Recently, consistent success in life-supporting (orthotopic) porcine cardiac xenotransplantation has been reported1. In that study hearts from α1,3-galactosyltransferase-knockout (GTKO) pigs that express human membrane cofactor protein (CD46) and human thrombomodulin (hTM) had been transplanted into baboons and survival times up to 195 days were achieved. This is a milestone on the way to clinical cardiac xenotransplantation which is urgently needed: The supply of human organs does not match the needs and many patients with terminal cardiac failure die while being on the waiting list.

Xenotransplantation with genetically modified porcine organs, as an alternative to allogenic (human-to-human) procedures may be associated with the transmission of porcine microorganisms, among them the porcine endogenous retroviruses (PERVs). PERVs are integrated in the genome of all pigs and they are able to infect human cells2. However, until now no PERV transmission was observed in the first preclinical (for review see ref.2) and clinical xenotransplantation trials3,4. Whereas PERV-A and PERV-B, which are present in all pigs, infect human cells, PERV-C infects only pig cells and is not present in all pigs2. However, recombinations between PERV-A and PERV-C can occur and the recombinant PERV-A/C is characterised by a higher replication competence5. Therefore, it is highly recommended to use PERV-C-free pigs for xenotransplantation. Interestingly, using CRISPR/Cas all retroviral sequences can be inactivated in the pig genome7, however, it is still unclear whether this is needed for a safe xenotransplantation9.

From the other viruses widely distributed in pigs, the porcine cytomegalovirus (PCMV) is of great concern10. PCMV is related with the human cytomegalovirus (HCMV), also called human herpesvirus 5 (HHV-5). HCMV causes fatal infections in human organ transplant recipients if not treated, leading to end-organ disease, such as gastrointestinal ulceration, hepatitis, pneumonitis or retinitis. HCMV can also lead to systemic infection and disease once a threshold value of virus load is exceeded11. In fact, HCMV has also been detected in the bowel mucosa where its reactivation has been suggested to lead to IL-6 release and inflammatory bowel disease12.

Meanwhile it was shown that PCMV is a roseolovirus and more closely related with human herpesviruses 6A, 6B and 7 (HHV-6A, HHV-6B, and HHV-7)13. Therefore the thermology PCMV is to a certain degree misleading and should actually be porcine roseolovirus (PCMV/PRV)14. The International Committee on Taxonomy of Viruses (ICTV) classified this virus as suid betaherpesvirus 215. The closely related HHV-6 and HHV-7 were reported to be associated with numerous diseases, e.g., liver failure16, multiple sclerosis17 and Alzheimer disease18. Furthermore, HHV-6 was found to promote cancer development19 and accelerate acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) in humans and monkeys20,21, possibly by its immunosuppressive property21,22,23,24,25.

Recently, by analysing a baboon recipient of orthotopic pig heart transplantation with a relatively short survival time (29 days) and hepatic failure, PCMV/PRV infection was observed in the recipient26. In addition, PCMV/PRV transmission was also found in two other baboon recipients with 4 and 40 days of transplant survival. Immunohistochemical studies of the recipient baboons showed PCMV/PRV-expressing cells in all organs of the animal, most likely representing disseminated pig cells27. These data, together with similar data on pig kidney xenotransplantions in non-human primates28,29, suggest that PCMV/PRV significantly reduces the survival of pig xenotransplants. However, the mechanism through which PCMV/PRV reduces transplant survival is still unclear30.

To better understand the impact of PCMV/PRV on pig transplant survival in orthotopic heart transplantation, numerous donor pig—baboon recipient pairs were retrospectively analysed for PCMV/PRV transmission. Here, we demonstrate for the first time that PCMV transmission in orthotopic pig heart xenotransplantation is associated with a reduced survival time of the transplant and indicate an impact of PCMV/PVR on cytokine release and coagulation. Furthermore, we show that other porcine viruses, which could potentially impact xenotransplant survival, including PERVs, hepatitis E virus (HEV), three porcine lymphotropic herpesviruses (PLHV) and the porcine circoviruses (PCV) 1 and 2, had not been transmitted.


