We consider exciton-photon coupling in semiconductor microcavities in which separate periodic potentials have been embedded for excitons and photons. We show theoretically that this system supports degenerate ground-states appearing at non-zero inplane momenta, corresponding to multiple valleys in reciprocal space, which are further separated in polarization corresponding to a polarization-valley coupling in the system. Aside forming a basis for valleytronics, the multivalley dispersion is predicted to allow for spontaneous momentum symmetry breaking and two-mode squeezing under non-resonant and resonant excitation, respectively.
Photonic and electronic systems support many common universal phenomena. To give a selection of examples, the field of topological photonics emerged recently from ideas in the study of topological insulators1, and the field of spintronics has been an inspiration for optical analogues in the optical spin Hall effect2 and the development of photonic spin switches3,4. While the advantages of spintronics for information processing remain promising, the emerging field of valleytronics proposes to encode information in the valley degree of freedom of multivalley semiconductors5,6, including transition metal dichalcogenides7,8,9,10. This raises the question of whether valleytronics is itself a universal concept that can also appear in suitably engineered photonic systems.
A few recent works have taken an approach to hybridize light confined in planar microcavities with transition metal dichalcogenides11,12 resulting in exciton-polaritons (EPs) with large binding energy. Indeed, this system is highly promising as a nonlinear photonic system operating at room temperature, however, the valleytronic features of multivalley semiconductors that occur at wave vectors given by the inverse crystal lattice constant are uncoupled to optical modes that are restricted to lower in-plane wave vectors inside the light cone. The engineering of multiple valleys suitable for nonlinear optical valleytronics thus requires a different approach.
Nevertheless, EPs remain a good candidate as their relatively large micron-scale de Broglie wavelength does present the advantage that EPs can be strongly manipulated by micron scale potentials. Such potentials may be achieved either through spatial modulation of the photon energy13,14 or the exciton energy15,16,17,18,19. Periodic potential arrays have been introduced14,20, with different lattice geometries21,22,23, leading to gap solitons24,25, flatbands26, and Bloch oscillations27,28. They also lead to new devices29,30 and (theoretically) non-trivial topological properties31,32,33,34.
In this Report we consider the behavior of EPs in a microcavity where both the optical and excitonic components are separately manipulated by a periodic potential. While not considered before, this could be achieved by “proton implantation”35 in which the properties of quantum wells and semiconductor microcavities can be spatially patterned after growth. A different localization of photons and excitons by their respective potentials theoretically allows for a peculiar overlap of their wave functions that depends on the in-plane momentum. Remarkably, we yield the momentum-dependent coupling between excitons and photons, which gives rise to the formation of unusual dispersions with degenerate ground states at non-zero momenta, at the bottom of different valleys in reciprocal space.
We further show that different valleys have different polarizations, in analogy to the spin-valley coupling that forms the basis of valleytronics in two-dimensional (2D) semiconductor systems. For additional effects that arise from the unusual EP dispersion in our system, we consider the behaviour under non-resonant and resonant excitation conditions. In the former case, it is known that EPs may undergo a Bose-Einstein condensation36, characterized by the breaking of U(1) phase symmetry and the appearance of a macroscopic coherent low-energy state. Other symmetries may also be broken during Bose-Einstein condensation, both in EP systems and other systems, including spin symmetry breaking37,38 translational symmetry breaking39, and angular momentum symmetry breaking40,41. In our system, we find that there is also a spontaneous breaking of linear momentum symmetry, unprecedented in other systems, where the condensate may spontaneously choose between different valleys in the dispersion. Finally, we show that under resonant excitation, the presence of a two-mode squeezing due to polariton-polariton interactions leads to the onset of non-classical quantum correlations.
Dispersion of exciton-polaritons in a lattice
We begin by considering a one-dimensional (1D) system of cavity photons and quantum-well (QW) excitons25, which experience potentials with the same periodicity but different alignment in energy, as shown in Fig. 1a. Applying the Bloch theory and the model of coupled harmonic oscillators, we can use the central equation and solve the eigenvalue problem of the system, which in a brief form reads:
where and are the kinetic energy terms of the photonic and excitonic counterparts, correspondingly. Parameters τC,X are the lifetimes of the cavity photons and excitons, Ω is the exciton-photon coupling constant, and are the Fourier series coefficients of the potentials localizing the cavity photons and excitons in real space. The summation is over G, which is the reciprocal lattice vector of the periodic potential; Ck are the (vector) amplitudes of the wave functions of polaritons in the photon-exciton basis with various k; E are the eigenenergies of the EP modes.
