Abstract
Anomalous random walks having longrange jumps are a critical branch of dynamical processes on networks, which can model a number of search and transport processes. However, traditional measurements based on mean first passage time are not useful as they fail to characterize the cost associated with each jump. Here we introduce a new concept of mean first traverse distance (MFTD) to characterize anomalous random walks that represents the expected traverse distance taken by walkers searching from source node to target node, and we provide a procedure for calculating the MFTD between two nodes. We use Lévy walks on networks as an example, and demonstrate that the proposed approach can unravel the interplay between diffusion dynamics of Lévy walks and the underlying network structure. Moreover, applying our framework to the famous PageRank search, we show how to inform the optimality of the PageRank search. The framework for analyzing anomalous random walks on complex networks offers a useful new paradigm to understand the dynamics of anomalous diffusion processes, and provides a unified scheme to characterize search and transport processes on networks.
Introduction
Complex networks are ubiquitous in the real world ranging from sociology to biology and technology^{1}. Going beyond the interesting topological properties, quantifying the impact of structural organization of networks on transport processes has become one of the most important topics. As a paradigmatic transport process, random walks on complex networks have been intensively studied^{2,3,4,5,6}. A variety of measurements including mean first passage time (MFPT)^{2}, first passage time^{4}, and average trapping time^{6} have been proposed, providing a comprehensive characterization of random walks on networks. Moreover, these studies also facilitate our understanding of diverse dynamical processes on networks including epidemic spreading^{7}, synchronization^{8}, and transportation^{9}.
However, for random walks, the walker is confined only to the neighbourhood of a node in each jump, which cannot model some real situations^{10}, and also impedes search and transport efficiency on networks^{4}. This limitation is circumvented by the natural of Lévy walks model^{11,12}. Recently, intensive attention has been devoted to anomalous random walks on networks, such as Lévy walks^{13,14,15}, traditional web surfing^{16}, and even electric signals transmitted in brain networks^{10}. One striking feature of anomalous random walks is having the longrange hopping (i.e., the walker can hop to far away nodes not directly connected to its current position). In fact, the occurrence of longrange hopping is frequently encountered in our life. For example, we usually communicate with people socially close to us, but also occasionally with those that are unconnected^{14}. Analogously, when doing web surfing, one usually proceeds by following the hyperlinks but casually may open a new tab to look for the related topic^{10}. Although it is widely agreed that anomalous random walks represent an important branch of search and transport processes on networks, how to characterize anomalous random walks and specifically, how to uncover the interplay between their dynamics and the underlying network structure has not been addressed. Traditional measurements like the mean first passage time neglect the difference between the cost associated with the nearestneighbor jump and the longrange hopping, therefore cannot properly characterize anomalous random walks on networks.
In this paper, we propose the mean first traverse distance that represents the expected traverse distance required by a walker moving from a source node to a target node. Importantly, this allows the cost associated with hopping to be taken into account in the characterization of anomalous random walks; this therefore overcomes the problems of traditional measurements adopted in general random walks. We obtain analytically the MFTD and the global MFTD on arbitrary networks. Results on Lévy walks demonstrate that these measurements can effectively characterize the relationship between network structure and anomalous random walks. Moreover, when applied to the PageRank search, we show how to inform the optimality of the PageRank search. The new metric enables effective characterization of dynamics of anomalous random walks on networks, which promises more efficient search and transport processes on networks.
