Amoebae of the genus Acanthamoeba are ubiquitous protists that have been isolated from many sources such as soils, water and the air. They are responsible for infections including fatal encephalitis and a severe keratitis in humans. To date, there is no satisfactorily effective therapeutic agent against this pathogen and the infections it causes are exacerbated by the existence of a resistant cyst stage produced by this amoeba. As dry eye syndrome is a risk factor for Acanthamoeba keratitis, we aimed to evaluate the anti-Acanthamoeba activity of a variety of proprietary eye drops intended to treat dry eye syndrome. From the nine eye drop formulations tested, “Systane Ultra” was determined to be the most active against all tested Acanthamoeba strains. During our investigations into the mode of action of Systane Ultra, we discovered that it decreases mitochondrial membrane potential and ATP levels, induces chromatin condensation, and increases the permeability of the plasma-membrane.
Acanthamoeba keratitis (AK) is increasingly being recognized as a serious infection of the cornea that can lead to a permanent visual impairment or even blindness1. In the developed world, AK is most often found in contact lens users particularly where poor hygiene has been practiced. AK is difficult to diagnose partly because clinicians rarely encounter this infection but also because the symptoms mimic those of other types of keratitis diseases (viral, bacterial and fungal). Patients with AK may experience eye pain and redness, blurred vision, photophobia and excessive tear production1. Dry eyes disease (DED) is a more common ocular surface disease that has a severe impact both on quality of live and on cost but it is also a predisposing risk factor for the development of AK2. DED results from either a systemic immunologic disorder known as Sjögren’s syndrome3 in which there is insufficient production of moisture in the salivary and tear-producing glands, or from the low production or high evaporation of tears caused by other means4. Its severity may range from mild/episodic to severe/chronic and the disease is characterized by several symptoms including visual disturbance (blurred and fluctuating vision), foreign-body sensation and eye discomfort, irritation, ocular surface inflammation, redness, excess tearing, and photophobia5. DED is treated with a range of proprietary eye drops which contain a variety of active ingredients. We could find no previous studies describing the potential anti-Acanthamoeba activity of eye dry drops, and so the aim of the present study was to assess the potential anti-amoebic activity of several eye dry drops solutions, against a range of Acanthamoeba strains.
Material and Methods
Nine proprietary eye drop solutions available commercially for topical use against DED were selected for analysis. Table 1 shows the details of the composition of these solutions.
In vitro drug sensitivity assay
The anti-Acanthamoeba activity of the selected eye drops were initially evaluated against the Acanthamoeba castellanii Neff (ATCC 30010) type strain from the American Type Culture Collection. Subsequently, eye drop solutions were tested against three clinical isolates, CLC-16 and Acanthamoeba griffini, genotype T3 and CLC-51, genotype T1 obtained in previous studies6,7. Those strains were grown axenically in PYG medium (0.75% (w/v) proteose peptone, 0.75% (w/v) yeast extract and 1.5% (w/v) glucose) containing 40 μg gentamicin ml−1 (Biochrom AG, Cultek, Granollers, Barcelona, Spain).
In vitro effect against the trophozoite stage of Acanthamoeba
The anti-Acanthamoeba activities of the eye drop solutions were determined by the Alamar Blue assay as previously described6,8. Briefly, Acanthamoeba strains were seeded in duplicate on a 96-well microtiter plate with 50 μl from a stock solution of 104 cells ml−1. Amoebae were allowed to adhere for 15 min and 50 μl of serial dilution series of the eye drop solution was added. Finally, the Alamar Blue Assay Reagent (Bioresource, Europe, Nivelles, Belgium) was added into each well at an amount equal to 10% of the medium volume. The plates were then incubated for 120 h at 28 °C with a slight agitation. Subsequently the plates were analyzed, during an interval of time between 72 and 144 h, with an Enspire microplate reader (PerkinElmer, Massachusetts, USA) using a test wavelength of 570 nm and a reference wavelength of 630 nm. Percentages of growth inhibition, 50% and 90% inhibitory concentrations (IC50 and IC90) were calculated by linear regression analysis with 95% confidence limits. All experiments were performed three times each in duplicate, and the mean values were calculated.
