Natural phosphides - the minerals containing phosphorus in a redox state lower than zero – are common constituents of meteorites but virtually unknown on the Earth. Herein we present the first rich occurrence of iron-nickel phosphides of terrestrial origin. Phosphide-bearing rocks are exposed in three localities in the surroundings of the Dead Sea, Levant: in the northern Negev Desert, Israel and Transjordan Plateau, south of Amman, Jordan. Seven minerals from the ternary Fe-Ni-P system have been identified with five of them, NiP2, Ni5P4, Ni2P, FeP and FeP2, previously unknown in nature. The results of the present study could provide a new insight on the terrestrial origin of natural phosphides – the most likely source of reactive prebiotic phosphorus at the times of the early Earth.
Phosphides as likely sources of prebiotic phosphorus
Phosphorus, one of life essential elements, exists under current geochemical conditions in the pentavalent state as orthophosphate ion (P5+O4)3−. However, at the times of the early Earth the situation might be very different: recently, phosphite species, (HP3+O3)2−, containing reduced trivalent phosphorus, have been identified in marine sediments related to the Archean era1. It was suggested that the phosphorus(III) served as a precursor of prebiotic organophosphorus compounds2,3, which raises an important question on the origin of reduced phosphorus in the Archean era. The plausible hypothesis assumes that the phosphite ions could be generated by the oxidation of phosphides, oxygen-free minerals containing phosphorus in a redox state lower than zero4,5.
Phosphide minerals are common accessory phases in meteorites and, to a lesser extent, in lunar rocks, interplanetary dust particles and comets6,7,8. Among eight known natural phosphides, five related to the ternary Fe-Ni-P system are particularly significant from the cosmochemical viewpoint: schreibersite - nickelphosphide, (Fe,Ni)3P - (Ni,Fe)3P (refs. 6,9), barringerite and its high-pressure polymorph allabogdanite, (Fe,Ni)2P (refs. 10,11,12) and melliniite, (Fe,Ni)4P (ref. 13). Knowledge of the phase relations in the Fe-Ni-P system substantially contribute to the understanding of the origin of planetesimals in the Solar System6,7,14 and to the prediction of phase transitions in planetary interiors12,14,15. Contrary to meteorites, phosphides have never been found in terrestrial rocks, with the exception of schreibersite found as trace inclusions in native iron from the Disko Island, Greenland16, the single find of barringerite in garnet peridotite from China17 and a few grains of phosphides found in fulgurites – silicate glasses formed by cloud-to-ground lightning events18,19.
The almost complete absence of phosphides in the Earth's crust resulted in the conventional view on the extraterrestrial origin of these minerals, hence meteoritic bombardment of the Earth's surface is considered as a likely source of phosphides and therefore of the reactive prebiotic phosphorus in the Archean era1,2,3,4,5.
Phosphides in Levant
Phosphide mineralization described herein occurs in the pyrometamorphic rocks related to the Hatrurim Formation, also known as a “Mottled Zone”. This unique geological complex is located in the vicinity of the Dead Sea, Levant, covering large areas in Israel and Jordan (Fig. 1a)20,21. The Mottled Zone is exposed in a series of outcrops with a total area of ~600 km2. The thickness of the formation reaches several hundred meters. The Mottled Zone has attracted scientific interest as a suite of chalky-marly sediments which underwent extensive and repetitive high-temperature (500–1500°C) and low-pressure (down to one bar) metamorphic events20,21. The sediments were subject to a combustion metamorphism, i.e. pyrometamorphism caused by the spontaneous or stimulated burning of carbonaceous matter. Two popular hypotheses explaining the source of the fired substance have been proposed. The first points out that the primary materials were bituminous sedimentary marls and chalks adjacent to the Mottled Zone20,21 and the second hypothesis is that the high temperature was a result of a firing of hydrocarbons (preferentially methane) from mud volcano explosions initiated by tectonic activity at the Dead Sea transform fault22. Both approaches are based on valuable observations and the exact origin of Hatrurim Formation is still a matter of debates. The age of the major metamorphic event was determined as 2–4 million years meaning that the formation is juvenile from the geological point of view23. High temperatures reached during combustion metamorphism resulted in the emergence of paragenetic mineral associations corresponding to the highest metamorphic grades such as pyroxene-hornfels and sanidinite facies and even in the formation of specific marbles composed of minerals know from cement clinkers, such as larnite, Ca2SiO4 and hatrurite, Ca3SiO5 (refs. 20,21). The primary mineralogy of the pyrometamorphic rocks of the Mottled Zone is rather complex itself20, but successive post-metamorphic hydrothermal alteration and weathering expanded mineral diversity even further. The total list of minerals known from the Hatrurim Formation approaches 200 species22.
