Hydraulic fracturing is often criticized due in part to the potential degradation of ground and surface water quality by high-salinity produced water generated during well stimulation and production. This preliminary study evaluated the response of the freshwater mussel, Elliptio complanata, after exposure to produced water. A limited number of adult mussels were grown over an 8-week period in tanks dosed with produced water collected from a hydraulically fractured well. The fatty tissue and carbonate shells were assessed for accumulation of both inorganic and organic pollutants. Ba, Sr, and cyclic hydrocarbons indicated the potential to accumulate in the soft tissue of freshwater mussels following exposure to diluted oil and gas produced water. Exposed mussels showed accumulation of Ba in the soft tissue several hundred times above background water concentrations and increased concentrations of Sr. Cyclic hydrocarbons were detected in dosed mussels and principle component analysis of gas chromatograph time-of-flight mass spectrometer results could be a novel tool to help identify areas where aquatic organisms are impacted by oil and gas produced water, but larger studies with greater replication are necessary to confirm these results.
Worldwide, an estimated 3 barrels of water are generated for each barrel of oil extracted1. Over 3 billion m3/year of oil and gas produced water is generated in the United States while pressure to beneficially use this water for agriculture and livestock is growing in water-stressed areas2,3,4. Produced waters often contain elevated radioactivity, total dissolved solids (TDS), dissolved metals, and organics that create unique challenges for disposal or beneficial reuse5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13. Accidental spill events, spreading on roads, and permitted releases of treated produced water have led to water and sediment contamination and raised concerns regarding potential toxicity to aquatic organisms12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,28,29 even at low concentrations (0.04–3.9%)22,23,24,25,26.
A limited number of studies have examined the lethal concentrations (LC50) and the developmental, mobility, and transcriptional responses to xenobiotic metabolomics pathways22,23,24,25 for select aquatic species from exposures to produced water. Acute and chronic effects have been observed in the aquatic invertebrate Lumbriculus variegatus (Californian Blackworm) at 10% and 0.1% additions of produced water, respectively. High salinity and low dissolved oxygen were thought to drive the toxicity. Similarly, salinity rather than organics in produced water controlled the mortality (and immobility) of the crustacean, Daphnia, introduced to freshwaters mixed with small percentages of raw and synthetic produced waters. Evaluations of zebra fish12,24,30,31 and rainbow trout26,32 also confirm toxicity and mortality with exposure to low concentrations of produced water. While many of these organisms listed above demonstrate acute and chronic toxicity after exposure to produced waters, the organisms’ mobility in aquatic ecosystems limits their ability to track pollution events or to be indicators of local changes in water quality. In contrast, sessile aquatic organisms, like freshwater mussels, spend their adult lives in one location, thereby allowing them to be potential indicators of water quality in specific geographic locations.
A limited number of studies have examined freshwater mussels exposed to high salinity water. Unionid mussels (Lampsilis Siliquoidea) exposed to elevated salinity in the form of high Cl concentrations from KCl and NaCl salts or synthetic inorganic mixtures that represent produced waters resulted in increased mortality and decreased growth33,34,35. In cages placed downstream of an oil and gas discharge, high mortality was observed in riffleshell mussels (Epioblasma torulosa rangiana)36. Another study demonstrated that freshwater mussels downstream of produced water discharges incorporated strontium into their shell material with 87Sr/86Sr signatures similar to that measured in oil and gas wastewaters37. Importantly, the potential of sentinel species to accumulate produced water contaminants in soft tissue, which could then be used as forensic tools, has not been assessed.
Sampling freshwater mussels, which are sessile, benthic filter-feeders, may be useful to assess water quality and bioaccumulation of environmental pollutants38,39,40,41. Environmental contamination is proposed as a factor in the recent decline of many freshwater species42,43,44 and the concentrations of trace metals (i.e., Cu, Fe, Mn) in mussel tissue are generally correlated to the concentrations in the water that they inhabit45,46,47. Importantly, studies on freshwater mussels indicate that the metal to calcium ratio in the water and the solubility of the divalent metal hydrogen phosphate mineral controls the accumulation potential of divalent metals in the soft tissue48,49,50. Alternatively, metals could accumulate as secondary precipitated minerals, such as barite in the carbonate shell51. Recent research has focused on freshwater mussel species as biomonitors, including monitors of energy extraction activities34,38,39 and long term studies have also been conducted such as a study by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) monitoring mussel bioaccumulation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs)41. The large geographic range of some mussel species makes these organisms candidates for studying the impacts to surface water from energy extraction activities. Importantly, North American freshwater mussel species are undergoing the largest extinction rates compared to any other faunal groups52,53,54.
Here, we exposed adults of a freshwater mussel species, Elliptio complanata, to low concentrations (1–4%) of hydraulic fracturing produced water similar to concentrations that were reported downstream of oil and gas wastewater disposal facilities. We assess the potential contaminant accumulation in adults in a limited controlled laboratory study to determine possible forensic tracers. We hypothesized that exposure to produced water can result in the accumulation of constituents in both the soft tissue and the hard shell that can be used to fingerprint the source of contamination events.
Results and discussion
Incorporation of organic signatures
Bioaccumulation of organic constituents in the fatty tissues of mussels was assessed by analysis with GC × GC-TOFMS, an analytical technique that maximizes the number of separated chemical compounds in a single analysis. This chromatographic method separated hydrocarbons based on vapor pressure (boiling point) in the x-axis and by pi-pi intermolecular interactions in the y-axis. Since compound separation is performed through interactions with the stationary phase of the columns, the axes are thus labeled retention times to indicate when the separated compounds elute from the columns. Since two mechanisms of separation are employed in GC × GC, compounds that are chemically related (i.e. increasing carbon chain lengths) elute in diagonal patterns in the chromatographic space. Differences in GC × GC-TOFMS chromatographs between treatment groups (control, low and high dose) show that hydrocarbons in oil and gas produced waters accumulated in the mussel tissue. Compared to mussels grown in control tanks (Fig. 1A) mussels exposed to produced water showed a higher abundance and diversity of cyclic hydrocarbons such as cyclopentanes, cyclohexanes, and hydronaphthalenes (white ovals in Fig. 1B,C). These signatures in fatty tissue are very similar to the GC × GC-TOFMS chromatographs of produced water, which is dominated by saturated hydrocarbons, including n-alkanes, branched alkanes, cyclohexanes, cyclopentanes, adamantanes, and hydronaphthalenes (Fig. 1D). While not every compound present in the produced water is also present in the mussel tissue, it is likely that the higher abundance and diversity of cyclic hydrocarbons observed in the fatty tissues is a result of the exposure to produced water.