In vitro effect against the cyst stage of Acanthamoeba
The cysticidal activity was determined by the Alamar Blue assay at 144 h and confirmed visually by inverted microscopy. A. castellanii Neff cysts were prepared as described by Lorenzo-Morales et al.9. Briefly, trophozoite were transferred from PYG medium based cultures (trophozoite medium) to Neff’s encystment medium (NEM; 0.1 M KCl, 8 mM MgSO4·7H2O, 0.4 mM CaCl2·2H2O, 1 mM NaHCO3, 20 mM ammediol [2-amino-2-methyl-1,3-propanediol; Sigma Aldrich Chemistry Ltd., Madrid, Spain], pH 8.8, at 25 °C) and were cultured in this medium with gently shaking for a week in order to obtain mature cysts. After that, mature cysts were harvested and washed twice using PYG medium.
A serial dilution of the eye drops was made in PYG. The in vitro susceptibility assay was performed in sterile 96-well microtiter plates (Corning™). To these wells the drug concentration to be tested and 5*104 mature cysts of Acanthamoeba/ml were added. The final volume was 100 μL in each well. Finally, 10 μL of the Alamar Blue Assay Reagent (Biosource, Europe, Nivelles, Belgium) was placed into each well, and the plates were then incubated for 144 h at 28 °C with slight agitation. Subsequently the plates were analyzed, with an Enspire microplate reader (PerkinElmer, Massachusetts, USA) using a test wavelength of 570 nm and a reference wavelength of 630 nm. Percentages of growth inhibition, 50% and 90% inhibitory concentrations (IC50 and IC90) were calculated by linear regression analysis with 95% confidence limits. All experiments were performed three times each in duplicate, and the mean values were calculated.
Double-stain assay for programmed cell death determination
A double-stain apoptosis detection kit (Hoechst 33342/PI) (GenScript, Piscataway, NJ, USA) and an inverted confocal microscope (Leica DMI 4000B) were used. The experiment was carried out by following the manufacturer’s recommendations, and 105 cells/well were incubated in a 24-well plate for 24 h with the previously calculated IC50 and IC90. The double-staining pattern allows the identification of three groups in a cellular population: live cells will show only a low level of fluorescence, cells undergoing PCD will show a higher level of blue fluorescence (as chromatin condenses), and dead cells will show low-blue and high-red fluorescence (as the propidium Iodide stain enters the nucleus).
Plasma membrane permeability
The SYTOX Green assay was performed to detect the parasite’s membrane permeability alterations. Briefly, 105 trophozoite were washed and incubated in saline solution with the SYTOX Green at a final concentration of 1 μM (Molecular Probes) for 15 min in the dark. Subsequently the test eye drop solution was added (IC90). After 24 h of treatment, cells were observed in a Leica TSC SPE- confocal microscope equipped with inverted optics at λexc = 482 nm and λem = 519 nm9,10.
Analysis of Mitochondrial Membrane Potential
The collapse of an electrochemical gradient across the mitochondrial membrane during apoptosis was measured using a JC-1 mitochondrial membrane potential detection kit (Cell Technology) by flow cytometry as described by the manufacturer. After being treated with IC50 and IC90 of the test solution for 24 h, the cells were centrifuged (1000 r.p.m. × 10 min) and resuspended in JC-1 buffer. 100 µl of each treated culture was added to a black 96 well plate than 10 µl of JC-1 was added and incubated at 26 °C for 30 min. The mean green and red fluorescence intensity was measured using flow cytometry for 30 minutes.
Measurement of ATP
ATP level was measured using a CellTiter-Glo Luminescent Cell Viability Assay. The effect of the drug on the ATP production was evaluated by incubating (105) of cells/ml with the previously calculated IC50 and IC90 of the active eye drop solution.
In vitro drug sensitivity assay
Initially, all eye drops were screened for their activity against the trophozoite stage of Acanthamoeba castellanii Neff strain. The IC50 and IC90 at/96 h were chosen as the appropriate and comparable data to give as previously described6. The results are illustrated in Table 2.
Among the nine tested eye drops, seven of them are active against trophozoites with an IC50 ranged from 2.036 ± 0.137% (v:v) for Systane Ultra to 47.946 ± 3.770% (v:v) for Artelac Splash. Based on their amoebicidal activity on the Neff strain, three eye drop solutions, namely Systane Ultra, Colircusi Humectante and Optiben were selected to evaluate their effect on the clinical Acanthamoeba strains. The results are illustrated in Table 3.