Transmission of PCMV/PRV into baboons after orthotopic pig heart transplantation

All baboon recipients received an immunosuppression including an induction therapy with an anti-CD20 antibody, anti-thymocyte-globulin and a monkey-specific anti-CD40 monoclonal antibody or humanized anti-CD40LPASylated as described in detail1. Three groups of animals have been transplanted. In group I, donor organs were preserved with two clinically approved crystalloid solutions, the animals survived for less than 30 days (animal C, Table 1) and suffered from perioperative cardiac xenograft dysfunction (PCXD). To reduce the PCXD, in group II the pig hearts were preserved with an oxygenated albumin-containing hyperoncotic cardioplegic solution. Three of the four animals of this group lived for 18 (animal F), 27 (animal H) and 40 (animal I) days. A diastolic heart failure and subsequent congestive liver damage resulting from massive cardiac overgrow were observed in these animals. To prevent this, in group III baboon recipients were weaned from cortisone at an early stage and received antihypertensive treatment since pigs have a lower systolic blood pressure than baboons. In addition, a temsirolimus medication was used to counteract cardiac overgrowth. Two recipients in this group survived for 195 (animal O, Table 2) and 182 (animal N) days1.

Table 1 PCMV infection in explanted pig hearts from different baboons.
Table 2 Testing donor pigs and recipient baboons of transplantation group III for different viruses.

When the recipient baboon organs from group I and group II were analysed for PCMV/PRV transmission, PCMV/PRV was detected not only in the explanted pig heart but also in several different organs from all baboons except one (G; Table 1). Some of these animals (B, D, E) survived only one day and showed very low virus load in the explanted heart. However, after only three days an increase of the virus load was observed (animal A). When analysing the animals with the longer survival time, e.g., animal F with 18 days, animal H with 27 days, animal C with 30 days and animal I with 40 days, it became evident that PCMV/PRV replicates over time. Animal I (number 64 in publication 27) had not only a very high virus load in the explanted heart, but a high virus load was also found in the spleen, kidney, and blood (between 100 and 1000 copies/100 ng DNA) and cells expressing PCMV/PRV proteins were found in all organs of the transplanted animal27. The longer the transplant was present in the recipient the higher was the virus load in the explanted and formalin/ethanol fixed pig heart (Table 1). This rule is operative only to a certain threshold of the virus load, above this threshold the survival time decreases due to the pathogenic effect of the virus.

When the recipient baboons of group III (early cortisone tapering, antihypertensive treatment and temsirolimus) and their donor pigs were analysed, PCMV/PRV was found to be absent in the donor pigs and consequently in the transplanted baboons of animals with the longest survival times such as baboon J (90 days), baboon K (50 days), baboon L (90 days), baboon N (182 days) and baboon O (195 days) (Table 2). In contrast, PCMV/PRV was found in the donor pigs of transplanted baboons that showed a shorter survival rate like baboon P (15 days), baboon Q (27 days) and M (euthanized 10 days after transplantation because of severe iatrogenic complication) (Table 2). In the hearts explanted from animals P and Q astonishingly high copy numbers of PCMV/PRV were detected. Since all these data were obtained testing the formalin/ethanol fixed pig hearts, in addition the virus load in the frozen right ventricle of the heart explanted from baboon P was analysed and 48 million copies were found (33 million in the fixed heart). This is in the same magnitude, indicating that testing of fixed and frozen materials give approximately the same result.

Distribution of PCMV/PRV in pig and baboon organs

Using real-time PCR, the copy number (viral load) of PCMV/PRV was analysed in PBMCs and different organs of all donor pigs and in the organs of the transplanted baboons after removal of the transplanted heart, which was also analysed. As an example we illustrate in Fig. 1 the pair donor pig 6249 and the recipient baboon P. All other animals analysed had a similar pattern. The virus load in several organs of baboon I has been shown previously (animal 64 in reference 27). With exception of the skin, the viral load was high in all baboon organs (spleen, liver, muscle, kidney lung and lymph nodes) and donor pig organs (lung, spleen, liver, kidney and PBMCs), in agreement with the results in baboon I27. The highest viral load was found in the explanted pig heart (Fig. 1). This is the main place of virus replication and this replication is possible due to the absence of the pig immune system, which could have reacted against the virus in the donor pig, and due to the strong immunosuppression in the baboon inhibiting its immune system.

Figure 1
figure 1

Viral load (copies per 100 ng DNA) in different organs of baboon P after explantation of the pig heart, in PBMCs and different organs of the donor pig and in the pig heart after explantation as measured by real-time PCR.

