Corrigendum: Identification of novel alleles of the rice blast resistance gene Pi54

Rice blast is one of the most devastating rice diseases and continuous resistance breeding is required to control the disease. The rice blast resistance gene Pi54 initially identified in an Indian cultivar confers broad-spectrum resistance in India. We explored the allelic diversity of the Pi54 gene among 885 Indian rice genotypes that were found resistant in our screening against field mixture of naturally existing M. oryzae strains as well as against five unique strains. These genotypes are also annotated as rice blast resistant in the International Rice Genebank database. Sequence-based allele mining was used to amplify and clone the Pi54 allelic variants. Nine new alleles of Pi54 were identified based on the nucleotide sequence comparison to the Pi54 reference sequence as well as to already known Pi54 alleles. DNA sequence analysis of the newly identified Pi54 alleles revealed several single polymorphic sites, three double deletions and an eight base pair deletion. A SNP-rich region was found between a tyrosine kinase phosphorylation site and the nucleotide binding site (NBS) domain. Together, the newly identified Pi54 alleles expand the allelic series and are candidates for rice blast resistance breeding programs.

multiple other blast resistance genes. Several of these genes also exist in multiple copy numbers, serving as evidence for the natural selection-driven R gene diversification 17,18 . Moreover, minor sequence variations among blast R genes, such as the presence of a few single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), lead to major differences in their function or resistance spectrum. For instance, only few amino acid changes among the predicted proteins of blast resistance genes Pi2, Pi9 and Piz-t determine their resistance specificities 19 , with each of them conferring broad-spectrum resistance against different rice blast isolates 20 . In addition to the resistance spectrum difference among individual blast resistance genes, different allelic forms of major R genes also often have varied specificities. For example, a single amino acid change differentiates the resistant and susceptible alleles of rice blast resistance genes Pita and Pid2 21,22 . Likewise, alleles of the powdery mildew resistance Pm3 gene in wheat exhibit different resistance patterns against a range of powdery mildew isolates [23][24][25] . Combining such alleles of a major R gene in a single genetic background or through multiline approach is a possible strategy to improve resistance in the field 26,27 . The presence of multiple allelic forms might reduce the selection pressure on the pathogen, thereby increasing the durability of resistance 5 . In addition, intragenic pyramiding that combines the specificities of different alleles is an alternative to broaden the recognition spectrum as compared to the parental alleles 25 . This has been successfully demonstrated in the case of Pm3 where the specificities of Pm3d and Pm3e were combined into a single allele. Moreover, a detailed molecular analysis of such allelic R gene variants facilitated understanding of host-pathogen interactions and evolution of disease resistance genes. Therefore, exploring naturally available genetic diversity for new alleles of resistance genes is an efficient approach for broadening the resistance sources against rice blast.
Seed banks are rich sources of such natural genetic diversity considering their large collections of cultivars, traditional varieties and wild relatives of many crops. This genetic potential can be accessed for identification of novel genes and/or their functional alleles. Several agriculturally relevant genes were obtained from wild relatives and landraces, such as the bacterial blight resistance gene Xa21 from O. longistaminata 28 and various blast resistance genes such as Pi9 from O. minuta 29 , Pid3-A4 from O. rufipogon 30 and Pi-hk1 from a landrace Heikezijing 31 . The available information on molecular markers together with advancement in sequencing technologies can be applied to dissect the molecular diversity of any favourable trait. Sequence based allele mining is one such approach 32 for exploring allelic diversity of major genes controlling important traits such as disease resistance 23 .
Here we report the allelic diversity of a major rice blast resistance gene Pi54 in Indian germplasm. Pi54 (formerly known as Pi-k h ) was first identified in the Indian rice cultivar HR22 and was cloned from the indica type rice cultivar Tetep. The gene confers broad-spectrum resistance against Indian rice blast isolates 33 and is being effectively used in several rice breeding programs in India. Pi54 belongs to the 'Coiled Coil -Nucleotide Binding Site -Leucine Rich Repeats' (CC-NBS-LRR) class of R genes and the protein activates several downstream defence related pathways upon pathogen attack 34 . The new Pi54 alleles that we have identified expand the known Pi54 allelic series and could potentially serve as a genetic resource for breeding or engineering resistance to rice blast.

