Abstract
The highest qubit Ardehali inequality violation with 203 standard deviations is first experimentally demonstrated using the hyper-entangled four-photon-eight-qubit Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) state. Moreover, we experimentally investigate the robustness of the Ardehali inequality for the four-, six- and eight-qubit GHZ states in a rotary noisy environment systematically. Our results first validate the Ardehali' theoretical statement of relation between violation of Ardehali inequality and particle number and proved that Ardehali inequality is more robust against noise in larger number qubit GHZ states and provided an experimental benchmark for us to estimate the safety of quantum channel in the noisy environment.
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
Nonlocality is one of the most surprising and important features of quantum physics. It is firstly referred by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (EPR) and has been receiving an enormous attention and interest of scientists since Bell designed an inequality to expose it. Bell-type inequalities against local realism (LR) model not only plays a crucial role in fundamental research, but is also at the basis of nearly all quantum information protocols applying process, such as proving the security of quantum cryptography, the reduction of communication complexity, the estimates for the dimension of the underlying Hilbert space and the entangled games1,2,3,4. For example, in Ekert's quantum key distribution (QKD) protocol5, one encrypts the key into the non-compatible qubit and the security of quantum cryptography is based on maximal violation of local realism, that is, the greater of the violation value means that the QKD scheme is more security. So, it is useful to know the largest violation of a given Bell inequality that quantum mechanics makes possible, and, in addition, which quantum state will produce this violation6.
What's even more exciting is Mermin and Ardehali showed that quantum mechanics (QM) can violate the multi-particle Bell-type inequalities imposed by LR by an amount that grows exponentially with particle number n7,8, that is, going to higher entangled systems the conflict between QM and LR becomes ever stronger. Over the past years, great efforts have been devoted to generate and manipulate more qubits and get the larger violation between QM and LR. However, the effect of quantum mechanics violates the Bell inequalities by an amount that grows exponentially with the number of particles is difficult to observe in real experiments because the low multi-photon (n > 4) coincidence count rate and the higher double-pair emission noise effect9,10,11,12. To the best of our knowledge, the highest qubit number experimentally used to demonstrate to the violation of the multi-particle Bell-type inequalities is only six by now13. Fortunately, one can encode quantum information not only in the polarization of a single photon and in its spatial modes14, arrival time or orbital angular momentum as well15. Obviously, using the hyper-entangled technology, one can effectively achieve higher qubit entanglement states, which significatively reduces the decoherence problems and dramatically increases the efficiency of detecting EPR elments of reality16. So, hyperentangled photonic states have been experimentally realized17,18 and shown to offer significant advantages in quantum super-dense coding19, efficient construction of cluster states20,21 and multiqubit logic gates22.
Moreover, the robustness of multi-bit hyper-entangled system with noise has almost no further research. As we all know, in realistic applications, pure entangled states become mixed states due to different types of noise, which will lead to the failure of the information processing23,24. It is lucky that the violations of Bell inequalities provide a method to characterize the robustness of the entanglement against noise. Thus, the experimental investigations of the robustness of Bell's inequality of multi-particle hyperentanglement states have important physical significance and application value.
In this work, using the hyper-entangled four-photon-eight-qubit GHZ states with a fidelity of (79.6 ± 0.5)% exploited both the photons' polarization and spatial degrees of freedom, we demonstrated the highest qubit (eight qubits) Bell inequality violation with 203 standard deviations. Most importantly, we systematically experimentally investigated the robustness of the Bell-type inequality for the four, six, eight-qubit GHZ states in a rotary noisy environment and first proved that the Ardehali inequality is more robust in lager number bits GHZ states.
Results
Theoretical model
Using the Bell' theorem, Mermin7 derived an n-particle Bell inequality and Ardehali derived an optimized Bell inequality for an n-particle system in a GHZ state8. Consider an n-particle GHZ state , where Hi and Vi are horizontal and vertical polarization of i particle. According to the local realism assumption, the nonlocal character of the state |Φn〉 can be characterized if defined the operator A as A = A1 + A2, with
and
here σa and σb are defined as and , respectively. Using the generalized Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt lemma25, the upper bound of the function F can be got according to the assumption of LR
In comparison, the expected value of A standard rules of QM can be calculate as
It can be seen that quantum theoretic value exceeds the limit imposed by the premises of EPR by an exponentially large amount of 2(n − 2)/2 for n odd or 2(n − 1)/2 for n even.
