When plants adapt to local environments, strong signatures of selection are expected in the genome, particularly in high-stress environments such as trace metal element enriched (metalliferous) soils. Using Arabidopsis halleri, a model species for metal homeostasis and adaptation to extreme environments, we identifid genes, gene variants, and pathways that are associated with soil properties and may thus contribute to adaptation to high concentrations of trace metal elements. We analysed whole-genome Pool-seq data from two metallicolous (from metalliferous soils) and two non-metallicolous populations (in total 119 individuals) and associated allele frequencies of the identified single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) with soil variables measured on site. Additionally, we accounted for polygenic adaptation by searching for gene pathways showing enrichment of signatures of selection. Out of >2.5 million SNPs, we identified 57 SNPs in 19 genes that were significantly associated with soil variables and are members of three enriched pathways. At least three of these candidate genes and pathways are involved in transmembrane transport and/or associated with responses to various stresses such as oxidative stress. We conclude that both allocation and detoxification processes play a crucial role in A. halleri for coping with these unfavourable conditions.
Local adaptation is a key evolutionary process allowing plants to cope with environmental changes and/or to colonize new and selective habitats. It is driven by natural selection acting on genetically controlled fitness traits1 and has received increasing attention in the last decade. As selection leaves distinct signatures in the genome, various landscape and population genomic approaches have been developed to (i) identify the regions in the genome that are putatively involved in local adaptation, (ii) find the environmental factors driving this process, but also (iii) pinpoint constraints decreasing local adaptation and convolute its detection2,3. When populations exhibit high levels of gene flow, strong selection pressure is required to maintain local adaptation. Hence, the interplay between gene flow and selection strength determines the genetic structure of populations as well as the possibility of detecting the genomic signature of adaptation3 and understanding its genomic basis.
Metalliferous (M) habitats exert a strong selection pressure on plant communities from high and potentially toxic concentrations of some trace metal elements (TMEs) in soils (Thlaspi caerulescens4, Biscutella laevigata5). Such high concentrations of TMEs can occur naturally, for example in rare serpentine soils6, or can result from anthropogenic activities (e.g. mining). Their toxic effect on growth, biochemistry, and physiology strongly depends on the bioavailability of these elements in the soil and on plant tolerance mechanisms7. At the cell level, TME stress can result from e.g. enzymatic dysfunction via TME binding to a functional domain and/or increased oxidative stress (OS8). Such reactions are amplified through the accumulation of some TMEs (e.g. zinc, Zn) within OS-prone organelles such as chloroplasts, causing injury to thylakoids and photosystems, consequently impairing photosynthesis9,10.
Populations of several plant taxa have locally adapted to harsh M environments11. While avoidance by exclusion is the most common mechanism of plant adaptation to TME toxicity, tolerance to metal stress relies on allocation and detoxification strategies at organ, tissue and cell level8. Increased TME tolerance can be achieved through allocation to e.g. older foliage organs12 and/or peripheral and physiologically less active tissues in the leaf vein13, leaf blade14, and within cells the vacuole15 or cell wall16.
In certain hypertolerant species, metal accumulation can exceed the concentrations found in non-hypertolerant species growing on non-metalliferous (NM) soils by several orders of magnitude. These hyperaccumulator species17 show exceptionally high transcription levels of many genes involved in metal transport, chelation, and sequestration18. Hyperaccumulators thus have a high potential for phyto-remediation of heavy metal contaminated soils or phyto-fortification of certain minerals for increased nutrition value. However, for efficient application of these approaches, the genetic basis of metal adaptation remains insufficiently understood19.
Phenotypic studies on adaptation to calamine or serpentine soils using species that thrive on both M and NM soils, so called pseudometallophytes, have revealed considerable intraspecific variation in metal tolerance and hyperaccumulation5,9,20. At the species level, this large quantitative variation is commonly associated with different edaphic origins of populations. In general, populations on NM soils accumulate lower quantities of metals than populations on M soils. Yet, under experimentally controlled conditions, when all plants are exposed to the same elevated metal concentrations, non-metallicolous populations often accumulate higher amounts of TME compared to metallicolous populations, thus also reaching the threshold concentration for hyperaccumulation20,21,22. Genome scans11,23 and quantitative genetic studies24,25 have shown the involvement of genomic regions and genes that underlie processes of internal metal transport, homeostasis and/or detoxification in leaves of hyperaccumulating plants. Still, these studies are based on genomic information and categorical assignment (e.g. M or NM soils) only and lack associations with quantitative environmental variables that characterize e.g. soil metal content. Furthermore, the existing analyses and interpretations are often gene-focused and thus offer only limited insight into the genetic basis of adaptation to environmental stress, despite increasing evidence suggesting that such adaptation is polygenic26.
Here, we explore the genetic basis of plant adaptation to high soil concentrations of TMEs by comparing two metallicolous (from M habitats) and two non-metallicolous (from NM habitats) populations (Fig. 1 and Table 1) of the pseudometallophyte Arabidopsis halleri (L.) O’Kane and Al Shebaz. This outcrossing and also vegetatively reproducing Brassicaceae hypertolerates and hyperaccumulates Zn and cadmium (Cd)27. While hyperaccumulation of Zn in A. halleri is constitutive (i.e. species-wide), it appears to be population-specific for Cd28,29. Yet, a broad quantitative variation among populations has been observed for both traits under field and experimental conditions20,28,29,30. We used whole-genome re-sequencing of population pools (Pool-seq31) and mapped the obtained reads to a de-novo assembled draft reference genome of Swiss A. halleri. Next, we associated the allele frequencies of the identified single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) with environmental variables via environmental association analyses (EAA2). To complement this nucleotide-based approach and to account for a putatively polygenic nature of adaptation, we further used a gene-set enrichment analysis approach32. We present the SNPs, genes and pathways associated with different soil types and discuss our results in light of potential biological functions regarding (local) TME adaptation.
