Erratum: Insight into the template effect of vesicles on the laccase-catalyzed oligomerization of N-phenyl-1,4-phenylenediamine from Raman spectroscopy and cyclic voltammetry measurements

Scientific Reports 6: Article number: 30724; published online: 26 August 2016; updated: 07 October 2016 In the original version of this Article, Peter Walde was incorrectly affiliated with: University of Belgrade-Faculty of Pharmacy, Department of Physical Chemistry and Instrumental Methods, VojvodeStepe 450, 11221 Belgrade, Serbia.

pH, typically between 0 and 2 12 . In contrast, the enzymatic synthesis of the PANI-ES like product, poly(PADPA), is conducted under milder conditions (pH = 3.5) and by using an enzyme and O 2 as the oxidizing agent, see also Shumakovich et al. 13 . The reaction of PADPA with TvL/O 2 leads to an oligo-or polymerization driven by radicals, whereby the first step of the reaction is most likely the formation of the radical cation, PADPA •+ 11,14 . Two of these radical cations possibly directly combine and then react further, upon oxidation, with other PADPA radical cations, to finally form positively charged PADPA-chains with a high concentration of unpaired electrons in polaron form, typical for PANI-ES ( Fig. 1) 1,11,13 . However, from previous studies it became evident that the products obtained from the oxidation of PADPA have a lower molar mass on average than conventional PANI-ES 1,8,15 . It seems that oligomeric rather than polymeric products are obtained from PADPA. Since the average degree of oligo-/polymerization is still not clear, and for the sake of convenience, we will continue using "poly(PADPA)" as general term for the oxidative reaction products obtained from PADPA.
Radical polymerizations involving radical-radical couplings of the type investigated here are difficult to control due to the high reactivity and low selectivity of the intermediate aromatic radical species. In this context the AOT vesicles have been found to be crucial for the TvL/O 2 -promoted oligo-or polymerization of PADPA: under the elaborated optimal conditions (see above), the vesicles direct the course of the reaction towards the desired poly(PADPA) end-products, i.e., PANI-ES like molecules 1 . In particular, the soft surface of the vesicle membrane clearly exerts control over the oxidation and the polymerization steps of the reaction. Similar effects of soft interfaces as "reaction regulators" (templates) of enzyme-catalyzed oxidative polymerizations have been known for several years [16][17][18][19] . They have been found with anionic micelles, as another type of molecular assemblies 13,18,[20][21][22] , or with anionic polymers, such as sulfonated polystyrene (SPS) 18,[23][24][25][26][27][28][29] . For all these previous examples, the regulating effect of the templates is still not completely understood. Our long-term goal is to better understand the template effect observed with vesicles.
Herein, we applied for the first time Raman spectroscopy measurements of a vesicle-assisted enzyme-catalyzed oligomerization/polymerization reaction. We showed that Raman spectroscopy is a convenient and sensitive method for in situ monitoring of the oxidation and oligomerization/polymerization of PADPA with TvL/O 2 in the presence of AOT vesicles, as well as in the absence of the vesicles. In contrast to the previously applied UV/vis/NIR and EPR spectroscopy measurements 1 , the present in situ Raman spectroscopy measurements of the reaction mixture during the course of reaction provide novel and detailed information on the evolution of the molecular structures of the oligomeric PADPA products through vibrational characteristics of distinct functional groups 4,30 and through changes in their abundancies. This yields new insight into the effect of vesicles on the structural evolution of poly(PADPA).
An additional advantage of the in situ measurements is that possible structural changes in the products which may occur upon product isolation are avoided. For a comparison, the in situ Raman spectra of the final poly(PADPA) products synthesized with and without AOT vesicles are compared (i) with the corresponding Raman spectra of final isolated solid poly(PADPA) products, as well as (ii) with the Raman spectra reported in the literature for solid PANI salts and bases, produced by classical chemical polymerization.
Compared to our previous work 1 , we also carried out additional EPR measurements of the reaction mixture during the course of the reaction and made a more detailed analysis of the EPR spectra.
In addition to the EPR and Raman spectroscopy measurements, we present the first results of cyclic voltammetry (CV) measurements of this system, which demonstrate that the final products in the reaction suspension with vesicles are redox-active, as expected for PANI-ES-like molecules. Moreover, the redox activity of poly(PADPA) produced with vesicles is preserved at higher pH values compared to ordinary PANI-ES and poly(PADPA) produced enzymatically without vesicles. The vesicular reaction suspension was directly used for these electrochemical measurements, i.e. without any product isolation, which paves the way for further electrochemical applications of this type of AOT vesicle/PANI-ES-like system.