Pathological findings and modulation of cytokine release

As mentioned above, baboons N and O from treatment group III, showed the longest survival time, 182 and 195 days, respectively, compared to baboons P and Q, which survived only 15 and 27 days. Interestingly, both baboons P and Q were characterized by pathological and inflammatory changes, some of which might be the result of a PCMV/PRV infection, bearing in mind the broad disease spectrum induced by herpesviruses. Both animals showed signs of low-output heart failure at the end of the experiments, resulting in multi organ dysfunction as indicated by the pathological increase in functional parameters of liver, pancreas and kidney such as aspartate aminotransferase, creatine kinase, and lactate dehydrogenase. Decreased abdominal perfusion probably caused loss of mucosal barrier function in the gut, leading to translocation of intestinal microbes and to a strong increase of levels of interleukin-6 (IL-6) (Fig. 2). In fact, Klebsiella pneumonia was found in blood cultures of baboon Q one day before euthanasia. The increase in IL-6 most probably is not due to treatment with an IL-6-receptor antagonist tocilizumab, since treatment began at the very beginning of transplantation and was given to all animals as part of the treatment protocol, including animals N and O that did not show high plasma levels of the cytokine. To confirm these data and to perform a broader analysis of further pro- and anti-inflammatory cytokines, a cytometric bead array (CBA) assay for non-human primate Th1/Th2 cytokines as well as an IL-10 ELISA were performed. The obtained data confirmed the strong increase of IL-6 (Fig. 3A), and also revealed a substantial increase of tumour necrosis factor (TNF) in baboons P and Q with the PCMV/PRV-positive hearts (Fig. 3B). No alterations were observed in serum levels of the proinflammatory cytokines interferon γ (IFN γ) (Fig. 3C) and interleukin 2 (IL-2) (Fig. 3D) as well as the anti-inflammatory cytokines interleukin-4 (IL-4) (Fig. 3E), interleukin-5 (IL-5) (Fig. 3F), and interleukin-10 (IL-10) (data not shown).

Figure 2
figure 2

Kinetics of the IL-6 amount in the blood of transplanted baboons as measured by ELISA. The baboon recipients of the treatment group III are indicated (N, O, P, Q).

Figure 3
figure 3

Increased IL-6 and TNF serum levels in baboons with PCMV/PRV-positive hearts. BD CBA Non-human primate Th1/Th2 kit was used to measure plasma levels of (A) IL-6, (B) TNF, (C) IFN γ, (D) IL-2, (E) IL-4 and (F) IL-5 one week before transplantation (day -7) and during the experiment (day 13, 26, 180 and 194, respectively) in baboons N, O, P and Q. Dotted lines indicate lowest standard concentration.

Interestingly, histological examination of the explanted pig hearts from baboons N, O, P, and Q revealed marked perivascular and moderate edema in otherwise unremarkable myocardial tissue (Fig. 4A, B). In particular, no morphologic signs of cellular or antibody-mediated transplant rejection was found (Fig. 4B), and in parallel no elevated levels of non-galactose-a1,3-galactose reactive IgM and IgG were measured (not shown), indicating that immunological rejection was not the cause of the reduced survival observed in animals P and Q.

Figure 4
figure 4

A Histopathologic evaluation of the explanted pig hearts from baboons N to Q. Arrowheads mark perivascular and arrows moderate edema in otherwise unremarkable myocardial tissue in all specimens. Scale bars indicate 250 μm. B. Histopathologic evaluation revealed perivascular (arrowhead) and interstitial (arrow) edema in otherwise unremarkable myocardial tissue in all specimens. In particular, no morphologic signs of cellular or antibody-mediated transplant reaction was found. Scale bars indicate 100 µm.

High levels of tPA-PAI-1 complex

To analyse whether animals infected with PCMV/PRV could present alteration in the coagulation system, tissue plasminogen activator (tPA) and plasminogen activator inhibitor 1 complexes (tPA-PAI-1) were measured in plasma samples by an ELISA31. Interestingly, we observed that baboons P and Q, which presented clear pathological alterations, also had very high levels of tPA-PAI-1 complexes (Fig. 5). This indicates a hypercoagulable state of the two animals and a decrease in fibrinolysis, originated most probably by endothelial cell damage.

Figure 5
figure 5

Measurement of tPA-PAI-1 complexes in the blood of baboons J65-Q74.

Expression of BaCMV afterPCMV/PRV transmission

Since all baboon recipients carried BaCMV, we looked into a possible activation of this virus, which may also influence the survival time of the transplant and recipient. Recently a significantly increased expression of BaCMV in plasma of baboon I after transplantation of a PCMV/PRV-positive pig heart was measured27. Although analysis of BaCMV in all baboon organs (liver, kidney, spleen and lung) showed a high virus load, a clear and measurable increase of the BaCMV virus load in the blood after transplantation as was found in animal I was not observed (Table 2). Moreover, no differences in the BaCMV viral load in baboons with a long or a short survival time was observed. This highly suggests that activation of BaCMV is not the cause of early loss of the transplanted pig heart.