De novo reference genome of Arabidopsis halleri
To map our reads to a reference genome that is phylogenetically closer to the sampled populations than the available assembly of a recently published Japanese accession33,34, we created a de novo assembly of two Swiss specimens. The Illumina sequencing of these two libraries led to 76*106 paired-end and 113*106 mate-pair reads. After quality trimming and filtering, 73% of the reads were used for the assembly process. Of those, 68% were incorporated in the final assembly. The draft reference genome (Ahalleri_CH_v2) established in this study was 164.6 Mb in size and therefore accounts for 66% of the estimated genome size of A. halleri (250–255 Mb)33. It consisted of 40 345 scaffolds, included ca. 25 kb Ns, N50 was 82 799 bp, and the largest scaffold 774 kb. Of the predicted genes, 26 249 were larger than 67 amino acids and 16 088 could be functionally annotated. In order to assess the completeness of the genome assembly, we ran BUSCO v2.0.135, which revealed 1312 complete and single-copy (91.1%), 16 complete and duplicated (1.1%), 52 fragmented (3.6%) and 60 missing (4.2%) orthologs.
Metalliferous sites differ in their history and TME concentrations
In order to cover the range of demographic clusters and the highly diverse ecological settings that characterise A. halleri populations, we selected two anthropogenic M locations at low altitude (M_PL22 and M_PL27), one NM sub-alpine location (NM_PL35), and the only known NM lowland location in the study area (NM_PL14, Fig. 1). Arabidopsis halleri populations from these four locations hypertolerate and hyperaccumulate TMEs9,21. However, the history and soil composition of the four sites differ. M_PL22 is located in the vicinity of the Bolesław Mine and Metallurgical Plant (still operational) on abandoned farmland36, whereas M_PL27 is located in the area of an open-cast Zn and Pb ore mine (closed in 1912), with mining dating back to the 14th century (https://szukajwarchiwach.pl/search?q=galman%20XSKANro%3At&order).
Since we were mainly interested in adaptation to different soils, we determined soil variables that significantly differentiated M and NM sites. In particular, we found that total Cd (F3,11 = 125, P = 4.7*10−7), extractable (surrogate for bioavailable) potassium (K) (F3,11 = 18.5, P = 5.8*10−4), extractable magnesium (Mg) (F3,11 = 331, P = 1.0*10−8), extractable lead (Pb) (F3,11 = 501, P = 1.9*10−9), and extractable Zn (F3,11 = 218, P = 5.2*10−8) content clearly differed between both site types (Fig. 2). Accordingly, these five soil variables were considered as the discriminators of M and NM soils in our study and thus included in specific EAAs. In particular, site M_PL27 showed considerably higher Cd, Pb, and Zn soil concentrations than the other M site (M_PL22), and very low levels of these elements were found at NM sites (Fig. 2). Concerning macronutrients, lower extractable K and higher extractable Mg at both M sites further indicated a distorted nutrient supply.
Climatic and soil variables are orthogonal
To assess environmental differences between the four studied sites, we performed a principal component analysis (PCA) on climatic and soil variables. Metalliferous and NM locations were not clearly separated by their environmental conditions (Fig. 3a). However, the sub-alpine location (NM_PL35, lowest temperature and highest precipitation) and the Galman site (M_PL27, highest soil TME concentrations) were clearly distinct from the other two locations. With the exception of soil phosphorous (P) content, climatic variables dominated the contributions to PC1 (54.7% of total variance explained), while PC2 (39.3% of total variance explained) was mainly driven by soil variables (Fig. 3b, Supplementary Table S1).
Next generation sequencing, mapping and SNP calling
From the four population pools, we obtained more than 109 reads in total, 253*106 reads per population on average. We could map 89% (coefficient of variation, CV = 1.5%) of reads to the reference genome, with an average (median) coverage of 155.1x (125x), 162.9x (131x), 122.8x (95x) and 165.3x (128x) for populations M_PL22, M_PL27, NM_PL14, NM_PL35, respectively (Supplementary Table S2). Each sequenced pool had >80% (average 83.9%, CV = 2.7%) of nucleotides covered at least 60x, that is each base is covered at least once per chromosome (30 diploid individuals per pool). In total, we found 3 724 036 raw SNPs. After stringent filtering we retained 2 529 878 high-confidence bi-allelic SNPs for downstream analyses.
Neutral population structure does not reflect the environment
To identify the neutral genetic population structure, we performed a PCA with 500 000 random SNPs revealing a genetic distinction of metallicolous and non-metallicolous populations (Fig. 3c) along PC2 (32.1% of variance explained), but not along PC1 (44.0%). Furthermore, metallicolous populations were genetically more similar to each other than to non-metallicolous populations, and the two non-metallicolous populations were clearly separated (for genetic differentiation among populations see Table S3). Altogether, this indicates three genetic clusters: one formed by the two metallicolous populations and two represented by the two non-metallicolous populations. Importantly, the neutral genetic population structure did not mirror the environmental conditions, neither when only the five highly differentiated soil variables were used in the environmental PCA (Supplementary Fig. S1). Genome-wide population-specific Tajima’s D values were very similar and slightly positive for the four populations (median values NM_PL14 = 0.130, NM_PL35 = 0.123, M_PL22 = 0.123, M_PL27 = 0.145).
Environmental association analyses reveal candidate genes involved in adaptation to soil TME concentrations
We used latent factor mixed models (LFMMs37) to identify the environment-driven genomic signatures of selection and found 12 927 SNPs (962 genes, Supplementary Table S4 and S5) to be associated with Site-type (M vs NM, example given in Fig. 4a). The SNP set identified as associated with Site-type in LFMM was strongly biased towards a Z statistic of 0.5 in Bayenv238 (an alternative EAA method that we used for cross-validation of the LFMM results), the latter value indicating a strong correlation with the environmental variable. In contrast, a random set of 12 000 SNPs, in the majority representing putatively neutral sequence variants, yielded a rather uniform distribution of the Z statistic in Bayenv2 (Supplementary Fig. S2). This generally confirms the results of the LFMM analysis.
To identify SNPs associated with specific TMEs, we performed more detailed and targeted EAAs using the five soil variables that differed significantly between M and NM sites: total Cd, extractable K, Mg, Pb and Zn. We found 23 413 associated SNPs (1789 A. thaliana orthologous genes), 26 459 (1763), 23 460 (1685), 24 469 (1648) and 22 982 (1902, example given in Fig. 4b), respectively. Since we consider these five elements as the main discriminators of M and NM soils, the overlap of these genes (1375 genes, Supplementary Tables S6 and S7) may represent a genomic basis of adaption to M soils. The biological process “response to cadmium ion” was one of the most frequent gene ontolgy terms in these genes (Table S7).
