Erratum: Griffiths phase behaviour in a frustrated antiferromagnetic intermetallic compound

The rare coexistence of a Griffiths phase (GP) and a geometrically frustrated antiferromagnetism in the non-stoichiometric intermetallic compound GdFe0.17Sn2 (the paramagnetic Weiss temperature θp ~ −59 K) is reported in this work. The compound forms in the Cmcm space group with large structural anisotropy (b/c ~ 4). Interestingly, all the atoms in the unit cell possess the same point group symmetry (Wycoff position 4c), which is rather rare. The frustration parameter, f = |θp|/TN has been established as 3.6, with the Néel temperature TN and Griffiths temperature TG being 16.5 and 32 K, respectively. The TG has been determined from the heat capacity measurement and also from the magnetocaloric effect (MCE). It is also shown that substantial difference in GP region may exist between zero field and field cooled measurements - a fact hitherto not emphasized so far.

interaction caused by the varying bong lengths affects the long range magnetic order throughout the sample, but are expected to be found in many microscopically small regions inside the samples. According to the Griffiths model, the disorder driven random distribution of magnetic interactions result in different sets of exchange constants for different lattice points throughout the material 1,17 . RETM x Sn 2 (x < 1) compounds that have the similar characteristics, therefore appear to be potential candidates for observing a GP. In the case of REFe x Sn 2 series (RE = Tb -Tm), it was shown earlier through neutron diffraction experiments that in addition to A-or C-type AFM ordering (favourable to a GP in AFM systems), the systems also have a sizeable number of frustrated rare earth ions, that ensures |θ | > T p N 18 . In our quest to search for GP in a GFM intermetallic system, we have synthesized and studied the magnetic properties of GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 , a material that satisfies most of the above mentioned criteria. The Gd-based system (L = 0) was chosen due to its negligible magnetic anisotropy resulting from the higher order exchange interaction 19 .

Results and Discussion
The powder x-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns taken at room temperature of GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 were analyzed by considering that the material has a CeNiSi 2 -type orthorhombic structure (space group: Cmcm). All the peaks in the XRD pattern could be indexed using this space group (Fig. 1, bottom). The lattice parameters, a = 4.443(1)Å, b = 16.43(1)Å and c = 4.371 (1)Å are close to that reported earlier for GdFe 0.17(2) Sn 2 16 . However, the full Rietveld analysis, allowing the variation of occupancy factor of Fe and Sn atoms, suggests the actual composition to be GdFe 0. 19 Sn 1.93 . We find the average interatomic distances Fe-Sn1 (d1) as 0.9 Å, Fe-Sn2 (d2) as 3.1 Å and the angle Sn1-Fe-Sn2 as 135.2° (Fig. 2). In isostructural stoichiometric CeNiSi 2 , we find that the Ni-Si1 and Ni-Si2, distances are nearly identical, close to 2.31 Å. The Sn1-Fe-Sn2 angle in GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 is also found to be quite stretched in comparison to that found in CeNiSi 2 , where the Si1-Ni-Si2 angle is close to 117.7°2 0 . Shorter average interatomic distances (Fe-Sn1) generally reflect the presence of vacancies (Fe and/or Sn) in the crystal structure, and earlier reported in quite a few RETM x Sn 2 series of compounds (TM-Sn ~ 2-2.5 Å) 12,21 . The scanning electron microscope (SEM) picture ( Fig. 1; (bottom: inset)) and energy dispersive analysis of X-ray (EDAX) suggest an essentially single phase nature with average composition as GdFe 0.19 Sn 1.91 which is close to the value obtained through Rietveld analysis. The diffraction patterns taken at lower temperatures do not suggest any major structural phase transformation ( Fig. 1; top). The magnetic susceptibility (χ) measurements (2-300 K) under the influence of external magnetic field, in excess of 5 kOe, suggest that the compound orders magnetically at ~16.5 K (Fig. 3). The negative value of θ p (− 59 K), estimated from inverse magnetic susceptibility in the paramagnetic region and the absence of spontaneous magnetization in the Arrott plot (M 2 vs. H/M) 22 (Fig. 4; inset (b)), suggest that GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 orders antiferromagnetically at T N ~ 16.5 K. The isothermal magnetizations measured below T N , do not exhibit any hysteresis behaviour and have a near linear magnetic field dependence, as expected for an AFM system ( Fig. 4) (Fig. 4; inset (a)).
