Half of postmenopausal women experience genitourinary syndrome of menopause, for which many use lubricating vaginal products. The effect of vaginal products on uropathogenic and commensal vaginal bacteria is poorly understood. We evaluated the effect of five common vaginal products (KY Jelly, Replens Silky Smooth lubricant, coconut oil, Replens Long-Lasting moisturizer or Trimo-San) on growth and viability of Escherichia coli and Lactobacillus crispatus. Bacteria were co-cultured products alone and in the presence of both vaginal epithelial cells and selected products. Bacterial growth was compared between conditions using an unpaired t-test or ANOVA, as appropriate. All products except for coconut oil significantly inhibited growth of laboratory and clinical strains of Escherichia coli (p < 0.02). Only two products (Replens Long-Lasting moisturizer and Trimo-San) significantly inhibited growth of Lactobacillus crispatus (p < 0.01), while the product Replens Silky Smooth stimulated growth (p < 0.01). Co-culture of selected products in the presence of vaginal epithelial cells eliminated the inhibitory effects of the products on E. coli. In conclusion, in vitro exposure to vaginal moisturizing and lubricating products inhibited growth of Escherichia coli, though the inhibition was mitigated by the presence of vaginal epithelial cells. Lactobacillus crispatus demonstrated less growth inhibition than Escherichia coli.
Urinary tract infections (UTIs) are among the five most commonly diagnosed problems in the ambulatory urologic setting, and over 80% occur in women1. Up to 70% of women will experience at least one UTI in their lifetime, and one third to one half will experience a recurrence2. An estimated 10% of women over 60 are diagnosed with recurrent UTIs (rUTI), which are becoming increasingly difficult to treat as antibiotic resistance limits therapeutic and preventive options3,4. Over 80% of community-acquired UTIs are caused by Escherichia coli5, and recurrent UTIs are strongly linked to vaginal E. coli colonization6.
Lactobacillus spp. dominance of the vaginal microbiota is an important factor in maintaining urogenital health. Decreased vaginal Lactobacillus spp. colonization is associated with increased UTI risk, and a lack of hydrogen peroxide (H2O2)-producing lactobacilli has been associated with vaginal E. coli colonization in women with rUTI7,8. While H2O2 is no longer thought to be the mechanism of beneficial effects, the ability to produce H2O2 in vitro is a marker of species (e.g. L. crispatus) and strains that are more likely to be beneficial than non-producing species and strains (e.g. L. iners). A vaginal L. crispatus probiotic was found to reduce recurrent UTI in women who established high quantity colonization9, indicating a benefit of vaginal colonization with Lactobacillus spp. in women with recurrent UTIs.
The use of over-the-counter vaginal lubricants and moisturizers for vulvovaginal dryness or sexual activity is common, especially among postmenopausal women10. These products commonly contain antimicrobial preservatives such as parabens, glycerine, or chlorhexidine11, which may affect the vaginal microbiota and thus urogenital health. Products with and without microbicidal effect may cause inflammation, as one limited study of intravaginal nonoxyl-9 (an ingredient in spermicide and a commonly used cytotoxic control) and universal placebo gel (isotonic) found that both have inflammatory effects on cells of the cervix and endometrium12. Additionally, individual ingredients commonly used in vaginal products have been found to alter the electrical resistance and morphology of ectocervical tissue13, and hyperosmolar lubricants have been demonstrated to be cytotoxic to vaginal epithelial cells, some of them also altering inflammatory mediators14. While these products have been shown to negatively impact cells of the female reproductive tract, little is known about how vaginal lubricants impact potentially protective Lactobacillus spp. or strains of uropathogenic E. coli. The aim of this study was to better understand the interaction between various vaginal products, commensal vaginal bacteria and a significant uropathogen. We evaluated the in vitro effect of lubricants, moisturizers and a pH balancing gel on the growth of clinical and lab strains of E. coli and a common vaginal Lactobacillus spp.
