Chemists usually synthesize molecules using stochastic bond-forming collisions of the reactant molecules in solution. Nature follows a different strategy in biochemical synthesis. The majority of biochemical reactions are driven by machine-type protein complexes that bind and position the reactive molecules for selective transformations. Artificial “molecular assemblers” performing “mechanosynthesis” have been proposed as a new paradigm in chemistry and nanofabrication. Here we present a simple non-proteinogenic machine-type molecule which drives the endergonic condensation of vanadate to cyclic tetravanadate using light as the energy source. The system combines selective binding of the reactants, accurate positioning, and active release of the product. Hydrolysis of the product prevents inhibition of further cycles. Our prototypic system demonstrates the prerequisites that are needed to selectively drive an endergonic reaction using an external energy source.
Most chemical processes in living organisms, unlike the larger part of synthetic chemistry, operate far from thermodynamic equilibrium1. Major advances in synthetic and supramolecular chemistry notwithstanding2,3,4,5, the control of artificial non-equilibrium systems is still in its infancy, and has been identified as a major challenge in chemistry6. To achieve control of such systems, a number of prerequisites have to be met that go beyond selective recognition and catalysis. A crucial point is to couple an exergonic process (driving reaction) to an endergonic reaction (driven reaction) in space and time to achieve an overall spontaneous process.
Here we demonstrate that a strong binding of the product in a ligand can drive an endergonic condensation (Fig. 1). Photochemical switching of the ligand to a non-binding state triggers the release of the product. Subsequent hydrolysis in solution allows for repeated cycles without product inhibition. While the system operates at thermodynamic equilibrium, it may serve as a prototype for the future development of biomimetic systems.
Vanadate condensation equilibria
For the rational design of our prototype system, the synthesis of ATP from ADP and phosphate and the non-ribosomal peptide synthetases served as paragons. We chose the endergonic condensation of monovanadate to cyclic tetravanadate (4 HVO42−+4H+ −>V4O124−+4 H2O) as the model reaction to be driven. As compared to the phosphate condensation, which would be closer to the ATP synthesis7, vanadate aggregation has the advantage of having a lower barrier of activation and therefore is easier to catalyze. Moreover, vanadium is one of the most NMR-sensitive nuclei in the periodic table8. Different vanadate aggregates give rise to distinct signals in the 51V-NMR spectrum, which can be unambiguously assigned, and whose concentrations thus can be easily determined by integration9. Their relative concentration depends on concentration, pH, and ionic strength of the solution (Fig. 2, for details see Supplementary Table 1, Supplementary Note 1, Supplementary Figs. 3 and 4)10,11.
At pH 9.5, and a total vanadate concentration of 1.5 mM, monovanadate HVO42− is the predominant species in solution (>95%) (Fig. 2). This monovanadate solution served as the starting point for the design of a supramolecular system driving the endergonic tetravanadate synthesis. We chose light as the external energy source because it is convenient to apply and no interfering byproducts are formed in contrast to chemical energy sources. Moreover, vanadates are completely inert towards light of wavelengths larger than 300 nm. Therefore, no direct impact on the vanadate condensation during irradiation was expected.
Design and synthesis of the photoswitchable ligand
To couple light energy to our photochemically inert reaction, we designed a ditopic, photoswitchable receptor12,13. The receptor consists of a photochromic azobenzene unit, and two Zn-cyclene moieties attached to both ends via methylene groups. Azobenzenes are very reliable, efficient, and frequently used photoswitches14, and Zn-cyclene is known to bind phosphates15 and vanadates9 even in water with high affinity. Upon irradiation with 365 nm light, the azobenzene isomerizes from its trans to the cis form, and light of 430 nm induces the isomerization back to the trans configuration. Thereby, the receptor performs a pincer-like motion (cis 1 ⇄ trans 1, Fig. 3).