Results
Selection of rice genotypes for Pi54 allele mining. A set of 885 rice accessions originating from India and found resistant against rice blast, both under natural as well as controlled conditions, were chosen to study the allelic variation of the Pi54 gene (Fig. 1). These accessions were recorded with a resistant phenotypic score of 0-3 against a field mixture of naturally existing M. oryzae strains when screened in the uniform blast nursery (UBN). Under controlled conditions, the selected accessions were found resistant against at least one of the five tested individual blast strains 35 i.e., M101-1-2-9-1, M39-1-2-21-2, JMB8401, M64-1-3-9-1 and Ca41 (Fig. 1). The 885 Indian accessions are also annotated as blast resistant in the International Rice Germplasm Collection Information System (IRGCIS) of the International Rice Genebank (IRG). The selected accessions represent three major varietal groups, indica (87.9%), javanica (8.6%) and japonica (3.5%). They were further screened for the presence of Pi54 using the 'Pi54 MAS' marker 36 , which is a functional co-dominant marker that amplifies a 216 bp fragment if a Pi54 allele is present or a 359 bp fragment if a Pi54 allele is interrupted by a 144 bp insert (often associated with the susceptible phenotype) 36 (Supplementary Fig. S1). A total of 329 accessions showed the presence of the amplified 216 bp product and were selected as the candidates for sequence-based allele mining of Pi54 (Fig. 1, Supplementary Table S1).
Isolation of new allelic forms of Pi54. Following the confirmation using the diagnostic marker 'Pi54 MAS' , the full length coding region of the gene was amplified from all 329 accessions. The primers flanking the start and stop codons as annotated for Pi54 allele from the cultivar Tetep 37 (hereafter, referred as Pi54_Tetep) were used for the sequence based amplification of Pi54 alleles. Detailed analysis of the sequences obtained from these 329 accessions identified eleven alleles of Pi54, based on the comparison with Pi54_Tetep 37 which was also used as a reference sequence to assign domains. The obtained sequences were further compared with already reported Pi54 allelic sequences 4,38-40 specifically for the ORF region as reported for Pi54_Tetep. The allele Pi54_3708 and the previously reported Pi54 alleles from a landrace Satti and the wild rice O. nivara were found identical. Similarly Pi54_40636 was found identical to alleles in the haplogroup-H2 from recently reported Pi54 alleles 39 . The nine new alleles we identified are unique due to the presence of unique SNPs/deletions and/or combination of shared SNPs observed in these alleles (Supplementary Table S2). Figure 2 shows the schematic representation of the sequence alignment of the identified Pi54 alleles to the reference allele Pi54_Tetep. Except for the three alleles Pi54_42439, Pi54_22419 and Pi54_3708 that were exclusively identified in single accessions, each of the remaining eight alleles was identified in several rice accessions (    Table 1). These eleven alleles differed from Pi54_Tetep by a total of 46 nucleotide polymorphisms, three double deletions and a stretch of 8 bp deletions present either uniquely or shared among the different alleles. Pi54_13758 is the only allele with a double deletion in the CC domain. A 'SNP-rich region' with nearly half of the total polymorphisms is found between nucleotides 232 and 429 (Fig. 3a). Five SNPs are present in the NBS domain of which three are synonymous changes (Fig. 2). In case of the LRR domains, one synonymous mutation was found in the Zn finger motif of the LRR1 domain and two non-synonymous mutations were found in both LRR domains, one in each (Fig. 2). All Pi54 alleles have an intact and highly conserved Zinc finger motif with only a single synonymous mutation at position 774. Similarly, the tyrosine kinase phosphorylation site is highly conserved, suggesting the significance of these motifs for Pi54 function. In addition, several post-translational modification (PTM) sites such as 13 casein kinase II (CK2) phosphorylation sites, four N-glycosylation sites, four N-myristoylation sites and three protein kinase C (PKC) phosphorylation sites were predicted in all Pi54 alleles 41 , but their number varied among the alleles because of SNPs and deletions (Table 2). Twenty-nine of the 46 SNPs are shared among all of the alleles except Pi54_3708, which differs from Pi54_Tetep by only 2 SNPs at positions 591 and 795. One of the two SNPs in Pi54_3708 is a synonymous mutation at position 591 that is shared with all other identified Pi54 alleles (i.e., from AAG to AAA; coding for Lysine). Seven alleles have at least one unique SNP (four of them non-synonymous) or deletions specific to that allele but absent in the other Pi54 alleles ( Table 1). The remaining four alleles share the SNPs with the other alleles but in varied combinations that still makes them unique Pi54 alleles. When compared to the recently reported Pi54 alleles, 84% of the polymorphisms observed in these eleven alleles were found to be shared with several other Pi54 alleles, the majority of which were identified in cultivars and landraces reported to be resistant against the diagnostic blast isolate Mo-nwi-37-1 39 . Additionally, several large insertions/ deletions were found in recently reported Pi54 alleles 39 , particularly in those identified from wild rice species, but none of these INDELs were present in the eleven alleles we identified. The presence of these polymorphic yet shared nucleotide changes between alleles indicate frequent sequence exchange between the alleles, possibly by gene conversion.
