Effect of addition of adjuvants on physical and chemical characteristics of Bt bioinsecticide mixture

Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) is the main bacterium used in the formulation of bioinsecticides because it produces toxins and spores that are toxic to several orders of insects. The efficacy of Bt bioinsecticide is influenced by the quality of its application. The association with other crop protection products, such as adjuvants, can affect the physical and chemical parameters of the mixture. This study evaluated the physical and chemical parameters, volume median diameter (VMD), uniformity coefficient of droplets (SPAN), percentage of volume in drift droplets (%V <100 µm), contact angle, surface tension, potential of hydrogen (pH) and electrical conductivity (E.C.) of Bt bioinsecticides in concentrated suspension (SC), and wettable powder (WP) formulations associated with adjuvants. The largest droplet diameter and smallest values of drift droplets were found in the WP formulation with lower drift potential. The addition of mineral oil and surfactant to the mixtures of bioinsecticide reduced contact angle values and surface tension of the droplets, resulting in greater spreading of droplets in leaves. The addition of lecithin and propionic-acid-based adjuvants lowered the pH in both formulations. The adjuvants used in this study affected the physical and chemical characteristics of the mixtures, improving or impairing the quality of Bt bioinsecticide applications.

. *Capital letters are used when comparing differences between formulations. Lowercase letters are used when comparing differences between treatments within each formulation. Comparisons followed by the same letter did not differ in Tukey's t test at P = 0.05. Source: Author.
When mixtures of the concentrated suspension (SC) formulation were compared, the wettable powder (WP) formulation had the highest VMD values. When adjuvants were added, VMD remained the same in the Bt WP mixture. Only the addition of mineral oil (MO) resulted in a higher VMD in the Bt SC (Fig. 1). The highest SPAN values were observed in the treatments with lecithin-and propionic-acid-based adjuvants (LPA), organosilicon (AO) and nonylphenol ethoxylate (NPE) in the WP formulation, and MO in the Bt SC mixture. Among the formulations, mixtures composed of nonylphenoxy polyethanol (NPPE) and NPE in the Bt WP had the highest SPAN values, while the Bt SC mixtures, obtained the highest SPAN values when MO, NPPE, and NPE adjuvants were added (Fig. 1). The SC formulation mixtures had higher drift risk (%V < 100 µm). In both formulations, the addition of vegetable oil (SOME), NPPE, and NPE adjuvants led to higher %V < 100 µm values (Fig. 1).
Surface tension and contact angle. Addition of MO, AO, and SOME adjuvants to the WP and SC mixtures resulted in the lowest surface stresses, while the highest stresses were observed in Bt WP mixtures and when the SLES adjuvant was added (Fig. 2). The lowest surface stresses among the formulations were observed in OM, LPA, Bt SC, and NPPE mixtures, respectively, while the highest were observed in SLES and NPE mixtures (Fig. 3). In spray solutions composed of Bt WP, the lowest surface stresses were obtained where MO, AO and SOME adjuvants had been added, while the highest were observed in Bt without adjuvants and with added NPPE and LPA adjuvants (Fig. 2).
Droplet contact angle differed for the two evaluated surfaces; the parafilm surface had higher values than the cotton leaf surface (Table 2). On the cotton leaf, the WP formulation had the lowest contact angles when compared to BS. On the parafilm surface, WP treatments with added LPA, AO, and NPPE adjuvants had higher contact angles, as did the SC without adjuvant and the SLES and NPE adjuvants ( Table 2). Comparing the spray solutions in each formulation, the LPA in the WP formulation on the leaf surface had the greatest angle, whereas the Bt WP spray solution without adjuvant was greater on the parafilm surface. In the SC formulation, the addition of LPA and NPE provided greater contact angles of droplets on the sheet surface. In the parafilm, the Bt SC without adjuvant and with NPE had the highest values of droplet contact angle values ( Table 2).
Potential of hydrogen (pH) and electrical conductivity (E.C.). The mixtures were subjected to four different periods of rest after agitation for evaluation of hydrogenionic potential (pH) and electrical conductivity (E.C.). During all rest periods, the highest E.C. values were observed when the LPA adjuvant was added to the SC and WP formulations of Bt bioinsecticide. The mixtures with the SC formulation had the highest pH values and the lowest E.C. values, while the WP spray solutions had the lowest pH values and the highest E.C. The pH and E.C. did not significantly vary during the rest periods of the mixture (Fig. 3).