Prevalence and transmission of other porcine viruses

In order to analyse whether other porcine viruses were present in the donor pig and were transmitted to the recipient, which also may influence the survival time of the xenotransplant, both Western blot and PCR/RT-PCR analysis was performed to detect PERV, PLHV, PCV and HEV in both pig and baboon tissues. PLHV-1 and PLHV-2 had been detected in all donor pigs used in this study. Despite this, no transmission of these viruses to the recipient baboons was observed (Table 2). Although Western blot analyses showed HEV infection in the donor pigs of baboons G, I, K and L, detection of HEV by RT-PCR gave negative results in all donor pigs, indicating that the virus was not present in their blood. However, transmission to the recipients was not observed (Table 2). Indeed, all baboons were negative for HEV infection independently to the test used for analysis, e.g., no positive RT-PCR reactions and no positive ELISA or Western blot analyses were found.

PERV was detected as expected in all donor pigs by PCR using specific primers binding to a highly conserved region in the polymerase (pol) gene (Table 2). In fact, these primers recognise both PERV-A, PERV-B and PERV-C. Since PERV-A and PERV-B is present in all pigs2, a PCR using primers specific for the env region of PERV-C was performed, and PERV-C was detected in all donor pigs.

PERV was also analysed in baboon samples using the pol specific PCR, detecting PERV-A, PERV-B and PERV-C. As shown in Table 2, these sequences were detected in all baboon blood samples, however the detection of PERV in the blood samples might be due to circulating cellular DNA from dead transplant cells or from circulating pig cells, a phenomenon called microchimerism. This was confirmed by the finding of porcine glycerinaldehyde-3-phosphat-dehydrogenase (GAPDH) by a specific PCR. Since the copy number of PERV-C in pig cells is much lower compared to the copy number of PERV-A and PERV-B, PERV-C sequences could not be detected in the blood of the baboons. Moreover, Western blot analysis showed no anti-PERV antibodies in all baboon samples, clearly indicating absence of infection (Supplementary Fig. 1). In summary, no other pig viruses which could influence the survival time of the transplant had been transmitted to the recipient baboons.


Recently, survival times of 182 and 195 days after preclinical orthotopic pig-to-baboon xenotransplantation were achieved by several measures that include an improved immunosuppressive regimen, non-ischaemic preservation with continuous perfusion and control of post-transplantation growth of the transplant1. Here, for the first time, we show that the use of organs from PCMV/PRV-positive pigs in this life-supporting model is associated with a reduction of the transplant survival time.

Our data on reduction of the survival time of PCMV/PRV-positive pig hearts orthotopically transplanted into baboons supports previous findings in other preclinical trials on kidney xenotransplantations28,29,32,33,34,35,36. In these studies, PCMV/PRV was found in all organs of the baboon recipients, with the highest copy numbers in liver, lung and kidney33. An increased PCMV/PRV virus load was found in 22 different pig xenotransplants with a survival time between 7 and 32 days in baboons33. The presence of PCMV/PRV was usually found associated with consumptive coagulopathy (CC)34. However, there was no correlation between PCMV/PRV infection and CC, but lower levels of PCMV/PRV infection were always associated with a prolonged transplant survival34. When a heterotopic pig heart transplantation was performed in baboons, the survival time of the transplant was shorter when the organs were PCMV/PRV-positive (median 20 days), compared with PCMV/PRV-negative transplants (median 53 days)35. Most importantly, early weaning was shown to prevent PCMV/PRV infection of the pigs35. Organs from PCMV/PRV-free animals due to early weaning did not induce CC. Unfortunately, PCMV/PRV had been shown to have a reduced susceptibility to ganciclovir which is very effective in inhibiting HCMV36. Ganciclovir was also given to the baboons in the present study. When kidneys from GTKO pigs were transplanted into baboons, the median survival time of the kidneys from PCMV/PRV-positive animals was 14.1 days, the survival time of kidneys from PCMV/PRV-negative animals was 48.8 days and that of kidneys from PCMV/PRV-negative animals after a Caesarean delivery was 53 days28, clearly demonstrating that the transmission of PCMV/PRV reduced significantly the kidney transplant survival. A similar effect was observed, when GTKO pig kidneys were transplanted into cynomolgus monkeys. Whereas the survival time of kidneys from PCMV/PRV-free animals was 28.7 days, the presence of PCMV/PRV reduced the survival time to 9.2 days29.

