Author Correction: iTRAQ-based quantitative proteome analysis insights into cold stress of Winter Rapeseed (Brassica rapa L.) grown in the field

Winter rapeseed (Brassica rapa L.) is a major oilseed crop in Northern China, where its production was severely affected by chilling and freezing stress. However, not much is known about the role of differentially accumulated proteins (DAPs) during the chilling and freezing stress. In this study, isobaric tag for relative and absolute quantification (iTRAQ) technology was performed to identify DAPs under freezing stress. To explore the molecular mechanisms of cold stress tolerance at the cellular and protein levels, the morphological and physiological differences in the shoot apical meristem (SAM) of two winter rapeseed varieties, Longyou 7 (cold-tolerant) and Lenox (cold-sensitive), were explored in field-grown plants. Compared to Lenox, Longyou 7 had a lower SAM height and higher collar diameter. The level of malondialdehyde (MDA) and indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) content was also decreased. Simultaneously, the soluble sugars (SS) content, superoxide dismutase (SOD) activity, peroxidase (POD) activity, soluble protein (SP) content, and collar diameter were increased in Longyou 7 as compared to Lenox. A total of 6330 proteins were identified. Among this, 98, 107, 183 and 111 DAPs were expressed in L7 CK/Le CK, L7 d/Le d, Le d/Le CK and L7 d/L7 CK, respectively. Quantitative real-time PCR (RT-qPCR) analysis of the coding genes for seventeen randomly selected DAPs was performed for validation. These DAPs were identified based on gene ontology enrichment analysis, which revealed that glutathione transferase activity, carbohydrate-binding, glutathione binding, metabolic process, and IAA response were closely associated with the cold stress response. In addition, some cold-induced proteins, such as glutathione S-transferase phi 2(GSTF2), might play an essential role during cold acclimation in the SAM of Brassica rapa. The present study provides valuable information on the involvement of DAPs during cold stress responses in Brassica rapa L, and hence could be used for breeding experiments.

www.nature.com/scientificreports/ root system, guaranteeing its safe overwintering and vegetativeness construction 11,12 . Growth regulation of the SAM is controlled partly by localized auxin biosynthesis and gradients and thus suggests a role of the hormone in cold tolerance 13 . Given the apparent role of the SAM in conferring cold tolerance, the current study aimed to investigate differences at the morphological, physiological, and molecular levels localized within the SAM of two turnip rape genotypes divergent in cold tolerance. Specifically, a differential proteomics approach using an isobaric tag for relative and absolute quantification (iTRAQ) was employed 14 . This gel-free mass spectrometry technique has been successfully applied to identify differentially accumulated proteins involved in stress response across various plants such as Vitis amurensis 15 , Triticum aestivum 16 , Gossypium hirsutum L 17 , Lycopersicon esculentum Mill 18 , Brassica rapa L 19 , and Spica Prunellae 20 . Proteins showing localized differences in abundance can be targets for marker-assisted selection and used to improve breeding efficiency 14 . More importantly, this knowledge gives fundamental insight into the direct role of the SAM in controlling abiotic stress tolerance in plants.
The SAM depression and bulge in the seedling might be associated with their strong cold resistance. The functions of SAM target protein regulations have not yet been examined. Thus, the objective of the present study is to explore the relationship between SAM-target proteins regulations and cold stress tolerance. The proteins identified can be used to understand the molecular mechanisms underlying cold resistance. Proteins showing localized differences in abundance can be targets for marker-assisted selection, thus improving breeding efficiency. More importantly, this knowledge gives fundamental insight into the direct role of the SAM in controlling abiotic stress tolerance in plants.

Results
Physiological development and cold tolerance. The morphological and physiological differences between the cold-tolerant Longyou 7 and cold-sensitive Lenox were studied at the seedling stage under cold stress. Longyou 7 had a creeping petiole with leaves growing nearly prostrate (Fig. 1A), whereas Lenox had an upright petiole with leaf habit (Fig. 1B). When grown in an open field, the height of the shoot apical meristem (SAM) levels was measured at the different growth stages. A high SAM of Lenox was recorded at − 11 °C (d) compared to 0 °C (CK). Moreover, the height of the SAM of Lenox was significantly higher than Longyou 7   (Fig. 1C,D,L). Compared with the 0 °C, the collar diameter of Longyou 7 and Lenox was significantly increased during freezing stress at − 11 °C, and among both varieties, Longyou 7 showed higher collar diameter (Fig. 1C,D,K). Compared with the L7 d and Le d, the level of SOD and POD activity and SP and SS content significantly decreased in the L7 CK and Le CK samples ( Fig. 1G-J). The MDA content significantly increased in L7 CK and Le CK. The IAA content of Le d was higher than that of L7 d (Fig. 1E). The MDA and content of Le CK and Le d were significantly higher than that of L7 CK and L7 d (Fig. 1F). These results suggested that Longyou 7 had smaller SAM but higher tolerance to freezing stress compared with Lenox. Strong cold-resistant varieties such as Longyou 7 were found to have a smaller SAM in the samples collected from field experiments, which were 5-10 cm below the soil surface. Thus, the SAM was located in sheltered moist soil under a relatively stable temperature, which is beneficial for winter B. rapa to the overwinter. These findings demonstrated an association between seedling SAM position and cold tolerance.