Results and Discussion
Reactions of PADPA with TvL/O 2 Analyzed by UV/vis/NIR Spectroscopy. If an air-exposed aqueous suspension of large unilamellar AOT vesicles with diameters of about 80-100 nm is incubated at an AOT concentration of 1.5 mM in the pH = 3.5 solution (see Fig. 2 and Methods) and T ≈ 25 °C with 1.0 mM PADPA and ≈ 32 or 64 nM TvL, oxidation of PADPA and the formation of dark-green oligomeric and/or polymeric products without any visible precipitation is observed 1 . Since the reaction products remain finely dispersed throughout the entire course of the reaction with vesicles, UV/vis/NIR spectroscopy can be used to monitor the progress of the reaction by recording spectra of the entire reaction mixture as a function of reaction time 1 . Figure 3a shows the UV/vis/NIR spectroscopic changes occurring from the early stage up to 4 h of the reaction. The results presented here, with [TvL] = 64 nM and a reaction volume of 10 mL, are in good agreement with those obtained previously 1 for a reaction mixture of the same composition, [TvL] = 32 nM, and a reaction volume of 15 mL, when both reactions are carried out in the same type of glass bottles (see Methods). This confirms the high reproducibility of the reaction, despite the heterogeneity of the system, and both used enzyme concentrations (32 or 64 nM) can be regarded as optimal. The products formed in the presence of the vesicular templates have a characteristic maximum absorbance at ≈ 1000 nm (A ≈1000 ) and at ≈ 420 nm, with a minimum at ≈ 500 nm. Based on literature data 3 , the bands at ≈ 1000 nm and ≈ 420 nm correspond to π → polaron band and polaron band → π * transitions of PANI and indicate the formation of the polaron form of PAN-ES-like poly(PADPA) chains. The band at 1000 nm is also indicative for high delocalization of polarons, expanded coil conformation of chains and consequently high conductivity 3,31 . Under the reaction conditions used, there is a continuous increase of A ≈1000 with time until ≈ 3 h, after which there are no more significant changes in the absorption spectrum (Fig. 3a). If the reaction is carried out without vesicles, but otherwise identical composition (template -free system), the dark-green products are not formed, and precipitation begins after about 2-3 hours ( Supplementary Fig. S1A) 1 . In the UV/vis/NIR spectra of this template-free system the characteristic band of delocalized polarons at ~1000 nm was not developed, but a band indicative for localized polarons is observed with a maximum at 700-780 nm 3 . Overall, it is very clear that the course of the reaction in the presence of AOT vesicles as well as the products obtained in the vesicular system are very different from the reaction and products of the template-free system.

Reactions of PADPA with TvL/O 2 Analysed by EPR Spectroscopy.
In an extension of our previous EPR measurements 1 , the reaction mixture with AOT vesicles was analyzed by EPR spectroscopy in more detail during the first 2 h. The recorded EPR spectra are shown in Fig. 3b. All samples analyzed show the presence of unpaired electrons. At the very beginning of the reaction, after t = 1 min, the signal intensity is rather weak and the spectrum is very broad without any hyperfine structure. If the reaction is run without vesicles, a weak and broad signal is also observed after t = 1 min. In this case, however, the EPR spectrum shows a hyperfine coupling ( Supplementary Fig. S1B). The calculated g-value of the radical species which are formed at the very beginning of the reaction in the absence of vesicles is g = 2.0031 ± 0.0001. Based on this g-value and the hyperfine splitting which is characteristic for arylamines 32 , we propose that the initial EPR signal is due to PADPA •+ , which is formed at the initial stage of the reaction without as well as with vesicles. The reason that hyperfine coupling is not detected during the reaction with vesicles may be because binding of PADPA •+ to the vesicles leads to a broadening of the hyperfine signals. For reaction mixtures with vesicles in a time interval from 5 to 120 min, a sharp EPR signal of increasing intensity can be seen (Fig. 3b). All measured EPR spectra can be fitted by assuming the presence of two principal radical species (structural entities), one being the reaction intermediate formed initially (most likely PADPA •+ ), and the other being the main final reaction product. The g-value for the radical centers in this final reaction product was determined to be g = 2.0030 ± 0.0001. In Fig. 3c, the integral of the EPR spectra originating from the final reaction product obtained with the vesicles is plotted vs. reaction time and overlaid with A 1000 vs. time as obtained from the UV/vis/NIR measurements. Note that the values for the integrals of the EPR spectra were scaled to match the course of the absorbance at 1000 nm. The time dependence of both signals is remarkably similar, confirming the correlation between A ≈1000 and the presence of unpaired electrons in the product, as it is typical for molecules with structural units that resemble the conductive polaron state of PANI-ES. With the mentioned fitting, the changes of the relative abundance of the two radical species during the reaction Scientific RepoRts | 6:30724 | DOI: 10.1038/srep30724 in the presence of the vesicles were determined (Fig. 3d). After 120 min the initially formed radical species (most likely PADPA •+ ) disappeared, while the radical species of the (main) products clearly dominated. For the reaction without vesicles (template-free system), the total concentration of radicals never reached the levels of the reaction with vesicles 1 .

Reactions of PADPA with TvL/O 2 in the Presence of Vesicles Analysed by in situ Raman
Spectroscopy Measurements. In order to gain information on chemical and structural changes of the reactive species during the enzymatic oxidative oligo-and polymerization of PADPA, and in order to gain new insights into the effect of vesicles, in situ Raman spectroscopy was applied as an alternative method to UV/vis/NIR and EPR spectroscopy.
Before measuring the reaction mixtures, reference spectra of the various reaction components (Milli-Q water, the phosphate solution, the AOT vesicle suspension, the PADPA solution, and the PADPA/AOT vesicle suspension) were recorded ( Supplementary Fig. S2). Afterwards, in situ Raman spectra of the reaction mixture containing AOT vesicles and PADPA were measured at different times after initiating the reaction by adding TvL (Fig. 4). For this, small volumes were withdrawn from the reaction mixture at various reaction times and transferred into sample wells of the gold sample slide, see Methods. Immediately afterwards, the Raman spectrum of the reaction mixture droplet was measured. The observed Raman bands clearly originate mainly from the reaction intermediates and products. Contributions from AOT are negligible.  Although the interpretation of Raman spectra of PANI samples, with their various possible chemical structures, states of oxidation and degree of protonation is still in progress 33 , the assignments of the observed spectral changes are based on current knowledge elaborated for chemically synthesized poly(PADPA) 11 and PANI [33][34][35] . Compared to the recent Raman analysis of thin PANI films formed on a gold surface 33 , where the authors found that the interaction of chemically adsorbed aniline oligomers (formed during the early stage of the reaction) with the smooth gold support causes enhancement and shifts of some peaks in the Raman spectra of PANI films, the in situ Raman spectra which were recorded here ( Fig. 4) originate from the molecules present in the reaction mixture. There are no noticeable interactions between the gold support and the reaction mixture which would alter the spectrum ( Supplementary Fig. S3), i.e., the influence of the used sample support on the Raman spectra is negligible ( Supplementary Figs S3 and S4).