The estimated value of frustration parameter, f = |θ p |/T N = 3.6, suggests that this compound is a frustrated magnetic system ( Fig. 3; inset(a)), as per the criterion suggested by A. P. Ramirez 23 . This magnetic frustration has its origin in the crystal structure itself. In the CeNiSi 2 -type crystal structure, the rare earth ions are arranged as infinite sheets of face-sharing RE 6 trigonal prisms, and also as RE 4 tetrahedrons stretched along [010] 18 . The neutron diffraction measurements on REFe x Sn 2 (RE = Tb -Tm, 0.1 < x < 0.15) had earlier established an A-(or C-) type AFM structure where some of the rare earth ions occupying the position of the trigonal faces of the prism and/or in the tetrahedron exhibiting frustration of the magnetic moments [see Fig. 4 18]. This is in agreement with the fact that these compounds also have frustration parameter f ~ 2-3 18 , similar to that observed in GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 . Temperature dependence of heat capacity in absence of any magnetic field is shown using the left side axis. The anomaly observed due to GP transition can be observed more clearly by taking derivative of the heat capacity around T G as shown using the right hand axis of the inset.
Scientific RepoRts | 5:15801 | DOi: 10.1038/srep15801 The origin of magnetic frustration in REFe x Sn 2 (RE = Tb -Tm, 0.1 < x < 0.15) primarily depends on the crystal structure. Therefore GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 , being in the same crystallographic structure, is also expected to possess geometrically frustrated magnetic moments. The magnetic structure of GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 , however, has not be directly checked using neutron diffraction technique due to the large cross-section of neutron absorption of Gd.
The value of effective magnetic moment per formula unit (μ eff ) calculated from the inverse magnetic susceptibility in the paramagnetic range found to be 8.19μ B which is slightly higher than that of free Gd 3+ -ions (7.94μ B ). One may attribute the origin of larger moment as due to the Fe atoms present in this compound. Here, it may be noted that the values of μ eff for all other members of the series REFe x Sn 2 (RE = Tb -Tm, 0.1 < x < 0.15) are also reported to be higher than that of their corresponding free ion values, where neutron diffraction measurements failed to detect any ordered moment of Fe 18 . Additionally, GdSn 2 that forms in the same space group (Cmcm), also exhibits μ eff of similar magnitude (8.16μ B ) 24 . Therefore, in our opinion, the slightly larger value in μ eff observed in our compound might originate from the positive polarization of conduction electrons 24 , or as A. P. Ramirez suggested, due to the reduction of moment density (resulting in an increase of effective magnetic moment) generally found in frustrated magnetic systems 23 .
The susceptibility (χ), however, measured at a field lower than 5 kOe, both in zero field cooled (ZFC) and field cooled (FC) configuration suggests the presence of another anomaly around 32 K ( Fig. 3; inset (b)). The field cooled magnetic susceptibilities do not show any remanence while measuring during cooling (FCC) and subsequent warming (FCW) ( Fig. 3; inset (b)). We first discuss the magnetic susceptibility measurements in FC configuration. The ZFC measurement and presence of thermoremanent behaviour in low field will be discussed later.
The inverse FC magnetic susceptibility (H < 5 kOe), in the paramagnetic region (T > T N ) shows a downward deviation from linearity below a temperature, T G ~ 32 K ( Fig. 3; I). As the applied external magnetic field increases gradually from 10 Oe onwards, the extent of deviation in magnetic susceptibility systematically diminishes until a Curie-Weiss (CW) behaviour is observed down to T N , for a field in excess of 5 kOe ( Fig. 3; I). The deviation from CW behaviour at a low measuring field, while approaching the ordering temperature (T C or T N ) from above (at T G ), may be attributed due to the presence of small clusters in addition to the paramagnetic matrix. The downward deviation in χ −1 (T) results from an enhancement in χ due to the contribution from the FM clusters. The deviation is suppressed in large magnetic field due to the polarization of spins outside the clusters. To establish the presence of magnetic clusters in GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 , we have also performed spin relaxation measurements by studying the Isothermal Remanent Magnetization (IRM) in the GP region. The magnetization exhibits a relaxation behaviour, that can only be fitted well using a stretched exponential form, Fig. 3; inset (c)), often observed in the systems containing magnetic clusters 25,26 . This FM-like anomaly at 32 K cannot be attributed to the structurally related compound GdSn 2 , even if it is present in our compound below the resolution limit of XRD, as it orders antiferromagnetically at 27 K 24 . It may be noted here, in the case of ThFe 0.2 Sn 2 , the cross-substitution effect of different constituent elements had been categorically ruled out through the 57 Fe and 119 Sn Mössbauer spectroscopy measurements 10 . It is therefore quite unlikely that any such cross-substitution would occur in the isostructural GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 system as well. Thus, the anomaly at 32 K appear to be an inherent characteristic of GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 . The phenomena observed in the magnetic susceptibility of GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 can be explained using a model proposed by Griffiths 1 . In the GP model, the long-range ordering temperature, T C (x), of a randomly diluted ferromagnet will be lower than the same of the undiluted one ( ) T C undiluted . The thermodynamic properties (e.g. magnetization) will be non-analytical in this region ( ( ) < < ) x T T T C undiluted C due to the formation of a low density clusters with short-range ordering. Here T C undiluted is the temperature at which this GP forms and is popularly known as the Griffiths temperature (T G ). The temperature range between T C and T G corresponds to a GP, and this GP is different from the paramagnetic as well as the long-range FM phase. Though the typical behaviour of a GP are already reported in several compounds 5,8,17,27 , the direct confirmation of GP in any system is really a difficult task 17 .