iTRAQ-Based quantitative proteome analysis. Previous RNA-seq and iTRAQ-based quantitative proteome analysis applied on leaves and roots tissues were limited to obtaining relative differences in the genes or proteins expression under a controlled environment and did not account for the localized difference in the SAM. Our present study had demonstrated that DAPs were used to evaluate relative differences in protein expression as cold acclimation progressed under field conditions from early autumn to winter. The field trials were designed to capture the big picture of global changes of the proteomics during cold acclimation in Longyou 7 and Lenox varieties of B. rapa. The iTRAQ-based quantitative proteome analysis was performed in both varieties. The analysis of protein was performed using 8-plex iTRAQ-based comparative proteome analysis. Three independent biological replicates were simultaneously performed. After using Mascot to search against the Brassica-rapa 1.0 database, a total of 6 328 proteins were identified (Supplementary  Table S5).

Classification of cold responsive DAPs.
To obtain the function of DAPs, all quantified proteins were searched through the UniProt-GOA database (https:// www. ebi. ac. uk/ GOA/) and gene ontology (GO) annotation (http:// www. panth erdb. org/). In total, 2669 identified proteins were annotated with GO terms. The top enriched GO terms of the DAP are shown in Fig. 3 and Supplementary Table S6. Cellular components, biological processes, and molecular function were assigned among DAPs based on the results of GO analysis. In L7d/Le d, most DAPs represented categories were hydrogen peroxide catabolic process, response to jasmonic acid and cadmium ion, and response to oxidative stress in biological_process. In addition, represented categories were chloroplast, cytosol, cell wall, vacuole, apoplast, and chloroplast stroma in cellular component; and heme-binding, peroxidase activity, and glutathione transferase activity in molecular function ( Fig. 3 and Supplementary  Table S6).
To further characterize the functions of the DAPs, KEGG pathway mapping was performed. KEGG enrichment analysis displayed the pathways of DAPs in L7 d/Le d. 24 DAPs were down-regulated in L7 d/Le d was found to be associated with glutathione metabolism (brp00480), thiamine metabolism (brp00730), and starch and sucrose metabolism (brp00500). Conversely, 6 DAPs up-regulated in L7 d/Le d were found to be associated with glutathione metabolism (brp00480), linoleic acid metabolism(brp00591), alpha-Linolenic acid metabolism brp(brp00592), pentose phosphate pathway(brp00030), phenylpropanoid biosynthesis(brp00940), and carotenoid biosynthesis(brp00906).

Discussion
Proteomic analysis has identified many differentially accumulated proteins related to plant secondary metabolism in germinated seeds under cold stress 21 . In this study, a large number of cold stress-responsive proteins were identified in winter turnip rape. Previously several candidate genes had been identified by EST analysis which may be involved in cold stress response in winter turnip rape 5,6 . However, the mechanisms underlying the effect of cold stress on SAM are largely unknown. Therefore, physiological and proteomic analyses were performed in this study to examine the mechanism of the increased freezing tolerance in winter tunip rape at the SAM.