E. coli growth
To assess the ability of products to inhibit E. coli growth, a mixture of E. coli broth culture, nutrient media and product (neat, or diluted 1:2 in sterile phosphate buffered saline (PBS) to facilitate pipetting for Trimo-San and Replens Long-Lasting) was incubated at 37 °C and compared to the addition of nutrient media alone. A 50uL volume of product was used in a 150uL total experimental volume, effectively a 1:3 or 1:6 dilution, which is comparable to what might be expected in vivo. Over six hours of co-culture, the growth of one laboratory and 6 clinical strains of E. coli were significantly inhibited in coculture with all vaginal products tested (Table 1) except coconut oil (p < 0.02 for all), with an effect seen as soon as 2 hours (Fig. 1a and Supplemental Fig. 1). Lactic acid and methylparaben both significantly inhibited growth of all E. coli strains (p < 0.01). Laboratory and clinical strains overall showed similar inhibition patterns, with the exception of clinical strain D, which demonstrated relatively poor growth overall (Supplemental Fig. 1). After six hours of co-culture, both the laboratory strain and a representative clinical strain of E. coli (from a postmenopausal woman with cystitis) were similarly impacted by the tested products (Fig. 1a).
To test the observed interactions in a more high-fidelity model, the vaginal products with the most significant inhibitory effects in simple co-culture were then co-cultured with bacteria in the presence of an immortalized vaginal epithelial cell line (VK2, ATCC, VA) grown in keratinocyte serum-free (KSF) media. A 1:100 dilution of products was used to have a uniform dilution that also maintained viability of human cells with all products, and was chosen based on prior publications and preliminary experiments (Supplementary Fig. 2). When exposed to a 1:100 dilution of KY Jelly, Replens Long-Lasting moisturizer, or Trimo-San in KSF, the laboratory strain of E. coli was inhibited compared to a KSF media control (p = 0.01, Fig. 2a). However, in the presence of human vaginal epithelial cells, E. coli demonstrated no inhibition in the presence of KY Jelly, and increased growth with Replens Long-Lasting and Trimo-San compared to control (p < 0.05, Fig. 2a). Cytotoxicity to VK2 cells among the products versus no product control was not significantly different (Supplemental Fig. 2).
Lactobacillus spp. growth
Over 12 hours of co-culture, L. crispatus growth in MRS (deMan, Rogosa and Sharpe) broth was inhibited by Replens Long-Lasting moisturizer and Trimo-San (p < 0.01), but not by KY Jelly or coconut oil (p > 0.05, Fig. 1b). L. crispatus growth was stimulated by Replens Silky Smooth (p < 0.01). As expected, methylparaben killed L. crispatus (p < 0.01), and lactic acid did not have a significant effect compared with control.
We then repeated these experiments in the presence of the immortalized human vaginal epithelial cells, using the same 1:100 dilution described above. When exposed to a 1:100 dilution of KY Jelly, Replens Long-Lasting moisturizer, or Trimo-San in KSF media, the growth of L. crispatus was no longer inhibited (p > 0.05, Fig. 2b). This lack of inhibition persisted in the presence of human vaginal epithelial cells (p > 0.05, Fig. 2b).
We demonstrate that several vaginal lubricant and moisturizing products commonly used by postmenopausal women inhibit both uropathogenic E. coli and commensal Lactobacillus spp. in an in vitro co-culture model without vaginal epithelial cells. However, when human vaginal epithelial cells were included in the co-culture, the products demonstrated less inhibition of E. coli. None of the products inhibited the growth of Lactobacillus spp. at a 1:100 dilution, regardless of whether immortalized human vaginal epithelial cells were added to the model.
