The myxozoan parasite, Tetracapsuloides bryosalmonae has a two-host life cycle alternating between freshwater bryozoans and salmonid fish. Infected fish can develop Proliferative Kidney Disease, characterised by a gross lymphoid-driven kidney pathology in wild and farmed salmonids. To facilitate an in-depth understanding of T. bryosalmonae-host interactions, we have used a two-host parasite transcriptome sequencing approach in generating two parasite transcriptome assemblies; the first derived from parasite spore sacs isolated from infected bryozoans and the second from infected fish kidney tissues. This approach was adopted to minimize host contamination in the absence of a complete T. bryosalmonae genome. Parasite contigs common to both infected hosts (the intersect transcriptome; 7362 contigs) were typically AT-rich (60–75% AT). 5432 contigs within the intersect were annotated. 1930 unannotated contigs encoded for unknown transcripts. We have focused on transcripts encoding proteins involved in; nutrient acquisition, host–parasite interactions, development, cell-to-cell communication and proteins of unknown function, establishing their potential importance in each host by RT-qPCR. Host-specific expression profiles were evident, particularly in transcripts encoding proteases and proteins involved in lipid metabolism, cell adhesion, and development. We confirm for the first time the presence of homeobox proteins and a frizzled homologue in myxozoan parasites. The novel insights into myxozoan biology that this study reveals will help to focus research in developing future disease control strategies.
Proliferative Kidney Disease (PKD) is an economically and ecologically important disease that impacts salmonid aquaculture and wild fish populations in Europe and North America1. The geographic range of PKD is broad and recent disease outbreaks in a wide range of salmonid hosts underlines the status of PKD as an emerging disease. The occurrence and severity of PKD is temperature driven, with projections of warmer climates predicted to align with escalation of disease outbreaks in the future2,3.
PKD is caused by the myxozoan parasite, Tetracapsuloides bryosalmonae. T. bryosalmonae spores are released from the definitive bryozoan host, Fredericella sultana4,5. Following spore attachment and invasion of epidermal mucous cells, the parasite migrates through the vascular system to the kidney and other organs, including spleen and liver6. Extrasporogonic proliferation of T. bryosalmonae in kidney tissues elicits a chronic tissue pathology, characterised by lymphoid hyperplasia, granulomatous lesions, renal atrophy, anaemia7,8 and hyper secretion of immunoglobulins9,10. The severity and development of these hallmark symptoms of PKD are modified by a variety of biological, environmental and chemical stressors, impacting on parasite load, host immunity, and disease recovery10,11. Variation in induced pathology and parasite development is observed depending on the identity of salmonid hosts and T. bryosalmonae strains. This variation likely reflects host–parasite coevolutionary histories. For example, European strains of T. bryosalmonae are unable to produce viable sporogonic renal stages in introduced rainbow trout and provoke clinical PKD in these ‘novel’ hosts5. Despite these recent advances in understanding the host responses to PKD, the molecular basis of the host–parasite interactions that drive PKD development are currently poorly known and there are no therapeutic measures for disease control.
An increasing number of genomic, transcriptomic and targeted gene studies, mainly based on parasites from the myxosporean clade, place myxozoans in the Phylum Cnidaria12,13,14. As adaptations to parasitism, myxozoans exhibit extreme morphological simplification and drastically reduced genome sizes relative to free-living cnidarians15,16. Nevertheless, polar capsules homologous to the stinging nematocysts of cnidarians have been retained and are used for host attachment. Whilst myxozoans exhibit an apparent streamlining of metabolic and developmental processes compared to free-living cnidarians, not surprisingly, they have retained large numbers of proteases18. Likewise, low density lipoprotein receptor class A domain-containing proteins (LDLR-As) are also numerous18,19. This along with the apparent dominance of myxosporean lipases in infected fish suggests that host lipids may represent an important source of nutrients for myxozoans with lipid metabolic processes potentially contributing towards myxozoan virulence18.
Tetracapsuloides bryosalmonae belongs to the relative species-poor, early diverging myxozoan clade Malacosporea, which has retained primitive features, such as epithelial layers and, in some cases, musculature20. Malacosporeans alternate between fish and freshwater bryozoan hosts17. There are clear host-specific developmental differences, including meiosis in bryozoan hosts and morphologies of spores released from fish and bryozoan hosts21. Host specific differences in gene expression may provide avenues for the development of targeted future therapeutics and are an important prerequisite in understanding the parasite’s biology. However, biological characterization of myxozoans via transcriptome and genome data has for various reasons been hampered. Provision of sufficient and appropriate material may be problematic. For example, sporogonic stages (henceforth referred to as spore sacs) of T. bryosalmonae can be released from the body cavity of bryozoan hosts by dissection and can occasionally be collected in substantial quantity (e.g. hundreds of spore sacs) from infected bryozoans maintained in laboratory mesocosms22 or from field-collected material3. Indeed, purified spore sacs were previously used to develop a full-length normalized T. bryosalmonae cDNA library to generate the first Sanger sequenced batch of ESTs, available in GenBank. However, attempts to purify parasite stages from infected fish kidney tissues have been unsuccessful. Although dual RNA-Seq approaches and selective enrichment of parasite stages from host tissues can be attempted, most myxozoan genomes and transcriptomes still carry host contamination23. In situ expression experiments are hindered by low parasite to host tissue ratios in infected tissues and the subsequent very low coverage of parasite transcripts.
In the absence of a complete host-free T. bryosalmonae genome, we used two transcriptome assemblies, one from infected fish kidney and the second from infected bryozoan hosts, to develop an intersect transcriptome for comparative transcriptomics. After maximising parasite representation in tissue samples of both hosts, normalised cDNA libraries were created to maximise the characterisation of low abundance transcripts. The transcripts expressed in both host transcriptomes were retrieved in the intersect transcriptome and coupled with a novel RT-qPCR assay to assess host-specific expression profiles of parasite transcripts of interest. Our rationale was that different expression profiles are likely to indicate the relative importance of parasite genes and proteins in each host. We particularly focused on proteins linked to putative virulence mechanisms, including; cell/tissue invasion, immune evasion, protein/lipid metabolism, cell–cell communication, and development15,18,24,25,26,27. We hypothesised that T. bryosalmonae uses different virulence strategies in the two hosts and tested this by comparative analysis of the expression profiles of candidate key virulence genes implicated in nutritional, metabolic, virulence and developmental activities. Our approach provides the first transcriptome datasets for T. bryosalmonae and affords valuable insights into malacosporean nutritional and metabolic processes and potential virulence candidates. We identify multiple members of key gene families that may be involved in differential exploitation strategies in different hosts. These data have also revealed, for the first time in myxozoans, transcripts encoding homeobox proteins and a frizzled homologue, with the latter implying that a Wnt signalling pathway could be present in myxozoans.
Transcriptome assembly and identification of intersect contigs
Prior to cDNA synthesis and library construction, total RNA from bryozoan-derived T. bryosalmonae spore sacs was confirmed to be of high quality with 28S rRNA/18S rRNA ratios being ≥ 1.4 (Supplementary Fig. S1). Typically, 28S rRNA/18S rRNA ratios of ≥ 1.0 correspond to RIN values higher than 8.0 (from Agilent Bioanalyser profiles)28. Sequencing of the normalized cDNA library from bryozoan-derived T. bryosalmonae spore sac RNA generated a total of 164,929,000 paired-end sequenced reads with 154,001,594 paired reads remaining after quality filtering and adapter trimming. Remaining reads were assembled into 48,153 contigs. 87.7% of filtered reads could be re-aligned to the assembly using Bowtie software.
Importantly, Tryptic Soy Agar (TSA) plates from kidney swabs of all fish used in this study did not reveal the presence of bacterial pathogens. Fish kidney total RNA prior to cDNA synthesis and library construction was determined to be of very high quality (28S rRNA/18S rRNA = 1.9; Supplementary Fig. S2). Sequencing of T. bryosalmonae infected trout kidney RNA generated 160,556,000 paired-end sequenced reads with 154,576,737 paired reads remaining after sequence trimming. Further sequential filtering was carried out by aligning remaining reads to a draft rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) genome29 and a multi-sourced rainbow trout transcriptome database30. In total, 277,422,293 reads mapped to rainbow trout genome and transcriptome datasets. The remaining 31,737,181 reads were assembled into 81,035 contigs. 82.9% of filtered reads could be re-aligned to the assembly using Bowtie software.