In the following, the observed Raman bands are assigned and the meaning of their changes with time are discussed, listed according to the functional groups/structural units indicated to be present in reaction intermediates and final products.
Bands characteristic of quinonoid and semiquinonoid structures. Already 1 min after the addition of TvL, a strong band appears at 1596 cm −1 and remains a characteristic peak in all spectra recorded further on. This band is attributed to the C= C and C~C stretching vibrations of quinonoid (Q) and semiquinonoid (SQ) rings, ν (C= C) Q and ν (C~C) SQ (Fig. 1), where ″ ~″ denotes a bond intermediate between the single and double bond 11,34,35 .
The band at ≈ 1498 cm −1 (visible for t = 1-120 min) can be assigned to the C = N stretching in quinonediimine units, ν (C = N) Q ( Fig. 1) 34,35 . Furthermore, there is a weak band at ≈ 1505 cm −1 at t = 1 min, which later develops into a strong band at 1513-1520 cm −1 . This band can be attributed to N-H bending vibrations, δ (N-H), and was previously correlated with SQ structures in PANI 34,35 . In the spectra taken at t = 1, 5, 10 and 15 min, the ν (C = N) Q band is stronger than the δ (N-H) band, but the intensity of the δ (N-H) band gradually increases with time so that at t = 20 min the two bands have almost equal intensities. At t = 120 min the δ (N-H) band becomes more intense than the ν (C = N) Q band, and for times after t > 120 min the peak at ≈ 1498 cm −1 disappears completely. This behavior indicates an increase of the protonation level and an increase in the content of SQ units in the reaction products with increasing reaction time.
The bands due to the C-H bending in-plane vibrations of SQ/Q, δ (C-H) SQ,Q , are observed at 1163-1168 cm −1 .
Bands characteristic of polaron structures. The broad band assigned to C-N + stretching vibrations, ν (C-N + ), and attributable mainly to ν (C-N •+ ) SQ vibration in polaron structures, with possible contribution of ν (C-N + ) ring-stretching vibration in N-phenazine-type units 34,35 , is observed at ≈ 1350 cm −1 for t = 1 min and at ≈ 1376 cm −1 for t = 5 min. At the beginning of the reaction (t = 1 min) this band is rather weak, but its relative intensity increases with time. The red shift of the ν (C-N •+ ) band from 1376 cm −1 to 1337 cm −1 between t = 5 min and t = 38 days is accompanied by an increase in band intensity. This can be explained by an increase in π -electron delocalization and/or formation of more delocalized polaron structures with an increase in reaction time 34 , indicating an increased electrical conductivity in the final products 8 . The shoulder at 1325-1316 cm −1 seen in the spectra for t ≥ 5 min can also be associated with ν (C-N •+ ) vibrations of the conductive PANI-ES-like form, probably in more delocalized polaron structures 34 . According to previous reports on conducting PANIs (ref. 34 and references cited therein), the coexistence of the two bands in the wavenumber range 1400-1300 cm −1 indicates that two differently organized polarons are present in the final product. In our case, two polaronic sites are present, one with relatively lower delocalization-the stronger peak at 1376 -1337 cm −1 -and one with highly delocalized polaronic sites-the shoulder at 1325-1316 cm −1 . This means that the distribution of semiquinone radical cations in poly(PADPA) is not uniform. However, this possibility is not clearly supported by the in situ EPR measurements which indicate that one type of radical dominates the final as-formed product (see above, Bands characteristic of phenazine-and phenoxazine-type units. In the spectrum recorded after 1 min, a strong band is observed at 1640 cm −1 with a similar intensity as the band at 1596 cm −1 (C-C vibrations in SQ and Q structures). The band at 1640 cm −1 is usually assigned to C~C ring-stretching vibrations in phenazine-, N-phenylphenazine-and/or phenoxazine-type units mixed with the C~C stretching vibration of the B ring, ν (C~C) B (Fig. 1) [34][35][36][37] . This band is much sharper and stronger in comparison to the broad band observed at ≈ 1640 cm −1 in the spectrum of PADPA/AOT vesicles ( Supplementary Fig. S2, spectrum e). It can be seen that the band at 1640 cm −1 shifts to lower wavenumbers with an increase of the reaction time (e.g., to 1634, 1630, 1627, and 1625 cm −1 at t = 5, 15, 20, and 120 min, respectively, Fig. 4). This band shift can be explained by taking into account an increased contribution from the ν (C~C) B vibrations (as present in ordinary PANI-like units) and a concomitant decrease in the contribution of C~C ring-stretching vibrations of phenazine-type units with increasing reaction time. In most of the spectra obtained at t ≥ 5 min, the intensity of the band at 1640-1621 cm −1 is lower than the intensity of the band at 1596 cm −1 (C-C vibration in SQ and Q structures). This is an indication that the content of ordinary PANI-like Q and SQ segments increases abruptly at t ≥ 5 min.