Results
The MFTD of anomalous random walks
We start from an undirected network consisting of N nodes. The connectivity of nodes is fully described by a symmetric adjacency matrix A, whose entry a_{ij} = 1 (0) if nodes i and j are (not) connected. For anomalous random walks, at each time step, the walker jumps from current node i to node j with a nonzero transition probability p_{ij} regardless of the connection profile of node i. Take Lévy walks on networks for example, the transition probability is defined as , where α is the tuning exponent lying in the interval 0 ≤ α < ∞ and d_{ij} is the shortest path length between nodes i and j^{13}. To characterize anomalous random walks, we propose the concept of a MFTD l_{ij}, which is the expected distance taken by a walker to first reach node j starting from node i. Intuitively, the traverse distance in a onestep jump is shorter for a walker when nodes are directly connected, while this distance tends to be larger for indirectly linked nodes. Inspired by the empirical findings that the lengths of links usually obey a power law distribution^{17}, we adopt the power function to describe the effective distance of onestep jump, where β named the cost exponent is a nonnegative value. In this situation, if the first step of the walk is to node j, the expected traverse distance required is ; if it is to some other node k, the expected traverse distance becomes l_{kj} plus for the previous step already taken. Thus, we have
Using the Markov chains theory^{18,19}, the MFTD l_{ij} of a anomalous random walk (see appendices) becomes
where w_{k} is the kth component of the stationary distribution of the anomalous random walk, T_{ij} is the MFPT from node i to node j, and z_{ij} is an element of the fundamental matrix Z = (I − P + W)^{−1}. Specifically, when β = 0, the effective distances of onestep jumps are same (i.e., c_{ij} = 1). In this situation, it is easy to verify that the MFTD l_{ij} reduces to the MFPT T_{ij}, which means that our paradigm can incorporate the commonly used MFPT as a special case. To further evaluate the search efficiency of an anomalous walker, we calculate the global MFTD 〈L〉 by averaging Eq. (2) over all pairs of source and target nodes, that is,
Substituting Eq. (2) into Eq. (3), we have
where 〈T〉 is the average of MFPTs over all pairs of nodes in the networks (see appendices). Here, 〈L〉 quantifies the ability of the anomalous walker to search and transport at the global scale on the network. In this context, smaller 〈L〉 represents a more effective way of achieving mobility. In the following we will demonstrate how these measurements can effectively characterize diverse anomalous random walks on networks.
The MFTD scheme for characterizing Lévy walks
We first address a specific anomalous random walk — Lévy walks on networks. A Lévy walk exerts a powerlaw transition probability with the distance given by . Clearly, the tuning exponent α plays an important role in controlling the trade off between shortrange and longrange jumping in one step, which in turn fully determines the behaviors of the Lévy walk. Specially, when α is very small, the walker visits all nodes with approximately equivalent probability. In contrast, the walker can only possibly hop to the nearest neighbors at an extremely large α. In this context, the Lévy walk degenerates to the generic random walk^{2}. Using the balance condition, the stationary distribution of the Lévy walk can be expressed as
Inserting the above equation and the transition probability into Eq. (2) yields
A similar calculation applied to Eq. (4), the global MFTD 〈L〉 of Lévy walks reads
To test the validity of Eq. (7), we report both the numerical and theoretical results of the global MFTD for Lévy walks taking place in the planar Sierpiński gasket^{20} and the (1, 2)flower model^{21}. These two networks are typical hierarchical nets having the same number of nodes and edges but exhibiting apparently distinct structural organizations, which can favor us to explore how the network structure directly influences the behavior of a Lévy walk. To achieve the numerical results, we compute the traverse distance required for a walker to travel from a source node to a target node chosen randomly and average over the ensemble of 50,000 independent runs for each test. Figure 1 shows an excellent agreement between numerics and Eq. (7) for the different cost exponents β. In particular, when β = 0, the minimum of 〈L〉 occurs at α = 0 regardless of the network structures, which reproduces the previous results based on the MFPT^{22}. However, this result is unreasonable in practice without considering the distinct costs induced by the nearestneighborhood jumps and the longrange hops. In contrast, we find that when β > 0, the profiles of different network organizations show clearly distinct behaviors. Specially, the profiles of the planar Sierpiński gasket display a clear minimum in the medium range α, which minimizes the search distance, (i.e., the global mean first traverse distance). However, such behavior is absent for the (1, 2)flower model for β > 0, where they present a clearly monotonous tendency, see Fig. 1(b). Such difference can be intuitively explained when referring to their topological properties. Specifically, the Sierpiński gasket is a fractal network without the “smallworld” property^{20}, see its topological structure in Fig. 1(a). In contrast, the (1, 2)flower network has the “smallworld” feature and the “scalefree” characteristics^{21}, as shown in Fig. 1(b). Meanwhile, we also notice that, when α is large, the transition probability of the Lévy walk degenerates to a generic random walk. Hence, all curves approach a fixed value for α > 9, see in Fig. 1(a) and (b), as expected.