Nucleotide polymorphism analyses for the eleven Pi54 alleles were performed in DnaSP 42 . The overall nucleotide diversity (π ) of the identified Pi54 alleles was calculated as 0.01551. The sliding window analysis of nucleotide diversity of Pi54 alleles showed a high rate of diversity within the SNP-rich region described above (Fig. 3b). The number of mutations (η -46) and the number of segregations sites (S-46) were the same, suggesting their positive selection. The negative Tajima's D test value (− 0.02431) also suggests that the alleles are under positive selection. However, the ratio of non-synonymous to synonymous substitutions per respective site (k a /k s value = 0.257) does not indicate a strong positive selection.
Analysis of predicted Pi54 proteins. The alleles with a complete ORF based on the Pi54_Tetep reference allele were subjected to protein prediction and analyses. Pi54_Tetep has a NBS domain of 21 amino acids (AA) and two non-synonymous mutations in the NBS domain were found among the studied Pi54 alleles. One of these non-synonymous mutations replaces tyrosine with phenylalanine at   only non-synonymous mutation in LRR1 that replaces leucine with phenylalanine at position 265 is observed in Pi54_3708 exclusively (Supplementary Table S3). The non-synonymous mutation in LRR2 changes threonine to alanine at position 272 and is shared among seven predicted Pi54 protein sequences (Pi54_10202, Pi54_40636, Pi54_22597, Pi54_41818, Pi54_22126, Pi54_40996, and Pi54_42439). The allele Pi54_22419 also has this LRR2-specific mutation but the predicted protein was not analysed because of a two bp deletion in its nucleotide sequence. The 'PredictProtein' server 43 was used to analyse the Pi54 protein sequences of alleles with complete ORFs for secondary structure elements, disordered regions, as well as exposed and buried regions. All analysed Pi54 proteins have predicted disordered regions within their CC domains from position 15 to 36 (Fig. 4a). To predict the surface accessibility of polymorphic AA residues, the Pi54 proteins were subjected to NetSurfP analysis 44 . The majority of the polymorphic residues are exposed and more than half of the predicted exposed residues are located within a PTM site and/or within a specific domain of Pi54 (Fig. 4b) suggesting that these AA changes are likely critical for interaction with M. oryzae effector proteins. A single SNP that replaces methionine with leucine at AA position 214 in 10 out of 11 alleles (except Pi54_3708) results in a predicted imperfect leucine zipper-like pattern (LxxxxxxLxxxxxxLxxxxxxL) but the predicted protein structures of various alleles retain a typical horse shoe-shaped conformation ( Supplementary Fig. S2).

Phylogeny of new Pi54 alleles and their distribution among rice subspecies. Five of the eleven
Pi54 alleles are unique to either indica or javanica subspecies, whereas the remaining alleles (Pi54_40996, Pi54_13758, Pi54_22126, Pi54_22597 and Pi54_40636) are distributed among all three subspecies ( Table 2). Pi54_3708 identified in an indica accession in the present study was previously isolated from a landrace Satti as well as from O. nivara. Pi54_10202, Pi54_41818, Pi54_52694 and Pi54_42439 were the alleles identified only in the indica subgroup. Pi54_22419 is the only allele found exclusively in javanica while no allele sequence specific to japonica was identified. The reference allele Pi54_Tetep is widespread among indica accessions and is also identified in some of the javanica accessions.
