.
Full text - Information storage | PDF (250 KB) - Information storage
Nature: Planetary science: Galvanized lunacy
Tim Elliott
doi:10.1038/490346a
The finding that magmatic material from the Moon is more enriched in the heavy isotopes of zinc than its terrestrial and Martian analogues prompts fresh thinking about the origin of our natural satellite.
Full text - Information storage | PDF (1,154 KB) - Information storage
Nature Geoscience: Moon formation: Earth's titanium twin
Matthias M. M. Meier
doi:10.1038/ngeo1434
A giant impact on the young proto-Earth is thought to explain the formation of the Moon. High-precision analysis of titanium isotopes in lunar rocks suggests that the Moon and Earth's mantle are more similar than existing models permit.
Full text - Information storage | PDF (433 KB) - Information storage
Nature: Planetary science: Ancient lunar dynamo
Dominique Jault
doi:10.1038/479183a
The differential rotation between the Moon's core and mantle may have powered the ancient lunar dynamo, either continuously over several hundred million years or intermittently after large impacts.
Full text - Information storage | PDF (510 KB) - Information storage
Nature: Planetary science: Making mountains out of a moon
Maria T. Zuber
doi:10.1038/476036a
The Moon's cratered surface preserves the record of impacts that occurred during the late stages of its accretion. New simulations show that a collision with a companion moon may have formed the lunar farside highlands.
Full text - Information storage | PDF (1,042 KB) - Information storage
Nature: Planetary science: The early Moon was rich in water
Marc Chaussidon
doi:10.1038/454170a
Analyses of lunar volcanic glasses show that they are rich in volatile elements and water. If parts of the lunar mantle contain as much water as Earth's, does this imply that the water has a common origin?
Full text - Information storage | PDF (1,125 KB) - Information storage
Nature: Planetary science: A younger Moon
Alan Brandon
doi:10.1038/4501169a
The most recent study of lunar rocks indicates that the Moon formed later than previously thought — a conclusion that requires our view of the early history of the inner Solar System to be revised.
Full text - Information storage | PDF (197 KB) - Information storage
Letters
Nature Geoscience: Water in lunar anorthosites and evidence for a wet early Moon
Hejiu Hui, Anne H. Peslier, Youxue Zhang & Clive R. Neal
doi:10.1038/ngeo1735
Water has been detected on the lunar surface and attributed to delivery by impacts and the solar wind to a dry early Moon. Spectroscopic detections of water in lunar anorthosites from the Apollo collection suggest that a significant amount of water is indigenous to the Moon.
First paragraph - Information storage | Full text - Information storage | PDF (376 KB) - Information storage
Nature: Zinc isotopic evidence for the origin of the Moon
Randal C. Paniello, James M. D. Day & Frédéric Moynier
doi:10.1038/nature11507
Lunar magmatic rocks are shown to be enriched in the heavy isotopes of zinc and to have lower zinc concentrations than terrestrial or Martian igneous rocks; these variations represent the large-scale evaporation of zinc, most probably in the aftermath of the Moon-forming giant impact event.
First paragraph - Information storage | Full text - Information storage | PDF (518 KB) - Information storage
Nature Geoscience: The proto-Earth as a significant source of lunar material
Junjun Zhang, Nicolas Dauphas, Andrew M. Davis, Ingo Leya & Alexei Fedkin
doi:10.1038/ngeo1429
Geochemical evidence continues to challenge giant impact models, which predict that the Moon formed from both proto-Earth and impactor material. Analyses of lunar samples reveal isotopic homogeneity in titanium, a highly refractory element, suggesting lunar material was derived predominantly from the mantle of the proto-Earth.