Three gene pathways enriched for a signature of adaptation to soil TME concentrations
To account for the putatively polygenic nature of adaptation, we tested whether certain gene sets were enriched for the z score, the test statistic of LFMM. In total, we found three pathways to be enriched: (1) solute carrier (SLC)-mediated transmembrane transport for Site-type, (2) translesion synthesis by POLH for all five soil variables, and (3) alpha-linolenic acid metabolism for all five soil variables (Supplementary Table S8).
Next, we marked all associated candidate genes that belong to one of the enriched pathways. This resulted in a total of 19 associated genes (hereafter referred to as ‘candidates’) that are the most likely involved in local adaptation to the soil characteristics in the study area (Table 2). In particular, we identified seven genes that belonged to the pathway enriched for Site-type, and 12 genes that were members of the two pathways enriched for the soil variables. One pathway is related to sequestration (solute carrier (SLC)-mediated transmembrane transport) while the other two are associated with response to stress, including OS (alpha-linolenic acid metabolism, Fig. 5), and DNA repair (translesion synthesis by POLH).
Signatures of positive selection and few non-synonymous substitutions
Three candidates had a negative Tajima’s D in at least one metallicolous population, indicating departure from neutral expectations by recent positive selection (likely less than 10 000 generations ago39). The alternative explanation of a recent population expansion can rather be excluded as the overall population-specific Tajima’s D values were slightly positive while the observed gene-specific Tajima’s D values were in the lower quantile distribution (Table 2, Supplementary Fig. S3). In particular, RFC4 (Replication Factor C4; AT1G21690) had a negative Tajima’s D in both metallicolous populations (M_PL22: −0.97, percentile = 0.0016; M_PL27: −0.92, percentile = 0.00008) and close to 0 or positive in non-metallicolous populations. JMT (jasmonic acid carboxyl methyltransferase; AT1G19640) and MTPA2 (metal tolerance protein A2; AT3G58810) had negative Tajima’s D in the population originating from the most contaminated site M_PL27 (JMT: −0.49, percentile = 0.0005; MTPA2: −1.08, percentile = 0.00004).
To evaluate how the identified variants potentially affect the respective proteins, we assessed the predicted effects of the associated SNPs on the protein structure of the 19 genes. Most SNPs were either synonymous or intron variants. Only one of 15 Site-type associated candidate SNPs and nine of the 42 soil-associated SNPs were non-synonymous (NS) substitutions, respectively, corresponding to 20.7% of SNPs on average (Supplementary Tables S9, S10). In two of the three genes (JMT and RFC4) with a signature of positive selection (negative Tajima’s D value), a single SNP out of a total of 36 and 100 SNPs, respectively, generates an intron variant associated with all soil variables. MTPA2 is the only identified transporter and had the lowest number of SNPs (five) identified, but four of these were associated with Site-type. One of these four SNPs is NS. We predicted the secondary structure of the MTPA2 protein to be an alpha helical transmembrane protein. The NS SNP associated with Site-type in MTPA2 causes replacement of Isoleucine at position 138 by Leucine (I138L, change in the side chain conformation) in the first transmembrane helix.
In the present study, we searched for adaptive genetic changes that have evolved to allow the Brassicaceae Arabidopsis halleri to grow on M soils that were polluted with TMEs by mining since the late medieval times or more recently (<100 years ago) by industry40. Using four populations to detect the signature of local adaptation is at the lower end of statistical power. However, we think that this is counterbalanced by the categorical sampling design (replicated populations of M and NM sites) and the strong selection pressure that such TME-enriched soils exert on plants, complemented by the genome-wide perspective. Furthermore, the selected populations exhibit a wide range of TME concentrations in plant shoots and represent the genetic diversity and recently refined population genetic structure of A. halleri in southern Poland21.
By combining approaches targeting signatures of selection at the level of single nucleotides, genes and functional pathways, we identified 19 genes in three functional pathways (Table 2) that are likely to play roles in adaptation to TME-rich soils. This combination of approaches allowed us to avoid subjective biases41 and should have largely reduced the number of false positives. Given the possible multi- to polygenic nature of TME adaptation11,23,28,29 (but see8) potentially including a high number of candidate genes, this combination of approaches further allowed reducing the number of candidate genes for follow-up molecular studies. Most of the identified genes are members of transmembrane transport and stress signalling pathways, which indicates that both allocation and detoxification of TMEs are important physiological processes in adaptation to M soils.
Since we were interested in variants that increased or decreased in frequency as a result of positive selection, we here focus on three candidate genes: MTPA2 (AT3G58810), JMT (AT1G19640), and RFC4 (AT1G21690). Besides being associated to soil factors in EAAs and being members of gene pathways that are enriched for soil adaptation, these three candidates also have negative values of Tajima’s D in at least one metallicolous population. We consider these three genes to be our strongest candidates for metal stress adaptation. Below, we discuss them in the context of the enriched pathways and their physiological function.
Metallicolous populations show alterations in ion transmembrane transport genes
The metal tolerance protein A2 (MTPA2/MTP3, AT3G58810) is involved in the transmembrane transport and vacuolar metal sequestration of divalent cations42. It is located in the vacuolar membrane (tonoplast), involved with Zn2+ homeostasis and confers tolerance to excess Zn42. This gene is a potential target of the Fe-deficiency induced transcription factor 1 (FIT1), a key regulator of Fe-deficiency responses43. However, there was no difference in the Fe soil content among our sites. Also, a recent study in A. halleri showed that FIT1 expression is not altered under Zn treatment28. Thus, the FIT1 transcription factor seems not to be involved in adaptation to the M locations investigated herein.
It is remarkable that we found a signal of selection (negative Tajimas D) for MTPA2 only in population M_PL27. Interestingly, M_PL27 was the most contaminated site in our study and had more than twice as much extractable Zn compared to the other M site M_PL22 (3900 versus 1600 ppm, respectively, Fig. 2). Furthermore, mining in the region of M_PL27 has been reported as early as the 14th century. The name of the region, Galman, actually means ‘zinc ore’ and is likely derived from the centuries-long mining activity (https://szukajwarchiwach.pl/search?q=galman%20XSKANro%3At&order). Accordingly, the weaker and much younger (ca. 100 years40) selection pressure at M_PL22 seemed to be insufficient to create a strong selective sweep and thus resulted in a non-negative Tajima’s D in this population.
