The spring diatom bloom in the Arctic Ocean accounts for significant annual primary production leading to the most rapid annual drawdown of water-column pCO2. Late-winter waters in the Atlantic Arctic & Subarctic Provinces (AASP) have lower silicic acid concentrations than nitrate, which suggests diatom blooms may deplete Si before N. Here we test a facet of the hypothesis that silicic acid limitation terminates the spring diatom bloom in the AASP and the sinking of the senescent and dead diatoms helps drive carbon sequestration. During a 6-week study, diatoms bloomed and progressively consumed silicic acid to where it limited their growth. The onset of growth limitation was concurrent with the minimum pCO2 in the surface waters and increases in both the proportion of dead diatoms and the diatom assemblage sedimentation rate. Data reanalysis within the AASP shows a highly significant and positive correlation between silicic acid and pCO2 in the surface waters, but no significant relationship with nitrate and pCO2 was observed unless data were smoothed. Therefore, understanding the future of the AASP spring diatom bloom requires models that explicitly consider changes in silicic acid supply as a driver of this process.
Polar oceans are characterised by strong spring blooms. These blooms are typically dominated by diatoms and, despite being concentrated within a couple of weeks1, they account for much of the annual net primary production2,3. Therefore, diatom activity can govern the capacity of polar marine ecosystems to take up atmospheric CO2 and fuel the food web in both the Southern4 and Arctic5,6 Oceans.
Diatoms require silicic acid (Si(OH)4) to produce their shells made of biogenic silica (bSiO2). In late winter, surface water [Si(OH)4] is low in the Arctic Ocean, ~5 µM7,8, close to an empirical threshold (2 µM) inferred to support diatoms’ niche for dominance of microphytplankton9. Late-winter [Si(OH)4] has declined across the Atlantic Arctic & Subarctic Provinces (AASP)8 in the last three decades. The pre-bloom [Si(OH)4] decline has likely affected the maximum potential diatom biomass during the bloom and has been suggested as a driver for the re-distribution of commercial fish species in the subarctic10. Yet Si(OH)4 uptake data over the broad region is limited11,12.
bSiO2 provides diatoms ballast, but cells can remain buoyant due to changes in the cellular constituents which are controlled by metabolic processes13,14. In Svalbard, Si(OH)4 depletion, associated with intense limitation of diatom Si uptake, potentially limited diatom growth rates even when [bSiO2] did not exceed [Si(OH)4]12. During this same campaign, Agustí et al.15 hypothesized, based on observations that (a) there was a high fraction of dead diatom cells at stations with low [Si(OH)4] and (b) higher sinking rates of dead compared to living diatom cells, that regional [Si(OH)4] depletion triggers mortality and subsequent sinking of diatoms. A recent analysis of 11 polar-diatom clones demonstrated that while their allometry scales similar to temperate diatoms, their elemental density (element µm−3) for C, N, P and Si is 5-50-fold higher16. These authors16 suggested this inherently high elemental density in polar diatoms may enhance trophic transfer and could be a mechanistic reason why polar systems can sustain exceptional higher-trophic-level biomass despite low annual primary production. Specifically, if the elemental yield (e.g. C, N, P) per polar diatom consumed is high, then polar zooplankton may gain more nutritional value than consuming the same quantity of lower-latitude diatom cells for a similar species and size. Such results also suggest that per cell, polar diatoms have a higher elemental-export potential, relative to their low-latitude counterparts.
Diatom sedimentation plays a large role in driving the biological carbon pump, particularly in polar waters17; therefore, resolving the processes controlling diatom sedimentation are critical for understanding oceanic carbon and silicon fluxes18. Combining recent results for Arctic diatom physiology16, export fate15, and limitation by Si(OH)412 suggests that the diatom senescence-aggregation export pathway may be important for driving pCO2 drawdown in the low [Si(OH)4] environment of the AASP. Such an observation is consistent with recent mesocosm findings in Norway (~63.5°N)19, showing that at low [Si(OH)4] diatom export mediated by a diatom senescence and aggregation pathway is favoured over a diatom→copepod→fecal-pellet pathway.
Here we test a facet of the hypothesis that Si(OH)4 limitation terminates the spring diatom bloom in the AASP and infer whether subsequent increases in sinking rates of the senescent and dead diatoms helps to drive carbon sequestration. We combine field observations of phytoplankton processes during a 6-week period in the outer-sill region (coastally influenced) of a Western Greenland fjord within the broader AASP; the timing of sampling encompassed the spring 2017 bloom. Laboratory incubations of field populations were used to quantify the degree to which [Si(OH)4] limits diatom Si uptake and reduces diatom growth, and to quantify the changes in sinking velocity of dead and living diatoms during the bloom sequence.
We show that depletion of Si(OH)4 halted the net accumulation of diatom bSiO2, limited diatom productivity, increased the proportion of dead diatom cells, and led to a 4-fold increase in average sinking velocity for the diatom assemblage at the end of the spring bloom. Therefore, this depletion of Si(OH)4 appears to be a probable trigger driving the annual signal in biogenic carbon sequestration. The trends observed at our Greenland study site are consistent with broader trends in the AASP from independent multi-national datasets. The timing of the spring bloom development and termination determined during this study is coincident with the timing of the broader regional depletion of Si(OH)4, typically with inorganic nitrogen remaining (as either nitrate or ammonium), and the most rapid rate of annual pCO2 decline in the broader region. Evidence of a pivotal role for silicon supply and diatom removal in driving the spring bloom, and thus ecosystem dynamics and carbon sequestration in the AASP, suggest that on-going8 and future20 changes in silicon supply will be an important driver of regional ecosystem change.