To determine if the cyclic hydrocarbons found in the fatty tissue of mussels that were exposed to produced water are statistically differentiated from the control group, a principal component analysis (PCA) of the GC × GC-TOFMS data was performed55. Both the high and low dose exposure groups plotted away from both method blanks and the control samples as well as produced water (Fig. 2). The PCA features that contributed to the differentiation between dosed and un-dosed groups were attributed to exposure to produced water because of the shift in both PCA 1 and PCA 2 scores. Of these features, 74% were cyclic hydrocarbons, which is a major class of compounds in the produced water. The persistence of the cyclic hydrocarbons in the fatty tissue may be a potential fingerprinting mechanism for identifying shale gas impacts. Aquatic organisms are known to accumulate PAHs, which can result in negative health responses56. Studies on a predator of mussels, muskrats, has shown that populations living in areas with higher PAHs in sediment could be negatively impacted57.
Analyzing the PCA, it is important to note that exposed mussels did not plot in a region near the produced water, indicating the produced water is chemically distinct from the mussels. However, the mussels exposed to produced water are more chemically similar to the produced water than those that were not exposed to the produced water, as shown by the separation between unexposed and exposed mussel populations in PC1 (Fig. 2). In addition, the exposed mussels show a large difference from the control mussels, as shown in PC2. Combined, the method indicates a measurable difference in exposed populations, as determined by PCA.
Elliptio complanata have been used as a biomonitoring species for a diversity of organic compounds. Most commonly, the bioaccumulation of persistent organic pollutants such as polyaromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) have been studied58,59,60,61. Previous studies have also assessed the accumulation of other environmental pollutants such as pesticides and polychlorinated biphenyls62,63,64,65,66. Sabik et al.67 reported on the bioconcentration of alkylphenol polyethoxylates in E. complanata, which are common surfactants used in hydraulic fracturing. While we did not observe alkylphenol polyethoxylates in the produced water used in this study, the bioaccumulation of these compounds further supports investigation into the biomonitoring potential of this species from impacts of oil and gas extraction activities.
Laboratory studies have previously determined that unresolved complex mixtures of hydrocarbons, similar to those found in the produced waters used to dose tanks in this study, can be toxic to marine mussels68,69. In this work, between 80–100% of the mussels in tanks dosed with produced water died after 56 days, compared to 25% of mussels in the control tank. It is possible that organic compounds in hydraulic fracturing produced water influenced the health and mortality of the mussels. But, due to the chemical diversity of cyclic hydrocarbons in the produced water we cannot attribute the toxicity to any one specific compound present in the produced water. Additionally, it is possible that the observed toxicity may be due to additive or synergistic effects of the mixture of compounds as opposed to individual components68,69 or inorganic salt concentrations alone. Indeed, mussel survival is known to be affected by the salts and inorganic compositions of diluted produced water34. In freshwaters mixed with small percentages of synthetic produced waters, mussel survival was significantly reduced in waters containing 2,050 and 3,250 mg/L Na and mussel shell length decreased when only 804 mg/L Na was present in the water34. Na concentrations in tank waters in this study were much lower, ranging between 398 to 1,824 mg/L in the low and high dose tanks. Yet, our results corroborate previous studies that showed high mortality of freshwater organisms with exposure to relatively dilute (1–5%) concentrations of produced water. While the work herein did not discriminate between mortality caused by salinity or organic compounds (e.g., with salt water or organic controls), future studies could focus on the mechanism of mortality.
Incorporation of inorganic constituents
The potential for freshwater mussels to accumulate metals over a relatively short exposure period (56 days) was quantified using both the accumulation factor (AF) and metal accumulation relative to calcium. The AF was calculated for each metal based on the final concentrations of metals measured in the soft tissue divided by the concentration in the water—but the authors note these may not represent equilibrium conditions. In addition, metal signatures in the carbonate shell were analyzed to determine if both shell and tissues could be used in forensic applications for relatively short exposure times. The accumulation factor calculated for Elliptio complanata varied widely between metals analyzed (Cu, Mn, Mg, Ba, Sr) (Table 1). Accumulation factor values > 1 were calculated for Cu, Mn, Mg, Ba, and Sr which indicates magnification of metal concentrations from water to soft tissue during exposure. The higher concentrations observed in the soft tissue could indicate the use of Cu, Mn, Mg, Ba, and/or Sr as candidates for forensic tracing of produced water exposure.
Strontium, barium and magnesium
The accumulation factor calculated for Sr was > 1, indicating the mussels incorporated Sr from the water into the soft tissue. There was both a positive correlation between the Sr concentration in the water and in the soft tissue and between Sr/Ca ratios in the water (Sr/Cawater) and tissue (Sr/Catissue) (Fig. 3), indicating magnification of Sr in dosed tanks (AFSr = 12 to 31). Despite the accumulation of Sr, mussels showed a preference to incorporate Ca in the tissue relative to Sr with distribution coefficient (DSr) values of 0.27 and 0.33. These DSr values < 1 indicate preferential uptake of Ca into the soft tissue compared to Sr, when both elements are present in solution. Indeed, the highest concentrations of Sr were present in the mussels collected late in high dose tank (151 mg/L), but similar concentrations of Sr in the soft tissue (~ 1,822 to 2,308 mg/kg) and Sr/Catissue (19 to 27) were recorded in all mussels exposed at both low and high dose. This likely reflects the similar Sr/Cawater ~ 75 that was recorded in all dosed tanks.