To further demonstrate the difference induced by network structure, we observe the size effect on the global MFTD 〈L〉 of the planar Sierpiński gasket and the (1, 2)flower model. We find that the profiles of each network present the same tendency for different network sizes N, see Fig. 2(a) and (b). Interestingly, the result presented in Fig. 2(a) clearly shows the presence of a minimum 〈L〉 for different network sizes at the same exponent α = 2.8. The way in which 〈L〉 scales with network size N on the planar Sierpiński gasket seems to follow rather different behaviors depending on the tuning exponent α. Specially, when α ≠ 2.8, the global MFTD 〈L〉 follows a power law with network size N, see Fig. 2(c). This is supported by observing the almost invariant values of the successive slopes δ_{s} obtained from ln〈L〉 versus lnN, as shown in the inset of Fig. 2(c). Conversely, for α = 2.8, the successive slopes δ_{s} present a clearly decreasing tendency. However, for the (1, 2)flower model, the 〈L〉 follows approximately a power law with network size N, see in Fig. 2(d). Note that here we choose the cost exponent β = 1 for convenience. However, such behavior of 〈L〉 versus N is general for an arbitrary cost exponent β.
Clearly, from Eq. (7), the cost exponent β plays an important role in controlling the search efficiency for Lévy walks. In order to explore how the optimal search efficiency of a Lévy walk changes with respect to the cost exponent β, we investigate the interplay between β and α for various networks including three synthetic models (the BarabásiAlbert (BA) model^{23}, the planar Sierpiński gasket^{20}, and the (u, v)flower model^{21}) and two real networks (the “Dolphin” network^{24} and an email network^{25}). Here, for a fair comparison, we calculate the measurement log_{N}〈L〉 in the (α, β) plane for eliminating the size effect of networks. Generally, regions with smaller log_{N}〈L〉 indicate an efficient way of search and transport based on Lévy walks. Figure 3 shows contour maps of log_{N}〈L〉 in the (α, β) plane computed for these selected networks. Interestingly, we find that distinct network structures lead to different patterns in the corresponding (α, β) plane. Specifically, the (α, β) planes generated from networks having the “smallworld” characteristics (such as the BA model and the (1, 2)flower model), demonstrate an “estuary” pattern — implying that Lévy walks are not the optimal way to search when β > 0.4. In contrast, typical fractal networks without the “smallworld” property (for example, the planar Sierpiński gasket and the (4, 5)flower model), result in a striking “flame” in the (α, β) planes, suggesting that there exists an optimal tuning exponent α, which minimizes the traverse distance for a broad range of cost exponents β. However, none of these patterns match the ones found in the Dolphin network and the email network, whose (α, β) planes show “rippled” features, meaning that the optimal exponent α gradually increases with the cost exponent β. The (α, β) plane uncovers the relationship between network structure and the behavior of Lévy walks, which provides information to design more effective search strategies and transport mechanisms in different environments. Note that, for convenience, we choose the cost exponent in the range [0, 1.2] as this can highlight the effect of network structure on the transportation of the Lévy walks. Of course, the cost exponent can take other values outside this range. However, based on the Eq. (7), we find that the profiles of the Lévy walk present a clearly decreasing tendency independent of network structure for the large cost exponent β. In this situation, the Lévy walk is less efficient than the random walk for information diffusion and transportation. For this reason, we do not include the trivial results of the large cost exponents here.
Furthermore, we follow the spirit of the MFPT, and extract more statistics from the MFTD. Here, we introduce the average trapping distance (ATD) defined as follows:
Clearly, the ATD L_{j} quantifies the mean of MFTD l_{mj} to the trap node j taken over all starting points with the stationary distribution. Submitting the results of Eqs (5) and (6) into Eq. (8) yields (see appendices)
where denotes the longrange degree of node j^{13} and the term z_{jj} is independent of the cost exponent β. Specifically, when α is small, the diagonal values of Z are almost the same. In this context, a clear scaling behavior emerges such that regardless of the underlying network structure. This is supported by observing the plots of lnL_{j} vs lnK_{j} shown in Fig. 4(a) and (b). With an increase of α, the slope of lnL_{j} versus lnK_{j} gradually decreases and finally asymptotically approaches to that of random walks as described in ref. 4. Results demonstrate the important role of α in shaping the ATD. Meanwhile, since the cost exponent β only influences the term based on Eq. (9), changing the cost exponent β will just shift vertically the curve of lnL_{j} versus lnK_{j} but does not affect their profile. This is supported by observing the profiles of lnL_{j} versus lnK_{j}, which present a similar tendency for different cost exponents β as illustrated in Fig. 4(c) and (d). We further find a linear relationship between lnL_{j} and β, when fixing the tapping position j and the tuning exponent α, see the insets in Fig. 4(c) and (d). The results are consistent with our theoretical prediction of the relationship lnL_{j}~Cβ, where C is a constant value related to the fractal dimension of a given network (see appendices).