Results and Discussion
Diatom and nutrient dynamics during the spring bloom
Prior to the onset of the spring bloom, phytoplankton biomass was low and inactive (Figs 1, S1), with pCO2 ~340 ppm. Pre-bloom nutrient concentrations ([Si(OH)4] = 5 µM, [NO3 + NO2] = 10 µM, [PO4] = 0.7 µM; Fig. 1) were characteristic of late-winter conditions in the broader region21,22. A diatom bloom, dominated by species of Thalassiosira and Bacterosira (Table S1), initiated by 27 April, whereby chlorophyll a (Chl a) increased 8-fold to its peak concentration (Fig. 1B). This total phytoplankton biomass change is similar to 6-7-fold increases in two diatom biomass proxies (e.g. biovolume per litre—proxy for biomass which considers both cell size and abundance, [bSiO2], Table 1). At the bloom peak, bSiO2 accounted for 50–80% of the total Si inventory (Fig. 2A) and pCO2 declined to a minimum, 250 ppm (17 May, Fig. 1A). As diatom biomass declined (Figs 1B, 2A), [Si(OH)4] was ~0.5 µM, while other nutrients were sufficient to maintain primary production among non-diatom phytoplankton ([NO3 + NO2] = 4 µM; Fig. 1). The first appearance of Phaeocystis sp., a flagellate not requiring Si(OH)4, was on 17 May, while not directly quantified (both due to the study scope and difficulty in quantifying total abundance because cells may be solitary or in a colony), their presence was more frequently observed in the subsequent weeks (data not shown). The [Si(OH)4] depletion was concurrent with increased diatom mortality, as dead diatom cells were 85% of the discernible stock within the photic layer at the end of the bloom (Fig. 3A). By the end of the bloom sequence, 5-m pCO2 had re-equilibrated with the atmosphere and increased (Fig. 1A).
Rate processes during bloom termination
Diatom activity mirrored temporal trends in stocks. Net bSiO2 accumulation and production rates peaked on 5 May, prior to the minimum [Si(OH)4] on 17 May (Fig. 2A, Table 1). Polar diatom Si:N is ~1.516, similar to the Si:N drawdown observed 1.7 ± 0.2 (slope in Fig. 2B), suggests that diatoms consumed a majority of the available NO3 + NO2 during the bloom. The intercept of the relationship, 2.1 ± 0.6 µM [NO3 + NO2]¸ indicated that if all the Si(OH)4 was depleted then sufficient N would be available for non-diatom phytoplankton. The 2017 trend is like previous years (2006–2013) at the time-series site in both the ratio of drawdown, 1.7 ± 0.2, and the positive intercept, i.e. 0.4 ± 0.8 µM [NO3 + NO2] (Fig. 2B).
[Si(OH)4] severely limited diatoms’ production. Si uptake increased linearly with increasing [Si(OH)4] (Fig. S2), a trend observed in subtropical gyres23,24. At higher [Si(OH)4], uptake rates neared 1.0 d−1 (Fig. S2), suggesting a decoupling from growth given that net diatom growth rates never approached this magnitude (Fig. 3A), and is consistent with surge Si uptake upon addition of Si(OH)4 after short-term Si-starvation25. The calculated uptake at the ambient [Si(OH)4] (Table 1) was normalized to uptake at 5 µM [Si(OH)4] (Fig. S2), the pre-bloom concentration21, since uptake did not saturate. 5-µM-normalized Si uptake declined progressively, where ambient [Si(OH)4] supported 91% of the 5-µM uptake rate on 18 April (prior to bloom) but <10% between 5–24 May. The lowest percentages coincided with the dates of the highest diatom biomass and [Si(OH)4] <2 µM. Si(OH)4 limitation of diatom production is also evidenced by the responses to Si additions in bioassay experiments, as the accumulated bSiO2 produced over the duration of the bloom would have doubled if diatoms had been supplied an additional 1 µM [Si(OH)4] among sampling points (Fig. 2A).
Silicon limitation appeared to limit diatom growth rate. The onset of growth limitation from [Si(OH)4] occurred between 10–17 May, as the standing stock of diatom bSiO2 exceeded the inventory of Si(OH)4 (Fig. 2A). Such yield limitation may be alleviated partially due to rapid bSiO2 remineralization, even in ~10 °C upwelling systems26,27. However, given the temperature was <1.5 °C (Fig. S1) and the Q10 for bSiO2 dissolution (2.4, see28), the local bSiO2 dissolution rates were predicted to be ~0.01 d−1 (compared to ~0.05 d−1 during upwelling in Monterey Bay, United States27). Such a low bSiO2 dissolution rate is from direct thermal suppression29 and indirect reduction of bacterial activity, a key group for accelerating bSiO2 dissolution30. Given the bSiO2 production rates (Table 1) and high bSiO2 standing stock (Fig. 2), most of which was living and not (likely) susceptible to dissolution, bSiO2 remineralization would have met between 3–7% of the diatom Si(OH)4 demand during the bloom (Table 1). There is also direct evidence for Si limitation of diatom growth. As the bloom progressed, e.g. once [Si(OH)4] was <2 µM, the addition of Si made the net diatom growth rate increase significantly (i.e. the 95% confidence interval did not include 0, confirming a positive effect for +Si, Fig. 3B). This direct experimental evidence is not surprising given the intense kinetic limitation (i.e. Si uptake <10% of 5-µM-normalized rate, Fig. S2), which would likely force diatoms to extend the duration of Si uptake during their cell cycle (i.e. slow growth) to meet the minimum amount of Si necessary for their cellular quotas.