Scientific RepoRts | 6:30724 | DOI: 10.1038/srep30724 Further bands typical for substituted phenazine-and/or phenoxazine-type of segments 34,36 are also seen in all spectra: at ≈ 1566 cm −1 (weak band) for t = 1-120 min, at ≈ 1572 cm −1 for t = 1-38 days, and at 1417-1408 cm −1 for t = 1 min-3 days. The relative intensities of the bands at 1566 cm −1 and 1408-1417 cm −1 decrease with an increase of the reaction time, and becomes very weak after t = 1 day and t = 3 days. An abrupt intensity decrease of "the phenazine band" at 1408-1417 cm −1 is observed in the spectrum measured at t = 120 min, while in the spectra recorded later on, this band is very weak (t = 1 day, 3 days) or absent (t = 18 days, 38 days).
Unclear assignment. In the spectrum recorded after t = 1 day there is a new band located at 1385 cm −1 which is not present in the spectra measured at t ≤ 120 min. This indicates that there are still changes in the chemical structure of the obtained products beyond t = 120 min, which are not clearly reflected in the Uv/vis/NIR spectra: the band intensity at about 1385 cm −1 decreases until it is very weak at t = 38 days. The appearance of the band at 1385 cm −1 after t = 1 day occurs simultaneously with the disappearance of "the phenazine band" at ≈ 1408 cm −1 . The origin of the band at about 1385 cm −1 is unclear at the moment. Possible assignments are ν (C-N + )/ring stretching vibrations in N-phenylphenazine (safranine) and/or phenoxazine type of units 11,34,37 . Changes in the Raman spectrum of chemically synthesized PANI films during aging are also known 31 , although the aging conditions in that case were treatement at 80 °C for three months. Bands characteristic of quinonoid and semiquinonoid structures. An important spectral difference between the reaction with and without vesicles is the intensity of the ν (C=N) Q band at ≈ 1498 cm −1 , which is much higher for the template-free system than for the system with vesicles. In the template free-system it increases with an increase of the reaction time (Fig. 5). This band is typical for the emeraldine base form of PANI, PANI-EB (Fig. 1), and becomes the strongest band in the spectra recorded between t = 1 day and t = 38 days (Fig. 5). This indicates a much higher content of quinonediimine segments in poly(PADPA) (Fig. 1) in the template-free system than in the vesicle system. Therefore, at least some of the reaction products obtained without vesicles resemble the structural units present in PANI-EB.
In all spectra of the products obtained without vesicles, the intensity of the δ (N-H) band at ≈ 1516 cm −1 (indicative of protonation and the presence of SQ rings) is lower than the intensity of the ν (C= N) Q band at ≈ 1497 cm −1 (up to t = 70 min), while for the spectra of the products obtained in the presence of vesicles (Fig. 4) the opposite is true: the δ (N-H) band becomes stronger than the ν (C=N) Q band (for t > 20 min). In the spectra of the template-free system recorded after t = 1 day or t = 38 days (Fig. 5), the peak at ≈ 1516 cm −1 is hardly visible.
Bands characteristic of polaron structures. One of the most important difference between the in situ Raman spectra of the reaction products obtained in the presence of AOT vesicles (Fig. 4) and in the absence of the vesicles (Fig. 5) is the intensity of the ν (C-N •+ ) band. In contrast to the spectra of the products obtained in the presence of vesicles− where the ν (C-N •+ ) band at ≈ 1350-1370 cm −1 is quite strong already in the early stages of the reaction (t = 5-15 min) and its intensity increases with time-the ν (C-N •+ ) band (1331-1350 cm −1 ) in the template-free system has a relatively low intensity all the time, even after t = 70 min and later at t = 1 day or t = 38 days (Fig. 5). This is an indication of a much lower content of polaron structures in the products from the template-free system, most probably resulting in a much lower conductivity in comparison to the products obtained in the presence of the vesicles. In addition, in contrast to the system with vesicles, the peak at about 1320 cm −1 due to ν (C-N •+ ) vibrations, also indicative of highly delocalized polaron structures, is not observed in the spectra of the template-free system. This correlates with the findings from the UV/vis/NIR (no band around 1000 nm) and the EPR measurements (very low signal intensity) for the template-free system.
Bands characteristic of phenazine-and phenoxazine-type units. The band attributable to phenazine ring stretching vibrations is observed in the first spectrum (t = 1 min) at 1413 cm −1 (Fig. 5). This band is significantly weaker in the spectrum recorded after t = 5 min, and it becomes very weak, or is even absent, in the spectra measured at longer reaction times. This behaviour is different from the spectra of the products obtained in the presence of the vesicles (Fig. 4), where a band at ≈ 1413 cm −1 is clearly seen in all spectra from t = 1 min to t = 120 min.

Unclear assignment.
A new band appears at 1390 cm −1 in the spectrum at t = 5 min (Fig. 5), and this band is also present (at 1385-1389 cm −1 ) in the spectra taken after longer reaction times. The appearance of a band at this frequency is also observed for the reaction in the presence of the vesicles, see above. The origin of the band is under discussion. As mentioned above, it can be tentatively assigned to the ν (C-N + )/ring stretching vibrations in N-phenylphenazine (safranine) and/or phenoxazine 11 -type of units 34,37 . Indeed, pure phenoxazine dyes show a strong Raman band 34,38 at 1390 cm −1 , and phenosafranine and its polymerization product give Raman bands at 1380 cm −1 and 1390 cm −1 , respectively 37 . After long reaction times (t = 38 days), the band is no more present, indicating that chemical changes 31 may still take place during prolonged storage of the reaction mixture.
Bands indicating C=O bonds. Weak bands at 1665 cm −1 and 1684 cm −1 observed in the first spectrum (t = 1 min) (Fig. 5) can be attributed to stretching vibrations of C= O bonds, indicating that partial hydrolysis of iminoquinonoid C= N bonds took place 11 . This suggestion correlates with previous findings from preliminary ESI-MS measurements that oxygen-containing species are present in reaction intermediates extracted from the template-free system 1 .

