The Mg-Y-Zn ternary alloy system contains a series of novel structures known as long-period stacking ordered (LPSO) structures. The formation process and its key concept from a viewpoint of phase transition are not yet clear. The current study reveals that the phase transformation process is not a traditional spinodal decomposition or structural transformation but, rather a novel hierarchical phase transformation. In this transformation, clustering occurs first and the spatial rearrangement of the clusters induce a secondary phase transformation that eventually lead to two-dimensional ordering of the clusters. The formation process was examined using in situ synchrotron radiation small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS). Rapid quenching from liquid alloy into thin ribbons yielded strongly supersaturated amorphous samples. The samples were heated at a constant rate of 10 K/min. and the scattering patterns were acquired. The SAXS analysis indicated that small clusters grew to sizes of 0.2 nm after they crystallized. The clusters distributed randomly in space grew and eventually transformed into a microstructure with two well-defined cluster-cluster distances, one for the segregation periodicity of LPSO and the other for the in-plane ordering in segregated layer. This transformation into the LPSO structure concomitantly introduces the periodical stacking fault required for the 18R structures.
Metallic alloys undergo various types of phase transformations. These processes, including spinodal decomposition1, clustering2, order-disorder transition accompanying spinodal decomposition3 and displacive transformation4, have been the subjects of intense interest from a statistical thermodynamics viewpoint5,6 and from that of strategies for developing innovative materials. An understanding of these mechanisms can be extended to a much wider range of self-organized nanostructures, such as semiconducting nanodot heterostructures7, block copolymers8 and complex fluids9. We demonstrate that novel light weight Mg alloys with industrial interest10, Mg-Y-Zn ternary alloys, exhibit a novel spontaneously hierarchical phase transition, first clustering and second crystallization of clusters, i.e., ordering of the spatial arrangements of clusters, ultimately leading to order-disorder (OD) structures11,12.
An emerging group of Mg alloys, with a series of novel structures called synchronized long-period stacking ordered (LPSO) structures13,14, have attracted much attention for two reasons. One is interest in how and why such strange structure is stabilized, i.e., from phase transformation viewpoints. The other reason is interest in their mechanical properties, i.e., higher strength for practical applications ranging from mobile computers to aircrafts and basic questions about the kink deformation mechanism15,16.
The LPSO phase was first observed in MgZnY alloys as a periodic concentration modulation of Zn and Y along the c axis13,14 in an hcp Mg matrix and then a more refined structure was determined by electron microscopic works focusing on determining equilibrium (stable) structures of LPSO phases17,18. A reported structure17 is schematically illustrated in Fig. 1. The segregation layers consist of a two-dimensionally ordered arrangement of L12-type Y8Zn6 or Gd8Al6 molecular-like clusters with × superstructures17, whose stacking in the perpendicular direction is described by crystallographic operations12. The structure appears similar to that of intermetallic compounds with well-defined atomic positions and occupancies. However, upon examining the temporal structural change using synchrotron radiation small-angle scattering (SR-SAXS), we observed that the distance between the ordered clusters changed continuously with time19,20 within the segregation plane. The in-plane structure shown in Fig. 1 appears to undergo a two-dimensional order-disorder transition of clusters21. Such superstructures by clusters in the segregation layer might be examined in terms of two-dimensional phase transformations of particles22 similar to colloidal crystals. The confinement of the L12-ordered clusters occurs in two-dimension, as if the clusters, a partial structure of a complex order structure, behave as an independent structure unit. It should be noted that the system is three-dimensional and the formation and growth of such clusters are driven by the same phase transformation process. Knowing this, we need to return to the question of how we can understand the stability and formation mechanism of the LPSO structures in three dimension in relation to the two-dimensional order-disorder behaviour.
In many metallic alloys, a phase transition is observed upon quenching materials from a high temperature (higher symmetry) phase into a supersaturated state. For example, by quenching Al alloys, clusters of a minority phase called Guinier-Preston (GP) zones23,24 develop, whose characteristic lengths, such as their average sizes, grow with a temporal power law25,26. Comparison of the growth power law with the prediction from cluster dynamics theories or simulations27 provides an image of the transformation, such as the centre of gravity of the nanoclusters moving (diffusion of clusters) and their coagulation during the early stage of precipitation. When the volume fraction of a minority phase is large, spinodal decomposition1 or spinodal ordering3 is expected. For the present Mg85Y9Zn6 alloys, thermodynamical analysis28 suggested possibility of spinodal decomposition1 as the major driving force of LPSO formation. However, the periodic stacking faults in the LPSO structures, as shown in Fig. 1 starts another discussion from a structural phase transformations viewpoint, i.e., stacking-fault driven transformation29. However, neither of the mechanisms appears to be compatible with the two-dimensional ordering kinetics of the present alloys described above.