The two binding sites (Zn-cyclene units) approach each other from a distance of about 11 Å (Zn–Zn distance, open form) to less than 4 Å (closed form). Density functional theory calculations (B3LYP/6-31 G*) predict that the cyclic tetravanadate fits exactly between the two Zn-cyclen units if the ditopic receptor is in the open trans configuration (monovanadate and divanadate are too small and the linear trivanadate is too large, Supplementary Figs. 12 and 13 and Supplementary Note 3). A second ligand can interact with the remaining four terminal oxygen atoms, thus wrapping the tetravanadate in a tennis ball-like fashion and preventing hydrolysis. The ditopic receptor in its closed cis configuration does not bind any vanadate species because the two binding sites are too close to each other. Thus, upon alternating irradiation with 365 and 430 nm the ditopic receptor switches between a non-binding mode and a configuration that is strongly and selectively binding cyclic tetravanadate. The ditopic receptor was prepared in a three-step synthesis (for details see Supplementary Fig. 1)16.
The monotopic ligand Zn-benzylcyclene12 served as a reference compound. NMR titrations following the 1H as well as the 51V NMR signals reveal that there is no measurable interaction between the closed cis-receptor and the vanadate in solution (Supplementary Fig. 7), whereas the monotopic receptor binds vanadate with a formation constant of log K = 3.812. We attribute the non-coordinating property of the ditopic cis-receptor to the fact that the two Zn2+ ions are bridged with water17, which blocks coordination with vanadate, whereas the Zn2+ ions are accessible in the monotopic reference compound12. Upon titration of a monovandate solution with the trans-receptor the 51V NMR signal of the monovanadate decreases and the signal of the bound cyclic tetravanadate (−575 ppm) appears. After addition of 0.7 equivalents of the trans-ligand the 51V NMR almost exclusively exhibits the tetravanadate signal (Supplementary Fig. 5). At this point 60% of the vanadate species in solution is bound as cyclic tetravanadate V4O124- (Supplementary Fig. 6). At very high concentrations divanadate is formed, which is in agreement with titration experiments with the monotopic reference compound12. To confirm the stoichiometry and to determine the stability of tetravanadate complex, the nonlinear sum of least square methods was applied to the 51V NMR data18,19,20,21 (Supplementary Tables 2 and 3, Supplementary Figs. 5–11 and Supplementary Note 2). The data confirm the 1:2 tetravanadate to ligand stoichiometry with a very large cumulative association constant of log β = 114.2 (Supplementary Table 3). The Gibbs free energy of complex formation (ΔG) from four molecules of protonated monovandate (HVO42−) and two azobenzene ligands under our experimental conditions is −68.3 kcal mol−1. Proton NMR spectra are also in agreement with the theoretically predicted binding mode. Whereas the 1H NMR spectrum of the closed form of the receptor does not change upon addition of vanadate, the phenyl proton signals of the open form broaden, and shift upfield by 0.3 ppm by anion–aromatic interactions22. The experimental value is in very good agreement with the calculated (GIAO B3LYP/6-31 G*) upfield shift of 0.4 ppm in the tennis ball-type complex compared to the free receptor (Supplementary Fig. 11). The signal broadening is due to the restriction of the conformational flexibility of the phenyl groups in the rigid complex.
The product is now stuck in the receptor and the situation corresponds to what Smalley coined the sticky finger problem23. However, upon irradiation with UV light (365 nm), the ligands can be converted to the non-binding cis configuration and the product is released. The free cyclic tetravanadate is not stable outside of the receptor under our experimental conditions (pH 9.53). It hydrolyses back to monovanadate with a half-life of 25 ms24. The switching of the vanadate aggregation states is impressively demonstrated by a 51V NMR experiment. Switching experiments were performed by alternating irradiation with 365 and 440 nm (Fig. 4). In the closed form of the receptor monovanadate is the predominant vanadate species in solution (83%). The small amount of tetravanadate (17%) can be attributed to incomplete conversion to the cis isomer in the photostationary equilibrium. Irradiation with 440 nm leads to the open form of the receptor accompanied by the condensation of the monovanadate to tetravanadate. Twenty-five percent of the monovanadate is transformed into tetravanadate. Subsequent closing of the receptor molecule through trans-cis isomerization results in the release of the tetravanadate, which hydrolyses instantly to monovanadate. The switching can be repeated for a large number of cycles without fatigue (Supplementary Note 4 and Supplementary Fig. 14).
