The formation, propagation, and maintenance of harmful algal blooms are of interest due to their negative effects on marine life and human health. Some bloom-forming algae utilize allelopathy, the release of compounds that inhibit competitors, to exclude other species dependent on a common pool of limiting resources. Allelopathy is hypothesized to affect bloom dynamics and is well established in the red tide dinoflagellate Karenia brevis. K. brevis typically suppresses competitor growth rather than being acutely toxic to other algae. When we investigated the effects of allelopathy on two competitors, Asterionellopsis glacialis and Thalassiosira pseudonana, using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and mass spectrometry (MS)-based metabolomics, we found that the lipidomes of both species were significantly altered. However, A. glacialis maintained a more robust metabolism in response to K. brevis allelopathy whereas T. pseudonana exhibited significant alterations in lipid synthesis, cell membrane integrity, and photosynthesis. Membrane-associated lipids were significantly suppressed for T. pseudonana exposed to allelopathy such that membranes of living cells became permeable. K. brevis allelopathy appears to target lipid biosynthesis affecting multiple physiological pathways suggesting that exuded compounds have the ability to significantly alter competitor physiology, giving K. brevis an edge over sensitive species.
Harmful algal blooms, dense congregations of marine phytoplankton that often produce noxious compounds, can be toxic to human and marine life and are becoming increasingly frequent1. In addition to killing fish, seabirds, and marine mammals, potent algal toxins exuded by bloom-forming phytoplankton accumulate in filter feeders and predators, eventually entering the human food web through contaminated seafood such as clams, oysters, and fish2,3,4,5,6. Toxins produced by some algae also persist in ambient waters, affecting human health through exposure to toxin-containing aerosols and cellular debris, leading to respiratory distress3,7,8,9.
Allelopathy, the release of compounds into the surrounding water that negatively affect competitors, is an important manifestation of competition that influences aquatic community structure10. Allelopathy can significantly alter species composition11,12 and species succession13,14 through lethal interactions14,15, as well as sub-lethal outcomes such as reduced growth16,17, induction of cyst formation18, and suppression of swimming behavior19,20. Little is known of the compounds responsible for allelopathy in the marine plankton or the molecular targets of allelopathy despite significant research21. Typically, toxins produced by these phytoplankton have not been shown to be allelopathic, with the exception of karlotoxins produced by the dinoflagellate Karlodinium veneficum22. A more thorough understanding of the modes of action of allelopathy and of the compounds responsible could enhance our understanding of the roles and ecosystem-wide impacts of allelopathy in algal blooms.
Karenia brevis, a dinoflagellate that blooms in the Gulf of Mexico and Southeastern Atlantic Ocean, produces a suite of neurotoxins called brevetoxins that cause neurotoxic shellfish poisoning in humans and marine life23. Despite their toxicity, brevetoxins are not responsible for observed allelopathic effects of K. brevis on competitors24,25,26. Instead, allelopathic compounds are yet uncharacterized fatty acid-derived lipids and aromatic molecules whose lack of stability has prevented complete characterization26. Potency of K. brevis allelopathy varies among blooms, strains, and cultured batches and its effects are selective towards certain competitor species in the early stages of growth24,27,28. Reduced growth, membrane integrity, and photosynthetic efficiency have previously been reported for allelopathy-affected competitors; however, the molecular explanation for these physiological responses is yet poorly understood27,29. K. brevis is a particularly useful model for addressing the metabolic responses of competitors to allelopathy as the effects of K. brevis exposure are sub-lethal24,25,28,29. Metabolomics can provide a snapshot of alterations to the collection of small molecule metabolites in an organism during allelopathic stress, providing broad, system-level insights into possible mechanisms of action and causative agents of physiological responses.
Using proteomics as well as analysis of the polar metabolomes of two competing phytoplankton, Asterionellopsis glacialis and Thalassiosira pseudonana, we previously showed that energy metabolism, osmoregulation, photosynthesis, and fatty acid synthesis were all disrupted due to K. brevis allelopathy29. Notably, various aspects of lipid metabolism appeared to be disrupted, with enhanced concentrations of enzymes associated with lipid anabolism, such as sulpholipid synthase and UDP-sulfoquinovose synthase, and decreased concentrations of certain lipids, such as terpene glycosides, when T. pseudonana was exposed to allelopathy29. This previous study, while providing significant insights into the molecular targets and metabolic pathways affected by allelopathy, was biased towards polar metabolites and therefore unable to fully describe the effect of allelopathy on competitor phytoplankton. The disruption of lipid metabolic enzymes and pathways has been shown to drive many human diseases and disorders, including diabetes, many forms of cancer, neurodegenerative disease, and infectious diseases30,31. Additionally, changes in lipid concentrations and the use of various lipids as signals is common in plants32,33, as well as in phytoplankton during stress34,35.