BLAST analysis of the fish kidney-derived transcriptome assembly against a T. bryosalmonae genome sequence dataset (H. Hartikainen, B. Okamura, unpublished data) resulted in 5384 matches (6.6% of the fish kidney-derived transcriptome). Only 191 contigs were filtered with the Thelohanellus kitauei genome assembly with all 191 also being filtered with the T. bryosalmonae genome. Owing to the low number of contigs filtered using the T. kitauei genome assembly due to the high level of sequence divergence between malacosporean and myxosporean parasites, only the T. bryosalmonae genome sequence dataset was subsequently used to filter parasite contigs from the spore sac-derived transcriptome assembly, yielding 21,720 matches (45.1% of the spore sac-derived transcriptome). Reciprocal BLAST analysis of the bryozoan parasite-filtered transcriptome against the trout parasite-filtered transcriptome yielded 7362 matches and 14,358 mismatches, whilst the converse revealed 4723 matches and 661 mismatches. The 7362 contig matches were defined as the intersect transcriptome. Assembly statistics are shown in Table 1. BUSCO scores are based on the percentage complete genes found in each assembly using the core Eukaryota gene set. Scores in pre parasite-filtered assemblies are likely to be attributed to both parasite and host contamination. Initial annotation, based on BLASTX against the nr NCBI database was used to partition each transcriptome dataset into transcripts according to homology with; eukaryotes, bacteria, archaea, and viruses. Remaining contigs with E values above the 10–3 threshold were deemed as unknown/no hit.
From the blob plot profiles, the span (Kb) and coverage of AT rich transcripts were of a similar level in bryozoan pre-filtered, bryozoan parasite-filtered and intersect transcriptomes with a marked decrease in the level of non-AT rich transcripts. AT rich transcripts were also enriched and non-AT rich transcripts markedly reduced in the trout parasite filtered transcriptome, albeit with lower span and coverage levels of the AT rich transcripts relative to the bryozoan parasite filtered and intersect transcriptomes (Fig. 1).
Pre- and parasite-filtered transcriptomes and the final intersect transcriptome are available via figshare (https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.11889672).
Transcriptome annotation, gene ontology and MEROPS analysis
Protein prediction and sequence annotation was performed on the intersect transcriptome as shown in Fig. 2. In total, 5432 contigs were homologous to protein sequences in the NCBI database (73.8%) with 1930 (26.2%) deemed as having no homology to known proteins. Of the 5432 contigs, 58% (3150 contigs) exhibited high homology (E value < 10–50) and 42% (2281 contigs) with matches between E values of 10–5 and 10–50 (Supplementary Table S1). 4015 were assigned to 9107 GO terms31. Predicted GO annotations were divided into 3 groups based on GO terms: (1) biological process (3526), (2) cellular component (1962), and (3) molecular function (3619). The GO term frequencies were plotted using the Web Gene Ontology Annotation Plot 9 (WEGO, version 2.0)32 for the GO-tree level 2, based on their properties and function (Fig. 3) and listed for GO-tree level 2, 3 and 4 (Supplementary Table S2). Of the annotatable and unknown protein sequences, 143 and 84 were predicted to contain a signal peptide respectively (Supplementary Tables S1, S5).
To detect proteases in the intersect transcriptome, all contigs were analysed using the MEROPS database. A total of 100 proteases homologous to metallo- (44) and cysteine (26) proteases, threonine (12), serine (11), aspartate (5) and asparagine proteases (2) were recovered (Supplementary Table S3; Fig. 4A). All contigs predicted to be lipases or involved in lipid binding based on GO annotation were further manually annotated using BLAST and PFAM. A total of 16 lipases and 22 contigs homologous to lipid binding proteins could be identified (Supplementary Table S4; Fig. 4B). Of the lipases all, but one, were homologous to phospholipase family members. Specifically, the detected families were phospholipase A1 (8), A2 (4), C (2) and D (1) and a single contig was homologous to the hormone sensitive lipase, lipase E. Two key lipid regulatory enzymes were also uncovered, namely phosphatidate phosphatase and diacylglycerol kinase.
Host specific gene expression
The relative expression of 53 selected T. bryosalmonae genes was analysed to compare expression profiles in infected bryozoan and infected rainbow trout kidney tissue cDNAs (Figs. 5, 6, 7, 8). No expression of any T. bryosalmonae gene was evident in control uninfected bryozoan and fish kidney cDNA samples or in -RT controls from uninfected/infected hosts. Three previously known T. bryosalmonae reference genes were tested, and the mean quantification cycle (Cq) calculated for each host (fish/bryozoan) were: TbRPL18 (20.00/24.51), TbRPL12 (20.77/25.03) and TbELFα (18.73/23.74). Similarly, uninfected/infected fish kidney and bryozoan cDNA samples yielded a mean Cq value of 11.02 and 14.58 for rainbow trout and bryozoan ELFα respectively (Marc N. Faber unpublished data).
Coefficient of variation (CV%) values were similar for all three reference genes (TbRPL12 = 9.39; TbRPL18 = 10.09; TbELFα = 11.65). This implies that TbRPL12 and TbRPL18 were slightly more stable as reference genes than TbELFα with primer efficiency of TbRPL18 amplification (1.94; 97%) being slightly higher than that for TbRPL12 (1.90; 95%). Relative expression normalised to each reference gene individually revealed the same repertoire of significant and non-significant genes. Thus, gene expression data, overall, are presented normalised to TbRPL18, which has been used to determine T. bryosalmonae load in trout kidney samples in previous studies33,34. ΔCq values were calculated representing the expression level of genes of interest compared to TbRPL18 in each infected host with values > 1 indicating lower expression and values < 1 indicating higher expression compared to TbRPL18 (Figs. 5, 6, 78). Fold differences in gene expression in infected fish relative to infected bryozoans were assessed for each gene of interest and presented as fold differences in gene expression in Supplementary Table S5. Gene names were assigned according to the closest BLAST search using protein similarity search based on the manually annotated UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot and UniProtKB/Swiss-Prot isoforms databases (https://www.ebi.ac.uk/Tools/sss/fasta/). Highest BLAST hits are listed alongside predicted functional domains (Supplementary Table S5).
19 genes exhibited significantly higher expression levels in infected bryozoan samples relative to infected fish kidney samples, namely: disintegrin and metalloproteinase domain-containing protein (ADAM)10–1 (P = 0.029), ADAM10-3 (P = 0.029), Phospholipase A1 member A (PLA1A) (P = 0.029), Phospholipase A-2-activating protein (PLAA) (P = 0.029), Group XV phospholipase A2 (PLA2-G15) (P = 0.029), Frizzled receptor-2 (FZ-2) (P = 0.029), Guanylate cyclase A/atrial natriuretic peptide receptor A (GC/NPR-A) (P = 0.029), heat shock protein (HSP)60 (P = 0.029), HSP90 (P = 0.029), Neurexin 4 (Nrxn4)-like (P = 0.029), Homeobox protein Sebox (Sebox) (P = 0.029), Transmembrane anterior posterior transformation protein 1 (TAPT1)-like (P = 0.029), T. bryosalmonae minicollagen-1 (TBNCOL-1) (P = 0.029), TBNCOL-2 (P = 0.029), TBNCOL-3 (P = 0.029), TBNCOL-4 (P = 0.029), Contig (C)-660 (P = 0.029), C-168 (P = 0.029) and HSP70 (P = 0.029).
In contrast, 12 genes, namely; Matrix metalloprotease 13 (MMP) (P = 0.004), LDLR-A1 (P = 0.029), LDLR-A2 (P = 0.029), LDLR-A3 (P = 0.029), Legumain (LGMN) (P = 0.029), Hepatic triacyl glycerol lipase (LIPC) (P = 0.029), Endothelial lipase (LIPG) (P = 0.029), Lipase Member H (LIPH) (P = 0.029), Pancreatic lipase-related protein 2 (PLPR2) (P = 0.029), Triacyl glycerol lipase (TGL) (P = 0.029), Microfibril-associated glycoprotein 4 (MFAP4) (P = 0.029), and Tetraspanin CD53 (CD53)-like (P = 0.029), exhibited significantly higher expression levels in infected fish kidney samples relative to infected bryozoan samples.
No significantly different expression between the two hosts could be detected for 20 genes, namely; ADAM10-2 (P = 0.057), Cathepsin L (CTSL)-like (P = 0.100), CTSL2 (P = 0.100), Oxysterol-binding protein 2 (OSBP) (P = 0.114), Sortilin-related receptor (SORL1) (P = 0.343), Homeobox protein Ceh-11 (Ceh-11) (P = 0.100), HSC71 (P = 0.886), Notch-like (P = 0.114), Neuroglian-like protein (Nrg-like) (P = 0.486), retinal homeobox-1 (Rx-1) (P = 0.057), Homeobox protein OTX2 (Otx-2) (P = 0.057), Homeobox protein Xenk-2 (Xenk-2) (P = 0.057), Nuclear export mediator factor (NEMF) (P = 0.200), Thymosin beta 4-like protein (TMSB4) (P = 0.100), T. bryosalmonae elongation factor alpha (TbELFa) (P = 0.200), T. bryosalmonae ribosomal protein L12 (TbRPL12) (P = 0.343), C-1242 (P = 0.100), C-39373 (P = 0.100), C-28481 (P = 0.100), C-51833 (P = 0.100) and C-52333 (P = 0.700).
However, there was a limited availability of biological replicates for infected bryozoan material restricted statistical analysis in some cases (where n = 3) and may underly the lack of significant differences (by Mann Whitney U test) for the genes; CTSL-like, Ceh-11, Otx-2, Rx-1, Xenk-2, TMSB4, C-39373, C-1242 , C28481, and C51833.
