Two-dose messenger RNA vaccines against the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) are highly effective in preventing symptomatic COVID-19 infection. However, the durability of protection is not known, nor is the effectiveness against emerging viral variants. Additionally, vaccine responses may differ based on prior SARS-CoV-2 exposure history. To investigate protection against SARS-CoV-2 variants we measured binding and neutralizing antibody responses following both vaccine doses. We document significant declines in antibody levels three months post-vaccination, and reduced neutralization of emerging variants, highlighting the need to identify correlates of clinical protection to inform the timing of and indications for booster vaccination.
Two-dose messenger RNA vaccines (BNT162b2/Pfizer and mRNA-1273/Moderna) against the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) are highly effective in preventing symptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infection1,2. However, the durability of protection, particularly with the emergence of viral variants of concern, is not known. Furthermore, the response to vaccination may differ based on prior SARS-CoV-2 exposure history.
In an IRB-approved community-based serological study, we compared vaccine response in 27 study participants (mean age 39.7 years, 51.9% female, 59.3% Pfizer, 40.7% Moderna). Participants who were seropositive (n = 13) and seronegative (n = 14) prior to vaccination were included. Four seropositive individuals had PCR confirmed COVID-19 infections; remaining seropositive individuals had asymptomatic cases. Samples were collected after the first dose (mean 18.5 days), and twice after the second dose (20.7 days and 56.3 days). Total duration of follow up after first vaccination was approximately 3 months (mean 95.5 days) (Table 1). SARS-CoV-2 receptor binding domain (RBD) IgG was measured with a quantitative immunoassay3, and a surrogate virus neutralization test (sVNT) was used to measure inhibition of binding to the ACE2 cell receptor in vitro of wild-type (Wuhan) SARS-CoV-2 spike, as well as the following spike variants: B.1.1.7, B.1.351, and P.14.
Overall, median anti-RBD IgG level increased five-fold after the second vaccine dose in comparison with the first dose (4.2 μg/mL vs 21.0 μg/mL) (Fig. 1A). Median inhibition against wild-type spike was 59.1% after the first dose and 97.7% after the second (Fig. 1B). However, responses were significantly lower to P.1 (27.1% and 70.0%), B.1.351 (34.2% and 66.7%), and B.1.1.7 (45.9% and 92.0%). Median anti-RBD IgG concentration dropped 50.1% at three months post-vaccination relative to the expected peak concentration after the second vaccine dose, and IgG after dose 2 predicted IgG at three months (Fig. 1C). Median inhibition against all the variants was lower at three months, with the largest declines in surrogate neutralization of P.1 (31.2%) and B.1.351 (27.5%), and smaller declines for B.1.1.7 (18.4%) and wild type (12.5%).
We investigated whether pre-vaccination SARS-CoV-2 exposure history influences the magnitude or durability of response to vaccination. Three months after first vaccine dose, median anti-RBD IgG was higher for seropositive participants with a PCR confirmed diagnosis of COVID-19 (27.2 µg/mL) in comparison with participants who were seronegative (8.7 µg/mL), as well as participants who tested seropositive for prior exposure but had asymptomatic infections (8.2 µg/mL). There were no significant differences in levels of surrogate neutralization of spike-ACE2 interaction between pre-vaccination seronegative and seropositive participants (Wilcoxon rank-sum, all comparisons p > 0.70). Neutralization of all the variants was higher for pre-vaccination PCR positive cases in comparison with pre-vaccination seronegative/seropositive participants (Fig. 1D).
We document lower levels of inhibition of spike-ACE2 binding for emerging variants of concern, and significant reductions in anti-RBD IgG and surrogate neutralization of all variants 3 months after a first mRNA vaccine dose. Consistent with a recent report5, we find stronger vaccine responses following prior PCR-positive SARS-CoV-2 infection. Importantly, these stronger responses were limited to participants with PCR confirmed cases of COVID-19, and were not seen among those who did not experience symptoms or were seronegative. A large proportion of SARS-CoV-2 infections are asymptomatic6, and our results indicate that seropositivity alone is not sufficient to predict a robust antibody response to vaccination. Recent data suggest that lower responses to vaccination are associated with increased risk of breakthrough infection: Among vaccinated healthcare workers in Israel monitored from January to April 2021, neutralizing antibody and anti-spike IgG titers were significantly lower in workers with breakthrough infections in comparison with matched, uninfected controls7. The B.1.1.7 variant was detected in 85% of the breakthrough infections. While antibody neutralization of emerging variants may be reduced in comparison with the ancestral strain of SARS-CoV-2, T cell reactivity following vaccination or natural infection has been shown to be similar across strains and may reduce the severity of COVID-19 if a breakthrough infection occurs8. The decline in antibody levels over three months post-vaccination, and the relatively reduced neutralization of variants of concern, point to an urgent need to identify correlates of clinical protection to inform the timing of and indications for booster vaccination.