Ba/Ca and Ba concentrations measured in the soft tissue were 10–60 times higher in the tissue of mussels grown in tanks dosed with produced water compared to controls (Fig. 3). The AF calculated for incorporation of Ba into Elliptio complanata soft tissue was between 102 and 610 in the dosed tanks and 1533 in the control tank. Similarly, Ba/Ca was higher in the soft tissue than the water, with DBa values between 1.66 and 5.34. These results differ from previous studies on a marine mussel species, Mytilus Edulis, that showed barium accumulates in soft tissue from either barite formation in the tissues or ingestion of barite that formed in the water column and biomagnification factors (BMF) < 170. The higher AFs (102–610) observed here may indicate that our mussels did not reach equilibrium with the concentrations of the water and the apparent magnification in soft tissue is temporary. Regardless, the Ba/Ca (mmol/mol) of both dosed tanks was very similar to the ratio in the produced water (~ 6) and different than the control water (0.36). Both the Ba AF and the DBa increased between early and late samples in both high and low dose tanks. The higher Ba/Ca ratios measured in the soft tissue could be a potential sensitive tracer of produced water spills or releases.
The mussels grown in tanks with a moderate dose (high dose early) of produced waters had higher Ba and Ba/Ca in the tissue than the tanks with the lowest dose (low dose early), but mussels exposed to the highest dose (high dose late) did not lead to higher Ba/Ca or Ba in the soft tissue. Instead, both the Ba/Ca and the Ba concentrations in the highest exposure group were intermediate between the lowest dose and the moderate dose for either 28 (high dose early) or 56 day exposures (low dose late). This implies that mussels may sequester Ba in environmental systems where produced waters are released, but the responses are not linear. For example, previous work suggested higher Ba/Ca may be a result of the ingestion of Ba-rich particulate matter or soluble Ba during respiration or feeding large volumes of water70,71 and is perhaps excreted at higher doses observed in our study. Laboratory or field studies with longer exposure times are necessary to determine the equilibrium accumulation factors.
Mgtissue increased as a function of Mgwater and was higher in the mussels exposed for longer periods of time (56 days). However, this led to Mg/Catissue ratios negatively correlated with Mg/Cawater. The Mg/Cawater was highest in the control tank and lowest in the high dose tank, meaning the Mg/Ca of the dosed water was lower than control water. This is likely due to the very high calcium concentrations found in produced water72,73. DMg values in the dosed tanks were below 1, meaning Mg was not preferentially accumulate relative to Ca. DMg values were higher in mussels exposed for the full 56 days compared to 28 days. The accumulation factor was less than 1, meaning Mg did not biomagnify in the mussels, although a higher Mgwater corresponded to higher Mgtissue and was highest in the mussels exposed for longer time periods. Mg incorporation into the shell is thought to be indicative of stress74,75, but Mg incorporation mechanisms in the soft tissue of freshwater mussels have not been described in detail. In either scenario, the lower Mg/Ca ratios in produced water and lack of background studies on Mg incorporation indicate that Mg may not be a sensitive tracer of produced water.
Calcium, manganese, iron, and copper
The produced water used in this study contained very high concentrations of calcium (17,200 mg/L). A positive relationship between concentration in the tank water and the concentration in the soft tissue was observed for all samples other than the day 56 sample in the high dose tank (high dose late). This may indicate that the high dose late specimens were no longer filtering. Indeed, the high dose late tissue sample concentrations for Sr, Ba, Mg, Mn and Ca, were consistently lower than most of the dosed tank samples. In addition, a negative relationship was observed between calcium concentration in the tank and the accumulation factor (Fig. 3I).
The concentrations of Mn, Fe, and Cu observed in soft tissue from both control and dosed tanks is consistent with a mechanistic control from Me2+-phosphate solubility for the accumulation of divalent metals in soft tissue of freshwater mussels as reported for other species49. Mnwater was below detection in both the control sample and the produced water, therefore, Mn may offer limited value as a forensic tracer of exposure. Despite the low concentrations of Mn measured in the water, the elevated Mn/Ca measured in the tissue appeared to demonstrate that Mn would likely produce both a large accumulation factor and a DMn > 1 that may be related to the extracellular formation of the relatively insoluble Mn-hydrogen phosphate49,50. Likewise, Fe concentrations in the water samples were below detection limit, but higher concentrations (13,764–34,999 mg/kg) were observed in the soft tissue indicating a positive and high accumulation factor. Cu appeared to behave in a similar way to Fe and Mn, with rather consistent concentrations observed in the soft tissue regardless of dose. However, Cu was consistently not detected in the water samples and was detected at much lower concentrations in the soft tissue (13.9–34.0 mg/kg) relative to either Mn or Fe.
Signatures in carbonate shells
Shells of mussels can also be used as an indicator of water quality. Mussels grow a shell of calcium carbonate in sequential layers through biomineralization in the extrapallial fluid76. While this fluid is isolated from the surrounding water, the mollusk derives the material used to build its shell from its environment, entering the hemolymph through respiration, ingestion, and direct uptake by the outer epithelium77. Transport of elements through the mussel are mediated by transport enzymes, which exert selective control on what elements enter the extrapallial fluid78 where organic macromolecules mediate the precipitation of calcium carbonate (CaCO3), building an aragonite or calcite structure bound by an organic framework79,80. As a consequence, shell precipitation can reflect environmental conditions but does not follow the expected thermodynamic partitioning behavior of inorganic minerals81.
Ablations of the hard calcium carbonate shell material did not show any significant indications of changes in concentrations in the distal 2 mm of shell, indicating that shell growth likely did not occur during the study period (56 days). This is not surprising given the high mortality. Unfortunately, this limits the utility of the shell material in forensic studies where high mortality was observed, but the utility in low-mortality areas is still promising. In high mortality conditions, only the soft tissue collected at the time of mortality is likely useful to fingerprint the contaminant source. Notably, the laser ablation method would likely not detect small barite minerals excreted from the extrapallial fluid onto the inner shell layer, as previously observed44.