To date, no tertiary structure of the MTPA2 protein has been resolved, thus preventing positioning of the I138L substitution that we observed. However, using the Scratch protein structure prediction software, we could predict the secondary structure and found that the I138L substitution is located in a transmembrane helix. Furthermore, the alternative allele of the responsible NS SNP is at high frequency (>0.9) in both metallicolous populations and absent or at low frequency in both non-metallicolous populations (Fig. 4a, Supplementary Table S9). Our findings indicate that a modified version of this divalent cation transmembrane transporter is necessary for adaptation via presumed different sequestration of Zn2+, which is the main contaminant at the studied M sites. A similar role was recently suggested for another member of the MTP gene family, AhMTP130,44,45,46. The well described MTP1 (also known as ZAT1 or CDF1) gene, encoding Zn2+ transporters involved in vacuolar sequestration, is considered a key component of hypertolerance to elevated Zn concentrations in A. halleri24,47. Still, several studies have demonstrated that different evolutionary fates, some of them not concurring with increased Zn tolerance, are likely to take place for the up to five paralogs of the MTP1 in A. halleri30,48,49. Our study suggests that the related MTPA2 has also played a role in the adaptive evolution of Zn tolerance in the species.
Another transporter that was identified as a candidate gene that is directly involved in ion homeostasis was choline transporter-like 1 (CTL1, AT3G15380). This gene regulates the expression pattern of different ion transporters through the modulation of vesicle trafficking50 and is closely associated with auxin signaling in the control of plant developmental processes51. Although CTL1 was significantly associated with Site-type in our analysis, considering its positive Tajima’s D value it seems unlikely that this gene was under direct positive selection (Table 2).
Stress signalling is putatively altered in response to high TME soil concentrations
Jasmonic acid (JA) and salicylic acid (SA) are two plant hormones that have widespread signalling roles with regard to many biotic and abiotic stresses which can cause oxidative damage52. In relation to oxidative stress, SA amplifies the oxidative signal and JA limits the oxidative lesion spreading53,54. Two candidate genes, SDP1 and SDP1-like (AT5G04040 and AT3G57140), are located at the beginning of the enriched alpha-linolenic acid metabolism pathway that leads to the synthesis of JA and are responsible for generating the substrate alpha-linolenic acid (Fig. 5). It is striking that EAA detected six genes within this enriched gene pathway to be associated with the five soil-specific variables that best discriminate between M and NM sites. Accordingly and in agreement with other studies showing that elevated TME concentrations often result in oxidative stress8,9,10, we conclude that TME-induced oxidative stress is the most likely selective force. However, selection of altered JA responses can also be imposed by other stressors, including herbivory or drought. While climatic factors were not correlated with soil-related factors (Fig. 3b) and are therefore unlikely to be the selective force driving the identified patterns, potential effects of herbivory or pathogens at M sites cannot be excluded. Thus, this latter hypothesis needs further testing.
The second candidate that has a negative Tajima’s D in at least one metallicolous population, is jasmonic acid carboxyl methyltransferase (JMT, AT1G19640). Similar to MTPA2, its Tajima’s D was negative only for the population from medieval mining of natural Zn and Pb ore outcrops (M_PL27), suggesting that this is an ancient allele. On the one hand, the single associated SNP leading to an intron variant might not alter the protein or the protein’s expression. On the other hand, it is also possible that it creates a different splice variant or plays a role in the candidate’s regulation via different binding of transcription factors55. However, JMT has a direct connection to TME-induced stress. Methyl-JA has been shown to improve reactive oxygen species (ROS) scavenging through an enhanced antioxidant defence system56, linking it to OS response. It has also been shown to alleviate Cd-induced photosynthetic damage57, assigning a more prominent role to the molecule in plants growing on Cd-rich soils. Different to JA, however, methyl-JA does not control for lesion spread during cell death events triggered by OS58. Such lesions are a phenotypic hallmark of local TME adaptation and were shown to occur less often in adapted genotypes (from M sites in the Olkusz region) of another pseudometallophyte of the Brassicaceae family, Biscutella laevigata, compared to its non-tolerant genotypes (from NM habitats)5. Since JMT1 and another five of the 19 candidates with associated SNPs are part of the alpha-linolenic acid metabolic pathway that ultimately leads to JA synthesis, we hypothesize that the levels of JA are balanced differently in adapted plants via methyl-JA and JA levels.
DNA repair pathways show genetic variation associated with variation in soil TME concentrations
The third candidate, Replication factor C4 (RFC4, AT1G21690), is the only candidate with a negative Tajima’s D in both metallicolous populations. Despite this clear signal of selection, we identified only a single associated SNP that results in an intron variant (Supplementary Table S10). The protein RFC4 is part of the replication machinery and belongs to the ATPase family associated with various cellular activities (AAA)59. The other candidates that belong to the enriched ‘translesion synthesis by POLH’ pathway are involved in protein quality surveillance (UFD1, AT2G2970) or also in the replication machinery (e.g. RPA32, AT3G02920). Via translesion synthesis, POLH is specific to resolve pyrimidine dimers, which result from UV radiation60. Our current knowledge of POLH does not indicate any relation to high TME soil concentrations. However, the associated genes ensure protein quality and DNA repair and might relate to stress in general.
Improved European A. halleri reference genome
As a backbone of our bioinformatic analyses, we established our own de novo assembled draft reference genome (Ahalleri_CH_v2) for mapping of the obtained reads. It represents a major improvement of the first A. halleri ssp. halleri draft genome used in Rellstab et al.61. Except for total assembly size, its assembly statistics are better than the first version of the assembly of the Japanese A. halleri ssp. gemmifera genome62, but inferior to its second version33, which was enhanced by adding long mate pair libraries of an inbred line. As Polish populations of A. halleri are genetically closer to Swiss than to Japanese populations34, and because the BUSCO analysis revealed a largely complete assembly (91.1%), we used the former as a reference.
Future directions based on this study
While the list of potential candidate genes in our study was limited to known A. thaliana orthologs, we found candidate genes that presumably play a key role in adaptation to TME-rich soils. As some of these genes have not previously been linked with adaptation to heavy metals, we can only hypothesize about the mechanism and role that these genes might have in the identified pathways. In silico data mining can only provide a list of the most promising genes that have to be investigated in more detail. To clarify whether the identified genes are indeed important for adaptation to M soils, further functional proof is needed. This could for example be achieved using knock-out lines or reciprocal transplant experiments to show that metallicolous and non-metallicolous genotypes and their respective alleles actually have a fitness advantage in their home environment. Such a transplant experiment that also involves our study sites and populations is currently ongoing.