Results and Discussions
To examine the initial stage of the formation process, small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) patterns were measured in situ while heating rapidly quenched Mg85Y9Zn6 ribbons. The sample ribbons were initially glassy and uniform at the macroscopic length scale. A single-phase 18R LPSO microstructure is reported for the composition after long-time annealing.
Figure 2 shows the change in the SAXS profile during heating. The round shoulders of the scattering intensities in the figure indicate that many small clusters stably exist even at low temperatures and grow as the temperature increases. Another important point is that the scattering pattern changes the shape from a single diffuse peak to a double sharp peak profile at higher temperatures. With a cluster model, a scattering profile is approximated by the cluster component (form factor, F(q)) and the spatial arrangements of the clusters (structure factor, S(q) ), as:
where q is the magnitude of scattering vector. The average radius obtained from the form factor is shown in Fig. 3. It is approximately 0.14 nm before crystallization and a rapid increase to a radius of approximately 0.2 nm was observed when crystallization occurred. The cluster size increased with temperatures and the growth slowed down at the radius of 0.34 nm at 570 K. The gyration radius of the L12 cluster obtained from a first-principles calculation of the MgYZn LPSO structure is 0.34 ± 0.01 nm, which implies that the early stage of the phase transition should be described by a cluster image, not by classical spinodal decomposition.
Figure 4 shows the structure factors for several temperatures and corresponding schematic illustrations of the nanostructures in the sample. At lower temperatures, the structure factor is characterized by a single diffuse peak, suggesting that the clusters are distributed isotropically in the amorphous or crystal matrix. At higher temperatures above 553 K, the peak of the structure factor begins to separate into two peak components, eventually split into well-defined two sharp peaks corresponding to reported compositional modulation for 18R at 4 nm−1 and an in-plane × peak at 6.4 nm−1 30. This transition indicates that the formation of LPSO is explained in terms of spatial rearrangements of isotropically distributed ordered clusters into two classes of orders, one corresponds to long-range compositional modulation in the direction of the c-axis to form 18R and the other corresponds to the two-dimensional ordering leading to a × superstructure. We may emphasize that L12 clusters in stable (equilibrium) LPSO structures need to have stacking faults, on which the clusters are pinned. For smaller clusters, mobile clusters without stacking faults are reasonable. The model clusters depicted in Fig. 3 are on an hcp lattice except L12 and the gyration radii indicated by the horizontal lines are determined from the optimized structures using first-principles calculations21. Such clusters on an hcp lattice do not need to drag stacking faults upon migration; therefore, the clusters can move and grow freely in the hcp lattice similar to clusters in Al-Zn. The difference between the two alloys is that the clusters in LPSO stopped growing at the size of Y8Zn6 and formed cluster crystals like colloid crystals with two characteristic distances, an interlayer and intralayer distances. After such separation started above 530 K, where the clusters align in a plane, cooperative shear transformed the hcp-based clusters with DO19 into fcc-based clusters with L12. Using first-principles calculations, the energy gain associated with the transformation from Y6Zn6 + Y2 clusters on an hcp lattice into a Y8Zn6 L12 cluster was estimated to be at least 1.86 eV per L12 cluster. Assuming a × and even coarser superstructure, this energy gain sufficiently overcomes the energy loss caused by stacking-fault formation in the surrounding Mg matrix. Then the clusters are pinned by the stacking fault and two-dimensional self-organization20,21 begins. An interesting point here is that the clusters of Y and Zn are stable enough to exist even in amorphous state, but never grow larger than the size of approximately one unit cell, resulting in a stable size of molecular-like Y8Zn6 clusters in the crystalline state. Sharp diffraction peaks from concentration modulation for the periodicity of 18R up to the second order peak at 8 nm−1 and in-plane diffraction peak agreed with those for cast samples annealed for long time, whose structure has been well examined by TEM10,14,18 are the signature of formation of 18R structure.
We may refer to two systems that exhibit similar nanostructures: perforated structures in block copolymer systems31 and confined colloidal crystal systems22. A perforated nanostructure in a block copolymer forms two-dimensional ordered layers self-organized in three-dimensional materials, however, it is different from the present case in that further two-dimensional ordering transition is not observed. Confined colloidal crystals do exhibit two-dimensional phase transition, however, the origin of confinement is external. In contrast, the clusters in the present alloy grows and voluntarily form two-dimensional cluster layers and then the two-dimensional order of the cluster proceeds, finally leading to interlayer (OD) ordering. An interesting point here is that these hierarchical transitions are driven by the single free energy curve of the LPSO alloy, with a different magnitude of interaction depending on the hierarchy. In short, a strong phase separation tendency29, repulsive, but much weaker interaction between the clusters22 and even weaker energy gain with OD structures are the key to understand the present case. Further systematic investigation of the related alloy will provide us with a perspective on alloy design and help determine how the magnitude of interaction be implemented to design building blocks in artificial nanostructures such as functional colloidal crystals.