From the 51V NMR titration data of the monotopic reference ligand9, and the ditopic ligand, the Gibbs free energy (ΔGrel) of four stages of the condensation reaction was determined (for details see Supplementary Table 5 and Supplementary Note 6). Note that the values do not include the energies of the ligand in cis and trans configuration, and are calculated based on the experimental conditions (see Fig. 5) to avoid ambiguities25. Binding of two monovanadate molecules to the ditopic ligand is slightly endergonic at our reaction conditions (values determined from the monotopic ligand9 assuming that there is no interaction between the two binding sites, which are ~11 Å apart). The condensation reaction forming the cyclic tetravanadate in the presence of the ligand is strongly exergonic (−68.3 kcal mol−1, stage c, Fig. 5), whereas it is endergonic without ligand in solution (+25.6 kcal mol−1, stage d). The 2:1 complex (stage c is the lowest point on the Gibbs free energy surface. Without further energy input the reaction would stop at this point and the ligand would not be available for further cycles (Fig. 3). Two equivalents of the ligand could only generate one equivalent of the product. A continuously operating assembler, however, has to operate many cycles without fatigue to justify the effort of its synthesis. In our case, active release of the product is achieved by photochemical switching of the ligand to the non-binding cis isomer. We would like to emphasize that this photochemically driven release of the product is the most energy-consuming process of the condensation cycle (in analogy to ATP synthase)26. Outside the ligand the cyclic tetravanadate is kinetically unstable and spontaneously hydrolyses back to monovandate (t1/2 = 25 ms)20. By switching of the ligand back to the trans isomer (440 nm) the next assembly cycle is started. Photoswitching experiments (irradiation with 365 and 440 nm in an alternating sequence) prove that our system performs a large number of cycles without detectable fatigue (Supplementary Note 4, Supplementary Fig. 14).
In conclusion, we have presented a prototype light-driven, molecular machine-type ligand, which mediates the endergonic condensation of monovanadate to cyclic tetravanadate. By positioning the reactants, the photoswitchable ligand guides the reactants through a specific reaction channel, and a molecule is formed that is not present in the starting solution, and which would not form spontaneously. Upon switching of the ligand to a non-binding state, the high energy cyclic tetravanadate is released and hydrolyses to monovanadate. The system does not exhibit measurable fatigue over a large number of cycles. Light energy is converted to chemical energy, similar to the formation of ATP from ADP and phosphate. Mechanosynthesis with artificial molecular assemblers is extremely challenging but worthwhile investigating. Developed up to the level of biochemical systems such as non-ribosomal peptide synthetases, and polyketide synthases, it would allow chemo-, regio-, and stereoselective synthesis without protecting groups or chiral auxiliaries, and has the potential to become an alternative paradigm in chemical synthesis. Moreover, molecular assemblers provide an alternative way of converting light into chemical energy.
Vanadate equilibria in solution as a function of pH and ionic strength
Calculation of relative free energies
Estimation of the light to chemical energy efficiency
See Supplementary Note 6.
The data that support the plots within this paper and other findings of this study are available from the corresponding authors upon reasonable request.
Fischbach, M. A. & Walsh, C. T. Assembly-line enzymology for polyketide and nonribosomal peptide antibiotics: logic, machinery, and mechanisms. Chem. Rev. 106, 3468–3496 (2006).
Meng, W. et al. An autonomous molecular assembler for programmable chemical synthesis. Nat. Chem. 8, 542–548 (2016).
Kassem, S. et al. Stereodivergent synthesis with a programmable molecular machine. Nature 549, 374–378 (2017).
De, Bo, G. et al. An artificial molecular machine that builds an asymmetric catalyst. Nat. Nanotech. 13, 381–385 (2018).
Lewandowski, B. et al. Sequence-specific peptide synthesis by an artificial small-molecule machine. Science 339, 189–193 (2013).
Coskun, A., Banaszak, M., Astumian, R. D., Stoddart, J. F. & Grzybowski, B. A. Great expectations: can artificial molecular machines deliver on their promise? Chem. Soc. Rev. 41, 19–30 (2012).
Hosseini, M. W. & Lehn, J.-M., Supramolecular catalysis: substrate phosphorylations and adenosine triphosphate synthesis with acetylphosphate catalysed by a macrocycle polyamine. Chem. Commun. 397–399 (1988).
