Reconfigurable integrated structures with functions of Fabry–Perot antenna and wideband liquid absorber for radar system stealth

This paper proposes a functionally reconfigurable integrated structure of a Fabry–Perot (FP) antenna and wideband liquid absorber. First, a two-layer partial reflecting surface (PRS) has been designed. Then, a patch antenna is used to act as the source antenna. By combining the source antenna with the PRS, an FP antenna has been designed. What’s more, taking full advantage of the reflective properties of PRS, a liquid broadband absorber is then designed. Last, the integrated structure with two functions has been realized. It can be used as the FP antenna or the liquid absorber through the extraction and injection of ethanol. In this way, it is effective to switch between stealth and detection states which can be used in different electromagnetic environments. The PRS is elaborately tailored to serve as both a component of the FP antenna and the metal ground of the broadband liquid absorber. Then the integrated structure is realized by combining the FP antenna with the liquid absorber. The PRS is composed of patches on the top layer of the substrate and the square loop on the bottom. The liquid absorber is composed of a 3-D printed container, 45% ethanol layer and the PRS is used to serve as the metal ground. The formula of Mie resonance theory has been extended and used to design the liquid absorber. The gain of the antenna is 19.7 dBi when the ethanol is extracted. When the ethanol is injected, a wideband liquid absorber is achieved. The absorption band (S11 < − 10 dB) ranges from 4 to 18 GHz. The absorption bandwidth is over 133%. The monostatic RCS reduction bands of the structure with ethanol range from 4 to 18 GHz and the average RCS reduction is 28.4 dBsm. The measured and simulated results are in good agreement.

