Multi-drug resistant Mycobacterium abscessus complex (MABSC) is a form of Nontuberculous mycobacteria (NTM) of special, international concern in Cystic Fibrosis (CF). We hypothesised that gastric juice and percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy (PEG) feeding devices might yield MABSC isolates. Gastric juice and sputa from sixteen adult PEG fed CF patients and five replaced PEG tubes were studied. Bacterial and fungal isolates were cultured. Mycobacterium were identified by rpoB, sodA and hsp65 gene sequencing and strain typed using variable number tandem repeat. Bacteria and/or fungi grew from all gastric juice, sputa and PEG samples. MABSC were detected in 7 patients. Five had MABSC in their sputum. Two had an identical MABSC strain in their sputum and gastric juice and one had the same strain isolated from their PEG tube and sputum. Two patients who were sputum sample negative had MABSC isolated in their gastric juice or PEG tube. MABSC were therefore identified for the first time from a gastric sample in a minority of patients. We conclude that gastric juice and PEG-tubes may be a potential source of MABSC isolates in CF patients, and these findings warrant further study.
Non tuberculous mycobacteria (NTM) are important human pathogens responsible for a wide spectrum of soft tissue infections, which are recognised to cause disseminated infection in immunocompromised patients. The incidence and prevalence of pulmonary NTM infection is increasing worldwide, contributing to concerns that NTM infection may become a serious health challenge1.
NTM infection is of special, international concern in people with CF and represents a significant emerging threat in patients with CF. Estimates of the prevalence of NTM in the CF population range from 1.3% to 32.7% depending on the geographical region and patient population2. To date, the largest CF studies report rates of NTM-positive respiratory cultures between 6.6% and 13.7%2.
Of the rapidly growing NTM species, the multidrug resistant Mycobacterium abscessus complex (MABSC) has emerged as a major respiratory pathogen particularly in individuals with CF, that is associated with an accelerated decline in lung function3. MABSC can also prevent safe lung transplantation, which is one of the few therapeutic approaches available in end stage lung disease. It is for this reason that many transplant centres consider active MABSC pulmonary disease to be a relative contraindication to lung transplant listing4. Treatment of MABSC is challenging, requiring extended therapy with combinations of multiple antibiotics required that may be associated with adverse effects and is not always successful clinically5.
MABSC can be divided into three subspecies (subsp): Mycobacterium abscessus subsp abscessus, M abscessus subsp massiliense, and M abscessus subsp bolletii6. A recent publication demonstrated a potential high rate of transmission of MABSC between CF patients despite stringent segregation7. It was postulated that transmission could occur indirectly, through fomite contamination or through aerosol generated during physiotherapy and spirometry testing8. The study also demonstrated that inferred transmission might occur from patients with persistent smear negative, culture positive sputa. This suggested that only a low level of inoculum might be needed for infection, contributing to debate regarding the need for rigorous preventative measures8.
We have recently described findings of a gastric juice reservoir of organisms relevant to CF lung pathophysiology in patients fed by percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy (PEG) tubes, which also confirmed a widespread presence of extra oesophageal reflux (EOR) symptoms and potential for micro-aspiration in patients with CF9,10.
This is consistent with the established diagnostic role for gastric aspirate culture in pulmonary tuberculosis11,12 and the finding that repeated gastric lavage has better sensitivity for microbiological diagnosis of childhood pulmonary tuberculosis compared with bronchoalveolar lavage11,13. The potential gastric juice culture of MABSC in people with CF has not been established to our knowledge however.
We hypothesised that gastric juice and PEG tubes from people with CF might yield NTM isolates, and in particularly MABSC. The aim of this cross-sectional study was therefore to provide a description of the NTM isolates of sputum, gastric juice and PEG tubes from adult CF patients.
Research Approval was obtained from Newcastle and North Tyneside Research Ethics Committee to perform research on samples collected as part of the Hepatopancreatobiliary groups biobank based in Newcastle University. All study participants provided written informed consent prior to initiation of the study. All methods were carried out in accordance with relevant guidelines and regulations.