The immunosuppression used in this trial is based on an induction therapy with an anti-CD20 antibody, anti-thymocyte-globulin and a monkey-specific anti-CD40 monoclonal antibody or humanized anti-CD40LPASylated. During maintenance therapy methylprednisolone was reduced gradually, whereas mycophenolate mofetil and anti-CD40 monoclonal antibody or anti-CD40L PASylated Fab treatment remained constant as described in detail1. This strategy has been used successfully in other laboratories2 and it was approved by the local Upper Bavarian Government. The selected immunosuppressive regimen will be easily translated into a future pig-to-human system. There are of course other immunosuppressive agents such as blocking leukocyte costimulatory molecules37, expression of CTLA4-Ig, which disrupts co-stimulatory pathways, and PD-L1, which activates T-cell inhibitory pathway38, and co-receptor blockage targeting CD4 and CD839, however these methods have not been applied in solid organ xenotransplantation, but mainly to prevent rejection of embryonic stem cells.

Our findings that PCMV/PRV induces IL-6 and TNF release and increases the amount of t PAI-1/tPA complexes significantly contributes to the understanding of the mechanism of action of PCMV/PRV on pig transplant survival. However, there are still open questions. It is still unclear, whether PCMV/PRV can infect baboon cells. Using PCR and immunohistochemical methods, PCMV/PRV was found in all organs of the transplanted baboon (Fig. 1 and reference 27), however it is unclear whether the cells stained positive with a specific antiserum against PCMV/PRV are disseminated PCMV/PRV-producing pig cells or infected baboon cells. It is also unclear whether PCMV/PRV can infect human cells. One report claimed infection of human cells40, whereas another report showed that human cells cannot be infected with PCMV/PRV41. In our preliminary experiments incubating PBMCs from PCMV-positive pigs with human 293 cells, no infection of the human cells was observed (unpublished data). Since different non-human primate species (cynomolgus monkeys, baboons) showed a similar reduction of the survival time (ref. 28, 29 and this study), it seems very likely that the same may happen in humans. It is important to note, that the high virus load in the recipient baboon, independent whether the virus was produced by the pig transplant or by infected baboon cells, caused rejection of the transplant mainly by acting on the cytokine production and coagulation and this cannot be analysed in a human system in vitro.

There are other factors which may contribute to the reduction of pig transplant survival time. A consumptive coagulopathy was often observed in non-human primates with pig xenotransplants34,42,43,44. Although in vitro an activation of the porcine tissue factor (TF) in porcine aortic endothelial cells by a PCMV/PRV infection was observed, no correlation between TF expression and PCMV/PRV infection was observed in vivo34. An enhanced expression of ICAM-1 (intracellular adhesion molecule I) and MHC (major histocompatibility complex) class II in the pig transplant in baboons suggests an activation of endothelial cells28. PCMV/PRV is like many other viruses immunosuppressive and was shown to modulate the expression of immune-related genes in pig immune cells22. Furthermore, a PCMV/PRV infection of pigs is usually associated with opportunistic bacterial infections on the basis of the suppressed immune system23 and a transcriptome analysis of PCMV/PRV-infected thymuses showed an up- and downregulation of immune-regulatory genes24. However, considering the strong pharmaceutical immunosuppression of the animals in order to prevent rejection of the pig organ, the immunosuppressive properties of PCMV/PRV may not be important for the PCMV/PRV-induced pathogenesis.

An upregulation of IL-6 and TNFα in several allo- and xenotransplantation studies has previously been described indicating pathological roles for these cytokines (for review see45). IL-6 is one of the most important cytokines during an infection, along with IL-1 and TNF46. TNF is a cytokine involved in systemic inflammation and is a critical effector molecule in the immune response to viral pathogens47. TNF is able to inhibit viral replication and respond to sepsis via IL-1- and IL-6-producing cells.

