Gadolinium-based contrast agents (GBCAs), routinely used in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), end up directly in coastal seawaters where gadolinium concentrations are now increasing. Because many aquatic species could be sensitive to this new pollution, we have evaluated the possibility of using shellfish to assess its importance. Gadolinium excesses recorded by scallop shells collected in Bay of Brest (Brittany, France) for more than 30 years do not reflect the overall consumption in GBCAs, but are largely controlled by one of them, the gadopentetate dimeglumine. Although its use has been greatly reduced in Europe over the last ten years, gadolinium excesses are still measured in shells. Thus, some gadolinium derived from other GBCAs is bioavailable and could have an impact on marine wildlife.
For thirty years now, linear or macrocyclic gadolinium-based contrast agents (GBCAs) are routinely used in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)1. They were initially assumed to have virtually no side effects, but gadolinium can accumulate in tissue, bone and brain2,3,4. Moreover, linear GBCAs cause nephrogenic systemic fibrosis, a debilitating and potentially life-threatening disease, for patients with kidney failure5,6. Thus, the use of some linear GBCAs has been reduced over the last decade, and recently banned in Europe7. As GBCAs are not recovered during wastewater treatment, more than 200 tons of anthropogenic gadolinium are conveyed each year by rivers of developed and densely populated areas, and end up directly in coastal seawaters where gadolinium concentrations, still low, are now increasing8,9,10,11,12. Aquatic species are sensitive to this new pollution: for example, gadolinium accumulates in the livers of fish and induces antioxidant enzyme productions13; in presence of gadolinium, larvae of sea urchins display abnormal shapes and growth14; gadolinium exposure produces mitochondrial and anti-inflammatory pathways in freshwater mussels15.
The incorporation of anthropogenic gadolinium by shellfish is evidenced by their Rare Earth Elements (REE) patterns. Unlike cerium which has two valence states in aqueous systems, and is easily decoupled from lanthanum and praseodymium, its neighbouring REEs, gadolinium has only one trivalent valence state, and cannot be easily decoupled from other rare earth elements by natural processes. Thus rocks and unpolluted waters do not show any large anomalies in gadolinium. Some mollusc shells from densely populated coastal areas such as Tokyo Bay16 or the southern North Sea17 now display positive gadolinium anomalies explained by pollution. Similar anomalies are also measured in shells from the Canary Islands and the French coasts, showing that this pollution affects vast regions (Fig. 1). Consequently, coastal shellfish could represent valuable archives of this pollution. Among non-motile shellfish, the great scallop (Pecten maximus) could be considered as a fixed sensor recording environmental variations because of its longevity (up to 12 years), high growth rate of its shells (up to 350–400 µm/day during growing phase) and production of both seasonal and daily growth bands18. We have studied a collection of wild great scallops collected alive during the last thirty years at the same sampling site of Bay of Brest at a mean depth of 20 m (Supplementary Fig. 1). All these scallops were fished in late fall and were between 3 and 4 years old (estimated with winter marks, see Fig. S2). Their sizes ranged from 8 to 10 cm. We analysed fragments of their left valves, corresponding to the carbonate formed since the winter preceding their catch.
Results and Discussion
The abundances of REEs in shells Fig. 2 and Supplementary Table 2) are low and highly variable: they range between 6 × 10−5 and 3 × 10−3 times the shale reference19. The shapes of the REE patterns are similar to those of other coastal shellfish (e.g., Fig. 1), with variable negative cerium anomalies (Ce/Ce* = 0.65–1.33, see Methods for the calculations of REE anomalies). In bivalves, shells result from the activity of the mantle epithelium inside specific internal liquid20. Their components are derived from organic matter, inorganic particles and water that have been assimilated by the mollusks16. Thus, their REE patterns are different from those of local seawater21, with less marked LREE depletions relative to shales. Furthermore, they display small but significant positive gadolinium anomalies (Gd/Gd* = 1.00–1.50, Fig. 3), which indicate that shells incorporated small amounts of anthropogenic gadolinium.