Using whole-genome Pool-seq and environmental data, we found genomic signatures of adaptation to metalliferous soils by means of environmental association analyses. These associations were substantiated by identifying several gene networks, linked to transmembrane transport and response to stress, showing involvement in the local adaptation of A. halleri populations from southern Poland to high soil TME concentrations.
Materials and Methods
Reference genome of Arabidopsis halleri
To map our obtained sequences (see below) to a reference, we assembled and annotated our own draft reference genome of European A. halleri. For this, we used Illumina paired-end and 3 kb mate-pair libraries and plants from two Swiss populations (Aha11 and Aha18) described in Fischer et al.63. For details of the assembly process, see Supplementary Methods.
Sampling and environmental data
Sampling included four locations of A. halleri in southern Poland (Fig. 1 and Table 1): two anthropogenic M locations in the Olkusz region (M_PL22 and M_PL27), one NM location in Niepołomice Forest (NM_PL14) – which is similar in climate to both M sites (Fig. 3a,b) – and one sub-alpine NM location in the northern foothills of the Tatra Mountains (NM_PL35). A recent study showed that plants from Olkusz and Niepołomice Forest regions belong to the same higher-level genetic cluster, while samples from the Tatra region were assigned to another cluster21. The latter cluster is considered to be the most ancestral and has the highest estimate of effective population size of all populations from southern Poland21. At each site, we collected leaves of 30 A.halleri plants every 4 m along transects to avoid potential clones and dried them on silicagel. We further collected three topsoil samples to a depth of 10 cm at each site using a cylinder of 7 cm diameter, followed by careful removal of the organic horizon.
To assess the soil and climatic environmental conditions at the study sites, we used (i) chemical data from local soil profiles and (ii) climatic factors (precipitation and temperature) from existing databases. For details on soil chemical analysis and climate data processing see Supplementary Methods. In total, we measured 16 soil variables (organic and total C, total N, available P, total and exchangeable Ca, Cd, K, Mg, Pb, and Zn) that are averages of three independent topsoil samples (Supplementary Table S11). We also generated 15 bioclimatic variables from the monthly temperature and precipitation data, averaged over the past 20 years (Supplementary Table S11).
To describe the environment, we performed a PCA with all 31 variables using the R package FactoMineR64 in R 3.3.465. To identify soil variables that were significantly different between M and NM sites, we performed one-way analyses of variance (ANOVAs) on linear models of the form ‘soil variable ~ population’ with the R-package MASS66. We tested for normal distribution of the residuals using the Shapiro test and further tested for homoscedasticity using the Breusch-Pagan test as implemented in the R package olsrr67. If those model assumptions were violated, we Box-Cox transformed the corresponding soil variable prior to ANOVA. Finally, we repeated the above described PCA only with the soil variables that were significantly different between M and NM sites.
Next-generation sequencing (NGS) and data processing
DNA extraction, library preparation, and next-generation sequencing followed the description in Supplementary Methods. We used a pooled sequencing approach (Pool-seq)31 that has been shown to deliver accurate allele frequencies in the studied species61.
We trimmed off adapter sequences of the Illumina Pool-seq data using cutadapt 1.968. We then mapped the reads to our reference genome of A. halleri using Bwa-mem 0.7.1269 and Samtools 1.370, and filtered the resulting BAM files for reads of mapping quality ≥10 with Bamtools 2.4.171. After removing duplicate reads, adding read groups, and indexing the BAM files using Samtools and Bamaddrg (https://github.com/ekg/bamaddrg), we called genetic variants using Freebayes 1.0.172. We used the pooled discrete mode for Pool-seq data, set ploidy to 60, the minimum alternate fraction to 0.083, minimum coverage to four, and maximum coverage to 10 000.
We filtered the resulting SNP list for bi-allelic loci using vcflib 1.0.1 (https://github.com/vcflib/vcflib) and for quality (PHRED scale) >30, minimum mapping quality >40, read depth <1200, individual sample depth >60, quality/read depth >0.25, no missing data and minimum (4) and maximum (236) alternate allele counts using bcftools73 (https://github.com/samtools/bcftools). Additionally, we removed all non-variant sites using a custom Python3 script. The complete list of options and parameters can be found in Supplementary Table S12.
Neutral population structure and environmental association analyses
Information on neutral genetic population structure, in particular how many genetic clusters (K) comprised our sample, was required to appropriately parameterize the subsequent EAA. To infer the neutral population structure, we randomly chose 500 000 SNPs from our data set and used their allele frequencies to perform a PCA with FactoMineR.
Using LFMM37 incorporated in the R package Lea274, we performed 12 runs (5000 burn-in cycles and 10 000 additional cycles) per environmental variable for K = 2–4 to account for neutral population structure. We used the categorical variable ‘Site-type’ (coded as 1 or 0), which denotes M or NM sites, respectively, and the soil variables (described above) as environmental variables. Following Lea2 instructions, we combined the results of the 12 runs using the median z score and calculated the genomic inflation factor (λ) for all Ks. For all six variables, the lowest λ was at K = 3, which is in concordance with the neutral genetic population structure (see Results). Therefore, we used the LFMM results for K = 3 and corrected the P values with the corresponding λ value. We set the false discovery rate to 1%.
We cross-evaluated the LFMM results using Bayenv238 in pooled mode. To construct the variance–covariance matrix, we randomly sampled 20% of all SNPs and saw the matrix converging after 32 000 iterations. Subsequently, we performed three runs with different random seeds for the set of SNPs associated with Site-type in LFMM. Additionally, we randomly selected 12 000 SNPs, excluding SNPs that were significantly associated in LFMM, and performed three runs as a random control. This number of random SNPs was chosen to match the SNPs found to be associated in LFMM analyses (see Results). We then assessed the overlap of the Z statistic histograms of the SNPs associated in LFMM and random sets to estimate the performance of the LFMM analysis.
In order to be able to functionally interpret our gene-based analyses, we focused on functionally annotated A. thaliana orthologs. Using “intersect” of Bedtools and Unix’ “awk” commands, we added the A. thaliana orthologue gene name to each SNP. Each annotated gene that contained at least one environmentally associated SNP was considered a candidate gene for adaptation to variation in soil TME concentrations.