Presence of frizzled receptor and homeobox genes in T. bryosalmonae genomic DNA
To further support the presence of homeobox and FZ-2 genes in T. bryosalmonae, primers were designed to specifically amplify genomic DNA from uninfected and infected hosts. PCR analysis detected specific bands, in infected but not in uninfected host tissues, of the correct predicted size and sequence verified for genes; Anf-1-like (358 bp), Sebox (279 bp), Ceh-11 (526 bp), Otx-2 (213 bp), FZ-2 (613 bp), Rx-1 (328 bp) and Xenk-2 (313 bp) (Fig. 8D; Supplementary Fig. S3).
The intersect transcriptome identifies parasite contigs shared by fish and bryozoan hosts
Comparisons of host-specific expression of key genes may pave the road to targeted approaches to future disease control strategies and identify candidate genes for further functional characterisation. We developed an intersect transcriptome to identify a key set of T. bryosalmonae contigs that were expressed to at least some degree in both hosts, whilst minimising host contaminants. In line with our previous studies and existing myxozoan transcriptomes18,23, contigs in the intersect transcriptome were predominantly AT-rich (Fig. 1; 60–75% AT). The intersect transcriptome comprised a 7362 contig group, with a greater number of AT-rich contigs compared to the 5384 reciprocal contig group but possesses a greater proportion of non-AT rich contigs (Fig. 1). Although low, our Busco scores were comparable to previously reported CEG scores for myxosporeans15. It is well known that myxozoan genomes and transcripts are AT-rich (> 60% AT), and AT content can be used to identify transcripts of parasite versus host origin15,18,23,35. The increased representation of non-AT-rich contigs in the intersect may, therefore, reflect the presence of non-parasite sequences (see later discussion) but it may also reflect the presence of myxozoan transcripts that encode proteins rich in amino acids using GC rich codons, such as minicollagens36. Whilst parasite origin of certain non-AT rich cnidarian/myxozoan-specific transcripts may be identified, others would need to be PCR verified in the absence of a complete host-free parasite genome.
Host-specific transcription indicates specialisation in nutrient acquisition and virulence
To identify host specific expression patterns, a subset of 52 contigs of specific interest to host–parasite interactions were chosen for RT-qPCR analysis in multiple infected fish and bryozoan samples. Primers designed to these contigs successfully amplified in both infected hosts and in multiple isolates and not in uninfected controls, confirming their parasite origin, along with their AT-rich composition. Proteases have been extensively targeted for therapeutic intervention due to their central roles in virulence mechanisms, including nutrient acquisition, cell/tissue invasion, and host immune evasion. Thus, they are essential to parasite survival and development in different host environments25,37,38,39,40. Parasite cysteine proteases are the most extensively studied group of proteases in parasites and, in this study, represent the second most abundant protease group in the intersect transcriptome (Supplementary Tables S1, S3). Host protein degrading CTS proteases are often co-expressed with nutrient acquiring and protease activating LGMN-like cysteine proteases in parasites40. Similar and high expression levels in both fish and bryozoan hosts of LGMN and CTSL imply that they are biologically important players in each respective host–parasite interaction (Fig. 5).
The dominance of metalloproteases in our T. bryosalmonae dataset is not surprising. Some of the most well characterised functional roles of parasite metalloproteases are prominent features of PKD pathogenesis, including modulation of the fish kidney tissue matrix and tissue remodelling that are most likely attributed to parasite migration, proliferation and differentiation25,41. Shedding of cell surface membrane proteins is fundamental to many cell signalling events triggered by changes in cellular microenvironments25. ADAM family members are an important group of ectodomain sheddases that regulate signalling associated with extracellular matrix homeostasis, often in association with tetraspanins. They regulate a wide range of functions including cell adhesion, inflammation, lymphocyte development, tissue invasion, and notch receptor processing. ADAM10 plays a central role in the regulation of immune and developmental events, including disease25. Consequently, dysregulation of ADAMs is strongly associated with infection-mediated tissue pathology and cancer, implicating them, along with tetraspanins, as important therapeutic targets25,38,42,43,44. In this study, we uncovered six ADAM-like transcripts, three that are ADAM10-like and three other contigs homologous to ADAM17, 22, and 28. Two of the ADAM10-like contigs exhibited a more bryozoan-specific expression profile suggesting that they may have an important regulatory role in bryozoan-parasite interactions (Supplementary Table S3, Fig. 5).
We have also uncovered several tetraspanins with a particularly abundant CD53-like transcript exhibiting a fish-specific expression profile (Supplementary Table S1, Fig. 8B). In mammals, tetraspanins in the CD family are important immune regulators with hematopoietic-specific CD53 being a suppressor of inflammatory cytokines45,46. Thus, association between T. bryosalmonae ADAM and tetraspanin homologues may, in part, be responsible for T. bryosalmonae-mediated disease pathology and dampening of fish pro-inflammatory responses observed during PKD11,47. Similarly, the T lymphocyte hormone TMSB4, dampens inflammatory processes by influencing TLR activity48. The very high expression levels of a T. bryosalmonae TMSB4 homologue in each host exceeding TbRPL18, highlight its general biological importance in both hosts.
Parasites often depend on salvaging of host lipids to fuel growth and survival in a range of hosts, including fish49,50,51. It is, therefore, not surprising to find a repertoire of T. bryosalmonae phospholipases with the majority belonging to the PLA1 family (Supplementary Table S4). PLA1s hydrolyze acylglycerols and phospholipids, liberating free fatty acids and lysophospholipids52. All full-length PLA1 transcripts revealed in this study are likely to be secretory with most having highly fish-specific expression profiles. Importantly, PLA1A and Lipase H release the lipid mediators lysophosphatidylserine (LPS) and lysophosphatidic acid (LPA) that induce cell proliferation and chronic disease pathology52,53. It is, therefore, tantalizing to speculate that such lipid mediators may drive PKD pathology. PLA2 activity, can also lead to the release of these lipid mediators, albeit to a lesser extent than PLA1. We did not uncover any calcium dependent PLA2 family members that are linked to arachidonic acid release and production of inflammatory eicosanoids. All PLA2s we found were homologous to intracellular calcium independent PLA2s implicated, to a lesser extent, in immune regulation54. Interestingly, PLA2-G15 and PLAA were more highly expressed in bryozoans than in fish kidney tissue suggesting that these family members play a less important role in lipid metabolism of the parasite when in fish than in bryozoan hosts.
As in previous myxozoan studies, we uncovered several LDLR-A transcripts18 with 3 being highly fish-specific (Supplementary Table S4, Fig. 6). LDLR-A proteins are crucial in receptor-mediated endocytosis of ligands, particularly cholesterol and acyglycerols. Many parasites are unable to produce cholesterol and are, therefore, dependent on host acquisition to fuel cell proliferation and differentiation51,55. Consequent alterations in host cholesterol homeostasis can lead to immune dysregulation and disease pathology. The apparent dominance of myxozoan LDLR-As and PLA1 family members in infected fish kidney tissue is strongly indicative of host cholesterol and acyglycerol exploitation that could be a major contributory factor to PKD pathogenesis. Indeed, recent studies describe several viable pharmacological approaches to interfere with parasite utilisation of host lipids, which may have relevance to the future control of myxozoan parasites56,57,58.
Host-specific transcription linked to parasite developmental processes
To develop a fuller understanding of myxozoan biology and potential future directions in disease mitigation, we examined datasets for genes involved in parasite development and functional morphology in each host. ADAM family members, especially ADAM10, are crucial in the regulation of notch signalling, implicating the involvement of some members in regulation of embryonic and adult developmental processes and thus as potentially important therapeutic targets42,59. The presence of meiosis in T. bryosalmonae stages in bryozoan hosts, may explain the bryozoan dominance of two of the ADAM 10-like molecules in this study.
Activation of natriuretic peptide receptors, including GC/NPR-A, leads to the accumulation of intracellular cGMP. They act as environmental sensors involved in the regulation of developmental events, blood pressure regulation, immune and electrolyte homeostasis in higher vertebrates60. The existence of NPR-like ligands in invertebrates is considered to be due to convergent evolution61. Whilst there are some functional similarities in the natriuretic systems of higher and lower vertebrates, such as ionic balance and osmoregulation, there is little known about this system in invertebrates61. Importantly, cyclic nucleotide balance, in general, is known to be important in parasite development, host-to-host transmission, target tissue recognition, and immune evasion events, enabling rapid adaptation to different host environments62,63. The significance of the bryozoan-specific nature of GC/NPR-A in this study may relate to the different parasite developmental events in each host or differences in electrolyte homeostasis and environmental sensing.
Heat Shock Proteins (hsps) have also been linked to both virulence and parasite development. They are crucial in maintaining protein homeostasis under extreme changes in environmental conditions and are, thus, essential to parasite survival, temperature-driven development and cell or tissue invasion64,65. Hsp60, 70, and 90 T. bryosalmonae homologues were found to be abundantly expressed in both hosts with Hsp60 and 90 exhibiting a bryozoan-specific expression profile. Since parasite developmental events in both hosts are known to be temperature dependent, bryozoan specificity of Hsp60 and 90 could be attributed to events unique to spore sac development, such as meiosis during sporogony21,66. Transcripts involved in cell–cell communication such as; neural sensory processing (Nrxn 4-like) and extracellular matrix interactions (MFAP4) exhibited host-specific expression profiles (Fig. 7). The expression of genes linked to neural development is intriguing given the lack of defined nervous systems in myxozoans20 and the inert nature of T. bryosalmonae sacs.
