Cryptococcosis is a major opportunistic infection and is one of the leading causes of death in adults living with HIV in sub-Saharan Africa. Recent estimates indicate that more than 130,000 people may die annually of cryptococcal meningitis in this region. Although complete diagnostic autopsy (CDA) is considered the gold standard for determining the cause of death, it is seldom performed in low income settings. In this study, a CDA was performed in 284 deceased patients from Mozambique (n = 223) and Brazil (n = 61). In depth histopathological and microbiological analyses were carried out in all cases dying of cryptococcosis. We determined the cryptococcal species, the molecular and sero-mating types and antifungal susceptibility. We also described the organs affected and reviewed the clinical presentation and patient management. Among the 284 cases included, 17 fatal cryptococcal infections were diagnosed. Cryptococcus was responsible for 16 deaths among the 163 HIV-positive patients (10%; 95%CI: 6–15%), including four maternal deaths. One third of the cases corresponded to C. gattii (VGI and VGIV molecular types, Bα and Cα strains) and the remaining infections typed were caused by C. neoformans var. Grubii (all VNI and Aα strains). The level of pre-mortem clinical suspicion was low (7/17, 41%), and 7/17 patients (41%) died within the first 72 hours of admission. Cryptococcosis was responsible for a significant proportion of AIDS-related mortality. The clinical diagnosis and patient management were inadequate, supporting the need for cryptococcal screening for early detection of the disease. This is the first report of the presence of C. gattii infection in Mozambique.
Cryptococcosis is the leading cause of meningitis in adults living with HIV in sub-Saharan Africa1,2. In 2008, the number of cryptococcal meningitis (CM) cases in this region was estimated to be 720,000 (range 144,000–1.3 million)3. Recent estimates from 2014 indicate that over 160,000 (95%CI 113,600–193,900) cases of CM, including more than 130,000 deaths occurred in sub-Saharan Africa4. This significant decrease in the absolute number of cases from 2008 to 2014 seems to be related to the scale-up of effective antiretroviral therapy (ART)5. However, the proportion of AIDS-related deaths due to Cryptococcus remains similar (around 15%), representing the second most common cause of AIDS-related mortality in adults, after tuberculosis4. Cryptococcal infection is believed to be acquired by inhalation of fungal cells from the environment. In immunocompetent hosts, the pathogen can be cleared or establish a latent infection6. In immunocompromised patients, Cryptococcus may induce pneumonia and its dissemination to the central nervous system (CNS) causes meningitis, the most severe form of the infection, which is fatal without appropriate treatment. In low income countries, the one-year mortality of CM, even in HIV-infected patients in care, has been estimated to be as high as 70%4.
Human cryptococcal infections were traditionally attributed to Cryptococcus neoformans until Cryptococcus gattii was classified as a distinct species by molecular methods in 20027. Cryptococcus gattii is further divided into four molecular types (variety gattii; VGI-VGIV) and little is known about C.gatti infections in Africa, where this pathogen has been isolated from both clinical and environmental samples8. Most VGIV strains have been described in the southern part of Africa, whereas VGI and VGII strains have been reported in central Africa8. C. gattii infections were thought to occur mainly in the tropics9 until 2004, when an outbreak of C. gattii in North America was recognized10. This outbreak was caused by VGII strains and included the emergence of hypervirulent variants11. Current knowledge on the epidemiology and clinical presentation of C. neoformans infection is clearly greater than that related to C. gattii. C. neoformans infections occur predominantly in people infected with HIV or with other immunocompromising conditions, whereas C. gattii infections have been mainly described in apparently immunocompetent patients9. Autopsy findings reveal that the CNS and the lungs are the organs most frequently affected in disseminated infections12,13, which may also affect multiple organs, especially in HIV-infected patients14. However, reported autopsy series do not usually include cryptococcal species identification, and therefore, knowledge regarding the histopathology of C. gattii remains limited.
In the present study, we determined the Cryptococcus-associated mortality of a series of 284 autopsies performed in two hospitals located in high prevalence HIV areas, Mozambique in sub-Saharan Africa and the Brazilian Amazonia. We also analysed the clinical presentation, management, and histopathological and microbiological findings of 17 cases of fatal cryptococcal infection.