To understand the genetic relatedness among the Pi54 alleles, phylogeny of the eleven alleles was analyzed together with the previously reported allelic forms of Pi54, including the alleles from eight wild rice species 4,38,40 and the recently reported Pi54 allelic sequences from Indian landraces and cultivated varieties 39 . A phylogenetic tree was constructed using the nucleotide sequences corresponding . Schematic representation of secondary structure elements, protein-binding sites, exposed/ buried and disordered regions within Pi54 proteins. (a) Protein sequences of alleles with complete ORFs as that of reference sequence Pi54_Tetep were analyzed using 'PredictProtein' server. (b) Surface accessibility of AA residues of Pi54 proteins predicted using NetSurfP server. 'X' represents polymorphic AA residues identified at least in one of the analysed Pi54 proteins. The conserved AA residues are represented by their respective single letter code. The polymorphic residues predicted as solvent exposed are highlighted in green and the ones predicted as buried are in red. The posttranslational modification sites and domain regions are illustrated.
Scientific RepoRts | 5:15678 | DOi: 10.1038/srep15678 to the complete ORF reported for Pi54_Tetep. Four major clusters were observed and the Pi54 alleles from most of the wild rice accessions formed a separate sub-cluster within cluster II (Fig. 5), but the alleles from O. nivara, O. rufipogon and O. minuta clustered together with alleles from cultivated rice. Pi54_3708 clustered together with alleles from wild rice O. nivara, landrace Satti and other cultivars including Pi54_Tetep (Fig. 5) within cluster II. The allele Pi54_40636 clustered with alleles from landraces and other cultivated rice accessions within cluster I. Except for Pi54_3708 and Pi54_40636, all the other alleles identified in this study formed two clear sub-clusters within cluster I and III. The five alleles in cluster I are closely related to O. minuta while the four alleles falling into cluster III show relatedness to different landraces and cultivars.

Discussion
Considering the narrow genetic base of agriculturally grown varieties, exploration of natural genetic diversity is critically important to broaden and diversify our resistance sources against detrimental crop diseases, including rice blast. Allelic variants of an R gene may vary in their Avr recognition specificities, thereby conferring race-specific or broad spectrum resistances. For example, assessment of allelic diversity of the barley powdery mildew resistance gene Mla 45 and flax rust resistance gene L 46,47 revealed different functional allelic forms carrying several sites of positive selection. The wheat powdery mildew resistance gene Pm3 currently has 17 identified functional alleles, representing one of the largest allelic series characterized among plant R genes 24 . Such allelic variants with SNPs of additive effects are sometimes more rewarding as they might confer broad-spectrum resistance to pathogen isolates from different geographical locations. For example, the orthologue of the rice blast resistance gene Pid3 isolated from the Indian cultivar Kasalath confers broad-spectrum resistance against Chinese blast isolates (20 of 23 tested isolates) compared to Pid3 orthologues from other cultivated and wild rice varieties 6 . Similarly, Figure 5. Phylogenetic relationship among Pi54 alleles. Analysis was performed using Pi54 sequences identified in our study material together with previously reported Pi54 sequences from wild rice species and cultivars. The ORF for all the sequences (including the previously reported sequences) were extracted from NCBI database based on the reported ORF for Pi54_Tetep reference sequence. Bootstrap values (1000 replications) are mentioned at the branch nodes. The alleles identified in our study material are labelled in yellow and the reference allele in green. The leaf nodes are coloured purple for wild rice, pink for landraces, green for cultivars, black for unknown status or unknown + breeding lines and blue for landraces + unknown/breeding line/cultivar, respectively.