The pleiotropic effects of IL-6 include the stimulation of antibody production and induction of acute-phase proteins, such as C-reactive protein (C-RP) and fibrinogen48. In a pig-to-baboon xenotransplantation study in which kidneys, hearts and artery patches from GTKO or GTKO/CD46-transgenic pigs were transplanted, significantly increased IL-6 levels were observed49. High levels of fibrinogen and C-RP positively correlated with IL-6 levels and C-RP depositions in the heart and kidney xenotransplants were detected. These data indicate that the up-regulation of IL-6 might promote systemic inflammation and together with the subsequent induction of C-RP leads to a dysregulation of coagulation after xenotransplantation49. Some studies suggest that the administration of tocilizumab, an antibody raised against the IL-6 receptor, reduced antibody-mediated rejection in post-transplantation and improved allograft survival50 or reduced C-RP levels and other factors to alleviate consumptive coagulopathy51,52,53,54. Tocilizumab reacts with the human and baboon IL-6 receptor, but not with the pig IL-6 receptor54. Blocking the baboon IL-6 receptor may lead to higher circulating levels of IL-6n in the blood and this may be detrimental to pig xenotransplant survival due to IL-6 stimulation of pig cells in the transplant.

Additionally, in an in vitro model in which porcine aortic endothelial cells or PBMCs were incubated with human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVECS) an upregulation of human inflammatory cytokines including TNFα, chemokines and tissue factors by porcine IL-6 and TNFα was observed. These data indicate that porcine IL-6 and TNFα can stimulate recipient cells and thereby promote coagulation as well as inflammation upon xenotransplantation55. Besides IL-6 also TNFα was reported to be up-regulated in baboons after pig heart transplantation and seems to act as a key pro-inflammatory cytokine in xenotransplant rejection56,57. TNFα was also detected during acute rejection in porcine islets transplanted into non-human primates NHPs58. Furthermore, the TNFα antagonist etanercept was shown to suppress coagulation dysfunction in xenotransplantation and to contribute to pig kidney survival in baboons59.

Cytokines released by immune cells can also directly influence the proliferation cardiomyocytes. Whereas murine Treg cells promote proliferation of murine neonatal cardiomyocytes through paracrine factors including cytokines80, TNFα, IFNα and IL-17A produced by CD4+ Th1 and Th17 cells reduced the number of cultured murine cardiomyocytes61. Therefore these cells directly inhibited proliferation and promoted the apoptosis of neonatal mouse cardiomyocytes.

Despite the seemingly overwhelming evidence for the role of PCMV/PRV, there may also be other factors contributing to the reduced survival rates. As explained elsewhere in detail1, xenotransplantation experiments in groups I and II failed because of insufficient organ preservation and overgrowth of the transplant, respectively. Baboons P and Q (group III) were euthanized because of beginning multi-organ failure, which might be attributed to other causes than PCMV/PRV: Baboon P had received a graft of borderline small size and baboon Q developed recurrent pericardial effusions. Relative size mismatch may lead to systolic heart failure, whereas recurrent effusions may lead to pericardial tamponade and diastolic insufficiency, both eventually causing multi-organ failure. Microbial translocation and opportunistic infections were observed in animals P and Q; both are common after infection with immunosuppressive viruses including human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)44, but can also be attributed to immunosuppressive treatment by itself.

It was clearly shown that PCMV/PRV replicates in the transplanted heart (Fig. 1, Table 1). Already at day three an increase of the copy number in the heart was observed, reaching much higher copy numbers later. It may be suggested that the pharmaceutical immunosuppression given to prevent rejection and possibly the PCMV/PRV-induced immunosuppression plays an important role in allowing increased PCMV/PRV replication. For comparison, previous studies of the replication rate of HCMV in humans showed that its dynamics are rapid, with a doubling time of viraemia of approximately 1 day63. In analogy to the HCMV infection, where a clear threshold relationship was observed, e.g., the virus causes disease once a threshold value of viral load is exceeded11, such a threshold seems also important in the case of PCMV. In this context, a viral load of 2 to 3 million copies may be tolerable until day 30–40, whereas higher viral loads further reduce the survival time.

Since other viruses could also interfere with the survival time of the transplants, activation of BaCMV in the transplanted baboon and transmission of HEV, PERV, PCV1, PCV2, as well as PLHV1, 2 and 3 was analysed. All baboons used in these investigations carried BaCMV, which is common in baboons. In one case a strong activation of BaCMV after transplantation of a PCMV-positive pig heart was observed (baboon I)27. In all other cases a direct activation of BaCMV could not be observed. Concerning BaCMV activation, in another preclinical trial transplanting pig kidneys into baboons, it was also observed in control animals without transplantation, but with the corresponding immunosuppression, indicating that immunosuppression alone is able to activate BaCMV64.