Study setting and design
An observational study was performed at the Department of Pathology of the Maputo Central Hospital in Maputo, Mozambique and at the Fundação de Medicina Tropical Doutor Heitor Vieira Dourado, in Manaus, Western Brazilian Amazon. The study was approved by the Comissão Nacional de Ética em Pesquisa - CONEP (Brazil; Ref. 1.074.304), the Clinical Research Ethics Committee of the Hospital Clinic of Barcelona (Spain; File 2013/8677) and National Bioethics Committee of Mozambique (Mozambique; Ref. 342/CNBS/13), which deemed verbal consent sufficient in this study. All research was performed in accordance with guidelines and regulations of the Montreal Statement on Research Integrity in Cross-Boundary Research Collaborations, and the Singapore Statement on Research Integrity.
From November 2013 to March 2015, complete diagnostic autopsies (CDAs) were performed in 284 deceased patients in the two study sites. Two hundred twenty-three cases were recruited from Mozambique: 169 were adults over 15 years of age (112 women, 57 of whom were maternal deaths, i. e., women dying during pregnancy, partum, post-partum or within 42 days of termination of pregnancy15), and 54 were children from 1 month to 15 years of age (37 males and 17 females). Sixty-one cases were recruited from Brazil: 59 adults (38 males and 21 females, including one maternal death) and two children. A description of the study design and inclusion criteria for the cases has been published elsewhere16,17,18. All cases fulfilling the inclusion criteria were included in the study; these were (1) a CDA requested by the clinician as part of the medical evaluation of the patient and; (2) a verbal informed consent to perform the autopsy given by the relatives. Traumatic deaths were excluded. A member of the study staff was tasked with liaising with the families in cases of deaths occurring in the pediatric department, but only after the clinicians had asked for consent for postmortem examination17. All the clinical records available regarding admission preceding death of each patient were reviewed and the clinical data were collected in a standardized manner.
Autopsy procedures and determination of the cause of death
The autopsy procedures and a description of the pathological and microbiological methods used have been reported elsewhere19,20 and for Briefly, samples of blood, cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), bone marrow and key organs such as the liver, lungs, CNS, spleen and kidneys, as well as uterus in all women of reproductive age were collected for histopathological and microbiological analysis. The microbiological methods included universal screening for relevant pathogens (e.g. HIV, viral hepatitis, tuberculosis, malaria) and bacterial/fungal culture of autopsy samples, targeted screening depending on the patient’s condition (i.e. screening for Cryptococcus, Toxoplasma gondii and Pneumocystis jirovecii in HIV-infected cases), and additional specific testing according to the histopathological findings. Following the analysis of the CDA samples, a panel composed of a pathologist, a microbiologist, and a clinician with expertise in infectious diseases and epidemiology evaluated all the data (including the clinical information) and assigned the final cause of death.
All cases in which the cause of death was assigned to a cryptococcal infection were further characterized. The histological evaluation included periodic acid–Schiff staining (PAS) of the samples of both lungs, CNS, bone marrow, spleen, liver, kidney and uterus, as well as Grocott-Gomorimethenamine silver staining in all CNS samples. Microbiological evaluation included a specific real time PCR for Cryptococcus spp.21, which was performed in the samples of both lungs, CNS, bone marrow, spleen, liver and uterus. PCR cycle threshold values >38 were considered negative. Plasma and CSF samples were tested by both real time PCR and the Cryptococcus antigen (CrAg) lateral flow assay (LFA) (IMMY Inc., Norman, Oklahoma). Discrimination between C. neoformans var. grubii, C. neoformans var. neoformans, and C. gattii was achieved by amplification of the rRNA intergenic spacer (IGS) region, followed by forward and reverse Sanger sequencing of the amplicons. Identities of the cryptococcal species were assigned based on a >98% match to the IGS sequence of a Cryptococcus reference strain (C. gattii: CBS 6289, ATCC MYA-4561, CBS 6955, ATCC MYA-4563; C. neoformans var. grubii: ATCC MYA-4564, ATCC MYA-4565 and C. neoformans var. neoformans: ATCC MYA-4567) as described previously22.
Cryptococcal strains isolated from the cultures of the autopsy samples underwent a consensus multi-locus sequence typing scheme for C. neoformans and C. gattii23. In addition, the sero-mating type of these strains was determined by multiplex PCR as described previously24,25. An anti-fungogram was performed for each strain using the Sensititre® YeastOne® susceptibility plate (TREK Diagnostic Systems, Thermo Fisher Scientific, Oakwood Village, USA).