Our results expand on previous in vitro studies which showed that KY Jelly is bactericidal to L. crispatus and L. jensenii15. Inhibitory effects of vaginal lubricants could be due to several of the ingredients, including glycerin, parabens, sorbic acid, chlorhexidine gluconate, all of which have been shown to have antimicrobial properties. Previously, parabens in mouthwash and vaginal moisturizer have been found to decrease or inhibit oral Lactobacillus spp.16. We found that Replens Long-Lasting moisturizer significantly inhibited L. crispatus growth while Replens Silky Smooth increased growth. Replens Silky Smooth is marketed as a preservative free lubricant and does not contain parabens, while the Replens Long-Lasting contains methylparaben. Both formulations of Replens, and all products except coconut oil inhibited E. coli, suggesting that L. crispatus may be less susceptible than E. coli to antimicrobial effects of these products.
When we added cultured, immortalized vaginal epithelial cells to the model, we demonstrated less inhibition of E. coli by the products that had been most inhibitory in the co-culture without vaginal cells. We used a 1:100 dilution of products to maintain viability of human cells, but even at this dilution E. coli growth was inhibited by all three products in the absence of human cells. One possible explanation for the difference in E. coli inhibition in the presence of cells involves the ability of bacteria to adhere to and proliferate on epithelial cell surfaces17. Not only does adherence potentially permit bacterial proliferation over that seen in liquid media, bacterial microcolonization of epithelial cell surfaces may also allow bacteria to access additional food sources. An inspection of the surface of bovine intestinal epithelial cells showed that adherent bacteria were digesting sloughed dead epithelial cells, suggesting another resource for bacterial survival and proliferation18. At the 1:100 dilution no products inhibited the growth of Lactobacillus spp., thus we were unable to assess how the presence of human vaginal epithelial cells modified lubricant inhibition of Lactobacillus spp.
Our data add to the existing literature showing that vaginal products and their ingredients affect bacteria growth and viability in vitro, but conclusive literature on effects in vivo is lacking. The majority of literature on the safety of lubricant products concerns HIV acquisition and transmission and the impact of these products on the vaginal epithelial barrier and mucosal inflammation, rather than uropathogens or commensal vaginal bacteria. A prospective study of 331 women found spermicide use correlated with increased vaginal colonization with E. coli, which in turn was associated with absent lactobacilli19. However, vaginal swabs from 235 women in a randomized trial of various nonoxynol-9 spermicide formulations found no significant alterations in vaginal microbiota with repeated use20.
We are unaware of any studies specifically examining the effect of vaginal products on factors that affect an individual’s risk of UTI. While it is reassuring that these products have a uniformly negative effect on uropathogenic E. coli in vitro, the abrogation of this effect in the presence of human vaginal epithelial cells suggests that the interaction may not be that simple. While the co-culture experiments that do not include human cells use a concentration of products that is more akin to what might be seen in actual use, the more dilute concentrations necessary to maintain human cells do inhibit E. coli when human cells are not present. This suggests factors in addition to concentration of product may contribute to bacterial survival or growth. In addition, the negative impact of some vaginal products on Lactobacillus spp. is worrisome.
Our study is limited by the lack of a better human vaginal model. The 1:100 product dilution needed to allow vaginal epithelial viability is not realistically translated to clinical use. In addition, the viscous properties of lubricants and moisturizers introduce additional variation to the results between technical replicates as well as between experiments. We did not assess mechanisms for the inhibitory effects, which could range from chemical toxicity to pH to osmolality. Strengths of this study include the addition of several clinical strains of uropathogenic E. coli taken from clinical urine cultures of women with acute cystitis, demonstrating equivalence between clinical and laboratory strains. The addition of vaginal epithelial cells brings the co-culture model closer to a human vaginal model and the differing results for E. coli demonstrate the potential drastic difference between in vitro and in vivo studies. We only tested the effects of products on L. crispatus, which is one of the most common vaginal species, and is being tested as a potential live biotherapeutic. However, results may not be generalizable to other vaginal Lactobacillus spp.
This study adds to the limited understanding of how common vaginal products and their ingredients may alter commensal and uropathogenic bacteria, a dynamic that is important in the acquisition and prevention of UTI. Although lubricants, moisturizers, and pH balancers are all used for symptoms of vaginal atrophy and other genitourinary pathology, our findings suggest that they may have varying effects on the urogenital microbiota and therefore on a woman’s risk for UTI.