The gadolinium anomalies (Gd/Gd*) in scallop shells do not show a clear temporal evolution (Fig. 3). Since shells have very different levels of REE concentrations, a given amount of anthropogenic gadolinium can result in very different Gd/Gd* ratios in carbonates. To reduce this effect, we estimated the gadolinium excess in each sample using the difference between the measured gadolinium concentration and the interpolated one (ΔGd = Gd − Gd*). These excesses in scallop shells (ΔGd = 0–2.3 ng/g) display a complex temporal evolution (Fig. 3b). The oldest sample collected in 1960, before the use of GBCAs, does not show any significant excess in gadolinium. A marked increase in gadolinium excesses is seen from 1989 to 2005, followed by a sharp decline until 2010 when normal levels are observed again. Afterwards, the excesses seem to increase again without reaching the 2005 maximum, but the data show some spread. Such an evolution is unexpected because the use of GBCAs has always been increasing since their introduction on the market. It could depend on the bioavailability of anthropogenic gadolinium as determined by its speciation in seawater.
Over the last thirty years, various GBCAs have been used. Their behaviours in seawater could be very different. The quantities of GBCAs produced by the different pharmaceutical companies and distributed each year in the different regions of the world are not in the public domain. However, these figures can be deduced for the French market: GBCAs can only be issued upon the prescription of a health care professional, dispensed by a licensed pharmacist, and are reimbursed by the Caisse Primaire d’Assurance Maladie (CPAM), the French health insurance agency. We used the CPAM database22 to assess the number of reimbursed boxes of referenced GBCAs each year since 2001. These data are not available for years before 2001, and we interpolated previous consumption using marketing authorisation dates. Although some prescriptions may have escaped this database, it provides a reliable picture of annual consumption of GBCAs and the relative importance of the different molecules (Fig. 3c,d). Prior to 2007, three GBCAs were mainly used in France: one macrocyclic, the gadoterate meglumine, and two linear GBCAs, the gadopentetate dimeglumine and the gadodiamide. When the link between nephrogenic systemic fibrosis and the administration of linear GBCAs was suspected around 20055,6, the prescriptions of some of them were considerably reduced, notably the gadopentetate dimeglumine. The sudden reduction of the gadolinium excesses in the shells is consistent with the abandonment of this agent. However, an apparent discrepancy between the decrease in French consumption of this agent (in 2007) and that of the Gd excesses recorded by the shells (in 2005) should be noted: prescribers in Western Brittany could have chosen another contrast agent as soon as 2005, either in accordance with a precautionary principle or due to supply or cost constraints. The available archives do not allow for a more detailed discussion of this point which should therefore not be overemphasized. Today, gadolinium consumption by MRI in France is three times that of 2005, but the magnitude of this increase is not recorded by scallop shells (Fig. 3). This could suggest that the bioavailability of anthropogenic gadolinium currently present in coastal areas is low.
GBCAs are very stable in fresh water. Anthropogenic gadolinium seems not to be very reactive and can be used as a useful tracer of the effluents of water-waste treatment plants23. Its bioavailability is apparently low. Accumulations of gadolinium have been detected in digestive glands and gills of a few fresh water bivalves24, but their shells do not show noticeable positive gadolinium anomalies25, suggesting that the GBCA molecules have been degraded little or not at all by these molluscs. The situation is different in the sea, but few data exist on the stability of GBCAs in marine waters. At present, only gadopentetate dimeglumine has been studied in depth26. This contrast agent is substantially dissociated upon mixing of river water with seawater in estuaries. Once these molecules are degraded, the gadolinium associated with them can become bioavailable and possibly toxic. This explains the incorporation of anthropogenic gadolinium by scallop shells seen until 2005–2006. The lack of a clear correlation between the gadolinium excesses recorded by the shells and the consumption of the other GBCAs from 2010 to today (Fig. 3) could suggest that the latter, particularly the macrocyclic GBCAs that are currently the most used, are extremely stable in seawater. However, although the use of linear GBCAs is now marginal in France (10% of gadolinium used in MRI was in the form of linear GBCAs in 2017), gadolinium excesses are still measured in shellfish (Figs 1 and 3). Two hypotheses can explain this observation: 1/part of the gadolinium derived from the degradation of linear GBCAs was adsorbed by sediments (clays, iron oxyhydroxides…) before 2005, and is now released; 2/ most of the bioavailable anthropogenic gadolinium still derives today from the destabilization of linear GBCAs, namely gadobenate dimeglumine which was seldom used before 2010, or from macrocyclic GBCAs, the degradation of which is probably much slower in the marine environment than that of gadopentetate dimeglumine. The first hypothesis is unlikely because anthropogenic gadolinium is apparently not affected by any kind of estuarine scavenging9,10. Accurate REE analyses on other types of organisms must, of course, be carried out in order to have a more complete view of gadolinium pollution on marine wildlife. However, it is urgent to determine the stability in seawater of the GBCAs currently used, particularly for the most widely used macrocyclic GBCAs such as gadoterate meglumine, gadobutrol and gadoteridol. As the world consumption of these molecules is increasing, these data are essential to predict the consequences of gadolinium pollution in coastal environments and possibly develop water treatment processes.