Scientific RepoRts | 5:15678 | DOi: 10.1038/srep15678 identification of new allelic forms of cloned rice blast R genes revealed a unique spectrum of resistance among these alleles, including alleles of Pi35 5 , alleles of Pi54 from O. rhizomatis (Pi54rh) and O. officinalis (Pi54of) 4,38 , and various alleles at the AC134922 locus 18 . Notably, Pi35 that confers quantitative broad-spectrum resistance is an allele of Pish, which confers race-specific resistance against rice blast 5 . Here, we investigated the allelic diversity of Pi54, a major blast resistance gene conferring resistance against rice blast in India. We identified nine new alleles of Pi54 that significantly extend the known Pi54 allelic series. Among the investigated Indian accessions, the distribution of new Pi54 alleles appeared to be enriched in indica as compared to japonica and javanica accessions.
Pi54 has a NBS-LRR structure with a CC domain at the N terminus 48 . The NBS domain is reported to function as a molecular switch in disease signalling and the LRR region is known to be involved in physical interactions with the AVR proteins 49 . Recent studies also revealed interactions of non-LRR and non-NBS regions of resistance proteins, such as CC domains, with their corresponding AVR proteins [50][51][52] . The CC domain of the potato Rx protein, which confers resistance against potato virus X, contains disordered regions that engage in intramolecular interaction with the NB-LRR region and intermolecular interaction with the Rx cofactor 53 . Our analysis of Pi54 proteins revealed disordered regions in the CC domain of all alleles, suggesting an important role of the CC domain for the functional structure of Pi54 and in intramolecular and/or intermolecular interactions. The proteins encoded by other allelic forms of Pi54 (Pi54, Pi54rh, Pi54of) interact with AVR-Pi54 using various domain as well as non-domain regions 4 . These studies together with our own results signify the role of non-domain regions in specificity determination. We have identified only a few polymorphic sites in the NBS and LRR domains of the new Pi54 alleles, while the majority of the sequence polymorphisms are in the region between the tyrosine kinase phosphorylation site and the NBS domain, which we refer to as the 'SNP-rich region' . The SNP-rich region as well as the overall nucleotide polymorphism of the alleles identified in this study is shared among the fifty Pi54 haplotypes that were recently reported from Indian rice varieties 39 . Despite the presence of large InDels in some alleles, such highly conserved polymorphic nucleotides suggest frequent re-shuffling between Pi54 alleles by gene conversion and recombination.
We found that 67% of the amino acid changes among the minor motifs/patterns and PTM sites are also in the SNP-rich region of the gene. The majority of the polymorphisms at the PTM sites does not result in their loss but could influence the accessibility of acceptor residue(s) within a PTM site for the modifying enzymes. More than half of the polymorphic AA residues predicted as exposed are located within a PTM site. It has been suggested that the difference in number and distribution of phosphorylation motifs between the resistant Tetep and susceptible Nipponbare alleles of Pi54 are responsible for the resistance phenotype in Tetep 54 . We therefore expect that the observed changes in the PTM sites together with the shared and unique SNPs observed (in domain and non-domain regions) among the identified alleles might influence the protein structure, their interactions with effector proteins and downstream defence signalling. This in turn could result in novel resistance specificities. The varied patterns of resistance/susceptibility among the rice accessions containing the new Pi54 alleles to different rice blast strains further indicate a possibility of novel and/or altered resistance spectrum as compared to the known Pi54 alleles (Supplementary Table S1). However, this would need to be functionally tested using approaches such as gene silencing and/or complementation assays. Although the presented alleles were isolated from selected rice accessions that are annotated as blast resistant in IRGCIS as well as in our own screening experiments under natural and controlled conditions, the possibility for resistance in these lines due to the presence of other major R gene(s) and/or QTLs cannot be ruled out. Once functionally validated, these alleles could be used in various combinations with previously reported allelic forms of Pi54 or with other rice blast resistance genes in order to enhance the durability of blast resistance. Furthermore, detailed understanding of polymorphic sites controlling resistance will facilitate intragenic allele pyramiding to combine resistance specificities of different alleles 25 .

