Abstract
Projectile impact into a light granular material composed of expanded polypropylene (EPP) particles is investigated systematically with various impact velocities. Experimentally, the trajectory of an intruder moving inside the granular material is monitored with a recently developed noninvasive microwave radar system. Numerically, discrete element simulations together with coarsegraining techniques are employed to address both dynamics of the intruder and response of the granular bed. Our experimental and numerical results of the intruder dynamics agree with each other quantitatively and are in congruent with existing phenomenological model on granular drag. Stepping further, we explore the ‘microscopic’ origin of granular drag through characterizing the response of granular bed, including density, velocity and kinetic stress fields at the meanfield level. In addition, we find that the dynamics of cavity collapse behind the intruder changes significantly when increasing the initial speed . Moreover, the kinetic pressure ahead of the intruder decays exponentially in the comoving system of the intruder. Its scaling gives rise to a characteristic length scale, which is in the order of intruder size. This finding is in perfect agreement with the longscale inertial dissipation type that we find in all cases.
Similar content being viewed by others
Introduction
We feel the drag force from air while walking, jogging or riding a vehicle. We also feel the drag force from sand while walking on the beach. The question is to which extent the drag force laws known for Newtonian fluid can be applied to granular materials, such as sand, powders and grains. Such an extension can not only shed light on a fundamental understanding of drag force in nonNewtonian fluids^{1,2,3}, but also on widespread applications of granular materials including pile driving in soil mechanics, impact cratering in geo and astrophysics, and last but not least, robotic locomotion^{4,5}.
Drag induced by projectile penetration is an interesting topic with a long history, particularly in association with ballistic impact^{6,7}. In the past decades, the interest has been broadened in connection with crater formation^{8,9,10,11}, partly motivated by space exploration^{12,13} as well as deciphering the history of planet formation^{4}. Moreover, it has been extended to the influence of air cavity collapsing as well as granular jet formation^{14}, the projectile shape^{11,15,16} and the role of gravity on the final penetration depth and time^{17}. As an extreme case, infinite penetration of a projectile into lightweighted EPS (expanded polystyrene) particles was observed, when the weight of the projectile exceeds a critical value^{18}.
Based on experimental and numerical investigations, an empirical law based on Poncelet model^{2,19} is typically used to describe the penetration curve of a projectile. It includes a ‘hydrostatic’ term dependent on the penetration depth \(z\)^{10} and a drag term \(\propto {v}^{2}\) with \(v\) the instantaneous speed of the projectile with respect to the granular medium. The inertial nature of this drag force has been proposed in the past^{10,20,21}. Nevertheless, that is not the complete story, as recent investigations also reveal a variation of the scaling with \(v\) for vibrofluidized granular materials^{22}. Moreover, collisional damping \(\propto {v}^{2}\) can also be understood, as a ‘viscous’ scale damping process, governed by a speed dependent collisional rate^{23,24} and the fluctuations of force chains with a stochastic nature^{25,26}. In short, a firstprinciple theory for describing granular drag is still lacking, partly owing to the challenges in predicting the rheological response of granular media, particularly on the brink of solidliquidlike transition^{27,28}.
From the perspective of applications, particles of expanded polypropylene (EPP) or expanded polystyrene (EPS) are widely used for construction, packaging, damping, as well as raw materials for molded forms, due to its light yet rigid, and good thermal isolation properties. For instance, the drop tower of the European Space Agency in Bremen Germany, uses EPS particles regularly as damping materials to capture drop capsules that weight typically over \(400\) kg. As such, a better understanding of granular drag, particularly the physical mechanisms behind the empirical laws, is desirable.
Here, we employ a recently developed microwave radar system that ‘sees’ through granular particles and DEM (discrete element method) simulations^{17} to investigate the influence of the impact velocity on the drag force induced by light weighted EPP particles (Neopolen, P9255) with a mean diameter of \(3\) mm on a spherical projectile with a diameter \(D=1\) cm. Experimentally, the position of the projectile is determined from the phase shift of \(10\) GHz electromagnetic waves traveling from the transmission to the receiving antennae with a triangulation process^{29}, as sketched in Fig. 1. The experimental conditions, including the dimensions of the intruder, granular particles, the container, as well as the material properties of the particles, are followed in the numerical simulations, which allows us to explore the origin of granular drag through characterizing the response of granular particles at the meanfield level. The results suggest that, despite the orderofmagnitude difference in the kinetic stress and granular energy levels, the profiles of scaled kinetic stress viewed from the perspective of the projectile is surprisingly independent on the initial speed of the intruder \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(0)\). In another word, the kinetics of the projectile inside of a granular medium is predetermined by the initial speed of the intruder \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(0)\).
Intruder Dynamics
We perform a systematic study of the intruder penetration dynamics at various initial impact speed (\({v}_{{\rm{i}}}\) = [0–2.3] m/s). Figures 2 and 3 show the vertical position \(z(t)\) and speed \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(t)\) of the intruder, obtained experimentally and numerically, respectively. For the experimental cases, the initial speed is estimated from a parabolic fit of the intruder trajectory before impact together with the initial falling height \(H\). As noted, in all cases the intruder dynamics predicted numerically is in very good quantitative agreement with the experimental results and in line with previous findings^{20,30,31,32}.