The previously observed complex response of lipid metabolism to allelopathy29, coupled with the importance of the lipidome in regulating stress responses in many systems, led us to investigate the impacts of K. brevis allelopathy on the lipidome of competitors. Using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and mass spectrometry (MS)-based metabolomics we identified the major metabolic effects of K. brevis allelopathy on the lipidomes (i.e., nonpolar metabolites) of two competitors, A. glacialis, which co-occurs with K. brevis during blooms and T. pseudonana, which originates from non-bloom areas, in order to achieve a more complete understanding of the physiological responses and mode of action of allelopathy. Insights from these new analyses include not only that the magnitude of the allelopathic effect is much more pronounced on the lipidome than on polar metabolites, and also that cell membrane stability, lipid metabolism, and thylakoid-associated lipid concentrations are dramatically impacted by allelopathy.
Allelopathy affects the lipidomes of competing phytoplankton
In the current study, K. brevis allelopathy significantly affected the lipidomes of both competitor species T. pseudonana and A. glacialis (Fig. 1), even more dramatically than was previously observed for polar metabolites29. When we employed a multi-platform metabolomics approach combining NMR spectroscopy and MS, algae exposed to K. brevis allelopathy were distinguished from algae grown alone based on chemical dissimilarities in their lipidomes (Fig. 1). Orthogonal partial least squares discriminant analysis (oPLS-DA) identified a subset of spectral features corresponding to putatively identified metabolites that differentiated algae exposed to K. brevis allelopathy from controls. The concentration of any individual molecule alone could not comprehensively describe the differences in plankton lipidomes, but when combined as part of a discriminating panel they accurately differentiated the treatment effects of exposure to K. brevis allelopathy.
Principal component analysis (PCA) models were also generated; however, the discriminating power of most of these models was insufficient to identify algae based on their exposure to K. brevis allelopathy (Fig. S1). Despite this lack of discriminatory power, PCA of T. pseudonana metabolome profiles obtained via ultra-high performance liquid chromatography mass spectrometry (UHPLC/MS) accurately classified algae as having been exposed or unexposed to K. brevis (Fig. S1B). However, the rest of these PCA scores plots thus suggested the need for supervised multivariate classification tools to describe differences in the lipidomes, as well as to determine which variables or features were most critical in distinguishing between exposed and unexposed algae. Because MS is more sensitive than NMR spectroscopy and therefore allowed detection of differences in lower abundance metabolite concentrations, the ability of the MS-based PCA model to successfully differentiate between T. pseudonana exposed or not exposed to K. brevis was not surprising, and consistent with previous findings29.
Metabolic responses to allelopathy are conserved among competitors, despite differential sensitivities
MS-based metabolomics analysis of lipidomes led to identification of 80 lipid metabolites whose concentrations differed significantly in T. pseudonana depending on exposure to K. brevis allelopathy (Table S1). Of these metabolites, 33 were significantly more abundant whereas 47 were significantly less abundant when T. pseudonana experienced K. brevis allelopathy (Fig. 2), with many of the metabolites exhibiting considerable fold differences due to K. brevis exposure (Table 1). These 80 metabolites represent nine major lipid classes, of which members of five (phosphatidylcholines [PCs], sulfoquinovosyldiacylglycerides [SQDGs], monogalactosyldiacylglycerides [MGDGs], digalactosyldiacylglycerides [DGDGs], and phosphatidylglycerols [PGs]) were generally less abundant when T. pseudonana was subjected to K. brevis allelopathy, whereas members of four classes (non-SQDG sulfonated lipids [SULF], free fatty acids [FFAs], primary fatty acid amides [PFAAs], and phosphatidylethanolamines [PEs]) were generally more abundant due to allelopathy (Table 1). In contrast, for the other competitor, A. glacialis, concentrations of only six metabolites were significantly affected by allelopathy, reinforcing that A. glacialis maintains a more robust metabolism in response to K. brevis allelopathy (Fig. 2, Tables S1 and S2). All six A. glacialis lipid metabolites whose concentrations varied with exposure to allelopathy were also modulated in T. pseudonana, all experiencing enhanced concentrations in both competitor species due to K. brevis exposure.
In addition to observing mass spectral features that represent SQDGs, MGDGs, DGDGs, PCs, and PGs as major lipid classes affected by allelopathy (Table 1), five additional metabolites whose concentrations were suppressed in T. pseudonana by K. brevis allelopathy were revealed only by NMR spectroscopic analysis. They were identified as aconitic acid, malonic acid, methyl guanidine, N-acetyl cysteine, and N-acetyl glutamine.