Materials and Methods
Plant material and molecular screening for Pi54. The rice germplasm material for this study was obtained from the International Rice Genebank (IRG) of the International Rice Research Institute (IRRI), Philippines. The accessions were screened for rice blast resistance against field mix-inoculum and five pure blast isolates 35 . Based on the standard scoring system for leaf blast 55 (scale 0-9), accessions that were resistant with a phenotypic score of 0-3 against field mix-inoculum and against any of the five isolates were selected for molecular screening. Molecular screening was carried out to identify the presence of Pi54 using a functional co-dominant marker 'Pi54 MAS' 36 that differentiates Pi54 alleles with and without an insertion of 144 bp, the former being correlated with the susceptible allele. Genomic DNA extracted from Pi54 monogenic line was used as the positive control and that from susceptible rice cultivar LTH was used as the negative control for the Polymerase chain reaction (PCR), in addition to a water control.
Isolation and cloning of Pi54 alleles. Forward primer 5′ -TACCTGATGGTTCTTTAAAATTGGG (designed for this study) and reverse primer 5′ -CATAAGCTAGACCTTGAAGGATGTC 38 were used for isolation of the full-length coding region of Pi54 alleles as annotated for Pi54 allele from cultivar Tetep 37 . PCR was performed with an initial denaturation at 95 °C for 5 minutes; followed by additional denaturation at 98 °C for 20 seconds, annealing at 61 °C for 20 seconds, extension at 72 °C for 1 minute (these Scientific RepoRts | 5:15678 | DOi: 10.1038/srep15678 three steps repeated for 35 cycles); followed by final extension at 72 °C for 2 minutes, using KAPA HiFi HotStart DNA polymerase (high fidelity proof-reading enzyme). The amplified products were cloned using pJET1.2 blunt end cloning vector.
Sequencing and sequence analysis. Forward primer 5′ -GTTAGGCCTTCAGGAATGGAGTGC was used as internal sequence primer in addition to the standard forward and reverse primers from the pJET1.2 cloning vector for the complete sequence coverage. The primers for isolation and sequencing of Pi54 alleles were designed in DNASTAR-SeqBuilder, using Pi54_Tetep as reference (Accession Nr. AY914077). DNA sequencing was performed using Applied Biosystems Capillary Sequencer 3730. Sequence assembly, consensus development and alignments were done using 'CLC Genomics Workbench, version-7.5′ . Multiple sequence alignment was performed to identify the Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNPs). Sequence polymorphism analyses such as, number of segregation sites and mutations, sliding window analysis of nucleotide diversity, k a /k s ratio and Tajima's D test were performed using DnaSP-v5 42 . Alleles with unique SNPs or InDels (insertion or deletion) were re-sequenced and in addition, re-amplified (from genomic DNA of respective accessions), re-cloned and re-sequenced for SNP/InDel confirmation. For the allelic forms identified in more than four accessions (thereby representing multiple independent amplification and cloning events), no repetitions were made. Phylogenetic analysis. Phylogenetic analysis was performed using DNA sequences of the newly identified Pi54 alleles together with previously reported Pi54 alleles from cultivated rice, landraces and wild rice species to analyse their genetic relatedness 4,[38][39][40] . The nucleotide sequences of previously reported Pi54 alleles i.e., from start to stop codon (including introns, if any) corresponding to that of Pi54_Tetep were obtained from NCBI. The sequence alignments were performed in CLC genomics workbench. The tree was constructed using 'Neighbor-joining' method and 'Jukes-Cantor' for nucleotide distance measure and bootstrap performed with 1000 replications.
Protein prediction and analysis. The protein sequences of Pi54 alleles were obtained using the EXPASY translation tool (http://web.expasy.org/translate/). The major domains such as NBS and LRR regions were assigned as previously reported for Pi54 37,40 . The CC domain was predicted using the COILS server (http://www.ch.embnet.org/software/COILS_form.html). The patterns and post-translational modification sites were predicted using ScanProsite server 41 . The secondary structure, solvent accessibility, disorders and flexibility regions of the predicted proteins were analysed using the PredictProtein server 43 . The surface accessibility of AA residues of Pi54 proteins were predicted in NetSurfP server 44 . Phyre2 server 56 was used for three-dimensional protein structure predictions of proteins of the alleles with complete ORFs based on the Pi54_Tetep reference allele. The prediction parameter was set to 'normal' mode for all the proteins analysed. PyMOL-version 1.3 was used to visualize, analyse and edit the protein structures for their secondary structure elements and orientation.