www.nature.com/scientificreports/metasurface has been also applied to the antenna systems to broaden the operating frequency band, improve radiation efficiency and gain and suppress the mutual coupling [17][18][19] .
The technologies proposed above are all based on inactive material.The properties of the antenna keep unchanged once processed.Meanwhile, this can't adapt to the complicated electromagnetic environment.With the design of active electronic components, such as p-i-n diodes 20,21 , varactors 22,23 and RF switches 24 , many multifunctional antennas have been designed which can adapt to complex electromagnetic environments.Unfortunately, these active electromagnetic components often affect the performance of antennas because of the parasitic effect and complex feed networks.So far, many liquid materials have been applied to absorbers [25][26][27][28] , antennas 29,30 , frequency selective surfaces 31,32 and so on because of their wide absorption band, transparency, reconfigurable properties, low-RCS, and low price.
To overcome the challenges of reconfigurable properties of FP antennas.This paper proposes a functionally reconfigurable integrated structure of FP antenna and wideband liquid absorber.The novelties and contributions of the design can be summarized as follows: (1) The liquid absorber and PRS of the FP antenna are designed integrally.Under the premise of not affecting the high gain of the antenna, the function switching of the wideband RCS reduction absorber is realized.(2) The formula of the Mie resonance theory has been extended and used to design different shapes of liquid absorbers.(3) Under the same height and metal ground condition, the topology of the wideband liquid absorber is constructed and selected.This paper will go as follows.First, the working mechanism of the integrated structure has been introduced.Then, the permittivity of the pure water and 45% ethanol solution is discussed.What's more, the design process of the liquid absorber and FP antenna has been discussed.Last, the property of the integrated structure has been introduced.
Working mechanism of the integrated structure.The working mechanism of the integrated structure is shown in Fig. 1.The structure has two functions.One is the liquid absorber, the other is the FP antenna.When the ethanol solution is injected into the structure, the source antenna doesn't work.Then the whole structure can be seen as the 3D container layer, the ethanol layer and the PRS.The PRS can be considered as the metal ground of the liquid absorber.In this way, the whole structure forms a wideband liquid absorber.On the contrary, when the ethanol solution is extracted from the structure, the source antenna comes into play.Then the whole system can be seen as the 3D container layer, the metal layer and the source.In this situation, the 3D container and the metal layer collaboratively form the PRS.It is noted that the amplitude and phase response of the PRS with 3D container is slightly different from that without 3D container.However, this slight difference can be overcome by changing the height of the FP resonator.The ethanol solution is controlled by the water cycle control system.The system used in this paper is the same as that in 17 .It takes about 40 s for the liquid to be completely evacuated from being filled.In this way, this structure can be used to switch between detection and stealth mode which can better adapt to the complex electromagnetic environment.
The permittivity of the pure water and 45% ethanol solution.The permittivity of pure water and 45% ethanol solution can both be described by the Debye formula.For pure water, the permittivity can be expressed by the formula as follows 31 : where ε ∞ (T), ε 0 (T) and τ(T) are the optical permittivity, static permittivity, and rotational relaxation time, respectively.The ε ∞ (T), ε 0 (T) and τ(T) are all directly dependent on the temperature T: Figure 1.The working mechanism of the integrated structure.
Design of the FP antenna and the liquid absorber.The unit cell of the PRS is shown in Fig. 3a, it is composed of the top metal patch, the F4B dielectric substrate (ε r = 2.2, tanδ = 0.0009) and the bottom metal loop.
The PRS has two functions: (1) acts as the metal ground of the absorber; (2) forms an FP cavity with the source antenna floor.The FP antenna consists of the PRS and the patch antenna which is served as a source, as shown in Fig. 3b.The source antenna is fed by a SMA connector at the back of the patch as shown in Fig. 3c.
Although it can improve the absorption property of the absorber with a high reflection magnitude of the PRS, the antenna's gain will decrease.Therefore, it must make a compromise between the absorption property of the liquid absorber and the gain of the FP antenna.As shown in Fig. 4a, with the increase of the width of the top patch w 1 , the reflection magnitude of the PRS at 10 GHz will increase.However, the gain of the antenna at 10 GHz decreases as proposed forward.Last, the intersection of two curves of the reflection magnitude of PRS and the gain of the antenna has been chosen.
The height of the FP resonant cavity can be designed according to the following equation 1,33 : where φ 1 and φ 2 are the reflection phase of PRS and the metal ground, respectively.λ is the wavelength of operating frequency.N is the resonance mode number of the resonant cavity and here only the zero-order (N = 0) is considered to make the antenna keep a low profile.Here, φ 1 = − 130°, as shown in Fig. 4b.φ 2 = 180° which is the reflection phase of the metal ground.λ is the wavelength of 10 GHz which is the operating frequency of the FP antenna in this work.Therefore, by Eq. ( 1), the calculated value of the height of the FP resonant cavity h = 9.6 mm.The optimized parameters are as follows: w 1 = 8.6 mm, p = 12 mm, w 2 = 8.6 mm.As the finish of the PRS, the metal ground of the liquid absorber has been fixed.To expand the low-frequency absorption bandwidth of the liquid absorber under the fixed metal ground, two shapes of liquid absorbers are compared.One is the truncated cone-shaped structure, the other is the prismatic-shaped structure.Each unit cell of the liquid absorber consists of three layers: the 3d container layer (ε r = 2.8, tanδ = 0.0318), the liquid layer and the metal ground.The only difference is their shape.As shown in Fig. 5a, keep the bottom diameter and the height of the truncated absorber unchanged, the first resonant frequency of the truncated cone-shaped absorber will go lower frequency with the increase of the top diameter d 1 .Similarly, the first resonant frequency of the prismatic absorber will also go lower frequency with the increase of the top width W 1 , as shown in Fig. 5b.However, compared to the truncated absorber, the first resonant frequency of the prismatic absorber is lower under a similar size.