Phosphides were found in the two outcrops within the area of Hatrurim Basin (wadi Nahal Halamish and Nahal Zahar - localities #1 and #2 on Fig. 1b) and in a small quarry exposing subsurface rocks of Daba-Siwaqa complex in Transjordan Plateau (locality #3, Fig. 1a). The first two localities are about 2 km apart, whereas the Transjordan occurrence is ~100 km NE of them, situated on the opposite side of the Dead Sea (Fig. 1a). In spite of large distances between the occurrences, phosphide associations in all three outcrops are similar. The host rocks are represented by “paralavas” (ref. 22) (Fig. 2a) – light-colored remelted carbonate-silicate sediments composed of clinopyroxene, anorthite, wollastonite, melilite and grossular-andradite garnets. Paralavas often contain centimeter- to decimeter-sized brecciated fragments of calcined marls, chalks and phosphorites (Fig. 2b). Late hydrothermal calcite, aragonite and a variety of hydrous calcium alumosilicates fill voids and fractures in paralava breccia. Phosphide grains ranging from a few microns to a few millimeters in size are usually located across the boundaries between brecciated clasts and host paralavas (Fig. 2c–f). Macroscopically, phosphides appear as yellowish-grey to nearly black inclusions in light-colored silicate-carbonate matrix and possess bright metallic luster. The minerals may occur as grains composed of a single-phase phosphide (Fig. 2e) or as complex intergrowths of two to three mineral phases (Fig. 2f). The phosphide grains that are exposed onto the weathered rock surfaces demonstrate different degrees of oxidation being partially or completely replaced by yet unidentified hydrous iron-nickel phosphates. The minerals usually associated with phosphides are pyrrhotite, Fe1-xS, troilite FeS, sometimes grains of Ni-free native iron, iron-phosphide eutectic, trevorite (natural spinel NiFe2O4), hematite, fluorapatite and a natural pyrophosphate CaFe2+P2O7, which is currently under investigation.
In total, we have identified seven minerals related to the Fe-Ni-P system, of those five are new in nature (Table 1). Representative chemical compositions of the phosphides reported herein are summarized in Tables S1–S7; crystallographic data for negevite, zuktamrurite, murashkoite, halamishite and transjordanite are presented in Tables S8–S12. The general chemical differences between meteoritic and terrestrial (i.e., Hatrurim) phosphides are illustrated by the ternary Fe-Ni-P plot (Fig. 3). It can be seen that minerals from the Hatrurim Formation exhibit much broader range of the metal-to-phosphorus ratios along with the extreme variations in the Fe/Ni ratios. Nickel is known as a mandatory constituent of meteoritic phosphides6,7,9,10,13,24,25, whereas the reported finds of terrestrial phosphides are nickel-poor16,17. It is noteworthy that some of the Hatrurim phosphides, such as halamishite Ni5P4 and negevite NiP2 do contain as low as 2–3% of Fe – the values not reported even in meteoritic phosphides, with the exception of the single grain of Ni5P2 found in the carbonaceous chondrite Allende26. The most likely source of nickel required for the formation of Ni-phosphides was natural oxide spinel trevorite, NiFe2O4, occurring in the same metamorphic rocks as phosphides. Trevorite, in due course, could be formed during metamorphic transformations of sedimentary marls and chalks which are reported to contain more than 200 ppm of Ni27. Note that completely distinct Ni-rich and Ni-free phosphides in the Mottled Zone often coexist in intimate intergrowths (Fig. 2f) that might indicate their rapid in-situ formation under non-equilibrium reducing environment. The temperatures attained in the course of phosphide formation were undoubtedly higher than 1050°C as indicated by the coexistence of phosphide grains with binary schreibersite-iron eutectic (steadite) well known in metallurgy28.
The origin of reducing conditions and high temperature needed for the transformation of oxides and phosphates to phosphides could be explained in the general context of the origin of the Mottled Zone20,21,22. It is known that the coal-based reduction of phosphates is widely employed in the industrial production of ferrophosphorus29. On the other hand, gaseous methane is known as an effective reductant of phosphates to phosphides30. Therefore, combustion of either bituminous rocks20,21 or methane originated from mud volcanoes22 could provide the environment sufficient for the direct reduction of natural phosphates and trevorite into Fe-Ni phosphides. At the same time, local spatial enrichment in nickel needed for the formation of trevorite and phosphides could be achieved via gas transport reactions involving, for instance, highly volatile nickel carbonyl Ni(CO)4. The source of phosphorus in phosphides has a straightforward explanation: it could be supplied via the incorporation of phosphorite breccia by the paralava melts. Phosphorite is the major constituent of the sedimentary Mishash Formation (late Campanian age) underlying the rocks of the Mottled Zone, where it forms meter-thick layers interstratified with marls and chalks21. Centimeter-sized clasts of metamorphosed phosphorites are common in paralavas and fine grains of fluorapatite along with CaFeP2O7 are frequently associated with phosphide grains.
