The transfer of chirality from individual molecules to macroscopic objects, and the recognition of chirality on the macroscopic scale have potential for many practical applications, but they are still key challenges for the chiral research community. Here we present a strategy for visible chiral recognition by macroscopic assembly using polyacrylamide-based gels modified with β-cyclodextrin (βCD-gel) and d- or l-tryptophan (homochiral d- or l-Trp-gel), which differs from most methods reported, e.g., colorimetric or chromogenic methods, fluorescence, gel formation and collapse. The circular dichroism spectra demonstrate that the chirality of Trp molecules is successfully transferred and amplified in the corresponding Trp-gels. The chirality of the d- and l-Trp-gels is macroscopically recognized by the βCD-gel selectivity in aqueous NaCl through the amplification of interfacial enantioselective host–guest interactions.
Chirality is widely regarded as a biosignature and vital to living organisms at both the microscopic and macroscopic levels1. For example, proteins are formed from L-amino acids, whereas nucleic acids contain d-sugars such as d-deoxyribose or d-ribose. The biomacromolecules further organize to form cells and tissues to generate asymmetric conformations and physical properties on a macroscopic scale, e.g., the spiral structure of shells, cucumber tendrils, and asymmetric appendages of organisms; differences in optical activities, tastes, and smells for a pair of enantiomers2.
Although chirality transfer and chiral recognition from the microscopic to the macroscopic scale have promise for many practical applications, e.g., chiral separation3,4,5, optical memories and switches6,7,8,9, and functional sensors and actuators10,11,12,13, they still remain key challenges in artificial systems1,2,14. To scale up chirality, a supramolecular strategy is generally employed to obtain various chiral architectures via assemblies of chiral or achiral molecules through non-covalent interactions15,16,17. Another strategy is a polymeric method, in which rigid main-chain or chiral units appear as helical structures with exclusive handedness18,19,20. The local chiral signals of monomeric molecules are primarily transformed to conformational chiral information during chirality transfer15,21,22, and this information could be switchable instead of being permanent23,24,25, although preserving uniformity for local and global chirality is desirable for better understanding chiral amplification and recognition. Moreover, significant effort has been put into achieving visible observation of chiral recognition and discrimination on the macroscopic scale. Strategies include colorimetric or chromogenic methods26,27,28, fluorescence29,30,31, crystal morphology32,33, gel formation and collapse34,35,36, and wettability switching37,38,39. By contrast, simultaneously observing chiral discrimination via side-by-side comparison of a pair of enantiomers, as clearly as we distinguish our left and right hands, has rarely been reported.
Cyclodextrins, cyclic oligomers of d-glucopyranose units with a conical chiral cavity, have chirality sensing ability through host–guest interactions40,41,42. Consequently, cyclodextrins are employed in various matrixes for applicable enantiomeric selectivity and separation, e.g., microspheres, nanochannels, electrodes, and the stationary phase of columns43,44,45,46. Additionally, l-tryptophan (l-Trp) is an essential amino acid for the composition of proteins, whereas d-Trp has probiotic properties that can stimulate the immune system47. Trp molecules can be incorporated into β-cyclodextrins (βCD) or complexed with metals such as Pt(II) and Cu(I) owing to their high hydrophobicity and electron density48. βCD shows a slight chiral preference toward l-Trp over d-Trp due to steric hydrogen bonding during inclusion complex formation45,49,50.
On the basis of our previous studies of macroscopic molecular recognition51,52,53,54,55,56,57,58,59, herein we show visible macroscopic chiral recognition that relies on interfacial enantioselective host–guest interactions. The chiral signals of the d- or l-Trp residues are seeded into poly(acrylamide) (pAAm)-based hydrogels (d- or l-Trp(x)-gels), in which the chirality is successfully transferred and amplified to the macroscopic scale. The interactions between the pAAm-gel bearing βCD moieties (βCD-gel) and the d-Trp(x)-gel and L-Trp(x)-gel are investigated in aqueous solutions with different components. Under appropriate conditions, such as in aqueous NaCl, the βCD-gel can successfully discriminate the d-Trp(x)-gel from l-Trp(x)-gel on a macroscopic scale by amplifying enantioselective host–guest recognition through interfacial multisite interactions.