Modal diatom sedimentation rates ranged from 0.3 to 8.78 m d−1 (slowest and fastest, respectively, resolvable with our experimental approach) across taxa and sampling dates (Table S2). Modal sedimentation rates between living and dead diatoms were not different when examining all data (Mann-Whitney, U = 993, p = 0.40); this was due to significant variability in the sedimentation rates for living (Kruskal-Wallis, H = 32.1, n = 47, p < 0.0001) and dead (Kruskal-Wallis, H = 31.7, n = 47, p < 0.0001) diatoms among sampling dates. The rate of sedimentation for the diatom assemblage (weighted by contribution to biovolume per species) was negatively correlated with the assemblage-average net growth rate for the previous week (i.e. time-lagged correlation: 2-tail Spearman Rho = −0.9, p = 0.037; Table 1). This correlation suggests that as net growth rates increased —driven by healthy, actively-growing populations— the sinking rate of the diatom assemblage decreased. The maximum modal sedimentation rate occurred on 24 May (Fig. 3A), which lagged the lowest [Si(OH)4] observed (17 May), consistent with the >3-day lag observed for diatoms persisting in nutrient depleted conditions prior to increased sedimentation31 and that the average net diatom growth rate between those time points was negative (17–24 May, Fig. 3A). Hence, we suggest Si(OH)4 depletion was the main factor contributing to the increased cell sinking rate.
Prior to Si(OH)4 minimum observed on 17 May, multiple proxies demonstrate an active and blooming diatom assemblage including: positive net growth rates for Chl a between 26 April to 10 May (Fig. 1A), net accumulation of diatom biomass (Fig. 1B) and bSiO2 (Fig. 2A) between 18 April to 10 May, and no significant difference in diatom growth rates between +Si and control treatments in bioassay experiments until 17 May (Fig. 3B). Si(OH)4 depletion, despite available [NO3 + NO2] (~4 µM), corresponded with diatom senescence, presumably turning on programmed cell death pathways32. T. rotula dominated diatom biomass prior to 24 May; on this same date sedimentation rates increased, and diatoms were declining in both total biomass (Fig. 1B) and the proportion of living cells (Fig. 3A). The observation that Si(OH)4 depletion increased cell death rates in a Thalassiosira-dominated assemblage has precedence, as high-latitude Thalassiosira appear to be more susceptible to increasing cell death rates in response to silicon limitation than other genera, e.g. Chaetoceros33, perhaps due to Chaetoceros escaping the water column prior to Si(OH)4 depletion by forming fast-sinking resting spores34 (note: Thalassiosira spp. also form resting spores but in a previous study34 did not do so prior to Si(OH)4 depletion). Additionally, Si-limitation in Coscinodiscus wailesii (another centric diatom) increases transparent exopolymer particles35, which are known to enhance aggregation and export36. It has also been proposed that for larger diatoms, post-mortem cell lysis may play a larger role in aggregation35. These prior observations are consistent with the results observed in our study where sinking rates increased concurrently with the increase in the proportion of dead diatom cells (Fig. 3A). And beyond marine systems, limnological studies have long suggested that when Si(OH)4 is depleted, but other limiting factors are replete, mass diatom mortality can occur37.
The results obtained support the hypothesis that Si(OH)4 limitation terminates the diatom bloom in the AASP. This is similar to results reported previously38, which inferred that increased Si(OH)4 supply can prolong a diatom bloom in the southern domain of the AASP. However, this prior study38 did not directly test whether diatom growth was limited by Si availability (i.e. only making inferences based on ecological niches9 from earlier mesocosm results) and provided no mechanistic explanation regarding the connection between diatom bloom termination and mass export. During our study, net diatom growth effectively stopped when [Si(OH)4] was <1 µM. Sedimentation experiments showed, consistent with earlier work using diatom cultures13,14,39 and recently in Svalbard15, that actively growing diatom cells are able to up-regulate buoyancy while senescent or dead cells sink at faster rates. We observed an inverse relationship between bSiO2-normalized production (Table 1), an independent metric of diatom growth from cell counts, and sedimentation rates (Fig. 3A); therefore, Si(OH)4 limitation led to diatom mortality and rapid sinking. Si(OH)4-limited diatoms in culture have significantly more organic matter than diatoms limited by nitrogen40 and polar diatoms have substantially higher elemental density than lower latitude diatoms16. Over an annual cycle in the AASP, [Si(OH)4] and pCO2 have a stronger correlation than pCO2 to [NO3 + NO2] (Fig. 4A, data from41). We suggest that Si(OH)4 uptake and depletion regulate the spring diatom bloom, its subsequent collapse, and thus is a main driver of the major spring carbon export event and surface pCO2 undersaturation —characteristic of the AASP at the end of the spring bloom42.
The role of Silicon in controlling the spring bloom in the Atlantic Arctic & Subarctic Provinces
The results reported are from a coastally-influenced station in a Greenland fjord but are consistent with observations for the broader AASP beyond the highlighted Svalbard studies12,15. Paired [Si(OH)4] and [NO3 + NO2] data from a 3.7 × 106 km2 subarea in the broader AASP (GLODAPv2 ~2400 observations; ICES Oceanography collections, ~4100 observations), demonstrate the condition of excess N, relative to Si, at the beginning of the season selects for diatom blooms to be limited by Si(OH)4 (Fig. 4B–E). Indeed, the intercept of the consumption curves among subregions and data sets range from −0.9 µM [NO3 + NO2] (i.e. N consumed before Si) to 1.2 µM [NO3 + NO2] (i.e. Si consumed before N, Fig. 4C–E). The correlation between gridded Si(OH)4 and pCO2 data41 is positive and highly significant (2-tail Spearman Rho = 0.54, n = 864, p < 0.0001, Fig. 4A), but the corresponding NO3 + NO2 correlation with pCO2 is negative and not significant (2-tail Spearman Rho = −0.11, n = 864, p = 0.06). Only when NO3 + NO2 are averaged among months and compared to average monthly pCO2 does the correlation become positive and significant (2-tail Spearman Rho = 0.72, n = 12, p < 0.01), but this monthly averaging also improves the correlation between Si(OH)4 and pCO2 (2-tail Spearman Rho = 0.94, n = 12, p < 0.0001).