Discussion
The Dipel ® WP formulation mixtures had higher volume median diameter (VMD) and consequently, lower susceptibility to drift (%V < 100 µm) and evaporation potential, reducing dehydration-induced non-viability of bacterial spores and providing greater protection against direct exposure to ultraviolet rays 21 . Larger droplets may support better persistence and survival of Bt in unfavorable environmental conditions like hot weather, because they are composed of more water and spores. Very fine droplets such as those with VMD less than 100 µm are highly susceptible to drift, and evaporate more easily when air humidity is below 55% 22 .  www.nature.com/scientificreports www.nature.com/scientificreports/ Adding adjuvants reduced the surface tension of the Bt SC and WP droplets. In both formulations, the mixtures containing MO, SOME and AO had the lowest surface tension values. Decreased mixture surface tension may be related to leaf spreading. However, correlation depends on the affinity of the liquid to the plant species on which the droplet is deposited. Notably, differences in the epidermis, such as composition of cuticular wax and cell anatomy among plant species, may affect spreading 26,27 .
Similar results were found for the Bt mixture when mineral and vegetable oil were added, reducing the surface tension of the spray droplets and resulting in greater spreading of the mixture in cassava leaves (Manihot esculenta Crantz) 7 . Surface tension was reduced with the addition of oils because of micelle formation by the molecules in the mixture 28,29 . These bonds act as a bridge between water molecules and insecticide, reducing the surface tension of the mixture and replacing stronger bonds represented by hydrogen bridges in the water 16 . Higher surface tension values were observed in NPPE, NPE, SLES, Bt WP and Bt SC mixtures, indicating decreased spreading power on the leaf surface. Droplets with higher surface tension, therefore, have higher VMD and are less susceptible to drift because solutions with higher surface tension are able to produce thicker droplets. These droplets are also more resistant to wind during spraying 30 .
The smallest droplet contact angles were observed in the WP formulation mixtures for both the parafilm and the cotton leaf. The mixtures with this formulation had higher spreading capacity on the plant leaf surfaces. Thus, the lower the surface tension of the liquid, the lower the contact angle. This is because the addition of surfactants promote molecular rearrangements such that the polar end of the molecules turns toward the water, while the other end turns to the interface where liquid contacts the surface, thus "breaking" the surface tension of the mixture, reducing the contact angle in relation to the leaf and increasing wettability 28 .
Adding of LPA to Bt mixtures decreased pH and increased electrical conductivity during all rest periods. During vegetative growth, acidic media provides greater sporulation in a Bt 12 -based mixture because the bacterium produces and excretes in the pyruvate and acetate culture medium resulting from carbohydrate fermentation 31 . At the end of vegetative growth, the synthesis of poly-β-hydroxybutyrate (PHB) begins, serving as an intracellular reserve of carbon and energy for sporulation in many Bacillus spp. 13 . The synthesis of PHB begins once the minimum pH value is reached, and lasts for a few hours until reaching the maximum concentration, when sporulation begins 32 . LPA contains lecithin and propionic acid, which influence the production of Bt spores, because synthesizing protein crystals requires a high amount of energy 13 . These components are an important energy source for crystal synthesis, contributing to the growth of colonies both regarding quantity and force.
The electrical conductivity of the mixtures remained constant during the rest period. The WP formulation had the highest E.C. values. The difference in electrical conductivity can be attributed to the composition of the mixture, which alters the biological efficacy of crop protection products 33 . It is important to study pH and E.C. because these factors can accelerate degradation of crop protection products influencing the rest of the application 34 .

Conclusions
The Bt WP formulation, with and without addition adjuvants, performed better with regard to droplet size and droplet spreading on the plant surface because its larger droplets made it less susceptible to drift. The lecithin and propionic acid-based adjuvant addition had slightly acidic pH and high electrical conductivity in the mixtures, which are physical and chemical characteristics favorable to the production of crystals and Bt spores during the fermentation process because they act as an energy source.  Table 1. Commercial products used to evaluate physical and chemical characteristics of mixtures in WP and SC formulations of Dipel in terms of droplet size spectrum, contact angle, surface tension of droplets and hydrogen and electrical conductivity potential of the mixtures. *All the dosages are recommended by the manufacturers for a mixture volume of 150 L ha −1 . a.i: Active ingredient. Source: Author.

Methods
Spray droplet size spectrum. The droplet size was determined by laser diffraction using a particle diameter meter (Mastersizer S ® version 2. 19). An optical unit in the equipment determines the droplet diameter of the sprayed spectrum by the path deviation of the laser when reaching them. The smaller the particle, the greater the degree of diffraction experienced by the ray of light 35 . The treatments are described in Table 1 as the Concentrated Suspension (SC) and Wettable Powder (WP) formulations, and a XR11003 (TeeJet Technologies) hydraulic deflector jet spray tip model was used for testing all spray solutions. The spray was triggered by compressed air and the pressure was constant at 275 kPa with a precision pressure regulator for each tip. Three specimens of the tip were evaluated four times, totaling 12 repetitions per treatment. The design was random and the values of VMD, SPAN and percentage of volume with droplets smaller than 100 μm (%V < 100 µm) were evaluated.
Surface tension and droplet angle on cotton leaf surface. The mixture surface tension was measured on a section of cotton leaf and parafilm, 0.5 cm wide × 5 cm long. Surface tension was determined using the hanging droplet method with an automatic tensiometer (Model OCA 15 Plus, Dataphysics Germany). The image of the droplet formed at the end of a syringe is captured by a camera and the equipment analyzes the shape of the droplet by axis asymmetry (ADSA-Axisymmetric Droplet Shape Analysis). Digitizing and analyzing the droplet profile determined surface tension, using the Young-Laplace equation for adjustment 36 . Mixture stability, pH, and electrical conductivity. Lidded 250 mL beakers were used for the preparation of the mixtures using the recommended concentration of each product ( Table 1). The liquid products were dosed using a 1,000 graduated pipette μL (LabMate ® ). The pH (pHmeter QUIMIS ® Q400AS) and electrical conductivity (Condutivimeter Mars ® MB-11P) were measured before and after mixing. The mixture was prepared and evaluated in a temperature of 25 ± 2 °C and relative humidity of 65 ± 5%.
The mixtures were evaluated at the following intervals: immediate separation after mixing (0) and after 2, 6, and 24 hours of the rest period, The effects of interactions between the products were analyzed for homo-and heterogeneity (flocculation, sedimentation, phase separation, formation of lumps and formation of crystals) and foam formation 37 . A metal sieve with a nominal opening of 149 μm was used 38 to evaluate flocculation and formation of lumps and crystals. Sedimentation was measured by the volume of mixture deposited at the bottom of the beaker. Statistical analysis. The droplet size spectrum and surface tension were analyzed using a 2 × 8 factorial design (Dipel ® formulation versus adjuvants). The contact angle was analyzed using a 2 × 8 × 2 factorial design