Cell membrane integrity is weakened by K. brevis allelopathy
Upon inspection of the identities of disrupted lipids in the current study, two major classes of lipids common to cell and thylakoid membranes were noted as being significantly affected by allelopathy: SQDGs and MGDGs. Prince et al. had previously found cell membranes of some competing algae to be disrupted upon exposure to K. brevis allelopathy27; however, T. pseudonana was not tested in that study. In the current study, following exposure to K. brevis for six days, the proportion of living T. pseudonana cells with permeable and therefore damaged cell membranes was significantly greater than for unexposed T. pseudonana (Figs 3 and S2). T. pseudonana exposed to caged or uncaged K. brevis experienced similarly suppressed growth rates and increased membrane permeability relative to dilute media controls, suggesting that cell-cell physical contact does not compound the effect of allelopathy on membrane stability. In contrast to the negative effects of K. brevis exposure, the exposure of T. pseudonana to caged members of its own species was not significantly different than T. pseudonana exposed to cages containing dilute media. Overall, these findings confirm that one of the major mechanisms or outcomes of allelopathy is via cell membrane disruption, possibly due to a decreased concentration of membrane lipids such as SQDGs and MGDGs.
Dominant impact of allelopathy on competitor lipidome
The major metabolic responses of two model algae indicate that a dominant consequence of K. brevis allelopathy is increased membrane permeability and decreased photosynthetic capability, both likely due to decreases in the concentrations of membrane- and thylakoid-associated lipids (Figs 1–3 and Table 1). Decreases in the concentrations of cell membrane associated PCs, SQDGs, and PGs (Tables 1 and S1) and permeabilization of the cell wall (Figs 3 and S2) suggested that allelopathy significantly disrupts membrane integrity by altering the lipid content without directly killing cells. Similarly, previously observed reduction in photosynthetic efficiency, as evidenced by decreases in the maximum quantum yield of photosystem II27 and in expression of 12 photosynthesis-related proteins29 could be due to damage to the thylakoid membrane and significant suppression of MGDGs, DGDGs, and SQDGs (Tables 1 and S1).
K. brevis allelopathy damages competitor cell membranes
Allelopathy-induced cell membrane permeabilization and depolarization is common in terrestrial plants36,37,38; however, it does not appear to be well known in phytoplankton (but see ref.27). Fluorescent staining of T. pseudonana showed that K. brevis allelopathy significantly reduced cell membrane integrity in living T. pseudonana cells (Figs 3 and S2). This increased permeability could have been caused by decreased abundance of membrane-associated lipids (Table 1). Whether T. pseudonana and K. brevis cells were in physical contact did not affect competitive outcomes between the two species, indicating that allelopathy occurs via waterborne cues and is the dominant cause of reduced competitor growth and membrane destabilization (Fig. 3). This pattern of lipid disruption was also suggested by the polar metabolome of T. pseudonana when exposed to K. brevis allelopathy suggesting that one of the major outcomes of allelopathy prior to cell death is cell membrane destabilization29. Despite this prior report, no molecular mechanism of action for K. brevis allelopathy has been described to account for the observed phenotypic response. Copepod eggs were also found to have significantly altered membrane morphology after three days of feeding on K. brevis, suggesting that the allelopathic compounds released by K. brevis could possibly be responsible for more ubiquitous membrane damage in competitors and grazers39. The current work implicates decreases in PCs, SQDGs, and PGs as molecular underpinnings of cell membrane destabilization (Tables 1 and S1).
Thylakoid-associated lipids are significantly disrupted by allelopathy
A second likely mechanism by which allelopathy affects competitor physiology is reduction of photosynthetic efficiency, which has been previously reported for diatom competitors exposed to K. brevis27. Previously, we showed that the concentrations of 12 photosynthesis-related proteins significantly decreased in response to K. brevis allelopathy29. Here we show that MGDGs, DGDGs, and SQDGs are also less abundant when competing algae are exposed to allelopathy (Tables 1, S1 and S2). MGDGs and DGDGs are the most abundant lipids in chloroplasts, constituting up to 80% of total plastidic lipid content40. In Arabidopsis leaves, higher MGDG content in the chloroplast led to maintenance of photosynthetic activity when subjected to ethylene-promoted senescence41. Additionally, plastids have been shown to elongate in mustard seedlings when exposed to high enough concentrations of the known allelochemical benzoic acid42. In general, the current findings suggest that a likely explanation for the observed loss in photosynthetic efficiency27 is destabilization of plastid membranes. While no direct experimental evidence exists in the current study that the number of plastids decreased or that thylakoid membranes became permeable, the downregulation of thylakoid-associated lipids and known consequences of allelopathy on plastids warrant additional tests of this hypothesis.