In general, the intruder dynamics is predominately conditioned by the initial conditions. For all cases, the intruder penetrates into the medium, slowly decelerates until stops at a certain depth. For low impact speeds, there exists an initial accelerating phase as gravity exceeds granular drag at impact, instead of continuous deceleration as in the cases with high impact velocities. Quantitatively, the intruder movement along the gravity direction can be described using its translational equation of motion.
which includes gravity \(mg\), drag force and depthdependent frictional terms with \(\gamma \), \(\kappa \) and \(\lambda \) phenomenological parameters. Following previous findings^{20}, the characteristic length scale \(\lambda \) is chosen to be the radius of the container \(15\ cm\), which is sufficiently large to avoid boundary effects. The frictional term is linear and scalefree for small penetration depths and it saturates to \(\kappa z\) for large scales^{20,31}. In the past, several experimental works showed that the quadratic dependence in speed is sufficient to describe the mechanical energy dissipation of the intruder^{20,31}. The energy dissipation from granular drag resembles an object moving in a fluid at high Reynolds number. The numerical solutions of Eq. (1) is also included in Figs. 2 and 3, for comparison in each case.
Nevertheless, we find the coefficient \(\gamma \) (see Fig. 4) is not a material constant, but decays with increasing \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(0)\) until it saturates at high impact speed. It suggests different mechanical response at low \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}\), which arises presumably from different perturbation distance in comparison to impact at high \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}\). Assuming that the coefficient \(\gamma \) can be estimated from the momentum transfer, \(\gamma {v}_{{\rm{i}}}^{2}\propto A\,{\rho }_{{\rm{p}}}\varphi \,{v}_{{\rm{i}}}^{2}\) with \(A\) projected projectile area^{31}, there outcomes would suggest that the initial impact reduce notably the packing fraction \(\varphi \) of the granular bed. Indeed, this trend was found earlier, examining intruders in fluidized beds, using an upflow air supply^{11}. In our experiment, however, we do not detect significant changes in volume fraction and, accordingly, our outcomes can not be explained following the same arguments. Moreover, we find the dependency of \(\kappa \) on the initial velocity is notably weaker^{11} (see inset in Fig. 4). It is worth mention, that the intruder’s trajectory Eq. (1) has also been described, in terms of its initial kinetic energy and introducing a depthdependent \(\gamma \)^{33,34}.
In Figure 5, we focus on the relation between the final penetration depth \({z}_{max}\) and \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(0)\). As expected, the final depth increases with increasing initial speed (see Fig. 5a). In both experiment and simulations, we find a slightly nonlinear response, which is more noticeable for low initial speed. It is important to mention that a linear dependency would be congruent with \({z}_{max}\propto {h}^{1/2}\), which was earlier reported and justified as a liquidlike viscous damping^{9}. On the other hand, the scaling \({z}_{max}\propto {H}^{1/3}\) was also reported in the past^{10,31} and explained as a complex inertial response of granular beds to impact. For a better comparison, in Fig. 5b,c, we examine in loglog scale \({z}_{max}\) vs \(h\) and \({z}_{max}\) vs \(H={z}_{max}+h\), respectively. As noted, our outcome does not match accurately on any of the two options, but both experiments and simulations are closer to the \({z}_{max}\propto {H}^{1/3}\) dependency, at least within the uncertainties.
Response of Granular Bed
Coarsegrained fields
Continuum approaches are also useful, addressing the intruder dynamics and the macroscopic response of the granular bed^{35}. Here, we use a coarsegraining method^{36,37,38,39}, which is a micromacro mapping technique, to examine the macroscopic responses of the granular bed, as the intruder moves through it. Thus, from the DEM data of each individual particle, we compute the macroscopic fields: volume fraction \(\varphi (\overrightarrow{r},t)={\rho }_{m}(\overrightarrow{r},t)/{\rho }_{{\rm{p}}}\), macroscopic velocity \(\overrightarrow{v}(r,z,t)\) and kinetic stress \({{\boldsymbol{\sigma }}}_{k}(r,z,t)\). We took advantage of the cylindrical symmetry of the system because the intruder gets into the media by the axis of the cylindrical container. Moreover, no significant deviations from this trajectory were detected. Thus, we average the vertical and radial components for the studied magnitudes within an azimuthal representative volume element with the same size, obtaining the macroscopic fields in terms of the cylindrical coordinates \(\rho \) and \(z\).