Gene set enrichment analyses
To identify signatures of putatively polygenic adaptation, we used the Polysel pipeline for gene set enrichment analysis32. We obtained GeneIDs, BSID and the BSID to GeneID lists for A. thaliana from the repository at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/biosystems/. We based our Polysel analyses on the maximum absolute LFMM z scores per gene (using all SNPs, not only the significantly associated). We added the NCBI Biosystems GeneID using a custom Python3 script. We applied the default settings of the pipeline and a post-pruning Q value cutoff of 10%. As we were primarily interested in adaptation to edaphic conditions, we performed this analysis for (i) Site-type and (ii) the five soil variables that significantly differed between M and NM sites.
Population genomic analyses, gene diversity and SNP annotation
We used custom python3 scripts to calculate nucleotide diversity π and Watterson’s θW75 to estimate Tajima’s D76 for every gene in every population. A negative Tajima’s D value indicates an excess of rare alleles and is usually interpreted as either a signature of a selective sweep or a recent population expansion, e.g. after a bottleneck.
To infer the possible effect and impact of a single substitution, we used SnpEff77. We added A. halleri to the SnpEff database following the developer’s instructions and annotated our final, stringently filtered vcf file. We used this annotated vcf file with our candidate bed files to extract the ‘Effect’ (e.g. intron-variant, non-synonymous (NS) variant) and ‘Impact’ (e.g. moderate, high) from the SnpEff annotation for the LFMM-derived SNPs. To identify whether a NS SNP has an influence on protein structure, we ran the online tool ‘Scratch Protein Predictor’ and used the SSpro (3 Class) and SSpro8 (8 Class) secondary structure predictor therein78.
The reference genome assembly is available at NCBI GenBank under PRJNA492199. Raw reads used for the reference genome assembly are available at NCBI SRA under SAMN10130990 (Aha18_mp and Aha11_10B combined), SAMN10095121/SRR8083399 (Aha18_mp), and SAMN10095118/SRR8083441 (Aha11_10B). Raw reads for SNP calling of the four population pools are accessible at NCBI SRA under projectID PRJNA495924, with reads for PL14 under SAMN10234903/SRR0840827, for PL22 under SAMN10234904/SRR8040826, for PL27 under SAMN10234905/SRR8040825, and for PL35 under SAMN10234906/SRR8040824).
Kawecki, T. J. & Ebert, D. Conceptual issues in local adaptation. Ecol. Lett. 7, 1225–1241 (2004).
Rellstab, C., Gugerli, F., Eckert, A. J., Hancock, A. M. & Holderegger, R. A practical guide to environmental association analysis in landscape genomics. Mol. Ecol. 24, 4348–4370 (2015).
Tigano, A. & Friesen, V. L. Genomics of local adaptation with gene flow. Mol. Ecol. 25, 2144–2164 (2016).
Dechamps, C. et al. Cost of adaptation to a metalliferous environment for Thlaspi caerulescens: a field reciprocal transplantation approach. New Phytol. 177, 167–177 (2008).
Babst-Kostecka, A. A., Waldmann, P., Frérot, H. & Vollenweider, P. Plant adaptation to metal polluted environments — physiological, morphological, and evolutionary insights from Biscutella laevigata. Environ. Exp. Bot. 127, 1–13 (2016).
Wójcik, M. et al. Metallophytes of serpentine and calamine soils – their unique ecophysiology and potential for phytoremediation. Adv. Bot. Res. 83, 1–42 (2017).
Greger, M. In Heavy Metal Stress in Plants (eds Prasad, M. N. V. & Hagemeyer, J.) 1–27 (Springer, 2004).
Ernst, W. H. Evolution of metal tolerance in higher plants. For. Snow Landsc. Res. 80, 251–274 (2006).
Meyer, C. L. et al. Variability of zinc tolerance among and within populations of the pseudometallophyte species Arabidopsis halleri and possible role of directional selection. New Phytol. 185, 130–142 (2010).
Vollenweider, P. et al. Compartmentation of metals in foliage of Populus tremula grown on soils with mixed contamination. II. Zinc binding inside leaf cell organelles. Environ. Pollut. 159, 337–347 (2011).
Turner, T. L. et al. Population resequencing reveals local adaptation of Arabidopsis lyrata to serpentine soils. Nat. Genet. 42, 260–263 (2010).
Cosio, C., Vollenweider, P. & Keller, C. Localization and effects of cadmium in leaves of a cadmium-tolerant willow (Salix viminalis L.). Environ. Exp. Bot. 58, 64–74 (2006).
Vollenweider, P., Cosio, C., Günthardt-Goerg, M. S. & Keller, C. Localization and effects of cadmium in leaves of a cadmium-tolerant willow (Salix viminalis L.). Environ. Exp. Bot. 58, 25–40 (2006).
Chardonnens, A. N. et al. Allocation patterns of zinc and cadmium in heavy metal tolerant and sensitive Silene vulgaris. J. Plant Physiol. 155, 778–787 (1999).
Frey, B., Keller, C. & Zierold, K. Distribution of Zn in functionally different leaf epidermal cells of the hyperaccumulator Thlaspi caerulescens. Plant Cell Environ. 23, 675–687 (2000).
Heumann, H.-G. Ultrastructural localization of zinc in zinc-tolerant Armeria maritima ssp. halleri by autometallography. J. Plant Physiol. 159, 191–203 (2002).
Reeves, R. D. & Baker, A. In Phytoremediation of toxic metals: Using plants to clean up the environment (eds Raskin, I. & Finsley, B. D.) 193–229 (2000).
Talke, I. N., Hanikenne, M. & Krämer, U. Zinc-dependent global transcriptional control, transcriptional deregulation, and higher gene copy number for genes in metal homeostasis of the hyperaccumulator Arabidopsis halleri. Plant Physiol. 142, 148–167 (2006).
Mahar, A. et al. Challenges and opportunities in the phytoremediation of heavy metals contaminated soils: A review. Ecotoxicol. Environ. Saf. 126, 111–121 (2016).
Stein, R. J. et al. Relationships between soil and leaf mineral composition are element-specific, environment-dependent and geographically structured in the emerging model Arabidopsis halleri. New Phytol. 213, 1274–1286 (2017).
Babst-Kostecka, A. et al. Evolutionary dynamics of quantitative variation in an adaptive trait at the regional scale: The case of zinc hyperaccumulation in Arabidopsis halleri. Mol. Ecol. 27, 3257–3273 (2018).