Earth's vs. meteoritic: what was the source of prebiotic phosphorus?
Phosphides, whose meteoritic origin has never been doubted, are arguably considered as likely precursors for prebiotic organophosphorus compounds1,2,3,4,5. In this respect, the occurrence of geologically juvenile terrestrial phosphides, being interesting itself, could call for the new insight on the source of “phosphide phosphorus” at the era of the early Earth: the Levant findings can provide a reliable model for the formation of the Earth's own prebiotic phosphides rather than meteoritic ones. Following to the present paper, the four conditions required for the formation of terrestrial Fe-Ni phosphides can be formulated: (1) the source of phosphate phosphorus; (2) the source of counterpart transition metals (i.e., Fe, Ni); (3) the highly reducing local geochemical environment; and (4) the elevated temperatures sufficient for the maintenance of the reduction processes. The sources of phosphorus, iron and nickel can be inferred from the any geochemical environment similar to that described in this paper. The phosphate minerals related to the apatite group, Ca5(PO4)3(F,Cl,OH), are widespread both in meteorites and on the Earth; their terrestrial occurrence in the Hadean Eon has been discussed and looks undoubtful31. The same considerations can be applied to the source of Fe and Ni31: ferric-ferrous spinels (magnetite, magnesioferrite, chromite) and common sulfides like pyrite FeS2, pyrrhotite Fe1-xS and pentlandite (Fe,Ni)9S8 could be likely precursors for Fe-Ni-phosphides. The fact that the metamorphic phosphide-bearing rocks described in this paper were primarily of sedimentary origin does not disrupt the overall geological reliability of the proposed model: the coexistence of apatite with Fe-spinels or sulfides is equally common in magamatic, metamorphic or sedimentary rocks (see for instance ref. 32).
The most debatable condition (3) implies the occurrence of strong reducing agent like the elemental carbon, methane or elemental hydrogen which are all known to be efficient phosphate reductants. It is known that the solid-state reduction of calcium phosphate by graphite begins above 1050°C33 whereas hydrogen-induced reduction of phosphates can be achieved at the temperatures above 400°C34. The possibility of reduction of phosphates by methane can not be ruled out30,35,36. Indeed, the speciation of carbon and hydrogen at the early Earth is widely debatable matter35,36,37,38,39 but, notwithstanding the diversity of existing opinions it is apparent that the geochemical environment in the Hadean and early Archaen Eons has been much more reduced than contemporary one35,36,37,38,39. Therefore it looks quite likely that elevated concentrations of elemental carbon, CH4 or H2 could be occurred at the local terrestrial sites at the Earth crust faults and volcanic areas. The elevated temperatures (condition 4) required for phosphate reduction could also be reached at the same environment40; however, other high-temperature natural events such as lightnings18,19,41 or combustion of abiogenic hydrocarbons35,36 can not be ruled out.
Phosphides are known as readily oxidizible minerals1,2,3,4,5. That is clearly supported by our findings showing that the diverse phosphide minerals from Levant were subject to pronounced surface oxidation. Therefore one can hardly expect that the unstable Earth's phosphides even emerged in the Hadean and Archaen Eons could be survived under late oxidizing environment on the geological timescale. Instead, they would be oxidatively consumed providing a source of phosphinites and phosphites: a likely basis for the geosynthesis of prebiotic organophosphorus compounds on the Earth1,2,3,4,5.
The mineral samples used for the study in this work were collected during the field trips in 2005–2013 across the localities of the Hatrurim Formation (Michail Murashko and Yevgeny Vapnik), the coordinates of the localities were determined during the field works.
Electron microprobe analyses of the minerals were performed in energy dispersive mode (acceleration voltage 20 kV, beam current 0.5–1 nA) by means of JEOL JSM 6460 LV scanning electron microscope equipped with Oxford Instruments INCA X-sight LN2 EDS system; analytical standards: pyrite (Fe and S), metallic Co (Co), metallic Ni (Ni), GaP (P), metallic Cr (Cr). Representative chemical compositions of phosphides are given in Supplementary tables S1–S7.