For eight qubits states, the Ardehali operator can be shown as
Experiment model
Here we experimentally observed violation of Bell inequality in case of eight qubit GHZ state. The four-photon-eight-qubit hyperentangled state exhibit maximal both in polarization and spatial degrees of freedom, which can be shown as
here H and V denote horizontal and vertical polarization and H′ and V′ label two orthogonal spatial modes of the photons.
The first step to create an eight qubit GHZ state is produce a four photon entangled GHZ state by combining two polarization entangled pairs into a polarization beam splitter(PBS) which produced from SPDC process in BBO. The experimental setup is shown in Fig. 1a and the operating steps are similar to Refs. 18, 26, 27. In which two pairs of entangled photons are produced by spontaneous parametric down-conversion28 in the state in paths 1–2 and in paths 3–4, respectively. The photon 2 is combined with photon 3 on a polarizing beam splitter (PBS). When the polarization of the two photons is identical, the four-photon GHZ entanglement state is prepared.
Then, four qubits in spatial modes are added to construct eight-qubit cat state. Consider a polarized single-photon qubit in the state α|H〉 + β|V〉 that passes through a PBS (see Fig. 1b). The PBS separates the photon into two possible spatial modes H′ and V′, according to their polarization H and V, respectively. The state of this single photon can now be written as α|HH′〉 + β|VV′〉, an entangled state between its polarization and spatial degree of freedom. Thereby, the hyper-entangled 8-qubit GHZ state (6) can be created.
A noisy quantum channels Rx(±θ) (see Experimental result section) is experimentally simulated by using one half-wave plate (HWP) sandwiched with two quarter-wave plates (QWPs)29 (see Fig. 1(c)).
The operation for qubit i with probability λ i.e. noisy intensity is given by30, here λ is equivalent for every one of the qubits (The noise is only generated on the polarization qubits). The HWP is switched angles θ and the QWPs are set at 0° with respect to the vertical direction. In this way, the noisy quantum channel can be engineered with intensity λ = sin2(2θ). The measurement of polarization qubits is performed using HWPs, QWPs and Polarizers as shown in Fig. 1(d). We measure the spatial qubit by using an optical interferometer which combine the two pathes onto a non-polarizing beam splitter and controlling the relative phase with an adjustable delay between these two paths (see Fig. 1(b)).
Discussion
To verify that |H〉⊗4|H′〉⊗4 and |V〉⊗4|V′〉⊗4 are indeed in a coherent superposition, the measurement in the basis |H〉 ± eiθ|V〉(|H′〉 ± eiθ|V′〉) is preformed, where θ = kπ/8(k = 0, 1 … 7). The expectation values of the observable 〈Mk⊗8〉 = 〈(cosθσx + sinθσy)⊗8〉 are shown in Fig. 2. From the experimental result in Fig. 2, we can further calculate the fidelity of the 8-qubit cat state and confirm the presence of genuine multi-particle entanglement. For the 8-qubit GHZ state, the fidelity can be measured using the operator . According to the data shown in Fig. 2, the fidelity observed for the state prepared in our experiment is (79.6 ± 0.5)%, which is greatly exceed the minimum bound of 50%31. Thus, with high statistical significance, genuine n-qubit entanglement of the GHZ states created in our experiment is confirmed. Furthermore, we give the measurement results in the |H〉/|V〉(|H′〉/|V′〉) basis, as shown in Fig. 3 a, b and c for |Φ〉⊗4, |Φ〉⊗6 and |Φ〉⊗8, which show that the signal-to-noise ratio (defined as the ratio of the desired components to that of the other non-desired ones) is about 11:1, 8.97:1 and 7.04:1 respectively.
In the following, let us analyze the QM predictions for the eight-qubit GHZ state (6). As the polarization states of a photon are a realization of a qubit, one can represent it as |H〉 and |V〉. That is, they can be treated as the two eigenvectors of Pauli operator σz with eigenvalues +1 and −1, respectively. Adopting the methods of Refs. 26, we consider measurements of linear polarization H/V and +/− where and , or of circular polarization R/L, where and , can be represented as the two eigenstates of Pauli operator σy with eigenvalues ±1. For the convenience of presentation, we define a measurement of +/− linear polarization as an x measurement and one of R/L circular polarization as a y measurement.