Main Findings from the in situ Raman Spectroscopy Measurements.
Although there are still uncertainties in the assignment of the bands 33 , the main findings can be summarized as follows: the products formed in the presence of vesicles exhibit (i) a much higher content of polaron structures, (ii) a significantly higher protonation level, and (iii) a much lower content of quinonediimine segments than the products formed without vesicles. The spectra of the system with vesicles indicate a continuous increase in π -electron delocalization with increasing reaction time (which would mean an increase in electrical conductivity). This feature is not observed for the template-free system, where the band characteristic for polaron structures retains a relatively low intensity all the time.
A comparison of the in situ Raman spectrum of poly(PADPA) obtained enzymatically with the vesicles with the Raman spectrum of solid, chemically synthesized PANI-ES 39 shows that there are differences in the molecular structure of the two types of products ( Supplementary Fig. S5). On the other hand, the Raman spectrum of poly(PADPA) obtained in the absence of vesicles is remarkably similar to that of chemically synthesized PANI-EB ( Supplementary Fig. S6). Furthermore, upon isolation of poly(PADPA) obtained enzymatically in the presence of vesicles, the Raman spectrum changes in comparison to the Raman spectrum recorded in situ ( Supplementary  Fig. S7). This may be due to oxidative intramolecular cyclization of branched units present in the formed products 11,34,40,41 . Cyclic Voltammetry Measurements. For the cyclic voltammetry (CV) measurements, the reaction products were deposited onto a glassy carbon (GC) electrode. This was done in two different ways, either (i) by using the isolated and purified poly(PADPA) products deposited in the form of a thin film with additives or (ii) by drop-casting the reaction mixture as obtained (no product isolation). In a first set of measurements, both approaches were applied for the investigation of the redox activity of the poly(PADPA) products obtained in the system with AOT vesicles, while only the latter one-without product isolation-was used to investigate the electrochemical behavior of poly(PADPA) products obtained in the template-free system.
Irrespective of the applied method, the recorded cyclic voltammograms show that poly(PADPA) obtained in the presence of AOT vesicles is redox active up to pH 6.00, being the upper limit of the investigated pH range (Fig. 6, the first and the second row).
By applying the direct drop-casting method, a complex pH-dependent electrochemistry of poly(PADPA) can be observed (Fig. 6, second and third row). At the lowest pH of 1.14, the cyclic voltammogram of poly(PADPA) obtained in the presence of AOT vesicles (Fig. 6d) resembles that of PANI, with two anodic peaks observed at 0.27 and 0.62 V vs. SCE, and the corresponding cathodic peaks found at 0.18 and 0.42 V vs. SCE. Commonly, the couple located at lower potentials is ascribed to the redox transformations of fully reduced chains of the leucoemeraldine form of PANI to the half-oxidized chains of the PANI-ES form and vice versa; while the second couple found at higher potentials is due to the interconversion of PANI-ES to the fully oxidized pernigraniline form of PANI 42,43 . Upon increasing the pH to pH = 3.04 a new anodic peak at ~0.4 V (Fig. 6e) was seen in the middle of the cyclic voltammogram, which can be attributed to incorporated phenazine-like structural units 44 . This peak is also seen in the cyclic voltammogram for pH = 6.00, but shifted to ~0.25 V (Fig. 6f). The observed shift of all oxidation peaks to less positive potentials with increasing pH indicates an easier oxidation process in more alkaline conditions, in accordance with previous findings for aniline monomer and oligomers 40,41 or phenazine derivatives 45 . The observed complex redox behavior as a function of pH is caused (i) by reduced levels of protonation of poly(PADPA) upon increasing the pH of the supporting electrolyte, (ii) by the presence of segments different from ordinary PANI-like segments (having different pK a values), and (iii) by the presence of different anions 8,43 , whereby it is difficult to isolate their individual contributions to the observed behavior. This also holds for the pH-dependent current peak shift, which is most obvious for the cyclic voltammograms shown in Fig. 6d-f. Although the peak shift towards lower potentials upon increasing the pH suggests simultaneous charge transfer and protonation, the complexity of the current response makes it rather difficult to determine the proton-to-electron ratio associated with the corresponding voltammetric peaks observed in the cyclic voltammograms.
Just like the obvious spectroscopic (and clearly visual) differences between the reaction products obtained from PADPA and TvL/O 2 in the presence of AOT vesicles and the ones obtained without AOT, the electrochemical behavior of the two poly(PADPA) products differs to a great extent. While the cyclic voltammogram of the poly(PADPA)-AOT products at pH = 1.14 corresponds well to the cyclic voltammograms of "standard" PANIs, the cyclic voltammogram of poly(PADPA) obtained without vesicles at the same pH is quite different, showing two very close oxidation peaks, which almost merged into one. The CV results thus support findings from Raman spectroscopy regarding the positive template effect of AOT vesicles on the formation of conductive PANI-ES-like poly(PADPA) products. The redox activity of poly(PADPA) obtained in the presence of AOT vesicles was preserved even at pH = 6.00, (Fig. 6c,f) which is a rather important finding because, usually, PANI loses its electro-activity at pH > 5 46 . For poly(PADPA) synthesized in the template-free system, the redox activity was lost already at pH = 3.04 (Fig. 6, third row), in contrast to the products obtained with vesicles which retained their redox activity also at pH = 6.00. These differences are likely due to the lower protonation level of poly(PADPA) in the template-free system, and also to a much lower conductivity, as compared to poly(PADPA) obtained in the presence of AOT vesicles. This is in agreement with the EPR and Raman spectroscopy measurements which both indicate a higher radical content in poly(PADPA) obtained in the presence of the vesicles, as compared to the reaction products obtained without vesicles, see above. Hence, the CV measurements clearly show that the presence of AOT vesicles is beneficial for the preservation of the redox activity of poly(PADPA) products at high Scientific RepoRts | 6:30724 | DOI: 10.1038/srep30724 pH. This is an important property for possible applications in which electrodes are coated with a conductive organic material [47][48][49][50][51] .

