Occupational and environmental exposure to Co and Cr has been previously linked to a wide array of inflammatory and degenerative conditions and cancer. Recently, significant health concerns have been raised by the high levels of Cr and Co ions and corrosion products released by biomedical implants. Herein, we set to analyze the biological responses associated with Co and Cr toxicity. Histological, ultrastructural and elemental analysis, performed on Cr and Co exposed patients reveal the presence of corrosion products, metallic wear debris and metal ions at varying concentrations. Metallic ions and corrosion products were also generated in vitro following macrophage phagocytosis of metal alloys. Ex vivo redox proteomic mapped several oxidatively damaged proteins by Cr(III) and Co(II)-induced Fenton reaction. Importantly, a positive correlation between the tissue amounts of Cr(III) and Co(II) ions and tissue oxidative damage was observed. Immobilized- Cr(III) and Co(II) affinity chromatography indicated that metal ions can also directly bind to several metallo and non-metalloproteins and, as demonstrated for aldolase and catalase, induce loss of their biological function. Altogether, our analysis reveals several biological mechanisms leading to tissue damage, necrosis and inflammation in patients with Cr and Co-associated adverse local tissue reactions.
Living organisms require a small amount of different metals for their metabolic functions. Among them Cr and Co are important microelements which are found in trace quantities in the human body where they regulate important biological functions. Cr is involved in glucose metabolism, either by facilitating insulin binding to its receptor or by amplifying the effect of insulin on carbohydrate and lipid catabolism1,2. On the other hand Co(III) ions occupy the catalytic site of vitamin B12 and are essential to the vitamin's biological activity3. Under physiological conditions both metals need to be present only in trace quantities because they are required for the biological activity of a very small number of specific cellular proteins4.
Cr and Co toxicity is associated with their oxidation state4,5. Cr can be present as a wide range of possible oxidation states (Cr(I), Cr(III), Cr(IV), Cr(V), Cr(VI)) even though Cr(III) and Cr(VI) are the most energetically stable and thus the most commonly observed6,7. The effects of hexavalent Cr (Cr(VI)) have been previously analyzed since it is classified as group 1 carcinogen (carcinogenic to humans) by the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) mostly related to evidence of excess of malignant lung tumors in exposed workers and is also an environmental pollutant8. On the other hand, the mechanisms related to the toxicity of Cr(III) are still unknown5,6 and therefore it is classified as group 3 carcinogen (unclassifiable due to lack of adequate evidence) by the IARC. Likewise Co can be found in different oxidation states among which Co(II) and Co(III) are the most common9,10 and it is classified with its compounds as group 2B carcinogen (possibly carcinogenic to humans) by the IARC. Occupational exposure to Co has been shown to be associated with cardiomyopathy and neurological damage11,12,13.
Lately, major health concerns have been raised by the toxic levels of Cr and Co released by metal-on-metal (MoM) bearing surface and also metallic junctions of hip implants used worldwide in orthopedic surgery14,15. Whereas in an industrial setting, the toxicity of Cr and Co is contingent upon the duration of exposure, nanoparticle concentration and entry routes into the body across a barrier membrane (dermal or inhalation absorption), the release of Co and Cr nanoparticles from metallic orthopedic implant devices represents an internal exposure to metals that is not dependent on absorption through barrier membranes and exemplifies a still relatively unexplored field of toxicology8. It has been determined that these implants release particulate metal debris in the form of corrosion with or without abrasion particles, which are non ionized metal alloys15,16. These non-ionized metal alloys are primarily nanometer-sized particles8,17.
Data from the literature indicate a range of 5–100 μg/L of Cr and 5–300 μg/L of Co present in plasma and tissues from patients with MoM implants at revision surgery18. With regards to metal ions, it is still controversial whether Cr is present as Cr(VI) in patients with MoM bearing surface and/or metal connections, with some reports supporting this idea and others disproving it19,20,21. There is a general consensus, however, that Cr(III) is elevated in the biological fluids of all patients with MoM-type implants22,23 and also that elevated Co(II), albeit at different levels, is found in serum, blood and urine of all examined patients24,25,26. Histologically, an exuberant inflammatory reaction often associated with tissue necrosis/infarction, macrophagic and lymphocytic infiltrate is observed and originally defined as aseptic lymphocytic vasculitis associated lesions (ALVAL) and later revised as adverse local tissue reaction (ALTR) or adverse reaction to metallic debris (ARMD)27,28. This reaction is likely due to a combination of metal ion toxicity combined with a hypersensitivity reaction which is particularly enhanced in some patients for reasons still not well understood.
These types of implant release particulate metal debris in the form of corrosion particles with or without addition of abrasion particles29. Since it is well established that the major health risk and toxicity of Cr and Co are not related to their elemental composition (Cr0 and Co0) but to their oxidation state it is of fundamental importance to understand the mechanism underlying metal oxidation in biological samples30,31,32. An in depth analysis of the relationship between the concentration of Cr and Co ions30,31,32 in the biological fluids and the biochemical, molecular and mechanistic analysis leading to biological damage is still missing. The surgical implantation of orthopedic implants represents a “controlled” model for examining the toxicity and mechanism of action of Co and Cr since there are well-defined parameters including duration of exposure and chemical composition of the implant. In this study, peri-implant tissues from revision surgeries were employed to examine the interaction between Cr and Co ions with tissue biomolecules and their relationship with the adverse tissue reaction.
Histological analysis of metal wear debris in periprosthetic tissues MoM implants
Histological examination of periprosthetic tissues recovered from patients with MoM implants demonstrated in some cases the occurrence of the classic layering of a high grade advanced adverse reaction with a thick superficial layer of necrosis/infarction, intermediate layer of macrophagic and lymphocytic infiltrate and deep layer of perivascular lymphoplasmacytic infiltrate (Figure 1a) associated with presence of large aggregates of corrosion particles of variable size in at least one histological section in most of the examined revision tissues (Figure 1b). Globular and/or irregular small particles of corrosion products were also observed in exfoliated (Figure 1c) and interstitial macrophages (Figure 1d). Ultrastructural analysis of the same case revealed phagosomes filled with predominantly round electron dense particles of variable intensity consistent with corrosion products and a few rod-shaped particles consistent with metallic abrasion particles not identifiable at light microscopy (Figure 1e). Particulate debris was present in the cytoplasm of the macrophages and interstitially as both electron dense rod-shaped and irregular particles and less electron dense, spherical particles that ranged from nanometer to micrometer in size (Figure 1e, 1f, 1g).