Synthesis and characterization of gels
Acrylamido d- or l-Trp (AC-Trp(d or l)) monomer was prepared from BOC (tert-butoxycarbonyl) protected BOC-Trp(d or l) in three steps (Supplementary Fig. 1–3). Homochiral D- or L-Trp(x)-gel (x denotes the mol% of AC-Trp(d or l) in the reaction mixture) was then prepared from the radical terpolymerization of acrylamide (AAm), N,N’-methylenebis(acrylamide) (MBA), and AC-Trp(d or l) monomers in DMSO using Irgacure 184 as the initiator under UV light at room temperature (Fig. 1). The resulting gels were washed with DMSO and immersed in excess water or 0.9 wt% aqueous NaCl (NaCl aq.). The βCD-gel was prepared according to our previous report56. Predetermined amounts of AAm, MBA, and mono(6-deoxyacrylamido)-β-cyclodextrin (5 mol%) were terpolymerized in water at room temperature using APS (ammonium persulfate) and TMEDA (tetramethylethylenediamine) as the initiator. The obtained βCD-gel was washed with water and immersed in excess of water or NaCl aq.
The chemical compositions for the d-Trp(x)-gel, l-Trp(x)-gel, and βCD-gel were determined by 1H FG-MAS-NMR, for which the ratios for each residue were practically the same as those in reaction mixture (Supplementary Fig. 4 and 5).
Gel swell-shrink properties in various aqueous solutions
The swelling properties of the d-Trp(x)-gel, l-Trp(x)-gel, and βCD-gel were observed and recorded after immersion in pure water, NaCl aq., or 10 mM aqueous Na2PdCl4 (Pd(II) aq.) for 3 days. Their swelling ratios (V/V0) and corresponding concentrations are illustrated in Fig. 2 (Supplementary Table 1).
d-Trp(x)-gel and l-Trp(x)-gel were as-synthesized from DMSO and expanded substantially after exchanging solvent molecules for water molecules (~24 and 31 times for x = 3 and 5, respectively, Supplementary Fig. 6). Accordingly, both d- and l-Trp(x)-gels become particularly fragile due to dramatic expansion. This finding greatly differs from that of our previous study, in which such hydrophobic aromatic residues were mostly aggregated, resulting in obvious gel shrinkage59. Thus, the remarkable swelling should be attributed to the strong ionic repulsion of the protonated Trp residues. Conversely, when immersed in NaCl aq., the swelling ratios were dramatically lower (1.87 and 1.78 for x = 3 and 5, respectively), which is likely due to the mitigation of the ionic repulsion between the protonated Trp residues60,61. Interestingly, serious shrinking was observed for the d- and l-Trp(x)-gels in Pd(II) aq. instead of expected swelling. The resulting gels were black and solidified, implying the formation of complexes between the Trp residues and Pd(II). This possibility was further examined by 1H-NMR of AC-Trp(L) in D2O, in which significant peak splits were detected after the addition of Na2PdCl4 (Supplementary Fig. 7). Moreover, a large amount of orange precipitate was observed in the clear D2O solution of AC-Trp(L) when NaPdCl4 was added. These phenomena demonstrated that the gel shrinkage was caused by complexation of Trp residues with Pd(II).
By contrast, the βCD-gel prepared from water swelled slightly in both pure water and aqueous NaCl. As the swelling ratios in water and NaCl aq. were nearly identical, the effect of NaCl on βCD-gel swelling is likely negligible. Conversely, the βCD-gel gradually shrunk and finally became brown in Pd(II) aq. (Supplementary Fig. 8). The shrinkage of the βCD-gel is likely the result of osmotic dehydration with slight Pd(II) accumulation because the gel was still soft and the process was relatively slow, i.e., 1~2 days for the βCD-gel but 2~3 h for the d- or l-Trp(x)-gel.