The analysis of variance by Multifactor ANOVA, illustrated that the biological activity was strain dependent with p = 0.0001 < 0.001. In fact, the Acanthamoeba castellanii Neff was the most sensitive strain to the eye drops. Meanwhile, A. griffini was the most resistant strain to all eye drops. The toxic effect was statistically significant with p = 0.0000 < 0.001, Systane Ultra was statistically the most effective drug against all the strains with the IC50 ranged from 2.036 ± 0.137% for the A. castellanii Neff to 10.691 ± 1.484% for A. griffini (Fig. 1).
Systane Ultra was observed to cause a dose-dependent cysticidal affect (Fig. 2). We found that 1.35% of Systane Ultra inhibited 50% excystation from the initial inoculum of cysts.
Systane Ultra treated cells stained positive in the double-stain assay
When double staining was performed, the tested drug at a concentration of IC90 could induce chromatin condensation proved by the bright-blue nuclei stain as shown by Fig. 3.
Systane Ultra caused plasma membrane permeability in treated cells
As shown in Fig. 4, amoebae treated with IC90 of the tested drug induced cellular membrane damage after 24 hours of treatment. Nevertheless, the cell integrity is still maintained.
Systane Ultra induced mitochondrial malfunction
As it can be observed in Fig. 5, the curve of the mitochondrial potential fluorescence ratio demonstrated that the treatment with the IC90, decreased the membrane potential (ΔΨm) of A. castellanii Neff comparing to the negative control. As presented in the Fig. 6, confocal microscopy confirmed the effects of the Systane Ultra on the mitochondrial potential. The mitochondrial damage has been documented by measuring the ATP level generated in 24 h. We found out, that the IC90 produced a pronounced decrease in the total ATP level (Fig. 7). In fact, cells treated with this dose generated only the half of ATP level produced in untreated cells.
AK is a vision-threatening ophthalmological illness that may even result in blindness if left untreated. In the early stages of infection, this disease usually manifests with nonspecific symptoms such as eye redness, epithelial defects, photophobia, edema and intense pain. AK is often mis-diagnosed as many of these symptoms are shared with the other eye problems11,12. An increase in the number of AK cases is blamed on contact lens use, particularly of soft contact lenses, and their improper use and maintenance12,13. The use of contact lenses is also associated with DED14, and this is also a predisposing factor in the development of AK2. We have described anti-Acanthamoeba activities of 9 eye drop solutions using a range of Acanthamoeba strains. Among the tested eye drops, Systane Ultra was the most active against all the tested Acanthamoeba strains. The fact that the eye drops have an anti-cyst activity has been established by viability and proliferative assay and analyzed by microplate-based fluorescence. The Systane Ultra formulation contains 0.4% Polyethylene Glycol 400 which has been reported15 to be effective against various pathogenic bacteria, including Klebsiella pneumonia, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Escherichia coli, and Staphylococcus aureus through damage to bacterial membrane15,16. Systane Ultra also contains 0.3% Propylene Glycol, and several reports have described the antimicrobial property of this molecule and its effectiveness as a preservative17,18.
The effects of Systane Ultra on Acanthamoeba that we describe here are consistent with a Programmed Cell Death (PCD) mechanism. A PCD-like process has been described in Acanthamoeba occurring 6 h after infection with Salmonella typhimurium19. The early stage was inferred from phosphatidylserine externalization and chromatin condensation. Since this initial report we20,21 and others22,23 have reported a number of PCD inducing agents in Acanthamoeba. In these reports, authors have been able to distinguish between early PCD cells, late PCD cells. This process is generally characterized by distinct morphological features that occurs in different stages from the loss of mitochondrial potential, the condensation of nuclear chromatin and exposure of phosphatidylserine (PS) on the cell exterior. At the late of PCD, the membrane starts blebbing and cell dehydration causes changes in cellular shape and size. The structural integrity and most of the functions of the cell membrane remain intact at least in the initial stages of the process20. In the present study, Systane Ultra at the IC90 was found to induce chromatin condensation observed through the Hoechst fluorescence as showed in the Fig. 3. Some of the brighter staining material is associated with structures within vacuoles and these are likely to be autophagosomes24. However, this is still a speculative hypothesis since a complete autophagy evaluation should be performed by analyzing the autophagosome formation among other assays.