Increased cobalt and chromium accumulation in periprosthetic tissues surrounding MoM implants
Periprosthetic tissues were collected from 18 patients undergoing hip revision surgery (Table 1). Metal ion concentrations were measured in periprosthetic tissues surrounding MoM implants (9 cases) and in revision tissues from alternative bearings revision samples (9 cases), including metal-on-polyethylene (MoP), ceramic-on-polyethylene (CoP) and ceramic-on-ceramic (CoC).
A significant increase in Co and Cr accumulation was detected in revision samples surrounding MoM implants as compared to control (alternative bearings) tissues (Figures 2a, 2b). Inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) measurements revealed a 2.5-fold increase of tissue Co levels surrounding MoM implants as compared to controls (Figure 2a). Periprosthetic tissue Cr levels from MoM implants were found to be 9-fold higher as compared to controls (Figure 2b).
To determine the elemental composition of wear particles, backscatter SEM coupled with energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) was used to examine wear debris powders accumulated in metallic sleeve adapters. EDS spectra demonstrate that both Cr and Co were present in implant wear debris (Figure 2c).
Metal ions are produced from phagocytosed Co or Cr nanoparticles in macrophage endosomal compartments
The confirmation of elevated Co and Cr levels in the periprosthetic tissues surrounding MoM implants led to the next series of experiments aimed at addressing the mechanism(s) underlying the formation of metal ions. Histological analysis of the tissues surrounding the tested implants revealed extensive macrophagic infiltrates with phagocytosed pale green corrosion products and in the pictured case, abrasion black metallic particles secondary to implant impingement were also present (Figure 3a). Ultrastructural examination of MoM revision tissue demonstrated that nanometer size electron dense wear debris particles are phagocytosed by macrophages in the periprosthetic tissue (Figure 3b). An accumulation and engorgement of late endosomes and lysosomes, with needle-shaped and spherical wear debris particles, were observed in macrophages present in revision tissues (Figure 3c).
The accumulation of phagocytosed wear debris in late endosomal and lysosomal compartments prompted us to examine the effects of the acidic, highly proteolytic micro-environment of these organelles on metal nanoparticles. Wild-type C57Bl/6 bone marrow macrophages were left untreated or exposed to cobalt or chromium nanoparticles at concentrations of 109, 1010, 1011 and 1012 particles per ml for 12 hours. Macrophages treated with cobalt or chromium nanoparticles demonstrated a dose- dependent increase in cobalt and chromium ions concentrations, as measured spectrophotometrically (Figures 3d, 3e). The observed increase in cobalt and chromium ion levels led us to examine the relationship between pH and metal ion generation. To this end we incubated primary macrophages in the presence or absence of NH4Cl and leupeptin, prior to treatment with chromium nanoparticles. The pre-treatment of cells with a combination of NH4Cl and leupeptin makes the intralysosomal pH more basic and inhibits lysosomal proteolysis, respectively. Macrophage chromium ion levels were determined 12 hours following nanoparticle exposure. Chromium ion levels were significantly elevated in macrophages exposed to nanoparticles alone as compared to cells pre-treated with lysosomal inhibitors and control cells. With increasing concentrations of nanoparticle exposure, NH4Cl and leupeptin pre-treated cells did not demonstrate a significant elevation of chromium ion release. Cells not pre-treated with NH4Cl and leupeptin, however, revealed a dose dependent increase in chromium ion levels following nanoparticle exposure (Figure 3f).
Chromium orthophosphate (CrPO4) is among the most commonly observed implant corrosion products in the periprosthetic tissue and it is due to the precipitation of chromium and phosphate ions. The observation of phagocytosed CrPO4 within macrophagic dominant infiltrates prompted us to examine the effects of endosomal/lysosomal microenvironment on CrPO4 and particularly whether Cr ions could be released from CrPO4. Primary macrophages were left untreated or exposed to increasing concentrations of CrPO4 (Figure 3g). A dose-dependent increase in chromium ion release was measured in cells exposed to CrPO4 (Figure 3h).
Histological examination of infiltrates with phagocytosed corrosion products demonstrated a transition from healthy to degenerated macrophages with foamy elements in the periprosthetic tissues surrounding MoM implants (Figure 3i). Together, these data indicate that phagocytosed corrosion products and also abraded metallic wear debris accumulate within late endosomes with the resultant release of metal ions.
Metal ion exposure increases oxidative stress and protein carbonylation
In the next series of experiments, we examined the relationship between metal ion formation and cellular free radical production. Primary macrophages were left untreated or exposed to cobalt or chromium ions at concentrations of 10, 100 and 1000 μM for 12 hours. Using a DiOxyQ probe that fluoresces upon reacting with free radicals, significant increases in ROS levels were measured in primary macrophages exposed to cobalt or chromium at concentrations of 100 μM and 1000 μM when compared to controls (Figure 4a). Significant increases in ROS production were detected in culture supernatants from chromium or cobalt exposed cells at all concentrations when compared to controls (Figure 4b).
Next, we investigated whether elevated concentrations of cellular ROS would result in an increase of oxidatively modified proteins in macrophages exposed to metal ions. To address this aim, the cytosol and mitochondria were isolated from untreated and metal ions exposed cells and subsequently incubated with 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazine (DNPH). DNPH selectively reacts with or derivatizes carbonyl groups. The DNPH-derivatized samples were separated by a 4–15% gradient SDS PAGE, followed by western blot analysis employing an anti- DNPH primary antibody. Western blot analysis detected carbonylated proteins in the cytosol and mitochondria from untreated and cobalt or chromium exposed macrophages (Figure 4c) A significant increase in the levels of oxidatively modified proteins was detected in the cytosol and mitochondria isolated from cobalt or chromium treated cells when compared to controls (Figure 4c). Western blot analysis of primary macrophages exposed to CrPO4 demonstrated a dose dependent increase in the levels of protein carbonylation in CrPO4 exposed cells as compared to untreated cells. (Figure 4d).
Following the observed increases in cellular ROS levels and protein carbonylation in primary macrophages exposed to metal ions and CrPO4, in addition to the significant elevation of metal ions measured in periprosthetic tissues surrounding MoM implants, the next experiments were designed to examine revision tissues surrounding hip implants for protein oxidation. The carbonyl content (carbonylated Arg, Lys, His and Pro residues) in revision tissues was analyzed spectrophotometrically at an absorbance of 375 nm following the reaction of carbonylated amino acid side-chains of oxidized proteins with DNPH. A significant increase in carbonyl content was detected in revision tissues surrounding MoM implants as compared to control tissues (Figure 4e).