One indirect way to confirm whether the short-range FM correlations observed in the PM state can be ascribed to the GP is the deviation of magnetic susceptibility for T < < T G . χ −1 in such case should generally follow power law behaviour describing the Griffith singularity 28 where λ is the magnetic susceptibility exponent, and T C R is the critical temperature of random ferromagnetic clusters where susceptibility tend to diverge. In most of the GP compounds reported so far, the magnetic transition temperature (T G or T N ) and T C R found to be very close 5,17,29,30 . However, for an AFM system, where θ p < T N , one is constrained to test the validity of the power law behaviour close to T N only, instead of a region close to T C R . However, in cases where θ | |/ > T 1 p N and T N ~ T G , i.e., is quite high (> 0.5), the temperature region available for testing the applicability of this power law turns out to be closer to T G , than to T C R , and in such cases, the above mentioned power law cannot be applied. The large value of (T N - .83, estimated in the case of GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 , restricts the applicability of the above mentioned power law behaviour in the present case. Although we also observed that the behaviour of χ −1 (T) in the temperature range, T N < T < T G , is similar to GP, or more accurately, a system having FM clusters in a temperature range above the long range magnetic ordering temperature. It may be noted here that the only other oxide GFM that also exhibits GP behaviour, Ca 3 CoMnO 6 , has similar values of f (~3.8), θ p (− 50 K) and T N (~13 K), but the much larger value of T G (~125 K) ensures that eq. (1) can be applicable close to T N in that compound 8 , unlike in the present case of GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 . In order to demonstrate the existence of a GP in our system, we should look into the possible reason behind the formation of such clusters. In GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 , only 17% of the transition metal-sites are randomly occupied with Fe atoms and the rest are vacant. This creates a local disorder in the crystal structure. As mentioned earlier, the presence of these vacancies are also reflected in the estimated shortened average bond lengths 12,21 . The random presence of vacancies in the transition metal site decreases the Gd 3+ -Gd 3+ interionic distance locally 11 and thereby introduces a random spatial variation of the exchange interaction (J) in the bonds between Gd 3+ ions on a regular lattice 31 . This results in the coexistence of two phases with different J values within the same crystalline phase. In the first phase, the Fe-sites are vacant and this forms the major phase, while the minor phase, containing Fe atoms at the transition metal-sites, are randomly distributed within the major phase 12 . Similar coexistence of magnetic phases has already been observed in isostructural CeNi 0.84 Sn 2 32 . In the original work of Griffiths, it was shown that, if a great enough fraction, x > x c , of the bonds of a ferromagnet have J = 0, then a GP will form in the temperature range, T C < T < T G , with non-analytic free energy in an external magnetic field. The observation of a GP is possible in a system where the random disorder results in random spatial variation of J. The effect of disorder is to partition the pure system into small FM clusters. The disorder also needs to be quenched 25 . The disorder is quenched in our system also, since the Fe atoms occupying the transition metal sites are fixed in the lattice. In GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 , it will be therefore justified to associate the major phase having vacant Fe-sites with long range AFM ordered state. The minor phase results from the random dilution of the AFM exchange interaction and is distributed in isolated small-sized FM clusters having positive J value. It may be pertinent to note here that in case of perovskite ruthenates, the variation of bond angle are argued to be responsible for observation of a GP 33 . Thus, intermetallic GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 appear to be one of the rare breed of compounds, apart from the oxide Ca 3 CoMnO 6 , to exhibit GP characteristics in an otherwise GFM material.