For each sample, about 100 mg of carbonates were spiked with a solution of pure Tm and dissolved in HNO3 in a Teflon beaker. REE have been separated from the major elements and concentrated before analysis27. Abundances were determined using a high-resolution inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometer Thermo Element HR at Institut Universitaire Européen de la Mer (IUEM), Plouzané, France. Each sample was analysed in duplicate or in triplicate, and the results were averaged28. Results on a carbonate standard obtained during the sessions are given in Supplementary Information.
The Gd anomalies are calculated using the Gd/Gd* ratio, where Gd* is the interpolated Gd concentration for a smooth Post Archean Australian Shale-normalized REE pattern and Xn is the concentration of element X normalised to PAAS:
The gadolinium excesses are simply given by the following equation:
Based on standards and sample replicates, the precisions for abundances and element ratios (including Gd/Gd* ratios) are in most cases much better than 5% (2 RSD) (see Supplementary Information). Typical errors for Gadolinium excesses in shells are assumed to be about 0.25 ng/g (2 σ).
All data is available in the main text or the Supplementary Materials.
Ramalho, J. et al. Gadolinium-based contrast agent accumulation and toxicity: an update. American J. Neuroradiol. 37, 1192–1198 (2016).
Sato, T. et al. Tissue gadolinium deposition in renally impaired rats exposed to different gadolinium-based MRI contrast agents: evaluation with inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS). Magn. Reson. Imaging. 31, 1412–1417 (2013).
Darrah, T. H. et al. Incorporation of excess gadolinium into human bone from medical contrast agents. Metallomics 1, 479–488 (2009).
McDonald, R. J. et al. Intracranial gadolinium deposition after contrast-enhanced MR imaging. Radiology 275, 772–82 (2015).
Grobner, T. Gadolinium: a specific trigger for the development of nephrogenic fibrosing dermopathy and nephrogenic systemic fibrosis? Nephrol Dial Transplant 21, 1104–1108 (2005).
Marckmann, P. Nephrogenic systemic fibrosis: suspected causative role of gadodiamide used for contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging. J Am Soc Nephrol 17, 2359–2362 (2006).
European Medicines Agency. 23/11/2017. Available from, http://www.ema.europa.eu/docs/en_GB/dovument_library/Referrals_document/gadolinium_contrast_agents_31/European_Commission_final_decision/WC500240575.pdf.
Bau, M. & Dulski, P. Anthropogenic origin of positive gadolinium anomalies in river waters. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 143, 245–255 (1996).
Nozaki, Y., Lerche, D., Alibo, D. S. & Snidvongs, A. The estuarine geochemistry of rare earth elements and indium in the Chao Phraya River, Thailand. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 64, 3983–3994 (2000).
Kulaksiz, S. & Bau, M. Contrasting behaviour of anthropogenic gadolinium and natural rare earth elements in estuaries and the gadolinium input into the North Sea. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 260, 361–371 (2007).
Hatje, V., Bruland, K. W. & Flegal, A. R. Increases in anthropogenic gadolinium anomalies and rare earth element concentrations in San Francisco Bay over a 20 years record. Environmental science & technology 50, 4159–4168 (2016).
Cyris, M. Behavior of gadolinium-based diagnostics in water treatment. PhD thesis. Institut für Instrumentelle Analytische Chemie der Universität Duisburg-Essen, Essen, Germany (2013).
Chen, Y., Cao, X. D., Lu, Y. & Wang, X. R. Effects of rare earth metal ions and their EDTA complexes on antioxidant enzymes of fish liver. Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 65, 357e365 (2000).