Minicollagens are likely to play a similar role to those in free-living cnidarians providing the high tensile strength needed to facilitate polar filament deployment67. In myxozoans this enables spores to attach to hosts. The dominance of minicollagen expression in bryozoan hosts that support spore development relative to the dead-end fish host is, therefore, an expected result now confirmed here by our expression analyses.
For the first time in myxozoans, we have detected several homeobox proteins and a frizzled receptor homologue (FZD-2). As in previous myxozoan studies, we did not find any Hox genes nor other elements of Wnt pathways. T. bryosalmonae FZD-2 and most homeobox proteins displayed bryozoan-specific expression profiles. This may further illustrate a developmental deficit in rainbow trout hosts (in contrast to natural fish hosts, such as brown trout, where viable spore development occurs). It is also possible that multicellular sac development in bryozoans requires more sophisticated regulation than cellular proliferation and development of simple pseudoplasmodia in fish hosts. Nevertheless, fish-specific expression of a Ceh11-like transcript suggests that some T. bryosalmonae homeobox proteins may have distinct roles in driving fish-specific development. We note, however, that caution must be exercised in assignment of T. bryosalmonae homeobox proteins to specific families. This requires in-depth phylogenetic analysis and will be facilitated when more family members are discovered in other myxozoans. Likewise, whether our frizzled receptor is truly indicative of Wnt pathways in myxozoans awaits clarification, particularly as they are also involved in non-Wnt signalling pathways68.
Limitations and caveats
Limitations of this study include lack of insight on proteins expressed during normal development of T. bryosalmonae pseudoplasmodia in kidney tubules of natural fish hosts and in the cryptic stages that develop in association with the body walls of bryozoan hosts. A range of other proteins may be expressed during these phases of the life cycle of T. bryosalmonae.
Non-parasite (< 60% AT) sequences were evident in the blob plots of both the fish kidney-derived and spore sac-derived transcriptomes. As highlighted by Foox and colleagues23, this illustrates the inadequacy of a single step depletion of host sequences by BLAST analysis against fish sequence resources. Notably the second non AT-rich (< 60% AT) peak in the blob plot of the spore sac-derived transcriptome, relative to trout-derived and intersect transcriptome blob plots, was not substantially reduced following filtering using a set of partial T. bryosalmonae genomic contigs (Hartikainen pers comm). This is not surprising as both the genomic and transcriptomic contigs were derived from sequencing libraries prepared from parasite spore sacs isolated from bryozoans and likely carried some bryozoan tissue. Importantly, all spore sacs used in this study appeared to be host-free with no visible signs of host tissue. Nevertheless, despite this scrutiny, it is likely that host coelomocytes adhere to and spread over the surface of spore sacs and could account for some of the host sequence contamination. Indeed, it is likely that non-parasite sequences are universally present in existing myxosporean assemblies due to the presence of host cell/tissue contaminants23. We propose that in the absence of clean and complete host and parasite genomes to filter against, the intersect transcriptome approach can identify a key set of contigs for targeted analysis as shown in this study. Overall, the blob profiles provide a level of quality control for host contamination, given the known AT-rich (> 60% AT) nature of T. bryosalmonae contigs, relative to ca. 49% AT content of the recently published F. sultana transcriptome69.
The intersect transcriptome is, however, not assumed to represent a complete transcriptome. A perhaps more important limitation is that numerous parasite transcripts are likely to be amongst the apparent bryozoan-specific and fish-specific mismatches. Both sets of mismatched contigs are unlikely to reflect host exclusivity but rather low transcriptome coverage, limitations of de novo assembly, and limited availability of T. bryosalmonae resources. Yet, this can also be construed an advantage when comparative follow up studies are conducted, as tracking transcripts expressed in both hosts could help to unravel host-specific aspects of the parasite’s biology. Indeed, BLASTX annotation of both groups of mismatches enabled us to pinpoint potentially important T. bryosalmonae players in host–parasite interactions (eg. TMSB4, MMP, LGMN, ADAM10-3; Supplementary Table S5). In addition, all T. bryosalmonae homeobox proteins reported in this study were identified in the two groups of host-specific mismatches. Likewise, FZ-2 was identified in the bryozoan-specific group of mismatches (Table 2, Supplementary Table S5). Given the contentious nature of the existence of homeobox and Wnt signalling components in myxozoans, we additionally further confirmed parasite origin via the detection of each gene specifically in genomic DNA from infected hosts (Fig. 8D; Supplementary Fig. S3).
Some 26% of contigs could not be annotated and thus encode unknown or orphan proteins. Comparable proportions of unknowns have been reported in other parasite transcriptomic datasets, including myxosporeans18,23,70. Myxozoans have undergone both extreme genome reduction and rapid molecular evolution and the high proportions of unknown proteins may reflect long branches that preclude resolving relationships to currently characterised proteins. We shortlisted seven unknown proteins for gene expression analysis that are representative of putative secretory and non-secretory unknowns found in the intersect transcriptome (C-168, C-660) and in the bryozoan-specific (C-1242) or fish-specific (C-28487, C-39373, C-51833, C-52333) groups of mismatches. Of the seven unknowns examined in this study, five exhibited host-specific expression profiles, implying that some unknown proteins may have particularly important host-specific functional roles in each host–parasite interaction. Given the extremely small size of myxozoan genomes compared to other metazoans, it is intriguing that they have retained such a large number of unknowns in their genomes/transcriptomes. Thus, it will be a major opportunity and challenge to determine how these unknown proteins may reflect intra- and inter-host adaptations to parasitism in myxozoans.
We have generated the first insights on malacosporean gene expression based on the analyses of transcriptome datasets using a 2-host sequencing approach. Subsequent RT-qPCR analysis enabled us to gain novel insights on myxozoan biology, particularly regarding virulence, metabolism and development. This study will promote future work to understand and mitigate myxozoan-borne diseases.
Materials and methods
Bryozoan and rainbow trout kidney tissue sampling
Infected bryozoans (F. sultana) were collected in late spring from the River Cerne, Dorset, UK, as described previously3. Immature and mature parasites (spore sacs) were isolated by dissection from hosts, rinsed in fresh river water and checked to ensure there were no other tissues associated with each spore sac before placing directly into ice-cold Trizol-reagent (Sigma) by capillary action. 150 spore sacs were pooled and used to generate sufficient total RNA for cDNA library construction. Lysed spore sacs in Trizol-reagent were stored at − 80 °C prior to RNA extraction.
For gene expression analysis, uninfected and overtly infected bryozoans from the Furtbach River, Switzerland, were used. Bryozoan collections were cultured in a laboratory mesocosm, as described previously71, with successfully attaching bryozoan branches constituting a single colony. All bryozoan cultures were maintained for 1–3 weeks to allow colonies to develop transparency, enabling the detection of overt infections using a stereomicroscope. Uninfected bryozoan colonies were assessed based on colony morphology, absence of overt T. bryosalmonae spore sacs and by 18S rDNA-based qPCR analysis, as described previously72. Similarly, confirmation that each spore sac-containing bryozoan sample was, indeed, infected with T. bryosalmonae, was obtained by 18S rDNA and RPL18 qPCR and sequence verification, as described previously33,72. We were unable to distinguish between different stages of overt spore sac infection in bryozoans with only bryozoan colonies exhibiting clear spore sac infection used for gene expression analysis. To ensure sufficient total RNA for RT-qPCR analysis, 4–8 individual uninfected or overtly infected colonies were pooled to form a single biological replicate. In total, 3–4 biological replicates were created for each infection category, with each replicate placed into 1 ml RNAlater for 24 h at 4 °C and stored at − 80 °C prior to RNA extraction.
Uninfected and infected rainbow trout exhibiting advanced clinical disease (kidney swelling grade 2–3), as determined using the Clifton-Hadley grading system73, were sampled from a commercial trout farm located in Southern England with a history of annual PKD outbreaks, as described previously33. From parallel studies in our laboratory, examining the dynamics of T. bryosalmonae transcript expression at different stages of clinical disease, expression levels in fish kidney samples reached maximal thresholds at grades 2 and 3. Thus, only fish kidneys graded from 2 to 3 were considered in subsequent cDNA library preparation and gene expression analysis (M. Faber, unpublished data). Presence/absence of T. bryosalmonae was confirmed by 18S rDNA/ RPL18 qPCR and sequence analysis, with extrasporogonic parasite stages in kidney interstitial tissue confirmed by histological examination, as described previously33,72. Checks for other common bacterial pathogens, including Aeromonas salmonicida, were conducted using kidney swabs, as described previously33. Kidney swabs were streaked onto TSA plates (Becton–Dickinson, Oxford, UK). Plates were incubated for 48–72 h at 20–22 °C before examination for bacterial growth. Approximately 100 mg trunk kidney tissue was removed immediately below the dorsal fin from each fish and archived in 1 ml RNAlater, as outlined above.