Competitors display different responses to K. brevis allelopathy
Previous research using K. brevis culture filtrates and extra-cellular extracts showed that competing algae exhibit differential sensitivities to K. brevis allelopathy24,25,27,29. Although we cannot fully eliminate the possibility that resource limitation play a role in competition between K. brevis and diatoms given this particular co-culture design, our results demonstrate detrimental effects of competition on diatom physiology. Our previous work demonstrating that K. brevis produces a suite of allelopathic compounds26, coupled with the relatively nutrient rich environment of these co-cultures29, suggests that allelopathy is a major mechanism by which K. brevis competes. Herein we report that both competitor species studied, A. glacialis and T. pseudonana, are affected by allelopathy, although T. pseudonana was significantly more sensitive (Fig. 1, Tables 1, S1 and S2). These findings support the previously posited hypothesis that A. glacialis possesses resistance mechanism(s) to mitigate the physiological impacts of allelopathy29. The long-term geographic and seasonal co-occurrence of A. glacialis and K. brevis may have provided the selection pressure for A. glacialis to evolve resistance, which T. pseudonana has not yet acquired29.
Consideration of the specific classes of lipids most affected in T. pseudonana by allelopathy (PC, SQDG, PFAA, FFA, and taurolipids) suggests that a majority of lipids induced (PFAA, FFA, and SULF) by allelopathic exposure are either metabolic breakdown products or metabolic precursors of PCs and SQDGs, whose pools shrunk in T. pseudonana upon exposure to allelopathy. These findings allow for two possible mechanisms: the stress of allelopathic exposure leads to the degradation of complex lipids, such as SQDGs and PCs, to their less complex components; or, allelopathic compounds exuded by K. brevis inhibit the biosynthetic enzymes within T. pseudonana that are responsible for the anabolic synthesis of complex lipids from more simple building blocks, resulting in a build-up of biosynthetic precursors (PFAA, FFA) and a loss of more complex lipids (SQDG, PC). Breakdown of more complex lipids to smaller products has been observed in the green alga Dunaliella salina, where the degradation of MGDGs to DGDGs was observed using radiolabeled carbon precursors43. In the current case of K. brevis allelopathy affecting T. pseudonana, the observed increase in concentrations, rather than decrease, of lipid biosynthetic enzymes such as sulpholipid synthase and UDP-sulfoquinovose synthase29, favors the hypothesis that complex lipids are degraded in response to allelopathy.
Complementing the MS lipidomic analysis, NMR spectroscopic profiling revealed that additional essential metabolites in T. pseudonana were disrupted by K. brevis allelopathy. Aconitic acid, an intermediate in the TCA cycle, and malonic acid, intermediate building block for fatty acid synthesis, were both less abundant due to allelopathy, which could be explained by the degradation of these acids, an enhanced production of some fatty acids thus reducing cellular stocks of starting materials and intermediates, or the slowdown in anabolism of these acids44,45. Three methylated and acetylated amino acids were also suppressed which point to alterations in amino acid metabolism as a consequence of allelopathic exposure. None of the five compounds identified via NMR spectroscopic profiling were identified as components of the MS-based model, highlighting the complementary nature of NMR and MS profiling.
K. brevis’ sub-lethal allelopathy provides a unique study system
K. brevis is relatively mild among allelopathic algae, some of which release compounds that are acutely toxic to other algae46,47,48,49,50. K. brevis allelopathy acts slowly on competitors, affecting cell viability and population growth over days by weakening cell membranes, impeding photosynthesis, and disrupting osmoregulation29. In contrast, Alexandrium dinoflagellates can cause lysis of competitor cells in minutes to hours46,50. The freshwater dinoflagellate Peridinium aciculiferum produces bubbles that later burst leading to cell death in its competitor Rhodomonas lacustris49. Due to the slow acting allelopathic effects of K. brevis, we were able to observe the disruption of lipid metabolism, which ultimately leads to catastrophic effects on membrane integrity and photosynthesis in some competing algae (Figs 3 and S2, Table 1).
Lipidomics provides essential knowledge on how competitors respond to allelopathy
In the current study focused on lipidomics, we show that the major effects of K. brevis allelopathy on T. pseudonana are permeabilization of cell membranes and significant decreases in the concentrations of membrane-associated lipids, including those typically associated with the thylakoid and cell membranes (Figs 3 and S2, Tables 1, S1 and S2). This complements previous findings regarding the polar metabolome and proteome in which we showed that T. pseudonana suffered significantly increased glycolysis activity, suppressed osmoregulation, enhanced enzymatic capabilities related to oxidative stress, as well as an increase in proteins associated with the pentose phosphate pathway and anti-trypsin protease inhibitors, when exposed to K. brevis allelopathy29. K. brevis allelopathy is, however, known to be highly variable and does not typically lead to devastating effects on cell growth51. The integration of metabolomics involving both polar and non-polar classes with proteomics analysis suggests that K. brevis allelopathy drastically affects T. pseudonana cellular functions on many levels. Cell membrane permeability, significantly altered metabolism, and decreased photosynthesis together paint a dreary picture for T. pseudonana. The current lipidomics work offers a glimpse into the robust metabolome of a more resistant competitor, A. glacialis, providing unique opportunities for exploring mechanisms of resistance to allelopathy.