Freezing stress affects morphology, physiological and biochemical changes in Brassica rapa. Freezing stress (< 0 °C) detrimentally affects plant growth and development, limits their geographic distribution, and significantly reduces agronomic productivity 22 . During the natural cooling process, plants change their morphological, physiological, and biochemical characteristics due to low-temperature stress, especially freezing 23 . The main target of freezing injury is the cell membranes rupture due to the expanding aqueous cellular content upon freezing. The lipids, peroxide, and MDA contents could reflect the damage of plants under low temperatures. The regulation of osmotic adjustment substances such as soluble protein and MDA could maintain the cellular structure and osmotic balance 24 . Meanwhile, MDA acts as a cell structure maintainer, a signaling molecule, and a ROS scavenger in response to cold stress. Among these, SOD and POD are the key antioxidant enzymes under stress 25,26 . These trends were observed in our data, where a decrease in the content of SS, IAA, MDA, and SP was observed in the control compared to the freezing stress treatment. Further, SOD and POD activity decreased in the CK compared to freezing stress (Fig. 1C) which is also in line with previous work [27][28][29] . Increased osmotic adjustment substance content could reduce the freezing point to increase plant cell mem-   30,31 . Linoleic and alpha-Linolenic acids play key roles in maintaining membrane integrity and fluidity and have been demonstrated to contribute to the osmotic tolerance in rice 32 . Our observation that enriched fatty acid metabolism-related proteins were differentially accumulated between the SAM of the costtolerant and cold-susceptible genotypes is therefore in agreement with published works. In a previous study, lipoxygenase (LOX) could damage cell membranes and other cell components. LOX2 was down-regulated stress and also played a key role in JA biosynthsis 33,34 . In this study, DAPs were involved in Linoleic acid, alpha-Linolenic acid, glycolipid, sphingolipid metabolism, and fatty acid degradation. Only fatty acid degradation was   35,36 . BAM was involved in the starch and sucrose metabolism 37,38 . It was reported that beta-amylase 5 (BAM5) might play an important role in the petunia response to cold stress 39 and was upregulated under heat stress 40 . The enzyme BAM accumulates SS under stress conditions 41 . Cold stress increased the content of soluble sugar and the activity of β-amylase 42 . Our study showed that the content of soluble sugar increased during cold stress, and BAM5(Bra038088) was down-regulated in L7 d/Le d and L7 CK/Le CK. This provides a new direction for future research in B. rapa under cold stress. cold/freezing stress in Arabidopsis, mycelia, loquat, and peach [43][44][45][46] . Glutamate decarboxylase (GAD) catalyzes the conversion of glutamate (Glu) to γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) 47 . GABA plays multiple roles in plant stress adaptation and ROS scavenging 48 . Thus, glutamate played an important role in amino acid metabolism 49 . Glutamate decarboxylase isoenzymes (GAD2) played a negative role in tolerance to freezing stress 50 . In the present study, GAD2(Bra004136, Bra004137) has low log2 FC in L7 d/Le d and L7 CK/Le CK, which is in line with previous work 50 . Therefore, GAD2 might play some essential roles in response to the cold stress in the B. rapa under cold stress.

DAPs involved in translation.
Posttranslational modification (PTM) in Brassica juncea cold stress systems include S-nitrosylation 51 and confers the glutathione S-transferase (GST) under oxidative stress 52 . GSTs are a major family of detoxification enzymes that protect plants against oxidative damage 53 . Auxin induced the expression of several GSTs such as GSTF2, which get up-regulated and might be linked with stress-mediated growth responses 52 . It was found that GSTF2 enhanced the tolerance to cold stress in wheat 53 . Our study showed that higher SAM height indicated relatively high levels of IAA content, while a relatively smaller SAM indicated relatively low levels of IAA content; hence, auxin content is profoundly related to the SAM height. Also, five GSTs (Bra000875, Bra021673, Bra000876, Bra036259, and Bra012409) and DHAR 1 (Bra025749) were downregulated, while GSTU (Bra012422, Bra000474) and GSTs (Bra032010) were up-regulated in L7 d/Le d. The increased accumulation of these proteins indicated that plant cells initiated their antioxidant mechanisms to maintain redox homeostasis and resist cold stresses. Also, GST was involved in posttranslational modification in L7 d/ Le d and L7 CK/Le CK. It played a crucial role in improving the genetics of low-temperature tolerance in plants.

Conclusion
In this study, two winter different winter turnip rapa cultivars (Longyou 7 and Lenox) of Brassica rapa L. with different phenotypes for cold stress were used to analyze molecular mechanisms for the cold response. Based on the proteomics data, it was found that major proteins were involved in metabolic pathways through differentially accumulated proteins (DAPs) in both winter turnip rape varieties (Longyou 7 and Lenox) under cold stress.
In addition, based on the functional analysis, we concluded that DAPs involved in amino acid, carbohydrate, lipid, and energy metabolism, which showed that DAPs greatly changed freezing stress of winter turnip rape. In summary, these findings improve our understanding on the molecular mechanism of freezing tolerance, which helps in breeding winter turnip rape against the cold stress.