RNA extraction and sequencing
Total RNA from T. bryosalmonae spore sacs and infected kidney tissue in Trizol-reagent was extracted from Trizol-reagent according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Owing to the very limited quantity and availability of T. bryosalmonae spore sacs for RNA extraction, archived spore sac Trizol homogenate was processed incrementally in six batches generating two aliquots of total RNA (Supplementary Fig. S1). To maximize retrieval of total RNA, GlycoBlue co-precipitant (15 mg/ml; Thermofisher) was included into the isopropanol step (1.5 μl per RNA sample). Owing to the presence of PCR inhibitors in bryozoan tissue, bryozoan total RNA was treated with a PowerClean Pro RNA Clean-up kit (Cambio) to remove free and nucleic acid-bound PCR inhibiting substances. PCR inhibition has been highlighted as a potential cause of low representation of myxosporean transcripts in qPCR studies, especially based on invertebrate tissue samples74. In our hands, we have found the PowerClean Pro RNA Clean-up kit to be highly effective in releaving PCR inhibition without the need to dilute cDNA samples (J.W. Holland, unpublished data). All total RNA samples were also treated with Dnase-I using a TURBO DNA-free kit (Invitrogen), quantified using NanoDrop ND-1000 UV–Vis spectrophotometer and quality checked using an Agilent Bioanalyser 2100 or using a Shimadzu MultiNA microchip system.
cDNA library construction, RNA sequencing, filtering of trout-derived reads using rainbow trout genome and transcriptome databases, and de novo assembly was performed by Vertis Biotechnologie AG (Friesing, Germany). Total RNA from bryozoan-derived T. bryosalmonae spore sacs was confirmed to be of high quality using an Agilent Bioanalyser 2100 (RIN > 8.0) prior to dry ice shipment to Vertis Biotechnologie AG (Friesing, Germany). Immediately prior to cDNA synthesis and library construction, total RNA quality was further confirmed using a Shimadzu MultiNA microchip electrophoresis system based on the ratio of 28S rRNA/18S rRNA (Supplementary Fig. S1). The two aliquots of spore sac total RNA were combined with a total yield of 1.3 µg. Poly (A) + RNA was isolated, reverse transcribed into cDNA and amplified using the Ovation RNA-Seq System V2 kit (NuGEN Technologies Inc.) according to the manufacturer’s instructions and fragmented by sonication. After end-repair and ligation of TruSeq adapters, cDNA was amplified by PCR and normalized by controlled denature-re-association to ensure maximum T. bryosalmonae representation in the transcriptome assembly. cDNA quality at each step was checked using a Shimadzu MultiNA microchip electrophoresis system (Supplementary Fig. S1). Single-stranded cDNA was purified by hydroxylapatite chromatography by PCR amplification. Normalized cDNA was gel fractionated and fragments ranging from 300 to 500 bp in length were sequenced using an Illumina HiSeq 2000 machine producing paired end 100 bp read lengths.
To ensure maximum T. bryosalmonae representation in the trout pre-parasite filtered transcriptome, total RNA from 65 kidney tissue samples was isolated and subjected to RT-qPCR, as described previously75. Primers unique to T. bryosalmonae and rainbow trout RPL18 (Supplementary Table S5) were used to determine the most heavily infected kidney samples for cDNA library construction, as described previously33. ΔCq values varied from 17.21 (lowest parasite burden) to 5.19 (highest parasite burden). Equal amounts of total RNA were combined from 3 kidney samples (combined total RNA yield = 21 μg) with the lowest ΔCq values (5.19, 5.22, 5.95) and quality assessed prior to and during cDNA library construction (Supplementary Fig. S2) and poly (A) + RNA sequencing performed, as described above.
Raw sequencing reads were quality filtered using a phred quality score cut-off of 33 in ASCII format in accordance with Sanger FASTQ format and a minimum length cut-off of 20 bp using trimming and sequence quality control tools within the CLC Bio Genomics Workbench (version 6.5.1). In the absence of a high-quality T. bryosalmonae genome scaffold, sequence reads were assembled de novo. In the case of the fish kidney-derived reads, to remove sequences having high sequence identities to rainbow trout, the sequences were mapped locally using megablast76, to rainbow trout genome29 and transcriptome assemblies30. After removal of trout sequences (e-value cut-off = 5e-5), assembly of high-quality unmapped reads was performed using the CLC Bio Genomics Workbench 6.5.1 at an optimized k-mer size. Assembled sequences were clustered with TIGCL77 and CAP378 with a minimal overlap of 100 bp and identity cut-off of 95% to form unigenes. Sequence reads from the T. bryosalmonae spore sac library, were not host filtered due to the absence of a F. sultana genome assembly and were directly assembled into contigs without removal of any contaminating bryozoan reads. All sequence reads have been deposited at the European Nucleotide Archive (ENA) under the accession number PRJEB19471. Fish kidney-derived contigs were further filtered by dc-megablast (e-value cut-off = 5e−3) using two available myxozoan genome assemblies. Firstly, the current genome assembly of the myxosporean, T. kitauei (GCA_000827895.1) and, secondly, a T. bryosalmonae genome (MiSeq) sequence dataset generated from spore sac genomic DNA with sequenced reads obtained from a single MiSeq run that yielded 6,334,237 PRINSEQ cleaned paired reads with read lengths ranging from 35 to 251 bp and a total GC content of 28% (H. Hartikainen, B. Okamura, unpublished data). Contigs mapping to both parasite genome sequence datasets constituted the final trout-derived parasite transcriptome dataset (referred to as the trout parasite-filtered transcriptome; Table 1). Owing to the low-level filtering of T. bryosalmonae contigs with the T. kitauei genome, only the T. bryosalmonae genome sequence dataset was used to filter the spore sac-derived contigs (resulting dataset referred to as the bryozoan parasite-filtered transcriptome; Table 1). Transcriptome metrics were calculated using Quast (version 3.1)79, the completeness of each transcriptome assembly was assessed using BUSCO (version 3)80 and raw reads were re-aligned to the assembly using Bowtie (version 1.1.1)81. Reciprocal blast (dc-megablast) analysis (e-value cutoff = 5e-3) was undertaken to determine contigs in common with both transcriptome datasets (intersect contigs). Reciprocal blast has been implemented in previous studies to discriminate between target (sequences or closely related sequences found in two sequence datasets) from non-target sequences82,83.
For assessment and visualisation of contamination, taxonomic assignment of each contig was carried out using BlobTools (version 0.9.19) at each stage of transcriptome production84.
An F. sultana transcriptome, from uninfected zoids, has become available since completion of transcriptome assemblies in the current study68. Retrospective use of this new sequence resource to filter F. sultana-derived raw reads from the bryozoan-derived spore sac HiSeq library data revealed a very low number of mapped reads (0.82% of total reads). This very likely accounts for only a fraction of the F. sultana contaminating sequence reads in the spore sac HiSeq library. The F. sultana transcriptome has, therefore, not been incorporated into the transcriptome assembly pipeline. Conversely, the F. sultana transcriptome revealed a significant level of host-derived reads (20.76%) in the T. bryosalmonae genome sequence data. This further reinforces the importance of the reciprocal blast analysis to identify contigs in common with both host-derived transcriptomes.
Annotation was performed on all contigs derived from T. bryosalmonae spore sacs and on myxozoan-filtered fish kidney-derived contigs using the Trinotate pipeline (version 2.0.2)85. Protein prediction was performed using TransDecoder (version r20140704) using default parameters86. Contigs were compared to Swiss-Prot and TREMBL (uniref90) databases87,88,89; downloaded March 2015 from www.uniprot.org) using NCBI BLAST + (version 2.2.27) with E-values more than 10–3 considered non-significant. Both sets of contigs were also subjected to BLASTX searches against the non-redundant (nr) nucleotide database (downloaded from www.uniprot.org on the 17-03-2015). All contigs predicted to be protein coding were submitted to signal-P (version 4.1)87, TMHMM (version 2.0c)88 and to HMMER (version 3.0)89 against the PFAM database (version 27.0 downloaded Jan 2015)90. RNAmmer (version 1.2) was used to predict the presence of any contaminating ribosomal RNA sequences91. Gene Ontology assignment was performed using eggNOG, and Swiss-Prot matches mapped to Gene Ontology classes using the mapping file: ftp://ftp.ebi.ac.uk/pub/databases/GO/goa/UNIPROT/gene_association.goa_uniprot.gz. GO classifications of intersect contigs were visualized using WEGO software32. Contig sequences were compared to the MEROPS (release 12.1; https://www.ebi.ac.uk/merops/download_list.shtml)92 database using BLASTX (version 2.2.31)93 with an e value cut-off of 1e−05 and a percent identity cut-off of 50%, with the most significant hit determined by the lowest e value.
Real-time quantitative PCR
We employed RT-qPCR to reveal parasite transcriptional differences between the two hosts.