Materials and Methods
Bacterial culture preparation
The bacterial species used in these experiments include a laboratory strain of E. coli (ATCC 8739) and 6 clinical strains of E. coli provided by the Massachusetts General Hospital microbiology lab, which had been isolated from women with cystitis. The Institutional Review Board at Massachusetts General Hospital has determined that this work does not meet the definition of human subjects’ research. The following reagent was obtained through the NIH Biodefense and Emerging Infections Research Resources Repository, NIAID, NIH: L. crispatus, Strain JV-V01, HM-103. Bacterial suspensions of E. coli were created by inoculating BD Difco Nutrient Broth (Fisher Scientific, MA) and incubating for 6 hours at 37 °C with agitation. For the L. crispatus suspensions, deMan, Rogosa Sharpe broth (MRS, BD Difco, Fisher Scientific, MA) was inoculated and incubated for 12 hours at 37 °C in an anaerobic chamber without agitation.
To achieve a lower viscosity for pipetting, Trimo-San and Replens Long-Lasting moisturizer were diluted 1:2 with sterile PBS. The following lubricants were used undiluted: KY Jelly, Replens Silky Smooth lubricant, generic coconut oil. The following solutions were prepared as positive controls (i.e. expected to inhibit bacterial growth) diluted in sterile PBS: 50 mM racemic lactic acid and methylparaben (Sigma-Aldrich, MA), reconstituted to 1% in ethanol. Two negative control conditions were used: sterile phosphate buffered saline (PBS, Thermo Fisher Scientific, UK) and diluted ethanol to match the ethanol content in the methylparaben condition (Table 1).
E. coli co-culture
In a 96-well microplate, the following were added to each well: 75 µL fresh nutrient broth, 50 µL test product, 25 µL E. coli broth culture at 0.5 OD, adapted from Kalyoussef et al.21. Each of the seven E. coli strains were tested against the five products and four controls (Table 1). Corresponding control wells, which served as blanks in calculations of optical density at 600 nm (OD600), were created for every test condition containing 25 µL of nutrient broth medium instead of 25 µL of bacterial broth culture. Plates were incubated at 37 °C with agitation for 6 hours. OD600 measurements were taken at every 2 hours with a Biotek Gen5 plate reader (Burlington, VT).
Lactobacillus spp. co-culture
In a 48-well microplate, the following were added: 400 µL fresh MRS media, 200 µL test product, 200 µL Lactobacillus spp. broth culture at 0.5 OD. Lactobacillus crispatus was tested against the five products and four controls (Table 1). The plates were incubated anaerobically at 37 °C without agitation for 12 hours. Supernatants were serially diluted and plated on MRS agar to count colony forming units (CFU) at both the start and end of incubation. After initial experiments to ensure that OD and CFU were measuring comparable phenomena (Supplemental Fig. 3), we continued with OD only for E. coli. However, for lactobacilli, OD results were very different from CFU results due to significant clumping of bacteria in the presence of lubricants, thus only CFU were used.
For both the E. coli and L. crispatus co-cultures, all experiments were performed at least twice, with each biological replicate containing technical triplicates for each condition, including blank control conditions. All ingredients were plated on agar to confirm viability of the broth pre-cultures and sterility of test materials. At the conclusion of the experiment, co-culture broth and negative controls were plated to confirm no contamination during experiments.
Vaginal epithelial cell co-culture with vaginal product and bacteria
To test the observed interactions in a more high-fidelity model, the vaginal products with the most significant inhibitory effects in simple co-culture were then co-cultured with bacteria in the presence of human vaginal epithelial cells. Bacterial broths were prepared as described previously, and then centrifuged at 1000 RPM for 5 minutes. The bacteria pellet was re-suspended in Gibco keratinocyte serum free media (KSF, Fisher Scientific, MA) (supplemented with epidermal growth factor, bovine pituitary extract and CaCl2 per manufacturer’s instructions) to an OD600 of 0.15.