The conflict between the quantum predictions for the GHZ states and local realism can be shown via violation of a suitable Ardehali inequality. In this case taking account of the errors is straightforward. A number of inequalities for n-particle GHZ states have been derived7,8,32,33. According to the optimal Bell inequality for eight-qubit GHZ state8, LR imposes a constraint on statistical correlations of polarization measurements on the eight-qubit system as the following
QM predicts with a maximal violation of the constraint of LR by an exponential factor of . To measure the expectation value of , we need to perform one hundred and twenty eight measurements such as measurement on qubit 8 is obtained if we insert in its path a quarter wave plate, whose optical axis is set at 45° with respect to the horizontal direction. Then, the two eigenstates of operator σa are converted into linear polarizations which are polarized along the directions of 22.5° and 67.5°. In the same way, the two eigenstates of operator σb can be converted into −67.5° and 22.5° linear polarizations. Substituting the experimental results into the left-hand side of inequality gives which violate the inequality (8) by over standard deviations, hence demonstrating the largest conflict between QM and LR using an eight qubits hyper-entangled GHZ states.
Next, we experimentally investigate the robustness of the Ardehali inequality for the eight-qubit GHZ states in noisy environment. We define as the violation of the Ardehali inequality and the , here Clhv is the up threshold of one inequality for local realism. Then the standard deviations of an entanglement test can be defined as28
where is the statistical error of the experiment. Table I shows our experimental results on the violation, statistical error and standard deviation at different noise levels. As a comparison, we give the results of four-bits and six-bits respectively. From the results shown in Table I, it can be seen that with different noise levels the experimental results of the violation, the standard deviations of the Ardehali inequality decrease accordingly. When θ = ±0°, the standard deviations of the Bell inequality in our hyper-entangled 8-qubit states is . Moreover, when θ ≥ 14° the measured value of Bell operator will not violate the Ardehali inequality. It is worth pointing out that the noise level of θ = 14° is three times of four photos GHZ states30 and twenty times of three photos GHZ states26 and at this noise level the Ardehali inequality still deviate LR verdict with standard deviations. It proves that the Ardehali inequality in hyper-entangled eight-qubit GHZ states is more robust against stronger noise.
It should be pointed out that the generation of the hyper-entangled state and the observation of the Ardehali inequality using hyperentanglement implies that some of the qubits are carried by the same photon, and, therefore cannot be spatially separated. So our setup cannot be used to close the locality loophole. However, the higher dimension entanglement state is helpful to relax the detection efficiencies required for closing the detection loophole in Bell tests13,16. At the same time, in both approaches, a good measure of nonlocality is the ratio between experimental value and the maximal possible value allowed by the local realistic theories. This measure is related both to the number of qubits needed to communicate nonlocally in order to emulate the experimental results by a local realistic theory and also to the minimum detection efficiency needed for a loophole-free experiment. In this sense, a higher value of this ratio, we experimentally demonstrated, is a significant step toward a loophole-free Bell test34,35.
In summary, using the hyper-entangled four-photon-eight-qubit GHZ states generated by exploiting both the photons' polarization and spatial degrees of freedom, we experimentally demonstrate the highest qubit Ardehali inequality violation with 203 standard deviations. It is important to point out that the higher violation is a basis for some quantum information processing process such as QKD. Moreover, we experimentally investigated the robustness of the Ardehali inequality for the four, six, eight-qubit GHZ states in a rotary noisy environment systematically and first proved that the Ardehali inequality with a higher qubit is more robust against noise. Our work, besides its significance in quantum foundations, could also be applied to investigate the basic quantum-information processing, such as quantum computation with linear optics36, topological error correction37 and quantum metrology38 and so on.