In Figs. 6 and 7, outcomes are illustrated for two initial speeds of the intruder, \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(0)=0\) m/s and \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(0)=2.3\) m/s, respectively. The coarsegraining methodology^{36,37,38,39} allows us to reproduce the macroscopic volume fraction fields \(\varphi \left(\rho ,z,t\right)\) at different times [see color maps in Fig. 6 (row I) and Fig. 7 (row I)] for two extreme initial speeds \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(0)=0\) and \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(0)=2.32\ m/s\), respectively. First, it is noticeable that the penetration process does not perturb significantly the macroscopic density, as the impact is more noticeable in the neighborhood of the intruder. Moreover, the fields allow visualizing the time evolution of the void cavity at different depths, as the intruder moves through the system. As noted, the impacting sphere creates a welldefined cavity, which first increases its size and suddenly collapses at a given time \({t}_{{\rm{c}}}\). Remarkably, the cavity shapes obtained in both cases are comparable with previous experiments using Xray radiograph^{14,40,41}.
The second row in Figs. 6 and 7 illustrates the vertical velocity field \({v}_{z}(\rho ,z)\) during the penetration process, while the third row in both figures represents the radial velocity field \({v}_{\rho }(\rho ,z)\). In general, the intruder notably perturbs the velocity fields of the granular bed, transmitting its mechanical energy through contacting particles over a certain distance. Interestingly, the field \({v}_{z}(\rho ,z)\) indicates that the existence of a shear band, which correlates with the development of the void cavity. While the intruder penetrates, it pushes away the particles below it towards the bottom and the radial direction of the container. When the intruder travels deep enough, the particles move back to fill the cavity. Interesting, the colormaps of \({v}_{z}(\rho ,z)\) (Fig. 6 (row II) and Fig. 7 (row II)) also show that, even from the beginning of the process, the intruder notably perturbs the region that is later accessed. Complementary, we quantify the percentage of mobilized contacts (contacts with \({F}_{t} > \mu {F}_{n}\)) in the bottom region of the intruder, after penetrating a distance of \(D/2\), and obtaining approximately \(4 \% \) for the case \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(0)=0\) and \(15 \% \) for \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(0)=2.3\,m/s\). These findings indicate that the initial impact perturbs the system at large distances, enhancing its local plasticity and favoring further reordering events. As a result, the granular bed changes its macroscopic response, when varying the initial speed. The latter might explain that the coefficient \(\gamma \) (see Eq. (1) intruder’s dynamics) is not a material constant, despite the weak changes in macroscopic volume fraction.
Additionally, we also connect the particle local activity to the intruder deceleration, exploring the behavior of the kinetic stress \({{\boldsymbol{\sigma }}}^{k}(\rho ,z)\), which is the stress associated with velocity fluctuations (see the fourth row in Figs. 6 and 7). Note that momentum transfer as well as energy loss from inelastic collisions is closely associated with the deceleration trajectory of the intruder. This process is very heterogeneous and happens at a length scale comparable to the size of the intruder. The energy consumption rate due particleparticle collisions correlates with the strength of kinetic pressure \({p}_{k}(\rho ,z)={\rm{Tr}}({{\boldsymbol{\sigma }}}^{k}(\rho ,z))\). During the impact, it is noticeable the complex propagation of the local kinetic activity, which is quantified by values of the kinetic pressure. As expected, the magnitude of the local activity correlates with the magnitude of the impact velocity in the initial stage of penetration. For the cases with \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(0)\ne 0\), the impact immediately generates a fluidized region bellow the intruder where \({p}_{k}(\rho ,z)\) maximizes at a certain distance from the intruder. The kinetic stress decays as the intruder decelerates, and other local maximums arise. Interestingly, the time evolution of \({p}_{k}(\rho ,z)\) indicates that the strength and location of a maximum are invariant, in the reference system of the intruder. For the case of \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(0)=0\), the fluidized region slowly develops as the intruder penetrates into the system. As the process happens, the general picture is very similar, even though the values of \({p}_{k}(\rho ,z)\) are one order of magnitude lower. In both cases, the disturbed region ahead of the intruder is on the order of \(D\).
Cavity collapse
The computed volume fraction fields allow us to explore nature of void collapse through a quantitative analysis on its dynamics. With that aim, we compute a sequence of \(\phi (\rho ,z)\) fields every millisecond. Subsequently, void profile \(R(z,t)\) is estimated using the definition \(\phi (\rho ,z) > {\phi }_{{\rm{RCP}}}/2\) for granular bulk. This definition is plausible given the value of coarsegraining scale \(w={r}_{p}\). Following this procedure, the void profile \(R(z,t)\) is extracted as a function of time, based on which the dynamics of the cavity radius \(h(t)=R({z}_{{\rm{c}}},t)\), the location \({z}_{{\rm{c}}}\) and time \({t}_{{\rm{c}}}\) of collapsing are identified.
In the past, the dynamics of the cavity collapse was experimentally accessed using XRay Tomography^{14,41}. Thus, it was found that the evolution of the cavity radius \(h(t)\) was consistent with a power law \(h(t)={({t}_{{\rm{c}}}t)}^{\alpha }\), where \({t}_{{\rm{c}}}\) is the collapsing time, and an exponent \(\alpha =0.66\) was reported^{41}. Moreover, several groups have studied theoretically and experimentally the collapsing of air bubbles in liquids^{42,43,44}. Furthermore, in void collapse due hydrostatic pressure, there are theoretical evidences supporting that the cavity radius should diminish as \(h(t)={({t}_{{\rm{c}}}t)}^{1/2}\), resembling a Rayleightype singularity^{44,45}.