Meyer, C. L. et al. Intraspecific variability of cadmium tolerance and accumulation, and cadmium-induced cell wall modifications in the metal hyperaccumulator Arabidopsis halleri. J. Exp. Bot. 66, 3215–3227 (2015).
Arnold, B. J. et al. Borrowed alleles and convergence in serpentine adaptation. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 113, 8320–8325 (2016).
Willems, G. et al. The genetic basis of zinc tolerance in the metallophyte Arabidopsis halleri ssp. halleri (Brassicaceae): an analysis of quantitative trait loci. Genetics 176, 659–674 (2007).
Wright, K. M. et al. Adaptation to heavy-metal contaminated environments proceeds via selection on pre-existing genetic variation. bioRxiv 029900 https://doi.org/10.1101/029900 (2015).
He, F. et al. The footprint of polygenic adaptation on stress-responsive cis-regulatory divergence in the Arabidopsis genus. Mol. Biol. Evol. 33, 2088–2101 (2016).
Bert, V., Bonnin, I., Saumitou-Laprade, P., De Laguérie, P. & Petit, D. Do Arabidopsis halleri from nonmetallicolous populations accumulate zinc and cadmium more effectively than those from metallicolous populations? New Phytol. 155, 47–57 (2002).
Schvartzman, M. S. et al. Adaptation to high zinc depends on distinct mechanisms in metallicolous populations of Arabidopsis halleri. New Phytol. 218, 269–282 (2018).
Corso, M. et al. Contrasting cadmium resistance strategies in two metallicolous populations of Arabidopsis halleri. New Phytol. 218, 283–297 (2018).
Meyer, C. L. et al. Potential preadaptation to anthropogenic pollution: evidence from a common quantitative trait locus for zinc and cadmium tolerance in metallicolous and nonmetallicolous accessions of Arabidopsis halleri. New Phytol. 212, 934–943 (2016).
Schlötterer, C., Tobler, R., Kofler, R. & Nolte, V. Sequencing pools of individuals — mining genome-wide polymorphism data without big funding. Nat. Rev. Genet. 15, 749–763 (2014).
Daub, J. T. et al. Evidence for polygenic adaptation to pathogens in the human genome. Mol. Biol. Evol. 30, 1544–1558 (2013).
Briskine, R. V. et al. Genome assembly and annotation of Arabidopsis halleri, a model for heavy metal hyperaccumulation and evolutionary ecology. Mol. Ecol. Resour. 17, 1025–1036 (2017).
Šrámková-Fuxová, G. et al. Range-wide genetic structure of Arabidopsis halleri (Brassicaceae): glacial persistence in multiple refugia and origin of the Northern Hemisphere disjunction. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 185, 321–342 (2017).
Simão, F. A., Waterhouse, R. M., Ioannidis, P., Kriventseva, E. V. & Zdobnov, E. M. BUSCO: assessing genome assembly and annotation completeness with single-copy orthologs. Bioinformatics 31, 3210–3212 (2015).
Kapusta, P., Szarek-Łukaszewska, G. & Stefanowicz, A. M. Direct and indirect effects of metal contamination on soil biota in a Zn–Pb post-mining and smelting area (S Poland). Environ. Pollut. 159, 1516–1522 (2011).
Frichot, E., Schoville, S. D., Bouchard, G. & François, O. Testing for associations between loci and environmental gradients using latent factor mixed models. Mol. Biol. Evol. 30, 1687–1699 (2013).
Günther, T. & Coop, G. Robust identification of local adaptation from allele frequencies. Genetics 195, 205–220 (2013).
Oleksyk, T. K., Smith, M. W. & O’Brien, S. J. Genome-wide scans for footprints of natural selection. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond., B, Biol. Sci. 365, 185–205 (2010).
Woch, M. W. In Natural and historical values of the Olkusz Ore-bearing Region (ed. Godzik, B.) 43–53 (Publishing House W. Szafer Institute of Botany, Polish Academy of Science, 2015).
Pavlidis, P., Jensen, J. D., Stephan, W. & Stamatakis, A. A critical assessment of storytelling: gene ontology categories and the importance of validating genomic scans. Mol. Biol. Evol. 29, 3237–3248 (2012).
Arrivault, S., Senger, T. & Krämer, U. The Arabidopsis metal tolerance protein AtMTP3 maintains metal homeostasis by mediating Zn exclusion from the shoot under Fe deficiency and Zn oversupply. Plant J. 46, 861–879 (2006).
Colangelo, E. P. & Guerinot, M. L. The essential basic helix-loop-helix protein FIT1 is required for the iron deficiency response. Plant Cell 16, 3400–3412 (2004).
Ricachenevsky, F. K., Menguer, P. K., Sperotto, R. A., Williams, L. E. & Fett, J. P. Roles of plant metal tolerance proteins (MTP) in metal storage and potential use in biofortification strategies. Front. Plant Sci. 4, 144 (2013).
Pauwels, M., Willems, G., Roosens, N., Frérot, H. & Saumitou-Laprade, P. Merging methods in molecular and ecological genetics to study the adaptation of plants to anthropogenic metal-polluted sites: implications for phytoremediation. Mol. Ecol. 17, 108–119 (2008).
Roosens, N. H. C. J., Willems, G. & Saumitou-Laprade, P. Using Arabidopsis to explore zinc tolerance and hyperaccumulation. Trends Plant Sci. 13, 208–215 (2008).
Krämer, U. Metal hyperaccumulation in plants. Annu. Rev. Plant Biol. 61, 517–534 (2010).
Fasani, E. et al. The MTP1 promoters from Arabidopsis halleri reveal cis-regulating elements for the evolution of metal tolerance. New Phytol. 214, 1614–1630 (2017).
Shahzad, Z. et al. The five AhMTP1 zinc transporters undergo different evolutionary fates towards adaptive evolution to zinc tolerance in Arabidopsis halleri. PLoS Genet. 6, e1000911 (2010).
Gao, Y.-Q. et al. A new vesicle trafficking regulator CTL1 plays a crucial role in ion homeostasis. PLoS Biol. 15, e2002978 (2017).
Wang, Y. et al. Arabidopsis choline transporter-like 1 (CTL1) regulates secretory trafficking of auxin transporters to control seedling growth. PLoS Biol. 15, e2004310 (2017).