Conclusions
We have shown that in situ Raman spectroscopy measurements are very suitable-and complementary to UV/vis/ NIR and EPR measurements-for following the Trametes versicolor laccase-catalyzed oxidation and oligomerization of PADPA in aqueous media consisting of stable dispersed vesicles. The reaction intermediates and products remain finely dispersed throughout the reaction which allows for easy and highly reproducible measurements without any need for forming films on a solid surface. Due to the complexity of the reaction mixtures investigated, the recorded Raman spectra show complex band patterns, which reflects the various structural units formed during the reaction in the vicinity of the vesicle surface. This complexity makes a complete and unambiguous band assignment difficult, and one has to rely on previous, currently accepted, assignments done on related samples 33 . Nevertheless, all four methods presented here clearly confirm the positive effect the vesicles have-if applied under optimal reaction conditions (Fig. 2)-on the progress and outcome of the reaction. The main conclusions which can be drawn from our investigation are the following: (i). There is one main radical type in the poly(PADPA) products obtained in the presence of the vesicles (Fig. 3d) which evolves during the reaction at the expenses of another radical species which dominates at the very early stage of the reaction (most probably PADPA •+ ). Without vesicles, the radical content in the products obtained is much lower 1 (EPR spectroscopy measurements).   -(a,b,c), or (ii) by direct drop-casting of the AOT-containing PADPA polymerization system (second row-(d,e,f) and the PADPA polymerization system without AOT vesicles (third row-(g). For the experimental conditions for the synthesis of poly(PADPA), see the legend of Fig. 3. Voltammograms were recorded in quiescent N 2 -purged solutions of different pH values (first column pH = 1.14, second column pH = 3.04, and third column pH = 6.00) at a common polarization rate of 20 mV s −1 .
several additional bands in the Raman spectrum of the final poly(PADPA) product-most likely originating from phenazine and/or phenoxazine-type units-indicate that its molecular structure is somewhat different from (e.g., more complex than) the molecular structure of PANI-ES prepared chemically with APS (ammonium peroxydisulfate). Clearly, "as-obtained" poly(PADPA) is different from PANI-ES prepared chemically with APS ( Supplementary Fig. S5, Raman spectroscopy measurements). (iv). During the isolation of poly(PADPA) from the poly(PADPA)-AOT vesicle suspension, chemical reactions seem to take place which lead to modifications of the product(s). This is important to keep in mind if the physical properties of solid, isolated poly(PADPA)-AOT products 52,53 are compared with the physical properties of "as-obtained" products. (v). The "as-obtained" poly(PADPA)-vesicle suspension can be used directly for coating glassy carbon electrodes (drop-casting), whereby the adsorbed poly(PADPA) products are redox active, as expected for PANI-ESlike products (CV measurements). At pH = 1.14, the cyclic voltammogram of poly(PADPA)-AOT products is very similar to the cyclic voltammograms of conductive 'standard' PANIs, thus supporting the results of Raman spectroscopy regarding the positive template effect of AOT vesicles on the formation of conductive PANI-ES-like poly(PADPA) products. In addition, the redox activity of poly(PADPA) produced with vesicles is preserved at higher pH values, up to the upper limit of the investigated pH range of pH = 6.00, unlike conventional PANI-ES which completely loses its redox activity at pH > 5 46 or even 4 54 and unlike poly(PADPA) produced without vesicles which loses its redox activity already at pH = 3.0.
A final challenge is to determine more precisely the chemical structure of poly(PADPA). This includes the molar masses, a final proof of the expected para-coupling of the PADPA repeating units-as they are expected to be present in PANI-ES-and a verification/disproof of the presence of phenazines and/or phenoxazine -type units, as suggested from the Raman spectroscopy analysis (see above). Work towards reaching this goal by using a detailed HPLC analysis in combination with mass spectrometry is in progress. More from an application point of view, the suitability of the direct use of the "as obtained" poly(PADPA)/AOT vesicle suspension for bioelectrode fabrication needs to be investigated. At least with respect to the first CV results obtained in this work, it seems appropriate to continue research in this field, and to compare the advantages and disadvantages of the PANI-ES-like poly(PADPA)-as obtained from PADPA in the present work with TvL/O 2 and AOT vesicles-with, for example, PANI-ES as obtained from aniline with horseradish peroxidase isoenzyme C/H 2 O 2 and the same type of vesicles 55 , even though we know that in this latter case much more enzyme is required for the synthesis than in the case of TvL/O 2 and PADPA 1 .
The Raman spectroscopy analysis we present here is the first one for a vesicle-assisted enzymatic polymerization reaction. There is no doubt that the type of in situ Raman spectroscopy measurements shown here can also be used in the future for investigating other similar enzymatic polymerizations with vesicles as structure-directing agent. This will allow a direct comparison among related enzymatic systems.

PADPA Stock Solutions.