In Fig. 8, the evolution of cavity radius \(h(t)\) is illustrated for two different impactor speeds. In general, we find that \(h(t)\) smoothly diminishes in the neighborhood of \({t}_{{\rm{c}}}\), exhibiting a power law behavior \(h(t)={({t}_{{\rm{c}}}t)}^{\alpha }\) (see the insets in Fig. 8a,b). This behavior is very similar to the cavity collapse in the wake of an impacting disk on a fluid^{45}. Moreover, this power law controlled pitchoff was also encountered when a ball is dropped in sand^{41}. We find that the exponent characterizing the collapsing process differs notably depending on the initial speed impact. For the case, \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(0)=0\) a \(\alpha =0.42\) is estimated, while a noticeable lower value \(\alpha =0.32\) is found for \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(0)=2.3\) m/s. Thus, the collapsing process gets slower as the initial speed gets larger, which might correlates with the amount of momentum transferred, the size of the perturbed zone and its corresponding dissipation time. It is important to remark, that in the case \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(0)=2.3\) m/s, the last accessible data point always deviates from this trend because it is the result of the movement of individual particles. A more systematic and quantitative analysis of the collapsing dynamics will be a focus of future investigations.
Characteristic length and time scales
In order to quantify the characteristic length and time scales of collisional energy dissipation, we examine the kinetic pressure profile in the vertical direction. The averaged values \(\left\langle {p}_{{\rm{k}}}(z)\right\rangle \) correspond to an average on a radial sector of \(\Delta r=D\), centered at the intruder location. Figure 9 illustrates several results \(\left\langle {p}_{{\rm{k}}}(z)\right\rangle \) corresponding to two initial intruder speeds and different times; Fig. 9a,b, \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(0)=0\) and \({v}_{{\rm{i}}}(0)=2.3\) m/s, respectively. For a better comparison, the spatial coordinates correspond to the mobile reference system at the intruder \(z{\prime} =(z{v}_{{\rm{i}}}t)\) and the values of kinetic pressure are rescaled with their maximum values \({p}_{k}^{i}\) (see insets of Fig. 9a,b), which is located in the neighborhood of the intruder. In general, the kinetic stress decays exponentially with the distance respect to the intruder location, regardless of the initial intruder velocity and time. Astonishingly, though the values of \(\left\langle {p}_{{\rm{k}}}(z)\right\rangle \) differ in one order of magnitude, the characteristic length scale is practically the same in all cases and it is of order of \(D\). In the past, a similar analysis was done for a 2D case^{46}, examining a scaled steadystate velocity field, which was found to decay exponentially, with a correlation length in the order of the particle size.
During the penetration process of an intruder in a granular bed with macroscopic mass density \(\rho \), dissipation occurs due to inelastic collisions between grains. In order to build a continuous theoretical approach of this process^{47}, the starting point is the energy balance equation in terms of the granular temperature T, which written in the moving reference system of the intruder \(z{\prime} =z{v}_{z}(t)t\) reads,
In Eq. 2, one can use the Fourier’s law \(q={\lambda }_{T}\nabla T\) for the heat flux with diffusivity \({\lambda }_{T}\); while \({\alpha }_{T}T\) represents the collisional granular dissipation and \(\dot{\varepsilon }\) is the macroscopic shear rate. Moreover, \({\rho }_{m}{v}_{{\rm{i}}}\nabla T\) accounts for the convective heat transmission.
Interestingly, the data shown in Fig. 9a,b suggest the presence of a very slow diffusiveconvective heat transmission scenario. In that conditions \(\dot{\varepsilon }\approx 0\) and Eq. 2 in \(1D\) reads as,
Note that \(T(z{\prime} ,t)\cong {T}_{{\rm{o}}}{e}^{\frac{t}{\tau }}{e}^{\frac{z{\prime} }{\xi }}\) is a solution of Eq. (3), where \({T}_{{\rm{o}}}\) is the granular temperature at the surface of the intruder. Remark that \(\tau \) and \(\xi \) are the time and space characteristic values of the penetration process. Naively, \(\tau \) is in the order of the penetration time, and \(\xi \), is the positive root of the characteristic equation \({\lambda }_{T}{\xi }^{2}{\rho }_{m}{v}_{{\rm{i}}}\xi +({\alpha }_{T}+\rho /\tau )\). From our data and assuming \(T(z{\prime} )\cong {p}^{k}(z{\prime} )\), we find that the length scale of the energy dissipation \(\xi \) is practically constant \(\xi \approx \frac{2}{5}D\). Interesting, this finding is in perfect agreement with the longscale inertial dissipation type \({F}_{d}=\,\gamma {v}_{{\rm{i}}}^{2}\) that we find in all cases. It is important to remark, however, that we find that the dissipation parameter \(\gamma \) decreases with increasing initial speed of the intruder. This fact correlates with the initial kinetic pressure that the intruder induces at impact, when mechanical energy is quickly transmitted through the granular bed by means of, e.g., shock waves^{48,49}. Thus, right from the beginning the intruder perturbs the strong particle contacts on the force network, and enhances the plasticity of the system. Consequently, the system responses distinctively depending on the initial speed of the intruder. Finally, we note that the existence of a critical length scale ahead of a projectile was also observed in previous investigations on projectile impact on dust agglomerates for understanding the evolution of protoplanetesimal^{50,51}. The authors also showed, based on dimensional analysis, that the characteristic length scale in the system should be directly related to the projectile size. Stepping further, our results show the length scale remains the same, when changing the initial speed and; i.e., the amount of energy transmitted by projectile to the surrounding particles.