A subset of participants that were enrolled in a larger seroprevalence study of over 8000 residents of the Chicagoland area (Screening for Coronavirus Antibodies in Neighborhoods (SCAN)), provided multiple, self-collected finger stick dried blood spot (DBS) samples from April 2020 through May 20219. Participants provided consent online and completed a survey regarding COVID-19 status and symptoms. Participants received materials for finger-stick DBS collection through the mail or on-site. DBS samples were returned through the mail or on-site. In January and February 2021, participants completed an additional survey reporting COVID-19 vaccination status and dates of vaccination and were asked to provide a DBS sample approximately three weeks after receiving dose 1, two weeks after receiving dose 2, and then again approximately 60 days after receiving dose 2. Participants were categorized based on pre-vaccination RBD IgG serology. Participants were categorized as COVID-19 PCR + if they reported testing positive for SARS-CoV-2 on a clinical molecular diagnostic test for acute infection any time prior to vaccination. Participants who lacked self-report of a positive SARS-CoV-2 clinical diagnostic test result were categorized as seropositive if anti-RBD IgG antibodies were detected in DBS samples collected between April and December 2020, while those without detectable levels of RBD IgG were categorized as seronegative. All research activities were performed in accordance with relevant guidelines and regulations with protocols approved by the institutional review board at Northwestern University (#STU00212457 and #STU00212472). All participants provided informed consent.
Anti-RBD IgG assay
Antibodies against SARS-CoV-2 receptor binding domain (RBD) were quantified with an established protocol validated for use with DBS samples which shows high agreement with results from matched serum samples (R = 0.99)3,10. Results were normalized to the CR3022 antibody with known affinity to RBD11. Anti-RBD IgG concentration (µg/ml) was calculated from the four parameter logistic regression of the CR3022 calibration curve. A value > 0.39 µg/ml CR3022 was considered seropositive.
Surrogate virus neutralizing test
A multiplex competitive immunoassay was used to quantify neutralizing activity (% inhibition) of spike-ACE2 interaction in vitro. The protocol was previously validated for DBS, with high agreement with results from matched serum samples (R = 0.99)4. Samples were incubated with human recombinant ACE2 conjugated with an electrochemiluminescent label in assay wells coated with an array of SARS-CoV-2 spike protein variants, including wild type, D B.1.1.7, B.1.351, P.1, and D614G (Meso Scale Discovery K15436U). The Meso Scale Discovery QuickPlex SQ 120 Imager was used to read mean fluorescence intensity (MFI), and % inhibition was calculated as follows: % inhibition = 100 × 1 − (sample MFI/negative control MFI). Prior validation studies indicate that results from the surrogate virus neutralization method correlate highly with results from conventional live virus (Pearson R = 0.93) and pseudovirus neutralization assays (R = 0.92)12.
Polack, F. P. et al. Safety and efficacy of the BNT162b2 mRNA Covid-19 vaccine. N. Engl. J. Med. 383, 2603–2615 (2020).
Baden, L. R. et al. Efficacy and safety of the mRNA-1273 SARS-CoV-2 vaccine. N. Engl. J. Med. 384, 403–416 (2021).
McDade, T. et al. High seroprevalence for SARS-CoV-2 among household members of essential workers detected using a dried blood spot assay. PLoS ONE 15, e0237833 (2020).
Sancilio, A. E. et al. A surrogate virus neutralization test to quantify antibody-mediated inhibition of SARS-CoV-2 in finger stick dried blood spot samples. Sci. Rep. 11, 15321 (2021).
Saadat, S. et al. Binding and neutralization antibody titers after a single vaccine dose in health care workers previously infected qith SARS-CoV-2. JAMA 325, 1467–1469 (2021).
Oran, D. P. & Topol, E. J. Prevalence of asymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infection: A narrative review. Ann. Intern. Med. 173, 362–367 (2020).
Bergwerk, M. et al. Covid-19 breakthrough infections in vaccinated health care workers. N. Engl. J. Med. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa2109072 (2021).
Tarke, A. et al. Impact of SARS-CoV-2 variants on the total CD4+ and CD8+ T cell reactivity in infected or vaccinated individuals. Cell Rep. Med. 2, 100355 (2021).
Demonbreun, A. R. et al. Patterns and persistence of SARS-CoV-2 IgG antibodies in a US metropolitan site. J. Clin. Investig. 6, e146148 (2021).
Amanat, F. et al. A serological assay to detect SARS-CoV-2 seroconversion in humans. Nat. Med. 26, 1033–1036 (2020).
Yuan, M. et al. A highly conserved cryptic epitope in the receptor binding domains of SARS-CoV-2 and SARS-CoV. Science 368, 630–633 (2020).
Tan, C. W. et al. A SARS-CoV-2 surrogate virus neutralization test based on antibody-mediated blockage of ACE2–spike protein–protein interaction. Nat. Biotechnol. 38, 1073–1078 (2020).
Financial support for this research from the National Science Foundation (BCS-2035114), National Institutes of Health (3UL1TR001422-06S4), and the Northwestern University Office of Research is gratefully acknowledged. The funding sources had no role in the study design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, or writing of the report.
Thomas McDade has a financial interest in EnMed Microanalytics, a company that specializes in laboratory testing of dried blood spot samples. All other authors declare no conflicts of interest.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
McDade, T.W., Demonbreun, A.R., Sancilio, A. et al. Durability of antibody response to vaccination and surrogate neutralization of emerging variants based on SARS-CoV-2 exposure history. Sci Rep 11, 17325 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-96879-3
This article is cited by
Monitoring of Both Humoral and Cellular Immunities Could Early Predict COVID-19 Vaccine Efficacy Against the Different SARS-CoV2 Variants
Journal of Clinical Immunology (2023)
Signal Transduction and Targeted Therapy (2022)
Humoral immunity induced by mRNA COVID-19 vaccines in Nursing Home Residents previously infected with SARS-CoV-2
Aging Clinical and Experimental Research (2022)
Immunogenicity decay and case incidence six months post Sinovac-CoronaVac vaccine in autoimmune rheumatic diseases patients
Nature Communications (2022)
Neurology and Therapy (2021)