The introduction of carbonyl groups into amino acid side chains can result in the loss of catalytic or structural function of the affected protein. Thus, total proteomic analyses were performed on the proteins extracted from revision tissues surrounding MoM implants to identify peptides and proteins with posttranslational modifications, including oxidation sites. The extracted total proteome from MoM tissue homogenates was fractionated on a FPLC gel filtration column subjected to protease digestion with endoproteinase Lys-C and trypsin and analyzed by tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) on a nano LC/Orbitrap system. Nano LC-ESI-MS/MS analysis demonstrated substantial oxidation of amino acids of several proteins in the periprosthetic tissues from MoM implants (Figure 4f).
The analysis mapped the side chain posttranslational modifications of several proteins (Supplement Table 1). Oxidations included the glutamic semi- aldehyde conversions of arginine, lysine, histidine and tryptophan (Arg- >GluSA, Lys->Allysine, His->2-oxo-histidine and Trp->Kynurenine) (Supplement Table 1). Analysis of the oxidatively damaged proteome indicated that proteins, related to different cellular function and sub-cellular location were oxidatively damaged (Figure 4g, Supplement Table 1). A directly proportional relationship between Cr levels and carbonyl content was observed in the periprosthetic tissues surrounding hip implants (Figure 4h).
Proteins in the MoM revision tissue proteome demonstrate binding affinity for Co and Cr
Immobilized-metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) was performed to separate metal- binding proteins from the total proteome extracted from periprosthetic tissues from MoM implants. Metal-binding proteins were fractionated on the basis of their differential binding affinities of the surface exposed amino acids towards an immobilized metal ion. To determine if some of the known proteins with high affinity for metals could be retained by the IMAC columns charged with cobalt [Co(II)] and with chromium [Cr(III)], metal depleted tissue homogenates were loaded on an IMAC column/chip saturated with Co(II) or Cr(III). Proteins with affinity for binding Co(II) or Cr(III) were eluted from the immobilized columns with increasing concentrations of imidazole (Figures 5a, 5b). Recovered fractions were pooled into six groups and separated by 1D SDS-PAGE. Silver stain analysis of the SDS-PAGE indicated that several proteins present in the revision tissues surrounding MoM implants were able to bind Co(II) or Cr(III) (Figure 5c, Supplement Table 2). Following in situ tryptic digestion, extracted peptides were analyzed by nano LC–ESI–MS/MS on Orbitrap to identify the metal binding proteins in the revision tissues. Among the proteins eluted from the Cr(III)-loaded column were several enzymes such as enolase (Mg2+), catalase (Fe(II)), myeloperoxidase (Fe(III)/Ca2+) and arginase (Mn(II)), as well as molecular transporters such as ferritin (Fe(III)), hemoglobin (Fe(III)), ceruloplasmin (Cu(II)) and different Ca2+ binding proteins involved in many cellular functions (Figure 5d, Supplement Table 2). Similarly, among the protein eluted from the Co(II) column, there were several subunits of cytochrome C (Cu(II), Fe(III) and Zn(II) dependent), enzymes that are part of the cellular redox system and Ca2+-binding proteins important for cell motility and cell signaling (Figure 5d, Supplement Table 2). Altogether, pathway analysis of the cellular proteome binding Co(II) and Cr(III) columns indicate that several cellular pathways and function could be potentially compromised by metal binding.
Chromium inhibits the catalytic activity of aldolase and catalase in vitro
To determine the potential effects of Co(II) or Cr(III) on cellular functions, we selected two enzymes; one, aldolase, which was previously reported to bind Cr(III) at a non-catalytic site33; and the other catalase, which could replace Fe(III) at its catalytic site with Cr(III). Fructose-bisphosphate aldolase (ALD), catalyzes a key reaction in glycolysis and energy production, i.e. the conversion of D-fructose-1,6-biphosphate into dihydroxyacetone phosphate and D-glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate. Thus, any impairment in this protein's catalytic activity would be followed by damage to the energetic balance of any cell34. The catalytic activity of pure human recombinant aldolase A was assessed to determine any enzymatic differences in the absence or presence of Co(II) or Cr(III) at different concentrations (4 mM, 0.4 mM and 0.04 mM for each Co(II) and Cr(III) solution). In each condition, the enzyme was incubated with the substrate, D-fructose 1,6-biphosphate and hydrazine sulfate. The resulting hydrazone product, which absorbs at 240 nm, was measured. Spectrophotometric analysis of hydrazone formation demonstrated a dose dependent Cr(III) inhibition of aldolase activity, with complete loss of catalytic activity observed at 4 mM Cr(III) (Figure 6a). Interestingly, spectrophotometric measurements of hydrazone formation in the presence of Co(II) revealed minimal inhibition of aldolase activity at all concentrations used as compared with untreated aldolase (Figure 6b).
The second protein examined, catalase, is an enzyme responsible for the conversion of hydrogen peroxide to water and oxygen. Catalase is a tetramer consisting of four identical, tetrahedrally arranged subunits. Each 60 kDa subunit contains a heme group and NADPH in its active center35. Inhibitors of catalase include metals, which can affect heme structure via the displacement of iron. To examine the effects of metals on catalase function and possible alterations to catalytic activity, H2O2 decomposition was measured spectrophotometrically at 240 nm in the absence or presence of Co(II) or Cr(III). The presence of Cr(III) exerted a dose dependent inhibitory effect on catalase activity, with near abolishment of activity observed at 4 mM Cr(III) (Figure 6c) Spectrophotometric measurements of H2O2 decomposition in the presence of Co(II) at all concentrations, however, did not reveal any inhibition of catalase activity as compared to untreated catalase (Figure 6d). Together, these results indicate that Cr(III), but not Co(II), affects protein function in a dose dependent manner.
A comparison of Co(II) and Cr(III) toxicity from the in vitro and ex vivo results in this study is presented in Supplement Table 3. The most notable differences between the metal ions are: a linear correlation between Cr(III) concentration and protein carbonylation and a Cr(III) dose dependent inhibition of enzymatic catalytic activity (in vitro).