Conclusions and Outlook
To summarize, we study experimentally and numerically the penetration of a spherical intruder in a granular bed at various impact velocities using radar particle tracking in experiments and coarsegraining techniques in simulations. The dynamics of the intruder is numerically reproduced and the obtained trajectories are in very good agreement with a wellaccepted phenomenological model. However, the obtained coefficient of the inertial drag term, which is \(\propto {v}_{{\rm{i}}}^{2}\), is not a material property, but deviates from a constant value as the initial speed decreases to zero. The latter raises the question of what determines the nature of granular drag. To explain this, we compute the relevant macroscopic fields of the granular bed (volume fraction, macroscopic velocity and the kinetic stress tensor) by means of coarsegraining techniques. Our results show that the intruder perturbs the granular bed even at very long distances, although notable changes in volume fraction are not detected. Further analysis of the cavity collapse behind the intruder reveals a power law diminishes of the neck radius \(h(t)\), with an exponent depending on the initial impact speed. Moreover, the kinetic pressure profiles \({p}^{k}(z{\prime} )\) in the comoving frame of the intruder decays always exponentially with the distance to the intruder \(z{\prime} \), and the characteristic length is practically independent of the initial speed of the intruder. Analytic arguments show that this result indicates a very slow diffusiveconvective collisionalenergy transmission within the granular bed. In the future, further investigations on how gravity influences granular drag shall be carried out by means of oblique impacts as well as microgravity experiments.
Method
Experimental setup
As illustrated in Fig. 1, the transmission horn antenna emits a \(10\) GHz electromagnetic (EM) wave into the free space, while a spherical projectile moves following an unknown trajectory. As the dielectric constant of styrofoam particles is very close to air, the granular bed is practically transparent to EM waves. Thus, the mobility of the target with respect to each receiving (Rx) antenna is obtained from the phase shift between the received signal and the emitted one. Finally, a coordinate transformation allows reconstructing the trajectory of the projectile accurately. Moreover, given the analog nature of the radar system output, an extremely high temporal resolution is also achieved. The limitation of the temporal signal only arises from the analogdigital (AD) converter. For the normal penetration processes studied in the current investigation, we use an AD converter (NIDAQ6015) up to \(200\) kHz. Furthermore, the noninvasive nature and the high temporal resolution, make this technique suitable for monitoring the trajectory of spherical and nonspherical projectiles in three dimensions (3D). More details on the radar system as well as its advantages and disadvantages in comparison to other particle imaging techniques can be found in^{29,52} and^{53}, respectively.
In the experimental setup, a steel ball with a radius of \(R=0.5\) cm is held by a styrofoam holder at various initial falling heights \(H\). By gently pulling a thin thread that wrapped around the sphere, we allow the sphere to fall freely with minimized horizontal and angular velocities. The granular sample is composed of EPP particles (Neopolen, P9255) with a slightly ellipsoidal shape and a mean radius of \({r}_{{\rm{p}}}=1.5\) mm, filled into a cylindrical container made of Styrofoam, which is also transparent to EM waves. The radius of the container is \({R}_{{\rm{c}}}=15\) cm and the filling height is \(23\) cm, sufficiently deep to avoid the influence from the side wall. The radar system starts shortly before the projectile release until its final resting state. It operates with a power of \(1\) W with the capability of tracking the projectile at a distance of \( \sim 1.5\) m with a field of view of \( \sim 30\) cm.
DEM and coarsegraining methodology
We use discrete element modeling (DEM)^{54}, describing a spherical intruder sinking into a granular bed composed of spherical particles. The implementation is a hybrid \(CPU/GPU\) algorithm that allows us to efficiently evaluate the dynamics of several hundred thousand particles^{55,56}. We initiate each simulation by generating a random packing of polydisperse spheres with radius \({r}_{{\rm{p}}}=1.5\) mm, confined in a cylindrical container of radius \({R}_{{\rm{c}}}\) with packing fraction \(\phi =0.63\pm 0.02\). The spherical intruder is released from the free granular surface with a given initial velocity, the range of which matches that in the experiments.