Materials and Methods
Generation and preparation of extracts for lipidomics
Lipids were accessed from intracellular phytoplankton extracts obtained for the experiment described by Poulson-Ellestad et al.29. Briefly, diatoms Thalassiosira pseudonana strain CCMP 1335 and Asterionellopsis glacialis strain CCMP 137 were grown in silicate-amended L1 media in artificial seawater (Instant Ocean, 35 ppt). Karenia brevis strain CCMP 2228 was cultured in similar conditions above with L1 media-amended artificial seawater. All cultures were maintained at 21 °C with a 12:12 light/dark cycle and an irradiance of 100–145 µmol/m2 s in a Percival incubator (Biospherical Instrument QSL2100). Diatom cell concentrations were quantified via in vivo fluorescence as a proxy for cell concentration or by visual counts under microscope. A Fluid Imaging Technologies FlowCam was used to determine K. brevis cell concentrations.
To expose competitors to allelopathic K. brevis, K. brevis was co-cultured with each of the two diatom species (n = 14 per species). K. brevis was grown inside a permeable dialysis membrane (SpectraPor 7, MWCO 50 kDa) to allow for exchange of exuded allelopathic compounds without direct interaction of K. brevis and diatom cells, which were grown in flasks in which the dialysis tubes were placed. Control cultures consisted of dialysis membranes filled with L1 media diluted to conditions similar to that of exponential growth phase K. brevis29 (n = 15 per diatom species) in order to account for the potential of nutrient limitation on the lipidomes of competitors. This co-culture experiment was halted once competitor cultures reached exponential growth stage, which was 6 d for T. pseudonana and 8 d for A. glacialis, after which diatom cells were filtered onto GF/C filters (Whatman #1922–110, muffled at 450 °C for 3 h) and dipped into liquid nitrogen to quench intracellular metabolism. Filtered cells were stored at −80 °C until extraction. Cells were ground with a liquid nitrogen-cooled mortar and pestle, and extracted with 30 mL of an ice-cold mixture of 3:1:2 methanol/acetone/acetonitrile. Particulate matter was removed via centrifugation (5 min at 0 °C, 1,460xg) and the supernatant was removed. Cell pellets were rinsed twice with 10 mL of fresh solvent mixture and a final 3 mL rinse. Rinses were added to the supernatant and solvent was removed in vacuo.
To separate polar and lipid intracellular metabolites, dried extracts were dissolved in a biphasic mixture of 9:10:15 water/methanol/chloroform. The more lipophilic layer was removed and washed twice with 9:10 water/methanol. Polar metabolites of diatoms undergoing stress from competition with K. brevis were previously reported by Poulson-Ellestad et al.29. For the current work, the lipid-soluble chloroform-methanol fractions were analyzed by 1H NMR spectroscopy and ultrahigh performance liquid chromatography mass spectrometry (UHPLC/MS) metabolomics. (See SI Materials and Methods for sample preparation, procedures, and analytical method parameters).
Prior to multivariate modeling, NMR52 and MS spectral data were preprocessed (See SI Materials and Methods). Principal component analysis (PCA) and orthogonal partial least squares discriminant analysis (oPLS-DA) models were generated to investigate the effect of K. brevis allelopathy on algal lipidomes (MATLAB and PLS Toolbox, version 7.9.1, Eigenvector research). Spectral features with discriminatory power in NMR-based models were annotated using the Human Metabolome Database and Chenomx Profiler while MS-based features were annotated using LOBSTAHS53, KEGG, LIPID MAPS, and Metlin databases53,54,55,56,57,58. Pooled extracts of each species were used to collect 2D NMR spectral data including: correlation spectroscopy (COSY), heteronuclear single quantum coherence (HSQC), and heteronuclear multiple bond correlation spectroscopy (HMBC) to aid in annotation.