Patients and sample
CF patients receiving PEG feeding represented an important opportunity to directly sample gastric juice, with less potential for contamination with oropharnygeal commensals. From the 270 CF patients attending the regional CF Centre, a potential 16 PEG-tube fed patients were available for study (Table 1).
Following overnight fasting gastric juice and sputum samples from those PEG-tube fed CF patients (CF 1–16). PEG tubes which became available due to renewal or removal as part of routine PEG management were collected form 5 patients (CF 4–6 and CF 14–15). All the potentially available patients with PEG tubes in the region were therefore included in this study. No PEG fed CF patients were excluded or positively selected for in the study.
Symptoms of extraoesophageal reflux
Patients with CF had symptoms of extraoesophageal reflux (EOR) assessed using the Reflux Symptoms Index (RSI) score; with a score of less than 13 classed as not EOR symptomatic14. The reflux symptom index is a patient reported outcome measure designed to assess laryngeal symptoms secondary to reflux, including cough.
Gastric juice pH was measured using pH strips and sputum samples were homogenised with equal amounts of Dithiothreitol for 1 to 3 minutes. The inner and outer part of the PEG tube were divided into small pieces and vigorously washed with 3 ml saline, yielding a PEG conditioned saline (PEG-s).
Microbiological culture conditions
Gastric juice, sputum samples and PEG-s underwent microbiological culture performed in accordance with national accredited methods. 10 μl of homogenised sputum, gastric juice and PEG-conditioned saline were plated for bacterial and fungal cultures. The following media were used: Columbia blood agar supplemented with 5% horse blood, chocolate agar supplemented with 70 mg/L bacitracin, Burkholderia selective agar (for CF sputa and gastric juice, CEP bioMérieux UK), cysteine lactose electrolyte deficient agar (CLED) and fastidious anaerobic agar (FAA). Plates were incubated according to a standard protocol, CEP cultures were incubated for 10 days at 30 °C for isolation of Burkholderia cepacia complex and rapidly growing mycobacterium.
Plates were examined daily for evidence of microbial growth and assessment of the number of distinct colonial variants was recorded. All morphological variants were sub-cultured and used for identification and stored at −20 °C in 10% glycerol skimmed milk. Isolates were identified by matrix assisted laser desorption ionisation time-of-flight (MALDI-TOF) mass spectrometry (Bruker Daltonics, UK) and where necessary, appropriate API kits (bioMérieux, UK)15. Mycobacterium was identified by rpoB, sodA and hsp65 gene sequencing and strain typed using variable number tandem repeat (VNTR), Colindale, UK7.
Univariate analysis was used to compare differences in demographic and clinical variables between CF patients with and without MABSC isolates. Comparisons were unpaired, and all tests of significance were two-tailed.
All data analyses were performed using SPSS for Windows, version 22; p-values < 0.05 were considered to be statistically significant.
This patient cohort had moderate to severe CF lung disease, which was in keeping with this PEG fed population (median FEV1, 1.6 L (37% predicted) range 0.5–2.7 L (17–88%), along with as is the norm in patients with CF, long term antibiotic exposure and use of acid suppression medication (Table 1).
Sputa and gastric juice microbiological results
Of the 16 patients investigated, the most frequent microorganisms detected were Streptococcus spp, MABSC, P. aeruginosa and Candida spp in both sputum and gastric juice samples. The exceptions were Aspergillus and Rothia spp which were more common in sputum samples while lactobacillus spp was more common in gastric juice samples (See e-Tables 1 and 2 in the online data supplement for CF gastric juice and CF sputum samples culture results). The most frequently isolated bacterial taxa from the gastric juices were Lactobacillus (6/16), P. aeruginosa (4/16), Streptococcus spp (3/16), and MABSC (3/16). Candida species were isolated from 14 gastric juice samples (Fig. 1).