Pregosin, P. S. Transition Metal Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (Elsevier, Amsterdam 1991).
Crans, D. C., Shin, P. K. & Armstrong, K. B. Application of NMR spectroscopy to studies of aqueous coordination chemistry of vanadium (V) complexes. Adv. Chem. 246, 303–318 (1995).
Pettersson, L., Hedman, B., Andersson, I. & Ingri, N. Multicomponent polyanions. 34. A potentiometric and 51V NMR study of equilibria in the H+−HVO4 2-system in 0.6 M NaCl medium. Chem. Scr. 22, 254–264 (1983).
Pettersson, L., Andersson, I. & Hedman, B. Multicomponent polyanions. 37. A potentiometric and 51V NMR study of equilibria in the H+-HVO4 2- system in 3.0 M sodium perchlorate medium. Chem. Scr. 25, 309–317 (1985).
Sell, H., Gehl, A., Sönnichsen, F. D. & Herges, R. Thermodynamic and kinetic stabilization of divanadate in the monovanadate/divanadate equilibrium using a Zn-cyclene derivative: towards a simple ATP synthase model. Beilstein J. Org. Chem. 8, 81–89 (2012).
Zhang, X. & Woggon, W.-D. A supramolecular fluorescence sensor for pyrovanadate as a functional model of vanadium haloperoxidase. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 127, 14138–14139 (2005).
Bandara, H. M. D. & Burdette, S. C. Photoisomerization in different classes of azobenzene. Chem. Soc. Rev. 41, 1809–1825 (2012).
Kimura, E., Aoki, S., Koike, T. & Shiro, M. A tris(ZnII-1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane) complex as a new receptor for phosphate dianions in aequeous solution. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 119, 3068–3076 (1997).
Maie, K., Mitsunobu, N. & Kazushige, Y. Conformational changes of DNA by photorirradiation of DNA-bis(ZnII-cyclen)-azobenzene complex. Nucleosides Nucleotides Nucleic Acids 25, 435–462 (2006).
Xiang, Q.-X. et al. Dinuclear macrocyclic polyamine zinc(II) complexes: syntheses, characterization and their interaction with plasmid DNA. J. Inorg. Biochem. 99, 1661–1669 (2005).
Cruywagen, J. Heyns, J, Vanadium(V) equilibria. Spectrophotometric and enthalpimetric investigation of the dimerization and deprotonation of HVO4 2-. Polyhedron 10, 249–253 (1991).
Ingri, N. et al. LAKE—a program system for equilibrium analytical treatment of multimethod data, especially combined potentiometric and nuclear magnetic resonance data. Chem. Scand. Acta 50, 717–734 (1996).
Schmidt, H., Andersson, I., Rehder, D. & Pettersson, L. A potentiometric and 51V NMR study of the aqueous H+/H2VO4 −/H2O2/L‐α‐alanyl‐L‐histidine system. Chem. Eur. J. 7, 251–257 (2001).
Del Piero, S., Melchior, A., Polese, P., Portanova, R. & Tolazzi, M. A novel multipurpose excel tool for equilibrium speciation based on Newton–Raphson method and on a hybrid genetic algorithm. Annali di Chimica 96, 29–49 (2006).
Schottel, B. L., Chifotides, H. T. & Dunbar, K. R. Anion π-interactions. Chem. Soc. Rev. 37, 68–83 (2008).
Drexler, K. E. & Smalley, R. E. Nanotechnol. CN Cover story 81, 37–42 (2003).
Crans, D. C., Rithner, C. D. & Theisen, L. A. Application of time-resolved 51V 2D NMR for quantification of kinetic exchange pathways between vanadate monomer, dimer, tetramer, and pentamer. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 112, 2901–2908 (1990).
Rosing, J. & Slater, E. C. The value of ΔG° for the hydrolysis of ATP. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 267, 275–290 (1972).
Boyer, P. D., Cross, R. L. & Momsen, W. A new concept for energy coupling in oxidative phosphorylation, based on molecular explanation of the oxygen exchange reactions. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 70, 2837–2839 (1973).
We gratefully acknowledge support by the German Research Foundation (DFG) via SFB 677.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.