Methods
Plant materials, field, sample collection. Two different winter turnip rapa cultivars were used in this study. Longyou 7 is a cold-tolerant variety, and Lenox is a cold-sensitive variety; both were collected from Gansu Agricultural University (Gansu, China). Plants were grown and maintained following local best agronomic practices. Seeds were sown in the field on August 20, 2018, and the seedlings emerged on August 27. The experiment was conducted in a normal agronomic field trial at the Gansu Research Center of Rapaseed Engineering and Technology in Lanzhou, China. Three rows of Longyou 7 and Lenox, respectively, were planted. Each row was 2 m long, with a row spacing of 20 cm and plant spacing of 10 cm under manual spot seeding. Seedling emerged within 7-10 days after sowing. Three replicates were prepared for each cultivar in the field. Samples were harvested on October 13 (five true leaves stage) as control (CK). Samples were taken on December 16 (seven true leaves stage) as a treatment (d). Measurements of the height of SAM and collar diameter were subsequently taken on October 13 and December 16, 2018. Data were collected daily at average daily minimum temperature (Tmin) from October to December. The Tmin was 0 °C On October 13 and − 11 °C on December 16. The temperature of October 13 and December 16 is the mean value of the lowest temperature in 15 days. The samples for analysis were named, Le CK (sample of "Lenox" at 0 °C October 13), Le d (SAM of "Lenox" at − 11 °C), L7 CK (SAM of "Longyou 7" at 0 °C), and L7 d (SAM of "Longyou 7" at − 11 °C). SAM (shoot) was collected from four to six plants in each point and replicates. Plants were collected in the field between 10:30 am and 11:30 am to minimize the circadian rhythm effect for each sampling point. The SAM (less than a 1 cm long section at the crown base, Fig. 2B) was used periodically for physiological analyses. SAM was flash-frozen in liquid nitrogen and stored in a freezer at − 80 °C. SAM was used for conducting physiological analyses, RNA extraction, and iTRAQ analysis.
Morphological and physiological analyses. Height of SAM and collar diameter were determined using a vernier caliper. The samples were analyzed in triplicates. POD activity 54 , CAT activity 54 , SS content 55 , IAA content 56 , SP and MDA content 57 were analyzed as indicators of physiological response. The majuscules indicated a significant difference (p < 0.05) for the freezing stress-treated samples compared with chilling stressed samples. Values are the means and SD of three biological replicates, each calculated from the mean of three technical replicates.
Protein extraction. Three biological replicates were used for iTRAQ-based comparative proteomics analysis. Approximately 500 mg from each biological replicate was ground into powder using liquid nitrogen and dispersed in (vortex blending) 500 µL extraction buffer (0.7 M sucrose, 0.1 M NaCl, 0.5 M Tris-HCl (pH 7.5), 50 mM EDTA and 0.2% DTT). The samples were homogenized at 60 Hz for 2 min. Then the extraction buffer (1 mL) was added and mixed, followed by adding Tris-phenol buffer and mixing for 30 min at 4 °C. The homogenates were centrifuged at 7100×g for 10 min at 4 °C. The supernatant was collected, added to five 0.1 M cold ammonium acetate methanol buffer volumes, and stored at − 20 °C overnight.
The homogenates were centrifuged at 12,000×g for 10 min to collect precipitations. The methanol was replaced with acetone, and the steps used to obtain precipitate were repeated. Next, the samples were centrifuged at 12,000×g for 10 min at 4 °C to collect supernatants. The supernatants were dried at room temperature for 5 min and dissolved in sample lysate form 2 h. The supernatants were centrifuged again to remove precipitations completely. The protein concentration was quantified using a commercial bicinchoninic acid assay following the manufacturer's protocol (Thermo Fisher Scientific). The assay was performed in a microwell plate with three technical replicates for each sample against a bovine serum albumin standard curve.