HEV, genotype 3, is a well-known zoonotic virus, it is frequently transmitted to humans by undercooked meat or contact, but also by manure-contaminated fruits and water, and it induces chronic infection in immunosuppressed patients and severe liver disease in patients with an underlying liver failure65. However, until now no HEV transmission was reported in all preclinical and clinical xenotransplantation trials, including this study (Table 2).

PERV DNA was observed in the circulation of baboons following transplantation of a pig heart (Table 2). However, this observation appears to be due to circulating DNA from dead transplant cells or persistent pig cell microchimerism.

PCV1 and PCV2 were not present in the donor pigs and, logically, could not be transmitted to the recipients. Meanwhile it was published, that four donor pigs (animals 5803, 5807, 6249, 6253) were infected with PCV3 and that this virus was transmitted in all four cases to the baboon recipients (baboons O, N, P, Q)66. PCV3 is a newly described member of the virus family Circoviridae, it is highly distributed among farms pigs and wild boars worldwide (for review see Reference 67). Similarly to the situation with PCV2, PCV3 was found in healthy animals as well as in animals suffering from different diseases, suggesting that coinfections with other viruses are necessary for the pathogenic potential. PCV3 does not seem to influence the survival time because baboons with the highest survival time (animal N—182 days, O—195 days) and animals with low survival times (P—15 days, Q—27 days) were infected with PCV3. In contrast, there was a clear correlation between the infection with PCMV and survival (15 and 27 days versus 182 and 195 days).

Although all donor pigs were infected with PLHV-1 and PLHV-2, no transmission to the baboon recipients was observed, PLHV-3 was not found in the donor pigs. PLHV-1, -2, and -3 belong to the subfamily Gammaherpesvirinae in the Herpesviridae family. The pathogenicity of PLHV in pigs under natural conditions is still unclear. Under experimental conditions PLHV-1 is associated with post-transplant lymphoproliferative disease (PTLD) in miniature pigs following allogeneic haematopoietic stem cell transplantation68,69. The clinical symptoms of experimental porcine PTLD, such as fever, lethargy, anorexia, high white blood cell count and palpable lymph nodes, are similar to those of human PTLD, a serious complication of solid organ and allogeneic bone marrow transplantation, which was linked to a human gammaherpesvirus, Epstein-Barr virus (human herpes virus-4, HHV-4)70.

In order to prevent transmission of porcine viruses after xenotransplantation, elimination programs had been proposed which are based on selection and isolation of virus-negative animals, vaccination or treatment with an effective antiviral drug (both are not available in the case of PCMV/PRV), early weaning, colostrum deprivation, Caesarean delivery or embryo transfer. Although PCMV/PRV can be transmitted via placenta71,72, successful elimination can be achieved by early weaning35,73, providing virus-free animals for a safe xenotransplantation.


Animals and transplantations

All details of the donor pigs, the baboon recipients and the transplantation procedures were described in reference 1.


All baboon recipients received an immunosuppression including an induction therapy with an anti-CD20 antibody, anti-thymocyte-globulin and a monkey-specific anti-CD40 monoclonal antibody or humanized anti-CD40LPASylated as described in detail1. The group III baboon recipients analysed here were weaned from cortisone at an early stage and received antihypertensive treatment. In addition, a temsirolimus medication was applied.

Plasma and blood collection

Blood sampling from adult sows was performed without sedation under manual fixation. Whole blood was drawn from the jugular vein with single‐use needles (Ehrhardt Medizinprodukte, Geislingen, Germany) into lithium heparin and serum Monovettes (Sarstedt, Nümbrecht, Germany). Blood from the baboons was taken using a central venous catheter.

Ethics statement

Both the generation of transgenic animals, as well as interventions on re-cloned animals, were performed with permission of the local regulatory authority. Applications were reviewed by the ethics committee according to §15 TSchG German Animal Welfare Act. The xenotransplantation experiment was approved by the Government of Upper Bavaria, Munich, Germany. Housing, feeding, environmental enrichment, and steps taken to minimise suffering, including the use of anaesthesia and method of sacrifice, was in accordance with the recommendations of the Weatherall report “The use of non-human primates in research”.