To verify this conclusion, the Mie resonance theory has been introduced.According to 34 , the first resonant frequency can be described by the following formulas:  where f is the first-order Mie resonance, r is the radius of the spherical medium.c is the velocity of light, ε p and μ p are the permittivity and permeability of the material of the particle, respectively.F(φ) is the function which is related to φ.Under the first-order Mie resonance, φ = π.In 31 , a modified formula (8) has been given in the case of the water block.However, this doesn't apply to our situation because there are more parameters of the liquid absorber which are analyzed.Therefore, formula (8) has been modified by the following: where f i is the impact factor of the absorber.n is the number of the impact factor and k i is the influence coefficient of each impact factor.b is the constant variable and is related to the shape of the liquid absorber.
Taking the truncated cone-shaped absorber as an example, three impact values have been considered: the basal diameter, the height of the absorber and the top diameter.Therefore, r can be calculated by the following equation: where d 1 , d 2 and h 11 are the top diameters, the bottom diameter and the height of the truncated cone-shaped absorber, respectively.Here, k 0 = 0.005, k 11 = 199.1,k 12 = 164.8,k 13 = 310.1,b 1 = 9.58.Similarly, for the prismaticshaped absorber, r can be described as: where W 1 , W 2 and h 21 is the top width, the bottom width and the height of the prismatic-shaped absorber, respectively.Here, k 21 = 265.4,k 22 = 186.1,k 23 = 311.3,b 2 = 9.81.To verify the correction of Eq. ( 4), The first resonant frequency of the truncated absorber with different top diameter d 1 and the first resonant frequency of the prismatic absorber with different top width W 1 have been shown in Fig. 6a and b, respectively.
From Eq. ( 6), we can find that f becomes smaller when r becomes bigger.When keeping the bottom diameter and the height of the truncated cone-shaped absorber unchanged, it can be known from Eq. ( 9) that with the increase of the top diameter, r will become larger, resulting in a decrease in f.This is consistent with the conclusion put forward.From Eqs. (10) and (11), we can find that k 21 > k 11 , k 22 > k 12 , k 23 > k 13 and b 1 ≈ b 2 .Therefore, when the two shaped absorbers have the same height (h 11 = h 21 ), metal ground (d 2 = W 2 ), and top length (d 1 = W 1 ), r 2 > r 1 .In other words, the first frequency of the prismatic-shaped absorber is lower than that of the truncated cone-shaped absorber.Last, the prismatic absorber has been chosen to realize good absorption properties at low frequencies.
In order to facilitate processing, a base layer is added to the container and this almost has no effect on the property of the liquid absorber.The unit cell of the absorber has been shown in Fig. 7a.It is composed of three layers: the 3D container, the 45% ethanol layer and the metal.A prismatic 3D container has been designed to enclose the liquid.To facilitate the circulation of liquid between adjacent unit cells, the water channels have been designed between adjacent units.To achieve good impedance matching in a wide band, 45% ethanol is chosen to replace water.The reason has been introduced in 30 .The optimized parameters are shown as follows: w 3 = 5 mm, w 4 = 8 mm, w 5 = 3 mm, w 6 = 7 mm, h 2 = 10 mm, h 3 = h 5 = 5 mm, h 4 = 9 mm.
The S 11 of the absorber has been simulated and measured, as shown in Fig. 7c.It is noted that lens antennas 35 and vector network analyzer 5245A are chosen to measure the S 11 of the liquid absorber due to size constraints  of the liquid absorber, as shown in Fig. 7b.The absorption band of the absorber ranges from 4 to 18 GHz.The difference between measurement and experiment is affected by the following factors: (1) it is difficult to ensure that the container is completely filled with ethanol; (2) a small amount of misalignment of the 3D container and ethanol concentration is unavoidable in such a setup.The absorption property of the liquid absorber can maintain until 50°, as shown in Fig. 8.
Structure and the property of the integrated structure.www.nature.com/scientificreports/ each adjacent unit cell of the liquid absorber to ensure the circulation of the ethanol.An ethanol outlet and an ethanol inlet are designed to ensure fluid injection and extraction.Square patches and square loops are placed on both sides of the substrate which form the PRS, as shown in Fig. 9b and c.The patch antenna is used as the excitation source and it is fed by a SMA connector as proposed forward.It is noted that the height of the FP resonant cavity h with container is lower than that without container because of the existence of the 3D container.
To verify the performance of the FP antenna, the antenna has been processed and measured.The container structure which is used to enclose liquid is fabricated by 3D printed technology.The PRS and the microstrip patch antenna are fabricated by the PCB technology.The container is installed on the PCB board with glass glue to ensure that the entire container is watertight.Figure 10a    We can find that the band of RCS reduction is consistent with the absorption band of the absorber.When the frequency is below 4 GHz, the RCS of the two states of the structure keeps almost unchanged.When the frequency is higher than 4 GHz in the absorption band of the absorber, the RCS reduction is noticeable.The average RCS reduction is 28.4 dBsm.To better explain the good properties of the proposed structure, a comparison between the existing low-RCS antennas or metasurfaces has been made.As shown in Table 1, it can be found that this