Protein digestion, iTRAQ labeling, and RP chromatography separation. For proteomic analysis, 15 µg of protein from each sample was separated on a 12% polyacrylamide gel. Protein digestion was performed according to the FASP procedure 58 . IAA was added to the final concentration of 50 mM in the dark for 40 min. The protein solutions were centrifuged at 12,000×g for 20 min at 4 °C. The supernatant was collected, and 100 mM tetraethylammonium bromide (TEAB, pH 8.0) was added before centrifuging at 12,000×g for 20 min. The solutions were collected and lyophilized. The lyophilized samples were suspended in TEAB (100 μL, 50 mM), and 40 μL of each sample was transferred into new tubes for iTRAQ labeling. The iTRAQ labeling reagent (iTRAQ® Reagents-8plex kit, Sigma) was used following the manufacturer's protocol (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA, USA). All labeled peptides were pooled together. Subsequent analyses were performed at the Shanghai Luming biology center (Shanghai, China). iTRAQ labeled peptides were fractionated by RP chromatography using the 1100 HPLC System (Agilent). RP separation was performed on the Agilent Zorbax Extend RP column (5 μm, 150 mm × 2.1 mm). Tryptic peptides were separated at an eluent flow rate of 300μL min −1 and monitored at 210 and 280 nm. Dried samples were harvested from 8 to 50 min, and elution buffer was collected every minute, numbered from 1 to 10 chronologically. The separated peptides were lyophilized for MS detection 59 . The protein concentration was quantified using the BCA method, and the protein purity was detected by SDS-PAGE 60 .
Mass spectrometry analysis. Compared with MS, LC-MS analyses were performed on a Q-Exactive mass spectrometer (Thermo, USA) equipped with a Nanospray Flex source (Thermo, USA). The peptides mixtures were loaded by a capillary C18 trap column (3 cm × 100 μm, C18, 3 μm, 150 A) and separated by a C18 column (15 cm × 75 μm, C18, 3 μm, 120 A) on a ChromXP Eksigent system (AB Sciex). Full MS scans were acquired in the mass range of 300-1600 mass compared with a mass resolution of 70,000, and the AGC target value was set at 1,000,000. The 10 most intense peaks in MS were fragmented with higher-energy collisional dissociation (HCD) with a collision energy of 30%. MS spectra were obtained with a resolution of 17,500 with Protein identification and function annotation. Raw data of iTRAQ-labeled proteins were compared against the Brassica rapa genome protein database at the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) using the Proteome Discoverer TM 2.2 (Thermo, USA). Database searches were performed with trypsin digestion specificity, and the cysteine alkylation option was applied. For the protein quantification method, the iTRAQ 8-plex was chosen. A decoy database search approach was used for protein identification to determine the false discovery rate (FDR) with an acceptance threshold of FDR < 1.0%, while protein identification required at least two peptides. The molecular functions of the identified proteins were classified according to their gene ontology annotations and their biological functions. Only the proteins identified with at least two different peptides (p < 0.05), and quantified with a ratio of fold change (FC) > 1.5 or FC < 0.8 were considered. The NCBI (https:// www. ncbi. nlm. nih. gov/) and Uniprot databases (https:// www. unipr ot. org/) were chosen for the validation and annotation of the protein sequences. Gene Ontology (GO) annotation for the identified proteins was assigned to the Uniprot database (http:// geneo ntolo gy. org/). The Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) (http: www. kegg. jp/ kegg/ kegg1. html) was used to predict the main metabolic pathways 62 .
RNA extraction and qPCR analysis of gene expression. Three biological replicates and three technical replicates were performed for each gene. According to the manufacturer's instructions, the total RNA from the SAM was extracted by using TRNzol Universal Reagent (Tiangen, China). 1 μg of total RNA from each sample was used for first-strand cDNA synthesis according to the protocol supplied with PrimeScript™ RT Master Mix (TaKaRa Biotechnology Dalian, China). Genes for analysis were selected, and primers were designed using Primer-BLAST (https:// blast. ncbi. nlm. nih. gov/ Blast. cgi) (Bethesda, MD, USA) based on the sequences of the selected indigenes. Actin was selected as reference genes. qRT-PCR amplification reactions were performed using a LightCycler®96 Real-Time PCR System (Roche, Basel, Switzerland). Genes were assayed in technical triplicates for each sample. The relative gene expression was calculated using the 2 − ∆∆Ct method 63 . The primer sequences were designed by Primer-BLAST (https:// blast. ncbi. nlm. nih. gov/ Blast. cgi) (Bethesda, MD, USA) based on the sequences of the selected indigenes (Supplementary Table S8). Mean values and standard errors were calculated from three independent experiments with three biological replicates, and relative expression was calculated using Actin's 2 − ∆∆Ct method as the reference.
Statistical analysis. The control and treatment groups were analyzed for statistical significance of differences between multiple groups using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by Duncan's multiple comparisons test. All calculations were performed using SPSS software (version 19.0, IBM, Armonk, NY, USA). All results are presented as mean ± standard deviation from three independent biological replications. Treatment means were separated by the Duncan multiple range test at P < 0.01. We used the minmax normalization method through the R programming language to analyze transcriptional and proteomic data and presented expression values using heat maps.