Identification of the bacteria isolated from 16 sputum samples revealed 13 different bacterial genera with Streptococcus spp (13/16), P. aeruginosa (7/16), MABSC (4/15), Achromobacter spp (3/16) and Rothia (11/16) the most frequently isolated from sputum samples. Candida species only were isolated in 4 sputum samples (Fig. 2).
Microbiological findings in PEG tube conditioned saline (PEG-s)
PEG tubes were removed from 5 patients (CF4-6 and CF-14-15) as part of their routine management, not due to clinical suspicion regarding potential microbiological infection. Bacterial and fungal species were isolated from all PEG tubes. The bacterial species isolated included MABSC, P. aeruginosa, lactobacillus, Enterococcus and Staphylococcus sp, isolated in 2 patients. Candida species were isolated in 4 patients (Fig. 3).
MABSC culture results
MABSC were detected in 7 out of 16 CF patient (43%), 5 patients had MABSC in their sputum, 3 patient with Mycobacterium massiliense (CF-3, CF-9, CF-13) and 2 with Mycobacterium abscessus sub sp abscessus (CF-6 and CF-4). Among the 5 patients with sputum isolates, 2 had the identical strain of MABSC confirmed by VNTR in their gastric juice (M. massiliense in CF-3 and CF-13) and one patient had the same strain isolated from their PEG tube (M. abscessus sub sp abscessus (CF-4).
2 patients who were sputum sample negative for MABSC (CF-1 and CF-14) had either M. massiliense in their gastric juice (CF-1) or M. abscessus sub sp abscessus and M. bolletii isolated from their PEG tube (CF-14). MABSC were therefore isolated for the first time from a non-respiratory lung, gastric site, in these patients (Table 2).
Longitudinal sputum MABSC culture results in CF patients where MABSC was first isolated from a non-respiratory, gastric site
MABSC was first isolated from a non-respiratory, gastric site in CF patients 1 and 14. Negative sputum samples were obtained through the clinical surveillance samples obtained at clinic visits prior to isolation of NTM from the gastric compartment.
CF 1. M. massiliense was isolated from gastric juice on 23-1-15. Eighteen sputum samples, over 20 months, were examined for NTM prior to this (dates: 22-5-13 to 23-1-15). Following the positive gastric sample, ten sputa were negative for NTM after this (23-1-15 to 2-3-16). A transient isolation of sputum M. abscessus subspecies abscessus occurred on 2-3-16. Seven subsequent sputa were negative for NTM (21-3-16 to 2-12-16).
CF 14. The positive gastric sample (percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy tube) was identified on 15-7-14, with isolates of M. abscessus subspecies abscessus sequence type 26 and M. bolletti. Prior to this five lung samples were examined for NTM (9-8-13 to 26-6-14; two sputa and three cough swabs). Seventeen subsequent sputum samples were examined and were negative for NTM (dates 13-8-14 to 22-10-16).
The longitudinal culture data were therefore consistent with the possibility that a gastric sample can represent the first isolation of NTM in people with CF independent of sputum samples.
Symptoms of extraoesophageal reflux in CF patients
Symptom scores for extraoesophageal reflux were available in 14 of the 16 patients with CF (Table 1). 13 patients were EOR symptomatic, despite the use of PPI or Ranitidine, with an RSI score >12; median RSI score 17 (range 13–36). One patient was EOR non symptomatic with RSI score 8.
RSI scores for patients positive for MABSC were higher (median 22, range 17–36) compared to patient who were negative for MABSC (median 15, range 8–20), but this was not statistically significant (p = 0.22). The cough domain score of the RSI questionnaire in MABSC positive patients ranged from 2–5, with 5 the highest score possible.
For the first time to our knowledge, we have shown that MABSC can be isolated from the gastric juice and PEG tubes of patients with CF in addition to sputum. Previous reports where gastric juice has been shown to be an advantageous sample for diagnosing Mycobacterium tuberculosis add plausibility to this main finding11,12. We also found that isolates were obtained from a gastric source with MABSC negative sputa. MABSC were therefore identified for the first time from a gastric sample in these patients, despite rigorous and extended previous sputum based surveillance in a tertiary laboratory, with a specialised interest in MABSC culture methodology16.