Total RNA representing uninfected/overtly infected bryozoans and uninfected/infected rainbow trout kidney tissue with a swelling grade of 2 (n = 3–4) was reverse transcribed into cDNA, as described previously33. Negative controls (without reverse transcriptase; −RT) were included to account for any residual DNA contamination.
Owing to limited amounts of bryozoan tissue, two batches of bryozoan and trout cDNA were utilised in this study providing 3 or 4 biological replicates per group. For bryozoan and trout cDNA, ca 1.5 µg and 5 µg of total RNA was reverse transcribed in 20 and 40 µl reactions respectively using a Revert Aid first-strand cDNA synthesis kit (Fermentas) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Primers were designed to transcripts encoding proteins involved in; protein and lipid metabolism, developmental processes, cell–cell communication, cnidarian-specific structures or unknown/unannotated proteins (Supplementary Table S5). Primers were designed towards the 3′ end of each open reading frame aided by the considerable difference in codon usage between T. bryosalmonae and host genes (ca. 60–75% AT and 45–55% AT respectively). To facilitate primer design for some contigs, further sequence was obtained by anchored PCR and all primers tested for specificity and efficiency using a previously developed normalised full-length spore sac cDNA library constructed by Vertis Biotechnologie AG (Friesing, Germany). The library was constructed from decapped poly A + RNA from spore sacs. Following 5′ RNA adapter ligation, first strand cDNA was performed, and cDNA amplified using 5′ and 3′ (oligo dT) adapter primers. Prior to directional cloning into eukaryotic expression vector, pcDNA3.1 + (Invitrogen), cDNA was normalised as described above.
Primer melting (Tm) temperature and annealing temperature (Ta) were assessed using OligoAnalyzer3.1 (https://www.idtdna.com/calc/analyzer) and listed for each primer pair (Supplementary Table S5). Many T. bryosalmonae contigs were found to have repeat elements or very AT-rich regions. Thus, it was not always possible to develop primer pairs generating amplicons in the range 150–300 bp with sufficient GC:AT content and melting profile to allow efficient and specific q-PCR. All amplicons in this study were, therefore, within the range 149–422 bp. All RT-qPCR data was analysed using LightCycler 480 Software 1.5.1 (Roche). Each sample reaction consisted of 4 μl of sample cDNA and 6 μl of SYBR Green (Thermofisher) master mix containing 0.5 μM of each forward and reverse primer (Supplementary Table S5), as described previously33. Cycling conditions used were; denaturation at 95 °C for 10 min followed by 40 cycles of 95 °C for 30 s, 54–69 °C for 20–30 s and 72 °C for 30 s with fluorescence acquisition at 84 °C for 5 s. Melting curve analysis was performed after each PCR cycle between 72 and 94 °C to ensure only a single product had been amplified. Purified PCR amplicons were diluted in TE buffer, quantified using a NanoDrop 8000 Spectrophotometer, adjusted to 1 nM, and serially diluted as described previously33.
Following sequence verification of each PCR standard, primer efficiency and concentration of each gene transcript was calculated by reference to its standard curve, with efficiencies ranging from 1.80 to 1.96 (90–98%). Similarly, primers were designed for three selected reference genes to enable transcriptional normalization, namely; TbRPL18, TbRPL12, and TbELFα. TbRPL12 has been shown to be a suitable reference gene for a range of invertebrate phyla, including cnidarians94,95. Likewise, TbRPL18 and TbELFα have been shown to be highly consistent as reference genes in invertebrates94,96. To test stability of each reference gene within the same host, between hosts, and across different cDNA sets, the coefficient of variation (CV) of the Cq was calculated from the ratio of standard deviation to the mean and expressed as a percentage.
Relative quantification of T. bryosalmonae transcripts in each infected host was calculated using data from serially diluted reference DNA and normalized against the T. bryosalmonae reference gene, RPL18 in each qPCR run and expressed as arbitrary units, as described previously33. Relative expression calculated in this way allows only comparison of host expression profiles for individual transcripts. Fold difference was used to facilitate interpretation of expression differences between hosts, with infected fish kidney expression levels normalized to infected bryozoan levels using the delta-delta Cq method97.
In support of the validity and reliability of this RT-qPCR assay, our previous laboratory studies indicate that the unknown fish-specific secretory antigen, P14G8 is expressed at the protein level in fish kidneys from early (grade 0–1) to advanced (grade 2–3) clinical disease and closely correlates with P14G8 transcription in kidney samples (Holland et al., in preparation). In contrast, the much lower P14G8 expression in infected bryozoan samples was concomitant with a lack of detectable protein. The unknown secretory antigen C-39373, examined in this study, exhibited a similar fish-specific transcriptional profile as PG148 (Fig. 8C). The reliability of our RT-qPCR data is further supported by the apparent dominance of parasite LDL-R transcripts in myxozoan-infected fish tissues, as reported previously (Fig. 6; Supplementary Table S4)18,19.
DNA extraction and further verification of gene origin
Genomic DNA was extracted from Trizol-reagent homogenate using a DNA back extraction buffer (BEB) and dissolved in TE buffer, as described previously98. To further verify that the T. bryosalmonae transcripts corresponding to homeobox genes and a frizzled receptor homologue were parasite in origin, PCR analysis was conducted on genomic DNA from uninfected and T. bryosalmonae-infected bryozoan and rainbow trout kidney tissues using validated primers designed to specifically amplify genomic DNA, as listed in Supplementary Table S5. All PCR amplicons were verified by sequencing.
All relative expression data sets of T. bryosalmonae were log2 transformed prior to statistical analysis to determine differences of expression. Using the Mann Whitney U test, T. bryosalmonae gene expression was considered significantly different between hosts when P < 0.05. All statistical analyses were performed using GraphPad Prism (version 5.04, GraphPad Software Inc., La Jolla, USA). No statistical test was performed on the fold change expression analysis calculated by the delta-delta Cq method, which was performed to improve visualisation of expression differences calculated by relative expression.
Additional data that support the findings of this study are available in; (1) Figshare submission of Supplementary Tables S1-S5 (https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.12951041) and Supplementary Figs. S1–S3. (2) European Nucleotide Archive (ENA) sequence submission under the accession number PRJEB19471. Raw sequence reads are available for both trout-derived and spore sac-derived transcriptomes. (3) Figshare submission of intersect transcriptome and bryozoan/trout pre- and post-parasite filtered T. bryosalmonae transcriptome datasets (https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.11889672), (4) GenBank submission of individual contig sequences (accession numbers provided in Supplementary Table S5).
Okamura, B., Hartikainen, H., Schmidt-Posthaus, H. & Wahli, T. Life cycle complexity, environmental change and the emerging status of salmonid proliferative kidney disease: PKD as an emerging disease of salmonid fish. Freshw. Biol. 56, 735–753 (2011).
Carraro, L. et al. Integrated field, laboratory, and theoretical study of PKD spread in a Swiss prealpine river. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 114, 11992–11997 (2017).
Tops, S., Lockwood, W. & Okamura, B. Temperature-driven proliferation of Tetracapsuloidesbryosalmonae in bryozoan hosts portends salmonid declines. Dis. Aquat. Org. 70, 227–236 (2006).
Canning, E. U., Curry, A., Feist, S. W., Longshaw, M. & Okamura, B. A new class and order of myxozoans to accommodate parasites of bryozoans with ultrastructural observations on Tetracapsulabryosalmonae (PKX Organism). J. Eukaryot. Microbiol. 47, 456–468 (2000).
Feist, S., Longshaw, M., Canning, E. & Okamura, B. Induction of proliferative kidney disease (PKD) in rainbow trout Oncorhynchusmykiss via the bryozoan Fredericellasultana infected with Tetracapsulabryosalmonae. Dis. Aquat. Org. 45, 61–68 (2001).
Longshaw, M., Le Deuff, R.-M., Harris, A. F. & Feist, S. W. Development of proliferative kidney disease in rainbow trout, Oncorhynchusmykiss (Walbaum), following short-term exposure to Tetracapsulabryosalmonae infected bryozoans. J. Fish Dis. 25, 443–449 (2002).
Bettge, K., Wahli, T., Segner, H. & Schmidt-Posthaus, H. Proliferative kidney disease in rainbow trout: Time- and temperature-related renal pathology and parasite distribution. Dis. Aquat. Organ. 83, 67–76 (2009).
Hedrick, R. P., MacConnell, E. & de Kinkelin, P. Proliferative kidney disease of salmonid fish. Annu. Rev. Fish Dis. 3, 277–290 (1993).
Abos, B. et al. Dysregulation of B cell activity during proliferative kidney disease in rainbow trout. Front. Immunol. 9, 1203 (2018).
Bailey, C., Strepparava, N., Wahli, T. & Segner, H. Exploring the immune response, tolerance and resistance in proliferative kidney disease of salmonids. Dev. Comp. Immunol. 90, 165–175 (2019).