To get a better knowledge of the membrane damage caused by Systane Ultra, we measured fluorimetrically the influx of SYTOX Green into the parasites, as its fluorescence is enhanced when bound to intracellular nucleic acids. After 24 hours of treatment, this eye drop solution was able to induce lesions in the plasma-membrane with a size large allowing the entrance of the dye but without cell rupture. The maintenance of cell’s shape was confirmed using confocal microscopy as showed by Fig. 4. It is well known that PCD is linked to the malfunction of the mitochondria. The loss of mitochondrial membrane potential leads to mitochondrial dysfunction and this is regarded as being an important factor in PCD25. In the present study, the selected eye drop produced a pronounced decrease in the mitochondrial potential and therefore in the total ATP level. It’s likely that Systane Ultra induces apoptosis in Acanthamoeba cells through the mitochondrial pathway.
Our results suggest that Systane Ultra possess an amoebicidal activity that may be useful for the prevention or even treatment of Acanthamoeba keratitis, or form the basis for an optimized solution. We suggest that the Systane Ultra eye drop solution probably induces PCD via the intrinsic pathway. Nevertheless, a limitation of this study is whether these eye drops could be used in the future since they could not be available commercially in ten-year time. Another issue is the need to perform further studies using an in vivo model, since the in vitro methodology used has its limitations such as the lack of a water related vehicle control and/washing action of tears in the eye once the eye drops are placed on the eye and washed away. Therefore, the need for further studies in the near future using these eye drops and an in vivo model.
Nevertheless, the potential use of these eye drops especially Systane Ultra due to its high anti-Acanthamoeba effects is clear and presents a promising alternative for AK treatment in the current and near future infection cases.
Lorenzo-Morales, J., Khan, N. A. & Walochnik, J. An update on Acanthamoeba keratitis: diagnosis, pathogenesis and treatment. Parasite 22, 10 (2015).
Lin, T. Y. et al. Risk factors and microbiological features of patients hospitalized for microbial keratitis: a 10-year study in a referral center in Taiwan. Medicine 94, e1905, https://doi.org/10.1097/MD.0000000000001905 (2015).
Sjögren, H. Zur kenntnis der keratoconjunctivis sicca (Keraritis filiformis bei hypofunction der tränendrüsen). Acta Ophthal. (Kbh). 11, 1 (1933).
Mertzanis, P. et al. The relative burden of dry eye in patients’ lives: comparisons to a US normative sample. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 46, 46–50 (2005).
Kanellopoulos, A. J. & Asimellis, G. In pursuit of objective dry eye screening clinical techniques. Eye and Vision. 3, 1 (2016).
Martín-Navarro, C. M. et al. The potential pathogenicity of chlorhexidine-sensitive Acanthamoeba strains isolated from contact lens cases from asymptomatic individuals in Tenerife, Canary Islands, Spain. J Med Microbiol. 57, 1399–1404 (2008).
González- Robles, A. et al. Morphological features and in vitro cytopathic effect of Acanthamoeba griffini trophozoites isolated from a clinical case. J Parasitol Res. https://doi.org/10.1155/2014/256310 (2014)
McBride, J., Ingram, P. R. & Henríquez., F. L. Development of colorimetric microtiter plate assay for assessment of antimicrobials against Acanthamoeba. J Clin Microbiol. 43, 629–634 (2005).
Lorenzo-Morales, J. et al. Glycogen phosphorylase in Acanthamoeba spp.: determining the role of the enzyme during the encystment process using RNA interference. Eukaryot Cell. 7, 509–517 (2008).
Kulkarni, M. M., McMaster, W. R., Kamysz, W. & McGwire, B. S. Antimicro-bial peptide-induced apoptotic death of Leishmania results from calcium-dependent, caspase-independent mitochondrial toxicity. J Biol Chem. 284, 15496–15504 (2009).
Niyyati, M., Lasjerdi, Z., Haghighi, A. & Nazemalhosseini Mojarad, E. Contamination of clinical settings to highly pathogenic Acanthamoeba in Iran. Occupational Health. 2, 8 (2012).
Niyyati, M., Dodangeh, S. & Lorenzo-Morales, J. A review of the current research trends in the application of medicinal plants as a source for novel therapeutic agents against Acanthamoeba infections. Iran J Pharm Res. 15, 893 (2016).