Conclusion
A structure that can serve as the FP antenna or wideband liquid absorber has been proposed in this paper.When the ethanol is injected, the structure acts like an absorber.When the ethanol is extracted, the structure acts like an FP antenna.This can be applied to the radar system stealth.With the convertible modes, the structure can adapt the complex electromagnetic environment.When the ethanol is injected to the structure, the structure acts as the liquid absorber which contributes to the stealth of the radar system.The absorption band ranges from 4 to 18 GHz.The absorption bandwidth is over 133%.When ethanol is extracted from the structure, the structure acts as the FP antenna.The antenna operates at 10 GHz and the gain of the antenna is 19.7 dBi which can help the radar system detect.The structure possesses reconfigurable RCS by injecting or extracting and this can adapt to the complex electromagnetic environment.The RCS of the integrated structure is reduced from 4 to 18 GHz and 28.4 dB average RCS reduction is realized.The formula of the Mie resonance theory has been extended to a different structure of liquid absorber and this can help instruct readers to design liquid absorbers.

Figure 3 .
Figure 3. (a) Unit cell of the PRS (b) 3D structure of the FP antenna.(c)The feeding diagram of the source antenna.

Figure 4 .
Figure 4. (a) Reflection magnitude of the PRS and the gain of the antenna with different w 1 at 10 GHz.(b) Reflection magnitude and phase of the PRS.

Figure 5 .
Figure 5. (a) S 11 of the truncated cone-shaped liquid absorber with different top diameters d 1 (b) S 11 of the prismatic-shaped liquid absorber with different widths of top bottom W 1 .
Figure 9a shows the 3D structure of the FP antenna.It is composed of a 3D container which is used to encapsulate ethanol.Channels are set up between

Figure 6 .
Figure 6.(a) The first resonant frequency of the truncated cone-shaped absorber with different top diameters d 1 .(b) The first resonant frequency of the prismatic-shaped absorber with different top widths W 1 .

Figure 7 .
Figure 7. (a) The unit cell of the liquid absorber.(b) Measurement setup of the S 11 of the absorber.(c) Simulated and measured S 11 of the liquid absorber.
and b show photographs of the fabricated FP antenna and PRS.The simulated and measured S 11 of the FP antenna is shown in Fig. 11a.The operating frequency is about 10 GHz.The operating bandwidth is about 100 MHz.The antenna gain at 10 GHz is 19.7 dB, as shown in Fig. 11b.The radiation pattern of the FP antenna has been measured.The test scene is shown in Fig. 12.The radiation patterns of the antenna have been shown in Fig. 13a and b.The monostatic RCS of the structure is shown in Fig. 14.

igure 8 .
S 11 of the prismatic-shaped liquid absorber with different incident angle.

Figure 9 .
Figure 9. (a) 3D sketch of the FP antenna.(b) Front of the PRS.(c) Back of the PRS.

Figure 12 .
Figure 12.Measurement setup of the radiation performance.

Figure 13 .
Figure 13.Radiation patterns of the proposed antenna at 10 GHz.(a) E-plane (b) H-plane.

Figure 14 .
Figure 14.Monostatic RCS of the integrated structure antenna for normal incidence.

Table 1 .
Comparisons (Simulated Results) with other structures.