Descriptive analysis was performed using univariate statistics with means and standard deviations for continuous variables and frequency distributions for categorical variables. All analyses, data manipulation, and implementations were done using Stata MP version 15 (Stata, College Station, TX, USA).
Mortality due to cryptococcal infections
Among the 284 deceased patients included in this study, 163 (57%) tested positive for HIV, and a total of 17 (6%) fatal cryptococcal infections were confirmed in the CDA. All the deaths except one occurred in HIV-infected cases. Among the HIV-infected cases, cryptococcosis was responsible for 16 deaths (10%; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 6–15%). Among the Mozambican adults, 109 out of 169 (64%) were HIV-infected, and 11 died of fatal cryptococcal infection (10%). Four of these cases were maternal deaths (three pregnant women and one in the puerperal period), accounting for 11% of the 36 maternal deaths occurring in HIV-infected women. None of the 17 HIV-positive children over one month of age had cryptococcal infection. Thirty-seven out of the 61 (61%) patients from Brazil were HIV-infected, and Cryptococcus was responsible for five of these deaths (13%). The only death caused by Cryptococcus in an HIV-negative patient occurred in a six-year-old child (infected with C. gattii).
Clinical presentation and management of fatal cryptococcal infections
The demographic features, HIV status, clinical presentation and management of the 17 patients with fatal cryptococcal infection are summarized in Table 1. The median age was 34 years (range 6–44 years); 11 cases (65%) were men. In 13 out of the 16 (81%) HIV-infected patients, a positive HIV test result was reported in the clinical records and was apparently unknown by the clinician in the other 3 cases. Four out of the 16 (25%) HIV-infected patients were on ART, but the duration of ART was only reported in one case.
Headache was the most common symptom (13 patients, 76%), followed by fever and vomiting (eight cases each, 47%). Upon admission to hospital, eight patients (47%) were confused and/or agitated, two patients (12%) were lethargic, and another two (12%) were fully comatose. Meningeal signs were detected in seven patients (41%). The mean time from admission to death was 9.3 days (95%CI: 2.4–16.2). Cryptococcal infection was considered the first clinical diagnostic option in only 4/17 (23%) of the confirmed cases, whereas it was included in the differential diagnosis in eight patients (47%). Antifungal treatment (fluconazole or Amphotericin B) had been prescribed to seven patients but to only five of the clinically suspected cases. Seven of the patients (41%) died within 72 hours of admission, and 12 out of the 16 HIV-positive patients (75%) died within one week of admission.
The clinical records of the remaining 267 cases included in this study were reviewed for clinical diagnosis of cryptococcal infection. Among these, three HIV-infected patients were clinically diagnosed with cryptococcal meningitis, but no evidence of cryptococcal infection was found in the autopsy (the cause of death was identified as toxoplasmosis in two cases and tuberculosis in one case).
Histopathological and microbiological analysis of the fatal cryptococcal infections
Table 2 shows the final cause of death, the cryptococcal species, other associated diagnoses identified in the CDA, as well as the results of the PAS staining, Cryptococcus real time PCR and CrAg test in the different samples analysed. Identification of the cryptococcal species was successful in 15 out of the 17 cases. In two cases, the tissue samples provided insufficient DNA to perform IGS amplification and sequencing. Interestingly, among the 15 cases identified, five (33%) were C. gattii whereas the remaining cases (66.6%) were C. neoformans var. grubii.
Twelve of the 17 cases (70%) were diagnosed as disseminated infections and the remaining 5(30%) as meningoencephalitis.The CNS was affected in all 17 cases. The following were the most affected organs (PAS and/or PCR positive): the lungs (88%), spleen (76%), liver (71%), bone marrow (59%) and kidney (47%). In addition, in five out of six (83%) deceased women, the pathogen was detected in uterus samples, and in one case it was detected in the placenta. Cryptococcus was found in more than 5 different samples in 11 patients (65% of the cases). More organs were affected in C. neoformans var. grubii than in C. gattii infections (mean of 6.2 vs. 2.8 organs positive by PAS staining), but no specific histopathological differences were observed between the two Cryptococcus species. Molecular testing expanded the detection of Cryptococcus in 14 additional tissues that were negative for PAS staining. In contrast, two tissue samples were positive for PAS staining but negative by real time PCR. Periodic acid–Schiff staining and Grocott-Gomorimethenamine silver staining showed identical results. Representative histopathological images of different affected tissues are shown in Fig. 1. Cryptococcus was detected by PCR in CSF and plasma in 80% and 47% of the cases tested, respectively. All plasma and CSF samples tested for CrAg LFA were positive. Co-infections with other AIDS-related pathogens or AIDS-defining illnesses (Mycobacterium tuberculosis, cytomegalovirus, esophageal candidiasis, Toxoplasma gondii, and Histoplasma capsulatum) were detected in five cases.