The \(DEM\) algorithm computes the movement of each particle \(i=1\ldots N\) for the three translational degrees of freedom, and the rotational movement is described by a quaternion formalism. The interaction force between particle \(i\) and particle \(j\), is composed of normal and tangential components
Given the particles normal overlap \({\delta }_{n}\) and the tangential relative displacement \(\overrightarrow{\xi }\), it reads as,
Here we used a HertzMindlin model^{54}, \({k}_{n}=\frac{4}{3}Y\sqrt{{R}_{e}{\delta }_{n}}\) and \({k}_{t}=8G\sqrt{{R}_{e}{\delta }_{n}}\), \({R}_{e}\) is the equivalent radius and \(Y\) and \(G\) are the equivalent Young’s and shear modulus, respectively. Moreover, \({\gamma }_{n}=2\sqrt{\frac{5}{6}}\beta \sqrt{{S}_{n}{m}^{\ast }}\) and \({\gamma }_{t}=2\sqrt{\frac{5}{6}}\beta \sqrt{{S}_{t}{m}^{\ast }}\), where \({S}_{n}=2Y\sqrt{R{\delta }_{n}}\), \({S}_{t}=8G\sqrt{R{\delta }_{n}}\), \({m}^{* }=\frac{{m}_{i}+{m}_{j}}{{m}_{i}{m}_{j}}\) and \(\beta =\frac{{\rm{ln}}({{\rm{e}}}_{{\rm{n}}})}{\sqrt{{{\rm{ln}}}^{2}({{\rm{e}}}_{{\rm{n}}})+{\pi }^{2}}}\). \({e}_{n}\) is the normal restitution coefficient of the particles. The tangential relative displacement \(\overrightarrow{\xi }\) is kept orthogonal to the normal vector and it is truncated as necessary to satisfy the Coulomb constraint \({\overrightarrow{F}}_{ij}^{t} < \mu {\overrightarrow{F}}_{ij}^{n}\), where \(\mu \) is the friction coefficient.
In all the simulations presented here, the system is composed of \(N=180864\) particles, the used contact parameters correspond approximately to particles with a Young’s modulus \(Y=800\) kPa (\(G=Y/10\)), density \({\rho }_{{\rm{p}}}=92.0\,{\rm{kg}}/{{\rm{m}}}^{3}\) and normal restitution coefficient \({e}_{{\rm{n}}}=0.4\). The intruder radius is \(R=5.0\times 1{0}^{3}\,m\) and density \({\rho }_{p}=7800\,{\rm{kg}}/{{\rm{m}}}^{3}\). The particlewall interaction is modeled using the the same collision parameters used for particleparticle interaction. The parameters are chosen to match the experimental conditions.
Besides the time evolution of the intruder, the simulation data also provides the position and velocities of all the particles of the bed, during the entire impact process. Thus, in order to explore the macroscopic response of the system a coarsegraining methodology is also used^{36,37,38}. As a result, the local response of the granular bed, as the intruder moves through it is addressed in detail, through the macroscopic fields of volume fraction \(\phi (\rho ,z)\), particle velocity \(\overrightarrow{v}(\rho ,z)\) and kinetic stress \({\sigma }_{k}(\rho ,z)\).
According to^{36,37,38}, the macroscopic mass density of a granular flow, \(\rho (\overrightarrow{r})\), at time \(t\) is defined by
where the sum runs over all the particles within the system and \(\phi (\overrightarrow{r}{\overrightarrow{r}}_{i}(t))\) is an integrable coarsegraining function. We use a truncated Gaussian coarsegraining function \(\phi (\overrightarrow{{\mathscr{R}}})={A}_{w}{e}^{{( {\mathscr{R}} /2w)}^{2}}\) with cutoff \({r}_{c}=4w\) where the value of \(w\) defines the coarsegrained scale. The value of \({A}_{w}\) is computed guarantying the normalization condition. From Eq. (6), the volume fraction field is \(\varphi (\overrightarrow{r},t)={\rho }_{m}(\overrightarrow{r},t)/{\rho }_{{\rm{p}}}\).
On the other hand, the coarse grained momentum density function \(P(\overrightarrow{r},t)\) is defined by
where the \({\overrightarrow{v}}_{i}\) represent the velocity of particle \(i\). The macroscopic velocity field \(\overrightarrow{V}(\overrightarrow{r},t)\) is then defined as the ratio of momentum and density fields,
Additionally, the propagation of the kinetic activity in the particle bed is quantified by values of the kinetic stress tensor, which reads,
where \({\overrightarrow{v}}_{i}^{{\prime} }\) is fluctuation of the velocity of particle \(i\), respect to the mean field \({\overrightarrow{v}}_{i}^{{\prime} }(t,\overrightarrow{r})={\overrightarrow{v}}_{i}(t)\overrightarrow{V}(\overrightarrow{r},t)\).
It is generally accepted that the trace of kinetic stress tensor (kinetic pressure) is proportional to the granular temperature. Thus, it represents a measurement of the grain fluctuations respect to the mean velocity field. That’s why it can be used to examine the propagation of the kinetic activity as the intruder moves through it.
References
Chhabra, R. P. Bubbles, Drops, and Particles in NonNewtonian Fluids, Second Edition (CRC Press, 2006).