X-ray single crystal studies were carried out using Bruker APEX DUO CCD diffractometer (for negevite, zuktamrurite, halamishite and transjordanite) and Stoe IPDS II image plate diffractometer (for murashkoite). Crystallographic data, details of the data collection and structure refinements are given in Supplementary tables S8–S12.
Pasek, M. A., Harnmeijer, J. P., Buick, R., Gull, M. & Atlas, Z. Evidence for reactive reduced phosphorus species in the early Archean ocean. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci 110, 10089–10094 (2013).
Pasek, M. A. Rethinking early Earth phosphorus geochemistry. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci 105, 853–858 (2008).
Bryant, D. E. et al. Hydrothermal modification of the Sikhote-Alin iron meteorite under low pH geothermal environments. A plausibly prebiotic route to activated phosphorus on the early Earth. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 109, 90–112 (2013).
Bryant, D. E. & Kee, T. P. Direct evidence for the availability of reactive, water soluble phosphorus on the early Earth. H-Phosphinic acid from the Nantan meteorite. Chem. Comm 2006, 2344–2346 (2006).
Pirim, C. et al. Investigation of schreibersite and intrinsic oxidation products from Sikhote-Alin, Seymchan and Odessa meteorites and Fe3P and Fe2NiP synthetic surrogates. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 140, 259–274 (2014).
Buchwald, V. F. Handbook of iron meteorites (Univ. of California Press, Berkeley, CA, 1984, vol. 1 ).
Papike, J. J., Ed. Planetary Materials (Reviews in Mineralogy, Mineralogical Society of America, WA, 1998), vol. 36.
Pasek, M. A. & Lauretta, D. S. Extraterrestrial flux of potentially prebiotic C, N and P to the early Earth. Origins Life Evol. Biosph 38, 5–21 (2008).
Britvin, S. N. et al. Nickelphosphide (Ni,Fe)3P – the nickel analog of schreibersite. Proc. Russ. Mineral. Soc 128, 64–72 (1999).
Buseck, P. R. Phosphide from meteorites: barringerite, a new iron-nickel mineral. Science 165, 169–171 (1969).
Britvin, S. N., Rudashevsky, N. S., Krivovichev, S. V., Burns, P. C. & Polekhovsky, Yu. S. Allabogdanite, (Fe,Ni)2P, a new mineral from the Onello meteorite: the occurrence and crystal structure. Amer. Mineral 87, 1245–1249 (2002).
Dera, P. et al. High-pressure polymorphism of Fe2P and its implications for meteorites and Earth's core. Geophys. Res. Lett 35, L10301 (2008).
Pratesi, G., Bindi, L. & Moggi-Cecci, V. Icosahedral coordination of phosphorus in the crystal structure of melliniite, a new phosphide mineral from the Northwest Africa 1054 acapulcoite. Amer. Mineral 91, 451–454 (2006).
Romig, A. D. & Goldstein, J. I. Determination of the Fe-Ni and Fe-Ni-P phase diagrams at low temperatures (700 to 300°C). Metall. Trans 11A, 1151–1159 (1980).
Scott, H. P. et al. Equation of state and high-pressure stability of Fe3P-schreibersite: implications for phosphorus storage in planetary cores. Geophys. Res. Lett 34, L06302 (2007).
Pedersen, A. K. Armalcolite-bearing Fe-Ti oxide assemblages in graphite-equilibrated salic volcanic rocks with native iron from Disko, Central West Greenland. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol 77, 307–324 (1981).
Yang, J. S. et al. Discovery of Fe2P alloy in garnet peridotite from the Chinese Continental Scientific Drilling Project (CCSD) main hole. Acta Petrol. Sinica 21, 271–276 (2005).
Essene, E. J. & Fisher, D. C. Lightning strike fusion: extreme reduction and metal-silicate liquid immiscibility. Science 234, 189–193 (1986).
Pasek, M. A., Block, K. & Pasek, V. Fulgurite morphology: a classification scheme and clues to formation. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol 164, 477–492 (2012).
Gross, S. The mineralogy of the Hatrurim Formation, Israel. Bull. Geol. Surv. Israel 70, 1–80 (1977).
Burg, A., Starinsky, A., Bartov, Y. & Kolodny, Y. Geology of the Hatrurim Formation (“Mottled Zone”) in the Hatrurim basin. Isr. J. Earth Sci 40, 107–124 (1992).
Novikov, I., Vapnik, Ye & Safonova, I. Mud volcano origin of the Mottled Zone, South Levant. Geosci. Frontiers 4, 597–619 (2013).