A 96-well tissue culture treated microplate was seeded with 4 × 105 cells per well of an immortalized vaginal epithelial cell line (VK2, ATCC, VA) in KSF. Vaginal epithelial cells were incubated overnight to achieve >90% confluence. The model was first tested with different dilutions of selected vaginal products alone to choose the highest concentration compatible with epithelial cell survival. Cell death was assessed with a lactate dehydrogenase cytotoxicity assay (Fisher Scientific, MA). As in previous studies, a dilution of 1:100 was found to be the optimal dilution to avoid toxicity to human cells15.
After a 24-hour equilibration to allow vaginal cells to adhere to the plate and become confluent, 25 µL of the laboratory strain E. coli suspended in KSF were added to the vaginal epithelial cells with 75 µL of fresh KSF media and incubated for 1 hour. Then 50 µL of KY Jelly, Replens Long-Lasting moisturizer, or Trimo-San were added, diluted 1:100 with KSF cell culture medium. The co-culture was incubated at 37 °C, 2 hours aerobically with agitation for E. coli. At the conclusion of the co-culture, the bottoms of the wells were scraped with a pipette tip to release the adherent human cells. The entire well contents (cells, bacteria, medium) were serially diluted and plated to count CFU for each bacterium. For all vaginal epithelial cell co-cultures, KSF cell culture media was used as a negative control, and at least two experiments were performed for each condition, with technical triplicates of each condition. The experiment was simultaneously performed without vaginal cells, using 1:100 diluted products, KSF medium and bacterial suspension.
Similarly, the vaginal epithelial cells were separately co-cultured with L. crispatus, though in anaerobic conditions for 1 hour prior to addition of experimental substance. However, because the growth of the Lactobacillus spp. was inhibited in the KSF media alone, a 1:1 mixture of MRS/KSF medium was utilized for that portion of the experiment, which was found to have a minimal impact on human cell viability (Supplemental Fig. 4).
Growth of each bacterial strain or species was determined by change in OD600 or CFU from the first baseline OD measurement (Supplemental Table 1) or a starting CFU/mL count of the L. crispatus innoculum, respectively. Using GraphPad Prism 6.0, the change in OD600 or CFU was compared between vaginal products and control with unpaired t-tests or ANOVA, with adjustment for multiple comparisons as appropriate. Statistical significance was set at p < 0.05.
Foxman, B. Epidemiology of urinary tract infections: incidence, morbidity, and economic costs. Dis Mon 49, 53–70, https://doi.org/10.1067/mda.2003.7 (2003).
Guglietta, A. Recurrent urinary tract infections in women: risk factors, etiology, pathogenesis and prophylaxis. Future Microbiol 12, 239–246, https://doi.org/10.2217/fmb-2016-0145 (2017).
den Heijer, C. D., Beerepoot, M. A., Prins, J. M., Geerlings, S. E. & Stobberingh, E. E. Determinants of antimicrobial resistance in Escherichia coli strains isolated from faeces and urine of women with recurrent urinary tract infections. PLoS One 7, e49909, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0049909 (2012).
Schwenger, E. M., Tejani, A. M. & Loewen, P. S. Probiotics for preventing urinary tract infections in adults and children. Cochrane Database Syst Rev, CD008772, https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD008772.pub2 (2015).
Hooton, T. M., Roberts, P. L., Cox, M. E. & Stapleton, A. E. Voided midstream urine culture and acute cystitis in premenopausal women. N Engl J Med 369, 1883–1891, https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa1302186 (2013).
Czaja, C. A. et al. Prospective cohort study of microbial and inflammatory events immediately preceding Escherichia coli recurrent urinary tract infection in women. J Infect Dis 200, 528–536, https://doi.org/10.1086/600385 (2009).
Gupta, K. et al. Inverse association of H2O2-producing lactobacilli and vaginal Escherichia coli colonization in women with recurrent urinary tract infections. J Infect Dis 178, 446–450 (1998).