Effect of aqueous solution composition on gel interactions
Gel interaction studies of the d-Trp(5)-gel, l-Trp(5)-gel, and βCD-gel were sequentially performed in pure water, NaCl aq., and Pd(II) aq. First, pieces of the βCD-gel and d- and l-Trp(5)-gels were placed in a glass petri dish with pure water. After agitation, no gel interaction was observed (Fig. 3a; Supplementary Movie 1). By contrast, in NaCl aq., the βCD-gel immediately assembled with both d- and l-Trp(5)-gels without selectivity (Fig. 3b; Supplementary Movie 2). The formed checkered gel aggregate is sufficiently stable to be lifted, indicating strong adhesion between the βCD-gel and the d- and l-Trp(5)-gels. Finally, in Pd(II) aq., no gel interactions were observed (Fig. 3c; Supplementary Movie 3).
These observations indicate that the gel interactions are strongly dependent on the components of the aqueous solutions. In pure water, the d- and l-Trp(5)-gels are largely swollen, which results in extremely low concentrations of the Trp moiety (3.2 mM) (Fig. 2; Supplementary Table 1). Such low concentrations in the d- and l-Trp(5)-gels are not high enough to form sufficient host–guest complexes on the interface of the βCD-gel to bind them together. By contrast, in NaCl aq., the expansion of the d- and l-Trp(5)-gels is well controlled, and the concentrations of Trp residues are appropriately high (55 and 57 mM) and close to the concentration of the βCD residue in the βCD-gel (61 mM). Hence, sufficient host–guest interactions can occur on the interface of the βCD-gel and d- or l-Trp(5)-gels to make them bind strongly. The concentrations of d- and l-Trp residues in the d- and l-Trp(5)-gels and the concentration of βCD residues in the βCD-gel are highest in Pd(II) aq. (170, 198, and 138 mM); thus, the strongest affinities are expected for gel assemblies in that solution. However, no gel assemblies were formed. This lack of assembly is likely attributed to the aggregation of Trp moieties that formed complexes with Pd(II), which does not involve βCD. Therefore, both the concentration and bound/unbound state of the Trp moieties are fundamental for macroscopic gel assembly in this study.
Visible chiral recognition on a macroscopic scale
To test the possibility of macroscopic chiral recognition, the interactions of the d-Trp(3)-gel and l-Trp(3)-gel with the βCD-gel were investigated in NaCl aq. Interestingly, the βCD-gel assembled with the l-Trp(3)-gel to form an aggregate but did not interact with the d-Trp(3)-gel (Fig. 4a; Supplementary Movie 4). This observation demonstrates that the βCD-gel can enantioselectively differentiate between the d- and l-Trp(3)-gels on a macroscopic scale. Moreover, the binding ability out of NaCl aq. was also examined that the βCD-gel adhered to l-Trp(3)-gel instead of d-Trp(3)-gel after treating with water (Supplementary Fig. 9; Supplementary Movie 5).
Subsequently, rupture stress-strain measurements were carried out to evaluate the adhesion strengths of these gel assemblies. A pair of assembled βCD-gel and d- or l-Trp(x)-gel was removed from the NaCl solution and set on a tensile meter to measure the stress values as strain was applied (Supplementary Fig. 10; Supplementary Movie 6). From the results shown in Fig. 4b, the adhesion strengths for the βCD-gel with the d- and l-Trp(5)-gels show higher values (3070 and 4070 Pa, respectively) than those of the d- and l-Trp(3)-gels (2150 and 1066 Pa, respectively), suggesting that the adhesion strength for the gel assembly is concentration dependent. In the case of the same x, the adhesion of the βCD-gel with the l-Trp(x)-gel is always stronger than that of the d-Trp(x)-gel. Consequently, the adhesion strength for the βCD-gel and d-Trp(3)-gel is the weakest and is not sufficient for forming an assembly in NaCl aq.