In summary, we demonstrated that the key to understand the formation of LPSO in the present alloy is neither typical spinodal decomposition1,3 nor structural transformation4. The kinetics indicated a hierarchical phase transformation sequence of clustering first, followed by cluster motion for long-period structures with the introduction of stacking faults. Finally two-dimensional nanoscopic ordering in segregation layers was observed.
Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) measurements were applied to examine the nanoscopic heterogeneity in the sample. Mg85Y9Zn6 alloy, the composition for single phase 18R LPSO, was rapidly quenched (RQ) from a liquid into amorphous ribbons. The ribbons were heated at a speed of 10K/min. from room temperature to melting in a furnace with carbon insulation and evacuated using a turbo molecular pump. SAXS profiles were acquired every 15 to 20 seconds in situ during heating. Calorimetric measurements were made separately to detect the transformation temperatures. XAFS measurements were preformed for as-quenched and annealed ribbons at the K absorption edge of Zn and Y and were compared with the results for cast ingots annealed at 673 K for a month. The ribbons were isothermally annealed for 5 minutes in sealed Pyrex® tube at the temperatures between 423 K and 582 K. The energetics and equilibrium structure of Mg-Y-Zn systems containing a solute cluster were obtained from first-principles density functional theory (DFT) calculations using the VASP code32.
How to cite this article: Okuda, H. et al. Nanoclusters first: a hierarchical phase transformation in a novel Mg alloy. Sci. Rep. 5, 14186; doi: 10.1038/srep14186 (2015).
Cahn J. W. On spinodal decomposition, Acta Metall. 9, 795–801 (1961).
Russel, K. C. Nucleation in solids: the induction and steady state effects, Adv. Colloid Interf. Sci., 13,205–318 (1980).
Khachaturyan, A. G., Lindsey, T. F. & Morris Jr. J. W. Theoretical investigation of the precipitation of δ’ in Al-Li, Metall. Mater. Trans. 19A, 249–258 (1988).
Weyman, C. M. & Bhadeshia, H. K. D. H. Phase Transformations, nondiffusive. Physical Metallurgy. ed. Cahn. R. W. & Haasen, P. 4th ed., chapt.16 North Holland, 1996.
Gunton J. D. & Droz M., Introduction to the Theory of Metastable and Unstable States. Letcure Notes in Physics. 183, Springer Verlag: Berlin, 1983.
Gunton J. D., San, M. & Sahni, P. S. The Dynmics of First Order Phase Transitions. Phase Transition and Critical Phonomena. vol. 8, pp.269–467
Rastelli A., Stoffel M., Tersoff J., Kar G. S., & Schmidt O. G., Kinetic Evolution and Equilibrium Morphology of Strained Islands, Phys. Rev. Letters, 95, 026103 (2005).
Hamley, I. W. ed. Developments in block copolymer, Science and Technology. John Wiley and Sons, Chichester 2004.
McConnell H. M. & Vrljic M., Liquid-liquid immiscibility in membranes, Annu. Rev. Biophys. Biomol. Struct. 32, 469–492 (2003).
Kawamura, Y., Hayashi, K., Inoue, A. & Masumoto T., Rapidly solidified powder metallurgy Mg97Y2Zn1 alloys with excellent tensile yield strength above 600 MPa, Mater. Trans. 42, 1172–1176 (2001).
Dorbberger-Shiff, K. On Order-Disorder Structures (OD-Structures) Acta Cryst. 9, 593–601 (1956).
Kishida, K., Yokobayashi, H. & Inui, H. The most stable crystal structure and the formation processes of an order-disorder (OD) intermetallic phase in the Mg-Al-Gd ternary system, Phil. Mag. 93, 2826–2846 (2013).
Yamasaki, M., Anan, T., Yoshimoto, S. & Kawamura, Y. Mechanical properties of warm-extruded Mg-Zn-Gd alloy with coherent 14H long periodic stacking ordered structure precipitate, Scr. Mater. 53, 799–803 (2005).
Itoi, T., Seimiya,T., Kawamura Y. & Hirohashi, M. Long period stacking structures observed in Mg97Zn1Y2 alloy. Scripta Mater. 51, 107–111 (2004).
Turner, F. J. Rotation of the crystal lattice in kink bands, deformation bands and twin lamellae of strained crystals. PINAS 48, 955–963 (1962).
Hagihara, K. Yokotani, N. & Umakoshi, Y. Plastic deformation behavior of Mg12YZn with 18R long-period stacking ordered structure. Intermetallics 18, 267–276 (2010).