Testing for PCMV/PRV

PCMV/PRV testing was performed as described25 using specific primers (Table 3). Briefly, DNA was extracted from sera, blood and organs of the pigs using the DNeasy Blood &Tissue kit (Qiagen GmbH, Hilden, Germany). DNA was quantified using a NanoDrop ND-1000 (Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc., Worcester, MA, USA). To screen for PCMV, a real-time PCR using described primers26 and the SensiFast probe no ROX kit was performed according to supplier recommendations (Bioline GmbH, Germany). DNA from formalin-fixed tissues was extracted by using the QIAamp DNA FFPE Tissue Kit (QIAGEN), following the manufacturer’s instructions. As the starting material was not paraffin-embedded but only formalin-fixed tissue, we started the process by cutting the tissue into small pieces, added buffer and proteinase and followed the manufacturer’s protocol by incubating at 56 °C. A detection limit of 20 copies was determined for the reported PCR method26. Various amounts (25—250 ng) of DNA were used for testing. The reaction mixture contained 300 nM of both primers, and 250 nM of the probe (Table 3) in a final volume of 20 µL. The following conditions for amplification were used: denaturation at 95 C for 5 min, and 45 cycles of amplification with denaturation at 95 C for 15 s, annealing at 56 C for 30 s and extension at 72 °C for 30 s. Reporter fluorescence was measured using the CFX96 Toich Real-time PCR detection system (Bio-Rad, Hercules, CA, USA).

Table 3 Primers and probes.

Testing for BaCMV

To test for BaCMV, a real-time PCR was performed using described primers32 (Table 3), but the enzymes and conditions had been changed: Denaturation at 95 °C for 5 min, and 45 cycles of amplification with denaturation at 95 °C for 15 s, annealing at 57 °C for 30 s and extension at 72 °C for 30 s.

Testing for PERV

To test for PERV, a PCR was performed using primers for the pol sequence (Table 3) as described4. This PCR detects PERV-A, PERV-B and PERV-C, since the pol region is highly conserved. To test for PERV-C, a PCR was performed using primers specific for the env region of PERV-C (Table 3)74,75. A Western blot analysis was performed using recombinant p27Gag protein, p15E protein and gp70 protein as well as goat sera against these recombinant proteins as positive control as described4,76.

Testing for HEV

To test for HEV, a real-time PCR was performed as described77 using specific primers78. Western blot analysis was performed using two overlapping recombinant ORF2 proteins of HEV genotype 3 as described77. On protein contained the immunodominant epitope (GT3-Ctr, aa 326–608, 32 kb)79, the other was with a glutathione-S-transferase tag (aa452-617, 44.5 kb, Orosperc, Ness Ziona, Israel).

Testing for PLHV

To test for PLHV-1, PLHV-2 and PLHV-3 two PCR methods and specific primers (Table 3) were used as described80,81,82.

Testing for PCV

To test for PCV1 and PCV2, a PCR method and specific primers (Table 3) were used as described63, using specific primers83.

Measurement of cytokines

IL-6 release over time was studied in the Laboratoriumsmedizin of the Munich University using an ELISA (Roche, Elecsys IL-6).

The BD™ CBA Non-Human Primate (NHP) Th1/Th2 Cytokine Kit (BD Biosciences, Heidelberg) was used to measure IL-2, IL-4, IL-5, IL-6, TNF and IFN γ in baboon serum samples according to the manufacturer´s instructions. Serum samples were diluted 1:20 before use. Samples were acquired by use of a LSR II cytometer (BD Biosciences). To measure IL-10 serum levels the IL-10 Monkey ELISA Kit (Thermo Fisher, Waltham) was used according to the manufacturer´s instructions.

Measurement of coagulation

The PAI-1/tPA complexes were measured in baboon EDTA plasma samples by a commercial ELISA kit for the measurement of human PAI-1/tPA complexes (Abcam, ab192151,

Tissue processing and histological staining

All myocardial specimens were fixed in 4% neutral-buffered formalin and embedded in paraffin. Tissue sections were then stained with hematoxylin and eosin.

Western blot analysis

To detect antibodies against PERV in baboons, recombinant surface envelope protein gp70, transmembrane envelope protein p15E and core protein p27 were used as described4,76. As control goat antisera against these recombinant proteins were used. Secondary anti-goat IgG and anti-human antibodies were used and the assay was developed using alkaline phosphatase. To detect antibodies against HEV in pigs and baboons, a recombinant genotype 3 (GT3) ORF 2 core antigen61 and a recombinant 44.5 kDa protein with a glutathione-S transferase (GST) tag fused to the ORF2 fragment (Prospec, Ness Ziona, Israel) was used77. Alkaline phosphatase conjugated antibodies were used and the reaction was developed using NBT (nitro-blue tetrazolium chloride)-BCIP (5-bromo-4-chloro-3′-indolyphosphate p-toluidine salt) substrate.