The optimal condition of the PageRank search based on the MFTD theory
We finally apply the MFTD theory to characterize the famous PageRank search^{16}. The PageRank search is widely used to compute the relevance of web pages. The transition probability p_{ij} of the PageRank search is
where is the degree of node i and μ is the damping factor lying in the range [0, 1]. Clearly, the damping factor μ together with the network size N plays an important role in controlling the preference of visiting neighborhood or nonneighborhood nodes in one step, which in turn fully determines the behaviors of the PageRank search. To explore their effect on the behavior of the PageRank search, we study the global MFTD 〈L〉 for the PageRank algorithm on the (1, 2)flower network. The (1, 2)flower model is a hierarchical net having the “smallworld” feature and the “scalefree” characteristics, which are the common features of various “webpage” networks^{23}. The result presented in Fig. 5(a) clearly shows the presence of a minimum 〈L〉 for different network sizes. However, the value of μ_{opt}, where the minimum 〈L〉 is achieved, increases gradually with the network size N as shown in the inset of Fig. 5(a). Such behavior is clearly distinct from that of a Lévy walk, where the optimal tuning exponent is independent of network size N. This unique behavior can be further tested by examining the form for 〈L〉 vs N, see Fig. 5(b). The way in which 〈L〉 scales with network size N seems to follow a power law behavior, which is supported by observing the almost invariant values of the successive slopes δ_{s} as shown in the inset of Fig. 5(b). These findings imply that the network size influences the optimal way of the PageRank search. Meanwhile, from the inset of Fig. 5(a), we also notice that the μ_{opt} relies on the cost exponent β and increases with increasing the cost exponent β. This characteristics shows more apparently in the (μ, β) planes as presented in Fig. 5(c) and (d), where the growth of μ_{opt} seems to follow the reverse “S” shaped line. This peculiar growth pattern means that the μ_{opt} increases slowly for a smaller β and then increases rapidly in the median range of β. Finally it will approach to μ_{opt} ≈ 1 for a large β. In this situation, the optimal PageRank search is the generic random walk. Of course, this is an extreme case seldom occurring in practice.
Finally, we investigate the behavior for the PageRank search on two real networks (webStanford^{26} and EgoFacebook^{27}). The contour maps of the (μ, β) plane presented in Fig. 6(a) and (b) show a similar pattern, where the growth of μ_{opt} possibly follow the reverse “S” shaped line. Interestingly, we notice the existence of the median range of β for which an optimal search is achieved at the value of μ_{opt} ≈ 0.85. We highlight this special range in Fig. 6(c) and (d), where the global MFTD 〈L〉 is near its minimum value around μ ≈ 0.85. This is consistent with the ad hoc damping factor of the PageRank search which is suggested to be chosen around 0.85. Although we could not provide a complete explanation of μ ≈ 0.85 in practice, here we find a possible “reasonable” range of the cost exponent for the PageRank search, which may be further confirmed in the future by computing the topological distance versus the distance in the metric space constructed through the hyperbolic mapping of the Internet^{28}. Moreover, we notice that the minimum 〈L〉 of the PageRank search is much smaller than that of generic random walks (i.e., μ = 1), which to some extent demonstrates the advantage of taking the PageRank search instead of generic random walks.
Discussion
In summary, we have introduced the concept of the MFTD, a measure that takes into account of the cost of jumps in anomalous random walks, and which therefore is particularly suited to capture the interplay between the diffusion dynamics of anomalous random walks and underlying network structures. We obtain an exact expression for the MFTD and the global MFTD of anomalous random walks on complex networks. We show that our paradigm provides a unified scheme to characterize diffusion processes on networks, which incorporates the commonly used MFPT as a special case.
We demonstrate the effectiveness of these measures by applying them to Lévy walks and the PageRank search. Specially, we find that distinct network structures result in different patterns in the (α, β) planes, which explores the effect of the cost exponent β on behaviors of Lévy walks with respect to network structure. Moreover, we address how the tuning exponent α and the cost exponent β affect the trapping problem of Lévy walks. Specifically, we find that for a small value of α, the profiles present a uniformly linear scaling behavior regardless of network structure. Finally, when applied to the famous PageRank search, we explore the effect of network size and the cost exponent on the behavior of the PageRank search. In particular, we find that the growth of μ_{opt} seems to follow the reverse “S” shaped line with respect to the cost exponent. These findings will guide us how to design an optimal PageRank search in practice.