Katsuragi, H. Physics of Soft Impact and Cratering, vol. 910 of Lecture Notes in Physics (Springer Japan, Tokyo, 2016).
Van der Meer, D. Impact on Granular Beds. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics 49, 463–484 (2017).
RuizSuarez, J. C. Penetration of projectiles into granular targets. Reports on Progress in Physics 76, 066601 (2013).
Hosoi, A. & Goldman, D. I. Beneath Our Feet: Strategies for Locomotion in Granular Media. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics 47, 431–453 (2015).
Robins, B. New Principles of Gunnery (London, 1742).
Poncelet, J. V. Cours de Mécanique Industrielle (Paris, 1829).
Uehara, J. S., Ambroso, M. A. & Ojha, R. P. LowSpeed Impact Craters in Loose Granular Media. Physical Review Letters 90, 194301 (2003).
de Bruyn, J. R. & Walsh, A. M. Penetration of spheres into loose granular media. Canadian Journal of Physics 82, 439–446 (2004).
Katsuragi, H. & Durian, D. J. Unified force law for granular impact cratering. Nature Physics 3, 420–423 (2007).
Brzinski, T. A. III, Mayor, P. & Durian, D. J. DepthDependent Resistance of Granular Media to Vertical Penetration. Physical Review Letters 111, 168002 (2013).
Colaprete, A. et al. Detection of Water in the LCROSS Ejecta Plume. Science 330, 463–468 (2010).
Shinbrot, T., Sabuwala, T., Siu, T., Vivar Lazo, M. & Chakraborty, P. Size Sorting on the RubblePile Asteroid Itokawa. Physical Review Letters 118, 111101 (2017).
Royer, J. R. et al. Formation of granular jets observed by highspeed xray radiography. Nature Physics 1, 164–167 (2005).
Askari, H. & Kamrin, K. Intrusion rheology in grains and other flowable materials. Nature Materials 25, 1274 (2016).
Kang, W., Feng, Y., Liu, C. & Blumenfeld, R. Archimedes’s law explains penetration of solids into granular media. Nature Communications 9, 1101 (2018).
Altshuler, E. et al. Settling into dry granular media in different gravities. Geophysical Research Letters 41, 3032–3037 (2014).
PachecoVazquez, F. & RuizSuarez, J. Cooperative dynamics in the penetration of a group of intruders in a granular medium. Nature Communications 1, 123 (2010).
Tsimring, L. & Volfson, D. Modeling of impact cratering in granular media. Powders and Grins 2, 1215 (2005).
PachecoVazquez, F. et al. Infinite Penetration of a Projectile into a Granular Medium. Physical Review Letters 106, 218001 (2011).
LópezRodríguez, L. A. & PachecoVázquez, F. Friction force regimes and the conditions for endless penetration of an intruder into a granular medium. Physical Review E 96, 030901 (2017).
Seguin, A. & Gondret, P. Drag force in a cold or hot granular medium. Physical Review E 96, 032905 (2017).
Crassous, J., Beladjine, D. & Valance, A. Impact of a projectile on a granular medium described by a collision model. Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 248001 (2007).
Seguin, A., Bertho, Y., Gondret, P. & Crassous, J. Sphere penetration by impact in a granular medium: A collisional process. EPL (Europhysics Letters) 88, 44002 (2009).
Clark, A. H., Kondic, L. & Behringer, R. P. Particle Scale Dynamics in Granular Impact. Physical Review Letters 109, 238302 (2012).
Takehara, Y. & Okumura, K. Highvelocity drag friction in granular media near the jamming point. Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 148001 (2014).
Jaeger, H. M., Nagel, S. R. & Behringer, R. P. Granular solids, liquids, and gases. Rev. Mod. Phys. 68, 1259 (1996).
Duran, J. Sands, Powders and Grains (An Introduction to the Physics of Granular Materials) (SpringerVerlag, New York, 2000), 1 edn.
Ott, F., Herminghaus, S. & Huang, K. Radar for tracer particles. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 88, 051801 (2017).
Pica Ciamarra, M. et al. Dynamics of Drag and Force Distributions for Projectile Impact in a Granular Medium. Physical Review Letters 92, 194301 (2004).
Katsuragi, H. & Durian, D. J. Drag force scaling for penetration into granular media. Physical Review E 87, 052208 (2013).
Xu, Y., Padding, J. T. & Kuipers, J. A. M. Numerical investigation of the vertical plunging force of a spherical intruder into a prefluidized granular bed. Physical Review E 90, 062203 (2014).
Clark, A. H. & Behringer, R. P. Granular impact model as an energydepth relation. EPL (Europhysics Letters) 101, 64001 (2013).
Bester, C. S. & Behringer, R. P. Collisional model of energy dissipation in threedimensional granular impact. Phys. Rev. E 95, 032906 (2017).
Dunatunga, S. & Kamrin, K. Continuum modeling of projectile impact and penetration in dry granular media. Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids 100, 45–60 (2017).
Goldhirsch, I. Stress, stress asymmetry and couple stress: from discrete particles to continuous fields. Granular Matter 12, 239–252 (2010).