Our data suggest that when [Si(OH)4] <1 µM, diatom growth limitation occurs from both extreme kinetic limitation for Si uptake and yield limitation due to the high diatom standing stock. If Si(OH)4 is growth limiting at ~1 µM, there would be sufficient [NO3 + NO2] in all data trends from the GLODAP and ICES data sets (Fig. 4C–E) to support further non-diatom primary production. Histograms demonstrate the occurrence of ≤1 µM [Si(OH)4] are frequent; thus, the regression slopes and intercepts are not driven by extrapolation or few data points. Similar trends in the relationship between [Si(OH)4] and [NO3 + NO2] have also been observed at higher latitudes (75°–85°N) in the AASP during the GEOTRACES GIPY11 cruise (July 2007; 2.9 ± 0.2 µM NO3 + NO2 remaining when Si(OH)4 depleted); this timing is consistent with the northward progression of the spring bloom in the AASP. In the southern region of our reanalysis domain in the AASP (Fig. 4B), a previous study observed mass export of diatoms due to formation of resting Chaetoceros spores, where the trigger for spore formation was coincident with a rapid drawdown of [Si(OH)4] (i.e. not full depletion), while [NO3 + NO2] was replete34. Thus, the first pulse of diatom carbon export can start prior to the maximum [Si(OH)4] depletion, i.e. prior to the onset of potentially growth limiting concentrations. This demonstrates diatom and Si(OH)4 coupling provides multiple modes of high export potential during spring bloom within the broader domain considered due to both growth limitation and settling (e.g. Thalassiosira and Bacterosira-dominated bloom here) or rapid [Si(OH)4] decline, prior to exhaustion, potentially triggering settling (e.g. Chaetoceros-dominated assemblage).
Collectively, these three independent data sets suggest that Si(OH)4 control of the spring diatom bloom is prevalent across the AASP and is consistent with some model results43. Other types of limitation for diatoms within the reanalysis data set do not appear to be as persistent. For instance, iron limitation (as observed in the Southern Ocean) would not be expected to promote full [NO3 + NO2] drawdown post bloom (Fig. 4A) and fuel the typically observed succession from diatoms to Phaeocystis and/or Micromonas spp. regionally12,15. Additionally, iron limitation increases diatom Si uptake relative to N44 and polar diatoms have higher Si:N ratios than lower-latitude diatoms16; thus, if iron limitation were the dominant factor regulating diatoms during the spring bloom we would anticipate N:Si depletion slopes (Fig. 4B–E) to be <1 instead of nearly 2.0 (i.e. N depleted twice as fast as Si).
These independent data represent a compilation by scientists from over 10 countries across a broad spatial domain (3.7 × 106 km2) spanning over 30 years. The low [Si(OH)4] condition in this region during late spring is a robust interannual trend, consistent with our dataset, and suggestive of a spatially-widespread condition when diatoms (vs. Phaeocystis) are favored to dominate the spring bloom. Clearly, under conditions when Phaeocystis are favored over diatoms, nitrate instead of Si(OH)4 will likely be depleted first. However, the annual Si(OH)4 drawdown in the GLODAP and ICES data sets corresponds well with the independent pCO2 data41 —where the strong positive correlation between pCO2 and Si(OH)4 is observed— further supporting the proposed link between diatom Si(OH)4 limitation and mass carbon export.
Silicon limitation may become more acute in the AASP. Atlantic diatoms within the 50–65°N latitude band are stimulated by increases in nutrient supply from turbulent conditions, e.g. positive phase of the North Atlantic Oscillation45. The reported decline in pre-bloom [Si(OH)4] since the early 1990s is attributed to decreased winter convection and retraction of the subpolar gyre8, and mirrors broader climatological trends reflected by a decline in the Atlantic meridional overturning circulation index during the same period46. On top of these basin-scale changes, multiannual sea-ice loss is likely to dilute Si(OH)4 pools, as concentrations are already limiting for ice diatoms47,48. Both processes, reduced physical convection and sea-ice melt, are predicted to restrict Si supply. In contrast, terrigenous freshwater discharge, with [Si(OH)4] ranging from 10–500 µM in glacial rivers, is a significant source —contributing 20 Gmol Si year−1 to Greenland coastal waters20. Indeed, increased discharge from melting of the Greenland glaciers is predicted to increase Si(OH)4 inputs into the Greenland coastal waters 20–160% by 210020. Assuming the current melt was confined to three months and flowed uniformly onto a 1.1 × 106 km2 Greenland shelf into a 5-m water column, this would input 0.04 µmol Si L−1 d−1 (Table S3). Such a Si-delivery rate corresponds represents 16–108% of our measured bSiO2 production rates (Table 1). Likewise, [Si(OH)4] reaches high levels in Siberian rivers (e.g. ≤160 µM49). Whereas sea-ice melting and reduced winter convection may make Si(OH)4 limitation more acute in the open AASP, increased discharge from the Greenland Ice Sheet and major rivers discharging may enhance the scope for diatom production later in the season at the land-sea interface if sufficient NO3 + NO2 is not consumed earlier. Understanding how diatom production will respond to such changes has broad implications for carbon sequestration and fisheries production in Greenland and the broad AASP coastal waters.
Rapid changes in the Arctic are driving efforts to model the likely future of the Arctic Ocean43. Whereas these models consider changes in ice loss, freshening, warming, nitrogen and turbidity with climate change, few include Si(OH)4 as a possible nutrient limiting diatom growth. Those models including Si suggest that spatially and temporally extensive Si(OH)4 limitation in some regions shifts the phytoplankton away from diatoms toward smaller flagellates43. Other AASP models which include Si-cycling processes50,51 lacked field data to ground truth kinetic parameters. These models used half-saturation constants for Si uptake which are 4-10-fold lower than recent field measurements12, and therefore wrongly implied that Si(OH)4 does not play an important role for regional diatoms, likely due to artificially enhancing diatoms’ efficiency for Si uptake. Whereas N likely sets the limit to total annual primary production, spring diatom productivity, which plays a significant role in net ecosystem production and driving carbon sequestration2,52, appears to be strongly controlled by Si supply. Understanding the future of the spring diatom bloom requires models that explicitly consider changes in Si supply as a driver of this key process.