Cryptococcus strain characterization
Eight strains were isolated by culture, seven from the CSF and one from the blood. The molecular characterization and antifungal susceptibility of the cryptococcal strains isolated are shown in Table 3. All C. neoformans var. grubii corresponded to the VNI molecular type, whereas two different genotypes, VGI and VGIV, were identified in the two C. gattii isolates. Sero-mating type Aα was found in all the C. neoformans isolates. Bα and Cα strains were found among the C. gattii strains.
Minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) of a variety of antifungal agents were determined (Table 3). All triazole antifungal agents (fluconazole, voriconazole, itraconazole and posaconazole) had MICs less than or equal to the defined epidemiological cut-off values (ECVs)26. One isolate showed a MIC to flucytosine (16 µg/mL), one dilution higher than the ECV (8 µg/mL). Although all the isolates presented a MIC ≤ 1 µg/mL to amphotericin, the MICs of three C. neoformans molecular type VNI (1 µg/mL) and two C. gattii (1 µg/mL) were one dilution higher than the defined ECVs (0.5 µg/mL)27.
In a large series of nearly 300 autopsies, we performed a thorough histopathological and microbiological analysis of 17 fatal cryptococcal infections, 12 from Mozambique and five from Brazil. Several studies on cryptococcal infection have been carried out in Brazil14,28, but there are no data from Mozambique. Indeed, despite being a highly endemic area for HIV, a literature search was unable to find reports describing the burden of this pathogen in this country. Thus, to our knowledge, this is the largest autopsy-based description of fatal cryptococcal infections in Mozambique. Interestingly, albeit being Maputo and Manaus two sites from different countries in terms of climate and income, some of the results obtained were very similar, such as the HIV prevalence in deceased patients (over 60%) and the Cryptococcus associated mortality in HIV positive patients. In this study Cryptococcus was responsible for 10% of the deaths among HIV-infected patients. This figure is in agreement with current estimates of 15% of AIDS-related deaths due to CM4. Although treatment with ART has led to an important reduction in the mortality of HIV-infected patients in sub-Saharan Africa, at present, cryptococcal-related death seems to remain similar to 2008 estimates. In agreement with other autopsy series, HIV-associated cryptococcosis is frequently presented as a disseminated infection14,28. Other studies have reported that up to one half of cryptococcal infections are detected in HIV-infected patients receiving ART29. In our series, only a quarter of the HIV-positive cases (4/16) were under ART. Unfortunately, the duration of ART was only available in one case. This case had a 6-year history of ART and a high viral load, and therefore, likely represents a treatment failure or defaulted. Other explanations for cryptococcal infection in patients receiving adequate ART include recent treatment initiation in patients with very low CD4 counts (late HIV diagnosis) and cases of immune reconstitution inflammatory syndrome30, which might also have been present in our series. Despite progress in ART deployment in sub-Saharan Africa, close to 50% of HIV-infected patients continue presenting to health facilities with advanced HIV disease31, thereby being at high risk of cryptococcal infection and death. In this regard, the CrAg can be detected up to three weeks before the onset of CM symptoms32 and therefore, screening of asymptomatic HIV patients followed by preemptive antifungal treatment might identify patients at risk of developing the disease and contribute to reducing CM-related mortality33,34. In the present study, most cases died within the first week of hospital admission, which is in contrast with other series reporting a mean of two weeks between admission and death35. Several factors might have contributed to the rapid fatal outcome in our series. Firstly, the low frequency of clinical suspicion of cryptococcosis may explain the absence of prescribed antifungal treatment in more than half of the patients. On the other hand, some patients may have presented to the hospital with advanced severe stages of cryptococcal infection, considering that seven died within three days of admission (four within 24 hours). The longest hospital admission involved a child who died of C. gattii meningitis about two months after hospital admission. C. gattii infections are rare in children, and as in the child in this series, the infection often occurs in previously healthy children and presents with CNS involvement9. The little knowledge available about C. gattii in sub-Saharan Africa has been obtained from studies performed in South Africa. Interestingly, in our study four out of the 12 cryptococcal infections (25%) from Mozambique were due to C. gattii infections. Although the numbers are small and should be interpreted with caution, these data contrast with previous findings from South Africa, where C. gattii represented only 2.4% of the cryptococcal strains isolated over a two-year period36. C. gattii infections have mainly been reported in immunocompetent hosts, until studies from South Africa revealed that it affects immunocompromised patients as well37,38. It has been reported that the VGI C. gattii molecular type is much more likely to affect immunocompetent patients than VGIV9. However, both genotypes were detected in HIV-infected patients in our study. All strains of C. neoformans var. grubii were molecular type VNI and possessed the sero-mating type Aα, similar to most of the strains described in South Africa. To our knowledge, this is the first report of C. gattii in Mozambique, and the Bα and Cα types detected have been previously reported in South Africa39,40. Although no clinical breakpoints are available for Cryptococcus, antifungal susceptibility testing did not suggest clear resistance patterns, with only MICs one dilution above the ECV being found.