Comparison to previous studies
The elevated TDS and Cl concentrations are known to cause high mortality among juvenile freshwater mussels36. The chloride concentrations in this study (low dose = 1,240 and high dose late = 4,470 mg/L) fall within the ranges (1,026–5,190 mg/L) used by previous studies to evaluate mortality associated with salinity34. Chloride concentrations were above the short-term aquatic toxicity for chloride (640 mg/L) as applied broadly to aquatic organisms by Canadian Water Quality Guidelines82. Both the short duration of the experiment and the use of a limited number of adult specimens for each exposure limits the conclusions that can be drawn regarding mortality rates (e.g., LC50 values). The influence of salt content or duration of exposure on mussel mortality could not be determined due to the similar mussel response in both the low and high dose treatments, but previous studies demonstrate the importance of both chloride and water hardness when assessing mortality33,34,35,83,84. Because our study utilized a relatively small number of individuals, a different genera, and adult mussels compared to previous studies, mortality rates were not thoroughly evaluated. Regardless, mortality rates here were similar to field studies36 (See Supplemental Material).
The potential for cyclic hydrocarbons to be used as forensic tracers through the food web is an area of potential future study. Studies on a major predator to mussels, muskrats, who lived were PAHs accumulated in sediments showed an association with negative health outcomes. Our results are consistent with previous studies that demonstrated Elliptio complanata had the potential to bioaccumulate PAHs58,59,60,61 and now a PCA approach could potentially fingerprint the accumulation other organisms.
Exposing freshwater mussels to oil and gas produced water showed the potential of produced water constituents such as Ba and Sr to accumulate at concentrations in soft tissue that could be used as forensic tools to identify releases to surface water. Overall, prolonged exposure to produced water resulted in 1) an increase in barium and cyclic hydrocarbons concentrations of soft tissue, and 2) incorporation of potentially unique tracers of cyclic hydrocarbons, Ba, and Sr that were distinguishable from signatures observed in control samples. As a forensic tool, petroleum hydrocarbons, Ba and Sr, are of particular interest because they are in high concentration in oil and gas produced water and often contain unique isotopic or element ratios. This work demonstrates that cyclic hydrocarbons and Ba can accumulate at concentrations 100–300 times that of the water. This work also suggests that mussels may be a significant end point when studying the fate of Ba downstream of permitted oil and gas releases and may indicate that studies of oil and gas produced water discharges should evaluate species that readily consume mussels such as muskrats, otters, raccoons, crayfish, birds, and fish for potential impacts56,57.
The study presented herein was designed to determine if Elliptio complanata mussels could be used as biomonitoring species, recording changes in freshwater from releases of oil and gas produced water at concentrations similar to those observed downstream of permitted facilities. Additional research is necessary to more accurately quantify the relationship between water chemistry and soft tissue, establish equilibrium constants (e.g. BMFs and chemical elimination rate constants), and to demonstrate the capability of mussels to record chemical signals of produced water in a natural system. Specifically, quantifying individual bioaccumulated organic compounds will aid in determining the cause of toxicity when exposed to produced water, which would be beneficial in assessing the broader impacts that contamination events can have on mussels. With further study, it is possible that mussels may also be used as sensitive indicators of contamination associated with releases of oil and produced waters.
Materials and methods
Both medium and large (5–7 cm length) adult Elliptio complanata were purchased from Carolina Biological Supply Company (Burlington, NC). The mussels were kept in 50 L aquaria filled with University Park, PA tap water that was preconditioned (i.e., aged to allow the reduction in chlorine) for 14 days prior to use with the mussels. Eight to nine mussels (n = 8 for low dose and control, or n = 9 for high dose) were kept in each tank and water was maintained at 21–22 °C with pH 7.2–8.2 throughout the study. Mussels were fed daily with 5 mL of algae food source obtained from Carolina Biological Supply Company, Burlington, NC. Ammonia and pH were measured frequently during the study. Mussels grew for a maximum of 60 days prior to harvesting. Tanks were exposed to laboratory lighting for roughly 12 h periods followed by 12 h of darkness. Bioaccumulation and toxicity were assessed for three treatment levels: control, low-dose, and high-dose, each with 8–9 individuals per dose. Produced water for the dosing was obtained from a hydraulically-fractured Utica Shale well located in southeastern Ohio. Concentrations of select constituents are presented in Table S1. The control tank contained only conditioned tap water while the low-dose contained a 1:80 dilution of produced water, and the high-dose contained a 1:40 dilution of produced water. The tanks were re-dosed with produced water after 4 weeks producing final ratios of 1:40 (low) and 1:20 (high). The resulting concentrations mimic those observed 30 to 500 m downstream of centralized waste treatment facilities where changes in water and sediment quality from disposal were observed previously86. The dilutions were determined based on the total organic content (TOC) values reported in streams impacted by unconventional gas development and the measured TOC in the produced water5,6. Importantly our study mimicked the concentrations in a static manner, but not the daily cycle of high and low concentrations observed downstream of facilities or lower concentrations that might be observed longer distances downstream where larger dilution factors decrease the forensic signals. Mussel mortality was assessed daily with visual inspection. Ammonia was monitored daily and the concentrations controlled with aeration. When mussels died, as assessed by open shells, they were removed from the tanks and stored at − 20 °C until processing.
Mussel tissue preparation
Whole mussel tissues were dried in a Speedvac until constant weight was achieved. There was no separation of body parts. Thereafter, 0.5 g of dried tissue was transferred to a 10 mL Teflon vial with 5 mL of 2 N nitric acid and 20 µL of hydrogen peroxide. Vials were heated at 60 °C until dry (approximately 6–8 h). This process was repeated 2 more times to oxidize most of the organic matter. Thereafter, the sample was refluxed in 5 mL of 2 N nitric acid for 3 h at 80 °C. The refluxed samples were then diluted to 40 mL with 2 N nitric acid and 4 mL of 12 M HCl. The diluted samples were further digested in a CEM Mars 6 microwave digester at 200 °C and 26.6 bar (400 psi) for 40 min. Microwave digested samples were diluted 100 times in 2% nitric acid before analysis on a Thermo Scientific iCAP 6,520 inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometer (ICP-OES, Na, Ca, Mg, Sr, K) or Thermo X-Series 2 mass spectrometer (ICP-MS, Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Ba, Pb). All dilution factors were accounted for on a mass basis and elemental concentrations were normalized by mass of tissue digested.