Two different PADPA stock solutions were prepared, one (1.5 mM) by using the pH = 3.5 solution, the other (150 mM) by using ethanol. For the in situ Raman and UV/vis/NIR spectroscopy measurements, the 1.5 mM PADPA solution was used (always freshly prepared for the day of use). In order to dissolve the PADPA in the pH = 3.5 solution, the required amount of purified PADPA was first dispersed in the pH = 3.5 solution, and the resulting suspension was shaken vigorously for ca. 30 min, placed in an ultrasound bath (Bandelin Sonorex RK 100 H) for 15 min, and subsequently shaken vigorously for another 15 min. The pH value was then adjusted to pH = 3.5 with the necessary amount of a 1 M H 3 PO 4 solution. Reactions carried out by using this aqueous 1.5 mM PADPA stock solution are referred to as conventional method (see below). For the EPR measurements, a stock solution of PADPA (150 mM) in ethanol was prepared, of which the necessary amount was directly added to the reaction mixture (injection method).

TvL Stock Solution.
A TvL stock solution was prepared by dissolving 12.92 mg of the commercial laccase product in 1 ml of water by vortexing, followed by 2 min of centrifugation at 16,000 rpm (Eppendorf centrifuge 5415 D) and subsequent removal of the supernatant. With the analytical method described previously 6 , the concentration of TvL in the stock solution (the supernatant) was found to be ≈ 16 μ M. This solution can be stored in the refrigerator at T ≈ 4 °C for up to 1 month without significant loss in laccase activity.

AOT Vesicles Preparation.
Large unilamellar vesicles were prepared by polycarbonate membrane extrusion 1 . A weighted sample of 0.178 g AOT was dissolved in a small amount (typically ca. 10 ml) of chloroform in a 250 ml glass round-bottomed flask. The chloroform was slowly removed on a rotary evaporator, thus producing a thin film of the AOT on the glass surface. The film was dried on high vacuum overnight and subsequently suspended in 20 ml of the pH = 3.5 solution to form the AOT stock solution with [AOT] = 20 mM. The resulting suspension underwent 10 freeze-thaw cycles in liquid nitrogen and a 60 °C water bath. Finally, the suspension was extruded 5 times through a Nucleopore ® polycarbonate membrane with a 200 nm pore size and 10 times through a polycarbonate membrane with a 100 nm pore size. The vesicles were subsequently characterized by dynamic light scattering (DLS) and were determined to have an average diameter of about 80-100 nm 56 . They were stored at room temperature and protected from light and used within one month after preparation.
Reaction of PADPA with TvL/O 2 in the Presence and Absence of AOT Vesicles. The reaction of PADPA with TvL/O 2 was always conducted by first adding into a reaction flask the pH = 3.5 solution, then the AOT vesicle suspension (20 mM), then the PADPA stock solution (1.5 mM in the pH = 3.5 solution or 150 mM in ethanol), and finally the aqueous TvL stock solution (≈ 16 μ M) to initiate the reaction. For the template-free reaction without vesicles, the vesicle stock suspension was replaced with the corresponding volume of the pH = 3.5 solution. We found that the kinetics of the reaction may depend on the type and geometry of the reaction vessel and the dimension of the surface area of the reaction volume which is in contact with air. Therefore, all reactions, which were analyzed by in situ measurements using UV/vis/NIR, EPR and Raman spectroscopy were carried out in the same way. Typically, a 50 mL Schott Duran ® laboratory glass bottle was used with a reaction volume, V rxn , of 10 mL. During the reaction, the bottle was kept closed with a polypropylene screw cap in order to avoid evaporation of water and the concomitant concentration changes. The reaction was carried out in two different ways, either with the method we used previously (conventional method), or with the injection method. Both methods yielded the same UV/vis/NIR spectra. For the 10 mL reaction volume with the conventional method, 2.56 mL of the pH = 3.5 solution was added to the bottle, then 0.75 mL of the AOT vesicles suspension, then 6.67 mL of the 1. In situ UV/vis/NIR Spectroscopy Measurements. UV/vis/NIR spectroscopy measurements were conducted on a Jasco-V670 spectrophotometer. Quartz cuvettes with a 1 mm path length (Helma Analytics) were used for all measurements. The background suspension consisted of the AOT vesicles ([AOT] = 1.5 mM) in the pH = 3.5 solution. After initiation of the reaction with TvL (conventional method), 300 μ L samples of the reaction mixture were removed from the reaction mixture at predetermined times, measured, and then discarded.
In situ EPR Spectroscopy Measurements. The EPR spectra were recorded with a Bruker EMX X-band spectrometer (Bruker BioSpin, Rheinstetten, Germany) at room temperature, equipped with a cylindrical TM (transverse magnetic) cavity. Ca. 1 mL (with a Pasteur pipette) of the reaction mixture (V rxn = 10 mL, injection method) was transferred into a EPR flat cell (Wilmad Labglass, Vineland NJ, USA) immediately after starting the reaction, i.e. after adding TvL, as well as after predetermined time (up to 2 h). For the measurements without vesicles, a small DPPH crystal (< 1 mm in diameter) was attached to the flat cell with a scotch tape at the position of the measurement window. Since the g-value of DPPH is known with great precision (g = 2.0036 ± 0.0001) 57 , the EPR signal of DPPH was used for calibrating the determination of the g-value of the signals of radical centers present in poly(PADPA) and in reaction intermediates. The spectra were measured at ≈ 9.7 GHz with a modulation frequency of 100 kHz and modulation amplitudes of 1 G. The spectra recorded in the presence of the vesicles were fitted by using the software Easyspin 58 , assuming that the measured spectra are composed of only two major individual spectra originating from two different radical species. Please note that in our previous EPR measurements, the reactions analyzed were run in 5 mL polypropylene Eppendorf tubes (V rxn = 1 mL), see Junker et al. 1 . The general behavior with respect to the outcome of the reaction was the same if compared to the reaction carried out in the way used for the present work (50 mL Schott Duran ® laboratory glass bottle, V rxn , of 10 mL). There are, however, differences between the two systems if the reaction kinetics is compared. Therefore, the EPR measurements presented in this work can not be compared directly with the EPR data presented previously 1 .