Materials and Methods
Study site and timing
From 12 April to 30 May 2017, eight (~weekly) samplings were performed at station GF3 (64°07′N, 51°53′W, Fig. S4, station location also denoted in Fig. 4B) near the entrance to Godthåbsfjord. The Godthåbsfjord covers 2013 km2 (average depth of ∼250 m) with several sills located near the fjord entrance21. The sampling station is part of MarineBasis-Nuuk monitoring programme and located in the outer part of the fjord (350 m depth).
Collection and experimental design
Vertical hydrography, fluorescence and irradiance profiles between were obtained using a SeaBird 19+ CTD profiler (Sea-Bird Scientific, Washington, United States) equipped with a Seapoint (Seapoint Sensors, Inc., New Hampshire, United States) Chl a fluorometer, and Biospherical radiometer (Biospherical Instruments, Inc., California, United States), respectively. Manual sampling at 5-m depth was done using 5-L Niskin bottles secured to a line and tripped using a messenger. From the Niskin bottles, water samples were collected for inorganic nutrients, Chl a, bSiO2, diatom abundance/taxonomy and viability, and Si rate measurements (discussed below).
Two types of 48-hr laboratory experiments were conducted: a bioassay and sedimentation experiment. For the bioassay experiments, four 5-L Niskin bottles were collected, homogenized and drained into two transparent 10-L polyethylene bags. One bag was a control and the other received an addition of sodium metasilicate to increase the [Si(OH)4] by 1 μM. Samples were incubated at 1 °C in a cold room illuminated with continuous irradiance (20–70 μE m−2 s−1) for 48 hours, then sub-sampled for nutrients, bSiO2, diatom abundance, and water for additional bSiO2 production measurements (see below). For sedimentation experiments, material was collected in the euphotic zone by two vertical net tows in succession using a 15 µm net (Surface to 10 m depth interval). Additional water was collected at 5 m, using Niskin bottles, for these experiments and stored in the dark and ambient temperature until the experiment was set up. Samples were incubated at 1 °C in a cold room but covered with black cloth to force diatoms into darkness (details below).
Nutrient, particulate, diatom quantification and viability analyses
Samples were analysed using established methods. For nutrients, water was filtered (nominal pore size 0.7 µm), stored in acid-washed 30-mL plastic vials, and frozen until analysis (−18 °C). Samples for inorganic nutrients (nitrate + nitrite, orthophosphate and silicic acid, detection limits 0.10, 0.06 and 0.20 μM, respectively) where measured with flow injection on a Skalar autoanalyzer52. Triplicate samples for Chl a determination were filtered onto glass-fiber filters (≤0.3 bar), extracted immediately into 10 ml 96% ethanol for 24 hours, then quantified on a fluorometer (TD-700, Turner Designs, CA, USA) calibrated against a pure Chl a standard. Partial pressure of CO2 was measured at 5 m depth using an infrared CO2 analyser (EGM-4, PP Systems as described elsewhere53). Triplicate samples (630 mL) for particulate bSiO2 were filtered onto a 1.2 μm pore polycarbonate filter and dried at 60 °C in a cryogenic vial, sealed and stored. bSiO2 was quantified using a 0.2 normality NaOH digestion in Teflon tubes according to previous methods54. Lithogenic silica was quantified, but even assuming a liberal 15% dissolution55, did not significantly change the major bSiO2 results. Consistent with previous studies, we report bSiO2 without lithogenic correction (but corrected data available in Table S4).
The diatom community was analysed using an inverted microscope with a Sedgewick Rafter chamber; this was done for the 5-m Niskin bottle samples and a subsample of the vertical net material used for the sinking-rate experiments starting on 5 May. Subsamples for diatom counts were split into two equal volumes to quantify viability. On one split duplicated total cell counts (dead + live cells) were quantified as described above; no fixatives were used, and samples were counted immediately upon arrival back on shore (e.g. finished within ~1 hour elapsed time from return). Diatom dimensions among species were quantified, to calculate biovolumes, thereby allowing cell concentration per sample volume to be converted to summed diatom biovolume per sample volume allowing for a proxy of biomass. Diatom biovolume and elemental content (e.g. C, N, P, Si) all have been demonstrated to scale together (reviewed elsewhere16). For the second split, a cell digestion assay (CDA)56 was conducted to quantify abundance of living cells using a method optimized for work with polar phytoplankton56. Briefly, for Arctic communities, the CDA involves incubation of fresh samples at 25 °C with an enzymatic cocktail for the digestion of dead cells, i.e. those with compromised membranes. After digestion, abundances were quantified as described above (i.e. for live cells) and the dead cells were calculated by difference from the total. For total (live + dead cells —i.e. what would be quantified without the CDA) and live diatoms (determined by the CDA), the net growth rate was calculated for each species between sampling points assuming logistic growth. An aggregate net-growth rate was determined by averaging all individual species/group growth rates for each sampling point and deriving the net change between sampling points based on a logistic-growth assumption.
Diatom viability data enabled estimating the fraction of bSiO2 associated with each pool. Given the total bSiO2, we partitioned this based on the proportion of diatom biovolume which was associated with living and dead diatoms. This approach assumes a negligible effect on bSiO2 from other phytoplankton (e.g. silicoflagellates), Rhizaria (e.g. polycystine radiolaria, pheaodaria), or diatom detrital fragments. Silicoflagellates and Rhizaria were not present in microscopy samples. During the bloom initiation and building, this assumption was likely valid; however, as the bloom declined and the proportion of dead diatoms increased, there was likely increased detrital fragments present.