Chromium and cobalt are minerals, both required as dietary supplements in trace amounts. The adequate daily intake for Cr is 25 to 50 μg/day and 5 to 8 μg/day for Co36. Both metals display toxic effects when present at high concentrations. Severe and irreversible cardiomyopathy and vision or hearing impairments are reported at serum Co concentrations over 700 μg/L and reversible hypothyroidism and polycythemia at ~300 μg/L and higher37,38,39,40. For Cr acute oral toxicity ranges between 1900 and 3300 μg/kg and is associated with damage to multiple tissues and often kidney and liver failure41. Overexposure to both metals is sporadic and associated with environmental and/or industrial exposure. Recently, groups of patients implanted with hip devices of MoM bearing surface have been shown to develop an accelerated inflammatory reaction frequently associated with tissue necrosis and cellular toxicity. The sense of urgency in determining the molecular association between MoM implants and toxic response relates to the fact that there is a large population worldwide carrying these devices to be monitored long-term.
Metal-based implants release micrometer and nanometer sized wear debris, due to the tribocorrosion of the bearing surfaces42. The particulate metals released from the wear of joint implants are mostly colloidal CrCo alloys and likely some oxides (Cr2O3 and CoO). Herein we determined by TEM and light microscopy of periprosthetic tissues that these metal particles are readily phagocytosed by tissue resident macrophages and transported in endosomal and lysosomal compartments as indicated by the several observed phagocytic cells engulfed with corrosion product particles. In endosomal compartments, due to the presence of an acidic pH, the transition metals release Cr and Co ions with different oxidation states43,44,45,46. Induction of endosomal alkalinization greatly decreased metal ionization, with a direct correlation between the amount of phagocytosed metal particles, acid pH and released metal ions observed. This determination is important since metal ions are the ones associated with biological damage.
Indeed, increased amount of both Cr(III) and Co(II) were found in tissues retrieved from patients with MoM implants as compared with control implants including MoP, CoP and CoC bearing surfaces which also may contain Cr and Co in their formulation but in much lower amounts. Cr(III) is the most thermodynamically stable species and does not tend to reduce to Cr(II) or oxidize to Cr(VI), which are more unstable oxidation states. Cr(VI), if present could be readily reduced to Cr(III)47. Cr(III) is the form mostly observed in patients with MoM “metallosis”22,48,49 and it often forms complexes with the ubiquitously found, negatively charged phosphate group. The resulting Cr orthophosphate (CrPO4) is commonly found in the periprosthetic tissue and the synovial fluid of patients with metal-on-metal-related pathology43. These precipitates are referred to as implant corrosion products. We observed these corrosion products both by TEM, where they present a globular and irregularly shaped appearance and by histological analysis, as pale green intracellular and extracellular tissue deposits. The equilibrium kinetic between Cr(III) and its combined form (CrPO4) and the conditions that skew the reaction toward free Cr(III) ion or its combined form will be worth exploring since these corrosion products serve as a constant source of metal ions that, since they cannot be disposed of, can amplify the tissue damage. Co(II) is the Co form mostly observed in patients with MoM “metallosis”.
Our analysis on the effects of Cr and Co ions retrieved from MoM patients, indicate that several mechanisms account for the induced damage. First, Cr(III) and Co(II) catalyze the conversion of hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) into reactive hydroxyl radicals (HO•) in a chemical reaction known as the Fenton reaction5. Fenton chemistry is regularly known to occur in vivo; however, the level of activity is generally negligible due to only trace amounts of transition metals present in the human body. Additionally, under physiological conditions the cells are equipped with a variety of enzymes, including several isoforms of catalase, glutathione peroxidase and heme oxygenase-1, that dispose of ROS. When higher amounts of metal ions are present, however, the hydroxyl radicals formed by the metal-catalyzed Fenton reaction are greatly increased to levels that cannot be readily inactivated50. Excess ROS cause deleterious biological effects and irreversible damage by promoting protein, lipid, carbohydrate and DNA oxidation50. Importantly, we found a strong positive correlation between the amount of Cr and Co ions and tissue oxidative damage. Patients with the highest amount of Cr and Co ions present the highest levels of protein carbonylation, a well-known consequence of oxidative stress50. It is known that extensive oxidative modifications result in cleavage, sub-unit dissociation, unfolding and aggregation, with an overall loss of biological function51. These conditions are effects of oxidative stress and are known to be associated with tissue degeneration and necrotic damage. High levels of oxidative stress can explain the necrotic tissue and formation of masses known as pseudotumors, observed in patients with MoM implants17,18,27,52,53,54,55. Our in vivo proteomic analyses indicate that several proteins associated with different cellular pathways are oxidatively damaged by Cr and Co-induced ROS. Having an overall carbonylated proteome could generally compromise cellular functions. Indeed, our in vivo data are further supported by several in vitro experiments indicating that Cr(III) induces cellular damage by activating ASK1 kinase, p38, Jun kinase and caspase 356. Cobalt has also been shown to induce necrotic and apoptotic cell death57.
As a second mechanism, Cr and Co metal ions can directly bind to proteins and directly induce oxidation and loss of biological function. It has been previously reported that Cr interacts with different serum proteins including hemoglobin, transferrin and albumin58. Co has been proposed to bind to several proteins involved in the cellular redox system and ROS clearance59.
Additionally, some of the toxic effects of Co(II) have recently been proposed to be due to inhibition of Ca2+ entry and Ca2+ signaling and competition with Ca2+ for intracellular Ca2+- binding proteins60. Co(II) has also been shown to interact with various receptors, ion channels and biomolecules13,61.
Our comprehensive proteomic analysis indicates that both Cr(III) and Co(II) can bind several more cellular proteins including enzymes involved in the cellular redox system (catalase, superoxide dismutase, glutathione peroxidase, metabolism (arginase 1, transglutaminase 3, enolase 1, molecular transport (transferritin, transcobalamin, hemoglobin, cellular motility (annexin A1, annexin A2, lymphocyte cytosolic protein 1, cell signaling (leukotriene A4 hydrolase, ryanodine receptor 2, phosphodiesterase 3A, cGMP-inhibited) and organelles functions. Altogether our data indicate that several cellular pathways and function can be potentially compromised by metal binding. As a proof of principle we determined that incubation of aldolase with Cr(III) and less so with Co(II), decreased the enzyme's ability to catalyze the formation of glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate from fructose 1–6 biphosphate, even though Cr(III) does not directly bind to the enzyme's catalytic site33.