In situ Raman Spectroscopy Measurements. The Raman spectra were recorded with a DXR Raman microscope (Thermo Scientific, Waltham MA, USA), equipped with a research optical microscope and a CCD detector. A HeNe gas laser with an excitation wavelength of 633 nm was used for all measurements. The in situ Raman spectra of the reaction products were recorded by withdrawing 5 μ L aliquots of the reaction mixtures (prepared with the conventional method) from the reaction vessel at specified reaction times and transferring them into sample wells at the sample platform (Gold EZ-Spot Micro Mount sample slide, Thermo Scientific), both for reactions run in the presence and in the absence of AOT vesicles. Each spectrum was measured for a new "drop" of the reaction mixture taken from the reaction vessel ('macroreactor') and transferred into the empty and clean sample well ('microreactor'), Supplementary Fig. S8. Thus, since there was no interrupting of the polymerization reaction for the purpose of Raman measurements, i.e., the spectra of the reaction mixture were recorded during the reaction without isolation of reaction products and changing reaction conditions, these measurements are considered as in situ Raman measurements. After filling the well with the sample of the reaction mixture, the slide with the sample was placed on an X-Y motorized sample stage and the laser beam was focused on the sample at an objective magnification of 10× . The scattered light was analyzed by the spectrograph with a 600 lines mm −1 grating. The laser power on the sample was kept at 5.0 mW for the spectra of the various reaction components measured before the reaction (Supplementary Fig. S2). For the spectra of the samples of the reaction mixture recorded during the reaction with vesicles (Fig. 4) the laser power was 4.0 mW, and for the spectra recorded during the reaction without vesicles (Fig. 5), the laser power was 2.0 mW and 4.0 mW for reaction times before and after 120 min, respectively. The spectra were recorded about 30 s after transferring the sample drop from the reaction flask into the sample wells. The exposure time was 10 s and 10 exposures per spectrum were applied. In the cases with high fluorescence background, automatic fluorescence correction was performed using the OMNIC software.
Poly(PADPA) Product Isolation. After 24 h reaction time with V rxn = 30 ml in a 100 ml Schott Duran ® laboratory glass bottle (injection method), the final products were isolated by extracting them from the reaction mixture with methyl-tert-butylether (MTBE). Multiple extraction steps were needed. MTBE was removed in vacuo, followed by treating the dried products with 1 M HCl to ensure protonation. Excess HCl was removed, and the products were washed with water by repeated centrifugation and removal of supernatant.
Raman Spectroscopy Measurements of Isolated Poly(PADPA). Raman spectra of solid poly(PADPA) products, isolated from the reaction mixtures and purified, were also recorded. These powdered samples were placed on an X-Y motorized sample stage and the laser beam was focused on the sample at an objective magnification × 50. The excitation wavelength and the spectrograph grating were the same as for the in situ Raman measurements, but the laser power on the sample was 0.2-0.5 mW.
Cyclic Voltammetry Measurements. The redox activity of the poly(PADPA) products was probed by using cyclic voltammetry (CV) in two different ways. First, the redox activity of isolated poly(PADPA) was measured upon modification of a glassy carbon (GC) disk electrode with a solid film of isolated product. The modification was done as follows: 2.5 mg of poly(PADPA) and 1.1 mg Vulcan XC-72 R (conductive carbon black from Cabot, USA) were dispersed in 500 μ L of a water/ethanol mixture (3:2 v/v) with the addition of 20 μ L of a 5 wt.% Nafion ® solution in ethanol and homogenized in an ultrasonic bath. Vulcan XC-72 R was added as a current collector and to increase the conductivity of the poly(PADPA) layer as done previously 59 . After homogenization, 10 μ L of the poly(PADPA) suspension was loaded onto a GC disk (Pine, USA; 5 mm in diameter) and dried in N 2 gas flow. Such a prepared electrode was transferred into an electrochemical cell and subjected to potential cycling. In this way, a total mass of 48 μ g of poly(PADPA) product was loaded onto the working GC electrode.
In the second set of the experiments, the redox activity of the poly(PADPA) product was probed by direct drop-casting of the reaction mixture on the working GC electrode without isolation of the reaction product and without the addition of Vulcan XC-72R or any other electronically conductive component. Upon completion of the enzymatic polymerization (5 days), 15 μ L of the reaction mixture was drop-casted on the surface of the GC disk electrode and dried under N 2 gas flow. Such a prepared electrode was transferred into the electrochemical cell and subjected to potential cycling. In this way, a total mass of 2.76 μ g of PADPA units (referred to the initial concentration in the reaction mixture) was loaded on the working GC electrode.
CV measurements were done in a conventional one-compartment glass electrochemical cell with a saturated calomel electrode (SCE) and a large Pt foil as reference and counter electrodes, respectively. Measurements were performed using the Gamry PCI4-750 potentiostat (Gamry, USA) at room temperature. The CV measurements were always started from cathodic potentials which depended on the pH of the electrolyte solution. 0.1 M HCl (pH = 1.14), 1 mM HCl + 0.1 M KCl (pH = 3.04) and 0.1 M sodium phosphate buffer (pH = 6.00) were used as supporting electrolytes. Prior to the deposition of the poly(PADPA) product on the GC electrode, the disk was polished to a mirror finish using a diamond paste, followed by thorough washing with acetone and deionized water.