Biogenic silica production and kinetics
Two different experiments were conducted to assess the impact of silicon availability on diatoms. At the time of collection, the kinetics of Si(OH)4 uptake were quantified by taking ten subsamples (300 mL per sample), amending seven bottles with sodium metasilicate (three received no addition) to create a concentration gradient between ambient and +20 μM Si(OH)454. After 48-hrs in the bioassay experiment, triplicate subsamples were drawn from both the control and +Si container, then prepared for measurement of bSiO2 production. To all samples, 260 Bq of high specific activity 32Si(OH)4 (>20 kBq µmol Si−1) was added to each sample and incubated at 1 °C in a cold room illuminated with continuous irradiance (20–70 μE m−2 s−1) for 24 hours. Samples were filtered using a 1.2-μm pore size polycarbonate filter, dried in a plastic liquid scintillation vial, and aged into secular equilibrium with 32P, the daughter isotope of 32Si, for four months prior to quantification of sample activity using a liquid scintillation method54; the activity signal relative to the blank was typically a factor of 3–7 for the lowest activity samples but this increased by one or two orders of magnitude for high-activity samples (i.e. signal to noise >100). bSiO2-normalized rates assume logistic growth54. The net bSiO2 production rate was also quantified by measuring the net change in bSiO2 over 48 hours, with and without a 1-μM [Si(OH)4] amendment, compared to the bSiO2 at time of sample collection. The standard deviation (average and median coefficient of variation among all triplicates was 11% and 7%, respectively) for bSiO2 at each time point was propagated as done previously54.
Estimation of sinking rate and modal-distribution modeling
To measure diatom sinking rates during the 48-hour sedimentation experiment, we used two 1-m height, 0.1-m diameter cylindrical chambers (filled to ~5.0 L) fit with a spigot at the base for sampling. Five litres of the 5-m Niskin sample water was 5-μm filtered and added to each sedimentation chamber. Phytoplankton, which was concentrated with the 15–µm vertical net tows (0–10 m), was gently added at the top of the chamber. An initial subsample was taken to quantify the live vs. dead fraction. Sedimentation chambers were kept in darkness and 200 mL of water was subsampled through the spigot at each time point (2, 6, 10–16, 24 and 48 h). The subsample was concentrated by inverted filtration to a final volume of 10 mL, this volume was then split to quantify total diatoms and living diatoms as discussed above.
Through time, sedimentation rates were determined using a modal-distribution approach, i.e. a conservative approach which is based on observation of quantifying the time point when the highest proportion of cells had settled the vertical height of the chamber. The experimental set-up allowed to resolve sinking rates within the range 0.30 to 8.78 m d−1. Cells sinking faster than 8.78 m d−1 would have reached the bottom of the chamber before 2 h (first sampling point) and cells sinking slower than 0.30 m d−1 would remain in suspension at final sampling time. Sinking cells for any one species and viability status were generally observed to have reached the bottom of the sedimentation chamber at more than one sampling time, indicating that cells within the population exhibited a range of sinking velocities. This observed distribution would be characterized by a modal velocity, i.e. the sedimentation rate most cells exhibited. The distribution of sedimentation rates is reflected in the distribution of cells added to the chamber retrieved at different sampling times.
The modal sedimentation rate for any one species and viability was inferred from the time-series of the cell population retrieved at different sampling times (Fig. S5). We first assigned the modal sedimentation time for a given taxa and viability as corresponding to the time at which the highest cumulative number of cells were retrieved (Fig. S5, e.g. 16 hours in panel B). Once that time was known, we estimated the modal sedimentation rate, which was based on our chamber dimensions, graphically displayed in Fig. S5A, where the minimum and maximum rates constrained by the range that could be resolved by the experimental set up (0.30 to 8.78 m d−1) —this was due to the chamber height and the sampling time points. These modal sedimentation rates are conservative (Table S2); as the sedimentation rate for cells retrieved at the sampling yielding the highest fraction of cells (tx, e.g. 16 hours in Fig. S5B) would corresponding to cells reaching the bottom of the chamber between times tx−1 and tx (e.g. between 6–16 hours, Fig. S5B).
We used non-parametric statistical tests. A two-tailed Mann-Whitney U test was conducted to examine whether significant differences in sedimentation data were observed between living and dead species when all experiment dates and species were pooled. To evaluate whether significant differences in living and dead diatom sedimentation rates were driven by variability among sample dates, a non-parametric one-way ANOVA (Kruskal-Wallis test) was run for both living and dead cells with time. Additionally, a two-tail non-parametric Spearman Rho test was run to examine correlations among sedimentation and diatom net growth rates, along with the trends in the historical data sets between pCO2, Si(OH)4, and NO3 + NO2. Model-II reduced major axis linear regression analyses were used to compare Si(OH)4, and NO3 + NO2 drawdown for this and previous data sets.
The original data can be found in the Figures, Tables, and Supplementary Information or are available upon request. Time-series data at station GF3 in Godthåbsfjord are available through the Greenland Ecosystem Monitoring Database (data.g-e-m.dk). GLODAP data are available as an oceanographic dataset in Ocean Data View (created by R. Schlitzer, odv.awi.de). ICES Oceanographic data are also freely accessible (ocean.ices.dk). Gridded pCO2 and associated nutrient data are also freely accessible and available through Columbia University (ldeo.columbia.edu/res/pi/CO2/carbondioxide/pages/global_ph.html).
Tremblay, J.-E., Michel, C., Hobson, K. A., Gosselin, M. & Price, N. M. Bloom dynamics in early opening waters of the Arctic Ocean. Limnology and Oceanography 51, 900–912 (2006).
Vaquer-Sunyer, R. et al. Seasonal patterns in Arctic planktonic metabolism (Fram Strait-Svalbard region). Biogeosciences 10, 1451–1469, https://doi.org/10.5194/bg-10-1451-2013 (2013).
Klein, B. et al. Phytoplankton biomass, production and potential export in the North Water. Deep Sea Research Part II: Topical Studies in Oceanography 49, 4983–5002 (2002).
Smith, W. O. & Asper, V. L. The influence of phytoplankton assemblage composition on biogeochemical characteristics and cycles in the southern Ross Sea, Antarctica. Deep Sea Research Part I: Oceanographic Research Papers 48, 137–161 (2001).