Membrane permeability assay
To detect differences in membrane permeability between T. pseudonana grown in the presence vs. absence of K. brevis, 100 mL media bottle containing 50 mL silicate-amended L1 media were inoculated with T. pseudonana to a concentration of ~1.0 × 104 cells mL−1. Cages made of 50 mL falcon tubes with 1 μm mesh bottoms containing 25 mL of either silicate-amended L1 media diluted to similar conditions to that of exponential growth phase K. brevis29 (control, n = 5), K. brevis (~1.0 × 104 cells mL−1) (treatment, n = 5), or T. pseudonana (~1.0 × 104 cells mL−1) (treatment, n = 5) were added to the T. pseudonana cultures. In a fourth treatment 25 mL of K. brevis (~1.0 × 104 cells mL−1) were added directly to the T. pseudonana cultures without a cage (n = 5) but with the same total volume as for the other treatments. Cultures were rearranged daily and cages were gently moved up and down twice per day to maximize exposure of T. pseudonana to the allelopathic compounds of K. brevis. After five days, two 500 μL samples of T. pseudonana were removed from experimental flasks. The first sample was preserved with an acidified Lugol’s solution for measurement of total cell concentration. The second sample was stained by direct addition of 20 μL Neutral Red solution (0.05% w:v in deionized water, Mallinckrodt Chemical) followed by the addition of 10 μL SYTOX Green solution (50 μM in DMSO, Invitrogen Molecular Probes, detected with excitation at 504 nm and emission at 523 nm) 30 min later, to test for live and permeable cells, respectively. The stained cells were incubated in darkness at room temperature for 1 hr prior to counting to allow T. pseudonana to uptake dyes. All cells were counted within 6 hrs of staining, using fluorescence and bright-field microscopy on an Olympus IX-50 inverted microscope with a Palmer-Maloney settling chamber, at 400X magnification (40X objective and 10X eyepiece). This enabled determination of the ratio of living cells with permeable membranes (red and fluorescent green) to the total number of living cells (red but not fluorescent green). Bonferroni corrected unpaired t-tests (α = 0.0167 for three comparisons) were conducted to test statistical significance of membrane destabilization and growth rate suppression of T. pseudonana exposed to dilute media controls vs. the other three treatments using Prism graphpad version 4.0. The membrane permeability assay was completed on three separate occasions with similar outcomes.
Data generated during and/or analyzed during the current study are available in the BMO-DCO repository, www.bco-dmo.org/project/528925.
Glibert, P. M., Anderson, D. M., Gentien, P., Granéli, E. & Sellner, K. G. The global, complex phenomena of harmful algal blooms. Oceanography 18, 136–147 (2005).
Backer, L. C. et al. Recreational exposure to aerosolized brevetoxins during Florida red tide events. Harmful Algae 2, 19–28 (2003).
Backer, L. C. et al. Occupational exposure to aerosolized brevetoxins during Florida red tide events: effects on a healthy worker population. Environ Health Perspect 113, 644–649 (2005).
Fleming, L. E. et al. Review of Florida red tide and human health effects. Harmful Algae 10 (2011).
Flewelling, L. J. et al. Brevetoxicosis: red tides and marine mammal mortalities. Nature 435, 755–756 (2005).
Scholin, C. A. et al. Mortality of sea lions along the central California coast linked to a toxic diatom bloom. Nature 403, 80–84 (2000).
Fleming, L. E., Backer, L. C. & Baden, D. G. Overview of aerosolized Florida red tide toxins: exposures and effects. Environ Health Perspect 113, 618–620 (2005).
Fleming, L. E. et al. Initial evaluation of the effects of aerosolized Florida red tide toxins (brevetoxins) in persons with asthma. Environ Health Perspect 113, 650–657 (2005).
Music, S. I., Howell, J. T. & Brumback, C. L. Red tide. Its public health implications. JFMA 60, 27–29 (1973).
Wardle, D. A., Karban, R. & Callaway, R. M. The ecosystem and evolutionary contexts of allelopathy. Trend Ecol Evol 26, 655–662 (2011).
Fistarol, G. O., Legrand, C. & Granéli, E. Allelopathic effect of Prymnesium parvum on a natural plankton community. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 255, 115–125 (2003).
Uronen, P., Kuuppo, P., Legrand, C. & Tamminen, T. Allelopathic effects of toxic haptophyte Prymnesium parvum lead to release of dissolved organic carbon and increase in bacterial biomass. Microb Ecol 54, 183–193 (2007).
Keating, K. I. Allelopathic influence on blue-green bloom sequence in a eutrophic lake. Science 196, 885–887 (1977).
Vardi, A. et al. Dinoflagellate-cyanobacterium communication may determine the composition of phytoplankton assemblage in a mesotrophic lake. Curr Biol 12, 1767–1772 (2002).
Ma, H., Krock, B., Tillmann, U. & Cembella, A. Preliminary characterization of extracellular allelochemicals of the toxic marine dinoflagellate Alexandrium tamarense using a Rhodomonas salina bioassay. Mar Drugs 7, 497–522 (2009).