Martino, C. et al. Gadolinium perturbs expression of skeletogenic genes, calcium uptake and larval development in phylogenetically distant sea urchin species. Aquatic Toxicology 194, 57–66 (2018).
Hanana, H., Turcotte, P., André, C., Gagnon, C. & Gagné, F. Comparative study of the effects of gadolinium chloride and gadolinium-based magnetic resonance imaging contrast agent on freshwater mussel, Dreissena polymorpha. Chemosphere 181, 197–207 (2017).
Akagi, T. & Edanami, K. Sources of rare earth elements in shells and soft-tissues of bivalves from Tokyo Bay. Marine Chem. 194, 55–62 (2017).
Ponnurangam, A., Bau, M., Brenner, M. & Kochinsky, A. Mussel shells of Mytilus edulis as bioarchives of the distribution of rare earth elements and yttrium in seawater and the potential impact of pH and temperature on their partitioning behavior. Biogeosciences 13, 751–760 (2016).
Chauvaud, L. et al. Shell of the Great Scallop Pecten maximus as a high-frequency archive of paleoenvironmental changes. Geochem. Geophys. Geosyst. 6, Q08001 (2005).
Pourmand, A., Dauphas, N. & Ireland, T. J. A novel extraction chromatography and MC-ICP-MS technique for rapid analysis of REE, Sc and Y: Revising CI-chondrite and Post-Archean Australian Shale (PAAS) abundances. Chem. Geol. 291, 38–54 (2012).
Wheeler, A. P. Mechanisms of molluscan shell formation. E. Bonucci (ed.), Calcification in biological systems, CRC press, Boca Raton, FL, 179–226 (1992).
Freslon, N., Bayon, G., Birot, D., Bollinger, C. & Barrat, J. A. Determination of rare earth elements and other trace elements (Y, Mn, Co, Cr) in seawater using Tm addition and Mg (OH)2 coprecipitation. Talanta 85, 582–587 (2011).
Medic’AM database (2018) maintained by the Sécurité Sociale, available from, https://ameli.fr/l-assurance-maladie/statistiques-et-publications/donnees-statistiques/medicament/medic-am/medic-am-mensuel-2018.php.
Möller, P., Dulski, P., Bau, M., Knappe, A. & Pekdeger, A. and Sommer-von Jarmersted, C. Anthropogenic gadolinium as a conservative tracer in hydrology. J. Geochem. Explo. 69, 409–414 (2000).
Perrat, E., Parant, M., Py, J. S., Rosin, C. & Cossu-Leguille, C. Bioaccumulation of gadolinium in freshwater bivalves. Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res. 24, 12405–12415 (2017).
Merschel, G. & Bau, M. Rare earth elements in the aragonitic shell of freshwater mussel Corbicula fluminea and the bioavailability of anthropogenic lanthanum, samarium and gadolinium in river water. Sci. Total Environ. 533, 91–101 (2015).
Schijf, J. & Christy, I. J. Effect of Mg and Ca on the stability of the MRI contrast agent Gd–DTPA in seawater. Frontiers in Marine Science 5, 111 (2018).
Barrat, J.-A. et al. Determination of rare earth elements in sixteen silicate reference samples by ICP-MS after Tm addition and ion exchange separation. Geostandards Newsletter 20, 133–139 (1996).
Barrat, J.-A. et al. Evidence from Tm anomalies for non-CI refractory lithophile element proportions in terrestrial planets and achondrites. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 176, 1–17 (2016).
We are grateful to Sebastien Seuron for his help with gadolinium consumption data, to Richard Greenwood (Open University) and Michel Rafini (UBO) for discussions and grammatical corrections, and to Jean-Charles Larsonneur for stimulating discussions. This work was supported by the “Laboratoire d’Excellence” LabexMER (ANR-10-LABX-19) and co-funded by grants from the French Government under the program “Investissements d’Avenir”.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Le Goff, S., Barrat, JA., Chauvaud, L. et al. Compound-specific recording of gadolinium pollution in coastal waters by great scallops. Sci Rep 9, 8015 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-44539-y
Competition Among Trivalent Elements (Al, Eu, Fe, Gd, Nd, Tm, and Y) for Uptake in Algae and Applicability of the Biotic Ligand Model
Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology (2021)