Gur, D., Steinitz, G., Kolodny, Y., Starinsky, A. & McWilliams, M. 40Ar/39Ar dating of combustion metamorphism (“Mottled Zone”, Israel). Chem. Geol 122, 171–184 (1995).
Britvin, S. N. Phosphides in metal-rich meteorites. Ph. D. thesis, Saint-Petersburg State University (2007).
Nazarov, M. A. et al. Phosphorus-bearing sulfides and their associations in CM chondrites. Petrology 17, 101–123 (2009).
Armstrong, T., Hutcheon, I. D. & Wasserburg, G. J. Zelda and company: petrogenesis of sulfide-rich Fremdlinge and constraints on solar nebula processes. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 51, 3155–3173 (1987).
Bogoch, R., Gilat, A., Yoffe, O. & Ehrlich, S. Rare earth and trace element distributions in the Mottled Zone complex, Israel. Israel J. Earth Sci 48, 225–234 (1999).
Van der Voort, G. F. Metallography: Principles and Practice (McGraw-Hill, New York, NY, 1984).
Voncken, H. L., Scheepers, E. & Yang, Y. Analysis of uranium-bearing Fe-phosphide grain from a submerged arc furnace for phosphorus production. Mineral. Petrol 88, 407–418 (2006).
Burns, S., Hargreaves, J. S. J. & Hunter, S. M. On the use of methane as a reductant in the synthesis of transition metal phosphides. Catal. Comm 8, 931–935 (2007).
Hazen, R. M. Paleomineralogy of the Hadean Eon: a preliminary species list. Am. J. Sci 313, 807–843 (2013).
Mücke, A. & Younessi, R. Magnetite-apatite deposits (Kiruna-type) along the Sanandaj-Sirjan zone and in the Bafq area, Iran, associated with ultramafic and calcalkaline rocks and carbonatites. Mineral. Petrol 50, 219–244 (1994).
Kántor, T. & Pungor, E. Investigation of thermal properties of high-temperature (1000–4000 K) systems by an arc spectroscopic method (decomposition of tricalcium phosphate). J. Therm. Anal 6, 521–527 (1974).
Prins, R. & Bussell, M. E. Metal phosphides: Preparation, Characterization and Catalytic Reactivity. Catal. Lett 142, 1413–1436 (2012).
Horita, J. & Berndt, M. E. Abiogenic methane formation and isotopic fractionation under hydrothermal conditions. Science 285, 1055–1057 (1999).
Fiebig, J., Woodland, A. B., Spangenberg, J. & Oschmann, W. Natural evidence for rapid abiogenic hydrothermal generation of CH4 . Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 71, 3028–3039 (2007).
Lindsay, J. F. et al. The problem of deep carbon – an Archean paradox. Precambr. Res 143, 1–22 (2005).
Hirshmann, M. M. & Dasgupta, R. The H/C ratios of Earth's near-surface and deep reservoirs and consequences for deep Earth volatile cycles. Chem. Geol 262, 4–16 (2009).
Rosing, M. T., Bird, D. K., Sleep, N. H. & Bjerrum, C. J. No climate paradox under the faint early Sun. Nature 464, 744–749 (2010).
Hamilton, W. Archean magmatism and deformation were not products of plate tectonics. Precambr. Res 91, 143–179 (1998).
Pasek, M. & Block, K. Lightning-induced reduction of phosphorus oxidation state. Nature Geosci 2, 553–556 (2009).
This research was financially supported by Russian Foundation for Basic Research grant no. 14-05-00910 and President grant for government support of the leading scientific schools of the Russian Federation no. 1583.2014.5. X-ray diffraction studies have been performed at the X-ray Diffraction Centre of St. Petersburg State University.
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Electronic supplementary material
About this article
Cite this article
Britvin, S., Murashko, M., Vapnik, Y. et al. Earth's Phosphides in Levant and insights into the source of Archean prebiotic phosphorus. Sci Rep 5, 8355 (2015). https://doi.org/10.1038/srep08355
This article is cited by
Communications Earth & Environment (2023)
Mineralogy and Petrology (2022)
Arabian Journal of Geosciences (2022)
Plausible Emergence and Self Assembly of a Primitive Phospholipid from Reduced Phosphorus on the Primordial Earth
Origins of Life and Evolution of Biospheres (2021)
Geochemistry of rare earth elements (REE) and redox sensitive elements (RSE) of pyrometamorphic rocks, central Jordan
Arabian Journal of Geosciences (2020)