Mussel tissue was prepared for organic analysis following the Extraction of Biological Tissue or Trace Organic Analysis procedure outlined in the NOAA Mussel Watch program41. For analysis, mussels were pooled for analysis based on time of death, and separated into 2 groups: early, and late mortality. Within each group, the soft tissue of two individuals was combined to generate enough material to analyze and one value was reported. For example, in the high dose tank, the tissue of mussels 7 and 8 were combined prior to analysis. Approximately 3 g of homogenized fatty tissue was mixed with 10–15 g of sodium sulfate and tissuemized for 3 min with three aliquots of 25 mL of dichloromethane. The samples were concentrated to 1 mL using a Kuderna-Danish apparatus and a sample cleanup was performed with 50 mg of primary-secondary amine media to remove the fatty acids native to mussel tissue. The samples were analyzed using GC × GC-TOFMS following the method described above with a 1:2 injector split.
Organic and inorganic measurements
The produced water sample was prepared for organic analysis by liquid–liquid extraction using a modified version of USEPA Method 3510C87. The produced water (500 mL) was extracted 3 times with 25 mL of dichloromethane and concentrated to 1 mL using a Kuderna-Danish apparatus. Produced water and soft tissue were analyzed using GC × GC-TOFMS (LECO Pegasus 4D, St. Joseph, MI), which was operated with a 250 °C injector temperature and a 2 mL/min helium flow rate. The first-dimension column was a Restek Rtx-DHA100 (100 m × 0.25 mm × 0.5 μm) (Bellefonte, PA) and the second-dimension column was a Restek Rxi-17SilMS (1.0 m × 0.25 mm × 0.25 μm). The first-dimension oven was programmed to maintain 50 °C for 0.2 min after a 1μL 1:100 split injection and increase at 5 °C/min to 315 °C. The modulator temperature was offset at 15 °C positive, and operated with a 2 s modulation period. The second-dimension oven was offset by 5 °C. The mass spectrometer operated with a 700 s acquisition delay, 250 °C ion source temperature, and − 70 eV ionization energy. The collected mass range was 30–550 amu at 200 Hz.
The produced water sample was prepared for inorganic analysis by acid digestion in accordance to USEPA method 3005A88. Major and minor trace element analyses were performed on a Thermo Scientific iCAP 6,520 inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometer (ICP-OES, Na, Ca, Mg, Sr, K) and a Thermo X-Series 2 mass spectrometer (ICP-MS, Li, B, Ba, Fe, Mn, Pb, Cd, Cu, As, U). Quality assurance calibrations for all instrument were verified by comparing measured and known elemental concentrations in check standards (USGS M-220, USGS T-227, and SRM1640a).
Laser ablation of carbonate shell
After the mollusks were harvested and the soft tissue was removed, the shells were prepared for laser ablation. Valves from each shell were cast in a hard, clear epoxy, then sectioned using a low speed mineral saw with a MK diamond MK-303 0.76 mm abrasive cutting wheel. Each puck was then polished on a mineral polishing wheel, cleaned using EMD Millipore Triton X-100 non-ionic surfactant, and washed with ultrapure 18.2 MΩ.cm water.
Polished shell samples were then analyzed for trace and major element chemistry using an ESI NWR193 laser coupled to a Thermo Xseries II ICP-MS located at the Penn State University Energy and Environmental Sustainability Laboratories (EESL). The laser was set to 30% power, a travel speed of 40 um/s, a pulse repetition rate of 40 Hz, and a spot size of 100 μm. A 10 s delay and a 15 s drawdown time were added at the start and end of each ablation. USGS MACS-3, a pressed powder carbonate, and NIST SRM 612, a trace metal in glass standard were ablated at the start and end of the set of ablations to correct for instrument drift and to calibrate the instrument. Metal concentrations are normalized to Ca, which acts as an internal standard to account for differences in ablation behavior between samples and standards.
The potential accumulation of metals in the mussel soft tissue was calculated by dividing the concentration measured in the dry tissue (mg/kg) by the concentration measured in the water (mg/L) to establish accumulation factors. These factors are analogous to biomagnification factors (BMF) or concentration factors, but importantly are not true BMFs because we did not assess if the concentrations in the soft tissue reached equilibrium. Calcium-normalized molar distribution (DMe), in both soft tissue and hard shell was calculated by dividing the Sr/Catissue by the Sr/Cawater to determine preferential incorporation of metals relative to calcium.
Statistical analysis was performed using MetaboAnalyst 4.089. The GC × GC-TOFMS data were first subjected to basic data processing in the ChromaTOF software followed by peak alignment and peak wise comparison in the Statistical Compare feature of ChromaTOF. The alignment results were exported to Excel and manual quality control was applied to remove peaks corresponding to column bleed. The data were then subjected to normalization based on an internal standard, mean centering and log transformation in accordance to procedures outlined by Weggler et al.55 A non-parametric ANOVA (Kruskal–Wallis) was performed at p < 0.05 to determine the analytes that contributed significantly. A principal component analysis (PCA) was performed on the significant analytes as a non-targeted data analysis tool to determine differences between treatment groups and the features which contribute to the differentiation.
The concentrations of major elements measured in both the low and high dose tanks represent roughly 1:40 and 1:20 mixtures of produced water to control tank water and are consistent with concentrations calculated via mass balance. Concentrations in soft tissue are reported on a dry weight basis (mg/kg). In most cases, individual samples of soft tissue from each tank were combined based on time of harvest to obtain enough material for analysis. Early samples were collected after 28–35 days and late samples after 56 days growing in the tanks.
Clark, C. & Veil, J. Produced water volumes and management practices in the United States. Argonne Natl. Lab. Rep. https://doi.org/10.2172/1007397 (2009).
Dolan, F. C., Cath, T. Y. & Hogue, T. S. Assessing the feasibility of using produced water for irrigation in Colorado. Sci. Total Environ. 640–641, 619–628 (2018).
McDevitt, B. et al. Isotopic and element ratios fingerprint salinization impact from beneficial use of oil and gas produced water in the Western U.S. Sci. Total Environ. 716, 137006 (2020).
McLaughlin, M. C., Borch, T., McDevitt, B., Warner, N. R. & Blotevogel, J. Water quality assessment downstream of oil and gas produced water discharges intended for beneficial reuse in arid regions. Sci. Total Environ. 713, 136607 (2020).