To discover the reason for the difference in the interaction of the βCD-gel with the d- and l-Trp(x)-gels, the molecular interactions between βCD and Trp(D) and Trp(l) moieties were investigated using a model system consisting of water-soluble polyacrylamide modified with 1 mol% Trp moiety (pAAm/Trp(D or L), Supplementary Fig. 11). Using fluorescence, the association constant (Ka) values for βCD with residues of Trp(D) and Trp(L) were determined to be 896 and 1890 M−1, respectively (Supplementary Fig. 12). These values are much higher than the reported Ka values for βCD with native Trp(D) and Trp(L) molecules, i.e., 13 and 214 M−1 49. The higher Ka value for βCD with the Trp(L) moiety suggests that βCD prefers to bind to Trp(L) residues over Trp(D) residues. Thus, the macroscopic enantioselectivity of the βCD-gel for the d- and l-Trp(3)-gels is obviously due to the difference in host–guest molecular association, which is further amplified on the interface of gel assembly through multisite interactions.
Indeed, if the chiral signal has not been correctly transferred to the gel objects, that is, achiral or same chirality for the gels, then the above observation can more precisely be described as macroscopic enantiomeric selectivity than macroscopic chiral discrimination. Fortunately, the circular dichroism (CD) spectra of the d- and l-Trp(3)-gels showed opposite signals both in water and NaCl aq., suggesting that the gels had different homochiralities (Fig. 4c). Accordingly, the CD spectra for the monomers of AC-Trp(D or L) in water and NaCl aq. were also measured, which indicated the influence of NaCl component was almost negligible on CD spectra (Supplementary Fig. 13). In contrast to the curves for the Trp-gels matched well with AC-Trp monomers in water, the spectra for the Trp-gels in NaCl aq. became flatter and reduced gradually near shorter wavelength. This should be caused by the relatively high UV absorbance of Trp-gels in NaCl aq. owing to their higher Trp residue concentrations (Supplementary Figure 14 and 15). However, the signals for the indole group close to the chiral center of the Trp moiety (~280 nm) show similar tendencies for the d- and l-Trp-gels with relative AC-Trp(D) and AC-Trp(L) monomers both in water and NaCl aq., implying the chirality is successfully transferred and amplified in the corresponding gels without conformational chiral interference. This result has two main explanations, which are as follows: (1) the pAAm main-chain is water soluble and flexible enough to avoid helical structural transition, and (2) the ionic repulsion of protonated Trp residues prevents aggregation formation. Therefore, macroscopic chiral discrimination that relies on enantioselective host–guest interactions has been achieved (Fig. 5).
Assembly that depends on chiral recognition at various scales is not only crucial for living organisms but also of great importance in artificial systems. In this study, we reported visible chiral recognition via the macroscopic assembly of d-Trp(x)-gel, l-Trp(x)-gel, and βCD-gel. The gel interactions were strongly related to the components of the aqueous solutions, and in aqueous NaCl, the βCD-gel successfully differentiated between the d- and l-Trp(3)-gels, which possess opposite chirality through transter from chiral Trp moieties. This achievement was realized due to the amplification of enantioselective host–guest interactions on the interface of the gel assemblies.
Chiral discrimination became visible in this experiment owing to macroscopic selective gel assembly, a process as clear as distinguishing our left and right hands, which originally defined chirality. This visible distinction would be beneficial for improving the understanding of chirality not only for scientists but also for the general public. We believe that the work presented here may contribute to the development of chiral recognition and separation.
1H NMR spectra were measured using a JEOL JNM-ECA500 spectrometer. Solid–state 1H FG-MAS NMR spectra were recorded on a JEOL ECA-400 spectrometer with a sample spinning rate of 7 kHz. Chemical shifts were referenced to the solvent signals (2.49, 4.79, and 7.26 p.p.m. for DMSO-d6, D2O, and CDCl3, respectively). Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) were collected on a Thermo Fisher LTQ Orbitrap XL. Fluorescence spectra for solutions of the model systems were obtained on a HITACHI F-2500 spectrophotometer using a 1 cm quartz cuvette (λex = 290 nm). The absorption spectra were measured with a JASCO V-650 spectrometer. Circular dichroism spectra were determined by a JASCO J820 spectrometer. Gel assembly tests were carried out using an EYELA CM-1000 cute mixer. The agitation speed was fixed at ~450 rpm unless otherwise indicated. Stress-strain curves for gel assemblies were recorded using a Yamaden RE-33005 Rheoner creep meter. Each sample was prepared in a quartz mold with a 5 × 3 mm2 cross sectional area and measured at a rate of 0.1 mm s-1 at room temperature. The swelling ratios were obtained as follow: as-synthesized Trp-gels from DMSO was cut into several samples (V0), and every three of them were immersed in each solution, i.e., pure water, NaCl aq., and Pd(II) aq., respectively. After 3 days, the volumes of gels in each aqueous solution were determined (V) to give swelling ratios as V/V0. The βCD-gels were synthesized from water and their swelling ratios were obtained by following the same steps as mentioned above (Fig. 2 and Supplementary Table 1).