Ribalet, F., Berges, J. A., Ianora, A. & Casotti, R. Growth inhibition of cultured marine phytoplankton by toxic algal-derived polyunsaturated aldehydes. Aquat Toxicol 85, 219–227 (2007).
Suikkanen, S., Engström-Öst, J., Jokela, J., Sivonen, K. & Viitasalo, M. Allelopathy of Baltic Sea cyanobacteria: no evidence for the role of nodularin. J Plankton Res 28, 543–550 (2006).
Fistarol, G. O., Legrand, C., Rengefors, K. & Granéli, E. Temporary cyst formation in phytoplankton: a response to allelopathic competitors? Environ Microbiol 6, 791–798 (2004).
Tillmann, U. & John, U. Toxic effects of Alexandrium spp. on heterotrophic dinoflagellates: an allelochemical defence mechanism independent of PSP-toxin content. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 230, 47–58 (2002).
Tillmann, U., John, U. & Cembella, A. On the allelochemical potency of the marine dinoflagellate Alexandrium ostenfeldii against heterotrophic and autotrophic protists. J Plankton Res 29, 527–543 (2007).
Schwartz, E. R., Poulin, R. X., Mojib, N. & Kubanek, J. Chemical ecology of marine plankton. Nat Prod Rep 33, 843–860 (2016).
Sheng, J., Malkiel, E., Katz, J., Adolf, J. E. & Place, A. R. A dinoflagellate exploits toxins to immobilize prey prior to ingestion. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 107, 2082–2087 (2010).
Landsberg, J., Flewelling, L. & Naar, J. Karenia brevis red tides, brevetoxins in the food web, and impacts on natural resources: Decadal advancements. Harmful Algae 8, 598–607 (2009).
Kubanek, J., Hicks, M. K., Naar, J. & Villareal, T. A. Does the red tide dinoflagellate Karenia brevis use allelopathy to outcompete other phytoplankton? Limnol Oceanog 50, 883–895 (2005).
Prince, E. K., Myers, T. L., Naar, J. & Kubanek, J. Competing phytoplankton undermines allelopathy of a bloom-forming dinoflagellate. Proc R Soc B 275, 2733–2741 (2008).
Prince, E. K., Poulson, K. L., Myers, T. L., Sieg, R. D. & Kubanek, J. Characterization of allelopathic compounds from the red tide dinoflagellate Karenia brevis. Harmful Algae 10, 39–48 (2010).
Prince, E. K., Myers, T. L. & Kubanek, J. Effects of harmful algal blooms on competitors: Allelopathic mechanisms of the red tide dinoflagellate Karenia brevis. Limnol Oceanog 53, 531–541 (2008).
Poulson, K. L., Sieg, R. D., Prince, E. K. & Kubanek, J. Allelopathic compounds of a red tide dinoflagellate have species-specific and context-dependent impacts on phytoplankton. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 416, 69–78 (2010).
Poulson-Ellestad, K. L. et al. Metabolomics and proteomics reveal impacts of chemically mediated competition on marine plankton. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 111, 9009–9014 (2014).
Vance, J. E. Lipid imbalance in the neurological disorder, Niemann‐Pick C disease. FEBS Letters 580, 5518–5524 (2006).
Wenk, M. R. The emerging field of lipidomics. Nat Rev Drug Discov 4, 594 (2005).
Testerink, C. & Munnik, T. Phosphatidic acid: a multifunctional stress signaling lipid in plants. Trends Plant Sci 10, 368–375 (2005).
Welti, R. et al. Profiling membrane lipids in plant stress responses role of phospholipase Dα in freezing-induced lipid changes in. Arabidopsis. J Biol Chem 277, 31994–32002 (2002).
Hessen, D., Lange, D. E. h. & van Donk, E. UV‐induced changes in phytoplankton cells and its effects on grazers. Freshwater Biol 38, 513–524 (1997).
Van Mooy, B. A. et al. Phytoplankton in the ocean use non-phosphorus lipids in response to phosphorus scarcity. Nature 458, 69 (2009).
Bates, G. W. & Goldsmith, M. H. M. Rapid response of the plasma-membrane potential in oat coleoptiles to auxin and other weak acids. Planta 159, 231–237 (1983).
Dakshini, K. & Einhellig, F. A. Allelopathy: organisms, processes, and applications (ACS Publications, 1994).
Glass, A. D. & Dunlop, J. Influence of phenolic acids on ion uptake. Plant Physiol 54, 855–858 (1974).
Lauritano, C., Carotenuto, Y., Procaccini, G., Turner, J. T. & Ianora, A. Changes in expression of stress genes in copepods feeding upon a non-brevetoxin-producing strain of the dinoflagellate Karenia brevis. Harmful Algae 28, 23–30 (2013).