Kahrilas, G. A., Blotevogel, J., Stewart, P. S. & Borch, T. Biocides in hydraulic fracturing fluids: a critical review of their usage, mobility, degradation, and toxicity. Environ. Sci. Technol. 49, 16–32 (2015).
Haluszczak, L. O., Rose, A. W. & Kump, L. R. Geochemical evaluation of flowback brine from Marcellus gas wells in Pennsylvania, USA. Appl. Geochem. 28, 55–61 (2013).
Lester, Y. et al. Characterization of hydraulic fracturing flowback water in Colorado: Implications for water treatment. Sci. Total Environ. 512–513, 637–644 (2015).
Michael Thurman, E., Ferrer, I., Blotevogel, J. & Borch, T. Analysis of hydraulic fracturing flowback and produced waters using accurate mass: identification of ethoxylated surfactants. Anal. Chem. 86, 9653–9661 (2014).
Hoelzer, K. et al. Indications of transformation products from hydraulic fracturing additives in shale-gas wastewater. Environ. Sci. Technol. 50, 8036–8048 (2016).
Piotrowski, P. K. et al. Elucidating environmental fingerprinting mechanisms of unconventional gas development through hydrocarbon analysis. Anal. Chem. 90, 5466–5473 (2018).
Piotrowski, P. K. et al. Non-Targeted chemical characterization of a Marcellus shale gas well through GC × GC with scripting algorithms and high-resolution time-of-flight mass spectrometry. Fuel 215, 363–369 (2018).
He, Y. et al. Chemical and toxicological characterizations of hydraulic fracturing flowback and produced water. Water Res. 114, 78–87 (2017).
Llewellyn, G. T. et al. Evaluating a groundwater supply contamination incident attributed to Marcellus Shale gas development. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 112, 6325 (2015).
Drollette, B. D. et al. Elevated levels of diesel range organic compounds in groundwater near Marcellus gas operations are derived from surface activities. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 112, 13184–13189 (2015).
Cozzarelli, I. M. et al. Environmental signatures and effects of an oil and gas wastewater spill in the Williston Basin, North Dakota. s 579, 1781–1793 (2016).
Digiulio, D. C. & Jackson, R. B. Impact to underground sources of drinking water and domestic wells from production well stimulation and completion practices in the Pavillion, Wyoming, Field. Environ. Sci. Technol. 50, 4524–4536 (2016).
Gross, S. A. et al. Analysis of BTEX groundwater concentrations from surface spills associated with hydraulic fracturing operations. J. Air Waste Manag. Assoc. 63, 424–432 (2013).
Hildenbrand, Z. L. et al. Temporal variation in groundwater quality in the Permian Basin of Texas, a region of increasing unconventional oil and gas development. Sci. Total Environ. 562, 906–913 (2016).
Kassotis, C. D. et al. Endocrine disrupting activities of surface water associated with a West Virginia oil and gas industry wastewater disposal site. Sci. Total Environ. 557–558, 901–910 (2016).
Burgos, W. D. et al. Watershed-scale impacts from surface water disposal of oil and gas wastewater in Western Pennsylvania. Environ. Sci. Technol. 51, 8851–8860 (2017).
Getzinger, G. J. et al. Natural gas residual fluids: sources, endpoints, and organic chemical composition after centralized waste treatment in Pennsylvania. Environ. Sci. Technol. 49, 8347–8355 (2015).
Blewett, T. A. et al. Sublethal and reproductive effects of acute and chronic exposure to flowback and produced water from hydraulic fracturing on the water Flea Daphnia magna. Environ. Sci. Technol. 51, 3032–3039 (2017).
Blewett, T. A., Delompré, P. L. M., Glover, C. N. & Goss, G. G. Physical immobility as a sensitive indicator of hydraulic fracturing fluid toxicity towards Daphnia magna. Sci. Total Environ. 635, 639–643 (2018).
He, Y. et al. Developmental toxicity of the organic fraction from hydraulic fracturing Flowback and produced waters to early life stages of Zebrafish (Danio rerio). Environ. Sci. Technol. 52, 3820–3830 (2018).
He, Y. et al. Effects on biotransformation, oxidative stress, and endocrine disruption in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) exposed to hydraulic fracturing flowback and produced water. Environ. Sci. Technol. 51, 940–947 (2017).
Blewett, T. A., Weinrauch, A. M., Delompré, P. L. M. & Goss, G. G. The effect of hydraulic flowback and produced water on gill morphology, oxidative stress and antioxidant response in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Sci. Rep. 7, 46582 (2017).
Tasker, T. L. et al. Environmental and human health impacts of spreading oil and gas wastewater on roads. Environ. Sci. Technol. 52, 7081–7091 (2018).
McDevitt, B. et al. Emerging investigator series: radium accumulation in carbonate river sediments at oil and gas produced water discharges: implications for beneficial use as disposal management. Environ. Sci. Process. Impacts 21, 324–338 (2019).
McLaughlin, M. C. et al. Mutagenicity assessment downstream of oil and gas produced water discharges intended for agricultural beneficial reuse. Sci. Total Environ. 715, 136944 (2020).
Folkerts, E. J., Blewett, T. A., He, Y. & Goss, G. G. Alterations to Juvenile Zebrafish (Danio rerio) swim performance after acute embryonic exposure to sub-lethal exposures of hydraulic fracturing flowback and produced water. Aquat. Toxicol. 193, 50–59 (2017).
Folkerts, E. J., Blewett, T. A., He, Y. & Goss, G. G. Cardio-respirometry disruption in zebrafish (Danio rerio) embryos exposed to hydraulic fracturing flowback and produced water. Environ. Pollut. 231, 1477–1487 (2017).
Delompré, P. L. M. et al. The osmotic effect of hyper-saline hydraulic fracturing fluid on rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss. s 211, 1–10 (2019).
Wang, N. et al. Acute toxicity of sodium chloride and potassium chloride to a unionid mussel (Lampsilis siliquoidea) in water exposures. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 37, 3041–3049 (2018).
Wang, N., Kunz, J. L., Cleveland, D., Steevens, J. A. & Cozzarelli, I. M. Biological effects of elevated major ions in surface water contaminated by a produced water from oil production. Arch. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 76, 670–677 (2019).