Bailey, C., von Siebenthal, E. W., Rehberger, K. & Segner, H. Transcriptomic analysis of the impacts of ethinylestradiol (EE2) and its consequences for proliferative kidney disease outcome in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchusmykiss). Comp. Biochem. Physiol. C Toxicol. Pharmacol. 222, 31–48 (2019).
Atkinson, S. D., Bartholomew, J. L. & Lotan, T. Myxozoans: Ancient metazoan parasites find a home in phylum Cnidaria. Zoology 129, 66–68 (2018).
Foox, J. & Siddall, M. E. The road to Cnidaria: History of phylogeny of the myxozoa. J. Parasitol. 101, 269–274 (2015).
Holland, J. W., Okamura, B., Hartikainen, H. & Secombes, C. J. A novel minicollagen gene links cnidarians and myxozoans. Proc. R. Soc. B 278, 546–553 (2011).
Chang, E. S. et al. Genomic insights into the evolutionary origin of Myxozoa within Cnidaria. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 112, 14912–14917 (2015).
Okamura, B. & Gruhl, A. Myxozoan affinities and route to endoparasitism. In Myxozoan Evolution, Ecology and Development (eds Okamura, B. et al.) 23–44 (Springer, Berlin, 2015).
Okamura, B., Gruhl, A. & Bartholomew, J. L. An introduction to myxozoan evolution, ecology and development. In Myxozoan Evolution, Ecology and Development (eds Okamura, B. et al.) 1–20 (Springer, Berlin, 2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-14753-6_1.
Yang, Y. et al. The genome of the myxosporean Thelohanelluskitauei shows adaptations to nutrient acquisition within its fish host. Genome Biol. Evol. 6, 3182–3198 (2014).
Saulnier, D. Cloning, sequencing and expression of a cDNA encoding an antigen from the Myxosporean parasite causing the proliferative kidney disease of salmonid fish. Mol. Biochem. Parasitol. 83, 153–161 (1996).
Gruhl, A. & Okamura, B. Tissue characteristics and development in myxozoa. In Myxozoan Evolution, Ecology and Development (eds Okamura, B. et al.) 155–174 (Springer, Berlin, 2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-14753-6_9.
Canning, E. & Okamura, B. Biodiversity and evolution of the myxozoa. In Advances in Parasitology Vol 56 43–131 (Elsevier, New York, 2003).
Hartikainen, H. & Okamura, B. Castrating parasites and colonial hosts. Parasitology 139, 547–556 (2012).
Foox, J., Ringuette, M., Desser, S. S. & Siddall, M. E. In silico hybridization enables transcriptomic illumination of the nature and evolution of Myxozoa. BMC Genom. 16, 20 (2015).
Alama-Bermejo, G., Holzer, A. S. & Bartholomew, J. L. Myxozoan adhesion and virulence: Ceratonovashasta on the move. Microorganisms 7, 397 (2019).
Geurts, N., Opdenakker, G. & Van den Steen, P. E. Matrix metalloproteinases as therapeutic targets in protozoan parasitic infections. Pharmacol. Ther. 133, 257–279 (2012).
Paing, M. M. & Tolia, N. H. Multimeric assembly of host–pathogen adhesion complexes involved in apicomplexan invasion. PLoS Pathog 10, e1004120 (2014).
Vallochi, A. L. et al. Lipid droplet, a key player in host–parasite interactions. Front. Immunol. 9, 1022 (2018).
Schroeder, A. et al. The RIN: An RNA integrity number for assigning integrity values to RNA measurements. BMC Mol. Biol. 7, 3 (2006).
Berthelot, C. et al. The rainbow trout genome provides novel insights into evolution after whole-genome duplication in vertebrates. Nat. Commun. 5, 3657 (2014).
Macqueen, D. J., Garcia de la Serrana, D. & Johnston, I. A. Evolution of ancient functions in the vertebrate insulin-like growth factor system uncovered by study of duplicated salmonid fish genomes. Mol. Biol. Evol. 30, 1060–1076 (2013).
Ashburner, M. et al. Gene Ontology: Tool for the unification of biology. Nat. Genet. 25, 25–29 (2000).
Ye, J. et al. WEGO 2.0: A web tool for analyzing and plotting GO annotations, 2018 update. Nucleic Acids Res. 46, W71–W75 (2018).
Gorgoglione, B., Wang, T., Secombes, C. J. & Holland, J. W. Immune gene expression profiling of Proliferative Kidney Disease in rainbow trout Oncorhynchusmykiss reveals a dominance of anti-inflammatory, antibody and T helper cell-like activities. Vet. Res. 44, 55 (2013).
Kotob, M. H. et al. Differential modulation of host immune genes in the kidney and cranium of the rainbow trout (Oncorhynchusmykiss) in response to Tetracapsuloidesbryosalmonae and Myxoboluscerebralis co-infections. Parasites Vectors 11, 326 (2018).
Holland, J. W., Gould, C. R. W., Jones, C. S., Noble, L. R. & Secombes, C. J. Immune gene expression during PKD infection. Department Environ. Food Rural Affairs Report FC 1112, 1–22 (2004).
Shpirer, E. et al. Diversity and evolution of myxozoan minicollagens and nematogalectins. BMC Evol. Biol. 14, 205 (2014).
Renslo, A. R. & McKerrow, J. H. Drug discovery and development for neglected parasitic diseases. Nat. Chem. Biol. 2, 701–710 (2006).
Wetzel, S., Seipold, L. & Saftig, P. The metalloproteinase. ADAM10: A useful therapeutic target?. Biochim. Biophys. Acta Mol. Cell Res. 1864, 2071–2081 (2017).
Hambrook, J. R., Kaboré, A. L., Pila, E. A. & Hanington, P. C. A metalloprotease produced by larval Schistosomamansoni facilitates infection establishment and maintenance in the snail host by interfering with immune cell function. PLoS Pathog. 14, e1007393 (2018).
McKerrow, J. H., Caffrey, C., Kelly, B., Loke, P. & Sajid, M. Proteases in parasitic diseases. Annu. Rev. Pathol. Mech. Dis. 1, 497–536 (2006).
Feist, S. W., Morris, D. J., Alama-Bermejo, G. & Holzer, A. S. Cellular processes in myxozoans. In Myxozoan Evolution, Ecology and Development (eds Okamura, B. et al.) 139–154 (Springer, Berlin, 2015).
Klein, T. & Bischoff, R. Active metalloproteases of the a disintegrin and metalloprotease (ADAM) family: Biological function and structure. J. Proteome Res. 10, 17–33 (2011).
Lambrecht, B. N., Vanderkerken, M. & Hammad, H. The emerging role of ADAM metalloproteinases in immunity. Nat. Rev. Immunol. 18, 745–758 (2018).
Möller-Hackbarth, K. et al. A disintegrin and metalloprotease (ADAM) 10 and ADAM17 are major sheddases of T cell immunoglobulin and mucin domain 3 (Tim-3). J. Biol. Chem. 288, 34529–34544 (2013).
Lee, H. et al. CD53, a suppressor of inflammatory cytokine production, is associated with population asthma risk via the functional promoter polymorphism −1560 C>T. Biochim. Biophys. Acta Gener. Subj. 1830, 3011–3018 (2013).
Schaper, F. & van Spriel, A. B. Antitumor immunity is controlled by tetraspanin proteins. Front. Immunol. 9, 1185 (2018).
Sitjà-Bobadilla, A., Schmidt-Posthaus, H., Wahli, T., Holland, J. W. & Secombes, C. J. Fish immune responses to myxozoa. In Myxozoan Evolution, Ecology and Development (eds Okamura, B. et al.) 253–280 (Springer, Berlin, 2015). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-14753-6_14.
Santra, M. et al. Thymosin β4 UP-regulation of microRNA-146a promotes oligodendrocyte differentiation and suppression of the toll-like proinflammatory pathway. J. Biol. Chem. 289, 19508–19518 (2014).
Gazos-Lopes, F., Martin, J. L., Dumoulin, P. C. & Burleigh, B. A. Host triacylglycerols shape the lipidome of intracellular trypanosomes and modulate their growth. PLoS Pathog. 13, e1006800 (2017).
Schaufler, L. E., Vollenweider, J. J. & Moles, A. Changes in the lipid class and proximate compositions of coho salmon (Oncorhynchuskisutch) smolts infected with the nematode parasite Philonemaagubernaculum. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. B Biochem. Mol. Biol. 149, 148–152 (2008).
Sviridov, D. & Bukrinsky, M. Interaction of pathogens with host cholesterol metabolism. Curr. Opin. Lipidol. 25, 333–338 (2014).
Inoue, A. & Aoki, J. Phospholipase A 1: Structure, distribution and function. Future Lipidology 1, 687–700 (2006).
Wang, T. et al. The mitotic and metabolic effects of phosphatidic acid in the primary muscle cells of turbot (Scophthalmusmaximus). Front. Endocrinol. 9, 221 (2018).
Ramanadham, S. et al. Calcium-independent phospholipases A 2 and their roles in biological processes and diseases. J. Lipid Res. 56, 1643–1668 (2015).
Hamid, P. H. et al. Eimeria bovis infection modulates endothelial host cell cholesterol metabolism for successful replication. Vet. Res. 46, 100 (2015).