Devaiah, S. P. et al. Quantitative profiling of polar glycerolipid species from organs of wild-type Arabidopsis and a phospholipast Dα1 knockout mutant. Phytochem 67, 1907–1924 (2006).
Jia, Y. & Li, W. Characterisation of lipid changes in ethylene-promoted senescence and its retardation by suppression of phospholipase Dδ in Arabidopsis leaves. Front Plant Sci 6 (2015).
Kaur, H. & Kaushik, S. Cellular evidence of allelopathic interference of benzoic acid to mustard (Brassica juncea L.) seedling growth. Plant Physiol Biochem 43, 77–81 (2005).
Cho, S. H. & Thompson, G. On the metabolic relationships between monogalactosyldiacylglycerol and digalactosyldiacylglycerol molecular species in Dunaliella salina. J Biol Chem 262, 7586–7593 (1987).
Krebs, H. & Eggleston, L. Metabolism of acetoacetic acid in animal tissues. Nature 154, 209–210 (1944).
Wakil, S. J. A malonic acid derivative as an intermediate in fatty acid synthesis. J Am Chem Soc 80, 6465–6465 (1958).
Hansen, P. J. The red tide dinoflagellate Alexandrium tamarense: effects on behaviour and growth of a tintinnid ciliate. Mar Ecol Prog Ser, 105–116 (1989).
Granéli, E., Edvardsen, B., Roelke, D. L. & Hagström, J. A. The ecophysiology and bloom dynamics of Prymnesium spp. Harmful Algae 14, 260–270 (2012).
Ribalet, F. et al. Phytoplankton cell lysis associated with polyunsaturated aldehyde release in the Northern Adriatic Sea. Plos One 9, e85947 (2014).
Rengefors, K. & Legrand, C. Toxicity in Peridinium aciculiferum—an adaptive strategy to outcompete other winter phytoplankton? Limnol Oceanog 46, 1990–1997 (2001).
Tillmann, U. & Hansen, P. J. Allelopathic effects of Alexandrium tamarense on other algae: evidence from mixed growth experiments. Aquat Microb Ecol 57, 101–112 (2009).
Poulin, R. X., Poulson-Ellestad, K. L., Roy, J. S. & Kubanek, J. Variable allelopathy among phytoplankton reflected in red tide metabolome. Harmful Algae 71, 50–56 (2018).
Günther, U. L., Ludwig, C. & Ruterjans, H. NMRLAB-Advanced NMR data processing in matlab. J Magn Reson 145, 201–208 (2000).
Collins, J. R., Edwards, B. R., Fredricks, H. F. & Van Mooy, B. A. LOBSTAHS: An adduct-based lipidomics strategy for discovery and identification of oxidative stress biomarkers. Anal Chem 88, 7154–7162 (2016).
Wishart, D. S. et al. HMDB 3.0—the human metabolome database in 2013. Nucleic Acids Res 41, D801–D807 (2012).
Weljie, A. M., Newton, J., Mercier, P., Carlson, E. & Slupsky, C. M. Targeted profiling: quantitative analysis of 1H NMR metabolomics data. Anal Chem 78, 4430–4442 (2006).
Kanehisa, M. The KEGG database. ‘In Silico’ Simulation of Biological Processes 247, 91–103 (2002).
Fahy, E. et al. Update of the LIPID MAPS comprehensive classification system for lipids. J Lipid Res 50, S9–S14 (2009).
Smith, C. A. et al. METLIN: a metabolite mass spectral database. Ther Drug Monit 27, 747–751 (2005).
The authors acknowledge support from NSF grants OCE-1060300 and OCE-1234449. The authors thank T. Alexander, C. Jones, E. McMillan, J. Roy, D. Sieg, K. Syhapanha, and M. Teasdale for assistance with culturing experiments and extraction of algae; U.L. Günter and C. Ludwig for access and support with Metabolab software; L. Gelbaum and J. Leisen for assistance with NMR spectroscopy; B. Van Mooy, H. Fredricks, and J. Collins for assistance with LOBSTAHS database.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Electronic supplementary material
About this article
Cite this article
Poulin, R.X., Hogan, S., Poulson-Ellestad, K.L. et al. Karenia brevis allelopathy compromises the lipidome, membrane integrity, and photosynthesis of competitors. Sci Rep 8, 9572 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-27845-9
This article is cited by
The ISME Journal (2023)
Nature Reviews Microbiology (2023)
Physiology and Molecular Biology of Plants (2023)
An innovative strategy to control Microcystis growth using tea polyphenols sustained-release particles: preparation, characterization, and inhibition mechanism
Environmental Science and Pollution Research (2023)
Assessment of the allelochemical activity of Ostreopsis cf. ovata and the ovatoxins towards competitive benthic microalgae
Aquatic Ecology (2022)