Methods
Generation of the hyper-entangled four-photon-eight-qubit GHZ states
A mode-locked Ti: sapphire laser outputs an infrared (IR) light pulse with a central wavelength of 780 nm, a pulse duration of 100 fs and a repetition rate of 80 MHz, which passes through a LiB3O5 (LBO) crystal and is converted to ultraviolet (UV) light pulse with a central wavelength at 390 nm and average power is 250 mW. Behind the LBO, five dichroic mirrors are used to separate the mixed IR and UV components. The ultraviolet light is focused on two β-barium borate (BBO) crystals to produce two pairs of entangled photons. Prisms ΔD1 is used to ensure that the input photons arrive at the PBS23 at the same time. Finally they are detected by fiber-coupled single-photon detectors and the coincidence events are registered by a programmable multichannel coincidence unit. Conceptual interferometer for implementation and analysis of hyper-entanglement. An incoming photon is split into two possible spatial modes by the PBS with regard to its polarization forming an Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen-like entangled state between the photons' spatial and polarization degrees of freedom. A Mach-Zehnder-type interferometer with an NPBS (Seord038088, CASTECH Co.)is used to coherently measure the spatial mode qubit and subsequently at both of its output ports conventional polarization analysis is carried out. QWP: quarter-wave plate; HWP: half-wave plate. The high visibility and the long-term stability (10 hour) of one interferometer used in our experiment are shown in Fig. 4.
References
Acin, A. et al. Device-independent security of quantum cryptography against collective attacks. Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 230501 (2007).
Buhrman, H., Cleve, R., Massar, S. & Wolf, R. D. Nonlocality and communication complexity. Rev. Modern Phys. 82, 665 (2010).
Brunner, N. et al. Testing the dimension of hilbert spaces. Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 210503 (2008).
Chuan, T. K. et al. Quantum discord bounds the amount of distributed entanglement. Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 070501 (2012).
Ekert, A. K. Quantum cryptography based on Bell's theorem. Phys. Rev. Lett. 67, 661 (1991).
Güney, V. U. & Hillery, M. Maximum quantum violations of a class of Bell inequalities. Phys. Rev. A 87, 052126 (2013).
Mermin, N. D. Extreme quantum entanglement in a superposition of macroscopically distinct states. Phys. Rev. Lett. 65, 1838 (1990).
Ardehali, M. Bell inequalities with a magnitude of violation that grows exponentially with the number of particles. Phys. Rev. A 46, 5375 (1992).
Zhao, Z. et al. Experimental violation of local realism by four-photon Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger entanglement. Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 180401 (2003).
Zhao, Z. et al. Experimental demonstration of five-photon entanglement and open-destination teleportation. Nature 430, 54 (2004).
Lu, C. Y. et al. Experimental entanglement of six photons in graph states. Nature Phys. 3, 91 (2007).
Yao, X. C. et al. Observation of eight-photon entanglement. Nature Photonics 6, 225 (2012).
Gao, W. B. et al. Bell inequality tests of four-photon six-qubit graph states. Phys. Rev. A 82, 042334 (2010).
Barreiro, J. T., Langford, N. K., Peter, N. A. & Kwiat, P. G. Generation of hyperentangled photon pairs. Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 260501 (2005).
Mair, A., Vaziri, A., Weihs, G. & Zeilinger, A. Entanglement of the orbital angular momentum states of photons. Nature 412, 313 (2001).
Barbieri, M., Martini, F. D., Mataloni, P., Vallone, G. & Cabello, A. Enhancing the violation of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen local realism by quantum hyperentanglement. Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 140407 (2006).
Schuck, C., Huber, G., Kurtsiefer, C. & Weinfurter, H. Complete deterministic linear optics Bell state analysis. Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 190501 (2006).
Gao, W. B. et al. Experimental demonstration of a hyper-entangled ten-qubit Schrödinger cat state. Nature Phys. 6, 331 (2010).
Barreiro, J. T., Wei, T. C. & Kwiat, P. G. Beating the channel capacity limit for linear photonic superdense coding. Nature Phys. 4, 282 (2008).
Chen, K. et al. Experimental realization of one-way quantum computing with two-photon four-qubit cluster states. Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 120503 (2007).
Vallone, G., Pomarico, E., Martini, F. D. & Mataloni, P. Active one-way quantum computation with two-photon four-qubit cluster states. Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 160502 (2008).
Lanyon, B. P. et al. Simplifying quantum logic using higher-dimensional Hilbert spaces. Nature Phys. 5, 134 (2009).