Bhatnagar, S., Nicklas, S., Morrisey, J. M., Goldberg, D. E. & Vaidya, A. B. Diverse chemical compounds target Plasmodiumfalciparum plasma membrane lipid homeostasis. ACS Infect. Dis. 5, 550–558 (2019).
Coppens, I. Targeting lipid biosynthesis and salvage in apicomplexan parasites for improved chemotherapies. Nat. Rev. Microbiol. 11, 823–835 (2013).
Nolan, S. J., Romano, J. D., Kline, J. T. & Coppens, I. Novel approaches to kill Toxoplasmagondii by exploiting the uncontrolled uptake of unsaturated fatty acids and vulnerability to lipid storage inhibition of the parasite. Antimicrob. Agents Chemother. 62, e00347-18 (2018).
Weber, S. & Saftig, P. Ectodomain shedding and ADAMs in development. Development 139, 3693–3709 (2012).
Pandey, K. N. Emerging roles of natriuretic peptides and their receptors in pathophysiology of hypertension and cardiovascular regulation. J. Am. Soc. Hypertens. 2, 210–226 (2008).
Grandchamp, A., Tahir, S. & Monget, P. Natriuretic peptides appeared after their receptors in vertebrates. BMC Evol. Biol. 19, 215 (2019).
Lakshmanan, V. et al. Cyclic GMP balance is critical for malaria parasite transmission from the mosquito to the mammalian host. mBio 6, e02330-14 (2015).
Salmon, D. Adenylate cyclases of Trypanosomabrucei, environmental sensors and controllers of host innate immune response. Pathogens 7, 48 (2018).
Daniyan, M. O., Przyborski, J. M. & Shonhai, A. Partners in mischief: Functional networks of heat shock proteins of plasmodium falciparum and their influence on parasite virulence. Biomolecules 9, 295 (2019).
Zilberstein, D. & Shapira, M. The role of pH and temperature in the development of leishmania parasites. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 48, 449–470 (1994).
Sinai, A. P., Knoll, L. J. & Weiss, L. M. Bradyzoite and sexual stage development. In Toxoplasmagondiigondii 807–857 (Elsevier, New York, 2020). https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-815041-2.00018-9.
Piriatinskiy, G. et al. Functional and proteomic analysis of Ceratonovashasta (Cnidaria: Myxozoa) polar capsules reveals adaptations to parasitism. Sci Rep 7, 9010 (2017).
Wang, Y., Chang, H., Rattner, A. & Nathans, J. Frizzled receptors in development and disease. In Current Topics in Developmental Biology Vol 117 113–139 (Elsevier, New York, 2016).
Kumar, G., Ertl, R., Bartholomew, J. L. & El-Matbouli, M. First transcriptome analysis of bryozoan Fredericellasultana, the primary host of myxozoan parasite Tetracapsuloidesbryosalmonae. PeerJ 8, e9027 (2020).
Sexton, A. E., Doerig, C., Creek, D. J. & Carvalho, T. G. Post-genomic approaches to understanding malaria parasite biology: Linking genes to biological functions. ACS Infect. Dis. 5, 1269–1278 (2019).
Fontes, I., Hartikainen, H., Holland, J., Secombes, C. & Okamura, B. Tetracapsuloides bryosalmonae abundance in river water. Dis. Aquat. Org. 124, 145–157 (2017).
Hartikainen, H., Fontes, I. & Okamura, B. Parasitism and phenotypic change in colonial hosts. Parasitology 140, 1403–1412 (2013).
Clifton-Hadley, R. S., Richards, R. H. & Bucke, D. Proliferative kidney disease (PKD) in rainbow trout Salmogairdneri: Further observations on the effects of water temperature. Aquaculture 55, 165–171 (1986).
Kosakyan, A. et al. Selection of suitable reference genes for gene expression studies in myxosporean (Myxozoa, Cnidaria) parasites. Sci. Rep. 9, 15073 (2019).
Wang, T. et al. Functional characterization of a nonmammalian IL-21: Rainbow trout Oncorhynchusmykiss IL-21 upregulates the expression of the Th cell signature cytokines IFN-γ, IL-10, and IL-22. J. Immunol. 186, 708–721 (2011).
Morgulis, A. et al. Database indexing for production MegaBLAST searches. Bioinformatics 24, 1757–1764 (2008).
Pertea, G. et al. TIGR gene indices clustering tools (TGICL): A software system for fast clustering of large EST datasets. Bioinformatics 19, 651–652 (2003).
Huang, X. CAP3: A DNA sequence assembly program. Genome Res. 9, 868–877 (1999).
Gurevich, A., Saveliev, V., Vyahhi, N. & Tesler, G. QUAST: Quality assessment tool for genome assemblies. Bioinformatics 29, 1072–1075 (2013).
Waterhouse, R. M. et al. BUSCO applications from quality assessments to gene prediction and phylogenomics. Mol. Biol. Evol. 35, 543–548 (2018).
Langmead, B., Trapnell, C., Pop, M. & Salzberg, S. L. Ultrafast and memory-efficient alignment of short DNA sequences to the human genome. Genome Biol. 10, R25 (2009).
Moreno-Hagelsieb, G. & Latimer, K. Choosing BLAST options for better detection of orthologs as reciprocal best hits. Bioinformatics 24, 319–324 (2008).
Dorrell, R. G. et al. Principles of plastid reductive evolution illuminated by nonphotosynthetic chrysophytes. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 116, 6914–6923 (2019).
Laetsch, D. R. & Blaxter, M. L. BlobTools: Interrogation of genome assemblies. F1000Res 6, 1287 (2017).
Bryant, D. M. et al. A tissue-mapped axolotl de novo transcriptome enables identification of limb regeneration factors. Cell Rep. 18, 762–776 (2017).
Haas, B. J. et al. De novo transcript sequence reconstruction from RNA-seq using the Trinity platform for reference generation and analysis. Nat. Protoc. 8, 1494 (2013).
Petersen, T. N., Brunak, S., von Heijne, G. & Nielsen, H. SignalP 4.0: Discriminating signal peptides from transmembrane regions. Nat. Methods 8, 785–786 (2011).
Krogh, A., Larsson, B., von Heijne, G. & Sonnhammer, E. L. L. Predicting transmembrane protein topology with a hidden Markov model: Application to complete genomes11Edited by F. Cohen. J. Mol. Biol. 305, 567–580 (2001).
Eddy, S. R. Profile hidden Markov models. Bioinformatics 14, 755–763 (1998).
Finn, R. D. et al. Pfam: The protein families database. Nucl. Acids Res. 42, D222–D230 (2014).
Lagesen, K. et al. RNAmmer: Consistent and rapid annotation of ribosomal RNA genes. Nucleic Acids Res. 35, 3100–3108 (2007).
Rawlings, N. D. et al. The MEROPS database of proteolytic enzymes, their substrates and inhibitors in 2017 and a comparison with peptidases in the PANTHER database. Nucleic Acids Res. 46, D624–D632 (2018).
Camacho, C. et al. BLAST+: Architecture and applications. BMC Bioinform. 10, 421 (2009).
Li, Y. et al. Systematic identification and validation of the reference genes from 60 RNA-Seq libraries in the scallop Mizuhopectenyessoensis. BMC Genom. 20, 288 (2019).
Rodriguez-Lanetty, M., Phillips, W. S., Dove, S., Hoegh-Guldberg, O. & Weis, V. M. Analytical approach for selecting normalizing genes from a cDNA microarray platform to be used in q-RT-PCR assays: A cnidarian case study. J. Biochem. Biophys. Methods 70, 985–991 (2008).
Bai, Z. et al. Identification of housekeeping genes suitable for gene expression analysis in the pearl mussel, Hyriopsiscumingii, during biomineralization. Mol. Genet. Genom. 289, 717–725 (2014).
Livak, K. J. & Schmittgen, T. D. Analysis of relative gene expression data using real-time quantitative PCR and the 2−ΔΔCT method. Methods 25, 402–408 (2001).
Triant, D. A. & Whitehead, A. Simultaneous extraction of high-quality RNA and DNA from small tissue samples. J. Hered. 100, 246–250 (2009).
This study was supported financially by the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC-1087-CS), a Swiss National Science Foundation Sinergia Project (CRS113 147649), a Ph.D. studentship to Marc Faber from the EU H2020 (H2020-SFS-10a-2014) program (ParaFishControl; 634429) and the Natural History Museum, London. We would like to thank Christopher Saunders-Davies of Test Valley Trout Ltd and Oliver Robinson of the British Trout Association for provision of fish and sampling facilities. Dr Daniel MacQueen of the Roslin Institute, University of Edinburgh, for provision of rainbow trout transcriptome assemblies. This publication reflects the views only of the authors, and the European Commission cannot be held responsible for any use which may be made of the information contained therein.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Faber, M., Shaw, S., Yoon, S. et al. Comparative transcriptomics and host-specific parasite gene expression profiles inform on drivers of proliferative kidney disease. Sci Rep 11, 2149 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-020-77881-7