Tremblay, J.-E., Gratton, Y., Fauchot, J. & Price, N. M. Climatic and oceanic forcing of new, net, and diatom production in the North Water. Deep Sea Research Part II: Topical Studies in Oceanography 49, 4927–4946 (2002).
Rat’kova, T. N. & Wassmann, P. Seasonal variation and spatial distribution of phyto-and protozooplankton in the central Barents Sea. Journal of Marine Systems 38, 47–75 (2002).
Rey, F. Declining silicate concentrations in the Norwegian and Barents Seas. ICES Journal of Marine Science 69, 208–212 (2012).
Hátún, H. et al. The subpolar gyre regulates silicate concentrations in the North Atlantic. Scientific reports 7, 14576 (2017).
Egge, J. & Aksnes, D. Silicate as regulating nutrient in phytoplankton competition. Marine Ecology Progress Series 83, 281–289 (1992).
Pacariz, S. V. et al. Nutrient-driven poleward expansion of the Northeast Atlantic mackerel (Scomber scombrus) stock: A new hypothesis. Elem Sci Anth 4 (2016).
Brown, L., Sanders, R., Savidge, G. & Lucas, C. H. The uptake of silica during the spring bloom in the Northeast Atlantic Ocean. Limnology and Oceanography 48, 1831–1845 (2003).
Krause, J. W. et al. Biogenic silica production and diatom dynamics in the Svalbard region during spring. Biogeosciences 15, 6503–6517, https://doi.org/10.5194/bg-15-6503-2018 (2018).
Bienfang, P. & Szyper, J. Effects of temperature and salinity on sinking rates of the centric diatom Ditylum brightwelli. Biological Oceanography 1, 211–223 (1982).
Gemmell, B. J., Oh, G., Buskey, E. J. & Villareal, T. A. Dynamic sinking behaviour in marine phytoplankton: rapid changes in buoyancy may aid in nutrient uptake. Proc. R. Soc. B 283, 20161126, https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2016.1126 (2016).
Agustí, S. et al. Arctic (Svalbard Islands) Active and Exported Diatom Stocks and Cell Health Status. Biogeosciences Discussions, https://doi.org/10.5194/bg-2018-459 (2018).
Lomas, M. W., Baer, S. E., Acton, S. & Krause, J. W. Pumped up by the Cold: Elemental Quotas and Stoichiometry of Polar Diatoms. Frontiers in Marine Science, https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2019.00197 (2019).
Tréguer, P. et al. Influence of diatom diversity on the ocean biological carbon pump. Nature Geoscience 11, 27 (2018).
Miklasz, K. A. & Denny, M. W. Diatom sinkings speeds: Improved predictions and insight from a modified Stokes’ law. Limnology and Oceanography 55, 2513–2525 (2010).
Moriceau, B. et al. Copepods Boost the Production but Reduce the Carbon Export Efficiency by Diatoms. Frontiers in Marine Science 5, 82 (2018).
Meire, L. et al. High export of dissolved silica from the Greenland Ice Sheet. Geophysical Research Letters 43, 9173–9182 (2016).
Juul-Pedersen, T. et al. Seasonal and interannual phytoplankton production in a sub-Arctic tidewater outlet glacier fjord, SW Greenland. Marine Ecology Progress Series 524, 27–38 (2015).
Rysgaard, S. et al. High air–sea CO2 uptake rates in nearshore and shelf areas of Southern Greenland: Temporal and spatial variability. Mar. Chem. 128, 26–33 (2012).
Krause, J. W., Brzezinski, M. A., Villareal, T. A. & Wilson, C. Increased kinetic efficiency for silicic acid uptake as a driver of summer diatom blooms in the North Pacific Subtropical Gyre. Limnology and Oceanography 57, 1084–1098, https://doi.org/10.4319/lo.2012.57.4.1084 (2012).
Brzezinski, M. A. & Nelson, D. M. Chronic substrate limitation of silicic acid uptake rates in the western Sargasso Sea. Deep-Sea. Research II 43, 437–453 (1996).
Thamatrakoln, K. & Hildebrand, M. Silicon uptake in diatoms revisited: A model for saturable and nonsaturable uptake kinetics and the role of silicon transporters. Plant Physiol. 146, 1397–1407, https://doi.org/10.1104/pp.107.10704 (2008).
Nelson, D. M. & Goering, J. J. Near-surface silica dissolution in the upwelling region off northwest Africa. Deep-Sea Research 24, 65–73 (1977).
Brzezinski, M. A., Jones, J. L., Bidle, K. D. & Azam, F. The balance between silica production and silica dissolution in the sea: Insights from Monterey Bay, California, applied to the global data set. Limnology and Oceanography 48, 1846–1854 (2003).
Demarest, M. S., Brzezinski, M. A. & Beucher, C. P. Fractionation of silicon isotopes during biogenic silica dissolution. Geochimica Et Cosmochimica Acta 73, 5572–5583, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gca.2009.06.019 (2009).
Kamatani, A., Riley, J. P. & Skirrow, G. The dissolution of opaline silica of diatom tests in sea water. Journal of the Oceanographical Society of Japan 36, 201–208 (1980).
Bidle, K. D., Manganelli, M. & Azam, F. Regulation of oceanic silicon and carbon preservation by temperature control on bacteria. Science 298, 1980–1984 (2002).
Bienfang, P. K. & Harrison, P. J. Sinking-rate response of natural assemblages of temperate and sub-tropical phytoplankton to nutrient depletion. Marine Biology 83, 293–300 (1984).
Bidle, K. D. & Falkowski, P. G. Cell death in planktonic, photosynthetic microorganisms. Nature Reviews Microbiology 2, 643, https://doi.org/10.1038/nrmicro956 (2004).
Timmermans, K. R., Veldhuis, M. J. & Brussaard, C. P. Cell death in three marine diatom species in response to different irradiance levels, silicate, or iron concentrations. Aquatic microbial ecology 46, 253–261 (2007).