Finally, as a third mechanism, Cr and Co ions could displace other metal ions present in tissue metalloproteins and affect their activity. Indeed, protein elution from Cr(III) and Co(II) columns retrieved several metalloproteins among which Ca2+, Fe(III) and Zn(II) binding proteins were particularly enriched. To determine whether Cr and Co ions can directly replace other ions present in metalloproteins we incubated catalase with Cr(III) ions since catalase contains a heme/Fe group in its active center35. A significant decrease in the catalytic ability of catalase to decompose H2O2 was observed.
In conclusion, our analyses indicate several mechanisms that can substantially explain the exaggerated tissue damage and accumulation of a large amount of necrotic macrophages in the joint fluid. Additional mechanisms, which were not mechanistically explored here, include the adverse tissue reactions associated with Cr and Co hypersensitivity, which are strongly dependent on the particle immunogenicity and patient immunological phenotype and can exponentially increase the inflammatory response.
Mice and bone marrow macrophage (BMM) preparation
C57BL/6 mice (3 months old) were purchased from Harlan Laboratories. Animal euthanasia and tissue harvesting were conducted according to a protocol approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee at Albert Einstein College of Medicine. Bone marrow cells were isolated from murine femurs and differentiated in M-CSF (10 ng/ml, RD Systems) for 5 days.
Primary macrophage cultures with metal nanoparticles and ions
In studies examining protein carbonylation and total free radical activity, cells were either left untreated or exposed to cobalt or chromium ions: cobalt (II) sulfate heptahydrate and chromium (III) chloride hexahydrate were prepared at concentrations of 1 μM, 10 μM, 100 μM in culture medium. For the spectroscopic analysis of metal ions, primary macrophages were incubated in the absence or presence of cobalt nanoparticles (purity 99.8%, a mean size of 28 nm) or chromium nanoparticles (purity 99.5%, a mean size of 50 nm, Nanostructured & Amorphous Materials, Inc., Houston, TX) or chromium orthophosphate (chromium (III) salt(1:1); phosphoric acid. Cobalt and chromium nanoparticles were suspended in culture medium at concentrations of 1 × 1010, 1011, 1012 particles per ml. In some experiments, prior to the addition of chromium nanoparticles, macrophages were pre-treated with a final concentration of 20 mM NH4Cl and 0.1 mM Leupeptin to inhibit endosome-lysosome system acidification. In all experiments, control and exposed cells were collected 12 hours following treatment.
Histological analysis of revision tissues
Periprosthetic tissues were collected at surgery from a total of 9 cases undergoing revision surgery for adverse local tissue reactions (ALTR). All patients provided informed, written consent regarding participation in this study. Studies and procedures were conducted according to a protocol approved by the Albert Einstein College of Medicine Institutional Review Board. The implant group composition was as follows: MoM CoCr bearing surface, 9 [5 THA large head (>36 mm diameter) with metallic CoCr Mo sleeve adapter and 4 resurfacing implants with the same bearing surface]; Control (CTR) group was comprised of 9 samples: Metal-on-Polyethylene (MoP) bearing surface, 5; Ceramic-on-Polyethylene (CoP) bearing surface, 3; and Ceramic-on-Ceramic (CoC) bearing surface, 1; all with a conventional stem and monoblock modular neck. The tissue was collected fresh from several areas around the implant on ice. Collected tissues were fixed in 10% neutral buffered formalin and processed for hematoxylin-eosin staining. Sections were examined with a Zeiss Axioskop 40 microscope and images captured digitally using a ProgRes® camera (Jenoptik, Germany).
Backscatter scanning electron microscopy and Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopic (EDS) analysis of wear debris powder
Wear debris powder was gently scraped or shaken from the implant metallic sleeves with a sterile carbon steel metallic surgical blade and saved in an OPTICLEAR® 15 × 45 mm screw thread borosilicate glass vial w rubber lined cap (Kimble Chase, Rockwood, TN) prior to analysis. Using carbon paste as an adhesive, powders were sprinkled onto a carbon stub and then coated with carbon. Spectra and maps were collected on a Zeiss Supra 40 FESEM with Oxford INCA energy dispersive spectrometer at 10 kV.
ICP-MS sample preparation and instrumental conditions
Each sample was mixed with 0.5 mL of aqua regia and then the sample was diluted to 10 ml with de-ionized water. A series of standard solutions of Co and Cr were prepared under the same acidic conditions. The inductively-coupled plasma (ICP) mass spectrometry (MS) measurements were performed on a PerkinElmer NexION 300X ICP mass spectrometer. 59Co and 52Cr were measured under the kinetic energy discrimination (KED) mode.
Spectrophotometric determination of protein carbonyl content
The carbonyl content of revision tissues and primary macrophages exposed to metal ions was quantified spectrophotometrically with the Protein Carbonyl Assay kit (Cayman Chemical Company, Ann Arbor, MI).
Western blot analysis of carbonyl groups
Revision tissue homogenates and primary cell lysates were prepared in 150 mM NaCl, 50 mM Tris, 1 mM EDTA and 1% NP40. Prepared samples were derivatized using the Oxyblot Protein Oxidation Detection Kit (Millipore, USA), separated on 4–15% SDS-PAGE and transferred membranes were incubated with a rabbit polyclonal anti-DNP antibody followed by a goat anti-rabbit IgG–HRP antibody. Proteins were visualized by chemiluminescence.
Transmission electron microscopy
Periprosthetic tissues, collected fresh on ice, were immediately fixed in 2.5% glutaraldehyde, 2% paraformaldehyde, in sodium cacodylate buffer 0.1 M, pH 7.4 for 3 hours at 4°C, post-fixed in 1.0% aqueous osmium tetroxide and embedded in LX112-Araldite (Ted Pella Inc, CA, USA). Ultrathin sections were stained with uranyl acetate followed by lead citrate and viewed with a Jeol JEM-1200EX transmission electron microscope (Jeol Ltd., Akishima, Japan) at 80 kV.
Fluorometric measurement of total ROS activity
The total free radical activity in control and metal ion exposed primary macrophages and culture supernatants was quantified with the OxiSelect In Vitro ROS/RNS Assay kit (Cell Biolabs, Inc., San Diego, CA).
Spectroscopic determination of cobalt (II) ions
Cobalt (II) concentrations in total cell lysates prepared from control and cobalt nanoparticle (Co0) exposed primary macrophages were measured following the incubation with a solution containing 0.8 ml 6 M HCl, 2.0 ml 50% potassium thiocyanate in 4.8 ml acetone. The absorbance of the complexes of cobalt ions with thiocyanate was measured spectrophotometrically at 620 nm.