Wang, N. et al. Evaluation of chronic toxicity of sodium chloride or potassium chloride to a unionid mussel (Lampsilis siliquoidea) in water exposures using standard and refined toxicity testing methods. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 37, 3050–3062 (2018).
Patnode, K. A., Hittle, E., Anderson, R. M., Zimmerman, L. & Fulton, J. W. Effects of high salinity wastewater discharges on unionid mussels in the allegheny river Pennsylvania. J. Fish Wildl. Manag. 6, 55–70 (2015).
Geeza, T. J., Gillikin, D. P., McDevitt, B., Van Sice, K. & Warner, N. R. Accumulation of marcellus formation oil and gas wastewater metals in freshwater mussel shells. Environ. Sci. Technol. 52, 10883–10892 (2018).
De los Ríos, A. et al. Assessment of the effects of discontinuous sources of contamination through biomarker analyses on caged mussels. Sci. Total Environ. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2018.03.297 (2018).
Pilote, M., André, C., Turcotte, P., Gagné, F. & Gagnon, C. Metal bioaccumulation and biomarkers of effects in caged mussels exposed in the Athabasca oil sands area. Sci. Total Environ. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2017.08.023 (2018).
Bonnefille, B., Arpin-Pont, L., Gomez, E., Fenet, H. & Courant, F. Metabolic profiling identification of metabolites formed in Mediterranean mussels (Mytilus galloprovincialis) after diclofenac exposure. Sci. Total Environ. 583, 257–268 (2017).
Spring, S. NOAA Technical Memorandum NOS ORCA 71 National Status and Trends Program for Marine Environmental Quality Sampling and Analytical Methods of the National Status and Trends Program National Benthic Surveillance and Mussel Watch Projects 1984–1992 Volume I Overview and Summary of Methods noaa NATIONAL OCEANIC AND ATMOSPHERIC ADMINISTRATION Coastal Monitoring and Bioeffects Assessment Division Office of Ocean Resources Conservation and Assessment National Ocean Service. (1993).
Lydeard, C. et al. The global decline of Nonmarine Mollusks. Bioscience 54, 321–330 (2004).
Strayer, D. L. et al. Changing perspectives on pearly mussels, North America’s most imperiled animals. Bioscience 54, 429–439 (2004).
Lopes-Lima, M. et al. Conservation status of freshwater mussels in Europe: state of the art and future challenges. Biol. Rev. 92, 572–607 (2017).
Shulkin, V. M., Presley, B. J. & Kavun, V. I. Metal concentrations in mussel Crenomytilus grayanus and oyster Crassostrea gigas in relation to contamination of ambient sediments. Environ. Int. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0160-4120(03)00004-7 (2003).
Ishikawa, Y., Kagaya, H. & Saga, K. Biomagnification of 7Be, 234Th, and 228Ra in marine organisms near the northern Pacific coast of Japan. J. Environ. Radioact. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvrad.2004.03.021 (2004).
Brenner, M., Smoak, J. M., Leeper, D. A., Streubert, M. & Baker, S. M. Radium-226 accumulation in Florida freshwater mussels. Limnol. Oceanogr. 52, 1614–1623 (2007).
Jeffree, R. A., Markich, S. J. & Brown, P. L. Comparative accumulation of alkaline-earth metals by two freshwater mussel species from the Nepean River, Australia: consistencies and a resolved paradox. Aust. J. Mar. Freshw. Res. 44, 609–634 (1993).
Markich, S. J., Brown, P. L. & Jeffree, R. A. Divalent metal accumulation in freshwater bivalves: an inverse relationship with metal phosphate solubility. Sci. Total Environ. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0048-9697(00)00721-X (2001).
Markich, S. J. & Jeffree, R. A. Absorption of divalent trace metals as analogues of calcium by Australian freshwater bivalves: an explanation of how water hardness reduces metal toxicity. Aquat. Toxicol. https://doi.org/10.1016/0166-445X(94)90072-8 (1994).
Fritz, L., Ragone, L., Lutz, R. & Swapp, S. Biomineralization of barite in the shell of the freshwater asiatic clam Corbicula fluminea (Mollusca: Bivalvia). Limnol. Oceanogr. 35, 756–762 (1990).
Ricciardi, A., Neves, R. J. & Rasmussen, J. B. Impending extinctions of North American freshwater mussels (Unionoida) following the zebra mussel (Dreissena polymorpha) invasion. J. Anim. Ecol. 67, 613–619 (1998).
Ricciardi, A. & Rasmussen, J. B. Extinction rates of North American freshwater fauna. Conserv. Biol. 13, 1220–1222 (1999).
Vaughn, C. C. & Taylor, C. M. Impoundments and the decline of freshwater mussels: a case study of an extinction gradient. Conserv. Biol. 13, 912–920 (1999).
Weggler, B. A. et al. Untargeted identification of wood type-specific markers in particulate matter from wood combustion. Environ. Sci. Technol. 50, 10073–10081 (2016).
Colborn, T. & Smolen, M. J. Epidemiological analysis of persistent organochlorine contaminants in cetaceans. Rev. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4613-8478-6_4 (1996).
Halbrook, R. S., Kirkpatrick, R. L., Scanlon, P. F., Vaughan, M. R. & Veit, H. P. Environmental Contamination a n d Toxicology Muskrat Populations in Virginia’s Elizabeth River: Physiological Condition and Accumulation of Environmental Contaminants. Arch. Environ. Contain. Toxicol 25, (ARCHIVES OF, 1993).
Birdsall, K., Kukor, J. J. & Cheney, M. A. Uptake of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon compounds by the gills of the bivalve mollusk Elliptio complanata. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 20, 309–316 (2001).
Thorsen, W. A. et al. Elimination rate constants of 46 polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in the unionid mussel, Elliptio complanata. Arch. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00244-004-3186-y (2004).
Gewurtz, S. B., Drouillard, K. G., Lazar, R. & Haffner, G. D. Quantitative biomonitoring of PAHs using the barnes mussel (Elliptio complanata). Arch. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00244-002-1153-z (2002).
Gewurtz, S. G., Lazar, R. & Haffner, G. D. Biomonitoring of bioavailable PAH and PCB water concentrations in the Detroit River using the freshwater mussel Elliptio complanata. J. Great Lakes Res. 29, 242–255 (2003).