First paragraph - Information storage | Full text - Information storage | PDF (291 KB) - Information storage
Nature: An impact-driven dynamo for the early Moon
M. Le Bars, M. A. Wieczorek, Ö. Karatekin, D. Cébron & M. Laneuville
doi:10.1038/nature10565
First paragraph - Information storage | Full text - Information storage | PDF (701 KB) - Information storage
Nature: A long-lived lunar dynamo driven by continuous mechanical stirring
C. A. Dwyer, D. J. Stevenson & F. Nimmo
doi:10.1038/nature10564
First paragraph - Information storage | Full text - Information storage | PDF (234 KB) - Information storage
Nature: Chronological evidence that the Moon is either young or did not have a global magma ocean
Lars E. Borg, James N. Connelly, Maud Boyet & Richard W. Carlson
doi:10.1038/nature10328
First paragraph - Information storage | Full text - Information storage | PDF (201 KB) - Information storage
Nature: Forming the lunar farside highlands by accretion of a companion moon
M. Jutzi & E. Asphaug
doi:10.1038/nature10289
First paragraph - Information storage | Full text - Information storage | PDF (1,526 KB) - Information storage
Nature: Lunar apatite with terrestrial volatile abundances
Jeremy W. Boyce, Yang Liu, George R. Rossman, Yunbin Guan, John M. Eiler, Edward M. Stolper & Lawrence A. Taylor
doi:10.1038/nature09274
These authors report the concentrations of hydrogen, chlorine and sulphur in the mineral apatite from a lunar basalt, and show that the concentrations are indistinguishable from apatites in common terrestrial igneous rocks. They conclude that both metamorphic and igneous models of apatite formation suggest a volatile inventory for at least some lunar materials that is similar to comparable materials within the Earth.
First paragraph - Information storage | Full text - Information storage | PDF (387 KB) - Information storage
Nature: The global distribution of pure anorthosite on the Moon
Makiko Ohtake et al.
doi:10.1038/nature08317
It has long been thought that the lunar highland crust was formed by the crystallization and floatation of plagioclase from a global magma ocean, but the exact mechanism by which such a crust formed remains debated. Data from the Japanese SELENE spacecraft are now used to produce a clear and high spatial resolution view of the composition of the lunar crust. The existence of widely distributed crustal rocks with compositions approaching 100 per cent (by volume) plagioclase is revealed.
First paragraph - Information storage | Full text - Information storage | PDF (1,050 KB) - Information storage
Nature Geoscience: Timing of crystallization of the lunar magma ocean constrained by the oldest zircon
A. Nemchin, N. Timms1, R. Pidgeon, T. Geisler, S. Reddy & C. Meyer
doi:10.1038/ngeo417
It has long been thought that the lunar highland crust was formed by the crystallization and floatation of plagioclase from a global magma ocean, but the exact mechanism by which such a crust formed remains debated. Data from the Japanese SELENE spacecraft are now used to produce a clear and high spatial resolution view of the composition of the lunar crust. The existence of widely distributed crustal rocks with compositions approaching 100 per cent (by volume) plagioclase is revealed.
First paragraph - Information storage | Full text - Information storage | PDF (3,769 KB) - Information storage
Nature: Volatile content of lunar volcanic glasses and the presence of water in the Moon's interior
Alberto E. Saal, Erik H. Hauri, Mauro L. Cascio, James A. Van Orman, Malcolm C. Rutherford & Reid F. Cooper
doi:10.1038/nature07047
First paragraph - Information storage | Full text - Information storage | PDF (274 KB) - Information storage
Nature: Super-chondritic Sm/Nd ratios in Mars, the Earth and the Moon
Guillaume Caro, Bernard Bourdon, Alex N. Halliday & Ghylaine Quitté
doi:10.1038/nature06760
First paragraph - Information storage | Full text - Information storage | PDF (203 KB) - Information storage
Nature: Late formation and prolonged differentiation of the Moon inferred from W isotopes in lunar metals
M. Touboul, T. Kleine, B. Bourdon, H. Palme & R. Wieler
doi:10.1038/nature06760
First paragraph - Information storage | Full text - Information storage | PDF (231 KB) - Information storage
News
Nature: Common source for Earth and Moon water
Ron Cowen
doi:10.1038/nature.2013.12963
Chemical fingerprints of lunar rocks suggest both bodies already had their water at birth.
Nature: Moon rocks offer new view of lunar dynamo
Alexandra Witze
doi:10.1038/nature.2013.12929
Process that generated magnetism lasted 160 million years longer than previously thought.
Nature: Moon-forming impact theory rescued
Ron Cowen
doi:10.1038/nature.2012.11610
Fast-spinning proto-Earth allows chemical mixing.
Nature: Question over theory of lunar formation
Ron Cowen
doi:10.1038/nature.2012.10300
Titanium signature poses puzzle for popular theory of Moon's origin.