Our paradigm based on the MFTD is generic and can be applied to other anomalous random walks. However, the measurement of MFTD largely depends on an important factor — the cost exponent β. The obvious question we thus face is how to determine a “natural” value of the cost exponent β underlying networks. For an abstract network without any physical background, the cost exponent β can take any value in the interval [0, ∞). With respect to the efficiency of search and transport, we show the behaviors of anomalous random walks for some interesting ranges of the cost exponent β for convenience. In particular, we show the results of the cost exponent β lie in the interval [0, 1.2] for Lévy walks, while for the PageRank search, we present the cost exponent β lying in the range [0, 1.5]. For any real network, we believe that the cost exponent β can be estimated by computing the topological distance (i.e., the shortest path length) versus the distance in the metric space hidden behind an observable network as reported in refs 28, 29, 30. In this sense, as we believe, the cost exponent β is a physical parameter intrinsic to the real physical system, which links the topological distance and the distance in the hidden metric space.
Finally, to implement Lévy walks, we need to compute all shortest paths of a network which involves high computational costs especially for a large network. This issue has been already addressed in the previous literatures^{13,14} and is not the main scope of this paper. Nonetheless, we think one can use several excellent algorithms such as the preprocessing algorithm^{31}, which is one possible solution for this problem. For the “natural” value of the cost exponent for the PageRank search, this can be achieved by computing the shortest path length versus the distance in the metric space which is constructed by a hyperbolic map of various web networks^{28}. The cost exponent explores the relative relation between the topological distance of the web network and the distance in the hidden metric space. We do not expect the cost exponents underlying different web networks to be exactly the same. However, the cost exponent obtained in this way will help us to deepen our understanding of not only the PageRank search but also the other behaviors taking place on the Internet, for example the Internet routing.
Additional Information
How to cite this article: Weng, T. et al. Navigation by anomalous random walks on complex networks. Sci. Rep. 6, 37547; doi: 10.1038/srep37547 (2016).
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
References
 1.
Barabási, A. L. The network takeover. Nat. Phys. 8, 14–16 (2012).
 2.
Noh, J. D. & Rieger, H. Random walks on complex networks. Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 118701 (2004).
 3.
Condamin, S., Bénichou, O., Tejedor, V., Voituriez, R. & Klafter, J. First passage times in complex scaleinvariant media. Nature (London) 450, 77–80 (2007).
 4.
Hwang, S., Lee, D. S. & Kahng, B. First passage time for random walks in heterogeneous networks. Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 088701 (2012).
 5.
Perra, N. et al. Random walks and search in timevarying networks. Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 238701 (2012).
 6.
Lin, Y. & Zhang, Z. Z. Mean firstpassage time for maximalentropy random walks in complex network. Sci. Rep. 4, 5365 (2014).
 7.
Yang, Z. M. & Zhou, T. Epidemic spreading in weighted networks: An edgebased meanfield solution. Phys. Rev. E 85, 056106 (2012).
 8.
Skardal, P. S., Taylor, D. & Sun, J. Optimal synchronization of complex networks. Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 144101 (2014).
 9.
Li, G. et al. Towards design principles for optimal transport networks. Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 018701 (2010).
 10.
Patti, F. D., Fanelli, D. & Piazza, F. Optimal search strategies on complex multilinked networks. Sci. Rep. 5, 9869 (2015).
 11.
Viswanathan, G. M. Ecology: Fish in Lévyflight foraging. Nature (London) 465, 1018–1019 (2010).
 12.
Raichlen, D. et al. Evidence of Lévy walk foraging patterns in human huntergatherers. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 111, 728–733 (2014).
 13.
Riascos, A. P. & Mateos, J. L. Longrange navigation on complex networks using lévy random walks. Phys. Rev. E 86, 056110 (2012).
 14.
Riascos, A. P. & Mateos, J. L. Fractional dynamics on networks: Emergence of anomalous diffusion and Lévy flights. Phys. Rev. E 90, 032809 (2014).
 15.
Weng, T. F., Small, M., Zhang, J. & Hui, P. Lévy walk navigation in complex networks: A distinct relation between optimal transport exponent and network dimension. Sci. Rep. 5, 17309 (2015).
 16.
Langville, A. N. & Meyer, C. D. Google’s PageRank and Beyond: The Science of Search Engine Rankings (Princeton University, 2006).
 17.
Li, D. Q., Kosmas, K., Armin, B. & Shlomo, H. Dimension of spatially embedded networks. Nat. Phys. 7, 481–484 (2011).