Ahmad, P. et al. Jasmonates: multifunctional roles in stress tolerance. Front. Plant Sci. 7, 813 (2016).
Baier, M., Kandlbinder, A., Golldack, D. & Dietz, K.-J. Oxidative stress and ozone: perception, signalling and response. Plant Cell Environ. 28, 1012–1020 (2005).
Kangasjärvi, J., Jaspers, P. & Kollist, H. Signalling and cell death in ozone-exposed plants. Plant Cell Environ. 28, 1021–1036 (2005).
Shang, X., Cao, Y. & Ma, L. Alternative splicing in plant genes: a means of regulating the environmental fitness of plants. Int. J. Mol. Sci. 18 (2017).
Farooq, M. A. et al. Methyl jasmonate regulates antioxidant defense and suppresses arsenic uptake in Brassica napus L. Front. Plant Sci. 7, 468 (2016).
Per, T. S., Khan, N. A., Masood, A. & Fatma, M. Methyl jasmonate alleviates cadmium-induced photosynthetic damages through increased S-assimilation and glutathione production in mustard. Front. Plant Sci. 7, 1933 (2016).
Wu, J., Wang, L. & Baldwin, I. T. Methyl jasmonate-elicited herbivore resistance: does MeJA function as a signal without being hydrolyzed to JA? Planta 227, 1161–1168 (2008).
Pendle, A. F. et al. Proteomic analysis of the Arabidopsis nucleolus suggests novel nucleolar functions. Mol. Biol. Cell 16, 260–269 (2005).
Gill, S. S., Anjum, N. A., Gill, R., Jha, M. & Tuteja, N. DNA damage and repair in plants under ultraviolet and ionizing radiations. ScientificWorldJournal 2015, 11–11 (2015).
Rellstab, C., Zoller, S., Tedder, A., Gugerli, F. & Fischer, M. C. Validation of SNP allele frequencies determined by pooled next-generation sequencing in natural populations of a non-model plant species. PLoS ONE 8, e80422 (2013).
Akama, S., Shimizu-Inatsugi, R., Shimizu, K. K. & Sese, J. Genome-wide quantification of homeolog expression ratio revealed nonstochastic gene regulation in synthetic allopolyploid. Arabidopsis. Nucleic Acids Res. 42, e46–e46 (2014).
Fischer, M. C. et al. Estimating genomic diversity and population differentiation – an empirical comparison of microsatellite and SNP variation in Arabidopsis halleri. BMC Genomics 18, 69 (2017).
Lê, S., Josse, J. & Husson, F. FactoMineR: An R package for multivariate analysis. J. Stat. Soft. 25, 1–18 (2008).
R Developmental Core Team R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. R Foundation for Statistical Compution, Vienna, Austria http://www.R-project.org (2017).
Venables, W. N. & Ripley, B. D. Modern Applied Statistics with S. (Springer Science & Business Media, 2002).
Hebbali, A. olsrr: tools for building OLS regression models. https://CRAN.R-project.org/package=olsrr (2017).
Martin, M. Cutadapt removes adapter sequences from high-throughput sequencing reads. EMBnet.journal 17 pp. 10–12 (2011).
Li, H. Aligning sequence reads, clone sequences and assembly contigs with BWA-MEM. arXiv:1303.3997 [q-bio.GN] (2013).
Li, H. & Durbin, R. Fast and accurate short read alignment with Burrows-Wheeler transform. Bioinformatics 25, 1754–1760 (2009).
Barnett, D. W., Garrison, E. K., Quinlan, A. R., Strömberg, M. P. & Marth, G. T. BamTools: a C++ API and toolkit for analyzing and managing BAM files. Bioinformatics 27, 1691–1692 (2011).
Garrison, E. & Marth, G. Haplotype-based variant detection from short-read sequencing. arXiv1207.3907v2 [q-bio.GN] (2012).
Li, H. et al. The sequence alignment/map format and SAMtools. Bioinformatics 25, 2078–2079 (2009).
Frichot, E. & François, O. LEA: an R package for landscape and ecological association studies. Methods Ecol. Evol. 6, 925–929 (2015).
Hartl, D. L. & Clark, A. G. Principles of Population Genetics (Sinauer, 2007).
Tajima, F. Statistical-method for testing the neutral mutation hypothesis by DNA polymorphism. Genetics 123, 585–595 (1989).
Cingolani, P. et al. A program for annotating and predicting the effects of single nucleotide polymorphisms, SnpEff: SNPs in the genome of Drosophila melanogaster strainw1118; iso-2; iso-3. Fly (Austin) 6, 80–92 (2011).
Cheng, J., Randall, A. Z., Sweredoski, M. J. & Baldi, P. SCRATCH: a protein structure and structural feature prediction server. Nucleic Acids Res. 33, W72–76 (2005).
Atlas Florae Europaeae (eds Kurtto, A., Sennikov, A. N. & Lampinen, R.) 16, (The Committee for Mapping the Flora of Europe & Societas Biologica Fennica Vanamo, 2013).
We thank René Graf (molecular lab), Niklaus Zemp and Jean-Claude Walser (bioinformatics), Christian Beisel (next-generation sequencing), Barbara Łopata (fieldwork), and two anonymous reviewers (valuable input on the previous version of the manuscript). This work was supported by the WSL-internal project METALink (F.G., C.R., P.V., A.B.-K.), the SNSF Sinergia project AVE (A.W., F.G., M.C.F., S.Z., C.R.), and the POWROTY/REINTEGRATION programme of the Foundation for Polish Science co-financed by the European Union under the European Regional Development Fund (POWROTY/2016-1/1; A.B.-K.).
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher’s note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Electronic supplementary material
About this article
Cite this article
Sailer, C., Babst-Kostecka, A., Fischer, M.C. et al. Transmembrane transport and stress response genes play an important role in adaptation of Arabidopsis halleri to metalliferous soils. Sci Rep 8, 16085 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-33938-2
- Arabidopsis Halleri
- Trace Metal Elements (TME)
- Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNPs)
- Soil Variables
- Metallicolous Populations
Root and shoot biology of Arabidopsis halleri dissected by WGCNA: an insight into the organ pivotal pathways and genes of an hyperaccumulator
Functional & Integrative Genomics (2022)
Metalliferous habitats and seed microbes affect the seed morphology and reproductive strategy of Arabidopsis halleri
Plant and Soil (2022)