Stapleton, A. E. The Vaginal Microbiota and Urinary Tract Infection. Microbiol Spectr 4, https://doi.org/10.1128/microbiolspec.UTI-0025-2016 (2016).
Stapleton, A. E. et al. Randomized, placebo-controlled phase 2 trial of a Lactobacillus crispatus probiotic given intravaginally for prevention of recurrent urinary tract infection. Clin Infect Dis 52, 1212–1217, https://doi.org/10.1093/cid/cir183 (2011).
Brown, J. M. et al. Motivations for Intravaginal Product Use among a Cohort of Women in Los Angeles. PLoS One 11, e0151378, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0151378 (2016).
Edwards, D. & Panay, N. Treating vulvovaginal atrophy/genitourinary syndrome of menopause: how important is vaginal lubricant and moisturizer composition? Climacteric 19, 151–161, https://doi.org/10.3109/13697137.2015.1124259 (2016).
Smith-McCune, K. et al. Unexpected Inflammatory Effects of Intravaginal Gels (Universal Placebo Gel and Nonoxynol-9) on the Upper Female Reproductive Tract: A Randomized Crossover Study. PLoS One 10, e0129769, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0129769 (2015).
Hu, M., Zhou, T., Dezzutti, C. S. & Rohan, L. C. The Effect of Commonly Used Excipients on the Epithelial Integrity of Human Cervicovaginal Tissue. AIDS Res Hum Retroviruses 32, 992–1004, https://doi.org/10.1089/AID.2016.0014 (2016).
Wilkinson, E. M., Laniewski, P., Herbst-Kralovetz, M. M. & Brotman, R. M. Personal and Clinical Vaginal Lubricants: Impact on Local Vaginal Microenvironment and Implications for Epithelial Cell Host Response and Barrier Function. J Infect Dis 220, 2009–2018, https://doi.org/10.1093/infdis/jiz412 (2019).
Dezzutti, C. S. et al. Is wetter better? An evaluation of over-the-counter personal lubricants for safety and anti-HIV-1 activity. PLoS One 7, e48328, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0048328 (2012).
Steinberg, B. J. Women’s oral health issues. J Calif Dent Assoc 28, 663–667 (2000).
Ribet, D. & Cossart, P. How bacterial pathogens colonize their hosts and invade deeper tissues. Microbes Infect 17, 173–183, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.micinf.2015.01.004 (2015).
McCowan, R. P., Cheng, K. J., Bailey, C. B. & Costerton, J. W. Adhesion of bacteria to epithelial cell surfaces within the reticulo-rumen of cattle. Appl Environ Microbiol 35, 149–155 (1978).
Gupta, K., Hillier, S. L., Hooton, T. M., Roberts, P. L. & Stamm, W. E. Effects of contraceptive method on the vaginal microbial flora: a prospective evaluation. J Infect Dis 181, 595–601, https://doi.org/10.1086/315267 (2000).
Schreiber, C. A., Meyn, L. A., Creinin, M. D., Barnhart, K. T. & Hillier, S. L. Effects of long-term use of nonoxynol-9 on vaginal flora. Obstet Gynecol 107, 136–143, https://doi.org/10.1097/01.AOG.0000189094.21099.4a (2006).
Kalyoussef, S. et al. Lactobacillus proteins are associated with the bactericidal activity against E. coli of female genital tract secretions. PLoS One 7, e49506, https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0049506 (2012).
Joseph E. Braidt and the Massachusetts General Hospital Microbiology Lab for clinical E. coli strains. This work was supported in part by the Vincent Memorial Research Funds.
Dr. Mitchell has served as a consultant for Lupin Pharmaceuticals and Scynexis, Inc. Dr. Mitchell receives research funding from Merck. The remaining authors declare they have no conflict of interest.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Hung, K.J., Hudson, P.L., Bergerat, A. et al. Effect of commercial vaginal products on the growth of uropathogenic and commensal vaginal bacteria. Sci Rep 10, 7625 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-020-63652-x