Colorimetric determination of chromium (VI) ions
Chromium (VI) concentrations in control and chromium nanoparticle (Cr0) exposed primary macrophages and culture supernatants were determined following the incubation with a solution containing 0.5 ml 3 M H2SO4, 0.5 ml 50% 1.5-Diphenylcarbazide in 9.0 ml deionized water. The absorbance was measured spectrophotometrically at 540 nm.
Organelle isolation and cytosol preparation
Cytosol was prepared was isolated from homogenates following centrifugation for 1 h at 100,000 g at 4°C. Mitochondria were isolated from homogenates following two consecutive centrifugations for 10 minutes each at 7,000 g at 4°C.
FPLC gel filtration fractionation of the proteome contained in the homogenates from revision tissues
Extracted proteins (about 5–6 mg of each homogenate from at least five patient revision tissues) were run through a Superdex S200 gel filtration column (HiLoad 16/60) coupled to a Bio-Rad FPLC system interfaced with Biologic DuoFlow software. One representative run consisted of 240 ml of PBS buffer with 300 mM NaCl, pH 7.4, run through the column at a flow rate of 0.5 ml/min.
rLys-C/trypsin digestion of the proteome
Multiple fractions were lyophilized before mass spectroscopy analysis and subjected to reduction and alkylation. Fractions were digested first with endoproteinase Lys-C followed by trypsin.
NanoLC-ESI-MS/MS analysis of Lys-C/tryptic peptides
Lys-C/tryptic digests were analyzed by nano LC/MS/MS with a Waters NanoAcquity HPLC system interfaced to a ThermoFisher Q Exactive with the Orbitrap operating at 60,000 FWHM and 17,500 FWHM for MS and MS/MS respectively. The fifteen most abundant ions were selected for MS/MS.
Raw tandem mass spectra data files were extracted, converted to mgf files using Proteome Discoverer version 1.3 and analyzed using Mascot (Matrix Science, London, UK). Mascot was set up to search the SwissProt-2013-07 database (selected for Homo sapiens, 20265 entries) Mascot was searched with a fragment ion mass tolerance of 0.80 Da and a parent ion tolerance of 10.0 PPM. For the redox proteome analysis we used as variable modifications the amino acids oxidations reported in Mascot.
Validation of the posttranslational (PTM) modifications and normalizing spectral counts
The proteins were considered identified having at least one bold red (BR) significant peptide with an ion score cut-off of 20 or greater (corresponding to p < 0.05 and a FDR proteins <1.0). Scaffold (Proteome Software Inc., Portland, OR) was used to validate MS/MS based peptide and protein identifications.
Immobilized metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) purification of metalloproteins
IMAC columns were charged with either Co(II) or Cr(III) (300 mM in PBS, pH 6.5). Columns were equilibrated in 50 mM NaH2PO4 with 10 mM imidazole and 0.3 M NaCl at 1 ml/min flow rate using the Bio-Rad FPLC system interfaced with Biologic DuoFlow software. 5 mg of protein homogenates were loaded on each IMAC column and 1 ml fractions were collected for the entire run. Eluted fractions at 20–350 mM imidazole were further fractionated on 1D 4%–20% SDS-PAGE and subsequently silver stained. 10 gel bands were cut across each sample lane and subjected to bottom-up proteomics analysis. In situ endoproteinase Lys-C and tryptic digestion was performed after reduction and alkylation. Extracted tryptic peptides were analyzed by nano LC–ESI–MS/MS on Orbitrap and the data were processed with Proteome Discoverer, Mascot and Scaffold.
Aldolase catalytic activity
Using the Boyer modification of the hydrazine assay62, in which 3-phosphoglyceraldehyde reacts with hydrazine to form a hydrazone product which absorbs at 240 nm, we designed a microassay in which pure human recombinant aldolase A (1–364 aa) (50 μg/assay mixture) was left untreated or incubated with different concentrations of the two heavy metals (4 mM, 0.4 mM and 0.04 mM for each Co(II) and Cr(III) solution) in the presence of the substrate, D-fructose 1,6-biphosphate (4.0 mM final concentration) and hydrazine sulfate (about 2.5 mM final concentration) in PBS at pH 7.4. The formation of the hydrazone was characterized by an increase in the absorption at 240 nm monitored over 10–15 min incubation time.
Catalase catalytic activity
To test the inhibition of catalase by Co(II) and Cr(III) we developed a microassay adapted from the Worthington's assay63 in which the disappearance of peroxide is followed spectrophotometrically at 240 nm. 20–50 μg of pure protein (from human erythrocytes) were incubated in an assay mixture containing 0.05 M potassium phosphate, pH 7.0 and 0.059 M hydrogen peroxide (30%) in 0.05 M potassium phosphate, pH 7.0 as the substrate. The consumption of peroxide was monitored in the presence or absence of Co(II) or Cr(III) using the same concentration range as in the aldolase assay.
Anderson, R. A. Chromium as an essential nutrient for humans. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol 26, S35–41, 10.1006/rtph.1997.1136 (1997).
Mertz, W. Chromium occurrence and function in biological systems. Physiol Rev 49, 163–239 (1969).
Hodgkin, D. C. et al. Structure of vitamin B12. Nature 178, 64–66 (1956).
Klaassen, C. D., Casarett, L. J. & Doull, J. Casarett and Doull's toxicology: the basic science of poisons. 8th edn, (McGraw-Hill, 2013).
Beyersmann, D. & Hartwig, A. Carcinogenic metal compounds: recent insight into molecular and cellular mechanisms. Arch Toxicol 82, 493–512, 10.1007/s00204-008-0313-y (2008).
ASTDR. (ed Public Health Service U.S. Department of Health and Human Services) 1–592 (2012).
Barceloux, D. G. Chromium. J Toxicol Clin Toxicol 37, 173–194 (1999).
Keegan, G. M., Learmonth, I. D. & Case, C. P. A systematic comparison of the actual, potential and theoretical health effects of cobalt and chromium exposures from industry and surgical implants. Crit Rev Toxicol 38, 645–674, 10.1080/10408440701845534 (2008).
ATSDR. 1–417 (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, 2004).
Barceloux, D. G. Cobalt. J Toxicol Clin Toxicol 37, 201–206 (1999).
McDermott, P. H., Delaney, R. L., Egan, J. D. & Sullivan, J. F. Myocardosis and cardiac failure in men. JAMA 198, 253–256 (1966).