N-(Tert-butoxycarbonyl)-d-tryptophan (BOC-d-Trp) and N-(tert-butoxycarbonyl)-l-tryptophan (BOC-l-Trp) were purchased from Tokyo Chemical Industries Co. Ltd., and β-cyclodextrin (βCD) was obtained from Junsei Chemical. All other reagents and solvents were purchased from Nacalai Tesque Inc., Tokyo Chemical Industries Cod. Ltd., Wako Pure Chemical Industries Ltd. or Sigma-Aldrich Co. and used without further purification.
Synthesis of 2D and 2L
Acryloyl chloride (0.72 g, 8 mmol) in THF (5 mL) was added dropwise to a solution of 1D (or 1L) (1.4 g, 4 mmol) and triethylamine (TEA) (0.81 g, 8 mmol) in THF (35 mL) at 0 °C. The mixture was allowed to react for 1 h at 0 °C and then overnight at room temperature. The solution was concentrated and purified by silica gel chromatography to give the product 2D (or 2L) in 54 % yield (Supplementary Figure 1). See Supplementary Fig. 2 and 3 for 1H NMR spectra.
Synthesis of acrylamido d- or l-Trp (AC-Trp(D or L))
Trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) (1 mL, 13 mmol) was added dropwise to a solution of 2D (or 2L) (200 mg, 0.5 mmol) in DCM (1 mL) at 0 °C. The mixture was stirred for 1 h at 0 °C and an additional 1 h at room temperature. The reaction solution was poured into diethyl ether (50 mL) to generate a precipitate and then vacuum dried to give the final product (Supplementary Fig. 1). Yield 87%. ESI-MS: calcd. for (C16H20N4O2)+ = 301.17 ([M + H]+); m/z = 301.17, [M + Na]+ 323.15 for AC-Trp(D); [M + Na]+ 323.17, [M + K]+ 339.17 for AC-Trp(L). See Supplementary Figure 2 and 3 for 1H NMR spectra.
Preparation of the d- or l-Trp(x)-gel
A predetermined amount of acrylamide (AAm), N,N’-methylenebis(acrylamide) (MBA), and AC-TAm(D or L) were dissolved in DMSO (3.0 mL, total monomer concentration: 6.0 M). After purging with dry argon for 30 min, Irgacure 184 (1.0 mol%) was added to the monomer solution. The reaction mixture was placed in a 1 cm quartz cuvette and sealed. The cuvette was irradiated with UV light at room temperature for 3 h. The newly formed gel was washed with DMSO and excess water to remove traces of initiator and unreacted monomers.
Preparation of the model polymer of pAAm/Trp(D or L)
Predetermined amounts of AAm and AC-Trp(D or L) were dissolved in DMSO. After dry argon was used to purge the solution for 30 min, APS (1.0 mol%) was added to the monomer solution. The reaction mixture was placed in a cuvette equipped with a stirrer, and the cuvette was sealed. The cuvette was then warmed in an oil bath thermostated at 65 °C overnight. The reaction mixture was poured into excess methanol to give a precipitate. The newly formed polymer was recovered by filtration and dried under vacuum. See Supplementary Figure 11.
All data are available from the authors upon reasonable request.
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
This work was supported by the ImPACT Program of Council for Science, Technology, and Innovation (Cabinet Office, Government of Japan). The authors thank Dr. Naoya Inazumi (Osaka University) for the NMR measurements and Mr. Takuma Adachi (Osaka University) for assistance with the CD spectrum measurements.