Metcalfe, J. L. & Charlton, M. N. Freshwater mussels as biomonitors for organic industrial contaminants and pesticides in the St Lawrence River. Sci. Total Environ. 98, 595–615 (1990).
Drouillard, K. G. et al. Quantitative biomonitoring in the Detroit River using Elliptio complanata: verification of steady state correction factors and temporal trends of PCBs in water between 1998 and 2015. Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 97, 757–762 (2016).
Drouillard, K. G., Chan, S., O’Rourke, S., Douglas Haffner, G. & Letcher, R. J. Elimination of 10 polybrominated diphenyl ether (PBDE) congeners and selected polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) from the freshwater mussel, Elliptio complanata. Chemosphere 69, 362–370 (2007).
O’Rourke, S., Drouillard, K. G. & Haffner, G. D. Determination of laboratory and field elimination rates of polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) in the freshwater mussel, Elliptio complanata. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 47, 74–83 (2004).
Xu, M. et al. Quantitative structure-activity relationship for the depuration rate constants of polychlorinated biphenyls in the freshwater mussel, Elliptio complanata. J. Environ. Sci. Heal. Part B 44, 278–283 (2009).
Sabik, H., Gagné, F., Blaise, C., Marcogliese, D. J. & Jeannot, R. Occurrence of alkylphenol polyethoxylates in the St. Lawrence River and their bioconcentration by mussels (Elliptio complanata). Chemosphere 51, 349–356 (2003).
Donkin, P., Smith, E. L. & Rowland, S. J. Toxic effects of unresolved complex mixtures of aromatic hydrocarhons accumulated by mussels, Mytilus edulis, from contaminated field sites. Environ. Sci. Technol. 37, 4825–4830 (2003).
Booth, A. M. et al. Unresolved complex mixtures of aromatic hydrocarbons: thousands of overlooked persistent, bioaccumulative, and toxic contaminants in mussels. Environ. Sci. Technol. 41, 457–464 (2007).
Gillikin, D. P. et al. Barium uptake into the shells of the common mussel (Mytilus edulis) and the potential for estuarine paleo-chemistry reconstruction. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gca.2005.09.015 (2006).
Geeza, T. J. et al. Controls on magnesium, manganese, strontium, and barium concentrations recorded in freshwater mussel shells from Ohio. Chem. Geol. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemgeo.2018.01.001 (2019).
Abualfaraj, N., Gurian, P. L. & Olson, M. S. Characterization of marcellus shale flowback water. Environ. Eng. Sci. 31, 514–524 (2014).
Chapman, E. C. et al. Geochemical and strontium isotope characterization of produced waters from marcellus shale natural gas extraction. Environ. Sci. Technol. 46, 3545–3553 (2012).
Poulain, C. et al. An evaluation of Mg/Ca, Sr/Ca, and Ba/Ca ratios as environmental proxies in aragonite bivalve shells. Chem. Geol. 396, 42–50 (2015).
Lorens, R. B. & Bender, M. L. The impact of solution chemistry on Mytilus edulis calcite and aragonite. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 44, 1265–1278 (1980).
Wheeler, A. Mechanisms of molluscan shell formation. (1992).
Wilbur, K. M. The Mollusca (Academic Press, Cambridge, 1983).
Crenshaw, M. A. The inorganic composition of molluscan extrapallial fluid. Biol. Bull. 143, 6–512 (1972).
Mount, A. S., Wheeler, A. P., Paradkar, R. P. & Snider, D. Hemocyte-mediated shell mineralization in the Eastern Oyster. Science 304, 297–300 (2004).
Nair, P. S. & Robinson, W. E. Calcium speciation and exchange between blood and extrapallial fluid of the quahog Mercenaria mercenaria (L.). Biol. Bull. 195, 43–51 (1998).
Kelemen, Z., Gillikin, D. P. & Bouillon, S. Relationship between river water chemistry and shell chemistry of two tropical African freshwater bivalve species. Chem. Geol. 526, 130–141 (2019).
Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment. Canadian water quality guidelines for the protection of aquatic life. Water Quality Index. (2001).
Todd, A. K. & Kaltenecker, M. G. Warm season chloride concentrations in stream habitats of freshwater mussel species at risk. Environ. Pollut. 171, 199–206 (2012).
O’Neil, D. D. & Gillikin, D. P. Do freshwater mussel shells record road-salt pollution?. Sci. Rep. 4, 1–6 (2014).
Ganoe, L. S., Brown, J. D., Yabsley, M. J., Lovallo, M. J. & Walter, W. D. A review of pathogens, diseases, and contaminants of muskrats (Ondatra zibethicus) in North America. Frontiers Veterin. Sci. 7, 233 (2020).
Warner, N. R., Christie, C. A., Jackson, R. B. & Vengosh, A. Impacts of shale gas wastewater disposal on water quality in Western Pennsylvania. Environ. Sci. Technol. 47, 11849–11857 (2013).
United States Environmental Protection Agency. Method 3510C (SW-846): Separatory Funnel Liquid-Liquid Extraction, Revision 3. (1996).
United States Environmental Protection Agency. Method 3005A (SW-846): Acid Digestion of Waters for Total Recoverable or Dissolved Metals for Analysis by FLAA or ICP Spectroscopy, Revision 3. (1992).
Chong, J. et al. MetaboAnalyst 4.0: towards more transparent and integrative metabolomics analysis. Web Serv. 46, W486–W494 (2018).
The authors would like to acknowledge LECO Corporation for the Pegasus 4D GC×GC-TOFMS system, Restek Corporation and Agilent Technologies for various chromatographic consumables and columns, Penn State University for student support, and Gulfport Energy for contributing samples.
This research was supported by funds provided by The Pennsylvania State University.
The authors declare no competing financial interest.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Piotrowski, P.K., Tasker, T.L., Geeza, T.J. et al. Forensic tracers of exposure to produced water in freshwater mussels: a preliminary assessment of Ba, Sr, and cyclic hydrocarbons. Sci Rep 10, 15416 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-020-72014-6
This article is cited by
Freshwater salinization syndrome: from emerging global problem to managing risks
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.