Morin, Y. & Daniel, P. Quebec beer-drinkers' cardiomyopathy: etiological considerations. Can Med Assoc J 97, 926–928 (1967).
Paustenbach, D. J., Tvermoes, B. E., Unice, K. M., Finley, B. L. & Kerger, B. D. A review of the health hazards posed by cobalt. Crit Rev Toxicol 43, 316–362, 10.3109/10408444.2013.779633 (2013).
Bozic, K. J. et al. The epidemiology of bearing surface usage in total hip arthroplasty in the United States. J Bone Joint Surg Am 91, 1614–1620, 10.2106/JBJS.H.01220 (2009).
Huber, M., Reinisch, G., Trettenhahn, G., Zweymuller, K. & Lintner, F. Presence of corrosion products and hypersensitivity-associated reactions in periprosthetic tissue after aseptic loosening of total hip replacements with metal bearing surfaces. Acta Biomater 5, 172–180, 10.1016/j.actbio.2008.07.032 (2009).
Higgs, G. B. et al. Is Increased Modularity Associated With Increased Fretting and Corrosion Damage in Metal-On-Metal Total Hip Arthroplasty Devices?: A Retrieval Study. J arthroplasty 28, 2–6 (2013).
Xia, Z. et al. Characterization of metal-wear nanoparticles in pseudotumor following metal-on-metal hip resurfacing. Nanomedicine 7, 674–681, 10.1016/j.nano.2011.08.002 (2011).
Sampson, B. & Hart, A. Clinical usefulness of blood metal measurements to assess the failure of metal-on-metal hip implants. Ann Clin Biochem 49, 118–131, 10.1258/acb.2011.011141 (2012).
Hart, A. J. et al. The chemical form of metallic debris in tissues surrounding metal-on-metal hips with unexplained failure. Acta Biomater 6, 4439–4446, 10.1016/j.actbio.2010.06.006 (2010).
Merritt, K. & Brown, S. A. Release of hexavalent chromium from corrosion of stainless steel and cobalt-chromium alloys. J Biomed Mater Res 29, 627–633, 10.1002/jbm.820290510 (1995).
Shettlemore, M. G. & Bundy, K. J. Examination of in vivo influences on bioluminescent microbial assessment of corrosion product toxicity. Biomaterials 22, 2215–2228 (2001).
De Smet, K. et al. Metal ion measurement as a diagnostic tool to identify problems with metal-on-metal hip resurfacing. J Bone Joint Surg Am 90 Suppl 4, 202–208, 10.2106/JBJS.H.00672 (2008).
Hart, A. J. et al. Sensitivity and specificity of blood cobalt and chromium metal ions for predicting failure of metal-on-metal hip replacement. J Bone Joint Surg Br 93, 1308–1313, 10.1302/0301-620X.93B10.26249 (2011).
Daniel, J., Ziaee, H., Pradhan, C. & McMinn, D. J. Six-year results of a prospective study of metal ion levels in young patients with metal-on-metal hip resurfacings. J Bone Joint Surg Br 91, 176–179, 10.1302/0301-620X.91B2.21654 (2009).
Dunstan, E. et al. Metal ion levels after metal-on-metal proximal femoral replacements: a 30-year follow-up. J Bone Joint Surg Br 87, 628–631, 10.1302/0301-620X.87B5.15384 (2005).
Schaffer, A. W., Pilger, A., Engelhardt, C., Zweymueller, K. & Ruediger, H. W. Increased blood cobalt and chromium after total hip replacement. J Toxicol Clin Toxicol 37, 839–844 (1999).
Pandit, H. et al. Pseudotumours associated with metal-on-metal hip resurfacings. J Bone Joint Surg Br 90, 847–851, 10.1302/0301-620X.90B7.20213 (2008).
Willert, H. G. et al. Metal-on-metal bearings and hypersensitivity in patients with artificial hip joints. A clinical and histomorphological study. J Bone Joint Surg Am 87, 28–36, 10.2106/JBJS.A.02039pp (2005).
Catelas, I. & Wimmer, M. A. New insights into wear and biological effects of metal-on-metal bearings. J Bone Joint Surg Am 93 Suppl 2, 76–83, 10.2106/JBJS.J.01877 (2011).
Auffan, M., Rose, J., Wiesner, M. R. & Bottero, J. Y. Chemical stability of metallic nanoparticles: a parameter controlling their potential cellular toxicity in vitro. Environ Pollut 157, 1127–1133, 10.1016/j.envpol.2008.10.002 (2009).
Kwon, Y. M. et al. Dose-dependent cytotoxicity of clinically relevant cobalt nanoparticles and ions on macrophages in vitro. Biomed Mater 4, 025018, 10.1088/1748-6041/4/2/025018 (2009).
Petit, A. et al. Induction of protein oxidation by cobalt and chromium ions in human U937 macrophages. Biomaterials 26, 4416–4422, 10.1016/j.biomaterials.2004.11.019 (2005).
Ertunga, N. S. et al. Cloning, expression, purification and characterization of fructose-1,6-bisphosphate aldolase from Anoxybacillus gonensis G2. J Biochem 141, 817–825, 10.1093/jb/mvm085 (2007).
Macomber, L., Elsey, S. P. & Hausinger, R. P. Fructose-1,6-bisphosphate aldolase (class II) is the primary site of nickel toxicity in Escherichia coli. Mol Microbiol 82, 1291–1300, 10.1111/j.1365-2958.2011.07891.x (2011).
Scibior, D. & Czeczot, H. [Catalase: structure, properties, functions]. Postepy Hig Med Dosw (Online) 60, 170–180 (2006).
Trumbo, P., Yates, A. A., Schlicker, S. & Poos, M. Dietary reference intakes: Vitamin A, vitamin K, arsenic, boron, chromium, copper, iodine, iron, manganese, molybdenum, nickel, silicon, vanadium and zinc. J Am Dietetic Assoc 101, 294–301, 10.1016/S0002-8223(01)00078-5 (2001).
Bowie, E. A. & Hurley, P. J. Cobalt chloride in the treatment of refractory anaemia in patients undergoing long-term haemodialysis. Aust N Z J Med 5, 306–314 (1975).
Davis, J. E. & Fields, J. P. Experimental production of polycythemia in humans by administration of cobalt chloride. Proc Soc Exp Biol Med 99, 493–495 (1958).