 18.
Grinstead, C. M. & Snell, J. L. Introduction to Probability (American Mathematical Society, 2006).
 19.
Kemeny, J. G. & Snell, J. L. Finite Markov Chains (van Nostrand Princeton, NJ, 1960).
 20.
Kozak, J. J. & Balakrishnan, V. Analytic expression for the mean time to absorption for a random walker on the Sierpiński gasket. Phys. Rev. E 65, 021105 (2002).
 21.
Rozenfeld, H. D., Havlin, S. & benAvraham, D. Fractal and transfractal recursive scalefree nets. New J. Phys. 9, 175 (2007).
 22.
Lin, Y. & Zhang, Z. Z. Random walks in weighted networks with a perfect trap: An application of Laplacian spectra. Phys. Rev. E 87, 062140 (2013).
 23.
Barabási, A. & Albert, R. Emergence of scaling in random networks. Science 286, 509–512 (1999).
 24.
Lusseau, D. et al. The bottlenose dolphin community of Doubtful Sound features a large proportion of longlasting associations. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 54, 396–405 (2003).
 25.
Guimerà, R., Danon, L., DíazGuilera, A., Giralt, F. & Arenas, A. Selfsimilar community structure in a network of human interactions. Phys. Rev. E 68, 065103 (2003).
 26.
Leskovec, J., Lang, K. J., Dasgupta, A. & Mahoney, M. W. Community structure in large networks: Natural cluster sizes and the absence of large welldefined clusters. Internet Mathematics 6, 29–123 (2009).
 27.
Mcauley, J. & Leskovec, J. Learning to Discover Social Circles in Ego Networks. Adv. Neural Inf. Process. Syst. 25, 548–556 (2012).
 28.
Boguñá, M., Papadopoulos, F. & Krioukov, D. Sustaining the Internet with hyperbolic mapping. Nat. Commun. 1, 62 (2010).
 29.
Boguñá, M., Krioukov, D. & Claffy, K. C. Navigability of complex networks. Nat. Phys. 5, 74–80 (2009).
 30.
AlanisLobato, G., Mier, P. & AndradeNavarro, M. A. Efficient embedding of complex networks to hyperbolic space via their Laplacian. Sci. Rep. 6, 30108 (2016).
 31.
Sommer, C. Shortest path queries in static networks. ACM Computing Surveys 46, 45 (2014).
Acknowledgements
J.Z. is supported by National Science Foundation of China NSFC 61104143. M.S. is supported by Australian Research Council Discovery Project DP 140100203. We also thank Kai Zhang for useful discussions and helps. This research has been supported, in part, by General Research Fund 26211515 from the Research Grants Council of Hong Kong, and Innovation and Technology Fund ITS/369/14FP from the Hong Kong Innovation and Technology Commission.
Author information
Affiliations
HKUSTDT System and Media Laboratory, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, HongKong
 Tongfeng Weng
 , Moein Khajehnejad
 , Rui Zheng
 & Pan Hui
Centre for Computational Systems Biology, Fudan University, China
 Jie Zhang
The University of Western Australia, Crawley, WA 6009, Australia
 Michael Small
Mineral Resources, CSIRO, Kensington, WA, Australia
 Michael Small
Authors
Search for Tongfeng Weng in:
Search for Jie Zhang in:
Search for Moein Khajehnejad in:
Search for Michael Small in:
Search for Rui Zheng in:
Search for Pan Hui in:
Contributions
T. F. Weng, J. Zhang, M. Small and P. Hui designed the research, performed the research, and wrote the manuscript. K. Moein and R. Zheng analyzed data and performed research. All authors reviewed the manuscript.
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Corresponding authors
Correspondence to Tongfeng Weng or Pan Hui.
Supplementary information
PDF files
Rights and permissions
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in the credit line; if the material is not included under the Creative Commons license, users will need to obtain permission from the license holder to reproduce the material. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
About this article
Further reading

Predatorprey games on complex networks
Communications in Nonlinear Science and Numerical Simulation (2019)

Efficiency of longrange navigation on Treelike fractals
Chaos, Solitons & Fractals (2019)

Predicting search time when hunting for multiple moving targets: A recursive harmonic law
Chaos: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science (2018)

Universal principles governing multiple random searchers on complex networks: The logarithmic growth pattern and the harmonic law
Physical Review E (2018)

Efficient sampling of complex network with modified random walk strategies
Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications (2018)
Comments
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.