Kristin, M. & Hammersmith, K. M. Diagnosis and management of Acanthamoeba keratitis. Curr. Opin. Ophthalmol. 17, 327–31 (2006).
Bakkar, M. M., Shihadeh, W. A., Haddad, M. F. & Khader, Y. S. Epidemiology of symptoms of dry eye disease (DED) in Jordan: A cross-sectional non-clinical population-based study. Cont Lens Anterior Eye. 39, 197–202 (2016).
Chirife, J. et al. In vitro antibacterial activity of concentrated polyethylene glycol 400 solutions. Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 24, 409–412 (1983).
Bozzini, J. P., Kohn, E. S., Joseph, A., Herszage, L. & Chirife, J. Submicroscopical changes in Klebsiella pneumoniae cells treated with concentrated sucrose and polyethylene glycol 400 solutions. J Appl Microbiol. 60, 375–379 (1986).
Kinnunen, T. & Koskela, M. Antibacterial and antifungal properties of propylene glycol, hexylene glycol, and 1, 3-butylene glycol in vitro. Acta dermato-venereologica. 71, 148–150 (1991).
Nalawade, T. M., Bhat, K. & Sogi, S. H. Bactericidal activity of propylene glycol, glycerine, polyethylene glycol 400, and polyethylene glycol 1000 against selected microorganisms. J Int Soc Prevent Communit Dent. 5, 114 (2015).
Feng, Y. et al. Apoptosis like cell death induced by Salmonella. Acanthamoeba rhysodes. Genomics. 94, 132–137 (2009).
Martín-Navarro, C. M. et al. Statins and voriconazole induce programmed cell death in Acanthamoeba castellanii. Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 59, 2817–2824 (2015).
Sifaoui, I. et al. Programmed cell death in Acanthamoeba castellanii Neff induced by several molecules present in olive leaf extracts. PloS one 12(8), e0183795 (2017).
Nakisah, M. A. et al. Anti-amoebic properties of a Malaysian marine sponge Aaptos sp. on Acanthamoeba castellanii. World J Microbiol Biotechnol. 28, 1237–1244 (2012).
Kusrini, E., Hashim, F., Azmi, W. N. N. N., Amin, N. M. & Estuningtyas, A. A novel antiamoebic agent against Acanthamoeba sp. — A causative agent for eye keratitis infection. Spectrochim Acta A Mol Biomol Spectrosc. 153, 714–721 (2016).
Moon, E. K. et al. Autophagy inhibitors as a potential antiamoebic treatment for Acanthamoeba keratitis. Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 59, 4020–4025 (2015).
Lakhani, S. A. et al. Caspases 3 and 7: key mediators of mitochondrial events of apoptosis. Science. 311, 847–851 (2006).
This work was supported by the grants Red de Investigation Colaborativa en Enfermedades Tropicales RICET (project no. RD16/0027/0001 of the programme of Redes Temáticas de Investigación Cooperativa, FIS), Spanish Ministry of Health, Madrid, Spain and PI13/00490 “Protozoosis Emergentes por Amebas de Vida Libre: Aislamiento, Caracterización, Nuevas Aproximaciones Terapéuticas y Traslación Clínica de los Resultados” from the Instituto de Salud Carlos III. IS and ALA were supported by the Agustín de Betancourt Programme. JLM was supported by Ayudas Plan Propio de la Universidad de La Laguna 2017 (proyectos puente I+D+i). The authors are grateful to Dr Maritza Omaña Molina for kindly providing the A. griffini isolate. The authors are grateful to Dr. SK Maciver for critical reading of the manuscript.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Sifaoui, I., Reyes-Batlle, M., López-Arencibia, A. et al. Toxic effects of selected proprietary dry eye drops on Acanthamoeba. Sci Rep 8, 8520 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-018-26914-3
Parasitology Research (2021)
Laurinterol from Laurencia johnstonii eliminates Naegleria fowleri triggering PCD by inhibition of ATPases
Scientific Reports (2020)
Drug targeting in Acanthamoeba keratitis: rational of using drugs that are already approved for ocular use in non-keratitis indications
Staurosporine from Streptomyces sanyensis activates Programmed Cell Death in Acanthamoeba via the mitochondrial pathway and presents low in vitro cytotoxicity levels in a macrophage cell line
Scientific Reports (2019)