Finley, B. L., Monnot, A. D., Paustenbach, D. J. & Gaffney, S. H. Derivation of a chronic oral reference dose for cobalt. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol 64, 491–503, 10.1016/j.yrtph.2012.08.022 (2012).
Jaimet, C. H. & Thode, H. G. Thyroid function studies on children receiving cobalt therapy. J Am Med Assoc 158, 1353–1355 (1955).
Katz, S. A. & Salem, H. The Toxicology of Chromium with Respect to Its Chemical Speciation - a Review. J Appl Toxicol 13, 217–224, 10.1002/jat.2550130314 (1993).
Bowsher, J. G., Hussain, A., Williams, P. A. & Shelton, J. C. Metal-on-metal hip simulator study of increased wear particle surface area due to ‘severe’ patient activity. Proc Inst Mech Eng H 220, 279–287 (2006).
Davda, K., Lali, F. V., Sampson, B., Skinner, J. A. & Hart, A. J. An analysis of metal ion levels in the joint fluid of symptomatic patients with metal-on-metal hip replacements. J Bone Joint Surg Br 93, 738–745, 10.1302/0301-620X.93B6.25804 (2011).
Dobbs, H. S. & Minski, M. J. Metal ion release after total hip replacement. Biomaterials 1, 193–198 (1980).
Luetzner, J., Krummenauer, F., Lengel, A. M., Ziegler, J. & Witzleb, W. C. Serum metal ion exposure after total knee arthroplasty. Clin Orthop Relat Res 461, 136–142, 10.1097/BLO.0b013e31806450ef (2007).
McPhee, I. B. & Swanson, C. E. Metal ion levels in patients with stainless steel spinal instrumentation. Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 32, 1963–1968, 10.1097/BRS.0b013e318133aa0d (2007).
Newton, A. W., Ranganath, L., Armstrong, C., Peter, V. & Roberts, N. B. Differential distribution of cobalt, chromium and nickel between whole blood, plasma and urine in patients after metal-on-metal (MoM) hip arthroplasty. J Orthop Res 30, 1640–1646, 10.1002/jor.22107 (2012).
Jacobs, J. J. et al. Local and distant products from modularity. Clin Orthop Relat Res, 94–105 (1995).
Kadoya, Y. et al. Wear particulate species and bone loss in failed total joint arthroplasties. Clin Orthop Relat Res, 118–129 (1997).
Cannizzo, E. S., Clement, C. C., Sahu, R., Follo, C. & Santambrogio, L. Oxidative stress, inflamm-aging and immunosenescence. J Proteomics 74, 2313–2323, 10.1016/j.jprot.2011.06.005 (2011).
Scharf, B. et al. Age-related carbonylation of fibrocartilage structural proteins drives tissue degenerative modification. Chem Biol 20, 922–934, 10.1016/j.chembiol.2013.06.006 (2013).
Billi, F. & Campbell, P. Nanotoxicology of metal wear particles in total joint arthroplasty: a review of current concepts. J Appl Biomater Biomech 8, 1–6 (2010).
Campbell, P. et al. Histological features of pseudotumor-like tissues from metal-on-metal hips. Clin Orthop Relat Res 468, 2321–2327, 10.1007/s11999-010-1372-y (2010).
Grammatopoulos, G. et al. The correlation of wear with histological features after failed hip resurfacing arthroplasty. J Bone Joint Surg Am 95, e81, 10.2106/JBJS.L.00775 (2013).
Pandit, H. et al. Necrotic granulomatous pseudotumours in bilateral resurfacing hip arthoplasties: evidence for a type IV immune response. Virchows Arch 453, 529–534, 10.1007/s00428-008-0659-9 (2008).
Rudolf, E. & Cervinka, M. Trivalent chromium activates Rac-1 and Src and induces switch in the cell death mode in human dermal fibroblasts. Toxicol Lett 188, 236–242, 10.1016/j.toxlet.2009.04.019 (2009).
Rovetta, F. et al. Cobalt triggers necrotic cell death and atrophy in skeletal C2C12 myotubes. Toxicol Appl Pharmacol 271, 196–205, 10.1016/j.taap.2013.05.005 (2013).
Tkaczyk, C. et al. Investigation of the binding of Cr(III) complexes to bovine and human serum proteins: a proteomic approach. J Biomed Mater Res A 94, 214–222, 10.1002/jbm.a.32700 (2010).
Ray, P. D., Huang, B. W. & Tsuji, Y. Reactive oxygen species (ROS) homeostasis and redox regulation in cellular signaling. Cell Signal 24, 981–990, 10.1016/j.cellsig.2012.01.008 (2012).
Simonsen, L. O., Harbak, H. & Bennekou, P. Cobalt metabolism and toxicology--a brief update. Sci Total Environ 432, 210–215, 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2012.06.009 (2012).
Simonsen, L. O., Brown, A. M., Harbak, H., Kristensen, B. I. & Bennekou, P. Cobalt uptake and binding in human red blood cells. Blood Cells Mol Dis 46, 266–276, 10.1016/j.bcmd.2011.02.009 (2011).
Jagannathan, V., Singh, K. & Damodaran, M. Carbohydrate metabolism in citric acid fermentation. 4. Purification and properties of aldolase from Aspergillus niger. Biochem J 63, 94–105 (1956).
Beers, R. F., Jr & Sizer, I. W. A spectrophotometric method for measuring the breakdown of hydrogen peroxide by catalase. J Biol Chem 195, 133–140 (1952).
VZ is supported by the PhD program in Genetics and cell Biology at the University of Tuscia, Department of Ecology and Biology(DEB), Viterbo, Italy.
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
About this article
Cite this article
Scharf, B., Clement, C., Zolla, V. et al. Molecular analysis of chromium and cobalt-related toxicity. Sci Rep 4, 5729 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1038/srep05729
Scientific Reports (2021)
The variations of electrical resistivity and thermal conductivity with growth rate for the Zn–Al–Cu eutectic alloy
Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Electronics (2021)
Iron-Zinc Impregnated Biochar Composite as a Promising Adsorbent for Toxic Hexavalent Chromium Remediation: Kinetics, Isotherms and Thermodynamics
Chemistry Africa (2021)
Alpha lipoic acid antagonizes cytotoxicity of cobalt nanoparticles by inhibiting ferroptosis-like cell death
Journal of Nanobiotechnology (2020)
Suitability of MDA, 8-OHdG and wild-type p53 as genotoxic biomarkers in metal (Co, Ni and Cr) exposed dental technicians: a cross-sectional study
BMC Oral Health (2020)