A few isolated autopsy reports of fatal C. gattii infections in immunocompetent patients have been reported41, which may be explained by the fact that the distinction between C. gattii and C. neoformans was not performed in many studies. Although the numbers are small, dissemination of the infection seems to be less intense in HIV-infected patients with C. gattii compared to C. neoformans. Larger studies are needed to better assess the histopathological features of C. gattii in HIV-infected patients. Moreover, studies based on post-mortem examinations should be performed to better assess the mortality attributable to specific pathogens in low- and middle-income countries. Accurate mortality data can then impact public health policies, for example, guiding prophylactic and treatment schemes for infectious diseases.
In conclusion, our study highlights the substantial mortality associated with cryptococcal infections among HIV-infected patients, supporting current recommendations42 of CrAg screening and preemptive therapy, which is even more relevant in settings in which insufficient pre-mortem clinical suspicion is given to this highly prevalent and life-threatening opportunistic infection.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The study protocol received approval of the National Mozambican Ethics Committee (ref.342/CNBS/13) and the Ethics Committee of the Hospital Clinic of Barcelona (Spain; approved, File 2013/8677). MIA and CDA procedures were only conducted after verbal informed consent was provided by the relatives.
All relevant data are within the paper. Any additional data use and transfer is monitored by ISGlobal’s Data Management and Biostatistics Unit (contact e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org).
Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
We would like to thank the families of the deceased patients included in this study. The authors are grateful to all the members of the Department of Pathology of Maputo Central Hospital and Department of Pathology of Fundação de Medicina Tropical Doutor Heitor Viera Dourado, whose support made this study possible, and to the staff of the Centro de Investigação em Saúde de Manhiça (CISM) for their logistic support. We specifically thank Mr. Bento Nhancale for his invaluable support to the study. We thank Dr. Sean Zhang (Mycology Laboratory, Department of Pathology, The Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine) for kindly providing the IGS sequences of the Cryptococcus reference strains and IMMY (OK, U.S.A) for providing the CrAg LFA tests. We also thank the European Society for Clinical Microbiology and Infectious Diseases Study Group for Forensic and Postmortem Microbiology (ESGFOR) for valuable training and advice. The CaDMIA research project (Validation of the minimally invasive autopsy tool for cause of death investigation in developing countries) was funded by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation (Global Health grant numbers OPP1067522; QB) (http://www.gatesfoundation.org/) and by the Spanish Instituto de Salud Carlos III (FIS, PI12/00757; CM) (https://portalfis.isciii.es). Data analysis has been supported by the CaDMIA plus research project, funded by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation (Global health grant numbers OPP1128001; JO) (http://www.gatesfoundation.org) and the Spanish Instituto de Salud Carlos III (Acciones CIBER; CM) (http://www.ciberisciii.es/). This study was partially supported by the Agència de gestió Agència de Gestió d’Ajuts Universitaris i de Recerca (AGAUR) - Departament d’Empresa i Coneixement. Generalitat de Catalunya [2017 SGR 794 to M.J.M.]. ISGlobal is a member of the CERCA Programme, Generalitat de Catalunya (http://cerca.cat/en/suma/). CISM is supported by the Government of Mozambique and the Spanish Agency for International Development (AECID). No funding bodies had any role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.