After solution of the eigenvalue problem (see details in Supplementary), we find the dispersion of the system of EPs in k-space shown in Fig. 1b and the wave functions of photons and excitons (shown in Fig. 1c,d). It should be noted that the excitonic dispersion is nearly flat on the inverse μm scale, such that excitons are localized inside the minima of their potential.
In the mean time, photons can also be localized depending on their momentum, which makes the overlap of photons and excitons momentum-dependent. As it follows from Fig. 1b, the dispersion is characterized by two minima at non-zero wave vectors, k = k0. This result is the milestone of this manuscript and in the following we show that this peculiarity leads to non-trivial effects such as spontaneous momentum symmetry breaking upon EP condensation and quantum entanglement.
Polariton condensation in the limit of thermal equilibrium
Before considering the structure of the dispersion in 2D lattices, it is instructive to study the potential consequences of the dispersion shown in Fig. 1b for the 1D case. Here we begin by considering the behavior of the system under non-resonant excitation under which polariton condensation can be expected in the lattice14. Due to their finite lifetime, exciton-polaritons are non-equilibrium systems and so would not necessarily form in the ground state42, however, at high densities energy relaxation is typically enhanced to the ground state23. In this section, we consider qualitative arguments in the limit of thermal equilibrium43. This is only intended to be used as a qualitative insight for more accurate non-equilibrium modeling that will be presented later in section 2.
Given the dispersion, Ek, obtained in the linear regime (shown in Fig. 1b), the Hamiltonian of the system can be written as
where we introduce polariton-polariton interaction with the strength α. The factor 2 in Eq. (2) is characteristic of the momentum space scattering processes44 and can be related to inequivalent permutations of .
At zero temperature, one can expect that only the two lowest energy momentum states at k1 = −k0 and k2 = k0 are populated, where k0 is the momentum of the right minimum of the blue curve in Fig. 1b. Then the energy of the system can be written as
where for simplicity we denoted , and the total population n = n1 + n2. The lowest energy state thus appears when ρ = (n1 − n2)/n achieves its extreme value of ±1. In other words, at zero temperature we expect the system to spontaneously choose either the state with all the EPs at k1 or k2. This can be further confirmed by calculating the second order correlation function and spectrum corresponding to Hamiltonian 2, as shown in Fig. 2 (details of the calculation are included in Supplementary).
Nonequilibrium model of polariton condensation
EPs have finite lifetime and consequently form non-equilibrium condensates. In samples with weak energy relaxation, they do not necessarily reach the actual ground state of the system42,45. Let us further investigate the behavior of the system using a stochastic quantum treatment and accounting for various scattering processes (see Supplementary). We considered an InGaAlAs alloy-based microcavity and in computations used the following parameters: speed of sound cs = 5370 m/s46, γ = iħ/τ = ħ/18 ps−1 47.
In Fig. 3a, we switch off the polariton-polariton interaction and see that in this case there is no blueshift and the particles occupy mostly the edge of the Brillouin zone. It happens due to the fact that the lifetime of particles increases with the increase of |k||| and thus the decay rate decreases with |k|||, see red curve in Fig. 3. However, with account of the interaction, we achieve the degenerate condensation at points k = ±k0 due to the interplay of particle lifetime and interactions, see Fig. 3b. EPs are blueshifted in energy (compare with Fig. 3a).
It is important to note, that if we change the potential profiles for the excitons and photons (change the shapes of the curves in Fig. 1a), we can achieve different points of condensation, in particular we can make particles condense at k = 0 and k = kBZ, see Supplementary.
While the condensation of EPs to non-zero momentum states has been observed previously14,42,48 in those observations it was a purely non-equilibrium effect. In our work, the condensation to non-zero momentum takes place even in the limit of equilibrium, that is, strong energy relaxation. Furthermore, since the non-zero momentum states represent the true ground-state of the system, they are likely to be highly stable after they have formed, particularly in polariton systems close to thermal equilibrium. This may include recently developed long-lifetime inorganic microcavities49 as well as organic systems50 with faster energy relaxation processes51.