Over the last 2 decades, with the increasing survival of patients with CF, a number of pathogens including MABSC have become of emergent, international importance. Outbreaks of MABSC in non-CF patients have also been reported and, for example, soft tissue, bone and line infections have occurred following the use of contaminated surgical equipment17.
To our knowledge there is no directly proven animal-to-human or human-to-human transmission of MABSC. Cross-infection between patients with CF has been suggested however, through elegant, indirect studies combining whole genome sequencing and detailed epidemiology8. Recently, Ricketts et al.18, provided, a case description of suspected human-to-human transmission of M. kansasii, involving genetically identical organisms isolated from a husband and wife living in East London. NTM outbreaks have been described following the use of disinfected surgical equipment in patients, with the presumption that this might be due to inadequate cleaning, or be derived from the water supply used to perform the disinfection. The exact source of such MABSC outbreaks has not been precisely identified however19.
A breach of “barrier defence” protection against microorganisms is a described risk factor for M. tuberculosis (TB)20. The stomach is not considered a primary site of infection in these patients, but illustrates this potential niche for mycobacterium and gastric juice can be used for the detection of pulmonary tuberculosis diagnosis in children13. No data are available regarding the potential to culture MABSC from gastrostomy to our knowledge however. We have recently shown that gastric juice is an under recognised reservoir of microorganisms relevant to people with CF9. Our previous paper investigated the aerodigestive microbiome in people with CF using Next Generation Sequencing but did not study NTM. Our present paper is independent of the first study, using different samples involving the specialised methodology necessary for NTM studies. In this study we investigated the presence of MABSC isolated from sputum, gastric juice and PEG tubes in our regional CF clinic PEG fed patients. The prevalence of MABSC in our combined samples from our PEG fed cohort was 43%; a high rate compared to our latest regional institution study of non-PEG-fed CF patients (16%)16, and another recent study (12%)21. This may be related to the severity of disease in our PEG-fed patients, however it may also be possible that the presence of a PEG may be associated with MABSC isolation in people with CF.
Our data indicated that MABSC was present in the gastric compartment and was cultured from both gastric juice and PEG tubes. These PEG tubes were removed from patients as part of their routine management and not because of any clinical suspicion of infection. Our findings are in keeping with the known resistance of MABSC organisms to divergent environments including high temperature and low pH22.
We are unaware of substantive previous data regarding MABSC culture in non-CF gastric juice. However, we have previously studied the microbiology of 14 gastric juice samples sampled at diagnostic gastroscopy of patients without known lung disease. Our experience showed that In 6 patients whose gastric juice had a pH of 4 or less, bacteria were not cultured. The remaining 8 patients, whose gastric pH was 5 to 8, all had cultures that grew a range of bacteria. These isolates did not include any MABSC or other mycobacteria however23,24. Our previous preliminary data may therefore suggest some specificity to our finding of MABSC in gastric juice in our PEG fed CF patient group and we conclude that this requires further study. Such studies could explore a novel possibility; that the stomach constitutes a potential reservoir and niche of viable MABSC in PEG fed people with CF. We speculate that this may have a role in failure of eradication treatment in some patients.
Our present study showed an association between MABSC colonisation of gastric juice and sputum in some of our CF patients. Two patients had MABSC in their gastric juice and sputum samples and where MABSC was found concordantly in CF gastric juice and sputum, we demonstrated genetically identical strains by molecular techniques.
Transfer of organisms including MABSC may be possible from lung to stomach through the widely recognised mechanism of cough and swallowing of expectorate. The finding of identical strains of P. aeruginosa cultured from the gastric juices and sputa further support the idea that sputum is being swallowed into the stomach. We also found that in a minority of the patients MABSC were isolated from the PEG and gastric juice of patients with MABSC negative sputa. A gastric sample therefore represented the first time that MABSC had been isolated in two patients from our series. These individuals also had negative sputum samples according to the routine clinical microbiology approaches in our centre in the year prior to the GI isolates. Our study cannot indicate that the stomach may be a primary site of infection with MABSC rather than just reflecting swallowing of infected sputum, but this could be a useful area of future research. We have also found that gastric juice and PEG tubes can be culture positive for P. aeruginosa, with no P. aeruginosa present in the earlier sputum samples. Future studies could therefore test the hypothesis that clinically relevant bacteria including MABSC survive in the gastric compartment independent from respiratory sources, which may have translational importance for the management of people with CF and approaches to attempted eradication of micro-organisms.