In order to study the change in magnetic entropy, if any, due to the FM ordering of such a small volume fraction of material, we have also made a careful study of the heat capacity as well as the magnetocaloric effect (MCE) close to T G . The heat capacity of GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 shows a large peak around 15.9 K, close to T N ( Fig. 3; inset (d)). The magnetic contribution to entropy at T N , estimated from the heat capacity data, is found to be only ~1.7R, instead of the theoretically expected value of 2.09R (R = universal gas constant). The reduced value of magnetic entropy suggests that nearly 20% of Gd-ions do not take part in long range ordering. Surprisingly, we find that the magnetic entropy associated with FM clusters in the GP, however insignificant, also leaves its imprint in heat capacity results, exhibiting a discernible anomaly close to T G ~ 32 K (Fig. 3; inset ( The presence of FM-like spins within the clusters can also be confirmed through low field MCE measurements, that tracks the associated entropy change due to GP ordering. Although the volume fraction responsible for the GP is small, nevertheless the isothermal magnetic entropy (Δ S M ) measured at low field, unambiguously show a reduction in value below T G (Fig. 5). The values of Δ S M have been calculated from magnetization isotherms using the Maxwell thermodynamic relation, Close to T G , Δ S M (T) exhibits an well-defined peak, often seen in materials with ferromagnetic type ordering. Similar to the reduction in excess magnetization below T G with the increase of magnetic field, the peak in MCE also gets suppressed for a magnetic field larger than 5 kOe ( Fig. 5; inset). To the best of our knowledge, probing of a GP through MCE has not been reported earlier in literature.
We now focus on the ZFC magnetization measurement, which particularly at very low field, exhibit a markedly different nature to that which was commonly observed in FC measurements. While the FC magnetization tends to saturate at lower temperature (T N < T < T G ), the low field ZFC measurements yield very small moment values, that rise with increasing temperature until reaching some maximum value below T G , and then follow the FC susceptibility for higher temperatures (inverse susceptibility as shown in Fig. 3; II). As the applied magnetic field strength increases gradually, the thermoremanence decreases, and for magnetic fields higher than 500 Oe, the thermoremanence becomes barely discernible. Such thermoremanence behaviour are generally reported in spin-glass type compounds due to the presence of metastable states 34 or in anisotropic ferromagnets 35 due to the competing interactions of magnetic coupling energy and anisotropy energy. Although a few GP compounds, e.g., Gd 5 Ge 4 , have also been reported to exhibit thermoremanent behaviour 5 , such a strikingly different behaviour of ZFC and FC magnetization has not been reported earlier for any GP compound. Our result thus shows that the typical signature of GP, generally observed through FC measurements, may yield different character when measured in ZFC configuration.
In conclusion, we have shown that the intermetallic compound GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 can be considered as a unique system that orders antiferromagnetically with geometric frustration (f = |θ p |/T N = 3.6), and exhibits features similar to that observed in a GP. Only one oxide compound, Ca 3 CoMnO 6 , has been reported earlier to have similar features 8 . We have found that the variation of magnetic susceptibility with field in the GP region may depend considerably on the measurement protocol, i.e., ZFC and FC measurements, due to the metastable states of the spins involved in the GP. Such magnetic thermoremanent behaviour had not been reported earlier in any GP compounds. We have also shown that beside the magnetic susceptibility, GP ordering temperature can also be probed through both the MCE as well as the heat capacity measurements.

Methods
A number of polycrystalline compounds having nominal composition GdFe 0.17 Sn 2 were melted in a water cooled arc furnace in the flowing argon atmosphere. The samples were melted several times to ensure homogeneity. The resultant ingots were then wrapped in Ta-foil and annealed under vacuum at 800 °C for 15 days. Powder x-ray diffraction (XRD) measurements were performed in the temperature range of 12-300 K using a 18 kW rotating anode diffractometer (Model: TTRAX-III, M/s Rigaku Corp., Japan). The single phase nature as well as lattice parameters were ensured through the Rietveld refinement The magnetic entropy measured at higher magnetic fields. analysis using FULLPROF software 36 . Magnetic [M (T, H, time)] and heat capacity (in the absence of external magnetic field) measurements were performed in the temperature range 2-300 K using a commercial SQUID-VSM and PPMS Evercool-II (M/s Quantum Design Inc., USA). The Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM) (S-3400N: M/s Hitachi, Japan) and energy dispersive analysis of X-ray (EDAX) (M/s Thermo Electron Corp. USA) measurements were also performed to check the spatial homogeneity and elemental composition of the system. The Isothermal Remanent Magnetization (IRM) measurements were carried out using the following protocol: the sample was cooled in the absence of magnetic field (H = 0) from room temperature to a temperature (25 K) below T G . Then, with a waiting time t w = 0 sec, the magnetic field was switched on and allowed to reach a value of 50 kOe. Once the magnetic field reaches 50 kOe, the field was switched off after t w = 0 sec. As soon as the magnetic field diminishes to 0, the time dependence magnetization measurement was carried out, again after t w = 0 sec.