Rynearson, T. et al. Major contribution of diatom resting spores to vertical flux in the sub-polar North Atlantic. Deep Sea Research Part I: Oceanographic Research Papers 82, 60–71 (2013).
Armbrecht, L. H., Smetacek, V., Assmy, P. & Klaas, C. Cell death and aggregate formation in the giant diatom Coscinodiscus wailesii (Gran & Angst, 1931). Journal of experimental marine biology and ecology 452, 31–39, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jembe.2013.12.004 (2014).
Passow, U. Transparent exopolymer particles (TEP) in aquatic environments. Progress in oceanography 55, 287–333, https://doi.org/10.1016/S0079-6611(02)00138-6 (2002).
Lund, J. Studies on Asterionella formosa hass: II. Nutrient depletion and the spring maximum. The Journal of Ecology, 15–35 (1950).
Allen, J. T. et al. Diatom carbon export enhanced by silicate upwelling in the northeast Atlantic. Nature 437, 728 (2005).
Smayda, T. J. Normal and accelerated sinking of phytoplankton in the sea. Marine Geology 11, 105–122 (1971).
Harrison, P. J., Conway, H. L., Holmes, R. W. & Davis, C. O. Marine diatoms grown in chemostats under silicate or ammonium limitation. III. Cellular chemical composition and morphology of Chaetoceros debilis, Skeletonema costatum, and Thalassiosira gravida. Marine Biology 43, 19–31 (1977).
Takahashi, T. et al. Climatological distributions of pH, pCO2, total CO2, alkalinity, and CaCO3 saturation in the global surface ocean, and temporal changes at selected locations. Mar. Chem. 164, 95–125 (2014).
Holding, J. et al. Temperature dependence of CO2-enhanced primary production in the European Arctic Ocean. Nature Climate Change (2015).
Popova, E. et al. Control of primary production in the Arctic by nutrients and light: insights from a high resolution ocean general circulation model. Biogeosciences 7, 3569–3591 (2010).
Brzezinski, M. A. et al. Variable influence of iron stress on siliceous biomass and silica production and silicon and carbon export in a frontal zone within the California Current. Journal of Geophysical Research: Oceans, https://doi.org/10.1002/2015JC010829 (2015).
Alvain, S. et al. Rapid climatic driven shifts of diatoms at high latitudes. Remote Sensing of Environment 132, 195–201 (2013).
Delworth, T. L. et al. The North Atlantic Oscillation as a driver of rapid climate change in the Northern Hemisphere. Nature Geoscience 9, 509 (2016).
Smith, R. E., Harrison, W. G., Harris, L. R. & Herman, A. W. Vertical fine structure of particulate matter and nutrients in sea ice of the high Arctic. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 47, 1348–1355 (1990).
Cota, G. F., Anning, J. L., Harris, L. R., Harrison, W. G. & Smith, R. E. Impact of ice algae on inorganic nutrients in seawater and sea ice in Barrow Strait, NWT, Canada, during spring. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 47, 1402–1415 (1990).
Pivovarov, S., Hölemann, J., Kassens, H., Antonow, M. & Dmitrenko, I. in Land-Ocean Systems in the Siberian Arctic 251–264 (Springer, 1999).
Slagstad, D. & Støle‐Hansen, K. Dynamics of plankton growth in the Barents Sea: model studies. Polar Research 10, 173–186 (1991).
Wassmann, P., Slagstad, D., Riser, C. W. & Reigstad, M. Modelling the ecosystem dynamics of the Barents Sea including the marginal ice zone: II. Carbon flux and interannual variability. Journal of Marine Systems 59, 1–24 (2006).
Sejr, M. K. et al. Seasonal dynamics of autotrophic and heterotrophic plankton metabolism and pCO2 in a subarctic Greenland fjord. Limnology and Oceanography 59, 1764–1778 (2014).
Sejr, M. K. et al. Air–sea flux of CO2 in arctic coastal waters influenced by glacial melt water and sea ice. Tellus B 63, 815–822 (2011).
Krause, J. W., Nelson, D. M. & Lomas, M. W. Production, dissolution, accumulation and potential export of biogenic silica in a Sargasso Sea mode-water eddy. Limnology and Oceanography 55, 569–579, https://doi.org/10.4319/lo.2010.55.2.0569 (2010).
Ragueneau, O. & Tréguer, P. Determination of biogenic silica in coastal waters - applicability and limits of the alkaline digestion method. Mar. Chem. 45, 43–51, https://doi.org/10.1016/0304-4203(94)90090-6 (1994).
Llabrés, M. & Agustí, S. Extending the cell digestion assay to quantify dead phytoplankton cells in cold and polar waters. . Limnology and Oceanography: Methods 6, 659–666 (2008).
Funding was provided by the Dauphin Island Sea Lab and King Abdullah University of Science & Technology (KAUST) to J.K. and S.A., respectively. We thank S. Acton, I. Marquez, R. Pickering, D. Wiik and Greenland Institute of Natural Resources for logistical support. M.K.S was supported by INTAROS funded by the EU H2020. Data from the Greenland Ecosystem Monitoring Programme were provided by the Greenland Institute of Natural Resources, Nuuk, Greenland in collaboration with Department of Bioscience, Aarhus University, Denmark
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Krause, J.W., Schulz, I.K., Rowe, K.A. et al. Silicic acid limitation drives bloom termination and potential carbon sequestration in an Arctic bloom. Sci Rep 9, 8149 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-44587-4
This article is cited by
Interlinking diatom frustule diversity from the abyss of the central Arabian Sea to surface processes: physical forcing and oxygen minimum zone
Environmental Monitoring and Assessment (2023)
Phytoplankton community shift in response to experimental Cu addition at the elevated CO2 levels (Arabian Sea, winter monsoon)
Environmental Science and Pollution Research (2023)
Phytoplankton growth and community shift over a short-term high-CO2 simulation experiment from the southwestern shelf of India, Eastern Arabian Sea (summer monsoon)
Environmental Monitoring and Assessment (2022)