An association between NTM lung disease and gastroesophageal disorders has been suggested in previous reports including disease related to M abscessus25 and reflux and aspiration events have been widely documented in CF patients26. Our present study showed a high level of symptoms associated with reflux leaving the oesophagus in our patient cohort, including cough. The validated RSI questionnaire instrument used in this study consists of a series of 9 questions to evaluate extra-oesophageal reflux. All the patients in our cohort colonised with MABSC in their gastric compartment had a high RSI domain score for cough. A single cough can produce a large amount of bioaerosols, which may contribute to infectious disease transmission27.
It may therefore be relevant that non-CF patients with pulmonary Mycobacterium avium complex (MAC) have a higher incidence of GORD than is reported in the general population25,28. Moreover, it has been found that the use of regular acid-suppressive medication is associated with an increased risk of MAC pulmonary disease. Acid-suppressive medication is frequently used by CF patients and we have recently contributed to an active debate that PPI usage and raised gastric pH may be associated with bacterial growth23. A recent recommendation for management of NTM highlighted the potential importance of PPI as a risk factor2. We feel our data is consistent with the need for further research to evaluate the potential roles of GORD and acid suppression, in studies of NTM in CF. A longitudinal study would be needed to address a potential risk of transfer of organisms to the lung from the stomach through mechanisms including cough and recurrent reflux and aspiration. We feel that this should be considered and investigated in CF, and it would be important to also consider the lifelong use of antibiotics in CF patients and their overall effect on microbiomes.
Gastrostomy tube placement is a well-established and tolerated method to augment feeding in patients with CF. The gastrostomy tube may be placed endoscopically, surgically, or fluoroscopically. Foreign body-associated MABSC infections are increasingly recognised now receiving increasing emphasis because of the increased use of indwelling medical devices29. The presence of a foreign body is believed to facilitate colonisation by weakening host barrier defence mechanisms30. An individual case of perigastrostomy infection caused by M abscessus in an immunocompetent patient has been reported31.
Because MABSC are resistant to conventional antibiotics and anti-tuberculosis drugs, it is important to recognize this specific group of pathogens, particularly in patients with CF. Early identification may allow timely susceptibility testing, appropriate therapy and PEG management. A strength of our study therefore is that to our knowledge, our findings are the first data showing gastric juice and PEG-tube insertion are a potential niche for MABSC in patients with CF. A weakness of our study is that alongside previous influential studies on MABSC in CF our cohort size was modest and our study is cross sectional. The presence of the PEG allows access to gastric juice without potential commensal sampling from the upper airways but this means that our findings are limited to PEG fed patients with CF. We feel that our preliminary findings might usefully be followed up longitudinally in multi-centre approaches, in a wider range of patients. With clinical concerns raised about the increasing prevalence of MABSC in CF we conclude that such studies are warranted.
How to cite this article: Al-momani, H. et al. Nontuberculous mycobacteria in gastrostomy fed patients with cystic fibrosis. Sci. Rep. 7, 46546; doi: 10.1038/srep46546 (2017).
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
H Al-momani received financial support from the faculty of medicine at The Jordanian Hashemite University. C Ward, J Pearson and R Jones were supported by a UK Government Technology Strategy Board Knowledge Transfer Partnership (Certificate No. KTP008821), between Newcastle University and Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust. M Brodlie was supported by a Medical Research Council Clinician Scientist fellowship. C. Ward was supported by a grant from the UK Medical Research Foundation, Grant Reference: MRF-091-0001 and an unrestricted grant in aid from Boehringer Ingelheim.