Entanglement generation: Resonant Excitation
The two degenerate dispersion minima within the first Brillouin zone (shown in Fig. 1b and also in Fig. 2) offer a unique opportunity to study controlled entanglement in the system. Indeed, let us assume that each minimum is driven by a cw laser with large enough spatial extension thus we can consider only two quantum modes, described by the creation operators and , respectively.
In order to describe the dynamics of such system, we use a dissipative master equation in the form:
where the deterministic evolution (the first term on the rhs) is described by the Hamiltonian,
which is similar to (2) after adding the pumping terms and in the frame rotating with the laser’s frequency, assuming and with Δj defined as the laser/modes detuning; let us also assume D1 = D2 = 0 and F1 = F2 for simplicity. It is crucial that the Hamiltonian (5) includes two kinds of interaction terms. The first one (α) stands for the interaction of EPs located within the same minimum, while the second term (4α) accounts for the cross-interactions between the minima which fulfills the energy momentum conservation by exchange of the wave vector +k → −k and no energy change (see Supplementary for details). Physically, the latter term corresponds to the cross-Kerr interaction which is known to induce two-mode squeezing52, and therefore continuous variable entanglement is expected to occur in reciprocal space.
In the indeterministic part of the evolution described by the last term in (4), correspond to the Lindblad superoperators which account for polariton losses due to the interaction with their environment. The continuous variable entanglement is quantified via the logarithmic negativity53, , where is the partial transpose of with respect to the second mode and is its trace norm. In Figure 4 we present steady state numerical solutions to Eq. (4) showing the average mode occupancies in panel (a) and the corresponding values of in panel (b) for increasing amplitude of the pumps. We observe a monotonous increase of both the quantities, as a direct proof of entanglement. Importantly, no state other than the one targeted by the laser can be reached by potential parametric processes which would violate the energy conservation.
Polarization-Valley coupling in 2D
Finally, we present the calculation of the dispersion in a 2D system obtained from generalization of the result in 1D to a square lattice. Figure 5a shows the energy of the system ground state in the first Brillouin zone (see also the 3D plot in Supplementary). Here we can identify four energy minima, at the bottom of different valleys in reciprocal space.
A fundamental feature of 2D semiconductors for valleytronics is the spin-valley coupling that allows different valleys to be excited with light of different polarization7,8,9,10. In the system of exciton-polaritons, it is well-known that transverse-electric and transverse-magnetic polarized modes are split in energy. This splitting can be modeled by introducing a spin-orbit coupling Hamiltonian acting on the photon spin degree of freedom38:
Accounting for this splitting, we obtain the polarization structure of the lowest energy band shown in Fig. 5b. Here we note that different valleys have different polarizations, which implies that they can be selectively excited by a resonant excitation of specific polarization. The geometry of the lowest energy pseudospin should allow to form such patterns as skyrmions54,55 or spin whirls56 under pulsed-resonant excitation.
We have considered the formation of exciton-polaritons in a semiconductor microcavity with separate spatially patterned potentials for cavity photons and excitons. The different confinement of photons and excitons allows for a momentum dependent coupling which gives rise to a unique form of the dispersion in which degenerate ground states appear at non-zero momenta. We considered two different limits corresponding to strong and weak energy relaxation. In the limit of strong energy relaxation, a simple equilibrium theoretical model predicts spontaneous symmetry breaking in momentum space. In the limit of weak energy relaxation, a non-equilibrium model accounting for phonon scattering processes shows non-equilibrium condensation at non-zero wave vector. Treating exciton polaritons as an open quantum system, we have also shown that correlations between the modes in reciprocal space can occur. Finally, considering exciton-polaritons in a 2D square lattice, we predict the formation of a multivalley-dispersion. Here different valleys exhibit different polarizations, which, in principal, allows for their selective excitation by a polarized laser and forms a foundation for exciton-polariton valleytronics.
How to cite this article: Sun, M. et al. Multivalley engineering in semiconductor microcavities. Sci. Rep. 7, 45243; doi: 10.1038/srep45243 (2017).
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
We thank Prof. Sergej Flach for fruitful discussions. M. Sun thanks Dr. Pinquan Qin for the discussions personally. We acknowledge support of Project Code (IBS-R024-D1); the Australian Research Council’s Discovery Projects funding scheme (project DE160100167), the government of Russian Federation (project MK-5903.2016.2) and the Dynasty Foundation. TCHL was supported by the MOE AcRF Tier 1 grant 2016-T1-1-084 and MOE AcRF Tier 2 grant 2015-T2-1-055.