Yokobayashi, H., Kishida, K., Inui, H., Yamasaki, M. & Kawamura, Y. Enrichment of Gd and Al atoms in the quadruple close packed planes and their in-plane long range ordering in the long periof stacking-ordered phase in the Mg-Al-Gd system, Acta Mater. 59, 7287–7299 (2011).
Egusa D. & Abe, E. The structure of long-period stacking /order Mg-Zn-RE phases with extended non-stoichiometry ranges, Acta Mater. 60, 166–178 (2012).
Okuda, H., Horiuchi, T., Ochiai, S. Yamasaki, M. & Kawamura Y. Evolution of Long Period Stacking Ordered Structures on annealing As-Cast Mg85Y9Zn6Alloy Ingot Observed by Synchrotron Radiation Small-Angle Scattering, Scripta Mater. 68, 575–578 (2013).
Okuda, H., Horiuchi, T., Yamasaki, M., Kawamura, Y. & Kohara, S., In-situ measurements on stability of long-period stacking ordered structures in Mg85Y9Zn6 alloys during heating examined by multicolor synchrotron radiation small-angle scattering. Scripta Mater., 75, 66–69 (2014).
Kimizuka,H. Kurokawa,S. Yamaguchi,A. Saki, A. & Oghata, S. Two-Dimensional Ordering of Solute Nanoclusters at a Close-Packed stacking fault; Modeling and Experimental Analysis. Scientific Reports 4, 7318 (2014).
Kawasaki, T. & Tanaka H. Structural signature of slow dynamics and dynamic heterogenerity in two-dimensional colloidal liquids; glassy structural order. J. Phys.:Cond. Matter 23, 194121 (2011).
Guinier, A. Structure of age-hardend Aluminium-Copper Alloys. Nature 142, 569–570 (1938).
Bauer, R. & Gerold, V. The existence of a metastable miscibility gap in aluminium-silver alloys. Acta Metallurgica 10, 637–645 (1961).
Binder, K. & Stauffer, D. Theory for the Slowing Down of the Relatxation and Spinodal Decomposition of Binary Mixtures. Phys. Rev. Letters 33, 1006–1009 (1974).
Osamura, K., Okuda & Ochiai, S. Isothermal phase decomposition diagram in Al-Zn binary alloys. Scripta Metall. 19, 1379–1383 (1985).
Soisson F. & Martin, G. Monte Carlo simulations of the decomposition of metastable solid solutions: Transient and steady-state nucleation kinetics. Phys. Rev. B62, 203–214(2000).
Iikubo, S., Matsuda, K. & Ohtani, H. Phase stability of long-period stacking structures in Mg-Y-Zn: A first-principles study, Phys. Rev., B86, 054105 (2012).
Iikubo S., Hamamoto S. & Ohtani H. Thermodynamic analysis of the Mg-RE-Zn (RE=Y,La) ternary hcp phase using the cluster variation method. Mater. Trans. 54, 636–640 (2013).
Yamasaki, M., Matsushita, M., K.Hagihara K., Izuno, H. Abe, E. & Kawamura, Y. Highly ordered 10H-type long-period stacking ordere phase in a Mg-Zn-Y ternary alloy. Scripta Mater. 78-79, 13–16 (2014).
Hamley, I.W., Koppi, K.A., Rosedale, J.H., Bates, F.S., Almadal, K. & Mortensen, K. Hexagonal mesophases between lameallae and cylinders in a diblock copolymer melt. Macromolecules, 26, 5959–5970 (1993).
Kresse G. & Furthmüller J. Efficient iterative schemes for ab initio total-energy calculations using a plane-wave basis set. Phys. Rev. B 54, 11169–11186 (1996).
This work was supported by Grant-in-aid for Scientific Research, numbers 23109005, 23109004 and 26630294 by MEXT/JSPS, Japan. SAXS measurements were made under proposal no. 13G576 of the Photon Factory and 2014B1100 of Spring8 Japan. The XAFS measurements were made at BL-5S2 of the Aichi Synchrotron Radiation Center, Nagoya Japan.
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
About this article
Cite this article
Okuda, H., Yamasaki, M., Kawamura, Y. et al. Nanoclusters first: a hierarchical phase transformation in a novel Mg alloy. Sci Rep 5, 14186 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1038/srep14186
Correlative atom probe tomography and scanning transmission electron microscopy reveal growth sequence of LPSO phase in Mg alloy containing Al and Gd
Scientific Reports (2021)
Solute Clusters/Enrichment at the Early Stage of Ageing in Mg–Zn–Gd Alloys Studied by Atom Probe Tomography
Acta Metallurgica Sinica (English Letters) (2019)
Scientific Reports (2017)
A formation criterion for Order-Disorder (OD) phases of the Long-Period Stacking Order (LPSO)-type in Mg-Al-RE (Rare Earth) Ternary Systems
Scientific Reports (2017)