Almeida, M. L., Barrett, S. J., Toth, G. & Acin, A. Noise robustness of the nonlocality of entangled quantum states. Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 040403 (2007).
Bovino, F. A., Castagnoli, G., Cabello, A. & Linares, A. L. Experimental noise-resistant Bell-inequality violations for polarization-entangled photons. Phys. Rev. A 73, 062110 (2006).
Clauser, J. F., Horny, M. A., Shimony, A. & Holt, R. A. Proposed experiment to test local hidden-variable theories. Phys. Rev. Lett. 23, 880 (1969).
Lu, H. X., Zhao, J. Q., Cao, L. Z. & Wang, X. Q. Experimental investigation of the robustness against noise for different Bell-type inequalities in three-qubit Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states. Phys. Rev. A 84, 044101 (2011).
Lu, H. X., Zhao, J. Q. & Wang, X. Q. Characterization of a high-intensity three-qubit GHZ state using state tomography and Gisin's inequality. Phys. Lett. A 375, 1850 (2011).
Lu, H. X., Zhao, J. Q., Wang, X. Q. & Cao, L. Z. Experimental demonstration of tripartite entanglement versus tripartite nonlocality in three-qubit Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger class states. Phys. Rev. A 84, 012111 (2011).
Chen, Y. A., Zhang, A. N., Zhao, Z., Zhou, X. Q. & Pan, J. W. Experimental quantum error rejection for quantum communication. Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 220504 (2006).
Jungnitsch, B. et al. Increasing the statistical significance of entanglement detection in experiments. Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 210401 (2010).
Ryff, L. C. Bell and Greenberger, Horne, Zeilinger theorems revisited. Am. J. Phys. 65, 1197 (1997).
Belinskii, A. V. & Klyshko, D. N. Interference of light and Bell's theorem. Phys. Usp. 36, 653 (1993).
Żukowski, M. Bell theorem involving all settings of measuring apparatus. Phys. Lett. A 177, 290 (1993).
Almeida, M. L., Pironio, S., Barrett, J., Toth, G. & Acin, A. Noise robustness of the nonlocality of entangled quantum states. Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 040403 (2007).
Brunner, N., Young, A. B., Hu, C. Y. & Rarity, J. G. Proposal for a loophole-free Bell test based on spin-photon interactions in cavities. New J. Phys. 15, 105006 (2013).
Pan, J. W. et al. Multiphoton entanglement and interferometry. Ren. Mod. Phys. 84, 777(2012).
Yao, X. C. et al. Experimental demonstration of topological error correction. Nature 482, 489 (2012).
Jin, X. M. et al. Sequential path entanglement for quantum metrology. Sci. Rep. 3, 1779 (2013).
Acknowledgements
We thank C. Lu, W. Gao and O. Gühne for valuable discussions. This work was supported by the Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No.11174224), the Natural Science Foundation of Shandong Province (Grant No.ZR2011AL012, ZR2013FM001, 2013SJGZ10), the Science and Technology Development Program of Shandong Province(Grant No.2011YD01049) and Higher School Science and Technology Program of Shandong Province(Grant No.J13LJ54).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
H.X.L., L.Z.C. and J.Q.Z. had the idea for and initiated the experiment. H.X.L., Y.D.L. and X.Q.W. contributed to the general theoretical work. H.X.L., L.Z.C. and J.Q.Z. designed the experiment. J.Q.Z. and L.Z.C. carried out the experiment. Y.D.L. and X.Q.W. analysed the data H.X.L., L.Z.C. and J.Q.Z. wrote the manuscript. H.X.L. supervised the whole project.
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Rights and permissions
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported license. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/
About this article
Cite this article
Lu, HX., Cao, LZ., Zhao, JQ. et al. Extreme violation of local realism with a hyper-entangled four-photon-eight-qubit Greenberger-Horne-Zelinger state. Sci Rep 4, 4476 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1038/srep04476
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/srep04476
This article is cited by
-
Experimental investigation of the CHSH-class inequality and its robustness in noisy environments
Optoelectronics Letters (2017)
-
Experimental investigation of the information entropic Bell inequality
Scientific Reports (2016)
Comments
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.