Weinhart, T., Hartkamp, R., Thornton, A. R. & Luding, S. Coarsegrained local and objective continuum description of threedimensional granular flows down an inclined surface. Physics of Fluids.25 (2013).
Artoni, R. & Richard, P. Average balance equations, scale dependence, and energy cascade for granular materials. Phys. Rev. E 91, 032202 (2015).
Artoni, R. & Richard, P. Coarse graining for granular materials: micropolar balances. Acta Mech 230, 3055–3069 (2019).
Royer, J. R., Conyers, B., Corwin, E. I., Eng, P. J. & Jaeger, H. M. The role of interstitial gas in determining the impact response of granular beds. EPL (Europhysics Letters) 93, 28008 (2011).
Homan, T., Mudde, R., Lohse, D. & Meer, D. v. d. Highspeed Xray imaging of a ball impacting on loose sand. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 777, 690–706 (2015).
Gordillo, J. M., Sevilla, A., RodríguezRodríguez, J. & MartínezBazán, C. Axisymmetric bubble pinchoff at high reynolds numbers. Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 194501 (2005).
Eggers, J., Fontelos, M. A., Leppinen, D. & Snoeijer, J. H. Theory of the collapsing axisymmetric cavity. Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 094502 (2007).
Bergmann, R. et al. Giant bubble pinchoff. Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 154505 (2006).
Gekle, S., Snoeijer, J. H., Lohse, D. & van der Meer, D. Approach to universality in axisymmetric bubble pinchoff. Phys. Rev. E 80, 036305 (2009).
Clark, A. H., Kondic, L. & Behringer, R. P. Steady flow dynamics during granular impact. Phys. Rev. E 93, 050901 (2016).
Seguin, A., Bertho, Y., Gondret, P. & Crassous, J. Dense granular flow around a penetrating object: Experiment and hydrodynamic model. Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 048001 (2011).
Bougie, J., Moon, S. J., Swift, J. B. & Swinney, H. L. Shocks in vertically oscillated granular layers. Phys. Rev. E 66, 051301 (2002).
Huang, K., Zhang, P., Miao, G. & Wei, R. Dynamic behaviors of supersonic granular media under vertical vibration. Ultrasonics 44, e1487–e1489 (2006).
Güttler, C., Krause, M., Geretshauser, R. J., Speith, R. & Blum, J. The physics of protoplanetesimal dust agglomerates. IV. Toward a dynamical collision model. The Astrophysical Journal 701, 130–141 (2009).
Katsuragi, H. & Blum, J. The physics of protoplanetesimal dust agglomerates. IX. mechanical properties of dust aggregates probed by a solidprojectile impact. The Astrophysical Journal 851, 23 (2017).
Rech, F. & Huang, K. Correction of iq mismatch for a particle tracking radar. European Microwave Conference (2019).
Amon, A. et al. Preface: Focus on imaging methods in granular physics. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 88, 051701 (2017).
Pöschel, T. & Schwager, T. Computational Granular Dynamics (SpringerVerlag Berlin Heidelberg New York, 2005).
Sanders, J. & Kandrot, E. CUDA by Example: An Introduction to GeneralPurpose GPU Programming (AddisonWesley Professional, 2010).
RubioLargo, S. M., Maza, D. & Hidalgo, R. C. Largescale numerical simulations of polydisperse particle flow in a silo. Computational Particle Mechanics 1–9 (2016).
Acknowledgements
We thank Ingo Rehberg, Simeon Völkel and Thorsten Pöschel for helpful discussions. K.H. and R.C.H. acknowledge the support of Bayerische Forschungsallianz through Grant No. BaylntAnUBT201872 for establishing the collaboration. This work is partly supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft through Grant No. HU1939/41. The Spanish MINECO (FIS201784631P MINECO/AEI/FEDER, UE Projects), supported this work. D.H. acknowledges Asociación de Amigos de la Universidad de Navarra. This publication was funded by the German Research Foundation (DFG) and the University of Bayreuth in the funding programme Open Access Publishing.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
R.C.H. and K.H. initiated and supervised the research. F.R., V.D. and K.H. performed the experiments. D.H. and R.C.H. conducted the simulations. All authors analyzed and contributed to the interpretation of the data. R.C.H. and KH wrote the manuscript.
Corresponding authors
Ethics declarations
Competing interests
The authors declare no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Huang, K., HernándezDelfin, D., Rech, F. et al. The role of initial speed in projectile impacts into light granular media. Sci Rep 10, 3207 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s4159802059950z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s4159802059950z
This article is cited by

Construction of velocity similarity graph for velocity field analysis in granular intruder motion
Granular Matter (2024)

The effect of particle shape on the dynamics of spherical projectile impacting into granular media
Computational Particle Mechanics (2024)

Dynamic characteristics of sphere impact into wet granular materials considering suction
Granular Matter (2023)

Coupled twodimensional discrete element and multibody dynamic modeling for interaction of the soil and rough shaped rigid bodies
Acta Mechanica Sinica (2022)
Comments
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.